This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.

MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com

Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

06?>@B23;6
a
;@ E96 DFBC6?6 4AFCE A7 ;@5;2

4C;?;@2> 2BB6>>2E6 <FC;D5;4E;A@

4C;?;@2> 2BB62> @A&)',0 A7 )'(.

#5_V`V[T \ba \S G]RPVNY @RNcR a\ 5]]RNY #7_Y'$ B\'*0-* \S +)*0$ b

A\UNZZRQ 5OQbYYN ?UN[ h 5]]RYYN[a

(+3464 c

D_NXN`U ?' h FR`]\[QR[a

<F58?6@E

4LKMINKQRIP% <&

*' @RNcR T_N[aRQ'

+' HUR `\YR _R`]\[QR[a V` NQZVaaRQYf aUR \d[R_ \S N ?N[[NQN f

8NVYf BRd`]N]R_ Of [NZR k%)9) &.3)1)l ]bOYV`URQ S_\Z

AN[TNY\_R% ?N_[NaNXN' C[ */'*+'+)*,% aUR `NVQ [Rd`]N]R_

g
PN__VRQ N [Rd` VaRZ P\[aNV[V[T PR_aNV[ NYYRTNaV\[` NTNV[`a aUR
Signature Not Verified

Digitally signed by
DEEPAK MANSUKHANI
Date: 2017.12.04
15:58:33 IST
N]]RYYN[a UR_RV[' 5PP\_QV[T a\ aUR N]]RYYN[a% aUR NYYRTNaV\[` N_R
Reason:

UVTUYf QRSNZNa\_f V[ [Nab_R'

h
(
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

,' HUR N]]RYYN[a Y\QTRQ N _R]\_a dVaU aUR DN[NZOb_ D\YVPR%

a
AN[TNY\_R% 8NX`UV[N ?N[[NQN 8V`a_VPa \[ *0'*+'+)*, NTNV[`a

aUR _R`]\[QR[a N[Q N[\aUR_ ]R_`\[ dU\ dN` RQVa\_ \S aUR

NO\cRZR[aV\[RQ [Rd`]N]R_' D\YVPR QVQ [\a aNXR N[f NPaV\['

b
HUR_RNSaR_% aUR N]]RYYN[a SVYRQ N ]_VcNaR P\Z]YNV[a NTNV[`a aUR

_R`]\[QR[a N[Q aUR RQVa\_ \S aUR NO\cRZR[aV\[RQ [Rd`]N]R_

ORS\_R aUR >'A';'7'&==% AN[TNY\_R V[ D7F B\'+-(+)*- dUVPU c

RcR[abNYYf PNZR a\ OR [bZOR_RQ N` 77 B\'*+.+ \S +)*-' HUR

YRN_[RQ ANTV`a_NaR a\\X P\T[VgN[PR \S aUR ZNaaR_ \[ *.')-'+)*-

S\_ aUR \SSR[PR` ]b[V`UNOYR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .))% .)* N[Q .)+ \S d

aUR =[QVN[ DR[NY 7\QR% *1/)'

-' 5TT_VRcRQ Of aUR \_QR_ QNaRQ *.')-'+)*-% aUR _R`]\[QR[a

e
PN__VRQ aUR ZNaaR_ V[ FRcV`V\[ DRaVaV\[ B\'+*2 \S +)*- ORS\_R aUR

GR``V\[` >bQTR% 8NX`UV[N ?N[[NQN% AN[TNY\_R' 6f aUR \_QR_

QNaRQ )/'**'+)*.% aUR _R`]\[QR[an` _RcV`V\[ dN` QV`ZV``RQ'

f
FR`]\[QR[a Sb_aUR_ PN__VRQ aUR ZNaaR_ V[ 7_VZV[NY DRaVaV\[

B\'1/02 \S +)*. a\ aUR ?N_[NaNXN <VTU 7\b_a V[c\XV[T GRPaV\[

-1+ \S aUR 7\QR \S 7_VZV[NY D_\PRQb_R% *20,' 6f N[ \_QR_ QNaRQ

g
+,'**'+)*/% aUR `NVQ ]RaVaV\[ dN` NYY\dRQ N[Q aUR ]_\PRRQV[T` V[

77 B\'*+.+ \S +)*-% V[`\SN_ N` aURf ]R_aNV[RQ a\ aUR _R`]\[QR[a%

dR_R ^bN`URQ'
h
)
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

.' 6\aU V[ UV` _RcV`V\[ N` dRYY N` aUR ]RaVaV\[ b[QR_ GRPaV\[

a
-1+ 7_'D'7'% aUR _R`]\[QR[a b_TRQ cN_V\b` T_\b[Q` dUVPU

NPP\_QV[T a\ UVZ _R[QR_ aUR \_QR_ QNaRQ *.')-'+)*- VYYRTNY' HUR

QRaNVY` \S aU\`R cN_V\b` T_\b[Q` N_R [\a [RPR``N_f S\_ \b_

b
]b_]\`R'

/' HUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY V` cR_f P_f]aVP' HUR SV_`a aU_RR

