Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art
Charlotte G. O'Kelly
Providence College
ABSTRACT: This paper reports findings from a content analysis of the gender role
images in the works of Gothic, Renaissance, Baroque and Modern art in three major
Western art history textbooks. Males were overrepresented as subjects; males and
females were presented in stereotypic roles and activities; the Madonna and the idle
nude were common female images; males were overrepresented in portraits. Fine art as
presented in major art history books was found to embody the gender role stereotypes of
the wider society.
Method
The data for this study are based on a content analysis of the 971 works
of art found in three major Western art history textbooks by
For reprint requests write: Charlotte G. O'Kelly, Department of Sociology,
Anthropology and Social Work, Providence College, Providence, RI 02918
Qualitative Sociology, 6(2), Summer 1983 136 ©1983 by Human Sciences Press
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art 137
Findings
The Church had few positive images of women during this period.
Females were seen as sources of temptation and sin which made the path
toward salvation more difficult for males. Even the wife and mother roles
of women were devalued by the medieval Church, although not necessarily
by the public. The highest ideal for men was to forgo sexual and intimate
contact with women altogether as part of
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art 139
o ~ 0
~
II ~
LT
0II CO
II
n 7
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~t
~ 00
$ ~
1 ~ ~
) ~ ~ ~
~c o
~ ~ 2 ~ ~
I ~ .I
~ ~ 0 ~ ~
I ~ ) A~ ~ ~II o ~
E
El cd II 1
~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~$ : ~~ ~~ ~
-II o
6)
~ O
o t
-
II ~ ~
~
~a <IE ~
~ ~ ~ 0
~
~
~ ~ ~ ~
~O rI ~
~
~~
~ q
~ o 0
~
~ ~II o Ox co ~
~ II A II
~
q
~ U ~ ~ ~ Z
~ ~
~ 2
~ 0) •I
~ o ~ ~
~n )$ ~
~~ co o 0 C □
~
~ ~
~~ ~ I
~ ~ ~
~
~ ~
~
~O ~
O O
5
~~ ~II ~ ~II 0
~ II II L
43
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~
-
~o
~ ~~ ~ ~ 0
~ ~
~ •1l
~~ ~
~~ ~ ~ 0
~ ~
~ ~ ~ o CO
~ ~ ~
~
1
~ ~
~ ~
~
~
§ ~0 4
*1l
o
~n 0 ~ co n
C
~
r ~ ~ ~
~O
·1l
H ~II ~II ~II 0
~
r
b0
*, ~ ~ 7
~ ~
~ ~
~
~
5
O O 0 0
~ ~
~ IE O O 0 0 a
~ O
~
$-
□
l
0
I
0
el
~O 3 I
~
~
1 • ~
J
□
I
~ ~ ~ ~ •$-~
•3
□
*
~ Id O
2 0 0
~
J
0 t 0O O0 O 5
1l
~ ~
•~GU c ~
-
l ~
~ ~
~
88
I ~ co
0
cd IE el
~ o
I 0
~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
~
~ a~ ~
~
~ ~0 ~ to □
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
1
~
~ ~o
. -
0 ~
$ $ ~
~ ~o ~3 ~~ ~3 o
3 ~
E
.H 3 .I
~
'
0 1
U0
~ ~~
■,
O~
$ ~
$~ ~0~ ~ ~
0 ~
~$
~~
o ~~
~ ~ ~2~ 8 E~
~
140 QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY
data from this study. Women were rarely depicted until the late Middle
Ages. Women are first seen in their roles as the mistress of the home and
the lady of courtly love. By the sixteenth century women are more visible
in a greater variety of roles, in particular, peasant women are pictured
working alongside their husbands. By the seventeenth century, Aries
states that the subject matter of calendar art reflects the increasing
importance of the family as a separate unit in society. Aries further
maintains that Western arts in its various forms reflects the gradual
emergence of private family life and modern family roles (including gender
roles) out of the more communal orientation of the medieval manor.
This study has also found that women were largely invisible, except for
the Madonna and other religious images, in Gothic art as well. Even
though the Reformation introduced important new images of women
during the Renaissance, these data indicate that in art, women continue
to be ignored or presented as Madonnas or Eves.
The Reformation and the breakup of medieval society overtly challenged
the Catholic view of women and of sex. The Puritans, for example, exalted
women in their roles as wives and mothers (Zaretsky, 1976). The view of
women was transformed from an emphasis on the evil, seductive
temptations of women to a view of women as the repository of virtue and
the mainstay of the new private family life. Simultaneously, among the
wealthy, women came to be valued for their beauty, as objects for display.
