Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sondhi BondingintheNewMillennium
Sondhi BondingintheNewMillennium
Sondhi BondingintheNewMillennium
Aim: To develop a cohesive and complete system for fabricating bonding trays and an effec-
tive indirect bonding procedure.Material and Methods: A new resin designedspecificallyfor
indirect bonding has been developed. Previous problems with indirect bonding systems,
which were partly related to the fact that resins designed for direct bonding had to be used,
have been addressed.Conclusion: A cohesiveand complete system for fabricating bonding
trays and for the indirect bonding procedure is presented. World J Orthod 2001;2:106-114.
106
bond the brackets to the teeth. Although this method Advantages of indirect bonding
was effective, it generated a significant amount of
flash, and cleaning up the resin presented a definite There are significant advantages to indirect bonding:1-7
problem. The technique also was awkward and
Iinvolved a significant amount of clinical and laboratory
1. Bracket placement is accurate
time. Alternative adhesives have been tried over the 2. Use of the orthodontist's time is optimized.
years, but all have proved only moderately successful. 3. Band fitting on posterior teeth is avoided.
The next major improvement in methodology 4. Need for separators is eliminated.
occurred during the 1980s, when heat-cured resins 5. Ability to bond posterior teeth is improved.
entered the market. However, there were reports of 6. Patient comfort and hygiene are improved.
clinicians experiencing problems with bracket float
during the heating required to cure the resin. Casts
had to be heated to 250°F to 300°F for approxi- Disadvantagesof indirect bonding
mately 15 to 20 minutes to cure the resin (Therma-
cure, Reliance Orthodontic Products, Itasca, IL, USA). 1. Indirect bonding is technique sensitive.
Some nonceramic esthetic brackets could not be 2. Additional set of impressions is needed.
exposed to such heat, and had to be placed sepa- 3. Posterior attachments are more likely to fail if the
rately, after the metal brackets had been heat patient abuses the appliance by chewing ice, etc.
cured-a cumbersome procedure.
When the bracket bases are constructed with
heat-cured resin, bonding placement is generally ACCURACYIN
accomplished with chemically cured sealants or BRACKET PLACEMENT
bonding resins. However, if a transparent tray is
used, a light-cured resin with cure-on-demand bene- Orthodontic appliances are now engineered with
fits is an alternative.7 increasingly sophisticated computerized design and
a vast array of tips, torques, labiolingual offsets, and
rotations are available to the clinician. However,
Previous resins used in some of this precision is lost when brackets are
indirect bonding applied to the teeth in an indiscriminate manner.
A number of bracket placement systems have
With the increasing popularity of indirect bonding over been proposed over the years. To realize the full
the past two decades, different methods of bonding potential of a preadjusted edgewise appliance, the
the brackets to the teeth have been developed. Ini- system for bracket placement must be reliable and
tially, brackets were positioned on the casts and the consistent. The orthodontist must be prepared to
bonding was accomplished with a filled resin. The incorporate variations in bracket placement dictated
indirect transfer trays were usually formed with sili- by the malocclusion. The positioning of brackets
cone tray materials. The bond strength achieved with clearly would be different in treatment of patients
filled resins was adequate, but the technique, particu- with open bites versus patients with deep anterior
larly the clean-up, was difficult. It became apparent overbites. Kalange has proposed, for example, that
that one of the deficiencies in the available systems the incisal edges of anterior teeth be recontoured
arose from the fact that all the resins and procedures prior to bracket placement.8 It is precisely this sort
had been designed for direct bonding and had subse- of variation that maximizes the efficiency of bracket
quently been adapted for indirect bonding. placement with indirect bonding.
A generous window of working time is an impor-
tant property in a resin designed for direct bonding.
This property has no advantage in indirect bonding, DEVELOPING A CUSTOMIZED
since there is no need for an extended cure time RESIN BASE
once the tray has been placed in the mouth. There-
fore, a resin designed specifically for indirect bond- In an effortto determine the best method for prepar-
ing was needed. After innovation, laboratory testing, ing a custom resin base, a number of clinical trials
and clinical trials, an efficient and effective indirect were completed. It was the author's finding that
bonding procedure was created. One benefit of this light-cured resin is a quick and efficient material for
procedure is that it does not require heating the placing brackets on models and for forming a cus-
casts, since a custom base of the bracket is devel- tom resin base. Using adhesive precoated (APC)
oped with light-cured resin. brackets. contamination is eliminated and laboratory
107
Fig 1 (a) Anterior view of the working cast. (b) Occlusal view of the working cast. Note the detail of dental and
soft tissue structures, and an absence of any bubbles or voids. (c) Separating medium being applied to the maxillary
working cast.
