Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effects of Different Forced Molting Methods on Pos
Effects of Different Forced Molting Methods on Pos
Effects of Different Forced Molting Methods on Pos
SUMMARY
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of different molting methods on postmolt
production, plasma corticosterone levels, and antibody production to SRBC for the welfare of
laying hens. This experiment was conducted with 120 IGH-type Brown laying hens (70 wk of age),
randomly divided into 3 experimental groups. The hens in one group were fed a whole-grain barley
diet during the first 10 d (WB diet). On d 11, hens consumed 100 g of layer diet/d until d 28. In
the second group, hens were fed a Zn diet containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO for 10 d (Zn
diet). Hens were then provided 100 g of a layer diet from d 11 to 28. In the third group, feed was
withdrawn for 10 d, and on d 11 hens were fed a cracked corn diet ad libitum until d 28 (California
method; CAL diet). Hens in all groups were returned to the layer diet ad libitum on d 29. Egg
weight was lower in the Zn treatment than in the other treatments. Feed intake and plasma
corticosterone levels were higher and antibody production was lower in the CAL treatment than
in the WB and Zn groups. The FCR was better in the WB than in the Zn group. Mortality, egg
production, and egg quality were not significantly different among the molting methods. As a
result, the WB molting program was the best method for postmolt production among the
programs examined.
Key words: molting, laying hen, postmolt production, corticosterone level, immune response
2007 J. Appl. Poult. Res. 16:529–536
doi:10.3382/japr.2006-00089
1
Corresponding author: obasilar@veterinary.ankara.edu.tr
530 JAPR: Research Report
Ingredient, %
Corn 52.00 56.36 100 —
Barley 13.40 7.00 — 100
Soybean meal 21.00 21.80 — —
Fish meal 3.00 3.00 — —
Limestone 9.00 9.00 — —
Dicalcium phosphate 1.00 1.00 — —
Salt 0.25 0.25 — —
Vitamin-mineral premix1 0.25 0.25 — —
DL-Met 0.10 0.10 — —
ZnO — 1.24 — —
Chemical composition (analyzed)
ME,2 kcal/kg 2,637 2,628 3,365 2,670
CP, % 16.30 16.39 8.00 10.90
Ca, % 3.10 3.18 0.04 0.22
P (total), % 0.68 0.72 0.04 0.35
Zn,3 mg/kg 84 10,084 18 22
1
Composition per 2.5 kg: 12,000,000 IU of vitamin A, 2,400,000 IU of vitamin D3, 30 g of vitamin E, 2.5 g of vitamin K3,
2.5 g of vitamin B1, 6 g of vitamin B2, 4 g of vitamin B6, 20 mg of vitamin B12, 25 g of niacin, 8 g of calcium D-panthotenate,
1 g of folic acid, 50 g of vitamin C, 50 mg of D-biotin, 150 g of choline chloride, 1.5 g of canthaxanthin, 0.5 g of apo-
carotenoic acid ester, 80 g of Mn, 60 g of Zn, 60 g of Fe, 5 g of Cu, 1 g of I, 0.5 g of Co, and 0.15 g of Se.
2
The ME content of diets was estimated by using a prediction equation [24].
3
Calculated based on the feed composition tables of the NRC [37].
ONBAŞıLAR AND EROL: MOLTING METHODS AND PERFORMANCE 531
Molting program1
WB Zn CAL
Time of
experiment n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM P-value
WB = whole-grain barley method; Zn = high dietary Zn method (containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO); CAL = California
1
method.
Table 4. Effects of different induced molting programs at different periods of the experiment on hen-day egg
production (%)
Molting program1
WB Zn CAL
Time of
experiment n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM P-value
Means within rows with different letters are different (P < 0.05).
a–c
WB = whole-grain barley method; Zn = high dietary Zn method (containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO); CAL = California
1
method.
532 JAPR: Research Report
Table 5. Effects of different induced molting programs at different periods of the experiment on egg weight (g)
Molting program1
WB Zn CAL
Time of
experiment n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM P-value
Means within rows with different letters are different (P < 0.05).
a–c
WB = whole-grain barley method; Zn = high dietary Zn method (containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO); CAL = California
1
method.
eggs per treatment were collected randomly to Antibody production against SRBC was
Table 6. Effects of different induced molting programs on feed intake (g/hen per d) and feed conversion ratio (g
feed:g egg)
Molting program1
WB Zn CAL
Time of
experiment Item n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM n Mean ± SEM P-value
Means within rows with different letters are different (P < 0.05).
a,b
WB = whole-grain barley method; Zn = high dietary Zn method (containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO); CAL = California
1
method.
