Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pakistan Studies - PMS
Pakistan Studies - PMS
2022
Q1. Compare and contrast the role of ECO and SAARC for regional connectivity and
stability.
Answer:
The Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) and the South Asian Association for Regional
Cooperation (SAARC) are two distinct regional organizations in Asia that aim to promote
regional connectivity and stability among their member countries. While both organizations
share similar goals, they operate in different geographic and geopolitical contexts, leading to
variations in their effectiveness, priorities, and outcomes.
2. Historical Context:
ECO emerged from the former Regional Cooperation for Development (RCD), which was
established in 1964 among Iran, Pakistan, and Turkey. The organization's objective was to
promote economic cooperation and integration in the region. It was later expanded and renamed
as ECO in 1985. SAARC, founded in 1985, aimed to foster economic and regional integration
among South Asian nations.
4. Connectivity Initiatives:
ECO's connectivity initiatives are more comprehensive due to its broader geographical scope. It
has prioritized projects like the ECO Trade and Development Bank, which supports trade
financing, and the ECO Fiber Optic Network, which enhances communication links among
member countries. SAARC's connectivity efforts are centered around the South Asian Free
Trade Area (SAFTA) agreement and the SAARC Preferential Trading Arrangement (SAPTA).
5. Political Dynamics:
The political dynamics within ECO and SAARC member countries influence the organizations'
effectiveness. ECO's member states have varying levels of political stability, which can impact
the implementation of initiatives. In SAARC, the historical tensions between India and Pakistan
have often impeded progress and hindered the organization's ability to achieve its full potential.
8. Energy Cooperation:
ECO member countries possess significant energy resources, such as oil, gas, and hydropower
potential. The organization has aimed to foster energy cooperation through projects like the
Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India (TAPI) gas pipeline. In contrast, SAARC nations
have explored energy cooperation, but progress has been slow due to political challenges and
differing energy needs.
In conclusion, while both the Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) and the South Asian
Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) share common goals of enhancing regional
connectivity and stability, they operate in different geographic contexts and face unique
challenges. ECO's broader membership and geographical scope provide opportunities for
diverse connectivity initiatives, while SAARC's focus on South Asia has been hindered by
historical tensions. The effectiveness of both organizations relies on member states' willingness
to prioritize cooperation and overcome political obstacles for the greater benefit of their
respective regions.
Q2. We need “Friends not Masters”. Critically evaluate Pakistan’s likely relations with the
United States of America after its withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Answer:
The phrase "Friends not Masters" encapsulates Pakistan's desire for a relationship with the
United States that is based on mutual respect and partnership rather than dependence or
subservience. The withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan has significant implications
for Pakistan-US relations, as both countries navigate their interests in the region. This essay
critically evaluates the likely trajectory of Pakistan's relations with the United States
post-withdrawal, considering factors such as regional geopolitics, counterterrorism efforts,
economic ties, and Pakistan's pursuit of strategic autonomy.
2. Geopolitical Realignment:
Pakistan's relations with the United States have often been influenced by its strategic ties with
other countries, particularly China. The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is a
flagship project of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), and it enhances Pakistan's economic
connectivity with China. This economic partnership could lead to a more independent foreign
policy stance for Pakistan, allowing it to pursue its national interests with less reliance on US
support.
3. Economic Considerations:
Economic ties have always been a significant aspect of Pakistan-US relations. The United
States is an important trading partner and source of aid for Pakistan. However, the US has often
used economic assistance as a tool to exert influence on Pakistan's policies, leading to tensions.
As Pakistan diversifies its economic partnerships, it may seek to reduce its dependence on US
aid, thus contributing to its pursuit of strategic autonomy.
As the United States withdraws from Afghanistan, Pakistan's relations with the US stand at a
critical juncture. The "Friends not Masters" sentiment reflects Pakistan's desire for a partnership
that respects its sovereignty and national interests. While counterterrorism efforts, regional
stability, and economic ties will continue to shape this relationship, Pakistan's pursuit of
strategic autonomy will likely lead it to diversify its foreign partnerships and policies. The
evolving dynamics of the region, including its ties with China and India, will significantly
influence the nature and direction of Pakistan-US relations in the post-withdrawal era.
Balancing these factors will require skillful diplomacy and a clear commitment to promoting
peace and stability in South Asia.
Q3. The Ulema of Nadwah attempted to make a synthesis of modernism of Aligarh and
conservatism of Deoband in their syllabus. Discuss.
