Advertising and older consumers

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Volume 9 Number 1 January 2000

Advertising and older


consumers: image and ageism
Marylyn Carrigan and Isabelle Szmigin

'Our generation are the new old. I remember what influential younger viewer market' (ITV 1998).
someone of 60 looked like when I was a kid. They Older people are clearly not seen as 'influential' by
didn't look like me.' (Jack Nicholson, actor, aged the advertising industry, and as research shows,
61 years, 1998) this is reflected in the attitudes and behaviour that
advertisers display towards older consumers
Cher, Cliff Richard, Jane Asher, David Bowie,
(Long 1998, Miller 1993, Thomas and Wolfe
Vivienne Westwood, Joanna Lumley, and the
1995, Corlett 1998). But this focus does not
ubiquitous Jack Nicholson all have one thing in
adequately reflect 'real life'. Demographic and
common apart from their celebrity status - they
economic changes in society are signalling a
are all aged over fifty years. None of these celebri-
growth in incidence and importance of the 'Baby
ties conform to the stereotype of decrepit old age,
Boomer' generation represented by the over-
and many others in society today who are over
fifties. By 2021, 33% of the UK population will
fifty are very unlike the commonly-held image of
be over 55 {Social Trends 1997). Estimates suggest
older people. Healthier diets, improved life ex-
that the over 45s have nearly 80% of all financial
pectancy and a widespread desire to feel younger
wealth in the UK, and are responsible for 30% of
for longer has developed a cognitively younger
consumer spending, and similar figures can be
mindset among those who may be considered by
found in Canada and the USA (Long 1998).
some to be chronologically in their dotage.
Ageism is particularly endemic in a media that A key issue that advertisers need to grasp is that
is obsessed with the Holy Grail of youth. Minette there is a difference between the over-fifties of
Marrin (1998), commenting in the Daily Telegraph today and those of previous generations. Past
states, 'For as long as I can remember, everyone in experience is not a predictor of the consumer
the media has been obsessed with getting a bigger behaviour of this new generation of over-fifties,
slice of "yoof ... But why? What is wrong with yet traditional prejudices against ageing persist,
the older market? It is enormous, and getting and culturally ingrained stereotypes continue to
bigger all the time, for the young get older every work against the older consumer in the minds of
day'. Joanna Lumley has also commented on this advertisers. One of the areas where this ageism is
youth mania (Rampton 1998). 'I'm 52 and I don't most prevalent is in the use of older models in
feel past it ... there must be millions like me not advertising. Older models are either non-existent
catered for by television. It's this obsession with in mainstream advertising, or they are depicted in
youth ... but the people with the most disposable inappropriate and stereotypical ways.
income are actually 60 and over'.
These concerns are not without foundation. A
recent brief for the ITV Advertising Education The advertising industry and ageism
Award for 1998/99 specifically seeks ways of
attracting 'young more upmarket viewers to Studies in the USA, Canada and the UK support
maintain its dominant position in the important the view that the advertising industry is guilty of

© Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000. 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 lJF, UK
42 and 350 Main St, Maiden, MA 02148, USA.
Business Ethics: A European Review

