Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dec 11 Ebulletin
Dec 11 Ebulletin
October/November/December 2011
Page 6 Interview with Representative Donna Howard Page 9 Holiday Greeting and Membership Drive Page 10 If we are Academically Adrift... in what direction should we sail now?
by Frank Fair by Frank Fair
Page 13 In the News: A TACT Member Responds Page 14 TACT Legislative Update
by Cindy Simpson
Page 16 Pictures from the Fall Conference Page 17 GRF Contributions Page 18 Membership
TACT
Texas Association of College Teachers 5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, Texas 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
Copyright 2011 by the Texas Association of College Teachers. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be produced in any form without permission; Chuck Hempstead, Editor.
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Presidents Letter
by Peter Hugill TACT President
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
As many of you are aware Lieutenant Governor Dewhurst and Speaker of the House Joe Straus recently established a Joint Committee to inquire into the governance of higher education in the State of Texas. On the House side this is chaired by Representative Dan Branch and on the Senate side by Senator Judith Zaffirini. Senator Kirk Watson is also on the Joint Committee. Several of the TACT Board, myself included, visited with staffers from the offices of Senators Zaffirini and Watson at the joint meeting with AAUP and TCFS this past October. Much of the reason for this Joint Committee was the high level of problems caused by the appointment by Governor Perry of persons associated with the Texas Public Policy Foundation to the Boards of the University of Texas and Texas A&M University. Although the TPPF has put forward a few useful ideas its Seven Breakthrough Solutions seem designed more to hinder and harm higher education than to help it. The TACT Board is, in general, of the opinion that the Joint Committee is well aware of the problems and seems to be working to improve governance at our Universities. But there are other Boards that are causing problems for our Universities, with at least one of which I have become familiar of late. A recent,
worrisome development has been the attempt by the Texas Board of Professional Geoscientists (TBPG) to force all Geoscientists in the state to be licensed under their rules (Im in the College of Geosciences at TAMU). In its first iteration these rules would have required licensure for any public contact, including teaching. Most Engineering Departments require a small number of their faculty be licensed by their professional organizations, mostly to testify in public hearings. At first glance this may seem no different, but, despite its name, the TBPG is NOT a professional organization of Geoscientists but a Board of three public and six professional members that came into existence in 2001 and which has been entirely appointed by Governor Perry. The Board states its goals as to protect public health, safety, welfare and the states natural resources by ensuring that only qualified persons carry out the public practice of geoscience, and it was initially set up to deal with oil and gas issues. Only two of the current the Board have Ph.D.s. The claim is that: Licensure is a means to protect the public, and the licensed profession, from unqualified and unethical practitioners of the profession. Licensing establishes a degree of legal accountability for the work product of the regulated
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Wow! Has TACT ratcheted up its activities since coming off a successful legislative session? Remember, most policy changes are at the margins, and we claim a handful from this past summer. Guns on campus, more money into TEXAS Grants (and providing preference to merit-based applications), slowing the outcomes-based funding proposal, maintaining ORP local supplements it was a good session considering the circumstances. As we do at least twice each year, your State Board Members recently pounded the pavement at the Capitol visiting with legislators and their staffers about issues of importance to you. While it is a bit premature to adopt our legislative agenda for next session, we did prepare a leave behind you can review; it is attached to Cindy Simpsons legislative article. We also showed them data that while Texas had been making progress in narrowing the gap between our salaries and the average of the top ten most populous states, that positive trend has reversed. That afternoon, TACT honored State Representative Donna Howard as its Legislator of the Year, primarily for her work on the Higher Education Committee in keeping student concerns at the top of the discussions. Be sure to read my interview with her beginning on page 6. . . . Shifting gears for a moment, are you aware that at each Coordinating
Board Meeting, they entertain a Major Policy Discussion in order to delve into issues that might not otherwise receive sufficient attention? This past meeting, board members and audience were treated to a live streaming of Richard Arum, Professor of Sociology and Education at New York University, discussing his findings outlined in his acclaimed book, Academically Adrift. TACT Board Member Frank Fair addresses some of these issues elsewhere in this newsletter, but I wanted to share a few thoughts from a legislative advocacy perspective. Circling back, one of the reasons Representative Howard was honored by TACT is her insistence on quality in higher education. Too many influential individuals at the Capitol have expanded the goals of Closing the Gaps to mean derrieres in seats. Recruit em and graduate em. Preferably for $10,000. Whos talking about what they learn that will benefit them and their employers? Arums talking about it. Hes saying too many students arent improving their critical thinking and writing skills. Hes saying students learn when faculty demand rigorous academic activities, like studying, for Petes sake. TACT talks about academic quality at the State Capitol. And I want to thank the professors who talk about it on your campuses.
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
An Interview
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Thank you for your time and dedication this year. Heres to a successful and bright 2012. Contact us! For every new member you bring to TACT, be entered to win...
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
A brand-new Kindle Fire! The more you recruit, the more chances you have to win.