]N_NT_N]U` \S aUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY #_b[[V[T V[a\ N `U\_a c

\[R N[Q N UNYS ]NTR$ ]b_]\_a a\ aNXR [\aR \S \[Yf \[R `bOZV``V\[

\S aUR _R`]\[QR[a'

kDN_N +' HUR YRN_[RQ 7\b[`RY S\_ aUR ]RaVaV\[R_ d\bYQ ]\V[a \ba d
aUNa aUR_R PN[ OR [\ cVPN_V\b` YVNOVYVaf V[`\SN_ N` aUR P_VZV[NY
YNd V` P\[PR_[RQ' HUR P\Z]YNV[N[an` NYYRTNaV\[ \S aUR
QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY ]bOYV`URQ V[ aUR [Rd`]N]R_ NTNV[`a UVZ%
RcR[ VS Va V` R`aNOYV`URQ% PN[ \[Yf OR `b`aNV[RQ NTNV[`a aUR RQVa\_
\S aUR [Rd`]N]R_ N[Q [\a aUR \d[R_ \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_' HUR
]RaVaV\[R_ NQZVaaRQYf dN` aUR \d[R_' HUR [Rd`]N]R_ PN__VR` N e
YRTR[Q aUNa aUR [Rd`]N]R_ V` RQVaRQ N[Q ]bOYV`URQ \[ ORUNYS \S
aUR ]RaVaV\[R_ N[Q aUR_R V` [\ QV`]baR V[ aUV` _RTN_Q'l

0' =a N]]RN_` S_\Z aUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY aUNa aUR

N]]RYYN[a UR_RV[ N_TbRQ aUNa V[ cVRd \S aUR YNd YNVQ Q\d[ V[ *$,$ f

,2B76E 7# *$%$ %3@272<# #+))+$ / G77 /0) aUR _R`]\[QR[an`

\OWRPaV\[ P\bYQ [\a OR `b`aNV[RQ' <VTU 7\b_a _RWRPaRQ aUR

`bOZV``V\[ \S aUR N]]RYYN[a' g

kDN_N ,' HU\bTU aUR YRN_[RQ 7\b[`RY S\_ aUR _R`]\[QR[a d\bYQ
`RRX a\ P\[aR[Q aUNa aUR ^bR`aV\[ V` [\ Y\[TR_ 3+4 .15+,3) N[Q V`
P\cR_RQ Of N WbQTZR[a \S aUR Gb]_RZR 7\b_a V[ aUR PN`R \S &#'#
')5-+8 74# &#$# $*3)-)0" 5=F +))+ G7 +212% Va V` U\dRcR_
[\aVPRQ aUNa aUR `NVQ QRPV`V\[ dN` V[ _R`]RPa \S N ZN[NTV[T h
*
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

RQVa\_% _R`VQR[a RQVa\_ \_ N PUVRS RQVa\_ \S _R`]RPaVcR [Rd`]N]R_

]bOYVPNaV\[`% dU\ dR_R ]N_aVR` aUR_RV['l a

HUR YRN_[RQ >bQTR _RP\_QRQ aUNa aUR WbQTZR[a V[ * , ,2B76EGA

42A6 P\bYQ OR QV`aV[TbV`URQ N[Q% aUR_RS\_R% \]V[RQ aUNa aUR

_R`]\[QR[an` ]RaVaV\[ V` _R^bV_RQ a\ OR NYY\dRQ' b

kDN_N ,' h HUR_RS\_R% Na aUR \ba`Ra% Va PN[ OR `NVQ aUNa aUR `NVQ
PN`R P\bYQ OR QV`aV[TbV`URQ S_\Z aUR PN`R \[ UN[Q% N`% aUR
]RaVaV\[R_ V` [\a PYNVZV[T N` N[ RQVa\_% dU\ UNQ N[f _\YR V[ aUR
]bOYVPNaV\[ \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_' HUR_RS\_R% Va V` N SVa PN`R dUR_R
aUR ]RaVaV\[ `U\bYQ OR NYY\dRQ'l c

=a V` b[S\_ab[NaR aUNa aUR <VTU 7\b_a QVQ [\a PU\\`R a\ TVcR N[f

_RN`\[ dUNa`\RcR_ S\_ ^bN`UV[T aUR P\Z]YNV[a RePR]a N T_N[Q

QRPYN_NaV\[ aUNa kVa d\bYQ YRNQ a\ N ZV`PN__VNTR \S Wb`aVPRl' d

k5PP\_QV[TYf% aU\bTU aUR P_VZV[NY ]_\PRRQV[T` PN[ T\ \[ NTNV[`a

aUR RQVa\_ \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_% aUR ]RaVaV\[R_ PN[[\a OR ]_\PRRQRQ
dVaU% N` Va d\bYQ YRNQ a\ N ZV`PN__VNTR \S Wb`aVPR'l

<R[PR% aUR N]]RNY' e

1' 6RS\_R b` aUR N]]RYYN[a N]]RN_RQ V[ ]R_`\[' =[`]VaR \S aUR

`R_cVPR \S [\aVPR% aUR _R`]\[QR[a [RVaUR_ PU\`R a\ N]]RN_ V[

f
]R_`\[ [\_ aU_\bTU N P\b[`RY' =[ cVRd \S aUR SNPa aUNa N

`bO`aN[aVNY ^bR`aV\[ \S YNd V` V[c\YcRQ V[ aUR ZNaaR_% dR aU\bTUa

Va N]]_\]_VNaR a\ _R^bR`a GU_V A'B' FN\% YRN_[RQ GR[V\_ 5Qc\PNaR

g
a\ N``V`a aUR 7\b_a V[ aUV` ZNaaR_'

h
+
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

2' <RN_Q GU_V A'B' FN\% YRN_[RQ GR[V\_ 5Qc\PNaR S\_ aUR
a
N]]RYYN[a'