The underside of these views of women as virtuous and beautiful was, that
those women who were not located within the confines of family
domesticity were evil, depraved, and available as sex objects for males.
These images of women are reflected first in Baroque art and continue
to dominate art in the modern period. Women are increasingly visible, but
their "new" feminine roles are limited to mother, idle beauties and sex
objects. Contrary to Lyvia Brown's analysis (1975), Madonnas are not
important in the works of either the Baroque or Modern periods. However,
a secularized version of the Madonna in the form of the good mother figure
with her child is a part of the composition of 7.9% (34) of the modern
paintings and 5.0% (35) of the Baroque works in this sample. The Madonna
image probably continues in this type of sub-theme at least partially
because the legitimate role of women in modern society was largely defined
by her position as a wife and mother. The Church's loss of power resulted
in a decline in the divine representation of the Virgin Mary, and the
importance of marriage and motherhood, with its concomitant artistic
figures, increased with the rise of modern capitalist and industrial society.
142 QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY
~ ~
71
~ ~ ~ v
##,
~
~
M
~
~
¢
~ ~
~•
*
1
n
"
1%
~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
#
~ ~
-
0 i
~ ~ ~
om
~ ~
vw
wt
~
7 %
~ ~ ~ ~
#
~
I
~ ~
II M~
~
~ ~
~1
1
~N
4J ~~ ~ ~ ~
l
~ ~ ~
~ ~~
#
-
7%
t
~
4
•v~ ~ ~
~
0
~ ~
0
7-
1
~
rt
~
r
~
U
0
·el
~
~ G ~t
%
5
~0 ~ ~ ~ ~38
0
~
~
~ ~
N ~
II ~
N
1- ~N
~
~ ~
##
~ ~ ~ ~
-i
~n ~
~ ~
A 00
~r ~
J
~
L ~ r ~
~ )
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
~a #
~ #
~ ~ ~ ~
##
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
7
~
in
~ II ~
fN ~
II ~II 1fN
) ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~
~ ~
#
4
I
~ ~
~
cg
~ 0 0 0
~
[x1
~ ~
~ 0 0 ~ ~ 0
~ 0 0
)
1 0 0 0
7
l
~ ~
~
»
~ ~ ow
~
~
-
~
~ ~
3
~EA ~
g
~ ~ o ~ ~
~ ~ t
~ ~ ~ ~L
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
(x
~0 4
0
~0 J
~~ ~)
~ 1
~ ~ ~
~
~ ~5 ~ L ~ ~ ~
~
·el ~
n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
~1)
~
~
0
~4J
~ )
~
~
~
~
µ
~
~
$.
0 7%
3 t
~ ~ ~0a a#%
~ ~
,
o
~
$ ~
~
0
3 ~0 ~$
~ ~ ~0
J
0
~
~ ~ ~
0
0
~
~0
¢
~
#
~
~ ~ ~
~ ~t
~
0 ~ ~ g
3 ~ 0
9 ~ ~$3 7*
-
0
~ ~ ~ ~0
0
~
~
pa
~
0 a
~ ~
~ 8~ KI~
~ ~
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art 143
Nudes
The frequency of females as nude subjects in art provides further
evidence of cultural imagery. We assume that female nudes represent
traditional sex roles such as that of the sex object and traditional female
behavior such as passivity in contrast with male activity. Although male
nudes outnumber female nudes in almost all the art periods, this is
attributable to the preponderance of more male subjects. Females are, in
fact, more likely to be portrayed in the nude than are males; 24.2% (330)
of the female subjects are nude compared to 11.9% (379) of the male
subjects. (See Table II)
Female nudes are usually presented in overtly sexual poses or in the
process of dressing or bathing. Males dress and bathe, but these do not
provide subjects for artistic endeavors. Males (but not females) are active
even when nude.
Portraiture.
The influence of wealthy and powerful patrons of the arts on the
subject matter of art can be seen in the rise of portrait paintings. Interest
in portraiture was spurred by the decline of the medieval community and
the rise of the urban bourgeoisie. Portraiture indicates an increased
emphasis on individualism. But as Eli Zaretsky (1976) points out,
individualism was accorded to males first as most females did not gain
the right to individual self development until recent decades.
