Question No.

2
Discuss the need and scope of secondary education system in
Indonesia and Germany.
Answer

Need and Scope of Secondary Education in Indonesia

Education system in Indonesia
Basic education, as defined by the National Education Law No. 2/1989 and the
Government Regulation No. 28/1990, is a nine-year general education curriculum that includes
six years of primary education and three years of junior secondary education. The nine-year
Compulsory Basic Education Program aims to educate every Indonesian between the ages of 7
and 15.

Need of Secondary Education

Indonesia has a rapidly growing population and a diverse socio-economic landscape.

Here are some key reasons why secondary education is crucial in Indonesia:

Human Capital Development:

Secondary education plays a critical role in developing the human capital of a nation. It
equips individuals with the knowledge, skills, and competencies needed to contribute effectively
to society and the economy. A well-educated population is better positioned to participate in and
drive economic growth.

Preparation for Higher Education:

Secondary education serves as a foundation for pursuing higher education, including
universities and colleges. It provides the academic skills and qualifications necessary for further
specialization and advanced studies.

Workforce Readiness:
As the job market becomes increasingly competitive and skill-oriented, secondary
education prepares students for the demands of the modern workforce. It imparts both academic
and vocational skills that enhance employability and adaptability in a rapidly changing job
landscape.

Poverty Reduction:
Education is a powerful tool for breaking the cycle of poverty. Secondary education
empowers individuals to access better job opportunities, earn higher incomes, and improve their
overall quality of life.

Gender Equality:
Ensuring equal access to and completion of secondary education for girls and boys is
essential for promoting gender equality. It empowers young women to overcome social and
cultural barriers, enabling them to make informed choices about their lives and contribute to
society.

Social Cohesion and Citizenship:

Secondary education fosters a sense of social cohesion and national identity. It promotes
values such as tolerance, respect, and critical thinking, which are vital for building an inclusive
and harmonious society.

Innovation and Development:

A well-educated population contributes to innovation, research, and development, which
are essential for driving technological advancement and addressing complex societal challenges.

Civic Engagement:
Secondary education helps individuals become informed and engaged citizens. It
provides them with the knowledge and skills to actively participate in civic life, make informed
decisions, and contribute positively to their communities.

Global Competitiveness:
In an increasingly interconnected world, countries with a strong secondary education
system are better positioned to compete globally. A well-educated workforce attracts foreign
investment and fosters international collaboration.

Health and Well-being:

Secondary education also has indirect benefits for health and well-being. Educated
individuals tend to make healthier lifestyle choices, have better access to healthcare information,
and are more likely to adopt preventive measures.

1
 In Indonesia, expanding access to quality secondary education is essential to address
these needs and to achieve sustainable development goals. By investing in secondary education,
the country can unlock the potential of its youth, promote social equity, and contribute to a
prosperous future for all Indonesians.

Scope of Secondary Education

The scope of secondary education in Indonesia encompasses various aspects related to
curriculum, structure, goals, and challenges. Here's an overview of the scope of secondary
education in Indonesia:

Curriculum:
The general secondary school curriculum is governed by Minister of Education and
Culture Decree No. 061/U/1993 issued on February 25, 1993. Pancasila education and
citizenship, religious education, Indonesian language and literature, national and general history,
English language, physical and health education, mathematics, natural sciences, social sciences,
and arts education are all covered in this program. Indonesian language and literature, English
language, other international languages, and cultural history are the four disciplines covered in
the language program. Physics, biology, chemistry, and mathematics are all part of the natural
science program. Economics, sociology, public administration, and anthropology are all
available through the social science curriculum. These disciplines are designed to help students
improve their abilities and foster dynamic links with the social, cultural, and natural
environments.

The customized teaching program adopted in Class III, which is based on basic courses in
Class I and II, can be chosen by students based on their talents and interests. This program
prepares students for further education in an academic or professional sector. Aside from general
and particular programs, extracurricular activities are available outside of class hours. Scouting,
school health activities, athletics, and first aid, as well as the theoretical information gained in the
curriculum program, are aimed to develop the full person.