*)' GRPaV\[ -22 =D7 QRSV[R` aUR \SSR[PR \S QRSNZNaV\[' =a

b
P\[aNV[` *) RePR]aV\[` N[Q - Re]YN[NaV\[`' HUR _RYRcN[a ]\_aV\[

_RNQ`4

kGRPaV\[ -22' 8RSNZNaV\['j JU\RcR_% Of d\_Q` RVaUR_ `]\XR[ \_

V[aR[QRQ a\ OR _RNQ% \_ Of `VT[` \_ Of cV`VOYR _R]_R`R[aNaV\[`%
ZNXR` \_ ]bOYV`UR` N[f VZ]baNaV\[ P\[PR_[V[T N[f ]R_`\[ c
V[aR[QV[T a\ UN_Z% \_ X[\dV[T \_ UNcV[T _RN`\[ a\ ORYVRcR aUNa
`bPU VZ]baNaV\[ dVYY UN_Z% aUR _R]baNaV\[ \S `bPU ]R_`\[% V`
`NVQ% RePR]a V[ aUR PN`R` UR_RV[NSaR_ Re]RPaRQ% a\ QRSNZR aUNa
]R_`\['l

d
**' 5[ N[NYf`V` \S aUR NO\cR _RcRNY` aUNa a\ P\[`aVabaR N[

\SSR[PR \S QRSNZNaV\[ Va _R^bV_R` N ]R_`\[ a\ ZNXR `\ZR

VZ]baNaV\[ P\[PR_[V[T N[f \aUR_ ]R_`\[4

e
#V$ GbPU VZ]baNaV\[ Zb`a OR ZNQR RVaUR_

#N$ JVaU V[aR[aV\[% \_

#O$ ?[\dYRQTR% \_
f
#P$ <NcV[T N _RN`\[ a\ ORYVRcR

aUNa `bPU N[ VZ]baNaV\[ dVYY UN_Z aUR _R]baNaV\[ \S aUR ]R_`\[

NTNV[`a dU\Z aUR VZ]baNaV\[ V` ZNQR' g

#VV$ =Z]baNaV\[ P\bYQ OR% Of

#N$ J\_Q`% RVaUR_ `]\XR[ \_ d_VaaR[% \_

h
,
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

#O$ 6f ZNXV[T `VT[`% \_

a
#P$ IV`VOYR _R]_R`R[aNaV\[`

#VVV$ =Z]baNaV\[ P\bYQ OR RVaUR_ ZNQR \_ ]bOYV`URQ'

HUR QVSSR_R[PR ORadRR[ ZNXV[T \S N[ VZ]baNaV\[ N[Q b

]bOYV`UV[T aUR `NZR V`3

=S mKn aRYY` mLn aUNa mLn V` N P_VZV[NY i mKn ZNXR` N[ VZ]baNaV\['

c
=S mKn aRYY` mMn aUNa mLn V` N P_VZV[NY i mKn ]bOYV`UR` aUR

VZ]baNaV\['

HUR R``R[PR \S ]bOYVPNaV\[ V[ aUR P\[aRea \S GRPaV\[ -22 V` d

aUR P\ZZb[VPNaV\[ \S QRSNZNa\_f VZ]baNaV\[ a\ ]R_`\[` \aUR_

aUN[ aUR ]R_`\[` NTNV[`a dU\Z aUR VZ]baNaV\[ V` ZNQR'*

e
*+' 7\ZZVaaV[T N[f NPa dUVPU P\[`aVabaR` QRSNZNaV\[ b[QR_

GRPaV\[ -22 =D7 V` ]b[V`UNOYR \SSR[PR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)) =D7'

D_V[aV[T \_ R[T_NcV[T N[f QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY V` NYa\TRaUR_ N

f
QVSSR_R[a \SSR[PR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)* =D7' CSSR_V[T S\_ `NYR \_

`RYYV[T N[f `bPU ]_V[aRQ \_ R[T_NcRQ QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY V` fRa

N[\aUR_ QV`aV[Pa \SSR[PR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)+ =D7'

g

"
'013+ )+4- #" &36.757 " "'.),# )- 1JD 43 -&+ "0EE#/ $3+7 *14/0 #" '#*# %+-+21+" "'.+*# ( 1JD 43 +.) "6<L#
h
-
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

*,' =S aUR P\[aR[a \S N[f [Rd` VaRZ PN__VRQ V[ N [Rd`]N]R_ V`

a
QRSNZNa\_f N` QRSV[RQ b[QR_ GRPaV\[ -22 =D7% aUR ZR_R ]_V[aV[T

\S `bPU ZNaR_VNY kX[\dV[T \_ UNcV[T T\\Q _RN`\[ a\ ORYVRcR aUNa

`bPU ZNaaR_ V` QRSNZNa\_fl Va`RYS P\[`aVabaR` N QV`aV[Pa \SSR[PR

b
b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)* =D7' HUR `NYR \_ \SSR_V[T S\_ `NYR \S `bPU