ageism in a number of ways (Long 1998, Roberts feeling that age is bad for business' (Knight 1998).
and Zhou 1997, Zhou and Chen 1992, Carrigan The message is that 'oldness' in itself is not a state
and Szmigin 1998a, 1998b). One source of the to be encouraged. Most advertising containing
problem is the advertising executives themselves. images of older people tends to depict them as
The average age of most advertising executives is either youthful, or as caricatures, rather than as
below fifty years, and many researchers have legitimate members of society.
commented on the lack of empathy this seems to The advertising agency business is a huge
create with the over-fifties population (Flanagan industry, and must take equal responsibility along
1994, Greco 1989, Bedell 1998, Tregeur 1998). with advertisers and the media for the ethicality
Nick Long of Market Behaviour Ltd, found that of advertising (Murphy 1998). A recent Pontifical
advertising executives under 30 were profoundly Council monograph on ethics in advertising raised
uninterested in understanding the over-fifties, and several important moral issues (Murphy 1998).
that their views and associations were largely Three key moral principles are cited upon which
based on stereotypes of decrepitude, imbecility advertising should be based: truthfulness, dignity
and physical repugnance (Long 1998). of the human person, and social responsibility.
Many of these advertisers harbour the belief The current attitudes of those in the advertising
that older people do not like to see older models in field towards older people, and the insignificance
advertisements, hence the removal of Jane Asher with which they are treated suggests that those
from the McVities biscuit campaigns, and Joanna involved with advertising are not respecting their
Lumley from the Muller yoghurt campaigns, both duty to uphold the dignity of this generation of
of whom were felt to be too old at 'fiftysome- people.
thing' (Anon. 1997, Deevoy 1998). Yet in the In today's society, advertising has a profound
recent Prime Time Survey by IPC Magazines impact upon the way that people understand life,
(1998) it was found that 62% of older women especially with regard to their values, and their
prefer to see women their own age in advertise- ways of choosing and behaving (Laczniak 1998).
ments. However advertisers continue to believe There is a particular moral imperative for the
that the presence of older people in advertisements advertising industry to be a constructive force in
will alienate their most important audience - the the community, and to respect persons, particu-
youth market (Thomas and Wolfe 1995, Deutsch larly those who are vulnerable, such as older
et al. 1986, Mazis et al. 1992). This belief has never people (Laczniak 1998). In the end, those who
been fully substantiated, and there is research commission, prepare or disseminate advertising
evidence to suggest that younger audiences view are all morally responsible for what they do. Yet,
older models at the very least neutrally, even as Murphy (1998) states, between the 'unholy
positively in many product advertisements trinity' of the media, advertisers and agencies no
(Gubernick 1996, Greco et al. 1997, Milliman one seems willing to accept primary responsibility
and Erffmeyer 1990, Day and Stafford 1997). for raising ethical standards. The consequence of
When the industry does make use of older this is that ethics in advertising generally is
models, these tend to be physically young and perceived to be rather low. The ethical position
attractive in appearance. Pearl Bailey (aged 56) in of advertising in relation to the treatment of older
her uplift bra for Age Concern, Josephine (aged people is particularly unacceptable.
79) in her Levi jeans, and Diana Moran (aged 50)
for Oil of Ulay all conform to this pattern. This
implies that old age is only acceptable in advertis- Print advertising and older consumers
ing if you don't actually appear to be old. Fay
Weldon, the celebrated author, admitted under- Research carried out by the authors confirms that
going her facelift in her fifties as a result of older models are not popular with mainstream
pressure upon her to look better in her book advertisers. Two studies examined the use of older
advertisements. 'It was about image, and also the models in print advertising; firstly in the Daily

© Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000 43


Volume 9 Number 1 January 2000

Mail, Daily Telegraph, Good Housekeeping and


Table 2: Readership profile of 50+ publications
Woman's Journal, all of which have a large per-
centage of over-fifties readers, and secondly, in Pubiication % readership aged 50+
Choice, Saga, Goodtimes and Active Life which are Choice 56%
specifically targeted at over-fifties readers. Saga 84%
Goodtimes 100%
Active Life 100%
Source: National Readership Surveys October 1996-
Table 1: Readership profile of mainstream publications September1997, Active Life (1998), ARP050 (1998).

