Professional Documents
Culture Documents
002
002
002
net/publication/330997303
CITATIONS READS
6 3,511
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Gandu Srikanth on 30 April 2019.
M.Tech Student1#*, Department of Civil Engineering, Lovely Professional University, 144411, Punjab, India.
gandusreekanth@gmail.com
Assistant Professor 2 Department of Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology- Jalandhar, 144011, Punjab, India.
kumarr@nitj.ac.in, Corresponding Author
Assistant Professor3 Department of Civil Engineering, Lovely Professional University,144411, Punjab, India.
rohit.22225@lpu.co.in
ABSTRACT
Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) is a new trend developed in Europe and after successful implementation in Europe USA
also accepted the warm mix technology in all 50 states. Presently in India Central Road Research Institute – Delhi
and some of the other organization working on this trend. To reduce the emission of various hazardous gas fumes,
consumption of fuel, compaction & placing Temperature and haul distance industries have Warm Mix Asphalt
instead of hot mix asphalt (HMA). Here they achieve all the properties similar to HMA meanwhile reducing
demerits of HMA by adding various types of additives like emulsions, wax based, chemical & foam technologies
etc. By the order of Supreme Court of India to shut down HMA plants in metropolitan cities so, WMA is an
alternative mix type in metropolitan cities. This paper is the review about various trends, merits & de-merits,
technical aspects, various temperatures of additives while adding with binders, various live examples where this
technology implemented, mix design, performance tests on WMA
KEYWORDS: Warm; Cold and Hot mixes; Mixing and Compaction Global Warming; Haul Distance.
INTRODUCTION
The hot mix asphalt industries constantly working to develop various technologies to enhance pavement
performance, construction efficiency, conserve resources, material improvement and environmental aspects
(Newcomb 2007). In that case, Hot mix asphalt also has a significant role in fuel consumption for heating aggregates
and binder and release various hazardous air pollutants. So, manufacturers need an alternative mix type that can
reduce these effects with same or better results. In HMA, temperature maintenance of aggregates, binder and mix is
a major issue so, to defeat that, asphalt industries constantly working on various asphalt mixes (Ex: Warm & Half-
Warm, Cold, LEA etc.) by reducing mixing & compaction temperature which will lead to reduce energy
consumption and environment pollutants. Mixing temperature of WMA is 110 to 140 OC compare to HMA of 150 to
180 OC (Behl et al. 2013). To safeguard the fossil fuel utilization, strong environmental acts, economical, haul
distances and global warming researchers are focusing on the warm mix technology (Figure 1).
ASMMCE’18 525
Proceedings of National Conference: Advanced Structures, Materials And Methodology in Civil Engineering
(ASMMCE – 2018), 03 - 04th November, 2018
PAPER CODE: T-407
WMA is a generic term for various technologies and products that are incorporated into plant produced HMA to
decrease the plant mixing, roadway paving and compaction temperatures while maintaining workability. It’s a
compaction aid for HMA. Warm mix is produced by decreasing the viscosity of binder or Surface Tension at
Asphalt Aggregate Interface or by increasing workability of mix in less temperature. WMA allow mixing, placing
and transporting process at low temperature. It’s not a mix type it is a technology that can use in any mix type where
to decrease mixing & compaction temperature (MS-2 2014).
The main goal of this paper is to write a review on the aspects associated with WMA involving background, history,
advantages and dis-advantages, various WMA technologies & mechanism’s, mix design, best practices for
producing WMA, lab experiments of warm mix asphalt and Various projects in India.
1 1956 LadisCsanyi, Iowa Foamed Foamed bitumen for use as a soil binder
State University
2 1968 Mobil Oil Australia Foamed Adding cold water rather than steam into
the hot bitumen
5 1994 Maccarrone, Foamed (Cold Mix) He introduced Cold Mix Asphalt using
G.Holleran Foamed Technology
Advantages :-(D’Angelo et al 2008),(AmbikaBehl 2016),(EAPA 2010), (Sangiorgi 2018), &(Prowell et al. 2014).
a) General: Significant less mixing & compaction temperature, less energy consumption, reduce hazardous
fumes emission, due to less difference between placing and surrounding ambient temperature we can
have long-haul distances, paving in un-attainable places, reduce thermal segregation, less aging effect,
faster construction i.e, compaction temperature is less (less curing time) so we can open traffic in less
time only , Improved deep lift & thin lift in Asphalt pavement, WMA has good compatibility with
RAP so there is reduction in usage of virgin materials and give good kick start to recycle theme
(Zaumanis 2010)
b) Environment: Mainly it decreasesgreenhouse gases by 25-30%. So, this would earn tradable carbon credits
(IRC:SP:101- 2014). It is quite compactable with reclaimed asphalt pavement technology (RAP) that
saves utilizing virgin materials and reduce the hazardous effect of dumping the damaged pavement
materials. Typically 30-40 % of CO2 & SO2, 50 % of Volatile Organic Compounds, 10-30 % or CO,
60-70 % of NOX and 20-25 % of dust reduced by using WMA(D’Angelo et al 2008)(Table-2).
