Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Update on Vital Pulp Therapy
An Update on Vital Pulp Therapy
An Update on Vital Pulp Therapy
To cite this article: Keith R. Boyer & Jan Trang Nguyen (2023) An Update on Vital
Pulp Therapy, Journal of the California Dental Association, 51:1, 2244707, DOI:
10.1080/19424396.2023.2244707
Table 1. Outcomes of VPT using CSCs in mature permanent teeth with irreversible pulpitis.
# of patients receiving # of patients Clinical success Follow up period
Article Study type Material VPT type intervention followed up (%) (months)
Taha and Khazali14 RCT MTA PP 27 26 85 24
Taha and Abdelkhader15 PCS BD FP 64 59 98.4 12
Cushley et al.16 SR MTA, BD, FP 330 275 97.4 12
CEM 283 233 93.97 36
*Asgary et al.17 RCT CEM DPC 73 69 94.7 12
PP 76 71 91.4
FP 69 65 95.5
RCT (randomized clinical trial), PCS (prospective cohort study), SR (systematic review).
DPC (direct pulp capping), PP (partial pulpotomy), FP (full pulpotomy).
MTA (Mineral Trioxide Aggregate), BD (Biodentine), CEM (calcium enriched mixture).
*Patients were diagnosed with reversible and irreversible pulpitis, but no statistically significant difference was shown.
tissue under high magnification. The clinician assesses the pulp capping that failed due to progressive decay and
tissue vitality and inflammation by noting the vascularity persistent symptoms. The tooth was then successfully trea
and amount of bleeding and then proceeds to verify ted with complete caries removal and direct pulp capping.
healthy pulp when hemostasis is achieved. If a portion of To allow pulps the best chance of healing, treatment
the pulp appears necrotic or hemorrhagic, the clinician should focus on aseptic technique, complete elimination
removes tissue until a healthy level is reached. Treating of bacteria, and immediate high-quality restoration.
pulps in this targeted manner may allow more patients to In the 2021 position statement on vital pulp therapy,5
receive successful VPT. the AAE states that the focus of VPT is broader than
The presence of microorganisms is the key factor that previously thought: A pre-treatment diagnosis of irreversi
significantly affects the health of the pulp.23 While avoid ble pulpitis does not necessarily preclude the possibility of
ing a pulp exposure by selective caries removal and indir pulp tissue repair and preservation, and improvements in
ect pulp capping may be easier for the clinician, leaving materials and understanding of pulpal disease allow clin
soft, leathery, or firm infected dentin results in continuous icians to offer VPT on mature permanent teeth in appro
pulpal inflammation.24 Additionally, restoration timing and priately selected cases. Such conservative therapy may be
quality play important roles in the success of VPT. easier to perform, preserve more tooth structure, and save
Residual caries-affected or infected dentin compromises costs as compared to complete root canal treatment. The
dentin bonding.25 Delay of restoration placement and leak next section discusses a suggested protocol and decision-
age of microorganisms negatively impact outcomes.18,26,27 making process for implementing VPT in teeth with deep
Figure 1 shows the case of a young patient with indirect carious lesions or pulp exposures.
Figure 1. (a). Pre-operative radiograph of young patient with deep caries and incompletely formed roots of the mandibular right first permanent molar; (b). Clinical
photograph showing occlusal and buccal caries; (c). Radiograph of IPC at time of placement; (d). 26-month follow-up radiograph of IPC with caries progression and
development of symptoms; (e). Radiograph of DPC at time of placement; (f). 12-month follow-up radiograph of DPC showing completion of root formation.
JOURNAL OF THE CALIFORNIA DENTAL ASSOCIATION 3
Vital Pulp Therapy Procedure canal therapy may still be indicated based on the intraoperative
or postoperative findings.
