Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 54

Forensic Genetic Approaches for

Identification of Human Skeletal


Remains: Challenges, Best Practices,
and Emerging Technologies 1st Edition
- eBook PDF
Go to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebooksecure.com/download/forensic-genetic-approaches-for-identification-of-h
uman-skeletal-remains-challenges-best-practices-and-emerging-technologies-ebook-
pdf/
More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant
download maybe you interests ...

(eBook PDF) Modeling and Simulation: Challenges and


Best Practices for Industry

http://ebooksecure.com/product/ebook-pdf-modeling-and-simulation-
challenges-and-best-practices-for-industry/

(eBook PDF) Policing America: Challenges and Best


Practices 9th Edition

http://ebooksecure.com/product/ebook-pdf-policing-america-
challenges-and-best-practices-9th-edition/

Emerging Technologies for Sustainable Desalination


Handbook 1st Edition - eBook PDF

https://ebooksecure.com/download/emerging-technologies-for-
sustainable-desalination-handbook-ebook-pdf/

Emerging Technologies in Engineering 1st edition -


eBook PDF

https://ebooksecure.com/download/emerging-technologies-in-
engineering-ebook-pdf/
Human Reproductive Genetics: Emerging Technologies and
Clinical Applications 1st Edition Juan A. Garcia-
Velasco (Editor) - eBook PDF

https://ebooksecure.com/download/human-reproductive-genetics-
emerging-technologies-and-clinical-applications-ebook-pdf/

(eBook PDF) Best Practices of Literacy Leaders, Second


2nd Edition

http://ebooksecure.com/product/ebook-pdf-best-practices-of-
literacy-leaders-second-2nd-edition-2/

(eBook PDF) Best Practices of Literacy Leaders Second


2nd Edition

http://ebooksecure.com/product/ebook-pdf-best-practices-of-
literacy-leaders-second-2nd-edition/

Handbook of HydroInformatics Volume III: Water Data


Management Best Practices 1st Edition - eBook PDF

https://ebooksecure.com/download/handbook-of-hydroinformatics-
volume-iii-water-data-management-best-practices-ebook-pdf/

(eBook PDF) Information Governance: Concepts,


Strategies, and Best Practices

http://ebooksecure.com/product/ebook-pdf-information-governance-
concepts-strategies-and-best-practices/
FORENSIC GENETIC APPROACHES
FOR IDENTIFICATION OF HUMAN
SKELETAL REMAINS
FORENSIC GENETIC
APPROACHES FOR
IDENTIFICATION OF
HUMAN SKELETAL
REMAINS
Challenges, Best Practices, and
Emerging Technologies

Edited by

Angie Ambers PhD


Henry C. Lee Institute of Forensic Science, University of New Haven, West Haven, CT, United States
Institute for Human Identification, LMU College of Dental Medicine, Knoxville, TN, United States
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
125 London Wall, London EC2Y 5AS, United Kingdom
525 B Street, Suite 1650, San Diego, CA 92101, United States
50 Hampshire Street, 5th Floor, Cambridge, MA 02139, United States
The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, United Kingdom
Copyright © 2023 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical,
including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from
the publisher. Details on how to seek permission, further information about the Publisher’s permissions policies and our
arrangements with organizations such as the Copyright Clearance Center and the Copyright Licensing Agency, can be found
at our website: www.elsevier.com/permissions.
This book and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under copyright by the Publisher (other than as may
be noted herein).
Notices
Knowledge and best practice in this field are constantly changing. As new research and experience broaden our
understanding, changes in research methods, professional practices, or medical treatment may become necessary.
Practitioners and researchers must always rely on their own experience and knowledge in evaluating and using any
information, methods, compounds, or experiments described herein. In using such information or methods they should be
mindful of their own safety and the safety of others, including parties for whom they have a professional responsibility.
To the fullest extent of the law, neither the Publisher nor the authors, contributors, or editors, assume any liability for any
injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or
operation of any methods, products, instructions, or ideas contained in the material herein.
ISBN 978-0-12-815766-4

For information on all Academic Press publications


visit our website at https://www.elsevier.com/books-and-journals

Cover Credit: Dr. Ambers

Publisher: Stacy Masucci


Acquisitions Editor: Elizabeth Brown
Editorial Project Manager: Fernanda Oliveira
Production Project Manager: Maria Bernard
Cover Designer: Miles Hitchen
Typeset by STRAIVE, India
Dedication

To Mom your mentorship, guidance, generosity, kind-


(1947–2009) ness, and friendship throughout the years.
For your unconditional love and always be- You truly are one of my favorite human be-
lieving in me. And for exemplifying a life ings on this planet, and I am honored to have
of integrity, kindness, and compassion for someone of your caliber and character in my
everyone you encountered, including the life. Thank you for everything. You are in my
underprivileged, oppressed, abused, and heart always.
disadvantaged.
To Dr. Art Eisenberg
Your unwavering altruism was an inspi-
(1956–2018)
ration to me, and I now realize that I got the
Who will always be remembered for his
best parts of who I am from you. Thank you
kindness as much as for pioneering the field
for instilling in me a fervent commitment to
of forensic DNA in the United States. His
justice and truth. I love you more than life’s
contributions to resolving missing persons
breath. I miss you every day.
and unidentified human remains (UHR)
To Dr. Harrell Gill-King cases, both domestically and internationally,
For inspiring me to accept the challenge of are immeasurable. I was fortunate to have
this career path and mission. And for believ- been mentored early in my career by such
ing in me more than I believed in myself. an amazing person and scientist. Gone from
Words cannot express how grateful I am for this Earth, but not forgotten.

v
In Memory of:
Paula C. Brumit, DDS, D-ABFO
(1956–2021)

This book honors the memory and legacy of sisted in the identification of victims from
Dr. Paula Brumit—an exceptional scientist, Hurricane Katrina and the 9/11 World Trade
humanitarian, mentor, and friend. She left an Center terrorist attacks); forensic odontolo-
indelible mark on not just the forensic human gist for the Bexar County Medical Examiner’s
identification community but also on all who Office (Bexar County, Texas); and consultant
were fortunate enough to have crossed her for the FBI, the Texas Rangers, Immigration
path personally or professionally. Her gener- and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Child
ous spirit, kindness, altruism, selflessness, and Protective Services (CPS), Department of
willingness to share knowledge will never be Public Safety (DPS), and various law en-
forgotten. She was the best friend one could forcement agencies.
ever hope for, and her sense of humor was Dr. Brumit was a member of the American
unmatched—she could make you laugh in
­ Society of Forensic Odontology (ASFO) and
even the most despondent of times. I was for- served on the ASFO’s Board of Governors.
tunate to have the gift of her friendship, and I She was a fellow of the American Academy
will miss her every day for the rest of my life. of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) and served as
Dr. Brumit was remarkably accomplished, Secretary, Program Chair, and Odontology
immensely respected by her peers, and de- Section Chair as well as on the AAFS Board
voted her life in service to others. She earned of Directors. Dr. Brumit was only the second
a Bachelor of Science degree in dental hygiene woman to hold the office of Odontology
and a Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) degree Section Chair in the 71-year history of the
from Texas A&M Health Science Center’s American Academy of Forensic Sciences.
Baylor College of Dentistry. During her ca- In addition, she was a Diplomate of the
reer, she made innumerable contributions to American Board of Forensic Odontology
forensic odontology and human identifica- (ABFO), served two consecutive terms on
tion casework in various professional roles, the ABFO Board of Directors, and one term
including as consulting forensic odontologist as ABFO President. During her career, she
for the Dallas County Medical Examiner's was appointed to the Texas Forensic Science
Office (Dallas, Texas); consultant for the Commission’s Bitemark Case Review
UNT Center for Human Identification’s Team, the National Institute of Standards
Laboratory of Forensic Anthropology (Fort and Technology (NIST) Scientific Area
Worth, Texas); member of the National Committees (SACs) Forensic Odontology
Disaster Mortuary Operational Response Subcommittee, and the Criminal Justice
Team (DMORT) Region 6 (in which she as- Information Services (CJIS) National Dental

vii
viii In Memory of Paula C. Brumit, DDS, D-ABFO (1956–2021)

Image Repository Review Panel for the Fellowship program and in the Forensic
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). Dentistry master’s program. Dr. Brumit
In 2020, she was elected to the Forensic had recently been promoted to Associate
Specialties Accreditation Board for a 4-year Professor in the College of Dental Medicine
term and was hired by the National Center at Lincoln Memorial University (LMU),
for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) and was hired as a forensic odontologist for
to assist in the fight against the abuse and ex- LMU’s Institute for Human Identification.
ploitation of children. In addition, she was Co-Director of
Academically, Dr. Brumit held an ap- the Southwest Symposium on Forensic
pointment as Assistant Professor in the Dentistry, and for nearly two decades was
Department of General Dentistry (Division an adjunct assistant professor in the Forensic
of Forensic Odontology) at the University Fellowship Program within the Center for
of Tennessee Graduate School of Medicine Education and Research in Forensics (CERF)
(UTGSM) in Knoxville, Tennessee. She at the University of Texas Health Science
taught in both UTGSM’s Forensic Odontology Center (San Antonio, Texas).
Contributors

Angie Ambers PhD Henry C. Lee Insti- Bobby L. LaRue, PhD Department of Forensic
tute of Forensic Science; Forensic Science Science, Sam Houston State University, Hunts-
Department, Henry C. Lee College of Crim- ville, TX, United States; Verogen Inc., San
inal Justice and Forensic Sciences, Center Diego, CA, United States
for Forensic Investigation of Trafficking in Brandon Letts PhD Federal Bureau of Investi-
Persons, University of New Haven, West gation (FBI) Laboratory, Quantico, VA, United
Haven, CT; Institute for Human Identifica- States
tion, LMU College of Dental Medicine, Knox-
ville, TN, United States James M. Lewis DMD, D-ABFO Department
of General Dentistry, Division of Forensics,
Eric J. Bartelink PhD, D-ABFA Department University of Tennessee Graduate School of
of Anthropology, Human Identification Labo- Medicine; Institute for Human Identification,
ratory, California State University, Chico, CA, LMU College of Dental Medicine, Knoxville,
United States TN; Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences,
Howard D. Cash CEO Gene Codes Forensics, Madison, AL, United States
Inc., Ann Arbor, MI, United States
Odile Loreille PhD Federal Bureau of Investi-
Thomas J. David DDS, D-ABFO Georgia gation (FBI) Laboratory, Quantico, VA, United
Bureau of Investigation, Division of Forensic States
Sciences, Decatur, GA; Department of General
Murray K. Marks, PhD, D-ABFA Knox County
Dentistry, Division of Forensics, University of
Regional Forensic Center, Department of
Tennessee Graduate School of Medicine; Insti-
General Dentistry, Division of Forensic Odontol-
tute for Human Identification, LMU College
ogy, University of Tennessee Graduate School of
of Dental Medicine, Knoxville, TN, United
Medicine; National Forensic Academy Outdoor
States
Decomposition Training Facility, University of
Suni M. Edson PhD Assistant Technical Leader, Tennessee; Department of Pathology; Institute
Past Accounting Section, Armed Forces DNA for Human Identification, LMU College of
Identification Laboratory (AFDIL), Armed Dental Medicine, Knoxville, TN, United States
Forces Medical Examiner System, Dover, DE,
Timothy P. McMahon PhD Department of
United States
Defense (DoD) DNA Operations, Armed Forces
Colleen Fitzpatrick PhD Identifinders Interna- Medical Examiner System, Defense Health
tional LLC, Fountain Valley, CA, United States Agency, Dover, DE, United States
Ranjana Grover PhD ANDE Corporation, Darinka Mileusnic-Polchan MD, PhD,
Waltham, MA, United States D-ABP Knox County Regional Forensic
Michael Hennessey BGS, MBA Human Iden- Center, Department of Pathology, University of
tification Projects, Gene Codes Forensics, Inc., Tennessee Graduate School of Medicine; Insti-
Ann Arbor, MI, United States tute for Human Identification, LMU College of
Irene Kahline MSFS Past Accounting Section, Dental Medicine, Knoxville, TN, United States
Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory Stephen Missal CFA Maricopa County Medical
(AFDIL), Armed Forces Medical Examiner Examiner Office, Forensic Science Center; Art
System, Dover, DE, United States Institute of Phoenix, Phoenix, AZ, United States

