Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Professional Practice 3 - SPP 206 Research Paper
Professional Practice 3 - SPP 206 Research Paper
Submitted by:
AGSALOG, ANTHONY GABRIEL
AMURAO, GWYNETH LIAREESA
ANGELES, MOIRA JUSTINE
ANTONIO, VHON RUZEL
ARELLANO, AVA RIANNE
BARENA, JAMES REINHART
BARLINAN, HEART KENNETH
BELLAFLOR, KRISLEAN
CAMADING, JOMELANE
CENTENO, ALLEN WALTER
Submitted to:
Ar/EnP Junar P. Tablan, PhD, uap, piep
4Q AY 2023- 2024
June 27, 2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Introduction.............................................................................................................. 2
1. Pre-Design Services.................................................................................................... 2
4. Post-Construction Services......................................................................................... 14
VII. Current Trends Concerning the SPP in the Global and Local Context.................18
Global Context..............................................................................................................18
Local Context............................................................................................................... 18
VIII. Issues and Challenges Concerning the SPP in the Global and Local Context... 19
Global Context..............................................................................................................19
Local Context............................................................................................................... 20
IX. References............................................................................................................ 22
1
I. Introduction
8.2 The idea of Comprehensive Architectural Services evolved over time to meet the
demands of increasingly complex building projects. This shift in the architectural
profession from offering "basic" and "additional" services to a more comprehensive
approach arose from the understanding that continuous services throughout design and
construction are essential for successfully completing a project.
8.4 In this extended dimension, the Architect serves as the primary professional, acting
as the creator, author, and coordinator of the building design, which underpins the
project's construction. To effectively assist and serve the Client, the Architect must also
have knowledge in other fields beyond building design, such as project management and
construction methods. This multidisciplinary expertise ensures the Architect can address
all aspects of the project's development and execution comprehensively.
8.5 The Architect is not expected to carry out all services personally. Instead, they act
as the Client's agent, responsible for procuring and coordinating the various services
needed for the project. This involves identifying and managing specialists and
consultants to ensure all aspects of the project are handled effectively.
2
These preliminary studies involve the procurement, analysis and use of
secondary information gathered for the project to aid the Client in early
decision-making. They represent the Architect’s initial assessment of a project’s
soundness, allowing the Client to promptly explore available/ readily identifiable
directions/ options. Researched/ processed/ validated secondary data are
generally used for such studies e.g. electronic, print, etc.
1.3. Feasibility Studies
Detailed analysis of the project based on pre-feasibility studies will determine the
viability of a proposed development. The studies will set the project against
present and future trends to forecast how it will perform over time. This requires
primary data gathering and analysis.
1.4. Site Selection and Analysis
This entails the formulation of site criteria, assistance to the Client in site
evaluation as well as analysis to determine the most appropriate site/s for a
proposed project or building program.
1.5. Site Utilization and Land-Use Studies
The detailed analysis of the site involves the identification of a site’s development
potentials through the proper utilization of land. The analysis covers the context
of the site as well as that of its surrounding environment and the development
controls that apply to the site and its environs.
1.6. Architectural Research
Architectural research entails the conduct of primary and secondary research and
assembled facts used as basis for conclusion.
1.7. Architectural Programming
This analytical problem-seeking process will lead to the statement and
identification of both horizontal and vertical requirements in offering a solution. It
incorporates a space program with characterizations of the envisioned spaces
such as ambiance, cost range, etc.
1.8. Space Planning
The Architect determines the adequate size and appropriate configuration and
assemblage for a proposed project in consideration of the use, allocation and
interface of spaces for given activities. Space planning is done mainly through
primary data gathering such as interviews, consultations, interfaces, focus group
discussions (FGDs), space planning surveys, space audits, etc. and subsequent
analyses i.e. spatial layouts with stacking concepts, particularly for multi-storey
structures.
1.9. Space Management Studies
An analysis of the space requirements of the project based on organizational
structure and functional set-up pinpoints linkages and interaction of spaces. The
formulation of the space program will serve as the basis for the development of
the architectural plan/design.
1.10. Value Management
3
This technique is applied in the cost management process to minimize the
negative effect of simplified operations associated with many cost-reduction
programs. The goal of value management is to achieve an unimpaired program
at minimum cost. Thus, a plan, design or system that has been successfully
value-managed will still satisfy the same performance criteria as the costlier
alternatives.
1.11. Design Brief Preparation
Under design brief preparation, the Architect states the project terms of
reference (ToR) including the concept, objectives and other necessary
requirements to bid out architectural services (whether public or private).
