Professional Documents
Culture Documents
considerationsonthefrequencyresourceofprofessi
considerationsonthefrequencyresourceofprofessi
considerationsonthefrequencyresourceofprofessi
, 6, 35–38, 2008
www.adv-radio-sci.net/6/35/2008/
Advances in
© Author(s) 2008. This work is distributed under Radio Science
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
Abstract. This Paper presents the results of spectral obser- assured access to the frequency resource. For the protec-
vations in the UHF TV Bands IV and V from 470 MHz up tion of PWMS a default signal strength of (68 dBµV/m) is
to 862 MHz with focus on the TV-Channels 61 to 63 and 67 specified in CEPT (1997). This value is also used for sev-
to 69. Concerning the discussions on WRC (2007) this fre- eral other governmental issues (e.g., ERC Report 88, 2000).
quency range is in great demand of several applications and is PWMS manufacturers suppose that this level is about more
usually treated as a ”white space” in the TV-Bands. Accord- than (10 dB) too high for a secure PWMS connection in on
ing to typical scenarios, two different spectral loads will be stage environments. According to ETSI (2006) a new sug-
presented considering the requirements of professional wire- gestion for the default protected signal strength in PWMS
less microphone receivers with respect to in-band intermod- for future frequency allocation in UHF is given, adapted from
ulation. the demands on PWMS in Sect. 2 of this paper. In Sect. 3 the
spectral loads of two different applicable cases are presented.
Futhermore one of them is evaluated from an objective point
1 Introduction of view by the aid of frequency availability and from a sub-
jective point of view with respect to in-band intermodulation
In the course of the digitalisation of the UHF TV-Bands a in PWMS receivers as well. Finally, in Sect. 4 the results are
reallocation of the UHF frequency spectrum will take place. concluded.
This is based on the presumption that Digital Video Broad-
casting (DVB-T) will occupy less spectrum than the ana-
logue counterpiece. On the other hand the increasing demand 2 PWMS – an application with high demands
on digital broadcasting for hand-held devices (DVB-H) may
require the vacant frequency resource, especially in urban ar- PWMS is a common application in the cultural industry and
eas. Furthermore several providers are interested in installing includes wireless microphones for professional usage, In-
new mobile multimedia-based services in UHF in so called Ear Monitoring Systems (IEM), Electronic News Gather-
“white spaces“. Applications like Professional Wireless Mi- ing (ENG) and wireless audio systems. These applications
crophone Systems (PWMS) which actually use these “white can be found in studios, theatres, musicals, politics, sports,
spaces” are not often mentioned as secondary users of the broadcasting and on stage. Thus PWMS is a core applica-
UHF frequency spectrum. Additionally unlicensed devices tion in the production of multimedia content and is used for
with cognitive skills may become access to the UHF fre- recording and archiving unique events. This leads to very
quency spectrum. On WRC (2007) the possibility to hold an high demands on the reliability and sound quality of PWMS.
auction on the upper TV channels was discussed. According Furthermore sound engineers and musicians have high de-
to BNetzA (2005) PWMS are allowed to operate on these mands on latency. Therefore PWMS, unlike wireless micro-
channels without individual permission until 2015, named phones, headphones or loudspeakers for consumer applica-
channel 61 to 63 (f =790 MHz to f =814 MHz) and channel tions, are not able to operate on Industrial, Scientific, and
67 to 69 (f =838 MHz to f =862 MHz) which were former Medical Bands (ISM). In contrast to daily usage, today’s
used by military applications. PWMS is a strongly grow- mass events, for example in sports, generate a temporary
ing application with high demands on reliability, latency and much higher demand on a useful frequency resource.
sound quality which in practice can only be faced with an
2.1 Requirements of PWMS
Correspondence to: S. Dortmund According to ETSI (2006) a high audio quality can be
(dortmund@hft.uni-hannover.de) achieved with an Audio Signal-to-Noise Ratio SNRAF of
Published by Copernicus Publications on behalf of the URSI Landesausschuss in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland e.V.
36 resource of professional
he frequency S. Dortmundwireless
et al.: Considerations
microphoneonsystems
the frequency resource of professional wireless microphone systems
ee 3 Spectral load
od For the spectral loads the concrete PWMS application is not
n necessary. However, it is important to distinguish two differ-
n Fig. Fig. 1. Measurement
1. Measurement locationin
location in the
the center
centerofofBerlin
Berlinwithin a diam-
within a diam- ent applicable cases, on the one hand the daily use of PWMS
eter of 1 km (marked by white, dotted circles), with known PWMS
m eter of 1 km (marked by white, dotted circles), with known PWMS in an urban area with a high concentration of PWMS users
users (marked by black circle).
