Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SM Final Report_Group 10(1)
SM Final Report_Group 10(1)
REPORT ON:
Submitted To:
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OVERVIEW OF KEY FINDINGS
The report thoroughly explores the commercial aviation industry with a focus on IndiGo, detailing
its competitive positioning and strategy within the rapidly evolving sector. Key findings highlight
IndiGo's dominance in the Indian aviation market, operational excellence, and strategic focus on
cost efficiency and customer satisfaction. Additionally, it addresses broader industry trends,
including the rapid expansion of the aviation sector, driven by increasing demand and
technological advancements, while also noting significant challenges such as fuel price volatility
and regulatory hurdles.
RECOMMENDATIONS
To bolster IndiGo's market dominance and foster the overall growth of the aviation sector, our
recommendations converge on enhancing customer service, optimizing cost efficiency, and
pursuing strategic expansion. IndiGo should focus on refining customer experiences through
superior service delivery and robust complaint resolution mechanisms, while also leveraging
technological advancements to streamline operations and engage customers more effectively.
Strategic fleet expansion with an emphasis on fuel-efficient aircraft will not only support
IndiGo's sustainable growth ambitions but also align with environmental sustainability goals.
Expanding international routes and forming strategic alliances will enable IndiGo to capitalize on
its domestic market strength and broaden its global footprint. For the government, simplifying
regulatory frameworks, incentivizing sustainable aviation practices, improving regional
connectivity, and advocating for carbon offsetting initiatives are critical steps to facilitate
industry growth and environmental stewardship.
INTRODUCTION
PURPOSE OF THE REPORT
This report aims to thoroughly examine the commercial aviation industry, focusing on its
attractiveness, challenges, and opportunities. It will analyze the various factors influencing the
industry's competitiveness and highlight the key challenges it faces today, as well as the emerging
opportunities expected to shape its future.
Moreover, the report will conduct a detailed analysis of IndiGo, a prominent player in the
commercial aviation sector. By scrutinizing IndiGo's business and corporate strategies, as well as
its key resources, capabilities, and core competencies, it seeks to uncover the factors contributing
to its competitive advantage over its rivals.
2
Based on the insights gained from the industry analysis and IndiGo's strategic examination,
actionable recommendations and suggestions will be provided for IndiGo to enhance its
competitive position in the short-term and medium-term.
Lastly, the report will offer recommendations to the government on potential policy changes that
could positively impact the commercial aviation industry and benefit companies like IndiGo.
These recommendations will aim to create a regulatory environment conducive to industry
growth and innovation.
• India's commercial aviation segment is the largest for aircraft deliveries and India ranks as the
third-largest domestic aviation market globally.
• Predicted to surpass the UK to become the third-largest air passenger market by 2024.
• Aviation contributes 5% to India's GDP and generates 4 million jobs.
• The industry adds USD 72 billion in gross value-added contribution to GDP.
• Expected increase in the air fleet from 600 to 1,200 by 2024
• In FY23, airports in India pegged the domestic passenger traffic to reach 270.34 million, a 62.1%
YoY increase, and international passenger traffic to reach 56.9 million, a 157% YoY increase, as
compared to FY22
• Freight traffic at Indian airports grew at a CAGR of 2.20% from FY16 to FY23, from 2.70 MMT to
3.15 MMT.
• To manage rising air traffic, India aims to expand its number of operational airports from 148 in
2023 to 220 by 2025.
3
Market Dominance
• IndiGo holds a significant 60.5 % market share in the Indian domestic aviation sector,
positioning itself as a crucial player for examination. Its dominance in both domestic and
international operations make it a pertinent subject for analysis.
Operational Excellence
• Renowned for streamlined operations and a cost-efficient business model, IndiGo
consistently demonstrates profitability amidst fierce competition. Examining its operational
strategies provides valuable insights into achieving efficiency in aviation.
Strategic Positioning
• IndiGo strategically positions itself as a leading low-cost carrier, appealing primarily to
budget-conscious travelers. Understanding how it maintains this positioning amid market
shifts and evolving consumer preferences is pivotal for understanding its competitive edge.
INDUSTRY ANALYSIS
MARKET OVERVIEW
4
Growth Trends:
• Asia-Pacific Leads Recovery: The Asia-Pacific region saw a 10% surge in air passenger traffic in
2022, totaling 2.2 billion passengers, showcasing strong recovery and pent-up demand post-
pandemic.