1.12. Promotional Services
Projects may require promotional activities in order to develop and generate
financial support and acceptance from governing agencies or from the general
public. In such cases, the Architect can act as the agent of the Owner by
producing and coordinating the additional activities necessary to complete the
services. In all such activities, the Architect must maintain his professional status
as the representative of the Owner.
4
9.2.3 Design Development Phase
The initial conceptual designs are refined into detailed plans, elevations, sections, and
other drawings. During this stage, architects work closely with engineers and consultants to
integrate structural, mechanical, electrical, and sanitary systems into the design. Detailed
drawings and specifications are produced, outlining materials, finishes, and construction
methods. Updated SPPCC is also submitted to the owner.
9.2.4 Contract Documents Phase
The Architect compiles comprehensive Contract Documents, including detailed designs
and construction drawings covering architectural, structural, electrical, sanitary, mechanical,
electronic, and communication systems. Technical specifications are prepared detailing material
types, quality, construction methods, and project conditions. Seven sets of these documents are
required and provided to the Owner to be able to obtain a building permit. Additionally, the
Architect updates the Schedule of Project Construction Costs (SPPCC) to reflect scope changes,
requirements adjustments, or market condition updates. The Architect also supports the Owner
in submitting necessary documents for securing approval from relevant government authorities
overseeing the Project's design.
9.2.5 Bidding or Negotiation Phase
During the bidding and negotiation phase, the Architect facilitates the selection of a
Contractor for the project. They prepare comprehensive Bid Documents, including contract
forms, construction documents, and instructions for prospective bidders. The Architect assists
the Owner in organizing pre-bid conferences, responding to bidder inquiries, and evaluating
submitted proposals. For competitive bidding, the Architect ensures that Bid Documents are
distributed to potential bidders and manages the process to ensure fairness and compliance
with regulations. In negotiated contracts, the Architect negotiates directly with a selected
Contractor, aiming to reach agreement on terms, scope, and pricing that align with the project's
goals and requirements.
5
9.3.3 Architectural Lighting Layout and Design
6
● Architectural services that include initial phases of project development such as site
analysis, space planning, architectural programming, and feasibility studies. These
services lay the groundwork for subsequent design and construction phases.
7
● Management and operational aspects of running an architectural practice, including
office operations, financial management, legal compliance, marketing, project
development, contract administration, and business process management.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 For the past 50 years, four principal members were involved in the design and building
construction process:
1.1.2 The Architect and his Specialist Consultants (SCs) who render plan / design services and
limited inspection work;
1.1.4 The individual or group of individuals who assist in the supervision and delivery of the
work.
1.3 When projects were still manageable in size, the Architect was then assisted by a
construction inspector, traditionally called Clerk-of-Works. As projects became more complex, it
became necessary for a construction supervision group to do the full-time inspection at the
project site.
1.4 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) is normally recommended by the Architect
based on their performance, and hired by the Owner. They are answerable to both the Owner
and Architect.
2. SCOPE OF SERVICES
8
2.3 Preparation of Daily Inspection Reports
There are two ways by which the Architect may enter into contract with the Owner:
3.1 Working in a dual capacity as Architect-of-record and as Consulting Architect for fulltime
supervision services or as the Construction Supervision Group (CSG). As the Architect-of-record
(Aor) of the project, the Aor is in a better position to interpret his drawings and documents and
to assure conformity by the Contractor. He can assign his staff to undertake the fulltime
supervisory work to perform the works as enumerated in the Architect’s Guidelines.
3.2 Working as Consulting Architect for fulltime supervision services only or as the CSG.
4. METHOD OF COMPENSATION
The Architect’s compensation is based on the Architect’s / architectural firm’s talents, skill,
experience, and on the type and level of professional services provided. Compensation for
Fulltime Supervision Services may be based on one or more of the following:
The Architect’s Fee for Fulltime Supervision as based on the PPC shall be detailed in the
Architect’s Guidelines.
The multiplier ranges from 1.5 to 2.5 depending on the office set-up, overhead and experience
of the Architect and the complexity of the Project.
9
Other items such as cost of transportation, living and housing allowances of foreign consultants,
out-of-town living and housing allowances of the local consultants and the like, are all to be
charged to the Client. At the start of the commission, the Architect shall make known to the
Client the rate of professionals and personnel who will be assigned to the Project and the
multiplier that has to be applied before agreeing on this method of compensation.
FORMULA
Assume:
T= Rate per hour of Technical Staff, Inspectors and others involved in the Project
AN, CN, TN = No. of hours spent by Architect, Consultants and Technical Staff
M = Multiplier to account for overhead and reasonable profit. The value may range from 1.5
to 2.5 depending on the set-up of the Architect’s office and the complexity of the Project.
