Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spanish-Traces
Spanish-Traces
1 Spring 2016
Association Manager
John Hiscock, PO Box 324, Kanab, UT 84741, phone 435-689-1620, ostamgr@gmail.com
The mission of the Old Spanish Trail Association (OSTA) is 9 Largo Canyon: Crow Canyon Petroglyphs
to study, preserve, protect, interpret and promote appropriate
use of the Old Spanish National Historic Trail (OSNHT). 12-14 OSTA Conference and Registration
OSTA promotes public awareness of the OSNHT and its
multicultural heritage through publications, a website and 15 PNTS Report
interpretive activities; by encouraging research; and by
partnering with governments and private organizations. We 17 Historical Assessments on North Branch
encourage you to join OSTA, help in trail preservation, and
increase appreciation of the multicultural heritage of the 18 Board of Directors Bios
American Southwest.
19 Trading OSTA Memberships
Visit our website: www.oldspanishtrail.org
32 Tenderfoot Campaign
The OSTA website is the place to go for both general and
comprehensive background and recent news on the OSNHT and 36 Membership Information
OSTA. The site contains maps, an overview history of the trail,
and a bibliography of relevant books with links for purchases
of books and other OSTA merchandise from the Association.
There is also a regularly updated news page that contains links
Features
to government reports, activities of OSTA members, and other 20 Spanish Trail Crosses: Treasures Found
news related to the trail. The web page links to National Park
Al Matheson
Service (NPS) and Bureau of Land Management (BLM) sites,
where public documents and maps related to the OSNHT can
be found. Memberships (new or renewal) may be paid on the 26 Ivie Creek Pictograph: Edward A. Geary
OSTA website, and donations, both general and for specific
projects, can be made through the OSTA website as well. 30 Crow Canyon Archaeological Center:
Suzy Meyer
31 Glen Canyon Inscription: Paul Ostapuk
Spanish Traces is the official publication of the Old Spanish Trail
Association (OSTA), a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization, incor- 33 The Trujillo Adobe: Nancy Melendez
porated under the laws of the State of Colorado. Spanish Traces
welcomes submission of articles, book reviews, and OST-related
news. OSTA assumes no responsibility for statements or opinions
35 Red Creek Markings
of contributors. Spanish Traces is copyrighted to OSTA in its en-
tirety, but copyright to individual articles is retained by the author.
The next deadline for submissions is July 18, 2016. All matters On the Cover: Sego Canyon pictographs, located on the
relating to Spanish Traces should be directed to the OSTA Editor. OSNHT North Branch between Grand Junction, Colorado, and
Green River, Utah. The pictographs include Ute era depictions
Ruth Friesen, Spanish Traces Editor, 1046 Red Oaks NE, of horses and riders, possibly influenced by travelers on the Old
Albuquerque, New Mexico 87122
Spanish Trail. The site is admininistered by the BLM.
phone: 505.681.3026 email: ruthosta@comcast.net
Photo: Ruth Friesen
Members of the Fish Lake Chapter of the Old Span- All Chapter members and honorary members have
ish Trail Association are bringing new attention to the now received copies of the recent edition of Spanish
historic trail and to a frequently-used alternate route Traces (Winter 2015) and enjoyed the new format.
through the Central Utah region, known as the Fish This is always much appreciated by us all and is our
Lake Cut Off. real lifeline to the Old Spanish Trail itself and the As-
sociation.
A Resolution is being considered by the Utah State Paid members have also received the publication Driv-
Legislature which supports and encourages the ing the Old Spanish Trail through Utah and Arizona,
designation of the Fish Lake Cut Off as part of the and some great comments on its quality have been
Old Spanish National Historic Trail. Richfield, passed to me. The two authors are to be complimented
Utah, Mayor and active OSTA member David Ogden for their work in this regard.
appeared recently before the Utah Senate Natural
Resources Committee in support of the measure. Since our last chapter report we have lost one member,
Utah Senate Majority Leader Ralph Okerlund, the Yvonne Ramsay, wife of our Chapter President Bill
sponsor of the Resolution, joined Mayor Ogden at the Ramsay, who died in November 2015 after a long ill-
presentation. ness. Members John and Anne Thompson returned to
UK in mid-February, having sojourned for our three
Mayor Ogden noted the historical significance of the coldest months in the Spanish Canary Islands.