• Fleet Expansion Plans: Airlines in major countries like China, India, Japan, and Indonesia,
representing 70% of the region's air traffic, are actively expanding fleets to meet rising demand
for air travel.
• Improvements in Passenger Load Factors: The Asia-Pacific region achieved a notable 17.9
percentage point increase in passenger load factors, reaching a robust 78.8%, indicating
efficient capacity utilization by airlines.
Market Size: The aviation industry in India has emerged as one of the fastest-growing industries
in the country during the last three years. Domestic traffic contributes around 69% of the total
airline traffic in South Asia and India’s airport capacity is expected to handle 1 billion trips
annually by 2023. The air traffic movement stood at 327.28 million in FY23 compared to 188.89
million in FY22.
Indigo is the largest airline company in India with the highest market share. India has become
the third-largest domestic aviation market in the world and is expected to overtake the UK to
become the third-largest air passenger market by 2024.
Growth Trends:
5
• MRO Services: The projected upsurge in air travel is expected to drive the demand for
Maintenance, Repair & Overhaul (MRO) services in India. The Indian Civil Aviation MRO market
is poised to grow from $900 million to $4.33 billion by 2025.
a) Barriers to Entry:
High capital requirements: for aircraft,
infrastructure (airports, hangars), landing
slots at congested airports, and obtaining
operating licenses create significant
barriers.
Landing Slots: Securing landing slots at
congested airports, especially major hubs, is challenging. Established airlines often have
preferential access, leaving limited slots for new entrants.
Operating Licenses: Obtaining the necessary operating licenses and permits involves navigating
complex regulatory frameworks, which can be time-consuming and costly.
b) Brand Recognition: Established airlines have strong brand loyalty and recognition, making it
difficult for new entrants to gain market share.
Customer Loyalty: Passengers develop trust and familiarity with established airlines, leading to
repeat business and positive word-of-mouth recommendations.
Positive Brand Associations: Strong brands are associated with certain qualities, like safety,
reliability, comfort, or a particular travel experience.
c) Government Regulations:
6
India's aviation market is heavily regulated, making it challenging for new airlines to enter. For
example, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has stringent safety regulations that
new airlines must comply with to obtain an operating license. Additionally, bilateral air traffic
agreements limit the number of flights that foreign airlines can operate to and from India,
restricting market access for new entrants.
2. Bargaining Power of Suppliers (HIGH)
a) Aircraft Manufacturers:
Duopoly Market: Airbus and Boeing dominate the large commercial aircraft market (over 100
seats) with a market share exceeding 90%. This lack of competition gives them significant leverage
in negotiations with airlines.
Order Backlogs: Both Airbus and Boeing maintain large order backlogs, meaning airlines need to
wait years for new aircraft deliveries, limiting their ability to pressure for lower prices. In 2023,
Airbus had an order backlog of over 7,000 aircraft, while Boeing had over 4,000.
b) Fuel Suppliers:
Fragmented Market: Unlike the duopoly in aircraft manufacturing, the jet fuel market has
multiple suppliers, including major oil companies and independent refiners. This fragmentation
gives airlines some leverage in negotiations.
Limited Control over Price: Jet fuel prices are primarily driven by global oil prices, which are
influenced by various factors beyond the control of airlines.
3. Bargaining Power of Buyers (MEDIUM)
a) Price Sensitivity:
According to a study by IATA (International Air Transport Association), the price sensitivity of
passengers varies depending on the type of travel. For example, leisure travelers are more price-
sensitive compared to business travelers.
b) Travel Aggregators:
Online travel agencies (OTAs) play a significant role in aggregating flight options and facilitating
price comparison. OTAs have empowered customers by offering transparency and convenience
in booking flights, leading to increased price sensitivity as customers can easily compare prices
across different airlines and make informed decisions.
c) Business vs. Leisure Travel:
Business travelers are generally less price-sensitive compared to leisure travelers. They often
prioritize factors such as schedule flexibility, loyalty programs, and premium services over price.
On the other hand, leisure travelers have a wider range of options, including budget airlines,
alternative travel methods (e.g., trains, buses), and vacation packages. This increased choice
7
makes leisure travelers more price-sensitive, especially when planning trips that are more
discretionary in nature.