Cost of printing of extra set of drawings, reports, maps, contract documents, etc. over the
seven (7) copies submitted to the Client, overseas and long distance calls, technical and
laboratory tests, licenses, fees, taxes and similar cost items needed by the Project.
Direct cost = AN + CN + TN
This method of compensation is frequently used where there is continuing relationship involving
a series of projects. It establishes a fixed sum over and above the reimbursement for the
Architect’s technical time and overhead. An agreement on the general scope of the work is
necessary in order to set an equitable fee.
10
4.4 Lump Sum or Fixed Fee
This method may be applied to government projects since they entail more paper work and
time-consuming efforts.
In some cases a Client may request an Architect to do work which will require his personal time
such as:
3.1.3 conferring with others regarding prospective investments or ventures and the like.
For these particular activities, the Architect as agent of the Owner may be paid on a per diem
and honorarium basis plus out-of-pocket expenses such as but not limited to travel,
accommodations and subsistence.
The SPP provides for more than one method of compensation on a project. Each project should
be examined to determine the most appropriate method of compensation.
5. LIMITATION OF AUTHORITY
5.1 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG), which may be a qualified architectural firm,
or which the Architect is only part of, shall not assume the responsibility of the Contractor’s
project superintendent.
5.2 The CSG shall not make decisions on matters that are the sole responsibility of the
Architect-of-record (Aor).
6. LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY
6.1 The Construction Supervision Group (CSG) is responsible to the Owner only for
administrative matters. For technical matters, the CSG is responsible to the Architect-of-record
(Aor).
6.2 Under Article 1723 of the present Civil Code, the CSG may appear not to have any legal
responsibility since the Architect-of-record (Aor) and Engineers-of-record (Eors) are responsible
11
for the design while the Contractor is responsible for the construction. However, a Service
Contract / Agreement between the CSG and the Owner may stipulate certain professional
responsibilities and civil liabilities of the CSG, particularly if the CSG is party to the review of the
Contract Documents and their subsequent evaluation and interpretation during the course of
construction.
6.3 If the Aor (and Eors) and the Contractor are sued by an Owner for civil liabilities due to
the performance or non-performance of certain acts traceable to the CSG, the Aor and Eors may
file cross claims against the CSG.
7. QUALIFICATIONS
Inspectors of the Construction Supervision Group (CSG) must have the ff:
7.2 Extensive experience in design and building construction and must be very
knowledgeable in building materials and construction detailing.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Due to the increasing complexity of construction projects, there is an upward demand
for more effective cost control and faster project implementation consistent with high quality of
work. Construction Management Services were thus instituted to fill this need in the
construction industry.
1.2.3 a firm hired by the Owner to manage the construction of a particular project.
1.3 The Architect can serve as the Construction Manager (CM). His training in the
coordination of various specialties allows him to supervise and assure proper monitoring of all
construction activities with regards to quality, workmanship and cost.
12
2.1 The responsibilities of the Construction Manager (CM) include the functions of the
Construction Supervision Group (CSG). (reference Doc. 204-A and Architect’s Guidelines)
2.2 The Construction Manager (CM) may hire the CSG to be under his employ or may
supervise the CSG hired directly by the Owner.
3. LIMITATION OF AUTHORITY
3.1 involve himself directly with the work of the Contractor such that it may be construed that
he is assuming the Contractor’s liability as provided for in Article 1723, etc. of the Civil Code.
3.2 Impose methods, systems or designs that will substantially affect the construction schedule
and impair the design concept of the Architect.
4. LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY
4.1 The Architect as the Construction Manager (CM) is directly responsible to the Owner on
all aspects of the construction work: programming, coordination, quality and cost control and
time management.
4.2 The CM assumes no liability in case equipment fail to function or if a portion of the
building collapses:
4.2.1 due to deficiencies in the plan / design, provided the CM did not participate in the plan /
design review and approval, or
4.2.2 due to the deficiencies in the manner of construction, provided the CM faithfully
discharged his function/s during the construction / project implementation.
5. QUALIFICATIONS
13
5.1 The individual or the principal of the firm must be a State-regulated professional,
preferably an Architect with managerial capabilities and extensive experience in the field of
construction. The Architect must be a Registered and Licensed Architects (RLA), with an
updated professional identification card and must be a member in good standing of the
Integrated and Accredited Professional Organization of Architects (IAPOA).
5.2 Architects who are Contractors or who have already been in responsible charge of
construction works are usually capable of becoming Construction Managers (CMs).
6. METHOD OF COMPENSATION
6.1 Since construction management is not part of the regular services of the Architect, the
services rendered by the Architect as a Construction Manager (CM) shall be separately
compensated.