xv
xvi Contributors

Nicole Novroski PhD Department of Anthro- Jodie Ward PhD Centre for Forensic Science,
pology, Forensic Science Program, University University of Technology Sydney, Sydney,
of Toronto Mississauga, Toronto, ON, Canada NSW, Australia
Vivek Sahajpal, PhD State Forensic Science Jeremy Watherston PhD Forensic and Analyt-
Laboratory, Directorate of Forensics Services, ical Science Service, NSW Health Pathology,
Shimla, Himachal Pradesh, India Lidcombe, NSW, Australia
Richard F. Selden MD, PhD ANDE Corpora- Frank R. Wendt PhD Department of Psychiatry,
tion, Waltham, MA, United States Yale School of Medicine, U.S. Department of
Eugene Tan PhD ANDE Corporation, Waltham, Veteran Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System,
MA, United States New Haven, CT, United States
Rosemary Turingan Witkowski PhD ANDE
Corporation, Waltham, MA, United States
Author’s biographies

Angie Ambers, PhD DNA topics. During this time, she also
Dr. Angie Ambers is an internationally was a team member with UNH’s Center for
recognized DNA expert and Director of Forensic Investigation of Trafficking in Persons.
Forensic Genetics at the Institute for Human She worked as a forensic geneticist for the
Identification in the College of Dental Medicine University of North Texas (UNT) Center for
at Lincoln Memorial University (LMU). She Human Identification for 8 years and, prior
also is a Professor of Forensic Genetics in the to pursuing her doctorate, was lead DNA
“Forensic Human Identification” graduate analyst and lab manager of UNT’s DNA
program. She has a PhD in molecular biol- Sequencing Core Facility. Her doctoral re-
ogy (with an emphasis in forensic genetics search involved an investigation of methods
and human identification) as well as mas- (e.g., whole-genome amplification, DNA
ter’s degrees both in forensic genetics and repair) for improving autosomal and Y-STR
criminology. Dr. Ambers conducts research typing of degraded and low copy number
at the National Forensic Academy (NFA) (LCN) DNA from human skeletal remains
Cumberland Forest Outdoor Decomposition and environmentally damaged biological
Facility, a research and training center de- materials. Her master’s thesis research in-
voted to studying the effects of environmental cluded the development and optimization
exposure on postmortem human remains. In of a DNA-based multiplex screening tool
collaboration with a team of board-­certified for genetics-based separation of fragmented
forensic anthropologists and odontologists, and commingled skeletal remains in mass
her research mission is to develop and op- graves.
timize methodologies to improve identifi- Dr. Ambers specializes in the character-
cation efforts in missing person cases, mass ization and identification of contemporary,
disasters, and unidentified human remains historical, and archaeological human skel-
(UHR) investigations. etal remains. Her casework has involved
Prior to LMU, Dr. Ambers previously DNA testing of an American Civil War guer-
served as Assistant Director of the Henry C. rilla scout; several Finnish World War II sol-
Lee Institute of Forensic Science in Connecticut, diers; unidentified late-19-century skeletal
a world-class institute that specializes in in- remains discovered by a construction crew
terdisciplinary research, training, testing, in Deadwood, South Dakota; unidentified
casework consulting, and education in fo- skeletal remains of Special Operations sol-
rensic science. She also held an Associate diers killed during the 1974 Turkish invasion
Professor (Forensic DNA) appointment in of Cyprus; skeletal remains exhumed from
the Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice Prague Castle in the Czech Republic; skele-
and Forensic Sciences at the University of tal remains of soldiers from the seven years’
New Haven (UNH), teaching forensic bi- war (1756–63); bone samples purported
ology and DNA analysis methods, in ad- to belong to a member of Jesse James gang
dition to specialty courses on advanced (killed during a bank robbery in 1876); and

xvii
xviii Author’s biographies

the exhumed remains of the wife of a Yale grave at Fort St. Louis, and the p ­ utative
medical school professor. She co-presented remains of Sieur de Marle. Additionally,
a workshop on “Advanced Methods for Dr. Ambers performed DNA extractions and
­DNA-based Analysis of Skeletal Remains” mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequencing
at the 26th International Symposium on on numerous sets of skeletal remains asso-
Human Identification (ISHI), and has been ciated with Spanish royalty and the House
an invited speaker at an international bone of Aragon (recovered from tombs within
workshop/conference in Prague, Czech the Royal Pantheon of San Juan de la Peña
Republic. In 2017, she traveled twice to India ­archaeological site in Spain). She is currently
to train scientists from various Indian states working on the putative remains of William
and the Maldives Police Service on the pro- Townsend Washington, the nephew of for-
cessing of bone samples in forensic DNA mer U.S. President George Washington.
casework. During her visit to India, she per- In addition to skeletal remains cases and
formed autosomal STR analysis on human research, Dr. Ambers collaborated with the
skeletal remains discovered along a hiking National Institute of Justice (NIJ) and the
route in the Himalayas (in the northern state Forensic Technology Center of Excellence
of Himachal Pradesh) to assist local officials (FTCoE) to develop and disseminate a formal
in the investigation of a missing person case. report on the use of familial DNA searching
Additionally, she performed DNA analysis (FDS) in casework. She is an active cold case
on a female homicide victim recovered from consultant, an advocate of postconviction
a clandestine grave in New Delhi. DNA testing, and an educator/advisor on
Dr. Ambers’ casework and research DNA testing or retesting of old, degraded, or
have been published in various peer-­ challenging evidentiary samples. Dr. Ambers
reviewed journals, including Forensic Science also was the 2017–18 Project Lead on a
International: Genetics (FSI: Genetics), Forensic U.S. State Department grant to combat hu-
Science International (FSI), International Journal man trafficking in Central America through
of Legal Medicine (IJLM), Legal Medicine, BMC the application of forensics. As part of the
Genomics, the Croatian Medical Journal, The program objectives, she traveled to three
Journal of Heredity, and Journal of Biological Northern Triangle countries (Guatemala, El
and Clinical Anthropology (Anthropologischer Salvador, Honduras) to perform gap assess-
Anzeiger). Her work has received press in ments of government laboratories and train
numerous local and national newspapers personnel in forensic DNA analysis, with the
(including The Washington Times, NBC News, goal of promoting quality casework methods
Criminal Legal News, The Root) and has been based on ISO 17025 standards. As Project
featured on several podcasts (Truth and Lead, she helped in training forensic DNA
Justice, Crime Waves). scientists at the Instituto Nacional de Ciencias
Her most recent casework (a collabora- Forenses de Guatemala (INACIF, the National
tion with the Texas Historical Commission) Institute of Forensic Sciences of Guatemala)
includes DNA analyses of human skele- in Guatemala City, Guatemala; the Instituto
tal remains associated with the French ex- de Medicina Legal (Institute of Legal Medicine)
plorer La Salle’s last expedition. This case in San Salvador, El Salvador; and the Instituto
involved massively parallel sequencing de Medicina Forenses: Centro de Medicina Legal
(MPS) of DNA from two adult male skele- y Ciencias Forenses (the Institute of Forensic
tons recovered from the La Belle shipwreck, Medicine: Center of Legal Medicine and
skeletal remains recovered from a mass Forensic Sciences) in Tegucigalpa, Honduras.
Author’s biographies xix
In addition to ­ providing both lecture and Anthropology 10e (Cengage), Introduction to
tactile training on DNA analysis methods to Physical Anthropology 15e (Cengage), and a co-
Northern Triangle laboratories, Dr. Ambers editor on New Perspectives in Forensic Human
was part of a consortium to help these coun- Skeletal Identification (Elsevier). Dr. Bartelink
tries develop and maintain forensic DNA teaches courses in introductory physical
databases to assist in the identification of anthropology, as well as forensic science,
missing persons related to human trafficking. human osteology, forensic anthropology, bio-
archaeology, and statistics. He is a Fellow of
Eric Bartelink, PhD, D-ABFA the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
Dr. Eric J. Bartelink is a Professor in (AAFS), and a member of the American
the Department of Anthropology and Association of Physical Anthropologists
Co-Director of the Human Identification (AAPA), Society of American Archaeology
Laboratory at California State University, (SAA), Paleopathology Association (PPA), and
Chico. He received his BS in Anthropology at the Society for California Archaeology (SCA).
Central Michigan University (1995), his MA in He is a past Board Member and President of
Anthropology at California State University, the American Board of Forensic Anthropology
Chico (2001), and his PhD in Anthropology (ABFA), and former Board Member of the
at Texas A&M University (2006). He is a American Academy of Forensic Sciences
board-certified Diplomate of the American (AAFS), the Scientific Working Group for
Board of Forensic Anthropology (ABFA). Forensic Anthropology (SWGANTH), and the
Dr. Bartelink’s interests are in forensic Organization of Scientific Area Committees
anthropology and bioarchaeology, and he (OSAC) Anthropology Subcommittee.
has conducted research focused on skel-
etal trauma, taphonomy, paleopathology, Howard Cash, CEO
and stable isotope analysis. He maintains Howard Cash is the CEO of Gene Codes
an extensive research program focused on Corporation. Before venturing into the
central California bioarchaeology and also field of computational biology, he studied
has conducted work in American Samoa. music at the University of Pennsylvania
Previously, he assisted with the excavation of and also served as Assistant Conductor
mass graves in Bosnia-Herzegovina through with the Pennsylvania Opera Theater,
the United Nations International Criminal Psychoacoustics at Stanford.
Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, and also At the forefront of commercial bioinfor-
assisted in the identification of victims from matics since 1984, Cash was Senior Engineer
the World Trade Center 9/11 disaster. and headed the Expert Systems Group at
He has published articles in Journal of IntelliGenetics, Inc., where many seminal
Forensic Sciences, Forensic Science International, biotechnology software tools were devel-
Forensic Sciences Research, American Journal of oped. One of the programs he worked on
Physical Anthropology, Journal of Archaeological during this period was key to the original
Science, International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, sequencing of the human immunodeficiency
International Journal of Paleopathology, Journal of (HIV/AIDS) virus. In 1988, he founded Gene
Archaeological Method and Theory, Archaeometry, Codes Corporation, one of the most success-
and California Archaeology. He is also a ful bioinformatics companies in the world.
co-author on the books Forensic Anthropology: He designed and developed the Sequencher
Current Methods and Practice (Elsevier, 1st program used in thousands of academic and
and 2nd editions), Essentials of Physical commercial DNA sequencing labs in more
xx Author’s biographies

than 90 countries. Specialized versions of chapters (including multiple editions of the


