Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AnAnalysisofSocialSpacesandtheInfluenceofResidentsinaUniversitySetting
AnAnalysisofSocialSpacesandtheInfluenceofResidentsinaUniversitySetting
net/publication/274140225
CITATIONS READS
0 131
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Mitchell Carlyle Clarke on 29 March 2015.
History has seen a transformation of the social constructs of residential halls in the United States, with influence from European models
that were established by the interaction of faculty and students both physically and academically through differing residential
arrangements. During the early to mid-20th century, however, the layout of facilities replicated more institutional based models such as
correctional facilities or mental health institutions. This in turn led to a lack of social interaction amongst residents, and lowered the
chance of these residents to transition and accommodate themselves into a university setting. With social changes in the late 1960s and
1970s, a turn for residence halls to accommodate more social connectivity between residents and the university took place. Multiple
examples of renovations and architectural planning took place across the country to better the conditions residents faced, as well as
allowing social interactions to be the main criteria of certain design decisions amongst the architects and facility planners. Moreover,
residence halls are looking to a more sustainable approach, in terms of design moves and material choices, to accommodate the social
attitudes of their occupants.
INTRODUCTION amongst students, and the effect it had on students. Taking
into consideration environmental factors, budgetary and
The effective transition of students into a university setting administrative restraints, and social attitudes of residents are
is what researchers believe is the ultimate foundation for all part of the equation when it comes to the ultimate success
academic and social success in a higher education of creating a residence hall. It is the hope of the author that
environment. History has provided examples of how this research can be used to assist universities, whether that
effective the interaction of students in their living work be in simple renovations to existing structures, or to
environment can ease this transition. History has also seen the beginning of a new complex.
that when this living environment becomes more
institutionalized and lacking in thought for student BACKGROUND
development, it sets a student up for failure. With the current
rise of mental health issues in college students, an analysis Historically, residences halls (primarily in the United States)
of their living environment can assist in how to examine have been based on two systems of influence; the British
students’ transitions and interactions. With the transition university-system and the German university-system. This
period for incoming students into college being a vital influence dates back to the twelfth century, with British
predicament for their academic career, their living universities such as Oxford and Cambridge using the
environment becomes essential in how that success is residential college model for its campuses1. At these
nurtured. This work seeks to analyze examples and case institutions, faculty and student interaction became a one to
studies that provide evidence of how spatial planning and one regular basis. Lodging for students saw a full immersion
design techniques of residence halls on a university campus into academic life, where professors would interact with
can provide its occupants with an improved chance of students both in and outside the classroom. The class and
successful transition into a higher education setting. In no dwelling were intertwined together, and one could not
way is this research attempting to say that there is one survive without the other. This system was based upon the
universal model of how a residence hall is constructed or overall social and academic development of the student2.
designed. Rather, it seeks to provide evidence of the effects The influence of the British system was the first of three
of how designers used techniques to enhance the interaction phases of the development of student dwellings in the
1
Roger B. Winston and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life: a
2
handbook for professionals committed to student development goals. (San Winston, Roger B., and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 168
Francisco: Jossey-Bass), 168.
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
1
MITCHELL CLARKE
American university system3. The American system dates men and women from Europe and the Pacific Rim, and with
back to the founding of Harvard College in 1636. Following the “GI Bill of Rights” providing several subsidies to
the pattern of their predecessors in Britain, the development veterans and their families, another surge of students took
of the student formally and informally became the role in the hold of the American university9. A shortage of facilities led
residence halls for American universities. These halls to mass construction for campuses, a maximization of
provided a system of interactions among peers and faculty, resources so that schools could house as many beds for little
primarily due to the isolation of students from their families. cost to them. Low-cost maintenance became the focus of
Young men would travel long distances to attend design, not livability for the occupant. No flexibility was
universities, with full immersion into university life4. given to students, even for the interior design of their space
However, with an increased emphasis on education in the which they would occupy for up to four years10. By the
United States, and with enrollment across the nation’s 1960s, students were more vocal with their distaste for their
universities increasing every year, the residence college living arrangements on campus. A study in 1969 at Arizona
system was slowly being pushed to its capacity by the time State University saw that students were unanimously against
of the American Civil War in the mid-19th century5. The the management and facilities that they lived in. Concerns
decline of the residence college model was fueled by of isolation, lack of security, and limited social interaction
rebellion of students and faculty for a lack of resources and were the biggest concerns found in the study11, a far cry from
inadequate facilities. American educators traveled through the heavy influence of the residence college system that took
Europe and analyzed the German system, which believed place in pre-colonial American universities.