The first step when considering VPT is to determine
After establishing adequate anesthesia, effective isolation
a preoperative diagnosis based on the patient’s history of symp
with a dental dam must be in place. The rubber dam facilitates
toms and a clinical exam with sensibility tests. A normal pulp is
found when the tooth in question responds equivocally to thermal an operative environment free of oral microorganisms and
testing as another healthy control tooth. A diagnosis of reversible protects the patient from the chemicals used during the pro
pulpitis is confirmed when the patient’s symptoms are minor to cedure. A high speed handpiece with water spray is used to
moderate, short-lasting, and only upon provocation with cold or remove unsupported enamel affected by caries, establishing
sweets. Once caries progresses into the pulp space, the presence of restorability and sound margins. Complete caries excavation
bacteria will render at least a portion of the pulp irreversibly must be completed using a slow speed handpiece and sharp
inflamed or necrotic. Symptoms of irreversible pulpitis usually spoon excavator, extending from the peripheral dentin con
include severe, often lingering pain that is provoked with cold or centrically inward axially and pulpally. It is important to
heat, spontaneous pain which can be worse at night, or referred remove as much caries as possible before exposing the pulp
pain which can be difficult for the patient to localize. The inflam to minimize contamination. Use of high magnification and
mation may be considered more extensive once periapical invol caries indicator dye throughout the procedure is recom
vement is noted, such as with radiographic periodontal ligament mended to identify infected dentin and conserve sound tooth
widening or pain to percussion, palpation, or biting. A necrotic structure.29 If caries is completely removed without resulting
pulp will have no response to cold or electric pulp testing.28 Only in pulp exposure, and the preoperative diagnosis was normal
teeth with some amount of remaining vital pulp tissue are candi or reversible pulpitis, then disinfection of dentin with sodium
dates for VPT. hypochlorite (NaOCl) and placement of a CSC at the deepest
The dentist should combine the preoperative diagnostic portion of the preparation, along with a liner and bonded
information with other clinical considerations such as the restoration is recommended (see Figure 2). Indirect pulp cap
patient’s ability to tolerate long treatment appointments and ping of carious dentin with a biocompatible material should
whether the tooth needs extensive restoration, along with tak only be considered as a temporary measure if circumstances
ing into account patient considerations such as finances and require it, such as insufficient procedure time or an unco
risk tolerance to determine whether conservative pulp treat operative patient.
ment options make sense for the individual. If it is determined If caries removal results in a pulp exposure or the patient
with the patient that VPT is to be attempted, the patient must has irreversible pulpitis symptoms, then the pulp tissue should
be informed that symptoms may persist or worsen and root be examined with strong magnification and illumination for
Figure 2. (a). Pre-operative radiograph of mandibular right first premolar with deep recurrent caries, reversible pulpitis, and complex apical root anatomy; (b). Post-
operative radiograph of tooth without pulp exposure treated with CSC, liner, and bonded restoration; (c). Caries remaining after failing restoration removed and clean
margins established; (d). Soft caries removed; (e). Caries indicator dye (to dye for [Roydent, Johnson City, TN, USA]) used to stain remaining cares; (f). Caries noted by
dye removed; (g). Caries indicator dye used again to show slight residual caries; (h). Preparation free of caries and without pulp exposure; (i). EndoSequence BC RRM
putty [Brasseler, Savannah, GA, USA] placement; (j). EndoSequence BC liner [Brasseler, Savannah, GA, USA] placement; (k). Tooth restored with composite.
4 K. R. BOYER AND J. T. NGUYEN
vascularity and perfusion as well as amount of bleeding. If bleeding is not controlled after a partial pulpotomy,
Avascular tissues appear either pale or very dark and must be then a full pulpotomy is performed by removing the pulp
removed. Healthy pulp will appear uniform and pink. Some tissue from the chamber with a high speed diamond bur to
bleeding is to be expected from a vital pulp, but dark or profuse the level of the canal orifice(s). The NaOCl and observation
bleeding indicates severe inflammation. Diluted or full- processes are repeated. If bleeding is controlled at the pulp
strength NaOCl is then used to gently rinse the pulp, or stump, then CSC is placed over the canal orifices and cham
a NaOCl-saturated cotton pellet is placed into the site. The ber floor, followed by liner and immediate bonded restora
NaOCl serves to disinfect the tissues, remove biofilm and tion. If hemostasis is not achieved, then initiation of
dentin chips, and achieve hemostasis.5 After two to ten min pulpectomy is recommended. See Figure 3 for a flow chart
utes of NaOCl exposure, the pulp is observed again to deter summarizing the above steps.