Conclusion
The world of art has long been a masculine domain. The artists,
teachers, patrons, gallery owners, art critics and museum curators have
been predominantly and sometimes exclusively male (Baxandall, 1972:
1-27; Munro, 1979: 19-35). When women do occupy these positions, they
often feel constrained to use the same standards as males. Women gallery
owners, for example, have to sell to stay open and if works by women
artists produce fewer profits, galleries have to
144 QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY
4)
~
~ ~ ~
7-l
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
II~ II~ ~ el
0 II IR 1-
II
~ ~
# ~ ~ 2~ ~
0 ~ ~ ~
•~ Io
~
~ ~ ~ 0
•
. . . .
)
~ ~~ ~ o ~ 0
Eo
o ~ ~ O O ~
el
~ ~ l
,□
4J
n
)
•1
~
□
~
~
1l o ~ ~ co ~
c0. . . .~
~O l
~ co ~
~
·,-l co ~ ~
U
~
w
H
H ~ )
0
H
~ ~O t l
~ l
fr]
~
~
~CU
2~ ~~ •
~
7 .
~
~
~•
~
co•
~
~
~ ~ F
E-
~
~
~
)
yr
U
~
~
fr
~
0
~ ~
o)
0
*I
~
4
~
~ 0 ~
~ ~ ~
7
~ ~ ~
*1I 7
$-
~ ~ ~ ~
$- ~
~ ~ ~ 0 ~
~( $ ~ ~ 0 $
~ ~
#
0 0
A ~ ~ ~ ~
< ~ O ~
)
4
~
00 ~ e-- ~ ~
~
#
0
cU ~ 1
~
#
~
#
0
~ □ ~ ~
~) ~
0
~
·l
~
1l □ ~
$- +l
0
~
~)
7
4 ~
~
~
~
0
~
~
~ c
42
~ 0
~ ~ KU 0 0
A
0 ~ 4 ~ ~ El
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art 145
focus on male artists (Fine, 1978: vii). Women were also long excluded
from membership in the important art academies and when a few were
finally elected in the late nineteenth century, they could not exercise the
full membership privileges available to the males until several decades
later (Harris and Nochlin, 1976: 45 -58).
The human experiences reflected in the most celebrated works of art,
have been, therefore, male experiences or what men conceive of as
female experiences. The books used in this study each contain only one
female artist. This is not because there have been no great female artists.
Clara E. Clement (1977) has carefully researched and documented the
existence of substantial numbers of gifted female artists from the seventh
century, B.C. to the twentieth century. These women have not been
accorded a high place in art history textbooks. It is not clear whether this
exclusion is because the artists are female or because their work is simply
not as good as the male artists who fill the textbooks.
Reference Notes
l The periods analyzed here include Gothic, Renaissance, Baroque, and Modern.
Gothic refers to medieval, primarily religious art, created between 1150 and 1550.
This was the Age of the Great Cathedrals and includes such artists as Giotto, Traini,
Lorenzetti, and van Eyck in the "late Gothic period." Renaissance art developed about
1420 and continued through the sixteenth century, thus overlapping with Gothic in
time but also in Christian influence. Renaissance artists include Donatello,
Michelangelo, Raphael, da Vinci, Titian and Durer. Baroque style predominated
between 1600 and 1750, and is a part of the Renaissance. Representative Baroque
artists are van Dyck, Rubens, Rembrandt, Gainsborough and Bernini, who received
patronage from the papacy. Modern Art began about 1750 and continues through the
1930's for the purpose of this study. Schools of Modern Art are Neo-Classicism,
Romanticism, Realism, Impressionism, Post Impressionism, Fauvism, Expressionism,
Cubism, Abstraction, and Reactions against Abstraction; and includes artists such as
David, Goya, Renoir, Van Gogh, Matisse, Picasso and Rivera.
2 Aries' (1962: 347-350) observation that family portraits became especially popular
in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries and continued into the nineteenth century
lends further support to this interpretation.
3 Examinations of sex role themes in particular works of art such as various
representations of Sampson and Deliliah (Kahr, 1972) and of Degas' depictions of
females (Broude, 1977) are found in a recent work on feminist art history (Broude
and Garrard, 1982). The field of feminist art history is a new one and the question of
the comparative imagery in male and female artists' works has only begun to be
analyzed.
References
Antal, Frederick
1948 Florentine Painting and Its Social Background. Boston: Boston Book and Art
Shop.
Aries, Phillipe
1962 Centuries of Childhood. New York: Vintage.
Bachman, Donna G. and Shery Piland
1978 Women Artists. New York: Scarecrow Press.
Gender Role Stereotypes in Fine Art 147
Baxandall, Michael
1972 Painting and Experience in Fifteenth Century Italy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Broude, Norma
1977 "Degas's Misogyny,"' The Art Bulletin 59: 97-107. Broude, Norma and Mary D.
Garrard (eds.)