4. Threat of Substitute Products or Services (LOW-MEDIUM)
a) Video Conferencing and Telecommunication:
Reduced Business Travel: Advancements in video conferencing technology have facilitated
remote communication, potentially reducing the need for some business travel, particularly short
business trips for meetings or conferences.
b) High-Speed Rail and Road Transport:
High-speed rail networks can be a significant competitor for airlines on short-haul routes (typically
under 500 km).
5. Rivalry among Existing Competitors (HIGH)
a) Fragmented Market:
The global airline industry is highly fragmented, with numerous airlines competing on various
routes. This fragmentation leads to intense competition on price, service offerings, and route
networks as airlines strive to attract passengers and gain market share.
b) Hub-and-Spoke vs. Point-to-Point Models:
Legacy carriers like Delta Air Lines and United Airlines operate hub-and-spoke models, using
major hubs like Atlanta and Chicago to connect passengers to various destinations. In contrast,
low-cost carriers like Southwest Airlines and JetBlue Airways primarily operate point-to-point
services, offering direct flights between select cities.
c) Strategic Alliances:
Airlines form strategic alliances, such as Star Alliance and Oneworld, to offer passengers a wider
network of destinations and benefits, such as shared frequent flyer programs and seamless
connections. While these alliances benefit passengers, they also reduce competition on some
routes as member airlines coordinate schedules and pricing.
8
2022 vs. 2023: Average jet fuel prices rose from
$80 to over $120 per barrel in 2023 due to global
events like the Russia-Ukraine conflict, posing
challenges to airline profitability.
2. Regulatory Challenges:
Safety Regulations: Stringent safety regulations,
such as new pilot training requirements, can
increase operational complexity and costs for
airlines.
Slot Restrictions: Limited landing slots at congested airports, like London Heathrow, can hinder
network expansion and incur high costs for airlines.
3. Technology Disruptions:
Autonomous Aircraft: Emerging technologies like autonomous passenger aircraft could disrupt
traditional aviation operations and impact pilot employment.
Urban Air Mobility (UAM): Electric vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft pose a potential
threat to short-haul flights, potentially altering travel patterns within urban areas.
4. Environmental Concerns:
COMPANY ANALYSIS
OVERVIEW
IndiGo is India’s largest passenger airline, known for its low-cost offerings and significant
market presence.
History:
Market Size:
STRATEGIES
Business Strategy
10
Corporate Strategy
• Market Expansion: IndiGo continuously adds new routes and increases flight frequencies to
capture a larger share of the Indian aviation market and strengthen its competitive position.
• Customer Focus: IndiGo prioritizes passenger needs and preferences to build long-term
relationships, enhance brand reputation, and ensure maximum customer satisfaction and
loyalty. This includes offering a seamless booking experience, reliable service, and competitive
fares.
• Partnerships and Alliances: IndiGo forms strategic alliances with companies in the travel and
tourism industry, such as hotels and car rental agencies, to offer integrated travel solutions
and expand revenue streams beyond ticket sales.
• Establishing Operational Synergy: With a 20-minute turnaround time, Indigo has very high on-
ground efficiency. It has accomplished this by implementing a few strategies, such as defining
tasks for each minute, whether it is during the arrival or departure of the flight. This strict
schedule helps to precisely define each person's function and promotes increased productivity.
In addition to the standard pre-flight briefings, Indigo offers post-flight briefings too. This is a
kaizen approach for exploring how to enhance overall operations even further. Indigo keeps
practically every aircraft in the air for an average of 12 hours each day as a result of these
procedures.
• Creating Financial Synergy: Indigo has maintained a strong financial control structure, which
aids in the effective management of working capital. A decreased turnaround time of 20
minutes resulting from its efforts to achieve operational efficiency, improves per-flight
utilization capacity and helps maintain the flight on schedule. This alignment of activities also
significantly lowers costs.
• Leasing Strategy: IndiGo utilizes the sale and leaseback (SLB) model, allowing it to purchase
aircraft at favorable prices, sell them to lessors, and then lease them back. This approach
generates revenue, provides fleet flexibility, saves on depreciation, boosts earnings, and
reduces taxes. SLBs enable IndiGo to maintain a minimal debt load while focusing on its core
operations. Its marketing strategy fosters strong ties with leasing businesses, facilitating the
flexibility of the sale-and-leaseback model.
