Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

WORKSHOP ON

SCIENTIFIC WRITING, RESEARCH INTEGRITY


& PUBLICATION ETHICS
(Capacity building programme for PG guides – A NCISM initiative)

INFORMATION BROCHURE
Contents:
1. Introduction
2. Objectives of the program
3. Guidelines to conduct the workshop
a. Criteria for selection of institute to host the workshop
b. Eligibility to attend the workshop
c. Program details
d. Master Trainers
e. Financial support
f. Instructions to host institute
g. Feedback & Assessment
h. Coordinators
i. Annexures
1. Schedule – Day wise Programme
2. List of Resource Persons
Introduction

Good research contributes to the advancement of science and helps society


at large when it is published. Scientific publications are necessary to impart the
knowledge of emerging trends in health care systems; time to time enhancement
of professional knowledge and to share ones own original work with the learned
community. Scientific publication and technology transfer are important aspect
of research which is the need of the hour for globalisation and global acceptance
of Indian Systems of Medicine i.e. Ayurveda, Unani, Siddha and Sowa-Rigpa. To
have quality publications, there is a need of enhancing the awareness of Good
Publication Practices and change the perception of scientific writing among
AYUSH community to address the gap prevailing in the current scenario in this
domain.
Hence, to overcome such issues NCISM proposed to orient and sensitize
all the post-graduate guides on “Scientific Writing, Research Integrity and
Publication Ethics”.
A lot of good research works are coming up as PG studies, which many
times doesn’t end in publication. This is a strong area and a reorientation to the
stakeholders in this regard will kindle the interest in scientific writing and would
increase the treasure of evidence to our systems. This programme is to help
faculty members and in turn research scholars in understanding the intricacies of
writing a paper, getting it published in quality journals and improving citations.

With this background NCISM in collaboration with Centre for Publication


Ethics and Centre for Complementary & Integrative Health (CCIH), Savitribai
Phule Pune University, Pune has trained 60 Master Trainers of ASU systems.
These Master Trainers are intended to train all PG guides throughout the country.

This information brochure is to facilitate the institution to host and conduct


such workshops.
Objectives of the PG Guide Orientation Workshop

To sensitize and train PG Guides for scientific writing research


integrity and publication ethics to influence the students.
To encourage PG guides to write and publish their original scientific
works in quality journals to add up evidence in Indian System of
Medicine.
To develop the potential human resource in Indian System of Medicine
through research integrity.
To mentor PG scholars on scientific writing.

Guidelines for conducting PG Guide Orientation


workshop
a. Criteria of eligibility for Institutes to host the Orientation workshop:
PG Institution duly permitted by MARBISM shall be eligible to conduct the
workshop.

b. Eligibility for participants:


Only Post Graduate Guides from NCISM approved Ayurveda, Unani
and Siddha institutes, shall be eligible to attend workshop.

c. Program details:
1. It will be three days full time residential program on scientific
writing, research integrity and publication ethics (Annexure 1)
2. There shall be a total of 20 training sessions in three days of workshop.
3. There will be maximum of 60 trainees per workshop.

d. Master Trainers:
Total 10 Master Trainers (one Master Trainer from each group) - As per
the Annexure 1 shall conduct the training sessions.
e. Financial Support:
Financial assistance will be provided directly to the host Institutions/
organizations by NCISM. Funds for a programme in the following pattern
will be released to the Institute on approval of the proposal:

S. No. Particulars Admissible


Amount ( in
Rs.)
1. Travelling charges to Master Trainers (Rs.15,000*10) Rs. 1,50,000/-
2. Remuneration to the Master Trainers Rs. 3000 per Rs. 60,000/-
Training session (3000*20)
3. Accommodation to the Master Trainers Rs. 4,500 per Rs. 67,500/-
person (4500*15) (including inaugural & valedictory
guests)
4. Breakfast, Twice Tea and working Lunch to all Rs. 65,250/-
participants, Master Trainers and organising committee
members (Rs 290*75*3) ( 60 Trainees & Master
Trainees)
5. Institutional support Rs. 50,000/-
Total amount Rs. 3,92,750/-

Traveling, boarding and lodging facilities to the trainees shall be born


by the institutes where the PG guides are working.