Trail, reminding the Senators that during the period
from 1829 to 1848, thousands of horses and mules Also, since we reported in the Autumn 2015 edition of
were moved through Utah from California to New Spanish Traces on the ill-health of Chapter Director
Mexico. He noted that the route varied from time to Bruce Alderson, it is pleasing to report that he is back
time, depending upon available vegetation, weather, at home. The secretary [David Fallowfield] visited
and conflicts with Native Americans. Evidence strong- with him last week in Penrith when he was in the good
ly suggests that the alternate route known as the Fish company of fellow director and Appleby neighbour
Lake Cut Off was frequently used. By identifying and Donald Harrison. We send greetings and best wishes to
designating this and other alternate routes, we add to all the U.S. members and officers of the Association.
our knowledge of the important trade routes that were
--David Fallowfield
traversed by traders, trappers, missionaries and explor-
ers.
tttt
The Natural Resources Committee unanimously ap-
proved the Resolution, it passed through the House
and Senate, and is now on the Governor's desk, await-
ing signature. The Utah State Legislature wraps up its In the News
45-day session on March 10, 2016.
OSTA member Harry Murray has an article published
--David Ogden in the February 2016 issue of Wild West magazine. The
article presents George Yount, "The Taos Trapper Who
Made His Mark."
Weather forecasts for this winter in California called Salida del Sol Chapter’s first meeting of 2016 was
for torrential El Nino rainstorms. The January to April February 20 at the studio of our newest member Liane
period is when the Tecopa chapter does most of its Brown, a spinner and a weaver. Lianne shared her
field survey work, locating and GPS-recording seg- skills and knowledge of wool and weaving.
ments of the OST and the later Mormon Road (MR)
wagon trail. Our annual meeting will take place on April 16, with
time, location and speaker to be announced. Field trips
To date (February 15), however, those storms have are being planned for June and August.
failed to materialize, and the Tecopa chapter is hop-
ing to take advantage of cool but dry winter weather The weekend of April 19 is the Historical Society of
to extend its recording of the Trail. The chapter was New Mexico’s meeting in Farmington, New Mexico,
active in recording during 2015 and has field records at which Rachel Prinz, Dennis Ditmanson, and Pat
and GPS waypoints for about 19 miles of the OST/ Kuhlhoff will make a presentation about the Armijo
MR. Weather permitting, the trail committee hopes and the Main Route trails through the San Juan Basin
this year to add several more miles of OST/MR to our and preservation of the routes there.
inventory. --Pat Kuhlhoff
Largo Canyon:
Crow Canyon Petroglyphs
Crow Canyon is a historic site located in Largo Canyon
on the Armijo Route of the Old Spanish Trail, about
30 miles southeast of Farmington, New Mexico. Largo
Canyon is one of the most sacred areas for the Diné
(Navajo) people. The site, located in Dinétah, the tradi-
tional homeland of the Navajo people, contains a variety
of Navajo ruins and rock art from the 16th, 17th, and
18th centuries, including horse and rider petroglyphs
possibly inspired by the OST that crosses the area. The
Crow Canyon Petroglyphs are the most extensive and
well-known collection of 16th–18th century Navajo
petroglyphs in the American Southwest. The site is
administered by the BLM. See www.blm.gov/nm/st/en/
Photo credit: Camerafiend at the English language Wikipedia (www.gnu. prog/recreation/farmington/crow_canyon.html for more
org/copyleft/fdl.html), from Wikimedia Commons
information.
California State
Public Hearing on Proposed Desert Monuments
On October 13, 2015, California Senator Diane Fein-
stein hosted a public hearing on the proposed national
monuments in California's Mojave Desert—sup-
ported by OSTA and National Parks Conservation
Association members in Washington, D.C.—near
Palm Springs. As an indirect result of Senator Fein-
stein's legislative proposal, President Barack Obama
established the Mojave Trails (BLM), Sand to Snow
(BLM), and Castle Mountains (NPS) National Monu-
The Nevada Chapter continued to place Hal Steiner’s ments by presidential proclamation in February. The
book The Old Spanish Trail Across the Mojave Mojave Trails NM includes portions of the OSNHT.
