Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect-of-fabrication-method-on-the-structure-and-electrom_2014_Composites-S
Effect-of-fabrication-method-on-the-structure-and-electrom_2014_Composites-S
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Casting, forge-rolling, and stretching methods have been used for preparation of polystyrene composites
Received 5 May 2014 with 0.25 wt.% loading of multiwall carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs). Electromagnetic properties of the
Received in revised form 23 June 2014 composites were studied using impedance spectroscopy and microwave probing in the Ka band. Analysis
Accepted 11 July 2014
of impedance spectra revealed capacitive behavior of the forge-rolled composite and charge tunneling
Available online 23 July 2014
through a polystyrene layer separating the nanotubes in two other composite samples. The stretched
composite demonstrated anisotropy of microwave response due to predominant orientation of nano-
Keywords:
tubes along deformation direction. The near-isotropic shielding efficiency of the forge-rolled composite
A. Carbon nanotubes
A. Polymer–matrix composites (PMCs)
was attributed to strong fragmentation of MWCNTs under applied shear forces.
B. Electrical properties Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Microwave absorption
1. Introduction For filling of polymers with CNTs, several methods have devel-
oped such as casting, spins coating [14], stretching [1,15], and
Polymer composites containing conductive inclusions are very forge-rolling [9,10,16]. Our previous investigations have shown
perspective for electromagnetic applications. Materials, which that both stretching and forge-rolling results in alignment of nano-
have a predetermined arrangement of the inclusions and provide tubes in polymer matrix and as a consequence in anisotropic elec-
the electromagnetic response in certain frequency range, are of tromagnetic properties of composites [1,2,9,10,16]. However, the
particular interest. In this context, carbon nanotubes (CNTs), con- measurement results are difficult to correlate because the CNTs
ductive quasi-one-dimensional nanoparticles, have attracted a have been produced in different synthetic conditions. Moreover,
special attention due to extremely high shielding efficiency of the properties of anisotropic composites contained the same CNT
composites in gigahertz [1–6] and terahertz [7–11] regions even amount but fabricated by different methods have never been stud-
at low nanotube concentration. ied comparatively, while it was mentioned that every method has
Electromagnetic characteristics of CNT-based composites are own advantages and limitations [17].
governed by many factors, such as, the polymer nature, geometry The present work is devoted to investigation of the electromag-
of CNTs (length, defectness, etc.), concentration and distribution netic response of three types of CNT/polystyrene composites pre-
of nanotubes in matrix. Variation in any of these parameters could pared using the nanotubes taken from the same batch and in the
drastically change property of composite material. For example, it equal amount. The composites were fabricated by a solution cast-
has been shown that lessening of the defect-free-length in CNT ing and forge-rolling or stretching of soft CNT/polystyrene film. The
walls results in reduction of dielectric permittivity, dc conductivity measurements were done in low-frequency (1 kHz–2 MHz) and
and electromagnetic interference shielding efficiency of compos- microwave (26.5–40 GHz) regions and analyzed in a light of the
ites [2]. Microwave probing of polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) nanotube length and orientation.
composite with CNTs detected a strong lowering of sample
transmission with a decrease of CNT diameter [12]. Dispersion 2. Experimental
and distribution of CNTs in polymer matrix are also important
for composite properties [13]. 2.1. Carbon nanotube synthesis
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +7 383 330 53 52; fax: +7 383 330 94 89. Arrays of aligned multiwall CNTs (MWCNTs) were grown on sil-
E-mail address: o.sedelnikova@gmail.com (O.V. Sedelnikova). icon substrates using aerosol-assisted catalytic chemical vapor
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2014.07.013
0266-3538/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
60 O.V. Sedelnikova et al. / Composites Science and Technology 102 (2014) 59–64
deposition (CCVD) method. Synthesis was carried out in a quartz composite plate was dissolved in toluene and nanotubes were
tube inserting into a horizontal tubular reactor with a length of extracted. Fig. 2a shows typical SEM image of the sediment. A pres-
800 mm and diameter of 36 mm. Construction of set-up and details ence of polymer in the sample indicates good adhesion between
of synthesis are described elsewhere [18]. In brief, a 2 wt.% solution polystyrene and CNT surface. The sonication causes shortening of
of ferrocene in toluene was injected into reactor heated up to MWCNTs down to 50–70 lm, although nanotubes with a length
800 °C. The pyrolysis was performed in an argon flow during a half of 20 lm were also observed. Since during the stretching only
hour. The structure of the product was characterized by scanning elastic field from the polymer matrix is acted on nanotubes [21],
electron microscopy (SEM) with a Hitachi S-3400N microscope. their length should be determined by the sonication treatment.