users (marked by black circle) with a moderate frequency load, on the other hand a mass
el
is event with a high frequency load (see Sect. 2). For record-
(80 dB (A)) at the NF-Path of a PWMS receiver. The associ- ing the daily use of PWMS, an area with a diameter of 1 km
al ated Radioload Frequency Signal-to-Noise Ratio SNRRF can be
3 Spectral within the center of Berlin was chosen (see Fig. 1). In this
a calculated from area at least 20 PWMS users were known (marked with black
a
For SNR
the spectral SNR
loads the
AF concrete PWMS application(1)
− Gdemod
is not circles). The measurement took place from 17th to 18th July
e- RF =
necessary. However, Kcompandit is important to distinguish two differ- 2007. For a mass event the biggest international music fair
(”Musikmesse”) was chosen. This Measurement took place
ent applicable
where Kcompand cases,represents
on the onea hand the daily
coefficient for use
the of PWMS from 28th to 31th March 2007 in the exhibition hall 4, Frank-
degree
2) in anof urban area with
companding a highKconcentration
(typically compand =2) andof GPWMS
demod rep- users furt/Main.
withresents
a moderate frequency load,
the demodulation gain of on the
the used
othermodulation
hand a mass The spectral load was recorded in both cases using as re-
h eventscheme. Actually
with a high PWMS load
frequency works(seewithsection
frequency modula-
2). For record- ceiving antenna a Sennheiser type A 5000 CP , which is
a tion (FM) with
ing the daily use of PWMS, G demod =20 dB. This leads to a minimum
an area with a diameter of 1 km an applicable, directional antenna installed by many PWMS
or SNRRF,min of typically 20 dB. The thermal noise level
within the center of Berlin was chosen (see Fig. 1). In this users, connected to a Rohde & Schwarz FSP 3 spectrum an-
or Nthermal for a PWMS channel with 200 kHz Bandwidth is alyzer. The data was measured with 1f =20 kHz, RMS de-
areaabout
at least
−12020 dBm.
PWMS users were
According known
to ETSI (2006)(marked with black tection and a reference level P =−20 dBm. The analyzer
other technical
d- circles). The measurement took place
ref
on-stage-applications, for example lightfrom 17th to 18th
installations, add aJuly was software controlled and the measured data stream was
B 2007. For a mass
cumulative event the biggest
man-made-noise NManMadeinternational
of 10 dB. Withmusic
a typ- fair mapped with a measurement PC. The whole analysis was
d- (”Musikmesse”)
ical noise figurewas F ofchosen.
a PWMSThis Measurement
receiver the minimumtook receiv-place performed by use of MATLAB. The surface plots in Fig. 2
d ing level
from 28th to 31thP can be calculated by
sens March 2007 in the exhibition hall 4, Frank- and Fig. 3 show the recorded signal levels PMusikmesse and
5) furt/Main. PBerlin (color coded) over frequency (abscissa) and measure-
Psens = Nthermal + NManMade + F . (2) ment cycle (ordinate) and will be discussed in detail in the
The spectral load was recorded in both cases using as re-
The output power of PWMS is limited to 17 dBm. With following subsections.
ceiving antenna a Sennheiser type A 5000 CP , which is
3) a typical stationary antenna gain Gstatic =5 dBi and a mobile
an applicable, directional antenna installed by many PWMS 3.1 PWMS in daily use
antenna gain Gmobile =0 dBi of a hand-held or of a body-
users, connected
mounted device, to the
a Rhode
maximum & Schwarz
path lossFSPL for3 aspectrum
gaussian an-
le
alyzer. Theisdata
channel givenwas
withmeasured
Lgauss =87 dBwith
including kHz, RMS In Fig. 2, an overview of the spectral load in Berlin is dis-
∆f =the20absorption
y played. The measurement equipment was placed in a car.
detection
of the and
human a reference
body Dhuman =30PdB
level = −20
refdefined in dBm. The ana-
ETSI (2006).
ut The car stopped at numerous stop stations, as close as pos-
lyzerForwas
a reliable PWMS
software link, fading
controlled andbreak-ins up to 30data
the measured dB have
stream sible to the known PWMS users, and continued in place for
n
was tomapped
be considered
with aandmeasurement
lead to Lrayleigh =57The
PC. dB. According to
whole analysis several measurement cycles. The recording was continued
is Meinke et al. (2005) the range r for f =800 MHz is calcu-
was performed by use of MATLAB. The surface plots in Fig. during driving from one stop station to another. The light
or lated with
2 and Fig. 3 show the recorded signal levels PM usikmesse 1
he r over frequency f PWMS are part of Service Auxiliary Broadcasting (SAB) / Ser-
and LP= 32.44dB
Berlin (color coded)
+ 20log + 20log . (abscissa)(3) and vice Auxiliary Program making (SAP) in CEPT (1997)
m. 1000m and willMHz
measurement cycle (ordinate) be discussed in detail
d
in the following subsections.
