Professional Documents
Culture Documents
02 01 PDDM Lean NPI Lecture
02 01 PDDM Lean NPI Lecture
02 01 PDDM Lean NPI Lecture
History
Agenda
• Product Development
• Principles of Lean
• Lean enablers
• Transformation process
An open mind to waste
Diet and
Surgery
exercise
Changes
Quick fix current
process
Instant Addition of a
results new process
Has not
addressed Sustainable
the process
Source: Browning (2003) On customer value and improvement in product development processes. Systems Engineering, 6, 49-61
6
Academic Dog!
7
• Business models have changed significantly over the last twenty years and
will continue to change to meet our changing demands
• Industry has to adapt to these changes if they are to continue successfully
in business
Source: AEROSPACE INNOVATION AND GROWTH TEAM 2003. An independent report on the future of the UK Aerospace industry.
Department of Trade and Industry; MORGAN, J. M. & LIKER, J. K. 2006. The Toyota product development system: integrating
people, process, and technology, New York, Productivity Press;
http://medicaltourismmag.com/detail.php?Req=296&issue=14 (date accessed 17/03/2010
8
Improvement Examples
Company
Rolls-Royce Component development lead-time reduced from 3.5 years to
(Aero engines) one year
Time to prototype Greater flexibility for change during evolution of the design
H&R Johnson Lead-time reduced from 10 days to 2 days
(Ceramic Tiles) Pipeline inventory reduced by three weeks
Time to supply Product range increased by 400 lines
Service levels up to 96%
Coats Vyella Design lead-time reduced by 75%
(Knitwear) Improved quality of information
Time to market Reductions in process inventory
Short Brothers Supplier lead-time reduction from 16 weeks to 2 days
(Aerospace) Removal of £3.5 million of current stock
Time to Receive 400 part numbers removed
Massey Ferguson Reduced cell lead-time by 70 days for 29 items
(Tractors) Increase in stock turn ratio of 24%
Time to 10% reduction in inventory
manufacture
Source: Gregory, I.C., Rawling, S.B., Profit from Time, McMillan Press
NPI Lead Time Opportunities
Value- Added
Rework 25% (necessary work)
30% • working on the right
• fixing errors things
• re-design • doing the right things
right
• doing the right things
25% most of the time
10% • working at the right place
10%
Un-necessary
• useless meetings Not Working
• reports read by no-one
Non-Value Added • vacation
• waiting
but necessary
• reports
• travel
Causes of Poor Product Introduction
Moving Policy Functional
Targets Delays Mismatch
Unstable Unresolved policy Inadequate knowledge
Poor Technology Sequential Issues other functional capabilities
Screening Working
Inadequate No Common
Market Organisation
resources Vision
changes Structure
Poor Project Interference Role of Snr. Poor
Execution Too many
Changes in Management communication
projects
requirement
Poor Product
Poor
Introduction
Technology Idea
Inadequate Resource
Strategy Generation
focus Planning Poor
Not unique
Communication Marketing
Poor
Overestimating Strategy Long lead time
Lack of Technical
Learning Technical Skills Product
Capabilities Project Strategy
Screening Low entry barriers
for Competition
Agenda
• Product Development
• Principles of Lean
• Lean enablers
• Transformation process
13
Origins of Lean
14
Specify value
• This element can only be defined by the customer
Pursue perfection
• Develop and amend the processes continuously in pursuit
of perfection
Source: WOMACK, J. P. & JONES, D. T. 1996. Lean Thinking: Banish waste and create wealth in your corporation, London, Simon &
Schuster.
15
Type 2 Muda
Value Adding Type 1 Muda
Those actions that do
Those which create Those which create no
not create customer
value as perceived by value but are required
value and can be
the customer by product development
eliminated immediately
Source: WOMACK, J. P. & JONES, D. T. 1996. Lean Thinking: Banish waste and create wealth in your corporation, London, Simon &
Schuster.
16
Source: MORGAN, J. M. & LIKER, J. K. 2006. The Toyota product development system: integrating people, process, and technology,
New York, Productivity Press.
Breakdown of ontology concepts and sub-concepts
Etc.
Etc.
Source: MORGAN, J. M. & LIKER, J. K. 2006. The Toyota product development system: integrating people, process, and technology,
New York, Productivity Press.
19
Agenda
• Product Development
• Principles of Lean
• Lean enablers
– Value Stream Mapping
– Visual Management
– Standard Work
– 5S
• Transformation process
20
Source: MCMANUS, H. 2005. Product Development Value Stream Mapping (PDVSM) Manual - Release 1.0. Lean Aerospace
Initiative, MiT.
21
Source: MCMANUS, H. 2005. Product Development Value Stream Mapping (PDVSM) Manual - Release 1.0. Lean Aerospace Initiative,
MiT.
23
Source: MCMANUS, H. 2005. Product Development Value Stream Mapping (PDVSM) Manual - Release 1.0. Lean Aerospace Initiative,
MiT.
24
VISUAL CONTROL
(KAMISHIBAI)
27
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
CS Con Dev Fre FD Eq Ind PP Lau Rel End
Project Management
Market
Engineering
Manufacturing
Purchasing & Supply
After Market (CST)
Finance
ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL ALL
ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES ROLES
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
CS Con Dev Fre FD Eq Ind PP Lau Rel End
Start Product change Initiation
Gate 1 Concept study gate/decision
Gate 2 Concept Gate Final Development Equipment Industrialisation
gate/decision gate gate/decision
Gate 3 Development gate decision Development
Freeze
gate Pre-production
Concept
Gate 7 Industrialisation gate/decision Study Development End
gate
Gate 8 Pre-production gate Pre
Industrialisation
Product
Gate 9 Launch gate decision change
Initiation
Study
Involve customers and • External parties rarely see the internal process of their partners
suppliers • Allow partners to see when they are causing bottlenecks
Source: TURNER, C. & PARRY, G. 2005. The Advantages of Visual Management. UK Lean Aerospace Initiative, Warwick
Manufacturing Group.