SEM analysis revealed a vertical alignment of MWCNTs relative In contrast, a shear deformation applied to the composite during
to the surface of silicon substrate (Fig. 1). The height of arrays forge-rolling procedure disentangles nanotubes from their agglom-
was 130 lm. Concentration of iron nanoparticles in the nanotube erates [20] and distributes the filler evenly [19]. SEM analysis
channels determined by elemental analysis was 5 wt.%. shows that strong forces of the rolls may break the nanotubes
down to 3–10 lm (Fig. 2b). One can assume that such fragmen-
tation of nanotubes should change electromagnetic response of
2.2. Composite fabrication
the MWCNT/polystyrene composite noticeably in comparison with
the casted and stretched samples.
Three types of polystyrene composites with 0.25 wt.% MWCNT
loading were prepared. MWCNT array was gently detached from
silicon substrate and portion of sample taken in the required 2.3. Measurement details
amount was stirred with a toluene solution of polystyrene for com-
plete polymer dissolving. Then, the composite suspension was son- Measurements of real (ReZ) and imaginary (ImZ) parts of the
icated for 2 min using a high-power sonic tip (200 W) with the impedance of MWCNT/polystyrene composites were done regard-
purpose to improve nanotube dispersion. Obtained slush was cast ing a two-contact method with an impedancemeter Z-2000 (made
onto metallic plate and dried at ambient conditions. The plate pro- by ‘‘Elins’’, Chernogolovka, Russia) in a frequency range from 1 kHz
duced after complete solvent evaporation is believed to contain to 2 MHz. The examined region of composite plate located in cen-
randomly distributed nanotubes and in further discussion it will tral part of the measuring cell was 0.38 cm2.
be referred as isotropic composite. The thickness of this composite Microwave response of MWCNT/polystyrene composites was
plate was 220 lm. To provide predominant orientation of nano- studied using a vector network analyzer Agilent N5247A. The mea-
tubes in polymer matrix we used a procedure of forge-rolling or surement cell was a standard waveguide (7.112 3.566 mm2)
stretching. The details of forge-rolling procedure for polymer filling
with different carbon nanostructures are described elsewhere
[16,19,20]. A composite plate dried to a viscous state was repeat-
edly forge-rolled along a certain direction under the following con-
ditions. A linear speed of the rolls was 10–15 cm/s, a clearance
between rolls was 500 lm during the several first cycles and then
it was decreased to 200 lm. As the stretching procedure was
used, a soft composite plate was uniaxially stretched at a heating
(70 °C), which was provided by a hot air gun. A microscrew setup
led to stretching of the plate in half. Finally, the composites were
dried under a light load at room temperature. The thickness of
the rolled and stretched plates was 180 and 390 lm, corre-
spondingly. All the prepared plates had visually homogeneous gray
color.
Aspect ratio is an important parameter when interaction of
CNTs with electromagnetic field is studied. We used the nanotubes,
which grew simultaneously and hence initially had the near same
length. However, during the treatment they can be shortened. First,
effect of sonication was checked. Polystyrene matrix of isotropic
Fig. 2. SEM images of MWCNT sediment extracted from isotropic (a) and forge-
Fig. 1. SEM image of MWCNT array used for composite fabrication. rolled composite by polystyrene dissolving. Numbers indicate the nanotube length.
O.V. Sedelnikova et al. / Composites Science and Technology 102 (2014) 59–64 61
supporting H10 oscillation. The composite samples placed in a with frequency increase. The impedance plotted in the Nyquist
break of waveguide line were irradiated by electromagnetic wave coordinates (ImZ vs ReZ) is close to a straight vertical line (Fig. 3c)
with the transverse electric field oriented either parallel or perpen- that indicates substantial capacitive nature of the composite. The
dicular to the deformation direction (rolling or stretching). The frequency dependence of impedance spectrum of the stretched
reflected (S11) and transmitted (S21) power was registered within MWCNT/polystyrene plate is quite different. The spectrum shows
26.5–40 GHz frequency range (Ka band). no dispersion in the range from 10 kHz to 2 MHz, however, around
4.1 kHz (the correlation frequency fc) the ReZ component has an
inflection, while the ImZ component passes through a maximum
3. Results and discussion (Fig. 3(a and b)). This behavior is similar to that observed for the iso-
tropic MWCNT/polystyrene composite. The correlation frequency in
3.1. Impedance spectroscopy data that case was 0.4 MHz. The complex impedance spectra of the iso-
tropic and stretched samples show well-defined semicircles with
Impedance diagrams of the MWCNT/polystyrene composites are diameters of 13.2 kX and 0.7 MX (Fig. 3c), respectively, charac-
presented in Fig. 3a and b. Real ReZ and imaginary ImZ components teristics of bulk resistance of a material.
