Development of Real-Time Damage Estimation

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

2013 International Conference on Signal-Image Technology & Internet-Based Systems

Development of Real-Time Damage Estimation


System for Embankment
Using Earthquake Early Warning

Tsuneo OHSUMI
Principal Research Fellow, Disaster Risk Research Unit,
National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention (NIED)
3-1 Tenodai, tsukuba, Ibaraki, 303-0006 Japan
E-mail: t_ohsumi@bosai.go.jp

Abstract— In this paper, some limitations about Earthquake before the arrival of the strong motions caused by the quake. In
Early Warning (EEW) were examined, which had become those areas close to the focus of the earthquake, however, the
apparent during and after the 2011 off the Pacific Coast of EEW may not be transmitted before the strong motions arrive.
Tohoku Earthquake. The proposal system analyzes automatically
correcting a detection error when server gets earthquake Before the S-wave motion comes, it is possible to utilize
information more than magnitude M7.5. The estimation method the supplementary information for help in decisions on and
for embankment settlement is performed using “Damaged priorities which correspond immediately after the subsiding of
Tables”. Thus, the earthquake damage of embankments against the quake according to information gained from the ground-
large earthquake can be evaluated. motion duration time..

Keywords— 2011 off the Pacific Coast of Tohoku Earthquake, B. Ground amplification ratio
Earthquake Early Warning (EEW), embankment, settlement
The major factor which controls the site effect is S-wave
velocities of the surficial sediments. We can therefore estimate
I. INTRODUCTION the site amplification characteristics from the S-wave velocities
The author proposed a solution to the issues of of the near surface layers. Averaged S-wave velocity in the
underestimation of the magnitude and seismic intensities of uppermost 30 m (AVS30) has been widely used to assess site
major earthquakes and that alarms were announced to area conditions which can be used for predicting earthquake ground
within a certain definite range from the epicenter, not judging motion [2]. We used amplification map based on 30-second
from seismic intensities estimated by the empirical equations. JEGM in grid cells of 7.5 arc-seconds JEGM, which is open
This solution is a method which a licensed business operator website by Japan Seismic Hazard Information Station
can use for the major earthquakes, and the author applied this (J-SHIS) [3] with the National Research Institute for Earth
solution to a prototype of a decision-making support system for Science and Disaster Prevention (NIED). A ground
an expressway company. Also, for false alarms when two amplification ratio was calculated by Fujimoto and
earthquakes occurred close to one another. The author Midorikawa (2006) [4] for AVS30 and velocity amplification
quantified the probability of false alarms and developed a relations.
decision-making support method for changing the operation
form of the disaster prevention system. C. Realtime ground-motion monitoring system(Kyoshin
monitor)
II. SYSTEM COMPONENT As a result of having analyzed the EEW at the time of the
2011 off the Pacific Coast of Tohoku Earthquake, the result
A. Earthquake Early Warning (EEW) was insufficient for the reporting of emergency earthquake
Using the focus information on the Earthquake Early breaking news that a great earthquake of more than magnitude
Warning (EEW) an early warning can be acquired several M8 was coming.
minutes earlier rather than using another earthquake Thus, now the proposal system analyzes automatically
information. The EEW (Kinky Jishin Sokuh) is a warning correcting a detection error when server gets earthquake
issued just after an earthquake in Japan is detected [1] (Fig.1). information more than magnitude M7.5 (Fig. 2). The correcting
The warnings are issued mainly by the Japan Meteorological of a detection error is analyzed by using K-NET and KiK-net
Agency (JMA), and they issue tips on how to react to the seismometers observation data, which are real time open data
warnings. The purpose of the EEW is to quickly announce to by the real-time ground-motion monitoring systems (Fig. 3).
the public that an earthquake has occurred and to inform them
of the estimated seismic intensity several seconds or more

978-1-4799-3211-5/13 $31.00 © 2013 IEEE 854


DOI 10.1109/SITIS.2013.139
Fig.1. The Earthquake Early Warning system provides advance announcement of the estimated seismic intensities and
expected arrival time of principal motion. http://www.jma.go.jp/jma/en/Activities/eew.html [1]

Fig.3. Realtime ground-motion monitoring system


(Kyoshin monitor) http://www.kyoshin.bosai.go.jp/ [3]