that the housing of students was not the role of the
university, but rather higher education had a primary focus Challenges students face when entering a
of the academic success of students6. When these educators university setting
returned to the United States, they attempted to fit their
The challenges that students face today when entering a
institutions to fit this similar model. Some universities, such
higher education setting are more powerful than ever. The
as Harvard and Columbia, saw their presidents deplore the
period of time for students transitioning to a new
dormitory system, with the President Charles Eliot of
environment is minuet, with an increased amount of factors
Harvard University denouncing university housing as a
to handle. The increase of student loan debt, weakened job
waste of funds and resources for students7. However, this
market, and rigor of academic adjusting accompany this
black listing of housing on campuses across the nation left
transition12. A national survey of two and four year
many students scrambling to find housing within an
institutions by the American College Health Association
adequate distance to their classrooms. College towns were
(ACHA) found that 30 percent of students experience
not equipped for the surge of students arriving each year. By
feelings of depression to the point of not being able to
the end of the 19th century, many conditions students faced
function properly during their first year13. Michigan State
in their dwellings were much worse than if they had situated
University found an increase of 76 percent over the past five
with on campus living8. The beginning of the 20th century
years of students seeking counseling for one or more mental
again looked to the administration of universities for their
health issues. The Association for University and College
involvement in the role of residence halls on campuses.
Counseling Center Directors reported that 95 percent of
Then president of Princeton University, Dr. Woodrow
directors found an increase in students seeking service, as
Wilson strongly supported the construction of new halls on
well as the diagnosis of students with more than one mental
the Princeton campus, and by 1915, many other schools took
health issue reaching 40 percent14. This rise of depression is
the same approach The United States federal government
also linked to the increase of suicidal thoughts and attempts
took over during the Great Depression and primarily with
by students. With these mental health issues plaguing
the end of World War II in 1945. With the return of young
3 12
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 168 "Anxiety, Depression Plague College Students, Survey Finds." Addiction
4
Roger Winston and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 168 Treatment Elements Drug Rehab Treatment Centers.
5
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 168 http://www.elementsbehavioralhealth.com/behavioral-health-news/anxiety-
6
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 169 depression-plague-college-students-survey-finds/
7 13
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 171 Depression and College Students." NIMH RSS.
8
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 170 http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/depression-and-college-
9
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 172 students/index.shtml
10
Roger Winston, and Scott Anchors. Student housing and residential life, 173 14
“Depression and College Students."
11
New Directions for Student Services-pg 33
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
2
AN ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL SPACES AND THE INFLUENCE OF RESIDENTS IN A UNIVERSITY SETTING
students, it is not surprising that one quarter of students socializing, friendships, and overall residence spatial
don’t return after their first year of college15, with many experience were the top factors for students23. While there
students making this decision about six weeks into their first may not be conclusive evidence that supports an exact
semester. Researchers have found that this period of time is arrangement of specific architectural methods that foster
critical for students, because it is an allotted time of these interactions best, there are times when certain
adjustment, and, statistically, if students fail to socialize and environmental factors allow for better interaction. This does
reach out to their fellow peers in this time, are likely to leave help to foster opportunities students can have to succeed in
the institution the next year16. As students adjust to a new their transition to college. An analysis of particular reaction
environment physically, they also adjust socially, many to certain spatial set ups were researched by Charles
leaving home for the first time. The social ties that students Holahan and Brian Wilcox at the University of Texas at
make help reduce the risk of depression, anxiety, and Austin in 1978. Their main focus included a broader
thoughts of suicide17. Another important factor for students approach towards analysis, focusing only on the social
in their transition is a creation of their own identity. With interaction of students within high-density and low-density
their parents no longer a key part of their decision making halls24. A number of research studies concerned with quality
process, students find themselves free to develop their own of life in student residential environments have reported less
morals and beliefs18. Then director of the Census Bureau, living satisfaction and social cohesion in high-rise settings
Herman Miller reported students differing in moral values compared to low-rise settings. It was predicted that,
from the previous generation during the 1960s19. according to previous research in student residential
Psychoanalyst Erick H. Erikson stated that students environments, high-rise dormitories would be characterized
transitioning into college were hoping to “redefine by lower levels of satisfaction and friendship development
[themselves] in personal, social and occupational terms after than would low-rise dormitories25. Two types of student
the revolution of sexual maturation”20. Erikson also believed residential environments were compared in the study; one
that establishing an identity ultimately could be a tragedy if high-rise mega-dorm and a number of low-rise dormitories.
not accomplished. The high-rise consisted of a tower of 10 floors occupied by
males and a tower of 13 floors occupied by females. The
Student interaction in a space meant for mega-dorm housed approximately 3,000 students26. The
living low-rise dormitories consisted of two dormitories for males
(one of two floors and one of four floors) and two
With the challenges that students face, the question of how
dormitories for females (one of two floors and one of five
students interact in a space meant for living comes into play.