of impedance of isotropic composite are considerably smaller as The impedance data can be analyzed using an equivalent circuit
compared to those for anisotropic composite plates. The forge- consisted of resistor and capacitor [22]. Depending on geometrical
rolled sample shows monotonic decrease of both ReZ and ImZ parts and electronic structure of material, network may be organized
through a series or parallel connection. In particular, the imped-
ance of CNT percolation film can be described by two parallel RC
circuits in series corresponded to conductivity inside of a nanotube
bundle and tunneling between the bundles [23]. In our case, where
the composites have a rather low concentration of nanotubes,
which are mainly isolated (see Fig. 2), the charge transfer from a
nanotube to another one takes place via a dielectric layer.
Frequency dependence of dielectric constant e and resistivity R of
the MWCNT/polystyrene composites are presented in Fig. 4a and b.
Reconstruction of dielectric characteristics was done as described
by Gavrilov et al. [20]. The measurement cell was considered as
two parallel Voigt elements, which correspond to own loss and
capacitance of experimental cell and composite material. For the
same content of MWCNTs, the dielectric constant of stretched com-
posite is two or three times larger than that of the forge-rolled sam-
ple, which properties are mostly governed by permittivity of the
unfilled polystyrene plate (epolystyrene = 1.9). At the same time, the
stretched composite was found to be more conducting than the
forge-rolled one. Further increase of the dielectric constant and
decrease of the resistivity were found for the isotropic composite.
The results presented show that dielectric response of MWCNT/
polystyrene composite is very sensitive to fabrication method. The
most important parameters responsible for this property are the
dispersion state and the size of carbon filler. Casting gives no pre-
dominant orientation of MWCNTs in polymer matrix and some of
the nanotubes can be perpendicular to the plate surface. As the
result, dielectric constant and conductivity in the cross-section of
the composite are considerably enhanced relative to those for
anisotropic composite plates. Despite the different orientation of
MWCNTs, the isotropic and stretched composites have similar fre-
quency dependence of impedance, although the shift of the maxi-
mum of the ImZ component from 0.4 MHz to 4.1 kHz indicates the
larger effective size of conducting inclusions in the latter compos-
ite [24]. The spectrum of the forge-rolled sample is distinct due to
differing in the length distribution of MWCNTs. Indeed, according
to the SEM investigation of sediments extracted from polystyrene
plates, the used fabrication methods provide effective disentan-
gling of nanotubes from their agglomerates. However, strong
forces of rolls break the nanotubes from the initial length of
130 lm to 3–10 lm (Fig. 3b), while average length of MWCNTs
constituting the isotropic and stretched composites is 70 lm. The
highly capacitive spectrum of the forge-rolled composite indicates
that distance between these short nanotubes is larger than that is
Fig. 3. Frequency dependence of real ReZ (a) and imaginary ImZ (b) parts of necessary for tunneling of electrons [25], and as the result the
impedance (Z) for MWCNT/polystyrene composites produced by stretching (green charge carriers are blocked by rather thick polystyrene layer pro-
squares) and forge-rolling (blue triangles). (c) Complex impedance of MWCNT/ viding an insulating state for the composite (i.e. forge-rolled sam-
polystyrene composites. The insets show impedance of isotropic composite (red
circles). Numbers in (c) indicates logarithm of the frequency. (For interpretation of
ple is below the percolation threshold). Response of the isotropic
the references to color in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version and stretched composites with longer nanotubes can be attributed
of this article.) to activation of conduction mechanism (i.e. the samples are above
62 O.V. Sedelnikova et al. / Composites Science and Technology 102 (2014) 59–64
Fig. 4. Frequency dependence of dielectric constant (a) and resistivity (b) for
MWCNT/polystyrene produced by casting (red circles), stretching (green squares),
and forge-rolling (blue triangles) procedures. (For interpretation of the references to
colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
matrix, while the transition from the insulating to conductive state [11] Macutkevic J, Seliuta D, Valusis G, Adomavicius R, Krotkus A, Paddubskaya A,
et al. Multi-walled carbon nanotubes/PMMA composites for THz applications.
was detected for the both composites with longer nanotubes.