ONBAŞıLAR AND EROL: MOLTING METHODS AND PERFORMANCE 533
ment groups were studied by one-way ANOVA. 35%, but the optimal BW loss of hens during
Means that were significantly different were sep- an induced molt was not identified.
arated by Duncan’s test. The frequencies of mor- In the present study during the molt period,
tality among groups were compared by using a hen-day egg production was higher in the Zn
chi-square test [25]. treatment than in the others (Table 4 and Figure
1). Postmolt (wk 5 to 22) hen-day egg production
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION was not significantly different among the 3 molt
In this experiment, BW loss was signifi- treatments (Table 4 and Figure 2). This result
cantly higher in the CAL treatment than in the agrees with the findings of Park et al. [27], who
other treatments (Table 3). Body weight loss is found that egg production was not different
an important factor contributing to the success among molting methods (feed withdrawal, Zn
of induced molting because of its impact on acetate, Zn propionate). However, Alodan and
reproduction and on fat deposits [26, 27]. This Mashaly [28] reported that egg production was
leads to regression of the reproductive tract, significantly affected by the molting program
which is proportional to the loss of BW, the [Zn, CAL, and on-again, off-again (ON-OFF)],
rejuvenation of the reproductive tract, and the and the Zn group had significantly (P < 0.05)
removal of fat accumulation, thereby increasing lower egg production than the CAL and ON-
tissue efficiency [28]. Webster [6] reported that OFF treatments. In the current study, postmolt
targeted weight losses have ranged from 15 to egg production was lower than expected in all
Table 7. Effects of different induced molting programs at different periods of the experiment on antibody production
against sheep red blood cells1
Molting program2
Means within rows with different letters are significantly different (P < 0.05).
a,b
1
Values are log2 of reciprocal dilution of antibody titer.
2
WB = whole-grain barley method; Zn = high dietary Zn method (containing 10,000 mg/kg of Zn as ZnO); CAL = California
method. Values are means ± SEM (n = 10).
534 JAPR: Research Report
groups. These results showed that the genotype 6). The FCR of hens in the WB treatment was
(obtained by Ankara Poultry Research Institute) better than that of hens in the Zn group. Berry
used in this experiment was not suitable for the and Brake [7] reported that hens in the low di-
second production cycle. etary Na treatment had significantly better (P <
Postmolt egg weight was significantly higher 0.05) feed efficiency than those in the high di-
in the CAL group than in the other groups (Table etary Zn and fasting treatments.
5). Contradictory to our findings, Alodan and During this experiment, 6 (15%), 7 (17.5%),
Mashaly [28] reported that different induced and 11 (27.5%) hens died in the WB, Zn, and
molting programs (Zn, CAL, ON-OFF) had no CAL treatment, respectively. Mortality was not
effect on egg weight. Previous studies of molting significantly affected by the different molting
methods have often shown conflicting results in treatments. This result is in agreement with Alo-
hen responses because of different conditions dan and Mashaly [28].
[4]. Body weight at the start of the experiment, One method of assessing welfare in different
BW loss [29], age of the hens [26], and strain molting programs is to measure the physiologi-
[30] have all been shown to affect the results cal parameters associated with the stress re-
of different molting methods. There were no sponse. Physiological parameters of stress in
significant differences among treatments in the poultry, as reviewed by Freeman [31], Siegel
egg quality characteristics examined in the cur- [32], and Hill [33], may include increases in
rent study (data not shown). Similarly, Alodan circulating levels of corticosterone and suppres-
and Mashaly [28] showed that Zn methods did sion of humoral immunity. In this experiment,
not affect egg quality. McCormick and Cunning- plasma corticosterone levels (mean ± SEM) of
ham [10] also reported that egg quality variables hens in the WB, Zn, and CAL treatments were
and shell breaking strength were not signifi- determined as 3.78 ± 0.16, 4.07 ± 0.13, and 4.71
cantly different between different molting meth- ± 0.19 ng/mL, respectively. The higher (P =
ods (fasting for 10 d and high dietary Zn). 0.001) corticosterone levels in the CAL treat-
Hens in the WB and Zn treatments consumed ment could reflect a period of higher-stress con-
much less feed (P < 0.001) from the 5- to 22- ditions than in the Zn and WB treatments. How-
wk postmolt than hens in the CAL group (Table ever, Keshavarz and Quimby [34] reported that
ONBAŞıLAR AND EROL: MOLTING METHODS AND PERFORMANCE 535
corticosterone levels were not significantly dif- antigen in birds [35]. Nathan et al. [36] showed
ferent among various molting regimens (feed that short-term starvation diminished the re-
withdrawal, continuous corn diet, and feed with- sponse to SRBC. Conversely, Alodan and Mas-
drawal-corn diet groups). haly [28] showed that the different induced molt-
On d 10 and 30 of the experiment, antibody ing programs did not adversely affect antibody
titers to SRBC in the CAL method were signifi- production against SRBC. Some of these differ-
cantly lower than in the other treatments (Table ences may be due to the genetic background of
7). This reduction may be due to the increase in the birds, the different molting programs, or the
circulating levels of corticosterone. Corticoste- use of different suspensions of sheep eryth-
rone can reduce the antibody response to an rocytes.
