Most precise test of Lorentz symmetry for the

photon finds that the speed of light is indeed

constant
by Lisa Zyga , Phys.org

(Left) Photo of the orthogonal sapphire crystal mount, with (right) simulations of the
electromagnetic resonant mode patterns. A frequency variation in the resonance would indicate a
variation in the speed of light. Credit: Stephen R. Parker, The University of Western Australia

(Phys.org)—The laws of physics are the same no matter which direction you're facing or how
fast you're moving—it's such an intuitive concept that most people probably don't know that it
has a name: Lorentz symmetry. Over the past several decades, physicists have been testing
Lorentz symmetry at ever-higher degrees of precision, as violations of the foundational property
are predicted by a number of proposals that aim to unify the two major theories of modern
physics: general relativity and the standard model of particle physics.

Now in a new paper, physicists have reported the most precise test to date of Lorentz symmetry
for the photon by looking for variations in the speed of light, but have found no violations. The
study, by Moritz Nagel at the Humboldt-University of Berlin, Stephen Parker at The University
of Western Australia, and their coauthors, is published in a recent issue of Nature
Communications.

Although the term "Lorentz symmetry" is named for the Dutch physicist Hendrik Lorentz and
the fact that it is a symmetry of spacetime, it may be better thought of as a property about
relativity, and in fact it is a cornerstone of Einstein's special relativity theory. According to
special relativity, there is no absolute space or absolute time. So if two objects are moving
relative to each other in empty space, it would actually be impossible for an observer to tell their
absolute velocities—maybe only one of the objects was moving and the other was stationary, for
example, but you wouldn't know which was which because their movements are relative to each
other, not to any external reference frame (assuming the reference frame is non-accelerating).

One important consequence of Lorentz symmetry is that the speed of light is invariant, or a
constant in vacuum. The fact that photons in vacuum always move at a speed of just under
300,000 km per second is intimately connected to the concepts in special relativity. In the new
study, the researchers performed an experiment that attempted to measure any tiny frequency
variation of light, which would indicate a variation in the speed of light.

(Left) Historical overview of Michelson-Morley-style tests of Lorentz symmetry for the photon.
Interferometer tests measure fractional shifts in the speed of light, while cavity-based tests
measure fractional changes in the frequency of light. (Right) Experimental set-up of the cavity-
based test, with the two crystal axes aligned at right angles. The original Michelson-Morley
interferometer test is shown in the top right corner for comparison. Credit: Moritz Nagel, et al.
©2015 Macmillan Publishers Limited

Their experiment consists of a highly sensitive Michelson-Morley cavity test, which is an

updated version of the seminal Michelson-Morley interferometer used in the late 1800s to
measure the speed of light in the search for an "aether" that pervaded the universe (for which, of
course, no evidence was found). While an interferometer is based on reflecting light back and
forth between mirrors, cavity tests consist of both optical and electrical components. The cavity
test here involves two cavities containing sapphire crystals. The researchers excited an
electromagnetic resonance in the crystals at a specific frequency, and supercooled them with
liquid helium to stabilize the frequency and improve sensitivity. Like the mirrors of the
interferometer, the cavities are carefully aligned orthogonal (at right angles) to each other to
detect any tiny change in the speed of light along different axes. In the case of the cavities, a
change in the speed of light would induce a change in the resonance frequency of the crystals.
But after analysis of a full year of data, no such change was found.

"This is the first direct test of polarization-independent effects for Lorentz invariance violations
of the photon that has reached the level of the Planck-suppressed electroweak unification scale,"
Parker told Phys.org. "The energy scale of electroweak unification (about 100 GeV) suppressed
by the Planck scale (about 1.2 x 1019 GeV) gives the dimensionless ratio of about 8 x 10-18, so
perhaps naively one might expect to start seeing Lorentz symmetry of the photon being broken in
this regime, yet we didn't see any evidence for this."