]_V[aRQ k`bO`aN[PR P\[aNV[V[T QRSNZNa\_f ZNaaR_l kX[\dV[T aUNa

Va P\[aNV[` `bPU ZNaaR_l V` N QV`aV[Pa \SSR[PR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)+ c

=D7'

*-' JURaUR_ N[ NPPb`RQ #`bPU N` aUR _R`]\[QR[a$ NTNV[`a dU\Z

N P\Z]YNV[a V` _RTV`aR_RQ b[QR_ cN_V\b` GRPaV\[` \S aUR =D7 d

#GRPaV\[` .))% .)* " .)+ =D7$ P\bYQ OR P\[cVPaRQ S\_ N[f \S aU\`R

\SSR[PR` QR]R[Q` b]\[ aUR RcVQR[PR _RTN_QV[T aUR ReV`aR[PR \S

e
aUR SNPa` _RYRcN[a a\ P\[`aVabaR aU\`R \SSR[PR`'

*.' =[ aUR P\[aRea \S aUR SNPa` \S aUR ]_R`R[a PN`R% SV_`a \S NYY% Va

Zb`a OR R`aNOYV`URQ aUNa aUR ZNaaR_ ]_V[aRQ N[Q \SSR_RQ S\_ `NYR
f
V` QRSNZNa\_f dVaUV[ aUR ZRN[V[T \S aUR Re]_R``V\[ b[QR_ GRPaV\[

-22 =D7' =S `\ ]_\cRQ% aUR [Rea `aR] d\bYQ OR a\ ReNZV[R aUR

^bR`aV\[ dURaUR_ aUR NPPb`RQ P\ZZVaaRQ aUR NPa` dUVPU

g
P\[`aVabaR aUR \SSR[PR \S dUVPU UR V` PUN_TRQ dVaU aUR _R^bV`VaR

V[aR[aV\[ \_ X[\dYRQTR RaP' a\ ZNXR UV` NPa` PbY]NOYR'

h
.
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

*/' 5[`dR_ a\ aUR ^bR`aV\[ QR]R[Q` b]\[ aUR SNPa`' =S aUR

a
_R`]\[QR[a V` aUR ]R_`\[ dU\ RVaUR_ ZNQR \_ ]bOYV`URQ aUR

QRSNZNa\_f VZ]baNaV\[% UR d\bYQ OR YVNOYR S\_ ]b[V`UZR[a b[QR_

GRPaV\[ .)) =D7' =S UR V` aUR ]R_`\[ dU\ k]_V[aRQl aUR ZNaaR_

b
dVaUV[ aUR ZRN[V[T \S aUR Re]_R``V\[ b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)* =D7'

GVZVYN_Yf a\ P\[`aVabaR N[ \SSR[PR b[QR_ GRPaV\[ .)+ =D7% Va Zb`a

OR R`aNOYV`URQ aUNa aUR _R`]\[QR[a V` [\a \[Yf aUR \d[R_ \S aUR c

[Rd`]N]R_ Oba NY`\ `\YQ \_ \SSR_RQ aUR [Rd`]N]R_ S\_ `NYR'

*0' JR Zb`a ZNXR Va PYRN_ aUNa S\_ aUR NPa` \S ]_V[aV[T \_ `RYYV[T

\_ \SSR_V[T a\ `RYY [RRQ [\a \[Yf OR aUR ]Uf`VPNY NPa` Oba V[PYbQR d

aUR YRTNY _VTUa a\ `RYY V'R' a\ a_N[`SR_ aUR aVaYR V[ aUR T\\Q` & aUR

[Rd`]N]R_' HU\`R NPaVcVaVR` VS PN__VRQ \[ Of ]R\]YR% dU\ N_R

e
RZ]Y\fRQ RVaUR_ QV_RPaYf \_ V[QV_RPaYf Of aUR \d[R_ \S aUR

[Rd`]N]R_% ]R_UN]` _R[QR_ NYY \S aURZ V'R'% aUR \d[R_% aUR

]_V[aR_% \_ aUR ]R_`\[ `RYYV[T \_ \SSR_V[T S\_ `NYR YVNOYR S\_ aUR
f
\SSR[PR` b[QR_ GRPaV\[` .)* \_ .)+ =D7% #N` aUR PN`R ZNf OR$ VS

aUR \aUR_ RYRZR[a` V[QVPNaRQ V[ aU\`R GRPaV\[` N_R `NaV`SVRQ'

*1' JURaUR_ aUR P\[aR[a \S aUR N]]RYYN[an` P\Z]YNV[a P\[`aVabaR`

g
N[ \SSR[PR ]b[V`UNOYR b[QR_ N[f \[R \_ NYY \_ `\ZR \S aUR

NO\cRZR[aV\[RQ `RPaV\[` dN` [\a ReNZV[RQ Of aUR <VTU 7\b_a S\_

^bN`UV[T aUR P\Z]YNV[a NTNV[`a aUR _R`]\[QR[a' G\ dR [RRQ [\a

h
/
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

a_\bOYR \b_`RYcR` a\ QRNY dVaU aUNa ^bR`aV\[' JR ]_R`bZR S\_ aUR

a
]b_]\`R \S aUV` N]]RNY aUNa aUR P\[aR[a \S aUR N]]RYYN[an`

P\Z]YNV[a Q\R` QV`PY\`R aUR SNPa` [RPR``N_f a\ R`aNOYV`U aUR

P\ZZV``V\[ \S \[R \_ NYY \S aUR \SSR[PR` ZR[aV\[RQ NO\cR'