Publication % readership aged 50+

Daily Mail (weekdays) 50


Daily Telegraph (weekdays) 51 Although in most cases the portrayal of older
Good Housekeeping 41 people was seen as favourable, it was evident that
Woman's Journal 55 the majority of advertisements were for disability
aids, and products which helped older people
Source: National Readership Surveys October 1996-
September1997. overcome infirmity (included in the 'Property-
interiors' category in Table 5).
This research echoes the findings of similar
studies in the US and Canada which confirmed a
We found that the percentage of 50+ models tendency for older models to be under-represented,
appearing in the mainstream publications was well and/or portrayed as debilitated (IPC Magazines
below that of the number of over-fifties in the UK 1998, Roberts and Zhou 1997, Zhou and Chen
population. On the other hand, the number of 1992, Peterson 1992, 1995). The respondents in the
50+ models appearing in advertisements in the IPC Magazines study stated that it was rather
over-fifties publications was far higher, and more depressing that many advertisers assumed that
representative of the UK population as a whole. people over fifty had a disabihty, and that so

Table 3: Comparative percentages of 50+ adults in UK population; readership figures and advertisements,
mainstream pubiications

Percentage of 50+ adults in UK Percentage of 50+ aduits in Percentage of 50+ adults in test
population 1995 readership (average of all) advertisements

25% 49%

Source: Office of Population, Censuses and Surveys (1996).

Table 4: Comparative percentages of 50+ adults !n UK popuiation; readership figures and advertisements, 50+
publications

Percentage of 50+ adults in UK Percentage of 50+ aduits in Percentage of 50+ adults in test
popuiation 1995 readership (average of all) advertisements

25% 85% 70%

Source: Office of Population, Censuses and Surveys (1996).

44 © Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000


Business Ethics: A European Review

Table 5: Product category of advertisements featuring 50+ models

Product category % featuring 50+ models/ % featuring 50+ models/


Mainstream media 50+ media
Alcohol 0 0
Cameras 0 0
Cars 0 0
Clothing 3 2
Diet Aids 0 0
Entertainment 6 0
Financial Services 6 27
Food 14 2
Health and Medicine 14 16
Homes/Estate Agents 3 0
Household appliances 19 4
Household Goods 0 0
IT (computers etc.) 0 2
Jewellery 0 0
Media 0 0
Personal Care 8 0
Property - gardens 0 2
Property - interiors 0 33
Society 8 4
Sports Goods 0 0
Tobacco 0 0
Travel and holidays 16 8
Total 100% 100%

many advertisements were fixated with infirmity i.e. that advertisers have preconceived ideas about
rather than portraying older people as able-bodied. what is, and what is not suitable for older people
Not only are older people not used very often in to advertise. Not surprisingly, there was enthusi-
mainstream advertising, there are also a very limited asm for the use of older models in advertisements
number of products that older people are con- for health and medicine, holidays and financial
sidered suitable to advertise. This echoes what services, but definite rejection of depicting older
Nick Long (1998) found when one of his respon- people in advertisements for clothing, cars, jew-
dents commented, 'We go and shop for washing ellery or cosmetics. This demarcation appears to
powder just like them (i.e. younger consumers) but be based on the belief of advertisers that older
they never show anybody our age'. We decided to people are happier to see models ten to fifteen
explore this more closely by questioning UK years younger than they are, and on the desire not
advertising executives on the subject. The agency to alienate younger consumers of these products.
executives were asked to indicate if they would As Rachel Miller (1998) pointed out in her article
recommend the use of an older character as a questioning the wisdom of the 'adman's thinking',
central figure in advertising for various product 'In the world of advertising, the over-50's have
classes, assuming that a client wished to target an their place. They drink tea but never touch soft
older audience. The responses confirmed what we drinks, don't eat crisps or chocolate ... don't
had already suspected from our previous research. shave and therefore have no need for aftershave

© Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000 45


Volume 9 Number 1 January 2000

... but they're pretty good at calling their friends achieved by a process which creates negative
and family'. consequences for other stakeholders (deontologi-
cal criteria). To enable marketers and advertisers
to make decisions, elements of both these philos-
The ethical implications of ageism in ophies need to be incorporated into ethical
advertising frameworks which encourage people to consider
both the effects of carrying out their decision (the
Any organisation today needs to maintain public means) as well as the consequences of that
confidence in the legitimacy and integrity of their decision (the ends). Ross (1930) suggests that the
operations and business conduct. To undermine behaviour of individuals and organisations should
this 'licence to operate' by behaving in an un- observe six fundamental moral principles, termed
acceptable manner exposes an organisation to a the six 'prima facie' duties. These are the moral
range of sanctions from the public. Companies duty of honesty and exactitude, the duty of
which fail to accept responsibility for their actions gratitude, the duty of justice, the duty of charity,
risk a host of punitive reactions - consumer the duty of self-improvement, and finally the duty
boycott, regulation, media hostihty, financial loss, not to cause harm to others (Nantel and Weeks
and above all loss of reputation which surrenders 1996). According to Garrett (1966) any moral
the initiative to competitors. Marketing has come decision involves three elements: what we intend,
under particularly close scrutiny in recent years how we carry out the intention, and what
with regard to its public responsibilities due to happens. Marketers and advertisers must there-
its high visibility (Laczniak and Murphy 1985, fore concern themselves with their intention, their
Nantel and Weeks 1996, Malhotra and Miller action and the consequences of that action.
1998, Smith and Quelch 1993). Laczniak (1983) presents a framework that
Advertising as the most visible form of market- incorporates both Garrett's (1966) and Ross's
ing is a particular target for criticism. A range of (1930) theories, and attempts as they do, to
high profile abuses - shock advertising, as approach ethics in both a utilitarian and deonto-
employed by Benetton, sexist advertising by logical manner. If an advertiser or marketer can
Wonderbra - has raised public awareness, and answer the following questions negatively, then
today the level of sensitivity exhibited by certain the action is probably ethical.
advertising professionals is being questioned.
Most marketers feel obliged to fulfil their legal (i) Does action A violate the law?
responsibilities; for instance, they will avoid using (ii) Does action A violate any general moral
images and portrayals in advertisements, which obligations?
are against the law, such as racist stereotypes. • duties of fidelity?
However, duty weakens in the face of their less • duties of gratitude?
tangible ethical responsibilities. Yet the line • duties of justice?
between ethical and legal responsibilities is not • duties of beneficence?
immutable; in fact, it is often only a matter of time • duties of self-improvement?
before ethical responsibilities become encapsu- • duties of nonmaleficence?
lated in legislation. Public opinion often recog- (iii) Does action A violate any special obliga-
nises ethical responsibilities before the legal or tions stemming from the type of marketing
regulatory system acts, and many people expect organisation in question?
organisations to embrace these newly emerging (iv) Is the intent of action an evil?
values. (v) Are any major evils likely to result from, or
Advertisers today need to make decisions because of action A?
concerning what is 'right' or 'responsible' to do. (vi) Is a satisfactory alternative B, which pro-
Although everyone wants to satisfy their custo- duces equal or more good with less evil than
mers (utilitarian criteria), this should not be A, being knowingly rejected?