• Sustainability Initiatives: IndiGo invests in next-generation aircraft, reducing its CO2 footprint
by approximately 20% compared to seven years ago. About 80% of its fleet consists of new-
generation aircraft, making it one of the world's lowest CO2 emitting airlines. Sustainability
measures are integrated into operations, including single engine taxiing, use of electric ground
vehicles, electronic flight bags, and water conservation measures on-board.
11
SWOT ANALYSIS
STRENGTHS WEAKNESS
• Largest airline in India by market share, • Overreliance on Domestic Market
with a robust domestic network. • Fuel Price Sensitivity
• Low-cost carrier model, with competitive • Need improvement on customer services
fares and lower operating expenses • Substantial debt may weaken its financial
• Operational efficiency, with high aircraft position
utilization rates, quick turnaround times,
and a lean organizational structure
• Brand Awareness and strong brand
reputation
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
• Growing Global Travel and Tourism (T&T) • Intense Competition
Industry • Change in regulatory policies and Airline
• International Expansion Security Measures
• Labor Disputes and Strikes
VRIO ANALYSIS
Valuable:
• IndiGo's lean operational model, which focuses on low-cost travel and high aircraft
utilization, is extremely valuable. Its large market share and extensive domestic network
also provide significant value.
Rare:
• IndiGo's strategy of maintaining a single type of aircraft (Airbus A320 family) for the
majority of its fleet is somewhat rare in the industry and contributes to reduced training
and maintenance costs.
Inimitable:
• The brand's reputation for punctuality and affordability is difficult for competitors to
imitate quickly. Over the years, IndiGo consistently maintained the highest average OTP
across four key metro cities: Bangalore, Delhi, Hyderabad, and Mumbai.
Organized to Capture Value:
• The company demonstrates efficient resource utilization through streamlined
operations and strategic route planning. IndiGo's adoption of a point-to-point model
facilitates direct passenger connections between cities, without the complexity of
layovers or hub-and-spoke systems. With extensive connectivity and penetration in tier
2 and tier 3 cities, its expanded network caters to a broader demographic, improving air
travel accessibility across India.
12
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE ANALYSIS
Domestic market share of airlines across India in financial year 2023, by passengers carried: With
a visible growth trend, it was
estimated that by 2034, India
would become one of the largest
aviation markets in the world. As
of financial year 2023, the
passenger carrier IndiGo was the
leader in the segment with
around 54.7 percent in the
market. Indigo airline’s low cost
and no-frills approach to
domestic flying had been cited as
one of the factors leading to its
relative success in India.
According to the Directorate-
General of Civil Aviation, IndiGo airline carried over 46.6 million passengers during the fiscal year
2022. It ranked fourth among the country’s most punctual airlines with almost 84 percent on-
time arrivals. As a carrier that also had the least complaints from the customer, IndiGo’s
popularity with the domestic base was high, soaring towards growth in the years to come.
13
Expansion of flight Fleet expansion with
services, fleet significant Boeing and Focus on on-time
addition, Airbus orders, merger performance, customer
partnership with initiatives with satisfaction, digital
Strategic Initiatives
Clever Tap for Vistara, focus on enhancements, fleet
improved digital and expansion, and
customer operational international growth
experience improvements
Need for strategic
Operational overhaul under Tata Maintaining market
losses, need to ownership, leadership amid growing
Key Challenges improve financial integration challenges competition, managing
health and market with mergers, large-scale operations
share improving operational efficiently
efficiency
Focus on recovery
Revitalization under Continued dominance in
and strategic
Tata leadership with the domestic market
growth through
Future Outlook fleet expansion and with plans for
fleet expansion
improved service international expansion
and service
quality and fleet growth
enhancement
Conclusion: Overall, IndiGo emerges as the leader in terms of revenue, fleet size, domestic
network, and strategic focus on on-time performance and cost management. However, Air
India's recent acquisitions and partnerships indicate efforts to stay competitive, while SpiceJet is
also expanding its services and partnerships to improve its market position.