By providing the strongest evidence yet that the speed of light is a constant, the results further
verify that Lorentz symmetry is a basic property of nature. Like other experimental results, the
speed of light does not seem to depend on the orientation of the laboratory (rotation invariance)
or its velocity though space (boost invariance). Since the precision of the new test (10-18) is an
order of magnitude better than that of previous tests of Lorentz symmetry of the photon, it does
allow the scientists to improve the bounds on the nine rotational and boost isotropies of the speed
of light by a factor of four.

These improved bounds could prove very useful for experimentally testing theories that unify
general relativity and the standard model while predicting Lorentz symmetry violations. Some of
these theories, for example, include string theory-based models and quantum gravity theories,
among others. Although these theories are complex, one reason for the predicted Lorentz
symmetry violation is that, in order to "quantize" gravity, there must be a minimum length scale
—an absolute distance that is difficult to reconcile with the relative nature of Lorentz symmetry.

In the near future, scheduled upgrades to the Michelson-Morley cavity experiment are expected
to improve the frequency stability, reduce the noise, and remove other interfering effects,
allowing for even more precise tests.

"We're in the process of upgrading our experimental setup to reduce the influence of systematic
noise," Parker said. "For example, we've now installed better cryogenic magnetic shielding
around our sapphire oscillators. At the same time, we're undertaking research to improve the
fundamental frequency stability performance of the oscillators, and we're developing a pair of
cryogenic optical resonators. These optical resonators will be added in to the same cryogenic
environment as the microwave oscillators, allowing us to make comparisons between them. So
we will be improving the raw sensitivity of the experiment and also the reach of this work, as
we'll be able to search for different types of Lorentz invariance violation effects, too."

More information: Moritz Nagel, et al. "Direct terrestrial test of Lorentz symmetry in
electrodynamics to 10-18." Nature Communications. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms9174

Journal information: Nature Communications

© 2015 Phys.org

Explore further

Researchers test speed of light with greater precision than before

Facebook

Twitter

Email

Feedback to editors

 Featured
 Last Comments
 Popular
Discovery of two new specimens suggests Hupehsuchus was an ancient filter feeder

15 hours ago

A biochip that can be used to perform rapid genetic screening of thousands of molecules

15 hours ago

Carbon Capture and Storage projects in Denmark at risk from bitumen formation

16 hours ago

Hip bone found in cave in France may represent a previously unknown lineage of Homo
sapiens

17 hours ago

Museum curator identifies the oldest spider fossil ever found in Germany

Aug 7, 2023

Chemical contamination on International Space Station is out of this world, study shows

7 hours ago

New technique measures structured light in a single shot

10 hours ago

Nitrogen runoff strategies complicated by climate change

11 hours ago

The 'unknome': A database of human genes we know almost nothing about

12 hours ago

New tool provides greater accuracy for medical biosensors

13 hours ago

Good smells, bad smells: It's all in the insect brain

13 hours ago

Ancient DNA reveals an early African origin of cattle in the Americas

14 hours ago

Researchers use SPAD detector to achieve 3D quantum ghost imaging

14 hours ago

Gravitational waves may reveal nature of dark matter

14 hours ago

City-dwelling wildlife demonstrate 'urban trait syndrome'

14 hours ago
  1
 2

More news stories

Chemical contamination on International Space Station is out of this world,
study shows

Concentrations of potentially harmful chemical compounds in dust collected from air filtration
systems on the International Space Station (ISS) exceed those found in floor dust from many
American homes, a new study reveals.

Space Exploration

7 hours ago

52

Carbon Capture and Storage projects in Denmark at risk from bitumen

formation

Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) is increasingly being cited to help our global warming crisis
by reducing greenhouse gas emissions through capturing carbon dioxide and storing deep
underground. In the Danish North Sea, chalk ...

Earth Sciences

16 hours ago

80

Smoking-gun evidence for modified gravity at low acceleration from Gaia

observations of wide binary stars

A new study reports conclusive evidence for the breakdown of standard gravity in the low
acceleration limit from a verifiable analysis of the orbital motions of long-period, widely
separated, binary stars, usually referred ...