46 © Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000


Business Ethics: A European Review

(vii) Does action A infringe on the inalienable A new age for old age: can we move
rights of the consumer? forward?
(viii) Does action A leave another person or
group less well off? Does advertising reflect the values of individuals
(ix) Is this person or group already relatively in society, or is it responsible for creating and
under-privileged? influencing those values? It is surely naive to
suggest that advertising is merely a 'source of
The major purpose of the framework is as a purchase-related information to consumers' (Zhou
pedagogical tool to sensitise marketing pro- and Chen 1992). Advertising is a means of social
fessionals to the factors that are important in communication (Leiss et al. 1990), and plays a
dealing with issues of responsibility. As Nantel significant role in the socialisation process by
and Weeks (1996) point out, the advantage of the providing visual symbolic models for learning how
framework is that it is both functional and simple. to behave (Langmeyer 1993). Past research into
If we take the action of 'portraying older people race and gender role models has demonstrated the
as comical or infirm caricatures', and apply the importance of advertising in influencing social
framework, we can see where ethical dilemmas relationships both positively and negatively
may arise. For example, we know that no laws are (Langmeyer 1993, Hess 1974). Advertising exerts
being violated, and there may be no evil intended, a significant impact on consumers' lives (Pollay
but can we be certain that no evils may result 1986); on the positive side, advertising has dis-
from the action? Advertisements create negative couraged participation in harmful behaviours and
opinions of old age among society, and older encouraged participation in socially beneficial
people themselves. Negative portrayals of older behaviours; on the negative side, advertising has
people are not the only way to use older people misled and deceived consumers (Davis 1994).
in advertising, and so there are satisfactory The United Nations International Year of Older
alternatives, which would produce equal good Persons (1999) is the culmination of the United
with less evil, yet these are being rejected. There is Nations action programme on ageing. Initiated in
no doubt that by their actions, advertisers are recognition of the growing population of older
leaving older people as a group within society people worldwide, it aims to promote 'a transition
less well off, because their advertisements serve to a positive, active and developmentally oriented
to perpetuate ageism. A recent designer jean view of ageing ... a society for all ages ... possibili-
advertisement used a black and white photograph ties of a new age for old age' (United Nations 1995).
of a glum-looking older couple, semi-naked on a The UN's guiding principles for the International
parkbench with the caption 'Age doesn't improve Year of Older Persons state that there should be a
everything'. When this advertisement was criti- positive, active and developmentally oriented view
cised as being undignified and mocking, the action of ageing. Unfortunately, many depictions of
was defended by saying the intention was to be older people in advertising achieve the opposite
humorous. Humorous to whom? Perhaps an effect. The negative and stereotypical representa-
eighteen-year-old might consider this humorous, tions of older people by many advertisers actively
but is it really necessary to ridicule older people in harm both the self-perception of older people, and
order to communicate humour to younger con- the attitudes of the rest of society towards older
sumers? Contrast this example with the recent people. As with gender and race, how older people
Nike advertisement which pictured an older, are featured in advertising has implications for the
female athlete with the copy line 'I am a thorn social and psychological well-being of the elderly.
in time's side'. Both were advertisements for Smith et al. (1984) found that advertisements
products bought by young people; both featured provided expectational messages to older people
older people. It is not difficult to see which about their behaviour. The negative portrayal of
advertiser has recognised their ethical responsi- older people in advertising negatively affects their
bilities and which has not. self-perception as well as wider societal attitudes