b
JURaUR_ aUR_R V` `bSSVPVR[a RcVQR[PR a\ R`aNOYV`U aUR TbVYa \S aUR

_R`]\[QR[a S\_ N[f \[R \S aUR NO\cRZR[aV\[RQ aU_RR \SSR[PR` V` N

ZNaaR_ aUNa PN[ OR ReNZV[RQ \[Yf NSaR_ _RP\_QV[T RcVQR[PR Na aUR c

aVZR \S a_VNY' HUNa PN[ [RcR_ OR N `bOWRPa ZNaaR_ \S N ]_\PRRQV[T

b[QR_ GRPaV\[ -1+ 7_'D'7'

*2' ;_\Z aUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY% Va N]]RN_` aUNa ORS\_R aUR d

<VTU 7\b_a Va dN` N_TbRQ \[ ORUNYS \S aUR _R`]\[QR[a aUNa aUR_R

V` [\ cVPN_V\b` YVNOVYVaf V[ P_VZV[NY YNd N[Q aUR_RS\_R aUR \d[R_ \S

e
N [Rd`]N]R_ PN[[\a OR ]_\`RPbaRQ S\_ aUR \SSR[PR` \S QRSNZNaV\['

k+' HUR YRN_[RQ P\b[`RY S\_ aUR ]RaVaV\[R_ d\bYQ ]\V[a \ba aUNa
aUR_R PN[ OR [\ cVPN_V\b` YVNOVYVaf V[`\SN_ N` aUR P_VZV[NY YNd V`
P\[PR_[RQ' HUR P\Z]YNV[N[an` NYYRTNaV\[ \S aUR QRSNZNa\_f
ZNaR_VNY ]bOYV`URQ V[ aUR [Rd`]N]R_ NTNV[`a UVZ% RcR[ VS Va V`
R`aNOYV`URQ% PN[ \[Yf OR `b`aNV[RQ NTNV[`a aUR RQVa\_ \S aUR f
[Rd`]N]R_ N[Q [\a aUR \d[R_ \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_' HUR ]RaVaV\[R_
NQZVaaRQYf dN` aUR \d[R_' HUR [Rd`]N]R_ PN__VR` N YRTR[Q aUNa
aUR [Rd`]N]R_ V` RQVaRQ N[Q ]bOYV`URQ \[ ORUNYS \S aUR ]RaVaV\[R_
N[Q aUR_R V` [\ QV`]baR V[ aUV` _RTN_Q'l

+)' =a N]]RN_` S_\Z ]N_N , \S aUR WbQTZR[a aUNa aUR N]]RYYN[a g

UR_RV[ `bOZVaaRQ V[ _R`]\[`R a\ aUR NO\cR Rea_NPaRQ P\[aR[aV\[ \S

aUR _R`]\[QR[a aUNa aUR ^bR`aV\[ V` [\ Y\[TR_ 3+4 .15+,3) N[Q V`

h
0
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

P\cR_RQ Of N WbQTZR[a \S aUV` 7\b_a V[ *$,$ ,2B76E 7# *$%$

a
%3@272< " .B76@A'+

HUR <VTU 7\b_a _RWRPaRQ aUR `bOZV``V\[ U\YQV[T3

khh'Va V` U\dRcR_ [\aVPRQ aUNa aUR `NVQ QRPV`V\[ dN` V[ _R`]RPa b

\S N ZN[NTV[T RQVa\_% _R`VQR[a RQVa\_ \_ N PUVRS RQVa\_ \S
_R`]RPaVcR [Rd`]N]R_ ]bOYVPNaV\[`% dU\ dR_R ]N_aVR` aUR_RV['
HUR_RS\_R% Na aUR \ba`Ra% Va PN[ OR `NVQ aUNa aUR `NVQ PN`R P\bYQ
OR QV`aV[TbV`URQ S_\Z aUR PN`R \[ UN[Q% N`% aUR ]RaVaV\[R_ V`
[\a PYNVZV[T N` N[ RQVa\_% dU\ UNQ N[f _\YR V[ aUR ]bOYVPNaV\[
\S aUR [Rd`]N]R_' HUR_RS\_R% Va V` N SVa PN`R dUR_R aUR ]RaVaV\[
`U\bYQ OR NYY\dRQ'l c

HUR <VTU 7\b_a P\[PYbQRQ aUNa ]_\`RPbaV\[ \S aUR _R`]\[QR[a

d\bYQ YRNQ a\ ZV`PN__VNTR \S Wb`aVPR' 5 P\[PYb`V\[ dVaU\ba N[f

QV`Pb``V\[ N[Q dVaU\ba QV`PY\`V[T N[f ]_V[PV]YR dUVPU S\_Z` aUR d

ON`V` \S aUR P\[PYb`V\['