108
Fig 2 APC brackets being placed Fig 3 Final bracket placement. Fig 4 Detail of the bonding set-
on the teeth. If APC brackets are checked by the orthodontist. Indi- up, which demonstrates the ability
not used, then Transbond XT rect bonding permits viewing the to control axial inclinations of sec-
should be applied to the bracket brackets and casts in all three ond molars with the initial arch-
bases. dimensions for optimal rotation and wire.
angulation.
curing because the access to light between the tics). The Bioplast layer is vacuformed onto the
plaster cast and the bracket base is limited. The cast first, and the excess material is trimmed off
amount of time for light curing is substantially (Figs 7a and 7b). The Bioplast surface should be
reduced with clear esthetic brackets, and 1 sprayed with a silicone spray or a light cooking
minute of exposure to the light should be ade- spray before the Biocryl is adapted, which will
quate (Fig 5). Curing can be done with a chairside permit easier separation of the two layers. The
light-curing unit if a light chamber is not available. hard outer shell should be trimmed away from all
6. Before forming the indirect bonding trays, a light heights of contour for patient comfort and closer
separating spray should be used to facilitate fit, since its purpose is only to permit firm seating
easy removal of the tray from the brackets. A sili- of the soft tray. The outer layer provides rigidity to
cone spray or a light cooking spray, such as Pam the bonding tray, and the inner layer permits eas-
(International Home Foods, Parsippany, NJ, USA), ier removal of the tray (Figs 7c and 7d).
may be used. The brackets should be sprayed 8. When a bonding tray made with a silicone transfer
lightly and for less than 1 second (Fig 6). material is used, the Biostar unit is not necessary
7. The indirect bonding trays can now be placed (Fig 8). A bonding tray can be made with a suit-
over the brackets. The author uses a Biostar able silicone transfer material. Once the putty has
(Great Lakes Orthodontics, Tonawanda, NY, USA) been mixed with the activating agent, a small but-
unit to vacuform a 1.5-mm-thick layer of Bioplast ton of the silicone material can be placed around
(Great Lakes Orthodontics) overlaid with a 0.75- individual brackets, followed by the placement of
mm-thick layer of Biocryl (Great Lakes Orthodon- the remaining material, which is rolled into the
109
I Sandhi WORLD JOURNAL OF ORTHODONTICS
Fig 7 (8) Cast with first layer of Bioplast. (b) The excess material around the base of the
cast being trimmed. (c,d) Occlusal and lateral views of the indirect bonding tray. The hard
outer shell of Biocryl provides rigidity to the tray.
Fig 8 (a) Superior view of an indirect bonding tray formed with Express silicone impression
material. A putty tray of this kind can be used if a vacuformed tray is not desired or a Biostar
is not available. (b) Posterior view of a silicone transfer tray, demonstrating bracket positions
and tray trimming around the hooks.
shape of a cylinder. The occlusal and lingual sur- trays have been trimmed, they should be placed in
faces of the teeth should also be covered with the the TRIAD unit for an additional minute to ensure
tray material, as has been described by Kalange.8 that any uncured resin is cured (Fig 9b).
9. The casts are soaked for approximately 1 hour to 10. The trays should now be cleaned with a dish-
permit the separating medium to dissolve. This washing detergent (eg, Dawn, Proctor & Gamble,
allows easier separation of the bonding trays. The Cincinnati, OH, USA) in an ultrasonic cleaner for
bonding trays are now removed from the casts and 10 minutes. The trays are then run through the
should be sectioned off with a bur (Fig 9a). It may ultrasonic cleaner, in water only, for an additional
be necessary to tease the tray off with a scaler. 5 minutes. They are then rinsed and dried thor-
Any excess material should be trimmed with crown oughly (Fig 10 shows external and internal views
and bridge scissors or a scalpel. Once the bonding of the maxillary bonding tray).
11n
Fig 9 (a) Vacuformed indirect bonding tray is removed from the cast. (b) Trimmed indirect
bonding trays in the TRIAD chamber for additional curing. One minute of additional curing is
recommended to ensure complete curing of the resin base.
111
2. Carefully examine the trays for any remaining ance is not apparent, repeat the etching process
separator or tray material that may be covering for 15 seconds.
the adhesive custom base on the bracket. Use a 10. Small amounts of the Resin A and Resin B liq-
microetching unit to lightly sandblast the adhe- uids should be poured into the wells (Figs 12a
sive custom bases. A fine aluminum oxide parti- and 12b). Take care to keep liquids separate.
cle (50 ~m) is recommended. Be careful not to Resin A can be painted onto the tooth surface
abrade the resin base. with a brush, and Resin B can be painted on the
3. If there is any contamination of the adhesive resin pads in the indirect bonding tray (Figs 12c
custom bases, especially if you touch them with and 12d).
your fingertips, the trays should be cleaned with 11. If too much resin has been placed on the
a detergent, rinsed, and dried. The application of enamel, gently remove the excess with a brush.
acetone to adhesive bases is not recommended, The overall method of painting the resin on the
since recent research has indicated that this enamel and the custom bases is similar to paint-
may have a degrading effect on the resin. ing fingernails.