Sequencher have been developed for ap- Manual of Forensic Odontology and the 2nd
plications including human identification, Edition of Forensic Dentistry). He also co-­
­mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) typing, ther- edited the book Forensic Odontology: Principles
apy review based on HIV strain dominance and Practice, which was released in 2018.
in AIDS patients, and rapid characterization Dr. David is a consultant in Forensic
of H1N1 flu variants from the 2009 world- Odontology to the Georgia Bureau of
wide outbreak. Investigation (GBI), Division of Forensic
After the 9/11 terrorist attacks, New York Sciences and the State of Georgia Medical
City asked Cash to develop DNA analysis Examiner’s Office. He also holds a faculty
software for identifying the remains of those appointment as a Clinical Assistant Professor
killed at the World Trade Center. A daunt- in the Department of General Dentistry
ing task from a technical standpoint—with of the Graduate School of Medicine at the
a database and set of analysis tools integrat- University of Tennessee Health Science
ing primary sequence, SNP, and STR data— Center. He provides instruction for the
it also raised ethical and legal issues. One Forensic Odontology Fellowship program
result of this effort was the Mass-Fatality and the University of Tennessee biennial
Identification System, or M-FISys (pro- Symposium “All That Remains.”
nounced like emphasis). Cash has applied bio-
informatics to numerous other humanitarian Suni M. Edson, PhD
genetic identification projects, including (1) Dr. Suni M. Edson started her career in sci-
the Boxing Day Tsunami; (2) the sexual as- ence working in a research laboratory while
sault and murder of hundreds of women an undergraduate at Texas Tech University.
in Juarez, Mexico; (3) postconflict identifi- She worked with graduate students and
cations from Guatemala’s 35-year civil war; professors on projects ranging from the in-
and (4) an international collaboration to de- sertion of traceable genetic material into
tect and interdict child trafficking. cotton seeds to the analysis of transposable
elements in Peromyscine rodents. Upon grad-
Thomas David, DDS, D-ABFO—Forensic uation with a BS in Biology, Dr. Edson mi-
Odontologist grated to Syracuse, New York to attend the
Dr. Thomas J. David earned his dental State University of New York (College of
degree from Emory University School of Environmental Science and Forestry). She
Dentistry in 1977. He has maintained a dental spent several of the snowiest-winters-on-­
practice since that time in the Atlanta metro- record traipsing through Adirondack Park
politan area. He is a member of the American to study the introgressive hybridization of
Society of Forensic Odontology (ASFO), a Mallards and Black Ducks. The project in-
Fellow of the American Academy of Forensic volved the collection of blood samples from
Sciences (AAFS), and a Diplomate of the numerous pairs of ducks and their broods,
American Board of Forensic Odontology and subsequent RFLP analysis to determine
(ABFO). Dr. David has served as Chair of the if these dabbling ducks are truly “monoga-
Odontology Section of AAFS and President mous” in their pair bonds.
of the ABFO, as well as on the Editorial Board After earning her MS degree, Dr. Edson
of the Journal of Forensic Sciences (JFS). He has moved to the Washington, D.C. area to work
authored articles in various periodicals (in- briefly at the Lombardi Cancer Center at
cluding the JFS) and a number of textbook Georgetown University. There she spent time
Author’s biographies xxi
as a research assistant examining human use of genetic genealogy (Y-STR and auto-
leukocyte antigen (HLA) genes, g ­arnering somal SNP analysis) for generating forensic
five publications as a coauthor. During the intelligence on cold cases that are sometimes
first few months of work at Georgetown, decades old. Dr. Fitzpatrick’s expertise in-
she ­answered an ad in the paper for a re- cludes the application of whole-genome
search assistant at the Armed Forces DNA ­sequencing to low level and highly degraded
Identification Laboratory (AFDIL) in DNA, enabling identifications that otherwise
Rockville, Maryland. While she was not are believed to have gone beyond the reach
hired for that position, she did become a of modern technology.
DNA technician in the Past Accounting Dr. Fitzpatrick has twice been awarded
Section, and thus began her almost 22-year fifth place in the prestigious international
tenure with the laboratory. Gordon Thomas Honeywell Cold Case Hit of
Dr. Edson moved from DNA technician the Year competition—first in 2018 for solv-
to DNA analyst to supervisory DNA analyst ing the 1992–93 Phoenix Canal Murders (out
in the short span of 3.5 years. She remained of 61 entries from 14 countries). This was
a productive supervisor for 9 years before the first case solved using genetic geneal-
transitioning in 2010 to her current role of ogy (2015). Her second Cold Case Hit award
assistant technical leader. During the time as came in 2020 for her work on the 1991 Sarah
a supervisor, she returned to her researcher Yarborough Homicide (out of 50 entries from
roots and started to examine the success of 20 countries). This was the first case where
DNA testing of different skeletal elements. genetic genealogy was used to generate in-
While research is not her primary role, vestigative leads (2011).
Dr. Edson has published over 20 peer-­ In addition to her work in forensic iden-
reviewed publications and book chapters tification, Dr. Fitzpatrick had been a key
regarding DNA testing of human remains member of the teams that have exposed two
and the intricacies surrounding human iden- international Holocaust literary frauds. She
tification. She has presented at numerous has also served as the forensic genealogist on
professional conferences in the United States several historical projects including the iden-
and internationally. In 2015, she was accepted tification of the unknown child on the Titanic
into a PhD program at Flinders University in and the Abraham Lincoln DNA Project. Her
South Australia. Her dissertation on improv- collaborations include the Armed Forces
ing the extraction of DNA from skeletal ma- DNA Identification Laboratory (AFDIL),
terials generated a novel method using GC/ the U.S. Army Casualty and Mortuary
MS to analyze skeletal materials for inhibi- Affairs Office, the Simon Wiesenthal Center
tors and materials deposited on the remains in Jerusalem, the University of Arizona, the
peri- and postmortem, as well as nine publi- University of Adelaide, the Henry C. Lee
cations to date. Dr. Edson graduated in 2019 Institute of Forensic Science, and other noted
and remains in her position at AFDIL, where professional organizations. She is a member
she continues to examine trends in DNA test- of the Vidocq Society and an associate mem-
ing of skeletonized human remains. ber of the American Academy of Forensic
Science (AAFS).
Colleen Fitzpatrick, PhD Dr. Fitzpatrick is the founder of Iden­
Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick is widely recog- tifinders International and co-founder of the
nized as the founder of modern Forensic DNA Doe Project. She lectures widely in the
Genetic Genealogy (FGG). She pioneered the United States, Canada, Europe, Australia,
xxii Author’s biographies

and New Zealand. She has appeared in hun- in New York City and provided opera-
dreds of newspapers and magazines (both tional consulting expertise on the World
domestically and internationally), and on Trade Center identification project. In 2005,
international radio and television programs. Mr. Hennessey also served on the DNA
She is the author of three books: Forensic Subcommittee of the Thailand Tsunami
Genealogy, DNA & Genealogy, and The Dead Victim Identification Center in Phuket,
Horse Investigation: Forensic Photo Analysis for Thailand. He has helped lead Mass Fatality
Everyone. Identification System (M-FISys) customer
training for users in Guatemala, Kenya,
Ranjana Grover, PhD El Salvador, Costa Rica, Libya, Israel,
Dr. Ranjana Grover is Vice President of Mexico, and Saudi Arabia. Additionally,
Molecular Biology at ANDE Corporation. Mr. Hennessey has conducted human iden-
She received a BS in Zoology (summa cum tification workshops at national and in-
laude), an MS in Genetics, and a PhD in ternational forensics meetings, published
Molecular Human Genetics from Delhi peer-reviewed journal articles, and serves on
University. She is an expert in the field of the Scientific Advisory Board of the Forensic
developing rapid, highly multiplexed PCR Anthropology Foundation of Guatemala
assays for diverse applications ranging from (FAFG). He has a Master’s of Business
human identification to in vitro diagnostic Administration (MBA) from the University
assays for human diseases. Dr. Grover has of Michigan with a concentration in opera-
worked in a high-­throughput human genetics tions management.
research laboratory exploring the genetics of
complex traits and has a strong background Irene Kahline, MS
in statistical methods related to molecular Irene Liunoras Kahline received her
genetics. She received postdoctoral train- Bachelor of Science (BS) in Biochemistry
ing at Johns Hopkins University and then at Florida State University. Following her
joined the Henry M. Jackson Foundation, undergraduate studies, she worked in a re-
where she worked on identifying genetic search lab studying the evolution and phy-
and epigenetic markers related to Down syn- logeny of shark and ray DNA. During her
drome, traumatic brain injury, and the toxic time in the research lab, she decided to pur-
effects of metals employed in bullets. While sue a career in forensic DNA. She moved
working on these projects, she received sev- to the Washington, D.C. area to obtain
eral Department of Defense (DoD) research her Master of Forensic Science in Forensic
grants and developed expertise in highly Molecular Biology at George Washington
advanced next-generation sequencing (NGS) University. While pursuing her master’s de-
technologies and in second-­ generation se- gree, she interned with the research depart-
quencing analysis. ment (now Emerging Technology section)
at the Armed Forces DNA Identification
Michael Hennessey, MBA Laboratory (AFDIL).
Mr. Hennessey was the onsite Project Irene has steadily moved through differ-
Manager for Gene Codes Forensics (GCF) ent positions at AFDIL from research intern
during the identification of victims of the to DNA technician to DNA analyst, and
9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001. For 3 years now as a supervisory DNA analyst for the
after the attacks, he reported daily to the Past Accounting Section. She is proficient
Office of Chief Medical Examiner (OCME) in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Sanger
Author’s biographies xxiii
­sequencing, next-­generation sequencing vironmental changes on animal populations.
(NGS) of whole-genome mitochondrial DNA, His research interests continue to revolve
autosomal STR typing, and Y-STR technolo- around the retrieval and analysis of DNA
gies working on dried skeletal remains from from highly degraded samples.
past military conflicts. Her dedication to the
mission of AFDIL was so immense that she James M. Lewis, DMD, D-ABFO
agreed to move to Dover, Delaware from the Dr. James M. Lewis earned his dental
Rockville, Maryland location. degree from the University of Alabama
School of Dentistry (Birmingham) in 1985.
Bobby LaRue, PhD He maintained a general dentistry practice
Dr. Bobby LaRue earned a PhD in Molecular exclusively in Madison, Alabama from 1986
Genetics from the University of North to 2018. Dr. Lewis completed a fellowship
Texas (UNT) and completed an Intelligence in Forensic Odontology from the Center
Community postdoctoral fellowship in which for Education and Research in Forensics
he ­studied the feasibility of small-amplicon, at the University of Texas Health Science
di-allelic markers for forensic applications. Center at San Antonio in 2001. As a board-­
Dr. LaRue recently left his position as an certified forensic odontologist, he assisted
Associate Professor of Forensic Science at in victim identification following the World
Sam Houston State University (SHSU) to Trade Center attack in New York City and,
accept a position in private industry (with since 2003, has served as a consultant to the
Verogen, Inc.). Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences
(ADFS) and a volunteer to the Alabama
Brandon Letts, PhD Office of Emergency Preparedness in relation
Dr. Brandon Letts is a Research Biologist to its mass disaster response group.
at the FBI Laboratory in Quantico, Virginia. Dr. Lewis is a Fellow of the Odontology
He possesses a BS in Forensic Science from Section of the American Academy of
Baylor University and a PhD in Genetics Forensic Sciences (AAFS), became board-­
from Pennsylvania State University. His cur- certified by the American Board of Forensic
rent duties include research and validation Odontology (ABFO) in 2008, has served on
of new techniques and technologies for im- the Board of Governors of the American
plementation at the FBI and troubleshooting Society of Forensic Odontology (ASFO),
laboratory issues arising in casework. Prior and became President of the organization
to becoming a research biologist, he was a fo- in 2012. For the American Board of Forensic
rensic examiner for the U.S. Army Criminal Odontology (ABFO), he served as member
Investigation Laboratory (USACIL) and both and Chair of the Dental Age Assessment
a forensic examiner and technical specialist Committee (2008–20); as a member of the
for the FBI. Certification and Examination Committee
Dr. Letts has a background in ancient (2011–15); Bitemark Evidence and Patterned
DNA, having performed his dissertation Injury Committee (2008–15; 2017–19); and
work under the supervision of Dr. Beth currently holds the office of ABFO President.
Shapiro, a leader in the study of ancient He is currently appointed to the Odontology
DNA and molecular evolution. In her lab, Subcommittee of the Organization of
he analyzed hundreds of samples up to Scientific Area Committees (OSAC) for
100,000 years old and used the information Forensic Science with the National Institute
he obtained to investigate the effects of en- of Standards and Technology (NIST).
xxiv Author’s biographies