floors). Each low-rise dormitory housed approximately 250
The fostering of interactions in the dwellings of a student is
students. The measure of the analysis did confirm that
conducive to their own opportunity for growth and students
residents of a high-rise dormitory felt isolated more often
who lived in residence halls that fostered social interactions
than students residing in a low-rise dormitory27. Overall, the
more consistently saw an easier transition to college 21.
implications of a residence hall’s spatial layout and set up
Researchers found that living on campus and in halls that
does play a role in how they begin to assist incoming
emphasize social interaction saw that microcosms of
students in their transition into college.
communities were built by student with their fellow peers.
These communities acted as a family and support system for
students adjusting22. Researcher David Cheng reported in
2004 that out of the top eight factors that students faced,
15
Allison K. Farris, “The Freshmen Adjustment Process: Commuter life versus 24
Holahan, Charles J., and Brian L. Wilcox. "Residential satisfaction and
Residence life” (PhD diss., California State University, 2010) friendship formation in high- and low-rise student housing: An interactional
16
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process analysis.” Journal of Educational Psychology 70, no. 2 (1978): 237
17 25
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process Holahan, Charles J., and Brian L. Wilcox. "Residential satisfaction and
18
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process friendship formation in high- and low-rise student housing: An interactional
19
Riker, Harold C. Student housing; a report. New York, NY: Educational analysis.”238
26
Facilities Laboratories, 17 Holahan, Charles J., and Brian L. Wilcox. "Residential satisfaction and
20
Riker, Harold C. Student housing; a report, 18 friendship formation in high- and low-rise student housing: An interactional
21
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process analysis.”238
22 27
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process Holahan, Charles J., and Brian L. Wilcox. "Residential satisfaction and
23
Farris, The Freshmen Adjustment Process friendship formation in high- and low-rise student housing: An interactional
analysis.”,240
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
3
MITCHELL CLARKE
Figure 2.
30
28 Baum, Andrew, and Glenn E. Davis. "Reducing the stress of high-density Baum, Andrew, and Glenn E. Davis. "Reducing the stress of high-density
living: An architectural intervention.” Journal of Personality and Social living: An architectural intervention.”
31
Psychology 38, no. 3 (1980): 471 Baum, Andrew, and Glenn E. Davis. "Reducing the stress of high-density
29
Baum, Andrew, and Glenn E. Davis. "Reducing the stress of high-density living: An architectural intervention.” -473
32
living: An architectural intervention.” 472 Baum, Andrew, and Glenn E. Davis. "Reducing the stress of high-density
living: An architectural intervention.” 473-474
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
4
AN ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL SPACES AND THE INFLUENCE OF RESIDENTS IN A UNIVERSITY SETTING
Note: The following case studies were simply examples of changes, renovations, or dormitory buildings on the campus, all incorporating the
overall design concepts that took the needs of students and placed emphasized on
social interaction. This section will give a brief analysis of each case study, and ideals and concerns of the students36.
how design decisions took note of student’s needs, as well as improvements for the
facilities if appropriate. Case Study: Utrecht University- Utrecht Uithof
(Utrecht, Netherlands)
Case Study: Massachusetts Institute of
Technology-East Campus Hall Much like American universities in the early 19th century
(Cambridge, Massachusetts) looked to solve the shortage of housing for students on
campuses, Utrecht University came across a similar
dilemma. In 2008, De Unithof opened on the campus to
provide a supplemental 380 units desperately needed for the
university37. Both interior and exterior emphasize on color,
and adequate spatial planning provided designers with a
challenge to create a facility that would encourage
interaction and still offer a time of individual console. The
façade, from a distance, blends together as a singular mass,
Figure 3. but closer approach reveals the matrix of color (see Figure
4). Each grid offering a window that is sliced into the
At the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), East
structure and a colorful array as a plinth above and below38.
Campus Hall (see Figure 3) had the unfortunate reputation
of being “not a happy place to live”, which was the opinion
of Lawrence Bishoff, then Vice President of Operations for
Housing at MIT33. What allows this case study to stick out
is the use of simple architecture methods and creativity of
architect Harry Ellenzwieg. Since the halls were not to be
re-modeled until 1978, in 1969, Ellenzweig was hired to
assist with a brief renovation. However, it was in his opinion
to not discuss major design moves, until they were approved
by the very people they served: the residents themselves34.
Every decision (within budgetary reasoning) was approved
by the students themselves through a democratic process
that the administration at MIT supported. Ranging from
simple material choices to serious spatial changes, the Figure 4.
renovations were at the hands of the students themselves.