1982 Feminism and Art History. New York: Harper.
Brown, Lyvia Morgan
1975 "Sexism in Western Art," Pp. 309-322 in Jo Freeman (ed.). Women: A Feminist
Perspective. Palo Alto: Mayfield.
Callen, Anthea
1979 Women Artists of the Arts and Crafts Movement, 1870-1914. New York:
Pantheon.
Canaday, John
1959 Mainsteams of Modern Art. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Cantor, Helen
1974 "Women, Culture and Class Society," Women and Revolution: 2-9.
Clement, Clara E.
1977 Women in the Fine Arts. Williamstown: Cornerhouse.
Collins, James L.
1975 Women Artists in America. New York: Wittenborn.
Collins, James L. and Glenn Opitz
1981 Women Artists in America. New York: Apollo.
Cornillon, Susan Kopplman (ed.)
1973 Images of Women in Fiction. Bowling Green: Bowling Green University.
Ferguson, Mary Anne (ed.)
1973 Images of Women in Literature. Boston: Houghton Millin.
Fine, Elsa H.
1978 Women and Art. New York: Allanheld and Schram.
Gardner, Helen
1975 Art Through the Ages (sixth edition, revised by Horst de la Choix and Richard
G. Tansey). New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.
Harksen, Sibylle
1975 Women in the Middle Ages. New York: Abner Schram.
Harris, Ann Sutherland and Linda Nochlin
1976 Women Artists: 1550-1950. New York: Knopf.
Haskell, Molly
1974 From Reverence to Rape. Baltimore: Penguin.
Hedges, Elaine and Ingrid Wendt
1980 In Her Own Image. Old Westbury, N.Y.: The Feminist Press.
Hess, Thomas and Elizabeth Baker (eds).
1973 Art and Sexual Politics. New York: Collier.
Hanson, H.W.
1969 History of Art. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Jolly, Eric and Charlotte O'Kelly
1980 "Sex Role Stereotyping in the Language of the Deaf" Sex Roles 6:285-292.
Kahr, Madlyn
1972 "Deliliah." The Art Bulletin 54: 282-299.
Lakoff, Robin
1975 Language and Woman's Place. New York: Harper and Row.
Lippard, Lucy R. (ed.)
1976 From the Center: Feminist Essays on Women's Art. New York: Dutton.
Mellon, Joan
1973 Women and Their Sexuality in the New Film. New York: Dell.
Munro, Eleanor
1979 Originals; American Women Artists. New York: Simon and Schuster.
148 QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY
Nochlin, Linda
1971 "Why Are There No Great Women Artists?", Pp. 480-510 in Vivian Gornick and
Barbara Morgan (eds). Woman in Sexist Society. New York: New American Library.
O'Kelly, Charlotte
1974 "Sexism in Children's Television," Journalism Quarterly 51: 722-724.
1980 "Sex Role Imagery in Modern Art: An Empirical Examination" Sex Roles 6:99-
111.
O'Kelly, Charlotte and Linda Bloomquist
1976 "Women and Blacks on Television" Journal of Communication 26:179-184.
Petersen, Karen and James L. Wilson
1976 Women Artists. New York: Harper.
Poe, Alison
1976 "Active Women in Ads". Journal of Communication 26:185-192.
Power, Eileen
1975 Medieval Women. New York: Cambridge, University.
Spawn, Walter (ed.)
1976 Women Painters of the World. New York: Hacker.
Stacy, Judith, Susan Bereaud and Joan Daniels
1974 And Jill Came Tumbling After. New York: Dell.
Tuchman, Gaye
1975 "Women and the Creation of Culture," Pp. 171-212 in Marcia Millman and
Rosabeth Moss Kanter (eds.) Another Voice. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday Anchor.
Tuchman, Gaye, Arlene Kaplan Daniels, and James Benet (eds.)
1978 Hearth and Home. New York: Oxford.
Vequaud, Ives
1977 Women Painters of Mithila. New York: Thames Hudson.
Water, Clara E.C.
1977 Women in the Fine Arts from the Seventh Century B.C. to the Twentieth
Century A.D. (orig. 1904). New York: Longwood.
Weitzman, Lenore, et. al.
1972 "Sex-role Socialization in Picture Books for Pre-School Children." American
Journal of Sociology 77:1125-1149.
Wheeler, Kenneth and Virginia L. Lussier (eds.)
1982 Women, the Arts and the Nineteen Twenties in Paris and New York. New
Brunswick; Transaction.
Zaretsky, Eli
1976 Capitalism, the Family and Personal Life. New York: Harper.