Dr. Lewis previously held the position r­etrieval of nuclear DNA from decades-old
of Director of Forensic Dentistry (Division human rootless hair shafts and characteri-
of Forensics) in the Department of General zation of single nucleotide polymorphisms
Dentistry at the University of Tennessee (SNPs) to identify the hair’s owner. Another
Graduate School of Medicine. He is currently research interest of hers is DNA analysis
Director of Forensic Odontology at the Institute of remains attributed to historical figures.
for Human Identification in the College of Dental These projects involved the tentative identi-
Medicine at Lincoln Memorial University fication of W.A Mozart, Friedrich Schiller, the
(LMU). He is also a ­ professor of Forensic unknown child of the Titanic, Everett Ruess,
Dentistry at LMU and an instructor for the The Romanov family (including the two chil-
National Forensic Academy (NFA) in Oak dren found in 2007), Sir George Yeardley, and
Ridge, Tennessee. He has edited numerous Henry Rathbone.
textbooks, authored textbook chapters, and Dr. Loreille has been a member of the
published a variety of articles in peer-reviewed International Society for Forensic Genetics
journals on forensic odontology. (ISFG) for the past 13 years and has pub-
lished 30 peer-reviewed research articles
Odile Loreille, PhD or book chapters. Her 2007 publication on
Dr. Odile Loreille holds a PhD in DNA extraction using total demineralization
Paleogenetics from the University of Claude has been cited more than 250 times, and her
Bernard in Lyon, France. During her PhD 2018 research article on the DNA analysis of
research and two postdoctoral positions, a 4000-year-old Egyptian mummy is one of
she specialized in extracting and analyzing the most-read articles of the journal.
DNA from extinct species (cave bears, cave
lions), mummies, and decades-old para- Murray K. Marks, PhD, D-ABFA
sites. When she joined the Armed Forces Dr. Murray Marks is the board-certified fo-
DNA Identification Laboratory (AFDIL) rensic anthropologist for the Regional Forensic
in 2004, she used her expertise in ancient Center (RFC) in Knoxville, Tennessee, and for
DNA (aDNA) analysis to tackle AFDIL’s the Hamilton County Medical Examiner’s
most challenging identification effort—the Office in Chattanooga. In these respective ap-
so-called Punchbowl samples, a large set pointments, he performs recovery, biological
of Korean War remains buried as unknown assessment, skeletal trauma, and identification
in the National Memorial Cemetery of the casework on human remains. Dr. Marks also
Pacific. After optimizing the DNA extraction serves as Director of Forensic Anthropology
protocol with a technique that is now used in at the Institute for Human Identification in
many forensic laboratories around the world, the College of Dental Medicine at Lincoln
she introduced next-generation sequenc- Memorial University (LMU). Additionally,
ing (NGS) to the laboratory. Using Illumina he is a Professor of Forensic Anthropology
technology and hybridization capture, she and Human Identification at LMU and man-
successfully retrieved mitochondrial DNA ages the National Forensic Academy (NFA)
(mtDNA) from these human remains. Outdoor Decomposition Training Facility, where
Dr. Loreille is now a Research Biologist in he teaches archaeological clandestine grave
the DNA Support Unit at the FBI Laboratory recovery methods and forensic anthropol-
and continues to work on improving tech- ogy. Dr. Marks previously held an Associate
niques for the FBI’s DNA Casework Unit. Research Professor appointment in the
The focus of her current research is the Graduate School of Medicine’s Department
Author’s biographies xxv
of General Dentistry (Division of Forensics) Line that allowed for the processing of 640
at the University of Tennessee Medical Center crime scene samples per day, developed an
Knoxville (UTMCK), instructing students in automated differential extraction line, and
the M.S. program on forensic dentistry, head performed over 200 validations for both
and neck anatomy, mineralized tissue his- North American and international crime lab-
tology, and research methods. He currently oratories. In February 2012, Dr. McMahon
holds adjunct visiting professorships in the returned to the Armed Forces Medical
Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology Examiner System (AFMES) as the Chief of
at Boston University and in the Department Forensic Services, where his role as the sci-
of Anatomy at the University of Western entific subject matter expert was to advise,
Australia. guide, and help maintain the AFMES as a
leader in the forensic community. He over-
Timothy McMahon, PhD saw all aspects of casework performed at
Dr. Timothy McMahon received his PhD DoD DNA operations while directing and
in Biomedical Sciences from the School of carrying out projects and programs to de-
Public Health at the University of Albany, velop innovative advances in DNA-based
New York. Dr. McMahon’s graduate stud- forensic testing methods. In this role, Dr.
ies and postdoctoral research were per- McMahon also established AFMES-AFDIL
formed in the division of Infectious Disease as the first laboratory in the United States to
and Immunology at the New York State develop and implement a forensically val-
Department of Health. His research included idated next-generation sequencing (NGS)
the identification and interaction of the method for human remains identification.
Human Cytomegalovirus Helicase-Primase In 2017, Dr. McMahon became the first ci-
replication proteins and a pro-death late vilian Director of the DoD DNA operations
transcript that caused cell death in infected section of the AFMES, where he is in charge
cells. From 2002 to 2007, Dr. McMahon es- of the Armed Forces DNA Identification
tablished the U.S. Department of Defense Laboratory (AFDIL) and the Armed Forces
(DoD) DNA Operation’s Quality Control Repository of Specimen Samples for the
and Validation section; in this role, he was Identification of Remains. Dr. McMahon
responsible for developing and forensically oversees over 150 scientists and is in charge
validating all new human remains DNA of all human remains DNA scientific initia-
identification instrumentation, reagents, and tives in support of the AFMES’ primary mis-
testing procedures. sion to identify fallen U.S. Service members
In March 2007, Dr. McMahon joined from present-day operations and from past
Applied Biosystems, where he established conflicts.
the first commercial Global DNA Forensic
Professional Service organization whose Darinka Mileusnic-Polchan, MD, PhD,
primary function was to design and estab- D-ABP
lish new DNA laboratories (as well as aid Dr. Darinka Mileusnic-Polchan is a grad-
local, state, and federal crime laboratories uate of the University of Rijeka Medical
with implementing new forensic DNA tech- School in Croatia. After earning her med-
nologies and instrumentation). During his ical degree, she graduated from Loyola
time at Applied Biosystems, Dr. McMahon University’s Neuroscience Graduate
was responsible for developing a state of Program in Chicago, Illinois. She com-
the art, fully automated Criminal Casework pleted her training in anatomic pathology
xxvi Author’s biographies