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Richard Arum and Josipa Roksas Academically Adrift has caught the attention of many people who are concerned about the state of higher education in this country. In our own state of Texas, the Higher Education Coordinating Board recently held a videoconference with Arum to discuss the findings reported in the book. Responses to the book vary, but here is the view of Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-North Carolina), chair of the House Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Training since January 2011, as reported in an interview in Academe, an AAUP publication: Warren: In one interview, you referred to the newly released book Academically Adrift, noting that recent research by two sociologists shows very little value added to most of higher education. Students in higher ed dont gain the kinds of skills that they need to continue in the work world. So I think higher education is going to have to prove its worth in the future. Could you expound on that statement? Foxx: This study speaks fairly well for itself. According to this book, nearly half of college students do not demonstrate any significant improvement in learning after two years of undergraduate studies. This is a scandal. If these findings are
accurate, institutions of higher education must examine whether those who are paying for a college education are getting their moneys worth. And those who are paying for college should ask the very same question. Note that Rep. Foxx speaks of a scandal, and note how she moves quickly to a question of accountability in terms of people getting their moneys worth. Her response is part of increasing pressure on institutions of higher education from quarters that are skeptical about the value added to many of the student products who move through the halls of academe. Indeed, Arum and Roksas reported findings should concern all of us who care about higher education since there are precious few national samples of their size (2,322 students) and diversity that have been followed long enough and tested sufficiently to provide an appropriate basis for significant conclusions. The conclusion that Rep. Foxx cites is reported this way: With a large sample of more than 2,300 students, we observe no statistically significant gains in critical thinking, complex reasoning, and writing skills for at least 45% of the students in our study. (p. 36) The lack of gains is shown by students
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
10
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
And they say further: The evidence indicates not only that college students are studying less than they used to, but also that the vast majority of the time they once devoted to studying is now being devoted to leisure activities, rather than paid work. (Babcock and Marks, p. 3) This latter point is reinforced in Arum and Roksas book by a pie chart reporting on a survey from selective institutions about how students use the 168 hours of the week: 9% in class, 7% studying, 24% sleeping, 9% working, volunteering, etc., and fully 51% of the time socializing and recreating. That works out to 15 hours in class, 12 hours studying, and 85 hours socializing and recreating. (p. 97) Arum and Roksa also state: Even more alarming, 37 percent of students reported spending less than 5 hours per week preparing for their courses. (p. 69) That last figure is arresting. One wonders how many of the type of
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
11
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
12
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
13
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Legislative Update
by Cindy Simpson TACT VP of Legislative Affairs
The 82nd Texas Legislative Session has come and gone, but TACT is still advocating on the behalf of higher education. During the TACT Fall Conference, at the end of October, TACT board members sat down with the legislative aides of a number of State Senators and Representatives to express our concerns and goals for higher education. We left behind copies of our TACT Issues 2011-2012, listed below, for the legislators to keep. A quick overview of the visits is as follows: The formation of the new Joint Committee on Higher Education Governance, Excellence and Transparency looks to be a vital ingredient in impacting the future of higher education. TACT spoke with key figures from each of the two Co-Chairs staffs: Senator Judith Zaffirini and Representative Dan Branch. Senator Zaffirini is the CoChair for the Senate as well as Chair of the Senate Higher Education Committee. Representative Branch is the Co-Chair for the House and serves as the Chair of the House Higher Education Committee. Both groups acknowledged that the crisis for higher education will continue into the next legislative session, but that the Joint Committee will be an enduring watchdog for the future of higher education in Texas.
Senator Kirk Watson is also on the Joint Committee on Higher Education Governance, Excellence and Transparency, and serves with Senator Zaffirini on the Senate Higher Education Committee. A visit to his office allowed TACT to thank him for his commitment to higher education. His is a voice perennially on the side of higher education, and TACT is confident that Senator Watson is for improving the quality of higher education in Texas, and not fixated on the reform ideas currently under scrutiny. Representative Vicki Truitt is the Chair of the House Committee on Pensions, Investments & Financial Services. The visit with Representative Truitts staff proved beneficial since, during the last legislative session, contribution levels to the Texas Retirement System fell to the Constitutional minimum of 6%. Realizing this pitfall, TACT has already begun to advocate on behalf of those members in TRS in hopes of an increase during the next legislative session. As equally important as the visit with Representative Truitt, TACT members visited the office of Senator Juan Chuy Hinojosa, Vice Chair of the Senate Finance Committee. Senator Hinojosa has a key role in determining
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
14
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
15
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
TACT President Peter Hugill, Representative Donna Howard, and Executive Director Chuck Hempstead pose as Rep. Howard receives her TACT: Legislator of the Year Award.
Representative Donna Howard delivers her address to the assembled members of TACT at the Fall Conference on October 26th.
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
16
Dr. Debbie Price, Dr. Gary Coulton, and Dr. Frank Fair attend the TACT Fall Board Meeting.
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
Andrea Williams
17
CONTENTS
Cover Page Index Letter from the President Executive Directors Report Interview with Rep. Donna Wise Holiday Greeting Academically Adrift In the News: A TACT Member Responds Legislative Update Fall Conference Photos GRF Contributions Membership
Membership Rates
$158 Regular Membership. Professional staff, full-time faculty, librarians, administrators and other professionals. Includes Educators Professional Liability Insurance starting 11/1/2011 and ending 10/31/2012. $113 Affiliate Membership. Administrative assistants, retired faculty, parttime faculty, graduate students, subscription members and libraries. Includes Educators Professional Liability Insurance starting 11/1/2011 and ending 10/31/2012. $250 Annual Business Membership.
Renew your TACT membership online by visiting Join TACT or renew over the phone by calling (512) 873-7404.
Contact us!
5750 Balcones Dr., Suite 201 Austin, TX 78731 tact@bizaustin.rr.com [p] (512) 873-7404 [f] (512) 873-7423
18