7. Berry, W. D., and J. Brake. 1987. Post-molt performance of 16. IGH. 1999. IGH type has cross-genetic background between
male of Rhode Island Red and female of GH type. Ankara Poult.
laying hens molted by high dietary zinc, low dietary sodium and
Res. Inst., Ankara, Turkey.
fasting: Egg production and eggshell quality. Poult. Sci. 66:218–226.
17. Davami, A., M. J. Wineland, W. T. Jones, R. L. Ilardi, and
8. Bell, D. D. 2003. Historical and current molting practices in R. A. Peterson. 1987. Effects of population size, floor space, and
the US table egg industry. Poult. Sci. 82:965–970. feeder space upon productive performance, external appearance, and
9. Breeding, S. W., J. Brake, G. D. Garlich, and A. L. Johnson. plasma corticosterone concentration of laying hens. Poult. Sci.
1992. Molt induced by dietary zinc in a low-calcium diet. Poult. Sci. 66:251–257.
71:168–180. 18. AA-13F1 (Gamma-B 125İ Corticosterone). IDS, Bolden, UK.
536 JAPR: Research Report
19. Wallac Wizard, 1479 Model Gamma Counter, Turku, 28. Alodan, M. A., and M. M. Mashaly. 1999. Effect of induced
Finland. molting in laying hens on production and immune parameters. Poult.
Sci. 78:171–177.
20. Onbaşılar, E. E., and T. Aksoy. 2005. Stress parameters and
immune response of layers under different cage floor and density 29. Andrews, D. K., W. D. Berry, and J. Brake. 1987. Effect of
conditions. Livest. Prod. Sci. 95:255–263. lighting program and nutrition on reproductive performance of
molted Single Comb White Leghorn hens. Poult. Sci. 66:1298–1305.
21. AOAC. 2000. Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC Inter-
national. 17th ed. AOAC Int., Gaithersburg, MD. 30. Cunningham, D. L., and C. C. Mccormick. 1985. A multicy-
cle comparison of dietary zinc and feed removal molting procedures:
22. Farese, G., J. L. Schmidt, and M. Mager. 1967. An automated Production and income performance. Poult. Sci. 64:253–260.
method for the determination of serum calcium with glyoxal bis(2-
hydroxyanil). Clin. Chem. 13:515–520. 31. Freeman, B. M. 1987. The stress syndrome. World’s Poult.
Sci. J. 43:15–19.
23. Agricultural Development and Advisory Service. 1981. The
Analysis of Agricultural Materials. 2nd ed. Ministry of Agriculture, 32. Siegel, H. S. 1980. Physiological stress in birds. BioSci.
Fisheries and Food, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London, UK. 30:529–533.
24. Leeson, S., and J. D. Summers. 2001. Nutrition of the 33. Hill, J. A. 1983. Indicators of stress in poultry. World’s Poult.
Chicken. Univ. Books, Guelph, Ontario, Canada. Sci. J. 39:24–32.
25. Dawson, B., and R. G. Trapp. 2001. Basic and Clinical 34. Keshavarz, K., and F. W. Quimby. 2002. An investigation
Biostatistics. 3rd ed. Lange Medical Books, McGraw-Hill Med. Publ. of different molting techniques with an emphasis on animal welfare.
Div., New York, NY. J. App. Poult. Res. 11:54–67.