Astronomy

19 hours ago
18

1799

New technique measures structured light in a single shot

Structured light waves with spiral phase fronts carry orbital angular momentum (OAM),
attributed to the rotational motion of photons. Recently, scientists have been using light waves
with OAM, and these special "helical" ...

Optics & Photonics

10 hours ago

86

The 'unknome': A database of human genes we know almost nothing about

Researchers from the United Kingdom hope that a new, publicly available database they have
created will shrink, not grow, over time. That's because it is a compendium of the thousands of
understudied proteins encoded by genes ...

Molecular & Computational biology

12 hours ago

156

Nitrogen runoff strategies complicated by climate change

As climate change progresses, rising temperatures may impact nitrogen runoff from land to lakes
and streams more than projected increases in total and extreme precipitation for most of the
continental United States, according ...

Environment

11 hours ago

14
Physicists open new path to an exotic form of superconductivity

Physicists have identified a mechanism for the formation of oscillating superconductivity known
as pair-density waves. Physical Review Letters published the discovery, which provides new
insight into an unconventional, high-temperature ...

Condensed Matter

17 hours ago

872

Scientists discover new ecosystem underneath hydrothermal vents

A new ecosystem has been discovered in volcanic cavities beneath hydrothermal vents at a well-
studied undersea volcano on the East Pacific Rise off Central America. The landmark 30-day
expedition aboard Schmidt Ocean Institute's ...

Plants & Animals

15 hours ago

36

New tool provides greater accuracy for medical biosensors

For more than 20 years, Li-Qun "Andrew" Gu at the University of Missouri has developed a
passion for solving life science problems by creating sophisticated diagnostic tools—in
nanoscale.

Biochemistry

13 hours ago

55

Ancient DNA reveals an early African origin of cattle in the Americas

Cattle may seem like uniquely American animals, steeped in the lore of cowboys, cattle drives
and sprawling ranches. But cattle didn't exist on the American continents prior to the arrival of
the Spanish, who brought livestock ...

Plants & Animals

14 hours ago

96

Gravitational waves may reveal nature of dark matter

Observations of gravitational waves from merging black holes may reveal new insights about
dark matter, suggests a new study from a UCL-led international team.

General Physics

14 hours ago

112

Good smells, bad smells: It's all in the insect brain

Everyone has scents that naturally appeal to them, such as vanilla or coffee, and scents that don't
appeal. What makes some smells appealing and others not?

Biotechnology

13 hours ago

42

Quantum material exhibits 'non-local' behavior that mimics brain function

We often believe computers are more efficient than humans. After all, computers can complete a
complex math equation in a moment and can also recall the name of that one actor we keep
forgetting. However, human brains can ...

Nanophysics
15 hours ago

16

Researchers use SPAD detector to achieve 3D quantum ghost imaging

Researchers have reported the first 3D measurements acquired with quantum ghost imaging. The
new technique enables 3D imaging on a single photon level, yielding the lowest photon dose
possible for any measurement.

Optics & Photonics

14 hours ago

71

Discovery of two new specimens suggests Hupehsuchus was an ancient filter

feeder

A combined team of paleontologists and geoscientists from China University of Geosciences and
Hubei Geological Bureau, both in China, working with a colleague from the University of
Bristol, has found more evidence suggesting ...

Evolution

15 hours ago

City-dwelling wildlife demonstrate 'urban trait syndrome'

City life favors species that are adaptable and, among other things, not too fussy about what they
eat. A worldwide consortium of scientists calls the resulting collection of characteristics "urban
trait syndrome."

Plants & Animals

14 hours ago

0
1

Medical Xpress

Medical research advances and health news

Tech Xplore

The latest engineering, electronics and technology advances

Science X

The most comprehensive sci-tech news coverage on the web

Newsletters
,.