Desert in many book outlets at both national and state
recreation areas and historic parks. We have found this Planning Session for the 2017 OSTA Conference
to be a good fundraiser for the Nevada Chapter, which On December 3, 2015, Jack Prichett met with Nelson
designates the proceeds to reprinting additional copies Miller, Ed Pearson, and Paul McClure in San Dimas
of the book. Additional funds are procured through to iron out details for the January 2016 OSTA board
donations from members and businesses throughout meeting in Barstow, as well as the October 7, 2017,
Southern Nevada. annual membership meeting also scheduled for Bar-
stow. The conference will coincide with Old Spanish
We are planning a “Spring Fling” in late March in Trail Day and should be an informative and memo-
rable event. --Paul McClure
Colorado State base funded pedestrian signs for trails in the area.
Fort Uncompahgre on the Old Spanish Trail in Delta, Recently, the partners acquired National Park Foun-
Colorado, has a new website. Designed by John Nel- dation Active Trails grant funding for health and
son, the site features pictures, videos, schedules, and wellness events on the recreational trails, additional
history, and went live in November. Visit it at http:// signage for Highway 50 and adjacent roads, and
fortuncompahgre.org. interpretive waysides at trailheads. The NPS funding
will be managed by the Western Colorado Interpretive
Mesa County, and partners OSTA, the City of Grand Association to achieve these actions.
Junction, and the National Park Service have acquired
--Vicki Felmlee
funding for signage, recreational and interpretive
improvements on the OSNHT in the Orchard Mesa -
Whitewater areas. In 2015, the National Park Service
Those are just some of the topics to be explored at the 2016 Old Spanish Trail Association (OSTA)
Conference July 29–30 in Grand Junction, Colorado, at the Clarion Inn. With the theme, “Most Ardu-
ous—Least Respected—Colorado’s Old Spanish Trail,” the conference is sure to be rich in history,
provoke questions, and demonstrate that history is alive and well on the trail.
• Professor Steven Stern - How the Trail’s Ecology has Changed in 200 Years
• Rod Martinez, author of four books - Photographing the Desert
• David Bailey, Curator, Museum of the West, author, and scientist with Western Investigations
Conference fees are only $65 for OSTA members, which includes all presentations, field trips (with free
transportation), reception, refreshments, and private tour of the Western Colorado Museum.
A special deal is available for those becoming new members of OSTA, a total of $85; $65 for confer-
ence registration, and $20 for annual individual membership (a $5 discount from the normal annual
membership rate of $25). For those who choose not to become members, the conference registration
rate is $75.
The banquet Saturday night is only $27 (members and non-members), which will include entertainment
and door prizes.
The Clarion Inn is hosting the conference and is providing a block of rooms at the special rate of $84,
which includes a hot breakfast. The address is 755 Horizon Drive, just off of I-70, and contact info is
970-243-6790. Early reservations are encouraged (mention the conference).
See the reverse side of this page for a registration form you can mail.
Just fill out this form and mail with your check or money order (made out to Old Spanish Trail Association) to:
Ms. Vicki Felmlee 178 Glory View Drive Grand Junction, CO 81503
Name(s) ___________________________________________________________
Address ___________________________________________________________
Email ___________________________________________________________
OSTA member? ____ Yes ____No (see our special membership/conference fees below)
Conference - includes Friday evening reception, refreshments, all field trips with transportation—the Free Ride—to and from field trips
(departing from and returning to the Clarion Inn)
Total - Please make check out to Old Spanish Trail Association $ __________
Please indicate if you want the Free Ride. Seating is limited, so get in quick.
Yes, I want the Free Ride for the Friday field trip _____ person(s)
to the “Back to the Trail” anniversary ceremony
Yes, I want the Free Ride for the Saturday field trip _____ person(s)
to Las Colonias Historical Park
* Individual OSTA membership is $25 per year. Membership includes three issues of Spanish Traces, OSTA’s periodical of technical pa-
pers, news, book reviews, local chapter information, and updates; and advocacy, education, leadership, and management opportunities.
Trading OSTA Memberships Approved • While speaking opportunities are often open to
non-members, actual members might have more
The Board of the Old Spanish Trail Association has and longer speaking opportunities and “enhanced
approved a policy to allow OSTA chapters the oppor- introduction” opportunities at meetings. Addition-
tunity to trade memberships with local organizations ally, OSTA chapter meetings would give similar
and groups. opportunities to the partner.