Secondary education in Indonesia is divided into two main stages:

Lower secondary education (SMP)

Upper secondary education (SMA/SMK)

The curriculum aims to provide students with a well-rounded education that includes
academic, vocational, and life skills. Subjects covered include language, mathematics, natural
sciences, social sciences, arts, physical education, and religious studies.

2
Lower Secondary Education (SMP):
This stage typically covers grades 7 to 9 and focuses on providing a broad and balanced
curriculum to build a strong foundation for further education or vocational training.

Vocational Education (SMK):

The vocational education track (SMK) focuses on preparing students for specific careers
and industries. It offers specialized subjects and practical training to equip students with skills
relevant to the job market. SMK programs vary widely, including fields like hospitality,
automotive, electronics, and more.

The Minister of Education and Culture established this curriculum in Decree No.
080/U/1993. The goal of vocational education is to prepare students for employment and to
develop professional skills, to instill the ability to compete and develop independently, and to
foster a national workforce to meet the manpower needs of business and industry.

Academic Preparation (SMA):

The academic track (SMA) prepares students for higher education. It provides a more
advanced curriculum, emphasizing subjects such as mathematics, natural sciences, and languages
to prepare students for university entrance exams.

Teacher Training and Development:

Teacher training and professional development are critical components of secondary
education in Indonesia. Improving the quality of teachers' education and skills enhances the
overall learning experience for students.

Technological Integration:
Efforts are being made to integrate technology into secondary education, providing
students with digital literacy skills and enhancing learning experiences through online resources
and tools.

Character Education:
Secondary education in Indonesia aims not only to impart academic knowledge but also
to instill positive values and character traits in students to become responsible and ethical
citizens.

Challenges faced by Secondary Education

3
 While there have been improvements, secondary education in Indonesia faces challenges
such as:

Quality Disparities: Quality of education varies between urban and rural areas, as well
as among different schools.
Access and Enrollment: Ensuring universal access to secondary education remains a
challenge, particularly in remote areas.
Teacher Shortages: There is a need for qualified teachers, especially in rural and remote
regions.
Curriculum Relevance: Adapting the curriculum to align with evolving job market
demands and technological advancements is important.
Infrastructure and Resources: Insufficient infrastructure, learning materials, and
facilities can hinder the learning experience.

In summary, the scope of secondary education in Indonesia aims to provide a

comprehensive and inclusive education system that prepares students for various pathways,
including academic and vocational pursuits. Addressing challenges related to quality, access, and
curriculum relevance is essential to ensure that secondary education effectively equips
Indonesian students for future success.

Need and Scope of Secondary Education in Germany

Need of Secondary Education
Secondary education in Germany is a critical component of the education system, and its
importance is underscored by several compelling reasons.

Here are some key needs and reasons for the significance of secondary education in Germany:

Skill Development and Workforce Readiness:

Secondary education equips students with the skills, knowledge, and competencies
necessary to enter the workforce or pursue further education. Germany's strong emphasis on
vocational education and training (VET) within secondary education prepares students for a wide
range of professions, helping to address skill gaps in various industries.

Differentiated Pathways:
Secondary education in Germany offers diverse educational pathways tailored to
students' aptitudes and interests. Students can choose between academic tracks leading to
universities (Gymnasium), technical and administrative careers (Realschule), and vocational
training (Hauptschule and vocational schools). This differentiated approach ensures that students
receive education best suited to their strengths.

4
Economic Competitiveness:
Germany's robust secondary education system contributes to its economic
competitiveness. The country's well-trained workforce is a driving force behind its strong
industrial base, technological innovation, and export-oriented economy.

Social Mobility and Equity:

Secondary education provides opportunities for social mobility by allowing students to
transition to higher levels of education and better job prospects. The system aims to reduce
socio-economic disparities by offering various paths to success, regardless of a student's
background.

Skilled Trades and Vocational Expertise:

Germany's vocational education and training (VET) system, integrated into secondary
education, produces skilled workers who play a crucial role in maintaining and advancing the
country's industrial and manufacturing sectors.