in the Department of Pathology, Loyola Arizona counties, has worked with law en-
University Stritch School of Medicine. forcement in Georgia, and is certified by the
Dr. Mileusnic completed forensic pathol- International Association for Identification
ogy training at the Cook County Office of (IAI). Stephen actively pursues a recon-
the Medical Examiner in Chicago, Illinois, struction caseload and contributes to edu-
subsequently receiving board certification cating the public about forensic art through
in Anatomic and Forensic Pathology. Upon lectures at various colleges and to high
completion, she accepted the position of school audiences. As an educator, Stephen
Assistant Medical Examiner for the Cook achieved full Professor at the Art Institute of
County Office of the Medical Examiner for Phoenix, where he taught with an elite fac-
several years. ulty that included two Emmy winners and
In 2002, Dr. Mileusnic-Polchan relocated several nationally recognized illustrators
to Knoxville, Tennessee, where she ­continued and designers. In 2016, he worked with the
the same line of forensic casework in the NRK (the national Norwegian broadcasting
Department of Pathology at The University network) as the forensic artist responsible
of Tennessee Graduate School of Medicine for a new reconstruction of the Isdal Woman,
(UTMCK). Currently, she is a Clinical Associate which was included in the documentary
Professor of Pathology at UTMCK. In 2008, about the case which aired that same year.
she accepted the position of Chief Medical Stephen’s facial reconstruction for this case
Examiner for Anderson County and Knox has since appeared in Die Zeit and many
County in the state of Tennessee. Dr. Mileusnic other European news outlets over the past
is the Medical Director of the Knox County 4 years. Aside from his forensic casework,
Regional Forensic Center (RFC), which has Stephen’s paintings and drawings can be
been accredited by the National Association of found in hundreds of private collections na-
Medical Examiners since 2010. She chaired the tionally. He also has co-authored and illus-
State Medical Examiner Advisory Council and trated two college textbooks on drawing for
has been an invited speaker at numerous local animation, and has appeared on local and
and national conferences. national cable television demonstrating his
forensic art techniques.
Stephen Missal, MFA, CFA Scores of Stephen’s forensic reconstruc-
Stephen Missal graduated with a BFA tions can be found in the National Missing
and MFA in painting from Wichita State and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs),
University and taught art at the college as well as on the Maricopa County Medical
level for over four decades. He later re- Examiner’s site where unknown cases are
ceived his training in forensic art by available for public view.
world-renowned forensic artists Karen T.
Taylor and Betty Pat Gatliff. Stephen has Nicole Novroski, PhD
specialized in forensic facial reconstruc- Dr. Nicole Novroski is a forensic geneti-
tion, and for the past 12 years, he has been cist and tenure-stream faculty member at the
the sole forensic facial reconstruction art- University of Toronto in the Department of
ist working with the Maricopa County Anthropology, with a primary teaching ap-
Medical Examiner in Arizona (home to pointment in the Forensic Science Program
Phoenix, Mesa, Scottsdale, and a number at the University of Toronto Mississauga
of other large cities). In addition, he does (UTM). Her research program focuses on
forensic reconstructions for several other novel and innovative approaches to improve
Author’s biographies xxvii
upon current forensic genetic methodologies Within her laboratory, she has a growing team
using traditional (PCR-CE) and MPS-based of undergraduate and graduate trainees.
instrumentation. Further, Dr. Novroski assists legal profession-
Dr. Novroski’s academic accolades in- als and the public as a forensic DNA expert
clude a Bachelor of Science (Hons) in through her firm 4NGen Consulting. In her
Forensic Science and Biology from the limited spare time, she volunteers with the
University of Toronto, a Master of Science Junior League of Toronto and Toronto Counter
in Forensic Biology from the University at Human Trafficking Network and is actively
Albany (SUNY), and a Doctor of Philosophy pursuing a degree in Forensic Accounting to
in Molecular Genetics from the University further diversify her portfolio.
of North Texas Health Science Center
(UNTHSC) at Fort Worth, Texas. Her edu- Vivek Sahajpal, PhD
cational training is largely focused on the Dr. Vivek Sahajpal is Assistant Director
exploration of previously uncharacterized of the Directorate of Forensics Services in
genetic markers for improved DNA mixture Himachal Pradesh, India. In addition, he
de-convolution of complex forensic profiles. is the Nodal Officer for the Disaster Victim
Dr. Novroski is the recipient of numerous Identification (DVI) Cell at the Directorate of
awards including the Forensic Sciences Forensic Services. Dr. Sahajpal has performed
Foundation (AAFS) Douglas M. Lucas Grant, forensic DNA analyses in more than 2000
the Connaught New Researcher Award, and criminal cases, as well as for numerous cases
the University of Toronto Mississauga Dean’s involving the identification of human skele-
Award for Excellence (Faculty). She is an as- tal remains and disaster victim identification.
sociate member of the American Academy Dr. Sahajpal attained his master’s degree in
of Forensic Sciences (AAFS), an active mem- Forensic Science from Punjabi University
ber of the International Society of Forensic Patiala, and his concern for wildlife con-
Genetics (ISFG), and an active member of servation and his interest in the field of
the Scientific Research Honor Society Sigma Wildlife Forensics brought him to the
Xi. Her publication record includes over 20 Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. At
peer-reviewed manuscripts, 35 scientific the Wildlife Institute of India, Dr. Sahajpal
communications, public abstracts, and oral carried out some of the pioneering research
presentations as well as two book chapters. work in the field of Wildlife Forensics and
She is an ad hoc reviewer for multiple inter- genetics. He earned his PhD in Forensic
national journals in the areas of human and Science from Punjabi University, Patiala.
forensic genetics and serves as a committee Identification of human skeletal remains
member for LabRoots Forensic Science, the has been an important area of work for
Swiss National Science Foundation, and the Dr. Sahajpal because Himachal Pradesh
American Society of Human Genetics “DNA is a popular tourist destination for hikers,
Day” Essay Contest. trekkers, and pilgrims—who often go miss-
Dr. Novroski is passionate about mentor- ing at high altitudes in the Himalayas (and
ing, volunteerism, and continuing education. along mountain passes and rivers) after get-
She actively holds mentorship positions with ting lost or due to abrupt weather changes.
the University of Toronto Mississauga Alumni Skeletonized remains are quite often recov-
Mentor Program as well as the Women in ered in these cases.
Science Mentorship Program (as part of an Dr. Sahajpal is currently working on the
ongoing NSERC CREATE PROMOTE Grant). genetic diversity of different forensically
xxviii Author’s biographies

s­ignificant markers across populations in Eugene Tan, PhD


India. He has experience in the field of quality Dr. Eugene Tan is Senior Vice President of
assurance (QA) and has worked as the quality Product Development at ANDE Corporation.
manager (QM) for the forensics laboratory in He received a BS in Engineering (summa
Himachal Pradesh. Dr. Sahajpal is a member cum laude), an MS in Engineering, and a
of the Indian Hair Research Society and the PhD in Engineering Physics from McMaster
International Society for Forensic Genetics University. He has extensive experience
(ISFG). He serves on the editorial panel of in realizing commercial products from
Forensic Science International: Reports, and ­early-­stage research programs. Among these
works for the “DNA Fights Rape—Save the commercialized products include the ANDE
Evidence” program run by Gordon Thomas Rapid DNA system, the Genebench FX rug-
Honeywell (GTH) Government Affairs. Dr. gedized microfluidic electrophoresis system,
Sahajpal has authored two books, contributed the DeNOVA 5000HT (Shimadzu) high-­
chapters to four books, and has published 25 throughput DNA sequencer, the XTM-72
research papers in the field of forensic genetics. (Xanoptix) highly parallel optical transceiver
for optical interconnection, and the ML-20
Richard Selden, MD, PhD Tunable Laser (CoreTek/Nortel) for tele-
Dr. Richard Selden is the Founder and Chief communications. At ANDE, Dr. Tan leads
Scientific Officer (CSO) of ANDE Corporation. the development of Rapid DNA Systems for
He founded the company in 2004 with a vi- clinical diagnostics, human forensic identifi-
sion to move DNA analysis from sophisti- cation, and biothreat detection. He is respon-
cated laboratories to the field, where it could sible for the design, construction, testing, and
have a daily impact in the military, disaster optimization of the optical, mechanical, and
victim identification (DVI), law enforcement, electrical systems; microfluidic design and
homeland security, and clinical diagnostic testing; and development and optimization
applications. He received his BA degree from of chip fabrication processes. Additionally,
Harvard University, MA and PhD degrees in he is responsible for the development of data
Genetics from the Harvard Graduate School processing and expert system algorithms.
of Arts and Sciences, an MD from Harvard Dr. Tan was the Program Manager and Chief
Medical School, and trained as a pediatrician System Architect for the Joint DoD/DHS/
at Massachusetts General Hospital. FBI ANDE program. He was also the prin-
Dr. Selden is an author of 45 scientific pub- cipal investigator on three National Institute
lications and an inventor on 47 U.S. patents. of Justice (NIJ) programs on Forensic DNA
He was named an honorary member of the Research and Development. Dr. Tan is an
Butte County Sheriff’s Department for his inventor on 21 ANDE-issued U.S. patents
humanitarian work on the 2018 Camp Fire, and an author on numerous peer-reviewed
the deadliest wildfire in California history. publications.
He has received numerous awards, including
the Ernst & Young New England Entrepreneur Rosemary Turingan Witkowski, PhD
of the Year award, the R&D 100 Award, the Not Dr. Rosemary Turingan Witkowski is
Impossible Award, and the 2020 CES Innovation Vice President of Forensic Biology at ANDE
Award. Additionally, Dr. Selden has been the Corporation. She earned a BS degree in
principal investigator (PI) on a broad range Chemistry (with Honors) at the University of
of government grants and contracts for clini- the Philippines (Diliman, Quezon City). After
cal and forensic programs. moving to the United States, she earned an MS
Author’s biographies xxix
and PhD in Chemistry from the University research, development, and application of
of Massachusetts, Amherst. Her graduate re- forensic human identification techniques for
search focused on understanding transcrip- missing person casework in Australia. Her
tion kinetics and DNA-T7 RNA polymerase specific research interests include investigat-
structural dynamics through fluorescence ing novel DNA technologies (e.g., massively
resonance energy transfer for which she was parallel sequencing, Rapid DNA testing) and
recognized at the Biophysical Society Annual their integration with complementary foren-
Meeting for Student Research Achievement. sic techniques to optimize the identification of
She joined ANDE in 2006 and has become unknown deceased persons in humanitarian
an integral player in the development, vali- forensic operations. Previously, she has held fo-
dation, and commercialization of the ANDE rensic DNA specialist roles with the New
Rapid DNA Identification System. She is re- South Wales (NSW) Forensic and Analytical
sponsible for developing protocols for analy- Science Service and NSW Police Force, and
sis of a wide range of sample types for Rapid forensic biology academic roles with the
DNA Identification, including Disaster National Center for Forensic Studies. She is
Victim Identification (DVI) and sexual as- considered an expert in mitochondrial DNA
sault evidence applications. She was directly testing and provides expert evidence for both
involved in the ­identification of the remains criminal and coronial cases in Australia.
of the 2018 California Wildfires, and her ex- Dr. Ward holds a PhD in forensic molec-
pertise in the processing of human remains ular biology from The Australian National
has led to the resolution of investigative University and has postgraduate qualifica-
cases at the request of various law enforce- tions in management and higher education.
ment agencies across the country. At ANDE, Her career highlight includes being awarded
Dr. Turingan Witkowski is also responsible a prestigious 2015 Churchill Fellowship to in-
for the development of biological threat as- vestigate world‑leading DNA identification
says and related clinical diagnostics based techniques for missing persons and disaster
on highly multiplexed PCR amplification victims. Following her fellowship, she de-
and sequencing methods. She is an author of vised, published, and promoted a number of
several peer-reviewed scientific publications international best-practice recommendations
and an inventor on a number of U.S. patents. for the DNA-led identification of human re-
mains, which provide the foundation for the
Jodie Ward, PhD National DNA Program for Unidentified and
Associate Professor Jodie Ward is Program Missing Persons. She was also recognized as
Lead for the Australian Federal Police’s one of Science and Technology Australia’s
National DNA Program for Unidentified 2017 Superstars of STEM and Australian
and Missing Persons. This multidisciplinary Financial Review’s 2018 100 Women of
forensic science program serves to aid the Influence for pioneering a specialist nuclear-
investigation of Australia’s current uniden- and mitochondrial DNA identification lab-
tified and missing person cases. In addition, oratory in NSW, which was used nationally
Dr. Ward is Director of the Australian Facility by police, forensic, and military agencies to
for Taphonomic Experimental Research identify challenging human skeletal samples
(AFTER) and an Associate Professor in the from contemporary and historical contexts.
Centre for Forensic Science at the University She is a member of the Australian Academy
of Technology Sydney. This unique joint ap- of Forensic Sciences (AAFS), Australian
pointment facilitates her ability to lead the and New Zealand Forensic Science Society
xxx Author’s biographies