ic Adv. Radio Sci., 6, 35–38, 2008 www.adv-radio-sci.net/6/35/2008/
ue
3.1 PWMS in daily use
n
S. Dortmund et al.: Considerations on the frequency resource of S.
professional
Dortmundwireless microphone systems
et al.: Considerations 37
on the frequency resource of prof
−30 24
lation cannot be generalized. Therefore a nonlinearity of a
measured ressource
−40 typical PWMS with an input intercept point I P3 =0simulated
dBm was
ressource
with respect to IM3
−50 burdened with the measured spectral load at several measure-
16
−60 ment cycles in a system simulation, considering only inter-
P
+µ σ
load was again compared with Pif =−100 dBm. The simu-
meas
−80
8
P
−90
lation results are displayed in Fig. 5. It is obvious, that the
−100
peak-periode of the spectral load with respect to IM3 at cy-
cle 0 to 125, 500 to 750 and above 1125 exceeds twice the
−110
790 800 810 820 830
freq / [MHz]
840 850 860 amount of the objective
0 spectral
125 250 load.
375 500 In625
the 750
cycle cycles
875 between
1000 1125
125 and 500, IM3 raises the spectral load insignificantly. The
Fig.4.4.99%
99% availability
availability atat“Musikmesse”. maximum load was detected for cycle 1 with a spectral load
Fig. ”Musikmesse” Fig. 5. Subjective spectral load with respect to IM3, ”Musikmess
of 7.2 MHz excluding IM3 and 18 MHz including IM3.
24
measured resource
simulated resource
99% corresponding with µ = 2.33 is determined as a suitable4 Conclusions 4 Conclusions
with respect to IM3
2
availability for PWMS. The availability AV (see Fig. 4) isThis paper shows that PWMS in daily use only requires a
used resource / [MHz]
16
This paper shows that PWMS in daily use only requires
now compared with Pif = −100 dBm defined in sectionsmall part of the available spectrum and that not all PWMS
small part of the available spectrum and that not all PWM
2.1. This leads to in use can be made visible easily. In contrast the results based
in use can be made visible easily. In contrast the results base
AV61−63 8 = 11.88 MHz/24 MHz for the frequency rangeon the on objective frequency availability as well as on the sub-
the objective frequency availability as well as on the su
from f = 790 MHz to f = 814 MHz, jective spectral load including IM3 show that a generously
jective spectral load including IM3 show
determined headroom of the allocated frequency resource that
fora generous
AV67−69 = 18.06 MHz/24 MHz for the frequency rangePWMSdetermined headroom
is strongly required of the
for mass allocated
events and thefrequency
recording resource f
from f =0 838 125
MHz
250
to
375
f 500
= 862
625
MHz
750
and
875 1000 1125 PWMS
of unique is strongly
multimedia required
content. for mass events and the recordin
cycle
AVtotal = 50.78 MHz/72 MHz for the frequency rangeAcknowledgements. of unique multimedia content.
We thank K.-H. Schwaiger (IRT) for post-
from f Subjective
Fig. 5. = 790 MHz f =with
to load
spectral 862respect
MHz.to IM3, ”Musikmesse” processing suggestions and M. Fiks (FHH) for the measurement
support.Acknowledgements. We thank K.-H. Schwaiger (IRT) for pos
3.2.2 Spectral load with respect to in-band intermodulation processing suggestions and M. Fiks (FHH) for the measureme
2
ability for PWMS. The availability AV (see Fig. 4) is now support.
References
compared with Pif = − 100 dBm defined in section 2.1. This
For thetousage in different scenarios a PWMS receiver has to
leads BNetzA: Allgemeinzuteilung von Frequenzen für drahtlose Mikro-
be designed
AV61−63 =11.88with aMHz/24
tradeoffMHz between frequency
for the frequency selectivity,
range to foneReferences
für professionelle Nutzung in den Frequenzbereichen 790–
avoid
from in-band
f =790 MHz intermodulation,
to f =814 MHz, and frequency agility for the 814 und 838–862 MHz, Bonn, Germany, 2005 (http://www.
option to cover
AV67−69 =18.06 different
MHz/24operating
MHz for frequencies.
the frequencyIn range BNetzA: Allgemeinzuteilung von Frequenzen für drahtlo
Germany, bundesnetzagentur.de/media/archive/4469.pdf).