Fig.2. Prototype Processing Image of Read-Time Damage Estimation


System for Embankment Using EEW㸬

855
D. Seismic Intensity Prediction Technique F. Digital Japan Portal Web Site Systems

In the seismic intensity prediction from EEW’s hypocenter This study used the GEBCO Digital Atlas, which the
uses the information is used attenuation relationship with fault Geographical Survey Institute provided to Digital Japan Portal
distance by Si and Midorikawa (1999) [5]. Therefore, the Web Site. A data file is established in format information
“fault distance” is defined by subtracting half of the estimated "Digital Japan Portal Web Site" [8] in text (XML) form. An
dislocation length from the hypocenter distance [6]. A ground HTML file to the information disclosure server (Web server),
amplification ratio, which is was shown in chapter II.B, is used. which indicates a Web page. In the HTML file, Digital Japan
And relationship between the average shear-wave velocity and Portal Web systems is described that API function with
the site amplification is used Fujimoto and Midrarikawa (2005) JavaScript.
[7], which computed the relation by using the peak ground If a user accesses the HTML file of an information
motions recorded at two nearby station points. In this case, a disclosure server using a web browser, information can be
reference observation point was used KiK-net Kainan, which is perused in the state where it overlapped with the background
located at the nearest NIED’s station with the target river map of the Geographical Survey Institute.
embankment.

G. Real-Time Damage Estimation Systems


E. Estimation Method of Embankment Settlement
The hypocenter information is acquired from the final
The estimation method for embankment settlement is announcement of EEW. To improve an estimate intensity by
performed using “Earthquake Damage Estimating Tables” automatically correcting a detection error caused when a
which are calculated using seismic intensity and embankment difference between an estimated acceleration and an observed
settlement. The “Earthquake Damage Estimating Tables” are acceleration is recoded by real-time ground-motion
calculated combining the results of the effective stress monitoring system (Kyoshin monitor).
analyses and previous earthquake damage within the The amount of subsidence in the top of an embankment
Tokushima area of embankments. Thus, the earthquake was evaluated from the result of the estimated seismic intensity,
damage of embankments against large earthquake can be and the system automatically sent a notification to a river
evaluated. administrator.
Furthermore, these “Damaged Tables” can be upgraded and The calculated results of the earthquake can be seen in the
improved by more reliable calculations in the future. analysis server which carries out a file output in the form which
can be displayed in the Digital Japan Portal Web systems. The
river administrator can peruse the analysis result by accessing
this server using a browser.

Read-Time Damage Estimation Systems


GEBCO Digital Atlas
Earthquake
Early Warning

Output
䠄XMLFiles䠅
Distribution Enterprises
(a) Information (b) Information Geographical Survey Institute
Digital Japan Portal Web Site
Processing Server Disclosure Server
NIED

Stacking

This mail is transmitted


Realtime ground-motion
to the portable
monitoring system
telephone or PC.
(Kyoshin monitor) The systems convertible to a
file form perusable by a general
browser.

Administrator

Fig.4. Prototype Image of Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment Using EEW.

856
H. Information output function

The contents exhibited by an information disclosure server


are shown. A river administrator accesses the information
disclosure server using a browser. The page has composition
shown in Fig. 4. The top page will be indicated the table when
more powerful tremors exceed the seismic intensity threshold
set up beforehand (Fig.5). This table is the structure
automatically added to a list.
The display page of a ground amplification ratio is shown
in Fig. 6.According to the size of a ground amplification ratio,
the levels are distinguished by different color.
Operation result pages include a seismic intensity
distribution information-on-forecast page and the amount Fig.4  Information Disclosure Server
information-on-forecast page of settlement.
On a seismic intensity distribution information-on-forecast
page (Fig.7), the map display of the seismic intensity
distribution is displayed in color boxes along the liver. Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment
By the check box of the lower part of a screen, a river levee
part and color boxes can change a display and un-displaying,
respectively.
The amount of prediction subsidence of an embankment is
expressed as the amount information-on-forecast page of Estimated Intensity, Settlement
subsidence (Fig. 8).