© Blackwell Publishers Lid. 2000 47


Volume 9 Number 1 January 2000

towards older people (Swayne and Greco 1987, commented, "I suggest that we could begin ... by
Zhou and Chen 1992, Langmeyer 1993). bolstering the image of older people in the media
Advertising, when called upon to defend itself ... the image of older people as full, useful and
against accusations of discrimination or negativ- active citizens must become implanted in the
ity, often makes the argument that the images it popular imagination". Already in the United
shows are society's construct, and that ageism States, ]V[odern IVTaturity magazine and the
itself is socially constructed (Featherstone and American Association of Retired Persons (AARP)
Hepworth 1995, Chaney 1995, Vincent 1995). have recognised the implications of the number
Society arbitrarily imposes the rules of retirement, of 'infirmity' related advertisements being placed
retirement represents a loss of function and in age-specific media and have developed a set of
income, and when coupled with consumer culture advertising guidelines to screen them out. In
images of youth, fitness and beauty lifestyles, the particular, they will only accept advertisements
result is a new set of exclusions for older people. which do not 'foster stereotypes and which
Through a variety of mass media images, audi- accomplish that purpose without making a nega-
ences are encouraged to see being young as strong, tive statement about ageing' (AARP 1998). When
independent and sexy (Chaney 1995).. In contrast, questioned, it became clear that none of the UK
ageing is necessarily unattractive, tending to be publications in the studies followed any other
characterised by images that are the converse of guidelines beyond the British Code of Advertising
strength, independence and sexiness. Practice, which although containing clauses
The images of mass media are a cultural against discrimination on the grounds of race,
resource, and they provide important evidence of sex, religion or disability, makes no reference to
the kinds of cultural resources a specific society discrimination on the grounds of age.
draws upon to give meaning to later life. Images, There is much that the advertising industry can
therefore, can act as representations of the general do to amend their perpetuation of these negative
ideals, which shape social practice (Featherstone images of ageing. Apart from the need for a
and Hepworth 1995). With this in mind, social change of attitude by young advertising executives
gerontologists advocate radical deconstruction who see themselves as the most important group
and displacement of negative images of ageing. in society, there is also the problem of limited
This means the deconstruction of the long-held creative imagination among the advertising in-
associations between old age and illness, disability, dustry when dealing with older consumers. It is
disengagement and decline, and a more positive easier to use the shorthand of stereotypical
elaboration of the new norms of positive ageing. messages than it is to face the creative challenge
As Vincent (1995) argues, society needs to build a of producing sophisticated, innovative well re-
community of values that does not devalue and searched, unpatronising advertising campaigns
restrict people on the basis of age criteria, and this featuring and targeting older consumers. There is
is as much the responsibility of advertising, as is it evidence of a small number of advertisers who
the rest of society. If advertising can change the have managed to create advertising, which uses
way that it portrays ageing, not only will this be a older people as integral members of society, rather
valuable contribution to the deconstruction of than as something quaint, comical or to be pitied.
negative ageing imagery, but it will be a positive Persil have used older couples in their recent
acceptance of the responsibility to observe the 'talking heads' campaign for washing powder
ethical duties outlined by Laczniak (1983). tablets, as have Prudential Banking in their 'Egg'
What is needed is a more accurate representa- account advertising; Marks and Spencer have
tion of older people in advertising and television; featured a mother and daughter in their jeans
treating older people as a 'funny minority' is campaign; and even designers Donna Karan and
grossly unfair on the part of the mass media. Giorgio Armani have used female model Bene-
Ambassador Julia Alvarez, speaking at the launch detta Barzini, who is visibly over fifty. Columbia
of the UN International Year of Older Persons sportswear have also broken tradition by using