f. Instructions to host institutes


 ASU PG institutes interested to host the workshop shall submit
expression of interest through online portal https://ayushedu.bisag-
.gov.in/AYUSH_EDU/

 Once the proposal of hosting the workshop has been approved by


NCISM; Name of college along with the dates of the program will be
displayed on the portal

 PG guides can attend the program either by getting nominated by the


Principal or by applying through the portal ( https://ayushedu.bisag-
gov.in/AYUSH_EDU/)

 Attending workshop is mandatory for all PG guides. PG Guides


can select the program as per their convenience and suitability
(However, the selection will be on first come, first serve basis)
 Not more than 5 participants shall be included from the host
institutes
 Participants and Master Trainer will be provided e-Certificates..
g. Feedback & Assessment:
i. Pre -test and Post-test would be conducted by the institutes through
online portal.
h. Feedback would be taken from the participants – through onlineportal

i. Coordinators: For any queries, contact with coordinators

Dr. Anupama Krishnan Dr. Kiran Tawalare Dr. Yogita Jamdade


Keraladr.anupamakrishan@g dryogitaaj@gmail.com
drkirantawalare@gmail.com
mail.com
Mob No. - 9895012658 Mob No. - 9226209022 Mob No. - 9922991376
Annexure-1
Workshop on
SCIENTIFIC WRITING, RESEARCH INTEGRITY & PUBLICATION
ETHICS
Organised by National Commission for Indian System of Medicine
Day: First

Lecture Topic Time


Registration & breakfast 09.00 – 10.00
Inauguration 10.00 - 10.30
Guidelines about workshop and introduction of participants & Pre-test 10.30 - 11.00
Lecture 1 Scientific publications: why, when& how?
 Scientometrics - How to select a journal?
11.00 – 12.00
 Activity - How to identify predatory journals?

Group photograph & Tea break 12.00 – 12.15


Lecture 2 Drafting original article- clinical study
 Framing a Title
 Choosing Keywords
12.15 - 01.00
 Writing an Introduction- Latest references, lacunae in current
knowledge, expected outcome of the study)

Lunch 01.00 - 02.00


Lecture 3 Study design & ethical issues in health research
 Basic idea about study designs & ethical issues in health research 02.00 - 02.45
 Activity- Evaluate manuscripts involving different study designs

Lecture 4 Methodology: Structure proper methodology


 Study population (Justification for inclusion, exclusion)
 Sample size
 Study conduct e.g. SOP, SOD 02.45 - 03.45
 Assessment variables e.g. use of standardized & validated tools
 Activity-How to calculate sample size?

Tea break 03.45 - 04.00


Lecture 5 Results: Understanding data type& data presentation methods
 Qualitative & quantitative data, how to assure clean & robust data,
how to arrange graphs, tables, figures according to author 04.00 - 04.45
guidelines

Lecture 6 Analysing and interpreting data- descriptive & Inferential Statistics


 Activity – How to apply right statistical test? 04.45 - 05.45

Feedback Forms 05.45 - 06.00


Workshop on

SCIENTIFIC WRITING, RESEARCH INTEGRITY & PUBLICATION


ETHICS
Organised by National Commission of Indian System of Medicine
Day: Second

Lecture Topic Time


Breakfast 08.45 - 09.15
Lecture 7 Essential components of research article
09.15 - 10.00
Lecture 8 Drafting drug research based original article
10.00 - 11.00

Tea break 11.00 - 11.15


Lecture 9 Drafting literary research article
 Difference between literature search and literary research 11.15 - 12.15

Lecture 10 Tips for translating thesis into article

 Activity - Participants can work upon original works, extract


research ideas for publication, decide design, procure supporting 12.15 - 01.00
data and materials from their work

Lunch 01.00 - 02.00


Lecture 11 Reporting guidelines

 Reporting guideline for various types of research studies


(CONSORT, STROBE etc.) 02.00 - 02.45
 Activity- Participants try to arrange their own work according
to guidelines.