724ED% ;DDF6 " C2E;A 564;56@5; A7 =&?& ?2E96GSD 42D61

e
+*' ?'A' ANaURd dN` aUR k7UVRS 9QVa\_l \S N QNVYf PNYYRQ

')/)9)/)0 ')123)0)' JUR[ UR dN` `\bTUa a\ OR ]_\`RPbaRQ S\_

aUR \SSR[PR \S QRSNZNaV\[% UR N]]_\NPURQ aUR <VTU 7\b_a b[QR_

f
GRPaV\[ -1+ 7_'D'7' ]_NfV[T aUNa aUR ]_\`RPbaV\[ OR ^bN`URQ \[

aUR T_\b[Q aUNa GRPaV\[ 0 \S aUR D_R`` N[Q FRTV`a_NaV\[ \S 6\\X`

5Pa% *1/0 \[Yf ]R_ZVa` aUR ]_\`RPbaV\[ \S aUR 9QVa\_ Oba [\a aUR
g
7UVRS 9QVa\_' HUR <VTU 7\b_a _RWRPaRQ aUR `bOZV``V\['

#
#+))+$ / G77 /0) h
('
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

++' 9cR[ ORS\_R aUV` 7\b_a% aUR `NZR `bOZV``V\[ dN` ZNQR' ,
a
HUV` 7\b_a _RWRPaRQ aUR `bOZV``V\[ U\YQV[T3

k*/' HUR P\[aR[aV\[ \S aUR`R N]]RYYN[a` V` [\a aR[NOYR' HUR_R

V` [\ `aNaba\_f VZZb[Vaf S\_ aUR 7UVRS 9QVa\_ NTNV[`a N[f
]_\`RPbaV\[ S\_ aUR NYYRTRQ ]bOYVPNaV\[ \S N[f ZNaaR_ V[ aUR
[Rd`]N]R_ \cR_ dUVPU aUR`R ]R_`\[` ReR_PV`R P\[a_\Y'l b

=a dN` Sb_aUR_ URYQ aUNa aU\bTU aUR ]_R`bZ]aV\[ b[QR_ GRPaV\[ 0

\S aUR D_R`` N[Q FRTV`a_NaV\[ \S 6\\X` 5Pa% *1/0 V` [\a N]]YVPNOYR

a\ `\ZRO\Qf dU\`R [NZR V` ]_V[aRQ V[ aUR [Rd`]N]R_ N` aUR c

7UVRS 9QVa\_% aUR P\Z]YNV[N[a PN[ `aVYY NYYRTR N[Q ]_\cR aUNa

]R_`\[` \aUR_ aUN[ aUR 9QVa\_% VS aURf N_R _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ aUR

]bOYVPNaV\[ \S aUR QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY' d

k+)' HUR ]_\cV`V\[` P\[aNV[RQ V[ aUR 5Pa PYRN_Yf T\ a\ `U\d aUNa

aUR_R P\bYQ OR N ]_R`bZ]aV\[ NTNV[`a aUR 9QVa\_ dU\`R [NZR V`
]_V[aRQ V[ aUR [Rd`]N]R_ a\ aUR RSSRPa aUNa UR V` aUR 9QVa\_ \S
`bPU ]bOYVPNaV\[ N[Q aUNa UR V` _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ `RYRPaV[T aUR
ZNaaR_ S\_ ]bOYVPNaV\[' HU\bTU% N `VZVYN_ ]_R`bZ]aV\[ PN[[\a e
OR Q_Nd[ NTNV[`a aUR 7UVRS 9QVa\_% FR`VQR[a 9QVa\_ \_ AN[NTV[T
9QVa\_% [RcR_aURYR``% aUR P\Z]YNV[N[a PN[ `aVYY NYYRTR N[Q ]_\cR
aUNa aURf UNQ X[\dYRQTR N[Q aURf dR_R _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ aUR
]bOYVPNaV\[ \S aUR QRSNZNa\_f [Rd` VaRZ' 9cR[ aUR ]_R`bZ]aV\[
b[QR_ GRPaV\[ 0 V` N _RObaaNOYR ]_R`bZ]aV\[ N[Q aUR `NZR P\bYQ
OR ]_\cRQ \aUR_dV`R' HUNa Of Va`RYS V[QVPNaR` aUNa `\ZRO\Qf
\aUR_ aUN[ RQVa\_ PN[ NY`\ OR URYQ _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ `RYRPaV[T aUR f
ZNaaR_ S\_ ]bOYVPNaV\[ V[ N [Rd`]N]R_'l

+,' *$,$ ,2B76EGA 42A6 UN` [\aUV[T a\ Q\ dVaU aUR ^bR`aV\[ \S

cVPN_V\b` YVNOVYVaf' HUR N_TbZR[a V[ *$,$ ,2B76EGA 42A6 dN`

g
aUNa V[ cVRd \S GRPaV\[ 0 \S aUR D_R`` N[Q FRTV`a_NaV\[ \S 6\\X`

$
8C@ >HGL@GLDHG HA LC@ <II@EE<GLK DG LC@K@ ><K@K DK LC<L LC@O C<? GHL =@@G KCHNG <K 2?DLHJK DG LC@K@ IM=ED><LDHGK
<G? LC<L LC@DJ G<F@K N@J@ IJDGL@? @DLC@J <K 1CD@A 2?DLHJ$ 5<G<BDGB 2?DLHJ HJ 7@KD?@GL 2?DLHJ <G? GHL <K P2?DLHJQ
<G? LC@J@ ><GGHL =@ <GO >JDFDG<E IJHK@>MLDHG <B<DGKL LC@F AHJ LC@ <EE@B@? ED=@EEHMK IM=ED><LDHG HA <GO F<LL@J DG
LC<L G@NKI<I@J% 96<J< '* HA '#(# (+90.;<8 ,+8.; h
((
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