48 © Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000


Business Ethics: A European Review

Mother Gert Boyle, the company Chairman, in ARP050 1998. Association of Retired and Persons
their clothing advertisements as a positive por- Over 50: Membership Information, London.
trayal of the experience of age. Bedell, G. 1998. 'All these familiar faces hit the big time
after 50'. Night and Day, September 27, 26-28.
Carrigan, M. and Szmigin, I. 1998a. 'Usage and
Conclusion portrayal of older models in contemporary consumer
advertising'. Journal of Marketing Practice: Applied
It is time for advertisers to recognise that ageism Marketing Science, 4:8, 231-248.
Carrigan, M. and Szmigin, I. 1998b, 'Older models
can no longer be tolerated. In keeping with any
in contemporary consumer advertising: usage and
other organisation today, advertisers have a duty portrayal in print media'. Working Papers in Com-
to respect the dignity and the rights of older merce, University of Birmingham.
people. This means neither ignoring them, nor Chaney, D. 1995. 'Creating memories: some images of
ridiculing them as a route to sales. The balance of ageing in mass tourism'. In Featherstone, M. and
power is shifting towards the older generation, Wernick, A. Images of ageing: cultural representa-
and the current disenchantment felt by this older tions of later life: 209-224, London: Routledge.
group of consumers is not surprising. Older people Corlett, C. 1998. 'Shattering the stereotypes ofthe 50 +
consume like everyone else; some are less affluent shopper: marketing'. Vital Speeches of the Day,
and buy discount brands; others are more prosper- 64:15, 478-480.
ous and buy premier brands. All wish to be treated Davis, J.J. 1994. 'Ethics in advertising decision-making:
with respect and dignity. This means that adver- implications for reducing the incidence of deceptive
tising which is targeted at them should be advertising'. Journal of Consumer Affairs, 28:2, 380-403.
aspirational in their terms, and when portraying Day, E. and Stafford, M.R. 1997. 'Age-related cues in
old age it should use fit, active and healthy role retail services advertising: their effects on younger
models from their own generation. At the same consumers. Journal of Retailing, 73:2, 211-233.
Deevoy, A. 1998. 'Will you still need me, will you still
time, if advertisers use older people to reach
feed me when I'm Ml' Night and Day, April 26, 7-10.
younger markets, their portrayal should avoid
Deutsch, F.M., Zalenski, C M . and Clark, M.E. 1986.
mockery and ridicule. Many older consumers wish 'Is there a double standard of ageing?' Journal of
to see at least some advertisements with which Applied Social Psychology, 16:9, 771-785.
they can identify, and will switch to brands which Featherstone, M. and Hepworth, M. 1995. 'Images of
recognise their existence and portray them as positive ageing: a case study of Retirement Choice
attractive people with plenty to offer. By behaving magazine'. In Featherstone, M. and Wernick, A.
detrimentally towards older people, advertisers Images of ageing: cultural representations of later life:
not only violate their ethical responsibilities, they 2 9 ^ 7 . London: Routledge.
also potentially violate their commercial responsi- Featherstone, M. and Wernick, A. 1995. Images of
bilities by failing to reach an important and affluent ageing: cultural representations of later life. London:
consumer market. It is time for the advertising Routledge.
community to assume their responsibility for the Flanagan, P. 1994. 'Don't call 'em old, call 'em
ethical standards of their industry towards the customers'. Management Review, 83:10, 17-22.
older generation. Garrett, T. 1966. Business Ethics. Englewood Cliffs:
Prentice Hall.
Greco, A.J. 1989. 'Representation of the elderly in
advertising: crisis or inconsequence?' Journal of
References Consumer Marketing, 6:1, 37-44.
Greco, A.J., Swayne, L.E. and Johnson, E.B. 1997.
AARP 1998. 'You and advertising: a few words about 'Will older models turn off shoppers?' International
advertising and AARP's acceptance policies'. Lake- Journal of Advertising, 16, 27-36.
wood, CA: American Association of Retired Persons. Gubernick, L. 1996. 'Grey hair is cool'. Forbes, 157:9,
Active Life, 1998. Media Information, London. 116-118.
Anon. 1997. 'McVitie's seek new star as Asher is axed'. Hess, B. 1974. 'Stereotypes of the aged'. Journal of
Marketing, October 23rd, 3. Communication, Autumn, 76-85.

© Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000 49


Volume 9 Number 1 January 2000

IPC Magazines 1998. Prime Time. London: Southbank. Peterson, R.T. 1992. 'The depiction of senior citizens
ITV 1998. 'Regaining the heartland of younger viewers: in magazine advertisements: a content analysis'.
a brief for the advertising education award 1998/99. Journal of Business Ethics, 11, 701-706.
http:www.ipa.co.uk Peterson, R.T. 1995. 'The portrayal of senior citizens
Knight, N. 1998. 'How do women feel about ageing?' by banks in newspaper advertisements: a content
Vogue, November, 262-266. analyis'. Journal of Professional Services Marketing,
Laczniak, G.R. 1983. 'Framework for analysing 12:2, 95-106.
marketing ethics'. Journal of Macromarketing, 1, Pollay, R. 1986. 'The distorted mirror: reflections on
7-18. the unintended consequences of advertising'. Journal
Laczniak, G.R. 1998. 'Reflections on the 1997 Vatican of Marketing, 50, 25.
statement regarding ethics in advertising'. Journal of Rampton, J. 1998. 'Pretty relieved'. The Magazine,
Public Policy and Marketing, 17:2, 320-324. December, 46-49.
Laczniak, G.R. and Murphy, P.E. 1985. 'Incorporating Robin, D.P. and Reidenbach, R.E. 1987. 'Social
marketing ethics into the organisation'. In Laczniak, responsibility, ethics and marketing strategy: closing
G.R. and Murphy, P.E. (Eds.), Marketing ethics: the gap between concept and application'. Journal of
guidelines for managers, Lexington: Lexington Marketing, 51, 44-59.
Books. Roberts, S.D. and Zhou, N. 1997. 'The 50 and older
Langmeyer, L. 1993. 'Age role portrayals in magazine characters in the advertisements of modern maturity:
advertisements: a content analysis'. In J.H. Summery growing older, getting better?' Journal of Applied
et al. (Eds.), Theories and concepts in an era of Gerontology, 16:2, 208-217.
change: 286-289. Carbondale, IL: Southern Market- Ross, W.D. 1930. The right and the good. Oxford:
ing Association Proceedings. Clarendon Press.
Leiss, W., Kline, S. and Jhally, S. 1990. Social com- Smith, N.C. and Quelch, J.A. 1993. Ethics in market-
munication in advertising, 2nd edition. Scarborough, ing. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
Ontario: Nelson. Smith, R.B., Moschis, G.P. and Moore, R.L. 1984.
Long, N. 1998. 'Broken down by age and sex: exploring 'Effects of advertising on the elderly consumer: an
the ways we approach the elderly consumer'. Journal investigation of social breakdown theory'. In Belk,
ofthe Market Research Society, 40:2, 73-91. R.W. et al. (Eds.), AMA Educators' Proceedings:
Malhotra, N.K. and Miller, G.L. 1998. 'An integrated 1-5, Chicago: American Marketing Association.
model for ethical decisions in marketing research'. Social Trends 1997, Vol. 27. London: HMSO.
Journal of Business Ethics, 17:3, 263-280. Swayne, L.E. and Greco, A.J. 1987. 'The portrayal of
Marrin, M. 1998. 'What a turn-off they have made of older Americans in television commercials'. Journal
Radio 4'. Daily Telegraph, October 22nd, 28. of Advertising, 16:1, 47-54.
Mazis, M.B., Ringold, D.J., Elgin, S.P. and Denman, Thomas, V. and Wolfe, D.B. 1995. 'Why won't tele-
D.W. 1992. 'Perceived age and attractiveness of vision grow up?' American Demographics, 17:5, 24-27.
models in cigarette advertisements'. Journal of Treguer, J. 1998. 'French expert says advertisers ignore
Marketing, 56, 22-37. wealthiest market'. Mediaage Newsletter: Vienna
Miller, C. 1993. 'Image of seniors improves in ads'. Forum on 'Mass Longevity - A Good Story?'
Marketing News, December 6th, 8-11. http://www.mediaage.net.
Miller, R. 1998. 'When did you last wear the jeans?' United Nations, 1995. Report of the United Nations
Goodtimes, December/January, 28-31. Department for Policy Co-ordination and Sustain-
Milliman, R.E. and Erffmeyer, R.C. 1990. 'Improving able Development. 'Social development, including
advertising aimed at seniors'. Journal of Advertising questions relating to the world social situation and to
Research, Dec/Jan, 31-36. youth, ageing, disabled persons and the family'. UN
Murphy, P.E. 1998. 'Ethics in advertising: review, A/50/114.
analysis and suggestions'. Journal of Public Policy & Vincent, J.A. 1995. Inequality and old age. London:
Marketing, 17:2, 316-319. UCL Press.
Nantel, J. and Weeks, W.A. 1996. 'Marketing ethics: is Zhou, N. and Chen, M.Y.T. 1992. 'Marginal life
there more to it than the utilitarian approach?' after 49: a preliminary study of the portrayal of
European Journal of Marketing, 30:5, 9-19. older people in Canadian consumer magazine
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys 1996. advertising'. International Journal of Advertising,
Population Projections, Series PP2, No. 15. 11, 343-354.

50 © Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000

You might also like