Lecture 12 Writing a review

 Narrative/systematic, brief idea about meta-analysis


02.45 - 03.45
 Activity - Participant derives topics from their area/work for
review, followed by homework

Tea break 03.45 - 04.00


Lecture 13 Case report/Case series

 Activity – Discuss published case using CARE guideline 04.00 - 04.45

Lecture 14 Research integrity and Publication ethics, Scientific misconduct


04.45 - 05.45
Feedback Forms 05.45 - 06.00
Workshop on
SCIENTIFIC WRITING, RESEARCH INTEGRITY &
PUBLICATION ETHICS
Organised by National Commission of Indian System of Medicine
Day: Third

Lecture Topic Time


Breakfast 09.00 - 09.30
Lecture 15 What makes a ‘good’ discussion?
 Discuss about different points covered under discussion.
09.30 - 10.15

Lecture 16 Preparing an Abstract


 Structured & non- structured 10.15 - 11.00

Tea break 11.00 - 11.15


Lecture 17 References: citing styles and management systems
 Discuss about different referencing styles and introduce to
management software like Zotero
11.15 - 12.15
 Activity-Hands on training reference management systems

Lecture 18 Overview of other publication types


 Letter to editor, short communication, book review. 12.15 - 01.00

Lunch 01.00 - 02.00


Lecture 19 Overcoming Language barrier
 Introduction to grammar check software 02.00 - 02.45

Lecture 20 Know the Editorial process


 How to reply to reviewers? How to deal with rejections? 02.45 - 03.30

Post test 03.30 - 04.00


Tea break 04.00 - 04.15
Feedback Forms 04.15 - 04.30
Valedictory program
04.30 - 05.00
Annexure 2

No. List of Master Trainers


For Lecture 1 & 2 on First Day
Dr Anupama Krishnan Dr M MEENAKSHI SUNDARAM, Professor, Dr. Pratibha. C.K Professor, Department of
Professor Department of Kuzhandhai Maruthuvam, Panchakarma G.S Ayurveda Medical
Dept of Swasthavritta National Institute of Siddha, Tambaram College, Hapur, Uttar Pradesh
VPSV Ayurveda College Kottakkal Sanatorium, Chennai - 600047. Ph: 9495637695
Kerala E-mail - mmssiddha@rediffmail.com; E-mail-drprathibhack@gmail.com
Mobile 9895012658 Mobile: 9444214582
E-mail dr.anupamakrishnan@gmail.com
1
Dr. UMAPATI C. BARAGI Associate Dr. Nitin Juneja Associate Professor/Reader, Dr. Zoheb Alam Khan, (M.D) Assistant
Professor Uttarakhand Ayurved Sarsawati Ayurveda Hospital and Medical Professor Dept. Ilaj bit Tadbeer National
University, Harrawala, Dehradun, College, Ajit Singh Nagar, Punjab. Institute of Unani Medicine, Ghaziabad,
Uttarakhand. Email id- drjuneja3110@gmail.com U.P. 247554
Mob no. 9342417398 Ph.No.-9888680112 E-mail - zohebalamkhan@gmail.com
Email id. - umapati.baragi@gmail.com Mobile-9997203570

For Lecture 3 & 4 on First Day


Dr. KIRAN TAWALARE, Associate Dr. Pavan Kumar Sangu, Assistant Professor, Dr. SRIHARSHA K V Associate Professor,
Professor, MD PhD. Research Sri Venkateshwara Ayurvedic College, Dept. of Samhita and Siddhanta Hillside
Coordinator, Central Research SVIMS Campus, T TDevasthanam, Tirupati Ayurveda Medical College,
Laboratory. Dept. of Kriya Sharir. Shri North-517507,Andhra PradeshDr. Bengaluru,Karnataka-560078
Ayurved College, Nagpur-24 Maharashtra. M0b – 9493410914, ayursriharsha@gmail.com 9980375322
Editor-In-Chief- AIRJATA Co-Editor for: email id: pavansangu@gmail.com.
JETHS
2 E-mail - drkirantawalare@gmail.com
Mob – 9226209022
Dr. VIJAY KUMAR Professor & Head, Dr.Asha S.A Dr. MADHUSUDAN. B. G Associate
Department of Swasthavritta & Yoga, Associate Professor Professor/Reader, Dept. of PG studies in
North Eastern Institute of Ayurveda & Dept. of Swasthavritta Roganidana, JSS Ayurveda Medical
Homoeopathy (NEIAH), Meghalaya- SJGAMC, Koppal, Karnataka. College, Mysuru, Karnataka
793018, Mob-9450354517 Ph:9483315576 Mob- 91-9986284748
E-mail-drvkdwivedi670@gmail.com E-mail- asha57dsa@gmail.com E-mail drmadhusudanbg@gmail.com