mine whether bleeding is controlled.30 If the pulp appears Follow up for any VPT procedure should include evalua
healthy once hemostasis is achieved, then the dentist should tion of signs and symptoms, condition of coronal restoration,
perform direct pulp capping with a CSC covering at least 1.5 pulp sensibility testing, and radiographic monitoring for api
mm in thickness and extension onto the dentin, followed by cal changes, resorption, or calcification. For teeth with
a liner such as resin-modified glass ionomer (RMGI), and incompletely formed roots, radiographic evaluation should
immediate restoration.31 Some fast-set CSCs allow bonding also include continuation of root development.32 Full pulpo
directly to the material without placement of a liner. tomies will not respond to pulp testing and they may be more
If the pulp is avascular, or bleeding is not controlled with difficult to reenter if root canal treatment is needed.
NaOCl, then the degenerated or inflamed portion of pulp However, full pulpotomies may provide more predictable
tissue should be removed to a healthy level in a partial pulpot results in cases of irreversible pulpitis or with signs or symp
omy procedure. Using a high speed handpiece with a sterile toms of apical periodontitis.16,33 Bonded direct restorations
diamond bur and adequate irrigation, the dentist then ampu will serve as the conservative choice to seal and restore most
tates approximately 1–3 mm of pulp tissue or until all necrotic VPT cases. Early failures (during the first 3–6 months) are
tissue is removed. This may include tissue only at the site(s) of most often due to endodontic causes resulting in signs and
exposure or it may require unroofing of the remaining pulp symptoms, while late failures are due to restorative reasons
chamber. The NaOCl step is repeated for 2–10 minutes and such as poor coronal seal.34 As such, preparation and place
then the tissue is observed again. If bleeding is controlled, then ment of an indirect definitive restoration such as an onlay or
at least 1.5–3 mm of CSC is placed over the remaining pulp crown should only occur if necessary to protect the tooth and
tissue and extended onto adjacent dentin, and the tooth is after sufficient time has passed to evaluate healing of the VPT
restored as in the direct pulp capping procedure.31 procedure.
29. Fusayama T. Clinical guide for removing caries using a traumatised anterior and carious posterior teeth using mineral
caries-detecting solution. Quintessence Int. 1988;19:397–401. trioxide aggregate: a 5-year retrospective study. Aust Endod J.
30. Santos JM, Pereira JF, Marques A, Sequeira DB, Friedman S. Vital 2022;48(3). doi:10.1111/aej.12583.
pulp therapy in permanent mature posterior teeth with symptomatic 33. Elmsmari F, Ruiz XF, Miro Q, Feijoo-Pato N, Duran-Sindreu
irreversible pulpitis: a systematic review of treatment outcomes. F, Olivieri JG. Outcome of partial pulpotomy in cariously
Medicina (Kaunas). 2021;57(6):573. doi:10.3390/medicina57060573. exposed posterior permanent teeth: a systematic review and
31. Bogen G, Dammaschke T, Chandler N. Cohen’s Pathways of the meta-analysis. J Endod. 2019;45(11):1296–1306 e3. doi:10.
Pulp. L. Berman and K. Hargreaves, Editors. Elsevier Health 1016/j.joen.2019.07.005.
Sciences: USA; 2020: 928. 34. Philip N, Suneja B. Minimally invasive endodontics: a new era for
32. Mousivand S, Sheikhnezami M, Moradi S, Koohestanian N, pulpotomy in mature permanent teeth. Br Dent J. 2022;233
Jafarzadeh H. Evaluation of the outcome of apexogenesis in (12):1035–1041. doi:10.1038/s41415-022-5316-1.