5Pa% *1/0 \[Yf aUR 9QVa\_ \S N [Rd`]N]R_ P\bYQ OR ]_\`RPbaRQ S\_

a
QRSNZNaV\[' GbPU N `bOZV``V\[ dN` _RWRPaRQ U\YQV[T aUNa GRPaV\[

0 Q\R` [\a P_RNaR N[f VZZb[Vaf V[ SNc\b_ \S ]R_`\[` \aUR_ aUN[

aUR 9QVa\_ \S N [Rd`]N]R_' =a \[Yf P_RNaR` N _RObaaNOYR

b
]_R`bZ]aV\[ aUNa aUR ]R_`\[ dU\`R [NZR V` `U\d[ N` aUR RQVa\_

\S aUR [Rd`]N]R_ V` _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ aUR PU\VPR N[Q ]bOYVPNaV\[ \S

aUR ZNaR_VNY V[ aUR [Rd`]N]R_' *$,$ ,2B76EGA 42A6 ZNQR Va c

PYRN_ aUNa VS N P\Z]YNV[a P\[aNV[` NYYRTNaV\[` #dUVPU VS ]_\cRQ

d\bYQ P\[`aVabaR QRSNZNaV\[$% ]R_`\[ \aUR_ aUN[ aUR \[R dU\ V`

QRPYN_RQ a\ OR aUR RQVa\_ \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_` PN[ OR ]_\`RPbaRQ VS d

aURf N_R NYYRTRQ a\ OR _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ aUR ]bOYVPNaV\[ \S `bPU

QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY'

e
HUR <VTU 7\b_a% V[ \b_ \]V[V\[% dVaU\ba ReNZV[V[T aUR _NaV\

\S *$,$ ,2B76EGA 42A6 PU\`R a\ P\[PYbQR aUNa aUR QRPV`V\[ V`

QV`aV[TbV`UNOYR' HUR WbQTZR[a \S aUR <VTU 7\b_a V` NO`\YbaRYf

f
b[`a_bPab_RQ YRNcV[T ZbPU a\ OR QR`V_RQ'

+-' IVPN_V\b` YVNOVYVaf S\_ N P_VZR V` NYa\TRaUR_ N QVSSR_R[a ZNaaR_'

g
=[ 9[TYN[Q% Na \[R ]\V[a \S aVZR% aUR \d[R_ \S N [Rd`]N]R_ dN`

URYQ a\ OR cVPN_V\b`Yf YVNOYR S\_ N[ \SSR[PR \S QRSNZNaV\[ #YVORY$'

HUR UV`a\_f \S YNd V[ aUV` _RTN_Q V` `bPPV[PaYf `aNaRQ Of @\_Q

h
()
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

7\PXOb_[ V[ 176 /C66= 7# )>;3@>>9'- HU\bTU aUR_R N]]RN_` a\

a
OR `\ZR Z\QVSVPNaV\[ \S aUR YNd `bO`R^bR[a a\ aUR R[NPaZR[a \S

@\_Q 7NZ]ORYYn` 5Pa V'R' aUR @VORY 5Pa *1-, #/"0 IVPa 7 2/$'

@\_Q 7NZ]ORYYn` 5Pa QVQ [\a N]]Yf a\ =[QVN' HUR D_R`` N[Q
b
FRTV`a_NaV\[ \S 6\\X` 5Pa #5Pa KKI \S *1/0$ V` ZNQR N]]YVPNOYR a\

6_VaV`U =[QVN N[Q P\[aV[bR` a\ OR V[ S\_PR Of cV_abR \S aUR

QRPYN_NaV\[ b[QR_ 5_aVPYR ,0+ \S aUR 7\[`aVabaV\[ \S =[QVN' HUR_R c

N_R ZNaR_VNY QVSSR_R[PR` ORadRR[ aUR `PURZR N[Q aR[\_ \S O\aU

aUR R[NPaZR[a`' =[ 02<2A2<8 7# +>92=252% #*11/$ =@F 2 ANQ

/2+% Va dN` URYQ3 d

kh 6ba dR PN[[\a U\YQ aUNa aUR ]_\cV`V\[` \S aUNa GaNabaR #9Q'

@\_Q 7NZ]ORYYn` 5Pa$ N_R N]]YVPNOYR a\ aUV` P\b[a_f% N[Q dR Zb`a
QRaR_ZV[R dURaUR_ aUR NPPb`RQ V` \_ V` [\a TbVYaf \S QRSNZNaV\[
dVaU _RSR_R[PR a\ aUR ]_\cV`V\[` \S aUR =[QVN[ DR[NY 7\QR' JR
P\[`VQR_ aUNa Va d\bYQ OR N `bSSVPVR[a N[`dR_ a\ aUR PUN_TR V[ aUV`
P\b[a_f VS aUR NPPb`RQ `U\dRQ aUNa UR R[a_b`aRQ V[ T\\Q SNVaU aUR e
aRZ]\_N_f ZN[NTRZR[a \S aUR [Rd`]N]R_ a\ N P\Z]RaR[a ]R_`\[
Qb_V[T UV` NO`R[PR% N[Q aUNa aUR YVORY dN` ]bOYV`URQ dVaU\ba UV`
NbaU\_Vaf% X[\dYRQTR \_ P\[`R[a' 5` aUR >bQTR UN`% U\dRcR_%
ZV`N]]_RUR[QRQ aUR RSSRPa \S 5Pa KKI \S *1/0% dR `UNYY `Ra N`VQR
aUR \_QR_ \S NP^bVaaNY ZNQR Of UVZ N[Q QV_RPa UVZ a\ _R`a\_R aUR
N]]RNY a\ UV` SVYR% a\ P\[`VQR_ aUR RcVQR[PR ]_\QbPRQ Of aUR
f
NPPb`RQ N[Q aUR[ a\ QV`]\`R \S aUR N]]RNY dVaU _RSR_R[PR a\ aUR
S\_RT\V[T \O`R_cNaV\[`'l