Decreasing the mixing temperature leads to the energy consumption of 35 % and more based on
process.
c) Health Benefits: During mixing PAH fumes contain carcinogenic, mutagenic and teratogenic elements that
cause severe health issue for workers.30-50 % of aerosol/fumes and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
(PAH) that affect the workers and surrounding area peoples also get reduced(Prowell et al 2014).
d) Technical Advantages: Less aging& oxidation of bitumen that delay fatigue cracks of pavement, high
workability, enough compaction time, longer haul distances, allow construction during cold weather
condition also.
e) Economical: Average production temperature of WMA is 27-30oC that results an average 22.1 % decrease
in fuel consumption and rest temperature maintain vehicles, burners etc make the value 35 % energy
consumption so parallelly the cost also reduced. Decrease load on Mixing Plant leads to less
maintenance and extend plant life.
f)
Drawbacks: WMA is susceptibility to moisture damage. Due to less mixing temperature leads to incomplete drying
of aggregates the moisture may get trapped in the pavement and leads to moisture damage. WAM have less aging
(Stiffness) of binder so it faces rutting. The initial production cost of WMA is high (Ex: Production at Iceland per-
ton $0.30 for WAM-Foam, $3.50 for Sasobit, and $4.00 for Aspha-Min).
Figure 2: Classification by temperature range, temperatures, and fuel usage are approx. (D’Angelo et al 2008)
2) Based on the type of additive we have three types a) Foaming (Water containing & Water based) b) Chemical
(polymers & Emulsification agents) c) Organic (synthetic wax, fatty acids, amides).
3) Based on purpose: a) Hybrid b) Rheological Modifiers c) Others
a) Foaming :(Zaumanis 2010) (Hurley et al. 2005) water expand 1600 times when converted into steam at
atmospheric pressure when this steam gets entrapped with viscous bitumen it produces foam then results in an
increase in its volume and decrease in viscosity(AmbikaBehl 2016). When preheated aggregates combine with this
foam (high volume bitumen or high surface area bitumen) enable coating of aggregates at a lower temperature.
Foaming technology is subcategorized into two types a) water-based b) water combined. In the water-based water is
injected with a foam generating machine and on other hand water combined here we use zeolites like
aluminosilicates of alkali metals (have 20% water content) when this type of zeolites gets combined with preheated
binder water get release and the same process continue to produce foam and warm mix. These synthetic zeolites are
added to the binder at the rate of 0.25 % by weight. Due to the presence of water stripping may occur so to
overcome this issue it is recommended to have chemical additives that promote the coating of aggregates and
decrease water sensitivity of mix.
ASMMCE’18 Srikanth, G 528
Proceedings of National Conference: Advanced Structures, Materials And Methodology in Civil Engineering
(ASMMCE – 2018), 03 - 04th November, 2018
PAPER CODE: T-407
Foaming technology is also used in Low Emission Asphalt (LEA) process. Here coarse and a portion of fine
aggregates are heated at normal HMA temperature and a coating and adhesion additives approx 0.50 % by weight of
binder after adding them heated, wet, coated and remaining fine aggregates or RAP mix together during this vapors
of 3-4 % is released and turn into foam and process continue up to aggregate coating.
Foam asphalt is also used in two-stage WMA process. It has two binders soft and hard binder. Soft binder ranges
between 20-30 % to total binder content first they make completely coat coarse aggregates and on second hard
binder get a coat to pre-coated aggregates.
Ex: Aspha Min, Advera, Double barrell green, Ultrafoam GX
b) Chemical :(Hurley et al. 2006) Generally this technology doesn’t depend on viscosity or foaming to make
changes in mixing and compaction temperature it uses improves chemical additives as surface agents, improve
aggregate coating, anti-stripping agent’s. It mostly contains polymers and emulsification agents etc. Generally, these
chemicals will get mix with binder directly. At normal temperature, it improves interfacial adhesion.
Ex: Rediset&Cecabase improve wetting of aggregates by bitumen, Evotherm is an American technology which
absorbs less water than emulsions. Evotherm 3G is the latest technology which is a water-free warm technology.
Ex: Evotherm, rediset& Table 3
d) Hybrid :( IRC: SP: 101- 2014) It’s a combination of two more technologies to achieve required results.
Ex: Low Energy Asphalt is a combination of Chemical and water based on improving aggregate coating at less
temperature.
e) Rheological Modifiers :( IRC: SP: 101- 2014) Here industries use such an additive to improve the rheological
properties of asphalt mix.
Ex: - Wax based additives modify the viscosity of binder.
f) Others :-( IRC: SP: 101- 2014) These are such products manufactured for other purposes but we incorporating
them to produce warm mix.