(ANZFSS), and International Society of in the human genome, including mitochon-


Forensic Genetics (ISFG), and has been drial DNA elements. As an undergraduate,
a Board Member of the Missing Persons Dr. Wendt was involved in the initial test-
Advocacy Network since 2018. ing of Rapid DNA instrumentation now
readily employed in law enforcement agen-
Jeremy Watherston PhD cies globally. At UNTHSC, he developed
Jeremy Watherston holds a Bachelor of pharmacokinetic-­ driven machine learning
Science in Biomedical Science (Forensic models of response to the synthetic opioid
Biology), a Bachelor of Social Science agonist tramadol. This exposure to complex
(Psychology), a Master of Forensic Studies trait genetics brought him to the Yale School
in Forensic Science (MForStForSc), and a of Medicine (Department of Psychiatry) to
PhD from the University of Technology study the cause and consequence of shared
Sydney (Australia). An experienced Senior genetic architecture across complex traits
Forensic Biologist currently working in the related to psychiatry, cognition, and human
Case Management Unit at the NSW Health behavior. Dr. Wendt is currently a National
Pathology, Forensic, and Analytical Science Research Service Award Fellow through
Service (Sydney, Australia), he reports on the National Institute of Mental Health. His
nuclear DNA, Y-chromosome DNA, mito- work focuses on understanding sex differ-
chondrial DNA (mtDNA), and mixed DNA ences in psychiatric disorders and related
profiles (including probabilistic genotyping comorbidities using sophisticated computa-
analyses), as well as genetic identification us- tional multiomics methods. To understand
ing paternity and kinship analysis. Jeremy’s these differences, Dr. Wendt works primarily
research focuses on the recovery of DNA from with large-scale genetic data as an analyst
compromised human remains and DNA- for the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium
based disaster victim identification (DVI). Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Substance
His research covers optimal sample selection, Use Disorder Working Groups (PGC-PTSD)
collection, and preservation, as well as novel and a genetic epidemiologist within the
profiling approaches and the application to U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Million
Rapid DNA platforms. Dr. Watherston’s re- Veteran Program.
search is being carried out in collaboration Dr. Wendt has received numerous pres-
with the Australian Facility for Taphonomic tigious awards from regional, national,
Experimental Research (AFTER). and international organizations including
the Million Veteran Program and the World
Frank Wendt, PhD Congress of Psychiatric Genetics Early Career
Dr. Frank Wendt holds a Bachelor’s Investigator Awards. Dr. Wendt is a crim-
Degree in Forensic Science (emphasis: bi- inalistics trainee affiliate of the American
ology) from Pennsylvania State University Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) and a
(PSU) and a PhD in Biomedical Science member of the American Society of Human
(emphasis: molecular genetics) from the Genetics. He serves as an ad hoc reviewer
University of North Texas Health Science for 10 journals for the international forensic
Center (UNTHSC). His educational train- science and human genetics communities.
ing is largely focused on the population ge- He has published a total of 50 peer-reviewed
netics of forensically relevant marker types, research articles, preprints, review arti-
including insertion–deletion, single nucleo- cles, and book chapters; has contributed
tide, and tandem repetitive polymorphisms to 41 conference abstracts; and has given
Author’s biographies xxxi
15 ­invited lectures across the United States Integration of Research, Teaching, and
and internationally. Learning. He has served on three mas-
Dr. Wendt is passionate about mentor- ter’s thesis committees for the Penn State
ship, STEM outreach, and bioinformatics Forensic Science Program and is an ac-
education. He holds an associate certifi- tive participant in the Penn State Alumni
cation of College Teaching Preparation Mentor Network where he mentors under-
from the multiinstitutional Center for the graduate forensic science students.
Editor biography

Dr. Angie Ambers is an internationally recognized DNA


expert and the Director of Forensic Genetics at the Institute
for Human Identification in the College of Dental Medicine at
Lincoln Memorial University (LMU). She is also a Professor
of Forensic Genetics and Human Identification at LMU.
She has a PhD in Molecular Biology (with an emphasis in
Forensic Genetics and human identification) as well as mas-
ter’s degrees in both Forensic Genetics and Criminology. Dr.
Ambers conducts research at the National Forensic Academy
(NFA) Cumberland Forest Outdoor Decomposition Facility,
a research and training center devoted to the scientific study
of the effects of environmental exposure on postmortem hu-
man remains. In collaboration with a team of board-certified
forensic anthropologists and odontologists, her research mis-
sion is to develop and ­optimize methodologies to improve
identification efforts in missing person cases, mass disasters,
and unidentified human remains (UHR) investigations.
Dr. Ambers previously served as Assistant Director of the Henry C. Lee Institute of Forensic
Science in Connecticut, a world-class institute that specializes in interdisciplinary research,
training, testing, casework consulting, and education in forensic science. She has also held an
Associate Professor (Forensic DNA) appointment in the Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice
and Forensic Sciences at the University of New Haven (UNH), teaching forensic biology and DNA
analysis methods, in addition to specialty courses on advanced DNA topics. During this time,
she also was a team member of UNH’s Center for Forensic Investigation of Trafficking in Persons.
She worked as a forensic geneticist for the University of North Texas (UNT) Center for Human
Identification for 8 years and, prior to pursuing her doctorate, was lead DNA analyst and lab
manager of UNT’s DNA Sequencing Core Facility. Her doctoral research involved an investiga-
tion of methods (e.g., whole genome amplification, DNA repair) for improving autosomal and
Y-STR typing of degraded and low copy number (LCN) DNA from human skeletal remains
and environmentally damaged biological materials. Her master’s thesis research included the
development and optimization of a DNA-based multiplex screening tool for ­genetics-based
separation of fragmented and commingled skeletal remains in mass graves.
Dr. Ambers specializes in the characterization and identification of contemporary, histor-
ical, and archaeological human skeletal remains. Her casework involved DNA t­esting of an
American Civil War guerrilla scout; several Finnish World War II soldiers; unidentified late-
19th century skeletal remains ­discovered by a construction crew in Deadwood, South Dakota;
unidentified skeletal remains of Special Operations soldiers killed during the 1974 Turkish in-
vasion of Cyprus; skeletal remains exhumed from Prague Castle in the Czech Republic; skeletal

xxxiii
xxxiv Editor biography

remains of soldiers from the 7 Years’ War (1756–63); bone samples purported to belong to a
member of Jesse James gang (killed during a bank robbery in 1876); and the exhumed remains
of the wife of a Yale medical school professor. She copresented a workshop on “Advanced
Methods for DNA-based Analysis of Skeletal Remains” at the 26th International Symposium
on Human Identification (ISHI), and has been an invited speaker at an international bone work-
shop/conference in Prague, Czech Republic. In 2017, she traveled twice to India to train sci-
entists from various Indian states and the Maldives Police Service on the processing of bone
samples in forensic DNA casework. During her visit to India, she performed autosomal STR
analysis on human skeletal remains discovered along a hiking route in the Himalayas (in the
northern state of Himachal Pradesh) to assist local officials in the investigation of a missing
person case. Additionally, she performed DNA analysis on a female homicide victim recovered
from a clandestine grave in New Delhi.
Dr. Ambers’ casework and research have been published in various peer-­reviewed journals,
including Forensic Science International: Genetics (FSI:Genetics), Forensic Science International,
International Journal of Legal Medicine, Legal Medicine, BMC Genomics, the Croatian Medical Journal,
The Journal of Heredity, and Journal of Biological and Clinical Anthropology (Anthropologischer
Anzeiger). Her work has received press in numerous local and national newspapers (including
The Washington Times, NBC News, Criminal Legal News, The Root) and has been featured on sev-
eral podcasts (Truth and Justice, Crime Waves).
Among her most recent casework (a collaboration with the Texas Historical Commission)
includes DNA analyses of human skeletal remains associated with the French explorer La
Salle’s last expedition. This case involved massively parallel sequencing (MPS) of DNA
from two adult male skeletons recovered from the La Belle shipwreck, skeletal remains
recovered from a mass grave at Fort St. Louis, and the putative remains of Sieur de Marle.
Additionally, Dr. Ambers performed DNA extractions and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
sequencing on numerous sets of skeletal remains associated with Spanish royalty and
the House of Aragon (recovered from tombs within the Royal Pantheon of San Juan de
la Peña archaeological site in Spain). She is currently working on the putative remains of
William Townsend Washington, the nephew of former U.S. President George Washington.
In addition to skeletal remains cases and research, Dr. Ambers collaborated with the
National Institute of Justice (NIJ) and the Forensic Technology Center of Excellence (FTCoE)
to develop and disseminate a formal report on the use of familial DNA searching (FDS) in
casework. She is an active cold case consultant, an advocate of postconviction DNA testing,
and an educator/advisor on DNA testing or retesting of old, degraded, or challenging evi-
dentiary samples. Dr. Ambers also was the 2017–18 project lead on a U.S. State Department
grant to combat human trafficking in Central America through the application of foren-
sics. As part of the program objectives, she traveled to three Northern Triangle countries
(Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras) to perform gap assessments of government laboratories
and train personnel in forensic DNA analysis, with the goal of promoting quality casework
methods based on ISO 17025 standards. As Project Lead, she helped train forensic DNA
scientists at the Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Forenses de Guatemala (INACIF, the National
Institute of Forensic Sciences of Guatemala) in Guatemala City, Guatemala; the Instituto de
Medicina Legal (Institute of Legal Medicine) in San Salvador, El Salvador; and the Instituto
Editor biography xxxv
de Medicina Forenses: Centro de Medicina Legal y Ciencias Forenses (the Institute of Forensic
Medicine: Center of Legal Medicine and Forensic Sciences) in Tegucigalpa, Honduras. In ad-
dition to providing both lecture and tactile training on DNA analysis methods to Northern
Triangle laboratories, Dr. Ambers was part of a consortium to help these countries develop
and maintain forensic DNA databases to assist in the identification of missing persons re-
lated to human trafficking.
Dr. Ambers has mentored hundreds of students during her career and for multiple
years served as the faculty advisor for Scientista, the largest network of college and grad-
uate women innovating science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) in the United
States. The Scientista Foundation is a national organization that empowers women in science,
technology, engineering, and math (STEM) through content, communities, and conferences.
During her free time, Dr. Ambers enjoys traveling, hiking, kayaking, reading, spending time
with her dogs, and volunteering to help victims of abuse as well as minority and oppressed
populations.

In 2017–18, Dr. Ambers was Project Lead on a U.S. State Department grant to combat human trafficking in Central
America’s Northern Triangle, where she helped train forensic DNA scientists at the Instituto Nacional de Ciencias
Forenses de Guatemala (INACIF, the National Institute of Forensic Sciences of Guatemala) in Guatemala City,
Guatemala; the Instituto de Medicina Legal (Institute of Legal Medicine) in San Salvador, El Salvador; and the Instituto
de Medicina Forenses: Centro de Medicina Legal y Ciencias Forenses (the Institute of Forensic Medicine: Center of Legal
Medicine and Forensic Sciences) in Tegucigalpa, Honduras
xxxvi Editor biography

Dr. Ambers at the 2016 funeral ceremony of unidentified human skeletal remains unearthed by a construction
crew in Deadwood, South Dakota. The remains were discovered in a residential neighborhood that was built atop
the original site of Ingleside Cemetery (Deadwood’s first burial ground, 1876–78). The remains were reinterred in
Mt. Moriah Cemetery, the final resting place of “Wild Bill” Hickok, Calamity Jane, and the City of Deadwood’s
first Sheriff Seth Bullock.
Preface