a from
typical frontMHz
f =838 endtobandwidth
f =862 MHz is and
24 MHz or 3 TV-channels. CEPT: TheMikrofone
Chester 1997fürmultilateral
professionelle Nutzung
coordination in denre-Frequenzber
agreement
total =50.78 lated toichen 790-814 und 838-862 MHz, Bonn,proce-
technical criteria, coordination principles and Germany, 200
TheAV spectral loadMHz/72 MHz for
of a mass the frequency
event like the range from
”Musikmesse”
f =790 MHz to f =862 MHz. dures for the introduction of Terrestrial Digial Video Broad-
(http://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/media/archive/4469.pdf)
causes in-band intermodulation inside the receiver front end, casting (DVB-T), Chester, England, 1997 (http://www.ero.dk/
CEPT: The Chester 1997 multilateral coordination agre
resulting from the
3.2.2 Spectral loadhuge
withamount
respect toofin-band
PWMSintermodulation
in use. This leads 132D67A4-8815-48CB-B482-903844887DE3?frames=0).
ment related to technical criteria, coordination princ
to a subjective higher spectral load inside the PWMS receiverERC: Compatibility ples inand
and sharing analysis between DVB-T and radio
procedures for Italy,
the 2000
introduction
than
For the
the objective one presented
usage in different scenariosinasection
PWMS 3.2.1.receiverThehasamount
to microphones bands IV and V, Naples, (http://www.of Terrestri
Digial Video Broadcasting
ero.dk/doc98/official/Word/REP088.DOC). (DVB-T), Chester, Englan
ofbethe
designed
increase withofa spectral
tradeoff between
load due frequency
to in-band selectivity, to
intermodula- 1997
ETSI: Electromagnetic (http://www.ero.dk/132D67A4-8815-48CB-B48
compatibility and Radio Spectrum Mat-
avoid
tion in-band
cannot be intermodulation,
generalized. Thereforeand frequency agility for of
a nonlinearity thea typ-
903844887DE3?frames=0)
ters (ERM), Technical characteristics for Professional Wireless
option to cover different operating frequencies.
ical PWMS with an input intercept point IP3 = 0 dBm was MicrophoneIn Germany, Systems (PWMS),
ERC: Compatibility and System
sharingReference
analysisDocument,
between DVB-T an
a typical front end bandwidth is 24 MHz or 3 TV-channels. Sophia-Antipolis, France, 2006.in bands IV and V, Naples, Italy, 200
burdened with the measured spectral load
The spectral load of a mass event like the “Musikmesse”
at several measure- radio microphones
Konstantinos, M., Athanassios, A. V.,Petros, V. P., Elias, K. K.,
ment cycles in intermodulation
a system simulation, considering only (http://www.ero.dk/doc98/official/Word/REP088.DOC)
causes in-band inside the receiver front end,inter- Nocolaos, R. E., and Constantinou, P.: A new methology for
modulation
resulting from of the
thehuge
thirdamount
order of (IM3).
PWMSThe resulting
in use. ETSI:coordination
spectral frequency
This leads Electromagnetic compatibility and Radio Spectrum Ma
of wireless microphone systems over oc-
loadPinside ters (ERM); Technical characteristics
on wirelessforandProfessional Wirele
load
to a was againhigher
subjective compared
spectralwith if = the−100 PWMS dBm. The sim- cupied TV-spectrum, IEEE Conference
receiver mobile
ulation
than the results
objective are one
displayed
presentedin in
Fig. 5. 3.2.1.
Sect. It is obvious,
The amount that the Microphone
computing, networking Systems
and (PWMS);
communication, System
Montreal, Reference
Canada, Documen
Sophia-Antipolis, France, 2006
of the increase
peak-periode of of
thespectral
spectralload duewith
load to in-band to IM3 at cy- 2005.
respectintermodu-
MeinkeM. H. Konstantinos,
and Gundlach, F. A.V.
W.: Athanassios,
Taschenbuch der V.P.Hochfrequen-
Petros, K.K. Elias, R.
cle 02 Into the
125, 500 to 750 and above 1125 exceeds twice the ztechnik,
following this value will be used, although PWMS Springer Verlag,
Nocolaos R.E., andBerlin, Germany, 1968. A new methology for fr
P. Constantinou:
amount
users and ofmanufacturers
the objective spectral
suppose that aload.
higherIn the cycles
frequency betweenWRC: World
availabil- Radiocommunication
quency coordination ofConference, Provisional Final
wireless microphone systems over o
125
ity and
might500, IM3 raises
be necessary the spectral
for a reliable PWMSload link. insignificantly. The Acts, International Communication Union, Geneva, Swiss, 2007.
cupied TV-spectrum, IEEE Conference on wireless and mobi
maximum load was detected for cycle 1 with a spectral load computing, networking and communication, Montreal, Canad
7.2 MHz
ofAdv. excluding IM3
Radio Sci., 6, 35–38, 2008 and 18 MHz including IM3. 2005 www.adv-radio-sci.net/6/35/2008/
H. Meinke and F.W. Gundlach: Taschenbuch der Hochfreque
2
In the following this value will be used, although PWMS ztechnik, Springer Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 1968
users and manufacturers suppose that a higher frequency availabil- WRC: World Radiocommunication Conference, Provisional Fin