Ground amplification ratio


III. CONCLUSION
In this study, a prototype decision-making support system
for river admistrators was developed so that the admistrators
can take initial response quickly to earthquake disasters. The
Embankment needs safety checks without delay just after a
large earthquake, even if the structure has been seismic- Estimated   Top Page
Fig.5Settlement
resistant designed as a proactive measurement.
In order to support emergency checkup just after the large settlement is performed using “Earthquake Damage Estimating
earthquake, a prototype decision-making support system for Tables” as high accuracy calculated tables.
river administrator was developed, which provides the
For earthquake vibrations values in each 250 m mesh box,
information about damage estimates for embankments using Japan real-time seismic-intensity exposed-population
EEW seismic parameters and about structures which need estimation system (J-RISQ) [10] will be applied in the future.
preferred checkups. The use of J-RISK for building earthquake vulnerability
Some limitations about EEW are examined which have analysis and for sending other related information as quickly as
been pointed out but have not been actively discussed about possible is under construction by NIED. J-RISK will be able to
those influences. Especially, the issues such as underestimation assist with damage estimate for an earthquake, exposed-
of the magnitude and seismic intensities at major earthquakes population estimation, hazard analysis, and damage analysis by
and false alarms when two earthquakes occurred close to one combining observational data such as real-time severe
another in spatially and in temporally were serious for users of earthquake data obtained from K-NET, KiK-net, a seismic
EEW, after the 2011 off the Pacific Coast of Tohoku intensity information network with a site specific amplitude
Earthquake. Similar problems could occur at the Nankai data, and population and building data.
Trough Earthquake. Some countermeasures for the problems Therefore, we would like to contribute “Real-time
are discussed and proposed, which can be performed by the
Embankment Damage Estimation” into the J-RISK system.
licensed operators of ground motion forecasting services.
“The Seismic Performance Evaluation Chart-system for
Coastal Structures” is construction by Ministry Land,
Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism Kinki Regional
Development Bureau [9]. This system can be apprised for
embankment

857
Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment

Ground amplification ratio Ground amplification ratio

Fig.6  Ground amplification ratio (Left: whole area, Right: embankment only )

Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment Read-Time Damage Estimation System for Embankment

Estimated Intensity Estimated Settlement

Fig.7 Estimated Intensity Map Fig.8 Estimated Settlement

858
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Records at Nearby Station Pairs, Journal of Japan Association for
Earthquake Engineering, Vol. 6, No. 1, pp. 11 - 22, 2006.
This study was supported by a Grant-in-Aid for technology [5] H. Si, and S. Midorikawa, New Attenuation Relationships for Peak
development in 2012 construction work (2012-01) to Tsuneo Ground Acceleration and Velocity Considering Effects of Fault Type
Ohsumi by the General Incorporated Association, Shikoku- and Site Condition, Journal of Structural and Construction Engineering,
Create, while at Tokushima University as professor. 523, pp. 63 - 70, 1999.
[6] T. Utsu, Seismology, kyoritsu_pub,1977㸬
[7] K. Fujimoto, and S. Midorikawa, Empirical Method for Estimation
J.M.A. Instrumental Seismic Intensity from Ground Motion Parameters
Using Strong Motion Records during Recent Major Earthquakes,
REFERENCES Journal of Social Safety Science, No. 7, pp. 241 ̽ 246, 2005.
[1] Earthquake Early Warnings, EEW, [8] Digital Japan Portal Web Site Web.NEXT
http://www.jma.go.jp/jma/en/Activities/eew.html http://portal.cyberjapan.jp/site/mapuse/index.html
[2] M. Mataoka, K. Wakamatsu, , Amplification map based on 30-second [9] H. Kimura, Seismic Performance Evaluation Chart-system for Coastal
JEGM in grid cells of 7.5 arc-seconds JEGM, Ground-condition map Structures, Ministry Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism Kinki
containing the attributes of geomorphologic classification latitude 11.25 Regional Development Bureau, Kobe Research and Engineering office
arc-seconds longitude for all of Japan, intellectual property management for Port and Airportࠊ
system: H20PRO-936, 2008. http://www.mlit.go.jp/chosahokoku/h18giken/program/kadai/pdf/new/ne
[3] Japan Seismic Hazard Information Station, J-SHIS, http://www.j- w4-01.pdf
shis.bosai.go.jp [10] S.Aoi㸪H .Na kamura㸪T. Kunugi㸪W .Su zuki㸪an d H. Fujiwara
[4] K. Fujimoto, S. Midorikawa, Relationship between Average Shear- (NIED), Real-time seismic-intensity exposed-population estimation
Wave Velocity and Site Amplification Inferred from Strong Motion system (J-RISQ), SSJ 2013 Fall Meeting, 2013 (in press).

859

You might also like