4. Post-Construction Services
Introduction
1.1 Building administration and management goes beyond maintenance and upkeep
functions. It requires the services of a multi-disciplinary professional who can perform a wide
range of functions for the efficient and economical operation and maintenance of a building,
facility or a complex.
1.2 In Post-Construction Services, the channels of communication are kept open among the
building owners, operators, architects, engineers, builders, manufacturers, building research
groups, utility providers, furniture and equipment vendors and building administrators/ property
managers to provide access to information regarding the performance and upkeep of buildings.
1.3 The Architect may be engaged as the Building Administrator and/or Property Manager of
a commercial, industrial, residential or institutional building, facility or complex to maximize the
lifespan of the building/s in order to produce the maximum economic return.
SCOPE OF SERVICES
a. see to it that the building and all the parts thereof (structure, plumbing, electrical,
partitions, finishes, etc.) are all in good condition.
14
b. formulate and enforce rules for the proper use of the building and facility, particularly in
the common areas and the emergency/ egress/ exit areas.
c. monitor security services, and
d. monitor maintenance and upkeep services (cleanliness of corridors, lobbies, stairs and
other common areas, exits, parking areas, garbage collection)
The Architect may enter into contract with the Owner in two possible ways:
15
METHOD OF COMPENSATION
10.1 The Architect, by virtue of their education and training, can provide various services as
outlined in Section 2. When the Architect or a firm is hired to oversee the entire scope of
Comprehensive Architectural Services (CAS), it is considered Project Management (PM).
10.2 Project Management (PM) encompasses management activities that go beyond typical
architectural and engineering (A&E) services during the pre-design, design, and construction
phases, with the primary goal of controlling time, cost, and quality in the construction project.
10.3 Having a PM does not absolve designers and contractors of their usual duties and
responsibilities in the project. Instead, the PM supports the roles of Architects, Engineers, and
Contractors to meet the extensive and intricate demands of the project.
16
4.2.2 Construction Phase
In a situation where the Project Manager (PM) is also the hired
Construction Manager, the Project Manager (PM) must provide the services listed
in SPP Documents 204-4 and/or 204-B
12.1 Normally, the Owner and the Architect sign a contract for the Architect to provide
full architectural services. He takes on the dual responsibilities of the Project Manager
(PM) and the Construction Manager (CM) by the nature of the services provided, which
essentially make him the overall coordinator whose duties are defined in this SPP.
12.2 The architect must utilize both his own skills and the services of other experts to
the fullest extent possible in order to complete the range of services listed under the
Comprehensive Architectural Services. He could could hire the experts that are required
or create a team with professionals like but not limited to:
● Architects
● Engineers
● Market Analysts
● Accountants
● General Contractors
● Real Estate Consultants
● Sociologists
● Planners
● Bankers
● Lawyers
12.3 In the event that the Owner hires a Project Manager (PM), the PM may be required
to appoint a Construction Manager (CM), who will be paid either directly by the Owner
or by the PM on a salary basis, or he may be required to act as the CM himself. Likewise,
the Fulltime Supervisor may be employed directly by the Owner or as a member of the
PM's team.
13.2 If the Architect as Project Manager (PM) performs regular design services for the
same project, he shall be compensated separately for these services as stipulated in SPP
Document 202.
17
VII. Current Trends Concerning the SPP in the Global and Local Context
Global Context
1. Principles of Professionalism
Expertise, Autonomy, Commitment and Accountability are some of the principles
recommended by the Union International des Architectes (2017) in their
legislation, focusing on providing a high degree of integrity, competence and
professionalism for Architects.
2. Intellectual Property
The International Union of Architects (Union Internationale des Architectes / UIA
,2017) recommends further Intellectual Property Protection for Architecture to
include ideas spoken to with clients, so as to protect the profession without
detriment to their responsibility, all while retaining ownership of their work.
3. Introduction of a Managerial Group for Architecture
The UIA encourages countries to design and create regulatory bodies whose
purpose is to promote and protect the interests of architects, suggesting
adherence to the UNESCO-UIA requirements, UIA International standards and
International Code of Ethics and Conduct.
4. Building Project Delivery Systems
The International standards for the responsibilities and services provided by the
Architect are important and thus the Architects should maintain a high degree of
service and professionalism
5. Sustainability and Green Architecture
They are guiding architects in designing energy-efficient buildings with
environmentally friendly materials and water-saving technologies. Comprehensive
Architectural Services includes managing construction to meet green building
standards and ensuring buildings operate efficiently with monitoring systems for
energy use and indoor quality. Emphasizing adaptability and resilience, CAS aims
to create lasting structures that meet current and future environmental
challenges while promoting occupant well-being.