“I hope my achievements in life shall be are seeking adventure and spiritual enlighten-
these—that I will have fought for what was ment amongst the majesty of the Himalayas.
right and fair, that I will have risked for that One evening, in my room at the Trident
which mattered, that I will have given help to Gurgaon Hotel, I initiated an internet search
those who were in need, and that I will have to learn more about this magical region of
left this Earth a better place for what I've done northern India. Despite its allure to adven-
and who I've been.” ture seekers and spiritualists, and its beauti-
—Carl Hoppe ful landscape, many travelers underestimate
the sheer vastness of the mountain range
The impetus for this book arose during and the unpredictable weather conditions in
an international trip that I took in 2017, on the area. As such, there is a popular hiking
behalf of Thermo Fisher Scientific’s Human region in the Himalayas within Himachal
Identification (HID) University, to train sci- Pradesh (called Parvati Valley) that has been
entists from various states in India and the unofficially nicknamed the “Valley of Death”
Maldives Police Service on the processing because of the large number of American
and extraction of DNA from human skeletal and European tourists who have gone miss-
remains. During my time in India, I was ap- ing while hiking in the area over the past
proached by a forensic DNA specialist from few decades. In fact, the number of missing
Himachal Pradesh, the northernmost state in American and European tourists is in the doz-
India which borders the Himalayan Mountain ens. During my search to learn more about the
Range and is the residence of the Dalai Lama missing tourists, I ran across a website titled
in exile. This scientist’s team had been tasked “The Adventures of Justin,” which chronicled
with identifying a set of skeletal remains dis- the adventures of a 32-year-old man named
covered in the Himalayas along a popular Justin Alexander Shetler, who quit a lucrative
hiking/trekking route—and he had brought job in corporate America, sold most of his
the remains with him to the bone workshop. belongings, and left behind the security of a
Each day, after the workshop training ended, salary and a life of consumerism in search of
we spent the evenings in the Thermo Fisher a life with deeper meaning. As I read Justin’s
Scientific laboratory facility in New Delhi at- posts, I felt a kinship to his expression that
tempting to recover sufficient genetic material experiences are more valuable than material
from the remains in hopes of making a posi- things. On his website, I was particularly
tive identification and returning the remains drawn to a photograph he had posted of the
to the family. During some of the long incuba- Catacombs in Paris, along with the caption
tion periods throughout the DNA extraction “A reminder that we are impermanent. One day
process, discussions ensued about the pos- we will be nothing but bones and stories.” There
sible identity of the decedent. I learned that was a strange irony to this statement, and I re-
Himachal Pradesh is a popular travel destina- member getting goosebumps thinking about
tion for American and European tourists who his insight and the ­ ostensible premonition

xxxvii
xxxviii Preface

of his own impending mortality. Although one potential option was to contact the re-
Justin was a seasoned traveler and an expe- spective Embassies of each foreign national
rienced outdoorsman, he had disappeared in who had disappeared in the “Valley of
the Parvati Valley of the Himalayas in 2016, Death,” to notify the families of the missing
nearly a year before I arrived in India to teach and request reference samples for compar-
the workshop. As I sat on the bed in my hotel ison to the DNA profile obtained from the
room perusing his story on my laptop, I won- remains. However, this option was far from
dered if the remains recovered in the Indian ideal, as only one of those families (or pos-
Himalayas were those of Justin Shetler. sibly none of them) would receive the news
After numerous evenings in the laboratory, that their missing loved one had finally
and after processing a number of different skel- been found. There was a distinct possibil-
etal elements for DNA, a complete short tan- ity that the skeletal remains discovered did
dem repeat (STR) profile was obtained using not belong to any of the missing American
the FBI’s expanded core CODIS loci and the or European tourists. Furthermore, this type
GlobalFiler™ PCR Amplification Kit (Thermo of investigative approach lacks sensitivity to
Fisher Scientific). For this case, we had the families who have already endured years (or
luxury of using state-of-the-art facilities and even decades) of grief regarding their miss-
equipment at the Thermo Fisher Scientific lab- ing loved one. Rather than notifying the fam-
oratory in New Delhi to conduct DNA testing ilies and unnecessarily raising their hopes
on these samples, which should have facili- that their loved one’s remains had finally
tated the process of making a positive identi- been found, I suggested that we first investi-
fication of the remains. Whenever I talk about gate the racial background of the decedent to
this case to colleagues and students—and see if it aligned with the Anglo-European de-
once I disclose that we obtained a complete scriptions of those missing in the “Valley of
DNA profile—the immediate assumption is Death.” Although a forensic anthropologist
that we were able to positively identify this can often predict the race of an unknown indi-
individual. However, at the time of this case, vidual by examining various characteristics
India did not have a national DNA database, of the skull, that possibility was precluded in
nor had they collected reference samples from this case by the partial nature of the skeletal
the families of the missing foreign nationals, remains recovered. The skull was disarticu-
so there was no genetic data available for lated, incomplete, and heavily fragmented.
comparison to aid in the identification or for Fortunately, recent advances in DNA tech-
reassociating the remains with any particular nology provide a mechanism through which
family. This is a common issue encountered to make an assessment of race in partial skel-
in forensic genetic investigations of unidenti- etal remains cases. With additional testing of
fied human remains (UHR). It exemplifies the a panel of ancestry-informative single nucle-
fact that, even when using the most advanced otide polymorphisms (aiSNPs) using mas-
technology and laboratory techniques, the sively parallel sequencing (MPS), and then
process of identification is multifaceted and comparing this aiSNP data to the Forensic
requires that certain infrastructure is in place Research/Reference on Genetics knowledge
in order to be successful. Ultimately, the DNA base (FROG-kb) and the ALele FREquency
profile obtained from the skeletal remains is Database (ALFRED), it was determined that
only one piece of the puzzle. the remains recovered from the hiking trail
At this stage in the investigation (and in the Indian Himalayas did not belong to
armed with a complete 24-locus STR ­profile), an individual of ­ Anglo-European descent.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
The Project Gutenberg eBook of On the effect of
electric and magnetic fields on spectral lines
This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States
and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no
restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it
under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this
ebook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the
United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where
you are located before using this eBook.

Title: On the effect of electric and magnetic fields on spectral lines

Author: Niels Bohr

Release date: March 1, 2024 [eBook #73082]

Language: English

Original publication: London: Taylor & Francis, 1914

Credits: Laura Natal Rodrigues (Images generously made available


by The Internet Archive.)

*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ON THE


EFFECT OF ELECTRIC AND MAGNETIC FIELDS ON SPECTRAL
LINES ***
THE LONDON, EDINBURGH, AND DUBLIN
PHILOSOPHICAL MAGAZINE
and
JOURNAL OF SCIENCE.

VOL. XXVII—SIXTH SERIES.

JANUARY-JUNE 1914.

LIX. On the Effect of Electric


and Magnetic Fields on
Spectral Lines.

By N. BOHR,

Dr. phil. Copenhagen[1].


CONTENTS
§ 1. The Emission of a Line Spectrum.
§ 2. The Effect of an Electric Field.
§ 3. The Effect of a Magnetic Field.
§ 4. Double Spectral Lines.
Concluding Remarks.

IN a previous paper[2] the writer has shown that an explanation of


some of the laws of line spectra may be obtained by applying
Planck’s theory of black radiation to Rutherford’s theory of the
structure of atoms. In the present paper these considerations will be
further developed, and it will be shown that it seems possible on the
theory to account for some of the characteristic features of the recent
discovery by Stark[3] of the effect of an electric field on spectral lines,
as well as of the effect of a magnetic field first discovered by
Zeeman. It will also be shown that the theory seems to offer an
explanation of the appearance of ordinary double spectral lines[4].
§ 1. The Emission of a Line Spectrum.
The theory put forward by the writer to explain the emission of a
line-spectrum may be summarized as follows:—
The principal assumption of Planck’s theory is that the energy of a
system of vibrating electrified particles cannot be transferred into
radiation, and vice versa, in the continuous way assumed in the
ordinary electrodynamics, but only in finite quanta of the amount ,
where is a universal constant and the frequency of the
radiation[5]. Applying this assumption to the emission of a line-
spectrum, and assuming that a certain spectral line of frequency
corresponds to a radiation emitted during the transition of an
elementary system from a state in which its energy is to one in
which it is , we have

According to Balmer, Rydberg, and Ritz the frequency of the lines


in the line-spectrum of an element can be expressed by the formula

where and are whole numbers and , , ... a series of


functions of , which can be expressed by

where is a universal constant and a function which for large


values of approaches the value unity. The complete spectrum is
obtained by combining the numbers and as well as the
functions , ..., in every possible way.
On the above view this can be interpreted by assuming:
(1) That every line in the spectrum corresponds to a radiation
emitted by a certain elementary system during its passage between
two states in which the energy, omitting an arbitrary constant, is given
by and respectively;
(2) That the system can pass between any two such states during
emission of a homogeneous radiation.
The states in question will be denoted as “stationary states.”
The spectrum of hydrogen observed in ordinary vacuum-tubes[6]
is represented by (2) and (3) by putting

Accordingly we shall assume that this spectrum is emitted by a


system possessing a series of stationary states in which,
corresponding to the th state, the energy, omitting the arbitrary
constant, is given by

According to Rutherford’s theory, the atom of an element consists


of a central positive nucleus surrounded by electrons rotating in
closed orbits. Concordant evidence, obtained in very different ways,
indicates that the number of electrons in the neutral atom is equal to
the number of the corresponding element in the periodic table[6].
On this theory the structure of the neutral hydrogen atom is of
extreme simplicity; it consists of an electron rotating round a positive
nucleus of opposite charge. In such a system we get on the ordinary
mechanics the following equations for the frequency of revolution
and the major axis of the relative orbit of the particles

where and are the charges, and the masses of the


nucleus and the electron respectively, and where is the amount of
energy to be transferred to the system in order to remove the electron
to an infinite distance from the nucleus. It may be noticed that the
expressions are independent of the degree of eccentricity of the
orbits.
In order to obtain a mechanical interpretation of the above-
mentioned stationary states, let us now in (6) put [7]. This
gives

According to this view, a line of the hydrogen spectrum is emitted


during the passage of the atom between two stationary states
corresponding to different values for . We must assume that the
mechanism of emission cannot be described in detail on the basis of
the ordinary electrodynamics. However, it is known that it is possible
on the latter theory to account satisfactorily for the phenomena of
radiation in the region of slow vibrations. If our point of view is sound,
we should therefore expect to find in this region some connexion
between the present theory and the ordinary ideas of
electrodynamics.
From (7) we see that vanishes for large values of , and that
at the same time the ratio tends to unity. On the present theory
the frequency of the radiation emitted by the transition from the
th to the th stationary state is equal to .

When is large, this approaches to . On the ordinary


electrodynamics we should expect the frequency of the radiation to
be equal to the frequency of revolution, and consequently it is to be
anticipated that for large values of
Introducing the values for and given by (5) and (7), we see
that disappears from this equation, and that the condition of identity
is

From direct observations we have . Introducing


recent values for , , and [8], we get for the expression on the
right side of (9) . The agreement is inside the limit of
experimental errors in the determination of , , and ; and we may
therefore conclude that the connexion sought between the present
considerations and the ordinary electrodynamics actually exists.
From (7) and (9) we get

For , corresponding to the normal state of the atom, we get


; a value of the same order of magnitude as the
values for the diameters of atoms calculated on the kinetic theory of
gases. For higher values of , however, is great compared with
the values of ordinary atomic dimensions. As I pointed out in my
former paper, this result may be connected with the non-appearance
in vacuum-tubes of hydrogen lines corresponding to high numbers in
Balmer’s formula and observed in the spectra of stars. Further, it will
appear from the considerations of the next section that the large
diameter of the orbits offers an explanation of the surprisingly great
magnitude of the Stark effect.
From (10) it appears that the condition (8) holds, not only for large
values of but for all values of . In addition, for a stationary orbit
is equal to the mean value of the total kinetic energy of the
particles; from (10) we therefore get
In using the expressions (6) we have assumed that the motion of
the particles in the stationary states of the system can be determined
by help of the ordinary mechanics. On this assumption it can be
shown generally that the conditions (8) and (11) are equivalent.
Consider a particle moving in a closed orbit in a stationary field. Let
be the frequency of revolution, the mean value of the kinetic
energy during a revolution, and the mean value of the sum of
the kinetic energy and the potential energy of the particle relative to
the stationary field. Applying Hamilton’s principle, we get for a small
variation of the orbit

If the new orbit is also one of dynamical equilibrium, we get


, where is the total energy of the system, and it will be
seen that the equivalence of (8) and (11) follows immediately from
(12).
In these deductions we have made no assumptions about the
degree of eccentricity of the orbits. If the orbits are circular (11) is
equivalent to the simple condition that the angular momentum of the
system in the stationary states is equal to an entire multiple of [9].