Currently, an OSTA chapter can add an organization/ • Links to websites and other information about the
club/group to the OSTA membership roster with the OSTA chapter would be included in the partner’s
sole intention of sending Spanish Traces to that or- newsletter, mailings, and Internet features, and
ganization/club/group. Chapters can now establish a would be reciprocated by the OSTA chapter, if ap-
more structured, beneficial, and communicated ap- plicable.
proach for an OSTA Chapter to form community part-
nerships, with the following significant advantages: OSTA chapters can use complete discretion over the
groups that are considered for membership trade, and
• Increase community attention and education about it is completely optional. The trade is a full trade—no
the Trail and the OSTA Chapter, and increase discounts. Partners would not receive the printed ver-
membership through outreach to like-minded sions of Spanish Traces, but would be able to access
members of the community. electronic/digital versions of the journal.
• OSTA chapter members would be introduced to a While the OSTA chapter can consider any group for
wider variety of community members, including the trade, some obvious local groups are museums and
business owners, who might be interested in the libraries, historical societies, Native American and
Trail and the chapter. Hispanic groups, and smaller Chambers of Commerce.
• Many groups have meetings and activities, includ- More information will be developed and added to the
ing networking opportunities (i.e., Business After website at oldspanishtrail.org. Call Vicki Felmlee,
Hours), where OSTA chapter members might be Colorado Director, at 970-245-8484 with any ques-
able to attend as members. tions.
Spring 2016 Spanish Traces 19
Spanish Trail Crosses: Treasures Found
By Al Matheson (OSTA) member near the Santa Clara River, presum-
ably where Armijo would have likely bypassed the
Long before the Old Spanish National Historic Trail Virgin River Gorge. Such petroglyphic inscriptions
came into being, the waters of Lake Bonneville served routinely bear evidence of Spanish travel, and to dis-
as an impenetrable barrier between the interior of the cover even one more Spanish Trail treasure can really
continent and the Pacific Ocean.1 When the waters of make your day.
the lake receded, the southern shoreline was exposed,
and a convenient corridor for trade and transit was The thrill of discovering another Trail Treasure was
discovered. Native Americans availed themselves repeated when members of the Southern Utah Chapter
of the opportunity to find new lands and new trade of OSTA discovered deeply engraved crosses (illus-
routes, the rim of the Great Basin2 becoming a natural tration 2) while searching for possible trail segments
highway of commerce. Thus it is no surprise that the along the Arizona Strip.3 Several years ago, Jim Guy-
original Great Basin corridor continued as the route man was one of the first to start the treasure hunting
of choice, and often the only choice, for transport and craze, but other OSTA members have been following
commerce through Great Basin country. And as travel- his lead since that time.
ers are wont to do, both Indians and Spanish travel-
ers along The Old Spanish National Historic Trail What Jim discovered was one of several steel Spanish
(OSNHT) left ample evidence of their passing. crosses incised in hard sandstone, each etched with a
unique “tail” attached. Chapter member and renowned
The Indians did so in their descriptive rock art along Spanish recorder Lyman Platt has identified the char-
established trails. The Spanish and Mexicans used acteristic crosses as being typical Spanish directional
inscriptive crosses or initials while traveling the same markers. The tail of any given cross was often used to
trails. The findings represented herein were all identi- direct travelers toward a nearby mission and/or water
fied by Association members along Old Spanish Trail location. Lyman also found them to be period specific
(OST) segments in either Iron or Washington County for the nationally designated OSNHT.
in Southern Utah and Mohave County, Arizona.
Another pictographic cross was found in the vicinity
Antonio Armijo may have been the first to leave evi- of the Armijo crosses, along with a typical Zia sun
dence of his transit through Southern Utah and North-
ern Arizona, but his better-informed followers elected
to follow a more northerly route, doing so within the
Great Basin corridor between Paragonah, Utah, and
Castle Cliff, Utah. This petroglyphic image (illustra-
tion 1) was found by an Old Spanish Trail Association
1. Spanish Trail
mule
2. Double crosses
4. Spanish spear
6. Castle Cliff Aerial
13. Date inscription over a petroglyph 15. Mounted horsemen and mountain goats on OST trailside
3. The Grand Canyon isolates the Arizona Strip from the rest of
16. Cross of Lorraine Arizona, making it among the most remote and rugged public
land in the lower 48 states. http://www.blm.gov/az/st/en/fo/
arizona_strip_field.html, accessed February 4, 2016.
exact location where the pictograph was found. Either
treasure was worth the time spent treasure hunting on 4. See John Azar, "Witch Pool," The Ol' Pioneer - The Quarterly
the Old Spanish Trail (illustration 17). Magazine of the Grand Canyon Historical Society, Vol. 17, No.