Ex:- Sulfur & Trinidad Lake Asphalt
ADVERA® WMA PQ Corporation 0.25% by total mass of the mixture 130-170 based on Binder Stiffness
LEA, also LEACO, Fairco, and 0.2 to 0.5 % by weight of Bitumen <100
EIFFAGETravauxPublics
EBE and EBT
Organic Additives
Licomont BS 100® Clariant 3% by weight of asphalt mixture 130-170 based on Binder Stiffness
Chemical Additives
Emerging US technology
Double- Barrel Green Astec Not necessary; an antistripping agent may 116-135
be added similar to normal HMA
Lab tests for Warm Mix Asphalt: (Bonaquist 2011) & (IRC:SP:101- 2014)NCHRP: 691 & WMA IRC-SP:101-
2014 have specified few performance tests for WMA although quality and performance tests are similar for both
WMA & HMA as per IRC:111 guidelines but mixing and compaction temperature of WMA is 30 OC lesser than
HMA.
They are three tests for WMA 1) Coating 2) Compatibility 3) Moisture Sensitivity.
a) Compacting: AASHTO T 195 : Min 95 % of coarse aggregate shall be coated.
b) Compatibility: AASHTO T245 : Ratio shall be such that 0.9 <R<1.1
c) Moisture Susceptibility: AASHTO T245 : Tensile Strength Ratio shall be greater than 80% as per IRC: 111
Indian Scenario :(Behl et al. 2013) & (Kumar 2016) India adopt this Warm Mix Asphalt since 2009 by Central
Road Research Institute -New Delhi its first trail begins with 0.50 KM stretch road using Thiopave additive at
Bavana Industrial area owned by DSIDC.
Basically, we have two WMA suppliers they are Shell and MWV (MeanWestvaco). Shell provide Thiopave and
MWV supply Evotherm. Shell Thiopave get accreditation by IRC because they are improving the mechanical
properties of AshokaBuildcon Ltd under gridlines of Ashoka Highway Research Center working on Thiopave since
2010. Since 2009 they are few projects constructed using WMA they are Bhavana Industrial Area (0.5 KM, 2009),
NH-3 (210 KM, Thiopave, 2010), NH-10 (Evotherm,2011), SH-5 Gujarat (1KM, VG-30,2011).
CONCLUSION:
Based upon the literature review its very clear that it has many advantages and for disadvantages, here have
solutions to reduce its negative effect. It’s an alternative way for HMA in metropolitan cities. WMA exhibiting same
positive results of HMA (Approx). Due to lower mixing temperature, it is reducing the aging of binder that that
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
With the grace of my parent's Srinivas Rao & Annapurna, my supporting faculty Mr.Charanjot Singh and Dr. Rajiv
Kumar, I have been constantly empowering myself, professionally and personally. Mr.RohitVasudeva & Ms.Banita
Sharma sustained and encouraged me in this field and encouraged me to write this paper. So, I would like to extend
my heartfelt gratitude to all of them.
REFERENCES
AmbikaBehl., 2016. “Performance Characteristics Of Warm Mix Asphalt.” PhD Thesis, IIT-Roorkee,
India.http://shodhbhagirathi.iitr.ac.in:8081/jspui/image/pdf/web/viewer.html?file=/jspui/bitstream/123456789/
13851/1/thesis%20final%2014.4.pdf
AmbikaBehl. (2013). “Rheological Characterization of Bituminous Binder containing Wax based Warm Mix
Asphalt Additive.” IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering, 9(1), 16–
22.http://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jmce/papers/vol9-issue1/C0911622.pdf
Behl, A., Kumar, G., Sharma, G., and Jain, P. K. (2013). “Evaluation of field performance of warm-mix asphalt
pavements in India.” Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Elsevier B.V., 104, 158–
167.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877042813044996
Bonaquist, R. (2011). Mix design practices for warm mix asphalt. NCHRP Report 691. Available online at
http://co-asphalt.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/nchrp_rpt_691.pdfAccessed August 25, 2015.
Button, J. W., Estakhri, C., and Wimsatt, A. (2007). “This synthesis documents the results of a comprehensive
review of worldwide information dealing with the following issues as related to warm-mix asphalt ( WMA )
technology : current state of the art / practice of WMA , benefits and costs of WMA technology.”
7(2).https://static.tti.tamu.edu/swutc.tamu.edu/publications/technicalreports/0-5597-1.pdf
Capitão, S. D., Picado-santos, L. G., and Martinho, F. (2012). “Pavement engineering materials : Review on the use
of warm-mix asphalt.” 36, 1016–1024.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950061812004308
D’Angelo J, Harm E, Bartoszek J, Baumgardner G, Corrigan M, Cowsert J, Harman T, Jamshidi M, Jones W,
Newcomb D, Prowell B, Sines R, Yeaton B. Warm-Mix Asphalt: European Practice FHWA Report No.
FHWA-PL-08-007; 2008. https://international.fhwa.dot.gov/pubs/pl08007/pl08007.pdf
Dinis-almeida, M. (2010). “Mix Design Criteria for Half Warm Asphalt Recycling ( HWMR ) - Case Study Mix
Design Criteria for Half Warm Asphalt Recycling ( HWMR ) - Case Study.”
(May).https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236118336_Mix_Design_Criteria_for_Half_Warm_Asphalt_
Recycling_HWMR_-_Case_Study