For Lecture 5 & 6 on First Day


Dr. Giridhar Vedantam, Prof. Mohd. Aslam, Professor, Dept. of Dr. Pooja Sabharwal, Assistant Professor,
Professor & HoD, IlmulAdvia School of Unani Medical Chaudhary Brahm Prakash
Department of Dravyaguna, Education & Research Jamia Hamdard, New AyurvedCharakSansthan, KheraDabar,
Guru Gorakshnath Institute of Medical Delhi-110062, India Mobile 9958394234 Najafgarh, New Delhi-110073
Sciences (Faculty of Ayurveda), Email: kmaslam@rediffmail.com 9650190893
Mahayogi Gorakhnath University, maslam@jamiahamdard.ac.in Email: drpoojasabharwal@gmail.com
Sonbarsa, Balapar road, Gorakhpur, U.P.
273007
Email:- drgiridharay@gmail.com,
3
Ph. 9731028625
91 9731028625
Dr. RAVI DHALIYA, Associate Professor Dr. RAJESH SHARMA. Associate Dr. K. Nalina Saraswathi M.D. Siddha Govt.
and HOD, deptt of Agada tantra. Babe Professor,&HOD Siddha Medical College, Arumbakkam,
Ke Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Government Ayurvedic Medical College, Chennai-600106.
daudhar, Moga, Punjab. 142053 Mob No. Akhnoor, Mob –8056966272.
: 7975116501 Jammu and Kashmir. E-mail- knalina.s@gmail.com
E-mail id –drravidhaliya@gmail.com E-mail - dr.rajeshsh@gmail.com
9419175762
For Lecture 7 & 8 on Second Day
Dr. Vaishali Mali Assistant Professor, Dr. Mohd. Aleemuddin Quamri, Prof & HoD Dr. G. Subash Chandran
Chaudhary AmrazeJildwa Tazeeniyat & I/c Moalijat Associate Professor
BrahmPrakeshCharakAyurvedSansthan, National Institute of Unani Medicine P.G Department of General Medicine
Delhi Bangalore. Karnataka. Govt Siddha Medical college
4
E-mail:riddhivp7@gmail.com E-mail drmaquamri@gmail.com 9341072974 Tirunelveli
vaishalipm257@gmail.com Phone: Tamil Nadu 627002
9910785248 Mobile no: 9345600723
E-mail-siddhadrgs21@gmail.com
Dr Kavita Aniruddha Jadhav (Thorat) Dr. Shailly Chhabra,
Associate Professor, Department of Associate Professor/Reader,
Shalakya tantra Mai Bhago Ayurvedic Medical College for
D.Y.Patil School of Ayurveda Nerul Navi Women, Muktsar, Punjab
Mumbai 400706 Contact no.9988819519
Mail id drkavitathorat@gmail.com Email- shallychhabra@yahoo.com
Contact number is 9167219691

For Lecture 9 & 10 on Second Day


Dr. Mohan Ramchandra Joshi, Dr. Subash Sahu, Associate Dr. SHWETA MUMBARADDI Associate
Professor, All India Institute of Ayurveda, Professor/Reader, Chaudhary Professor, Faculty of Indian Medical
Village-Dhargal, Taluka – Pernem, BrahmPrakeshCharakAyurvedSansthan, New System, SGT University, Gurugram
Manohar Airport Road, Goa-403513. Delhi Haryana 122505,
Mob- 9822435536, Mobile no -9990537725, phn no. 7982510643 email id-
E-mail: manvantar@gmail.com 7982166384. ssm1709@gmail.com
Email-drsubashsahu@gmail.com

5
Dr. SAROJANI KUCHANUR, Associate Dr. Mohd Maqbool Hussain, Associate Dr. Mohammed Sheeraz Mushtaque
Professor, G.S Ayurveda Medical College professor and I/C HOD PG dept of Ahmed, RRIUM (REGIONAL RESEARCH
& and Hospital, Hapur Uttar Pradesh Tahaffuziwa Samaji Tib Govt. Nizamia Tibbia INSTITUTE OF UNANI MEDICINE
ph-7011940769 College, Hyderabad. Telangana SRINAGAR, J&K.
Email- sarojanish@gmail.com Email: maqboolahmar@gmail.com Mob – 9797750472
Mobile. numbers 9948679786,9912391786. Email :sheeraz.rrium@gmail.com