In Planck’s vibrators the particles are held by quasi-elastic forces,


and the mean value of the kinetic energy is equal to the mean value
of the potential energy due to the displacements. Consequently (11)
forms a complete analogy to Planck’s original relation

between the energy of a monochromatic vibrator and its frequency


. This analogy offers another way of representing the present theory
—a way more similar to that used in my former paper[10].
Considering, however, the widely different assumptions underlying
the relation (11) and Planck’s relation, it may seem more adequate
not to seek the basis of our considerations in the formal analogy in
question, but directly in the principal condition (1) and in the laws of
the line-spectra.

In dealing with the more complicated structure of the spectra of


other elements, we must assume that the atoms of such elements
possess several different series of stationary states. This complexity
of the system of stationary states, compared with that of the hydrogen
atom, might naturally be anticipated from the greater number of
electrons in the heavier atoms, which render possible several
different types of configurations of the particles.
According to (1), (2), and (3) the energy of the th state in the th
series is, omitting the arbitrary constant, given by

The present theory is not sufficiently developed to account in


detail for the expression (13). However, a simple interpretation may
be obtained of the fact that in every series approaches unity
for large values of .
Suppose that in the stationary states one of the electrons moves
at a distance from the nucleus which is large compared with the
distance of the other electrons. If the atom is neutral, the outer
electron will be subject to very nearly the same forces as the electron
in the hydrogen atom. Consequently, the expression (13) may be
interpreted as indicating the presence of a number of series of
stationary states of the atom in which the configuration of the inner
electrons is very nearly the same for all states in one series, while the
configuration of the outer electron changes from state to state in the
series approximately in the same way as in the hydrogen atom.
It will appear that these considerations offer a possible simple
explanation of the appearance of the Rydberg constant in the formula
for the spectral series of every element. In this connexion, however, it
may be noticed that on this point of view the Rydberg constant is not
exactly the same for every element, since the expression (8) for
depends on the mass of the central nucleus. The correction due to
the finite value of is very small for elements of high atomic weight,
but is comparatively large for hydrogen. It may therefore not be
permissible to calculate the Rydberg constant directly from the
hydrogen spectrum. Instead of the value 109675 generally assumed,
the theoretical value for a heavy atom is 109735.
§ 2. The Effect of an Electric Field.
As mentioned above, J. Stark has recently discovered that the
presence of an external electric held produces a characteristic effect
on the line-spectrum of an element. The effect was observed for
hydrogen and helium. By spectroscopic observation in a direction
perpendicular to the held, each of the lines of the hydrogen spectrum
was broken up into five homogeneous components situated very
nearly symmetrically with regard to the original line. The three inner
components were of feeble intensity and polarized with electric vector
perpendicular to the field, while the two outer stronger components
were polarized with electric vector parallel to the field. The distance
between the components was found to be proportional to the electric
force within the limits of experimental errors. With a field of 13,000
volt per cm. the observed difference in the wave-length of the two
outer components was and for and
respectively. For both systems of lines emitted by helium, Stark
observed an effect on the lines of the Diffuse series which was of the
same order of magnitude as that observed for the hydrogen lines, but
of a different type. Thus the components were situated
unsymmetrically with regard to the original line, and were also not
polarized relative to the field. The effect of the field on the lines of the
Principal series and the Sharp series was very small and hardly
distinguishable.
On the theory of this paper the effect of an external field on the
lines of a spectrum may be due to two different causes:—
(1) The field may influence the stationary states of the emitting
system, and thereby the energy possessed by the system in these
states.
(2) It may influence the mechanism of transition between the
stationary states, and thereby the relation between the frequency of
the radiation and the amount of energy emitted.
Considering an external electric field we shall not expect an effect
of the second kind. Having assumed the atoms to be systems of
particles governed by electrostatic forces, we may consider the
presence of the field simply as a complication of the original system;
but on the interpretation given in the former section of the general
principle of Ritz of combination of spectral lines, we may expect that
the relation (1) will hold for every system of electrified particles.
It appears that a necessary condition for the correctness of this
view is that the frequencies of the components of spectral lines
produced by the electric field can be expressed by a formula of the
type (2). As we shall see, this seems to be consistent with Stark’s
experiments.
Let us first consider the effect of an electric field on the hydrogen
spectrum. In order to find the effect of the field on the energy of the
atom in the different stationary states, we shall seek for its influence
on the relation between the energy and the frequency of the system.
In this calculation we shall make use of the ordinary mechanics, from
analogy with the considerations of the former section.
For simplicity, let us suppose that the mass of the nucleus is
infinitely great in comparison with that of the electron. Consider an
electron originally moving in a circular orbit round the nucleus.
Through the effect of an external electric field the orbit will be
deformed. If the force is not accurately perpendicular to the plane of
the orbit, this deformation will in course of time be considerable, oven
if the external electric force is very small compared with the attraction
between the particles. In this case, the orbit may at every moment be
considered as an ellipse with the nucleus in the focus, and the effect
of the field will consist in a gradual variation of the direction of the
major-axis as well as of the eccentricity. During this variation, the
length of the major-axis will approximately remain constant and equal
to the diameter of the original circular orbit. A detailed investigation of
the motion of the electron may be very complicated; but it can be
simply shown that the problem only allows of two stationary orbits of
the electron. In these, the eccentricity is equal to 1 and the major-axis
parallel to the axis of the external field; the orbits simply consist of a
straight line through the nucleus parallel to the axis of the field, one
on each side of it. It can also be shown that orbits which are very
near to these limiting cases will be very nearly stationary.
Neglecting quantities proportional to the square of the magnitude
of the external electric force, we get for the rectilinear orbits in
question

where is the frequency of vibration and the amplitude of the


orbit. is the external electric force, and the two signs correspond to
orbits in which the direction of the major-axis from the nucleus is the
same or opposite to that of the electric force respectively. For the total
energy of the system we have

where is an arbitrary constant. The mean value of the kinetic


energy of the electron during the vibration is

Leaving aside for a moment the discussion of the possibility of


such orbits, let us investigate what series of stationary states maybe
expected from the expressions (14) and (15). In order to determine
the stationary states we shall, as in the former section, seek a
connexion with ordinary electrodynamics in the region of slow
vibrations. Proceeding as on page 4, suppose when is large

where and denote the energy and the frequency in the th


state. By help of (14) and (15) we get
This gives

or

Introducing this in (14), (15), and (16) we get

and

It should be remembered that these deductions hold only for large


values of . For the mechanical interpretation of the calculations we
need therefore only assume that the eccentricity is very nearly unity
for the large orbits. On the other hand, it appears from (17), (18), and
(19) that the principal terms in the expressions for , , and
are the same as those deduced in the former section directly from the
Balmer formula. If we therefore suppose that these quantities in the
presence of an electric field can be expressed by a series of terms

involving ascending powers of , we may regard the above


deduction as a determination of the coefficient of the second term in
this series, and may expect the validity of the expressions for every
value of . It may be considered, in support of this conclusion, that
we obtain the same simple relation (11) between the frequency of
revolution and the mean value of the kinetic energy as was found
without the field, c. f. page 5.
In the presence of an electric field we shall therefore assume the
existence of two series of stationary states of the hydrogen atom, in
which the energy is given by (19). In order to obtain the continuity
necessary for a connexion with ordinary electrodynamics, we have
assumed that the system can pass only between the different states
in each series. On this assumption we get for the frequency of the
radiation emitted by a transition between two states corresponding to
and respectively:

This formula gives for every hydrogen line two components


situated symmetrically with regard to the original line. Their difference
in frequency is proportional to the electric force and equal to [11]

According to the deduction of (21) we may expect that for high


values of the radiation corresponds to vibrations parallel to the
electric force. From analogy with the above considerations and in
order to obtain agreement with Stark’s result we shall assume that
this polarization holds also for small values of .
Introducing in (21) the experimental values for , , and , and
putting corresponding to an electric force of 13,000 volt
per cm., we obtain for the distance between the components of
and , and
cm. respectively. We see that these values are of the
same order of magnitude as the distance observed by Stark between
the two components polarized parallel to the electric force, viz.
and cm. The values calculated are somewhat
higher than those observed; the difference, however, might possibly
be due to the difficulties, mentioned in Stark’s paper, of the
determination of the magnitude of the electric force in his preliminary
experimental arrangement.
For the ratio between the displacements of and we get
from (21) 0.7168, independent of the magnitude of the electric force.
It will be seen that this value agrees closely with that observed, viz.
or 0.69. In this connexion it may be noticed that the value
calculated for the ratio in question is independent of the value of the
numerical factor in the expression (21), and consequently of the
detailed assumptions used in deducing this expression. The value for
the ratio can be derived directly from the assumption of the existence
of a series of stationary states, in which the energy can be expressed
in terms corresponding to ascending powers of .

A possible origin of the feeble components polarized


perpendicular to the field, which were observed by Stark, may be
found when a closer examination is made of the effect of the electric
field on the motion of the electron[12]. This problem, however, will not
be considered further at this stage.
The problem of the influence of an electric field on the spectra of
other elements is naturally far more complicated than for hydrogen,
and cannot be discussed in detail until the theory for such spectra is
further developed. It seems, however, possible on the present theory
to obtain a simple explanation of the characteristic difference,
observed by Stark, in the effect of the field on the lines of the different
series of the helium spectrum.
According to the last section, the different series of lines in the
spectrum of an element correspond to different series of stationary
states of the atom in which one of the electrons moves in an orbit
outside the others. For any high value of this orbit is approximately
the same as that of the electron in a hydrogen atom. In the discussion
we assumed that the effect of an electric field on the energy of the
stationary states of the hydrogen atom, is connected with a
considerable variation in the position and eccentricity of the orbit of
the electron in the presence of the field. The possibility of such a
variation is due to the fact that without the field every elliptical orbit is
stationary. When, however, there are perturbing forces from the inner
electrons the latter condition is not satisfied, and thus the effect of an
external electric field on the stationary states may be expected to be
much smaller than for the corresponding states of the hydrogen atom.
A measure of this effect of the inner electrons on the motion of the
outer may be obtained by considering the function . The nearer
this function approaches unity the smaller is the disturbance due to
the inner electrons, and the more the motion of the outer approaches
to that of the electron in the hydrogen atom. Now for the elements of
low atomic weight, such as helium and lithium, has a value
very nearly unity for the Diffuse series, while for the Sharp series or
the Principal series, the value is not at all as close. On our theory we
should, therefore, expect a much greater influence of an electric field
on the first series than on the other two series. This is in agreement
with Stark’s experiments[13].
On the present point of view a line of the Diffuse series of the
helium spectrum corresponds to a transition between two stationary
states, one of which is affected by the presence of an electric field,
and the other not: while for the hydrogen lines both states were
assumed to be affected by the field. This circumstance may afford, an
explanation of the fact observed by Stark, viz. that the components of
the helium lines were not polarized relatively to the field like the
hydrogen lines.

You might also like