4. Isolate the teeth that are to be bonded, using the 12. Position the tray over the teeth and seat the tray
Nola (Nola Specialties, Hilton Head, SC, USA) with a hinge motion. With the fingers, apply equal
dry-field system. If necessary, plastic cheek pressure to the occlusal, labial, and buccal sur-
retractors, Tongue Away (TP Orthodontics, faces. Hold for a minimum of 30 seconds (Fig
laPorte, IN, USA), cotton rolls, and Dri-Angles 13a). Figure 13b shows the maxillary and man-
(Young Dental, Earth City, MO, USA) may be dibular bonding trays in place. Allow 2 more min-
used. utes of curing time before removing the trays. Due
5. Dry teeth thoroughly with an air syringe. to the rapid set time of this adhesive, removal of
6. Dab (do not rub) etching solution onto teeth and the first tray can begin once the opposing tray is
set stopwatch for 15 seconds. The etching solu- placed (Fig 14). Figure 15 shows the completed
tion should be applied with extreme care; do not appliance placement.
allow it to contact skin or gingiva. The etch 13. Remove the tray by using a scaler to peel the
should be applied in the general area that is to tray from the lingual to buccal. Use extreme
be covered by the bracket. Do not allow the etch care when removing the tray from around
to flow into the interproximal contacts. The clean- bracket wings. Scale the excess resin around
up will go more smoothly if this is kept in mind the brackets and from the interproximal con-
(Fig 11a). tacts. Use dental floss to check that all contacts
7. Wait 15 seconds and then rinse with a steady are open.
stream of water for 15 seconds. Rinse with a 14. Repeat steps 4 to 13 for the remaining trays.
steady spray of water and air for another 30 sec- 15. The initial archwire can now be inserted (Fig 16).
onds. Suction excess water and do not allow
saliva to come into contact with the etched
enamel (Fig 11b and 11c). RESULTS
8. Replace cotton rolls and Dri-Angles; again, mak-
ing sure that saliva does not contact the etched This system has been used by thousands of clini-
enamel. cians internationally, and several thousand patients
9. If the clinician chooses to use a moisture insen- have been treated. Communication with orthodon-
sitive primer, such as Transbond MIP, on the tists who have used this system indicates that the
enamel surface for the indirect bonding proce- bonding is relatively consistent and efficient. Occa-
dure, then the air syringe should be used to sional bond failures do occur, of course, and are
remove excess moisture. Complete desiccation usually related to contamination or improper tech-
of the teeth is optional. A liberal coat of Trans- nique. In those cases, it is a simple matter to section
bond MIP should be painted onto the enamel the bonding tray, reapply the adhesive, and reseat
surface. Air dry for approximately 2 seconds. the brackets.
Light curing of this primer is not necessary for Bond strength tests have also proved the efficacy
indirect bonding. If Transbond MIP moisture of the resin. Bond strength compares favorably with
insensitive primer is not used, and the bonding indirect bonding using Concise Enamel Bond (3M
is accomplished with the indirect bonding resin, Unitek) and Custom IQ (Reliance). Figure 17 (shown
then all visible moisture should be removed. The on the web edition of the Journal at http://www.
etched teeth should have a frosty appearance, quintpub.com) provides important bond strength
and be completely desiccated. If a frosty appear-~ data. The indirect resin shows substantially greater
112
VOLUME 2, NUMBER 2, 2001 Sandhi I
Fig 11 (a) Enamel surfaces are etched with a gel etching material in preparation for bonding. (b,c) Enamel is rinsed
after removal of the etching gel. Note that the entire arch can be etched and dried to permit bonding of the com-
plete dental arch.
Fig 12 (a,b) Dispensing wells are supplied with the indirect resin. Resin A is app)ied to the
tooth surface and should be placed in the well identified with the tooth icon. Resin B is
applied to the bracket base and should be placed in the well with the bracket icon. (c) Resin A
is applied to the etched tooth surface. (d) Resin B being applied to the bracket base.
Fig 13 (a) Placement of the bonding tray. (b) Maxillary and mandibular Fig 14 Removal of the outer shell
bonding trays in place. of the mandibular bonding tray. The
Biocryl layer will lift off easily if the
two layers were separated during
laboratory preparation. The soft
Bioplast layer is then remo,!ed.
113
.
Fig 15 (a) Lateral view of right buccal segments of the indirect bonded Fig 16 Initial archwires engaged.
appliance. (b) Anterior view of complete indirect bonded appliance. (c) Lat- Note the control over second molar
eral view of the left buccal segments of the indirect bonded appliance. (d) positioning with the initial leveling
Maxillary occlusal view of the indirect bonded appliance. (e) Mandibular archwire.
occlusal view of the indirect bonded appliance.
114