30
STANDARDISATION
31
Time’s
Start
Up!
32
1 2 3
5 6
7 8 9
33
1 2 3 Intersection
4 5 6
Rightward Arc
7 8 9
1 2 3
4 5 6
7 8 9
35
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
diagram) 4 5 6
7 8 9
36
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
diagram) 4 5 6
7 8 9
37
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
diagram) 4 5 6
7 8 9
38
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 2 on grid
1 2 3
3 From right hand side of M draw See diagram for position of arc
and 3 4 5 6
7 8 9
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 6 on grid
1 2 3
3 From upper intersection of 5 and 6 See diagram for position of arc
hand side of W 4 5 6
7 8 9
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 8 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw downward arc joining the two See diagram for position of arc
Ws together
4 5 6
7 8 9
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw a circle approximately 10mm in See diagram for position of
4 5 6
7 8 9
42
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw a straight line from base of See diagram for start and end
5 6
7 8 9
Start
End
43
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw a straight line from top of circle See diagram for start and end
5 6
7 8 9
Start
End
44
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw two small circles approximately See diagram for position of the
7 8 9
45
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw a straight line (approximately See diagram for start and end
7 8 9
Start End
46
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 4 on grid
1 2 3
3 Draw a circle approximately 4mm in See diagram for position of
7 8 9
47
1 Drawing a pig
NO. MAIN STEPS NO. OPERATING DESCRIPTION KEY POINTS EXPLANATION / EXAMPLES / DIAGRAMS
2 Go to area 3 on grid
1 2 3
3 From the lower intersection of area 2 See diagram for position of
10mm long 5 6
7 8 9
48
1 2 3
5 6
7 8 9
49
1 2 3
4 6
7 8 9
50
Standard Engines
54
Design standardisation
Process standardisation
Source: MORGAN, J. M. & LIKER, J. K. 2006. The Toyota product development system: integrating people, process, and technology,
New York, Productivity Press.
55
5S
56
• Standardise Conformity
Seiketsu
• Sustain Custom
Shitsuke
Implementation of the 5 C’s
Unnecessary
http://www.evolvingexcellence.com/blog/examples_of_excellence/page/2/
59
• You have 60 seconds to cross out the numbers on sheet 3 of your handout
• You must start at number 1
• You must cross the numbers out sequentially up to number 49
• All numbers must be crossed out diagonally, bottom left to top right 15
66 72
6 15 9
45
60
39 85 54
75 21 69 79
29 78 53 52
38
23
41
11 59 77 17 62 26
80
64
37
76 49 31 16
73 4 34 Time’s Up!
55 28 67
86 58
61 What was
the highest
number?
Source: NHS - INSTITUTE FOR INNOVATION AND IMPROVEMENT 2008. Releasing time to care: The Productive Ward.
62
6 15 9
45
39
21
29
38
23
41
11 17 26
37 49 31 16
4 34 Time’s Up!
28
What was
the highest
SORT number?
Source: NHS - INSTITUTE FOR INNOVATION AND IMPROVEMENT 2008. Releasing time to care: The Productive Ward.
63
6 15 9
45
39
21
29
38
23
41
11 17 26
37 49 31 16
4 34 Time’s Up!
28
What was
the highest
STRAIGHTEN
number?
Source: NHS - INSTITUTE FOR INNOVATION AND IMPROVEMENT 2008. Releasing time to care: The Productive Ward.
64
Numbers from 1 to 49
1 3 6 8
5
16
14
10 13
20 22 27
29 34
33
32
37 38 40 43 45
48 Time’s Up!
What was
SWEEP the highest
number?
Source: NHS - INSTITUTE FOR INNOVATION AND IMPROVEMENT 2008. Releasing time to care: The Productive Ward.
65
Numbers from 1 to 49
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45
Time’s Up!
46 47 48 49
What was
STANDARDISE the highest
Source: NHS - INSTITUTE FOR INNOVATION AND IMPROVEMENT 2008. Releasing time to care: The Productive Ward.
number?
68
Source: HART, J. 2005. On your marks for a quick change. The Sunday Times (MPH Supplement). London.; Image courtesy of
http://www.motorshots.com/all_free_pictures_free_f1_pictures_s_49_f_5.html
69
Cast and
Machined
Cast
Fabricated
Design
Intent
Design for Assembly: What’s
Wrong?
71
Design for Assembly
Agenda
• Product Development
• Principles of Lean
• Lean enablers
• Transformation process
74
NPI Process
Project
Lean tools
Management
76
Further Reading
• www.leanppd.eu
• Sobek, D., Ward, A. and Liker, J. (1999).Toyota’s Principles of Set-Based
Concurrent Engineering. [online] MIT Sloan Management Review. Available
at: https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/toyotas-principles-of-setbased-
concurrent-engineering/
• Roos, D., Womack, J. and Jones, D. (2014), The machine that changed the
world, Free Press.
• Jones, D. and Womack, J. (2014).Lean thinking, Free Press.
• Morgan, J. and Liker, J. (2008), The Toyota product development system, New
York, NY: Productivity Press.
• Ohno, T. (1988),Toyota production systems. Cambridge, Mass.: Productivity
Press.
• Morgan, J. and Liker, J. (2019), Designing the future, New York: McGraw-Hill
Education.
• Ward, A., Shook, J. and Sobek, D. (2014), Lean product and process
development. Cambridge, MA: Lean enterprise Institute.