Diamond Relat Mater 2012;25:13–8.
MWCNT arrangement in polystyrene matrix enhances absorbance [12] Paddubskaya AG, Kuzhir PP, Kuznetsov VL, Mazov IN, Moseenkov SI, Ishchenko
of composite plate, while transmittance depends on the length and AV, et al. CNT/PMMA electromagnetic coating: effect of carbon nanotube
alignment of nanotubes. Noticeable anisotropic transmission diameter. Fullerene, Nanotube, Carbon Nanostruct 2012;20:527–30.
[13] Breuer O, Sundararaj U. Big returns from small fibers: a review of polymer/
detected for the stretched composite indicates high potential of carbon nanotube composites. Polym Compos 2004;25:630–45.
the mechanical stretching technique for the production of giga- [14] Xu XJ, Thwe MM, Shearwood C, Liao K. Mechanical properties and interfacial
hertz polarizers. characteristics of carbon-nanotube-reinforced epoxy thin films. Appl Phys Lett
2001;81:2833.
[15] Jin L, Bower R, Zhou O. Alignment of carbon nanotubes in a polymer matrix by
Acknowledgments mechanical stretching. Appl Phys Lett 1998;73:1197.
[16] Kanygin MA, Selyutin AG, Okotrub AV, Bulusheva LG. Anisotropic permittivity
of multi-walled carbon nanotube/polystyrene composites. Fullerene,
This work was supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Nanotube, Carbon Nanostruct 2012;20:523–6.
Research (Grant 14-03-90028 in a part of low-frequency measure- [17] Goh PS, Ismail AF, Ng BC. Directional alignment of carbon nanotubes in
ments and Grant 13-02-90711 in a part of the microwave polymer matrices: contemporary approaches and future advances.
Composites: Part A 2014;56:103–26.
measurements). [18] Kudashov AG, Kurenya AG, Okotrub AV, Gusel’nikov AV, Danilivich VS,
Bulusheva LG. Synthesis and structure of films consisting of carbon
References nanotubes oriented normally to the substrate. Tech Phys 2007;52:16271631.
[19] Gavrilov NN, Okotrub AV, Bulusheva LG, Kuznetsov VL, Moseenkov SI. Low-
frequency (10–50 kHz) impedance of polystyrene-onion-like-carbon
[1] Bychanok D, Kanygin M, Okotrub A, Shuba M, Paddubskaya A, Pliushch A, et al.
composites. Tech Phys Lett 2009;35:85–8.
Anisotropy of the electromagnetic properties of polymer composites based on
[20] Gavrilov NN, Okotrub AV, Bulusheva LG, Sedelnikova OV, Yushina IV,
multiwall carbon nanotubes in the gigahertz frequency range. JETP Lett
Kuznetsov VL. Dielectric properties of polystyrene/onion-like carbon
2011;93:607–11.
composites in frequency range of 0.5–500 kHz. Compos Sci Technol
[2] Kanygin MA, Sedelnikova OV, Asanov IP, Bulusheva LG, Okotrub AV, Kuzhir PP,
2010;70:719–24.
et al. Effect of nitrogen doping on the electromagnetic properties of carbon
[21] Iakoubovski K. Techniques of aligning carbon nanotubes. Cent Eur J Phys
nanotube-based composites. J Appl Phys 2013;113:144315.
2009;7:645–53.
[3] Suslyaev VI, Kuznetsov VL, Zhuravlev VA, Mazov IN, Korovin EY, Moseenkov SI,
[22] Macdonald JR, Barsookov E. Impedance spectroscopy: theory, experimental
et al. An investigation of electromagnetic response of composite polymer
and applications. New York: Wiley Intersience; 2005.
materials containing carbon nanostructures within the range of frequencies
[23] Garrett MP, Ivanov IN, Gerhardt RA, Puretzky AA, Geohegan DB. Separation of
10 MHz–1.1 THz. Russ Phys J 2013;55(8):970–6.
junction and bundle resistance in single wall carbon nanotube percolation
[4] Kuzhir P, Paddubskaya A, Bychanok D, Nemilentsau A, Shuba M, Plusch A, et al.
networks by impedance spectroscopy. Appl Phys Lett 2010;97:163105.