N[Q _RVaR_NaRQ V[ '<?6@>@ 7# &>58 -2@2F2=2 02> IOJ ($

)2@8A2@D>B72<2 02>% #*2)2$ =@F ,+ ANQ ,,13

g
k@\_Q 7NZ]ORYYn` 5Pa% \S P\b_`R% V` [\a V[ S\_PR V[ =[QVN% N[Q aUR
7_VZV[NY @Nd \S 9[TYN[Q V` [\a [RPR``N_VYf aUR `NZR N` aUR
7_VZV[NY @Nd \S =[QVN N` P\[aNV[RQ V[ aUR =[QVN[ DR[NY 7\QR hl

%
@'F' , E68 /) h
(*
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

+.' HUR ReaR[a \S aUR N]]YVPNOVYVaf \S aUR ]_V[PV]YR \S cVPN_V\b` a

YVNOVYVaf V[ P_VZV[NY YNd ]N_aVPbYN_Yf V[ aUR P\[aRea \S aUR \SSR[PR`

_RYNaV[T a\ QRSNZNaV\[ N_R [RVaUR_ QV`Pb``RQ Of aUR <VTU 7\b_a V[

b
aUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY [\_ N_TbRQ ORS\_R b` ORPNb`R aUR

_R`]\[QR[a [RVaUR_ N]]RN_RQ V[ ]R_`\[ [\_ aU_\bTU N[f

NQc\PNaR' HUR_RS\_R% dR QR`V`a S_\Z ReNZV[V[T aUR ^bR`aV\[ V[

c
QRaNVY' 6ba dR N_R \S aUR \]V[V\[ aUNa aUR ^bR`aV\[ _R^bV_R` N

`R_V\b` ReNZV[NaV\[ V[ N[ N]]_\]_VNaR PN`R ORPNb`R aUR \d[R_ \S

N [Rd`]N]R_ RZ]Y\f` ]R\]YR a\ ]_V[a% ]bOYV`U N[Q `RYY aUR

d
[Rd`]N]R_ a\ ZNXR N SV[N[PVNY TNV[ \ba \S aUR `NVQ NPaVcVaf' 9NPU

\S aUR NO\cRZR[aV\[RQ NPaVcVaVR` V` PN__VRQ \[ Of ]R_`\[`

RZ]Y\fRQ Of aUR \d[R_'

e

+/' JUR_R QRSNZNa\_f ZNaaR_ V` ]_V[aRQ #V[ N [Rd`]N]R_ \_ N

O\\X RaP'$ N[Q `\YQ \_ \SSR_RQ S\_ `NYR% dURaUR_ aUR \d[R_ aUR_R\S

PN[ OR URN_Q a\ `Nf aUNa UR PN[[\a OR ZNQR cVPN_V\b`Yf YVNOYR S\_ f

aUR QRSNZNa\_f ZNaR_VNY PN__VRQ Of UV` [Rd`]N]R_ RaP' _R^bV_R` N

P_VaVPNY ReNZV[NaV\['

g
+0' 9NPU PN`R _R^bV_R` N PN_RSbY `P_baV[f \S aUR cN_V\b`

^bR`aV\[` V[QVPNaRQ NO\cR' BRVaUR_ ]_\`RPbaV\[` [\_ aUR ]\dR_

h
(+
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

b[QR_ GRPaV\[ -1+ 7_D7 PN[ OR RVaUR_ P\[QbPaRQ \_ ReR_PV`RQ a

PN`bNYYf N` dN` Q\[R V[ aUR PN`R \[ UN[Q'

+1' HUR WbQTZR[a b[QR_ N]]RNY PN[[\a OR `b`aNV[RQ S\_ aUR

b
_RN`\[` V[QVPNaRQ NO\cR' HUR `NZR V`% aUR_RS\_R% `Ra&N`VQR N[Q

aUR N]]RNY V` NYY\dRQ' HUR a_VNY P\b_a dVYY [\d ]_\PRRQ dVaU aUR

PN`R V[ NPP\_QN[PR dVaU YNd'

c

h'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3%
#<& 496>2?6DG2C$
d

h'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3%
#D& 235F> @2H66C$

BRd 8RYUV e
8RPRZOR_ -% +)*0

(,
This is a True Court Copy™ of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
MANU/SC/1520/2017 : Downloaded from www.manupatra.com
Printed on : 07 Mar 2024 Printed for : The Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law

TM
This is a True Court Copy of the judgment as appearing on the Court website.
Publisher has only added the Page para for convenience in referencing.