Integration and Social Cohesion:

Secondary education promotes integration by bringing students from diverse
backgrounds together, fostering mutual understanding and a sense of belonging. It contributes to
social cohesion and helps build a more inclusive society.

Cultural and Intellectual Development:

Secondary education in Germany emphasizes critical thinking, problem-solving, and a
strong foundation in academic subjects. This contributes to students' intellectual development
and prepares them for active participation in civic life.

Innovation and Research:

Secondary education serves as a foundation for higher education and research. It prepares
students to pursue advanced studies and engage in scientific and technological research,
contributing to innovation and progress.

Civic Engagement and Responsible Citizenship:

Germany's education system promotes values such as democracy, tolerance, and social
responsibility. Secondary education helps cultivate informed and engaged citizens who actively
participate in democratic processes and contribute positively to society.

Health and Well-being:

5
 Education has positive implications for individual health and well-being. Well-educated
individuals tend to make healthier lifestyle choices, have better access to healthcare information,
and are more likely to engage in preventive health measures.

In short, the need for secondary education in Germany is multifaceted, encompassing

workforce development, economic growth, social mobility, integration, cultural enrichment, and
civic engagement. The differentiated pathways offered within the secondary education system
cater to diverse talents and aspirations, contributing to Germany's reputation as an educationally
advanced and economically successful nation.

Scope of Secondary Education

` The scope of secondary education in Germany is extensive and well-structured, offering
various educational pathways and opportunities for students to develop their skills, pursue higher
education, and enter the workforce. The German secondary education system is designed to cater
to diverse student needs and aspirations. Here's an overview of the scope of secondary education
in Germany:

Hauptschule:
 Duration: Typically covers grades 5 to 9 or 10.
 Focus: Provides a general education with a strong emphasis on practical skills and
vocational preparation.
 Career Pathways: Prepares students for entry-level jobs, apprenticeships, or further
vocational training.

Realschule:
 Duration: Typically covers grades 5 to 10.
 Focus: Offers a broader and more academic curriculum compared to Hauptschule,
including mathematics, science, and foreign languages.
 Career Pathways: Prepares students for technical or administrative professions,
vocational training, or further academic education.

Gymnasium:
 Duration: Typically covers grades 5 to 12 or 13.
 Focus: Provides a rigorous academic curriculum, emphasizing subjects like mathematics,
languages, sciences, and humanities.
 Career Pathways: Prepares students for university entrance, enabling them to pursue
higher education in various fields.

6
Gesamtschule:
 Duration: Typically covers grades 5 to 12 or 13.
 Focus: Offers a comprehensive education, combining elements of Hauptschule,
Realschule, and Gymnasium.
 Career Pathways: Provides multiple pathways, including vocational training or
university entrance, based on students' abilities and preferences.

Vocational Education and Training (VET):

 Duration: Varies based on the specific vocational program.
 Focus: Combines classroom instruction with practical training, preparing students for
specific trades or professions.
 Career Pathways: Leads to skilled trades and technical professions, offering
opportunities for immediate entry into the workforce or further career advancement.

Berufsschule:
 Duration: Typically part of vocational training programs.
 Focus: Offers specialized education and training for specific occupations or trades.
 Career Pathways: Equips students with practical skills and knowledge needed for their
chosen professions.

Integration Courses:
 Duration: Varies based on individual needs.
 Focus: Aids non-German speakers in learning the language, culture, and values, helping
them integrate into German society and the workforce.

Higher Education Preparation:

Secondary education in Germany, particularly Gymnasium, prepares students for
university entrance exams (Abitur) and higher education in universities or colleges.

Life Skills and Citizenship:

German secondary education emphasizes the development of critical thinking, problem-
solving abilities, and responsible citizenship.

Overall, the scope of secondary education in Germany is comprehensive, offering a range

of educational paths tailored to students' abilities, interests, and career aspirations. The system

7
aims to equip students with the skills and knowledge needed to succeed in the modern world,
whether in academic pursuits, vocational careers, or active citizenship.