Designer Rem Koolhaas believed that an open floor and
Removal of two rooms on each floor to convert into a
access to the urban surrounding provided a greater
lounge, painting, softening lighting, and the introduction of
opportunity for students to interact not only with each other,
blackboards into the space brought an emphasis on
but also with the surrounding urban context provided to the
personality and education35. The results themselves were
campus. Contrary to the former facility, which possessed a
seen in the interaction of students and faculty. For the first
series of individual closed off structures, the building was
time, faculty were invited to the hall to give seminars on
combined into one, and lifted up, allowing for a transparent
topics relevant to the students. Seeing the success at East
opening to the city, offering itself as both a communal and
Campus Hall, Bishoff saw the overhaul of multiple other
commercial interaction of occupants and citizens (see Figure
5)39.
33 37
Student Housing; a report.. New York, NY: Educational Facilities Laboratories, "380 Student Units and Public Space Design / Architectenbureau Marlies
23 Rohmer." ArchDaily. http://www.archdaily.com/120265/ (accessed March 4,
34
Student Housing, 23 2014).
35 38
Student Housing, 23 "380 Student Units and Public Space Design / Architectenbureau Marlies
36
Student Housing, 23 Rohmer."
39
"Architectenbureau Marlies Rohmer : / home / actueel." Architectenbureau
Marlies Rohmer : / home / actueel.
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
5
MITCHELL CLARKE
Figure 5.
The subsequent floor plans hold the residencies towards the The main connector is the HUB itself. This becomes the
northern and southern ends of the building, providing the embodiment of the project, due to its placement as the
center space as a communal interactive space. The intent of central body. The literal connect for the units is through
the architect was also that typical necessities of the structure hidden electrical cords, and an exterior promenade that
(hallways, stairwells, etc.) would become places of focus latches in. The interior of the central component offers a
and interaction would create a microcosm of social communal living arrangement (see Figure 8) with a kitchen
development40 and entertainment space43. Described by the designer as a
polyvalent space, the functions of the project cover a range
of issues the students find dear, from sustainable practices
to recreational use. Attached with the living units to the hub
is also a unit mean for recognition of “passive living”.
Cladded with vegetation, it incorporates active (solar panels)
and passive (material palatte) design methods to both shelter
and educate students44.
Figure 6.
http://www.rohmer.nl/?view=detail&pageAlias=projecten&subAlias=highlights 42
"Student Housing of the Future.”
43
&naamLetter=&jaarId=&werkveldId=&stadLetter=&landId=&projId=22 "Hub 01 Mobile Student Housing Terminal / dmvA Architecten + A3
(accessed April 1, 2014). Architects." ArchDaily. http://www.archdaily.com/312863/ (accessed March 4,
40
Architectenbureau Marlies Rohmer 2014).
41
"Student Housing of the Future." dmvA Architectecten . http://www.dmva- 44
“Hub 01 “ Mobile Student Housing Terminal”
architecten.be/v2/index.php#public|175 (accessed March 31, 2014).
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
6
AN ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL SPACES AND THE INFLUENCE OF RESIDENTS IN A UNIVERSITY SETTING
Figure 11.
45 47
Furulo, Alison. "University of Southern Denmark Student Housing Benschneider, Benjamin . "West Campus Student Housing / Mahlum
Winning Proposal / C.F. Møller Architects." ArchDaily. Architects." ArchDaily. http://www.archdaily.com/408376/ (accessed
46 "University of Southern Denmark Student Housing Winning Proposal March 4, 2014).
/ C.F. Møller Architects." 48 "West Campus Student Housing / Mahlum Architects
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
7
MITCHELL CLARKE
spaces occurs through the designer’s techniques of university setting when it comes to facilitating a communal
concealing and revealing at differing moments49. At times, environment for students, while offering them the privacy
the resident’s common spaces take full view in a public they request as they mature. Some unanswered questions
setting, and at times are marked away for their own from this research are how we begin to notate the social cues
seclusion. Visual connections also strengthen relationships that truly prepare a student, and how this translates
between residents, where different “territories” begin to help architecturally.
students with a creation of a community for themselves as a
part of the larger whole.
Figure 12.
CONCLUSION/FUTURE WORK
49
Mahlum . "Cedar Apartments | Mahlum." Cedar Apartments |
Mahlum. http://www.mahlum.com/projects/UWCedar/index.asp
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
8
AN ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL SPACES AND THE INFLUENCE OF RESIDENTS IN A UNIVERSITY SETTING
University of Florida | Journal of Undergraduate Research | Volume 12, Issue 3 | Spring 2014
9
View publication stats