3, Jul/Aug/Sep 2006, p.3 for more information on the history
of this site. Read it www.grandcanyonhistory.org/Publications/
Just like gold, treasure is where you find it. While it TheOlPioneer/TOP_2006_3.pdf .
is not every day or every person who is fortunate to
find trail treasure on The Old Spanish National His- 5. Frederick S. Dellenbaugh. A Canyon Voyage: The Narrative
toric Trail, for those willing to try, it is highly unlikely of the Second Powell Expedition down the Green-Colorado River
they will be disappointed in their experience. All of from Wyoming, and the Explorations on Land, in the Years 1871
and 1872. Reprint of the 1962 edition, (University of Arizona
the discoveries herein were located by one or more Press, 1984).
OSTA members on or near the Old Spanish Trail, and
I suspect there are many more treasures waiting to be All photos by Al Matheson.
discovered. Is that an invitation for you to try? Yes, it
is.
Kenneth B. Castleton included a black-and-white pho- 12. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, and Price, Utah:
College of Eastern Utah Prehistoric Museum, 2010, 109.
tograph of the panel and a reproduction of Ethan Pettit’s
sketch in his voluminous Petroglyphs and Pictographs
of Utah.11 More recently, Steven R. Simms and Francois Edward Geary is an emeritus professor at Brigham Young Univer-
Gohier printed a large color photo in Traces of Fre- sity who retired to his native Huntington, Utah, to pursue interests
mont: Society and Rock Art in Ancient Utah.12 that include historic trails and prehistoric rock art. Among his
publications are Goodbye to Poplarhaven: Recollections of a
[The Ivie Creek pictograph panel, on Fishlake National Utah Boyhood and The Proper Edge of the Sky: The High Plateau
Country of Utah.
A unique aspect of the center is the way it involves the The Center’s one-hour Crow Canyon Tour is an even
public in its work. Through the flagship Archaeology briefer introduction into archaeology and the center’s
Research Program, adults can spend a week excavat- programs. It’s held on Wednesday, Thursday, and Fri-
ing alongside Crow Canyon’s professional archaeolo- day mornings.
30 Spanish Traces Spring 2016
Glen Canyon Inscription Being Protected
By Paul Ostapuk
In September 2006, a group of volunteers removing
graffiti in the Glen Canyon National Recreational Area
reported a “Paso por Aqui Año 1776” inscription. The
finding was historically significant and likely related
to the Dominguez-Escalante expedition of the same
year, whose successful ford of the Colorado River
became known as “The Crossing of the Fathers” (now
Padre Bay, Lake Powell). This historic ford is also part
of the Old Spanish National Historic Trail.
Stopped short of their destination by unknown ter- Expedition members became the first non-native
people to cross the Colorado River at a site later called
El Vado de Los Padres, the Crossing of the Fathers.
Crow Canyon also has programs for school groups
from fourth grade through high school, one-week
After 235 years, the 1776 Paso Por Aqui inscription
camps for middle school and high school students,
longer field schools for high school and college stu- survives as a faint whisper carved into the soft Entrada
dents, and an annual program for educators sponsored Sandstone. Although marred by graffiti, the inscription
by the National Endowment for the Humanities. and the physical setting provide emotional context and
a powerful interpretive opportunity.
More information about all programs―as well as a
wealth of information about the people and archaeol- [After Chapter members and stakeholders visit the site
ogy of the Central Mesa Verde region and the results this spring with the NPS to view the new protective
of Crow Canyon’s extensive research programs―is fence, an update will be written for the Autumn issue
available at the Center’s website, www.crowcanyon. of Spanish Traces, describing NPS efforts to protect
org, or by calling 1-800-422-8975, ext. 451. the site.]