Local Context
1. Competition in a growing industry
In a study by Duran et al., (2015), the construction industry is mentioned to be
rapidly growing - resulting in architects competing with each other for business.
On one scenario, even allied disciplines are considered as potential competitors
rather than partnering as allies; Engineers are more preferred by clients and
easily win over more projects due to the lack of understanding of the services
and design processes of an architect.
2. Unfaithful Adherence to Laws and Standards
18
In a study by Duran et al., (2015), the proponents interviewed architects, whom
most turned out to be government employees. The proponents mentioned that
despite the fact that the interviewees are not allowed to practice other
professions outside of their jobs, they still do; On another case, the proponents
mentioned that there are certain times when an Architect has to make
adjustments - though these may or may not be moral and legal.
3. AI in Architecture
Starting with Computer-Aided Design (CAD) and moving on to Building
Information Modeling (BIM). Today, AI-driven platforms are taking the industry
further by automating time-consuming tasks, enhancing collaboration, and
offering real-time analysis for sustainable and efficient design solutions. As we
witness this technological progress, architects and designers embrace AI’s
potential to positively impact the built environment, paving the way for a
brighter, more sustainable future in the architectural realm.
4. Technology
Adoption of new technologies: The architecture industry is increasingly
embracing technologies like virtual reality, augmented reality, and building
information modeling (BIM) to enhance the design, construction, and
management of buildings. These tools allow for more immersive visualization,
improved coordination, and more efficient construction processes.
5. Adaptive Reuse of Buildings
A growing appreciation for Philippine heritage in architecture. Architects are
finding ways to blend traditional Filipino elements with modern design principles,
creating buildings that are both forward-looking and rooted in history.
VIII. Issues and Challenges Concerning the SPP in the Global and Local Context
SPP Document 206 outlines the standards of professional practice for architects, aiming
to ensure consistent and high-quality architectural services. However, both global and
local contexts present unique challenges and issues in implementing and adhering to
these standards.
Global Context
19
2. Cross-Cultural Collaboration
Cross-cultural collaboration presents the challenge of managing projects with
multicultural teams and diverse stakeholders, requiring effective communication
and cooperation across different cultural contexts to ensure project success.
3. Sustainability and Environmental Concerns
Integrating global sustainability standards and environmental regulations
presents the challenge of balancing environmental concerns with practical and
economic considerations, which can vary significantly across different regions.
4. Ignorance of an Architect's Scope of Service
Individuals who fail to recognize the significance and breadth of an architect's
engagement frequently overlook the intricate and multifaceted role that
architects play in ensuring the success of a project. Architects are not simply
designers of aesthetically pleasing structures; they serve as critical
problem-solvers who guarantee that a building is functional, safe, and adheres to
all applicable codes and regulations. They harmoniously integrate the technical
aspects of engineering with the artistry of design, meticulously considering the
needs of the client, the constraints of the site, and the realities of budget and
time constraints.
Local Context
1. Regulatory Compliance
Local building laws and ordinances have a big influence on how architects
practice their craft. It can be difficult to fulfill international standards and adhere
to these local requirements at the same time. Professional practices must be
updated on a regular basis due to changes in local regulations, which are
frequently impacted by political and economic considerations (Enriquez, 2019).
2. Resource Availability
Resource availability poses a significant challenge in accessing essential
materials, skilled labor, and advanced technology necessary for construction
projects. This variability can directly impact project timelines and costs, as delays
in obtaining materials, shortages of skilled workers, and limited access to
necessary technology can lead to increased expenses and extended project
durations.
3. Client Expectations
Managing diverse client expectations and requirements involves the challenge of
tailoring project management approaches to meet specific client needs while still
adhering to SPP 206 guidelines, ensuring both client satisfaction and compliance.
4. House Bill 10234: To Elevate or to Undermine the Practice
20
The article discusses House Bill 10234 in the Philippines, which aims to reform
the architecture profession and has sparked significant controversy. Architects
and students are concerned that the bill could undermine professional standards
by allowing non-architects on the regulatory board, complicating licensure, and
exempting small projects from needing licensed architects. They fear this could
lower the quality of architecture. However, the bill's proponents are open to
revisions, and a Technical Working Group will address these issues to refine the
legislation.
21
IX. References
Duran, F. C., Manalastas, C., Ilan, J., Espina, Ma. R., Bayot, G. K. L., Zacarias, R. J., &
Reytas, W. R. (2015). A Study on the Actual Architecture Practice vs. the
Standards of Professional Practice. Eastern Visayas State University.
22