For Lecture 11 & 12 on Second Day


Dr. Yogita Jamdade, Professor & HOD, Dr. Renuka Tenahalli, Professor an HOD, A.V. Dr.Sumith Kumar M, Associate Professor,
P.D.E.A’S College of Ayurved & Research Samiti’s Ayurveda Mahavidyalaya,Vidya HOD Guru Gorakshanath Institute of
Centre ,Nigdi, Pune, Guruprasad,S.no.80, Nagar, Bagalkot Road, Dist. & Tal Bijapur- Medical Sciences, Arogyadham, Balapar
Sudarshan, Maharashtra- 411061, 586101, Karnataka 895160699 Road, Sonbarsa, Gorakhpur- 273007
dryogitaaj@gmail.com 9922991376 rbjumanal@gmail.com drsumith@gmail.com
Residential address drskm.nair@gmail.com Ph. 9995635703
Bungalow no.7 'Guruprasad' Lane #2,
6 Sudarshan Nagar, Pimple Gurav , Pune
411061, Maharashtra
Dr. Ashish Kate, Professor, L.N. Ayurved Dr. Amrita Mishra, Associate Professor, Dr. Wasim Ahmad
College & Hospital, Bhopal, J.K Town, PodarAyurved Medical College, Maharashtra. Principal
Sarvadharam, C-Sector, Kolar Road, Pnone-91-9823171494 State Unani Medical College
Bhopal-462042, Madhya Pradesh mail-dramritamishra@gmail.com Prayagraj, UP - 211016
PH.NO. 9422120316 E-mail-drwasim@gmail.com
Email- drashish.kate@gmail.com 9371566384

For Lecture 13 & 14 on Second Day


Dr. Yogesh Deole, Professor, G.J. Patel Dr. AMIT KATARIA, Dr Suchita Manish Sheth (MD,PhD)
Institute of Ayurvedic Studies & Research, Associate Professor, HOD/Associate Professor
New Vallabh Vidyanagar, Anand, Gujarat PG Dept of Kaumarbhritya Department: Rasashashtra and Bahishjya
Email: dryogeshdeole@gmail.com Institute for Ayurved Studies and Research Kalpana
Contact: +91-9974999309 (erstwhile Shri KG Mittal Ayurved college
Krishna Govt. Ayurvedic Charni Road
College & Hospital) Mumbai-40002
Kurukshetra-136118 Maharashtra
Haryana Phone no-9322265702
7 Email:dramitkataria@rediffmail.com Email: smsheth1972@gmail.com
Mob:9034001230
Dr surya Prakash Sumant Moreshwar Pande Dr.Fahmeeda Zeenat, Assistant Professor
Department of panchkarma Associate Professor, Department of Rognidan in IlmulQabalatwaAmraz-e-Niswan
Babe ke ayurvedic medical college and Mahatma Gandhi Ayurved College Hospital Department of Amraz-e-NiswanwaAtfal,
hospital, daudhar, moga , punjab 142053 and Research Center, DMIHER (DU), Salod, Ajmal Khan Tibbiya College, Faculty of
Phone no. 8005582825 Wardha, Maharashtra 442001 Unani Medicine, Aligarh Muslim
Email. draryabhu11@gmail.com University, Aligarh (UP)
Phone: 9766507311 Email-fahmeedazeenat@gmail.com
Email: sumantpande@gmail.com Mob-8149536134
For Lecture 15 & 16 on Third Day
Dr. Md Tanwir Alam,MD Assistant Dr.Kishori Lal Sharma, Associate Professor Dr. SHIROMANI MISHRA Associate
Professor & In Charge- and HOD, Dept of KriyaSharir, Madan Professor/Reader, Govt. Dhanwantri
Neurorehabilitation Unit, Dept. of Mohan Malviya Govt. Ayurveda College, Ayurved College & Hospital, Madhya
TahaffuziWaSamaji Tib (Preventive & Rada ji circle, Ambamata, Udaipur-313001, Pradesh E-mail id-
Social Medicine) and Coordinator- Rajasthan Mobile- 9414702671 Email- shiromishra@gmail.com
Peripheral Pharmacovigilance drklalsharma@gmail.com contact no. - 9893158853
Centre(PPvc), Govt. Tibbia College,
(Patna) Bihar-800003
E-mail-tanveernum@gmail.com
8 Mob: 7543854407
Dr. REETESH VERMA, Assistant Prof. Mohammad Idris, Ayurvedic & Unani Dr. Arzeena Jabeen,
Professor/Lecturer, Govt. Auto. Ayurved Tibbia College & Hospital, Govt. of Delhi, Principal & Assistant Director,
College &Hospital, Madhya Pradesh Ajmal Khan Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110 National Research Institute of Unani
E-mail reeteshdr@rediffmail.com 005 Mobile: +91 85888 75226 Medicine for Skin Disorders, A.G`s Colony
Mob –7869371496. E-mail ID: drmohammadidris@gmail.com Erragadda, Hyderabad- 500 038, India.
md.idris@gov.in Email: criumhyderabad@gmail.com
aarzu763@gmail.com
Phone: +919032519286