Microwave probing of nanocarbon based epoxy resin composite films: toward
[24] Macutkevič J, Banys J, Glemža, Kuznetsov V, Borjanovic V, Shenderova O.
electromagnetic shielding. Thin Solid Films 2011;519:4114–8.
Dielectric properties of annealed onion-like carbon composites in microwave
[5] Kuzhir PP, Paddubskaya AG, Shuba MV, Maksimenko SA, Celzard A, Fierro V,
region. Lithuan. J. Phys. 2013;53:238–43.
et al. Electromagnetic shielding efficiency in Ka-band: carbon foam versus
[25] McClory C, McNally T, Baxendale M, Pötschke P, Blau W, Ruether M. Electrical
epoxy/carbon nanotube composites. J Nanophoton 2012;6:061715.
and rheological percolation of PMMA/MWCNT nanocomposites as a function
[6] Mazov I, Kuznetsov V, Moseenkov S, Usoltseva A, Romanenko A, Anikeeva O,
of CNT geometry and functionality. Eur Polym J 2010;46:854–68.
et al. Electromagnetic shielding properties of MWCNT/PMMA composites in
[26] Kymakis E, Alexandou I, Amartunga GAJ. Single-walled carbon nanotube–
Ka-band. Phys Status Solidi B 2009;246:2662–6.
polymer composites: electrical, optical and structural investigation. Synth
[7] Suslyaev VI, Zhuravlev VA, Dotsenko OA, Sarkisov SY, Kuznetsov VL,
Metal 2002;127:59–62.
Moseyenkov SI, et al. Electromagnetic properties of composites based on
[27] Khattari Z, Maghrabi M, McNally T, Jawada SA. Impedance study of polymethyl
multiwall carbon nanotubes studied by THz-TDS and cw BWO-based
methacrylate composites/multi-walled carbon nanotubes (PMMA/MWCNTs).
spectrometer at different levels of peak THz power. In: 2013 23rd Int.
Phys B: Condens Matter 2012;407:759–64.
Crimean Conf. ‘‘Microwave & Telecommunication Technology’’ (CriMiCo’2013).
[28] Kuzhir PP, Paddubskaya AG, Maksimenko SA, Kuznetsov VL, Moseenkov S,
Sevastopol; 2013. p. 980–1.
Romanenko AI, et al. Carbon onion composites for emc applications. IEEE Trans
[8] Zhuravlev VA, Suslyaev VI, Dunaevskii GE, Emelyanov EV, Mazov I, Moseenkov
Electromagn Compatibility 2012;54:6–16.
SI, et al. Complex permittivity of polymer composites containing carbon
[29] Kuzhir PP, Paddubskaya AG, Maksimenko SA, Kaplas T, Svirko Yu. Microwave
nanostructures in frequency range 0.17–1.1 THz. 2012 37th INT. Conf.
absorption properties of pyrolytic carbon nanofilm. Nanoscale Res Lett
‘‘IRMMW-THZ’’. Wollongong; 2012. 6380147.
2013;8(60):2013.
[9] Okotrub AV, Kubarev VV, Kanygin MA, Sedelnikova OV, Bulusheva LG.
[30] Batrakov K, Kuzhir P, Maksimenko S, Paddubskaya A, Voronovich S, Kaplas T,
Transmission of terahertz radiation by anisotropic MWCNT/polystyrene.
et al. Enhanced microwave shielding effectiveness of ultrathin pyrolytic
Phys Status Solidi (B) 2011;248:1568–71.
carbon films. Appl Phys Lett 2013;103:073117.
[10] Bychanok DS, Shuba MV, Kuzhir PP, Maksimenko SA, Kubarev VV, Kanygin MA,
[31] Chen W, Zhang Z, Feng Z, Chen Y, Jizng K, Fan S, et al. Measurement of
et al. Anisotropic electromagnetic properties of polymer composites
polarized nano-material (pnm) for microwave applications. IEEE MTT-S Int
containing oriented multiwall carbon nanotubes in respect to terahertz
Microwave Sympos Digest 2008;1–4:1584–7.
polarizer applications. J Appl Phys 2013;114:114304.