Note: For Indigo Cost per Available Seat Kilometer (CASK): CASK increased by 5.0% from Rs. 4.60 in FY 2022 to Rs. 4.83 in FY
2023, primarily driven by increase in fuel cost and foreign exchange, offset by higher capacity deployment
14
Performance Analysis Over the Years
1. Number of passengers transported by IndiGo from financial year 2014 to 2023 (in millions):
India’s leading low-cost air carrier, IndiGo, carried around 85.27 million domestic and
international passengers in the financial year 2023. This was an increasing number as compared
to about 46.7 million in the fiscal year 2022.
2. Load factor of InterGlobe Aviation Limited from financial year 2018 to 2023: In financial year
2023, IndiGo's load factor reached just above 82 percent, 8.5 percent higher than the previous
year. In 2018, load factor of IndiGo reached its peak at 87.4 percent. From 2018 to 2020, it
remained stable and significantly declined in fiscal year 2021.
3. Number of passenger aircrafts of InterGlobe Aviation Limited in financial year 2023, by type:
In financial year 2023, out of all aircraft types of IndiGo, the number of Airbus A320 NEO was
the highest at 162. The passenger aircraft fleet of IndiGo consisted of ATR, A320 NEO, A320
15
CEO, and A321 NEO. The company had a plan to expand its fleet by ordering more aircraft,
especially Airbus Xtra Long Range for long-haul flights.
4. Fleet size of InterGlobe Aviation Limited from financial year 2018 to 2023: In financial year
2023, there were 304 aircraft in IndiGo's fleet. In fiscal year 2022, the fleet size declined and stood
at 275. In the future, the company plans to order more aircraft such as Airbus Xtra Long Range XLR
aircraft.
16
RECOMMENDATIONS
FOR INDIGO
Short Term:
Medium Term:
• Fleet Expansion: Expand the fleet strategically to meet rising demand, focusing on fuel-
efficient aircraft to enhance operational efficiency and reduce environmental impact.
• International Expansion: Explore new international routes to high-traffic destinations,
leveraging IndiGo's strong domestic network and reputation for operational excellence to
capture market share in key international markets.
• Alliances and Partnerships: Pursue alliances and partnerships with other airlines or join global
alliances to expand code-sharing agreements and network connectivity, enabling IndiGo to
offer seamless travel options and enhance its global reach.
• Digital Transformation: Invest in digital technologies to streamline booking processes,
enhance check-in procedures, and improve customer engagement. This includes developing
17
user-friendly mobile apps, implementing self-service kiosks, and leveraging data analytics for
personalized customer experiences.
FOR GOVERNMENT
Policy Recommendations:
• Simplify Regulatory Processes: Streamline approval procedures for aviation projects to cut
down on bureaucratic delays, making operations smoother and more cost-effective for airlines.
• Encourage Private Investment: Offer tax incentives and subsidies to attract private investment
in airport infrastructure and research initiatives, fostering growth and innovation in the sector.
• Boost Regional Connectivity: Enhance support for regional airlines operating in remote areas,
improve regional airport infrastructure, and enhance connectivity to underserved regions to
promote economic development.
• Promote Sustainable Aviation Fuels: Provide incentives for airlines to adopt sustainable
aviation fuels, ensuring an eco-friendlier approach to air travel.
• Invest in Green Infrastructure: Allocate funds for the development of eco-friendly airport
infrastructure, including electric vehicle fleets and energy-efficient terminals, reducing carbon
emissions and environmental impact.
• Implement Carbon Offsetting: Introduce programs to offset carbon emissions from flights,
encouraging airlines to reduce their environmental footprint and contribute to sustainability
efforts.
REFERENCES
https://www.mordorintelligence.com/industry-reports/commercial-aircraft-market
https://www.investindia.gov.in/sector/aviation https://www.ibef.org/industry/indian-aviation
https://www.ibef.org/industry/indian-aviation
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/expert-view/why-indigo-has-been-a-stand-out-
performer-in-the-aviation-sector-pieter-elbers-answers/articleshow/101037498.cms?from=mdr
https://www.business-standard.com/companies/news/indigo-should-be-compared-with-global-carriers-
not-domestic-ceo-elbers-123092600673_1.html
https://www.goindigo.in/
https://www.cnbctv18.com/aviation/why-sale-and-leaseback-is-the-centerpiece-of-indigos-airbus-
300massive-aircraft-orders-4617661.htm
18