For Lecture 17 & 18 on Third Day


Dr. Gaurav Sawarkar Professor and HOD, Dr. Mithila Amin Dr. MANDEEP JAISWAL Associate
Dept. of Rachana Sharir, Mahatma Associate Prof, Professor & HOD Department of Rasa
Gandhi Ayurved College, Hospital & Dept. of Kaumarabhritya, Shastra &Bhaishajya Kalpana, SRM State
Research Centre, DMIHER (DU), Wardha, DY Patil School Of Ayurved, sector 7,Nerul, Ayurved College & Hospital, Bareilly, Uttar
Maharashtra. Navi Mumbai 400706. Pradesh.
Mob- 8956977899, 9970082590 Mob- 09969947997 Mob-9456614038; 9839442777
Email- drsawarkar.gaurav@gmail.com Email- vaidya.mithila@gmail.com E-mail mandeep.ayu@gmail.com
9
Dr. Aisha Anjum A, Professor & HOD Dr. Zakir Ali Maqbool Ahmad Khan, Assistant Dr. RAJASHEKHAR JAKATI Associate
Govt. Unani Medical College, Bangalore, Prof. dept. of Moalijat (Medicine) ZVM Unani Professor, Department of agadatantra
Karnataka Medical College, (Pune) MS. Shri J.G. Cooperative Hospital Society's
Email Id: dr.aanjuma@gmail.com Cont. +91-9561519303 E-mail: Ayurved Medical College, Ghataprabha,
Mobile No: 8951592300 dr.kzakir@gmail.com Tq Gokak, Dist. Belgaum, Karnataka,
mobile no 9742967250
Email-rajubams@gmail.com

For Lecture 19 & 20 on Third Day


Dr. PRASAD MAMIDI Professor & H.O.D, Dr. Nazim Husain Dr. GIRIMALLA S PATIL Assistant
Department of Kayachikitsa, R.B. Research Officer (Unani) Professor,Dept of Rasashastra and B.K
Ayurvedic medical college and hospital, Regional Research Institute of Unani All India Institute of Ayurveda,
Agra, Uttar Pradesh. Medicine, Silchar, Assam 788014 (a Sarita Vihar, New Delhi.
Contact number: +91-7567222856; Email peripheral of CCRUM under Ministry of Mob-9663588869
ID: drprasadmamidi@gmail.com Ayush, Govt. of India) Email-girishpatil.patil2@gmail.Com

Email ID: nazimrrium@gmail.com


10 Mob. +919212143572
Dr.Chander Shekhar Sharma, Professor& Dr. Nafasat Ali Ansari, Dr Asha Hosur
Head, Department of Kayachikitsa StateTakmil-ut-Tibb. College and Hospital, Associate Professor & HOD
Dayanand Ayurvedic College, Jalandhar, (Lucknow) UP. MOb.8005115252 Dept. of Prasooti tantra &Stree Roga,
Punjab Contact No. 9417785499 Email- naansari1963@gmail.com Government Ayurveda medical college
shekhars76@gmail.com and teaching, Shivamogga, karnataka
Email-ashafhosur@gmail.com Mob-
9480006711

You might also like