Answer:
The synthesis of modernism from Aligarh and conservatism from Deoband in the syllabus of
the Ulema of Nadwatul Ulema represents a fascinating attempt to reconcile two contrasting
Islamic educational ideologies. The Aligarh Movement, led by Sir Syed Ahmad Khan, and the
Deoband Movement, founded by Maulana Qasim Nanotvi and others, held differing views on
the approach to Islamic education in the face of modern challenges. The Nadwah sought to
bridge this gap by creating a curriculum that incorporated elements of both modernism and
conservatism, aiming to produce well-rounded Islamic scholars capable of engaging with the
modern world while maintaining traditional values.
1. The Aligarh Movement's Modernism:
The Aligarh Movement emerged during the 19th century as a response to the socio-political
challenges faced by Muslims under British colonial rule. Sir Syed Ahmad Khan emphasized the
importance of modern education, science, and rationality to uplift the Muslim community. He
believed that Muslims needed to embrace Western education and modern knowledge to progress
and compete in the changing world. Aligarh Muslim University was established with these
principles in mind, promoting modern education in various disciplines alongside Islamic
studies.
The synthesis of modernism from Aligarh and conservatism from Deoband in the curriculum of
Nadwatul Ulema represents a remarkable effort to navigate the complexities of Islamic
education in a changing world. By integrating modern sciences with traditional Islamic studies
and emphasizing Islamic values, the Nadwah aimed to produce scholars who were
well-equipped to engage with both the modern world and their religious heritage. This synthesis
reflects the ongoing tension between tradition and modernity in Islamic education and
demonstrates the capacity of Islamic institutions to evolve and adapt to meet the needs of their
communities.
Q4. The location of Pakistan has given strategic strength to the State. What are its
physical features and narrate its advantages and disadvantages?
Answer:
Pakistan's strategic strength is heavily influenced by its unique geographical location and
diverse physical features. Situated at the crossroads of South Asia, Central Asia, and the Middle
East, Pakistan's geography has endowed it with both significant advantages and some notable
disadvantages. These features play a crucial role in shaping Pakistan's geopolitical position,
trade routes, security considerations, and regional influence.
Physical Features:
Mountain Ranges:
Pakistan is home to some of the world's highest mountain ranges, including the Himalayas and
the Karakoram Range. Notable peaks like K2, the second-highest mountain globally, are located
within its borders. These mountainous terrains provide natural barriers and defensive positions,
enhancing Pakistan's strategic advantage.
Coastline:
Pakistan has a coastline along the Arabian Sea, which extends for approximately 1,046
kilometers. This coastline serves as a gateway to maritime trade and connectivity, enabling
Pakistan to access international markets and engage in maritime activities.
Strategic Location:
Pakistan's location at the crossroads of South Asia, Central Asia, and the Middle East grants it
significant geopolitical importance. It serves as a bridge between these regions, facilitating
trade, energy transit, and cultural exchanges.
Maritime Access:
The Arabian Sea coastline enables Pakistan to access international maritime trade routes,
connecting it to global markets. Gwadar Port, developed under CPEC, further enhances
Pakistan's maritime significance.
Natural Defenses:
The mountainous terrain of northern Pakistan offers natural defensive positions, which
historically have played a role in protecting the country from invasions. The difficult terrain can
act as a deterrent to potential aggressors.
Energy Opportunities:
Pakistan's diverse geography provides opportunities for energy generation, including
hydropower potential in its rivers and wind power potential in its coastal areas. Utilizing these
resources can contribute to the country's energy security.
Disadvantages:
Security Challenges:
The country's porous borders and proximity to conflict zones, such as Afghanistan, can expose
Pakistan to security challenges, including terrorism and cross-border conflicts.
Water Scarcity and Management:
While Pakistan relies heavily on its river systems for irrigation and water supply, disputes over
water resources with neighboring countries, such as India, can create challenges in water
management and agricultural productivity.
Landlocked Neighbors:
While Pakistan's location facilitates connectivity, it also shares borders with landlocked
countries like Afghanistan and the Central Asian states. Political instability or conflicts in these
neighboring regions can impact Pakistan's own stability and trade routes.
Pakistan's strategic strength is undeniably shaped by its geographical location and physical
features. The advantages it derives from its position as a crossroads of diverse regions and its
maritime access have the potential to drive economic growth and regional influence. However,
the country also faces challenges related to security, natural disasters, and water management,
which require careful policy considerations and strategic planning. Pakistan's ability to leverage
its advantages while mitigating its disadvantages will play a critical role in determining its
future development, stability, and regional significance.
Q5. Separation of East-Pakistan, though a tragic part of History of Pakistan, was not the
negation of Two-Nation theory.” Discuss.
Answer:
The separation of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) from West Pakistan (now Pakistan) in 1971
was undoubtedly a tragic and pivotal moment in the history of Pakistan. It marked the end of
the unity envisioned by the Two-Nation Theory, which had served as a foundation for the
creation of Pakistan in 1947. However, the separation of East Pakistan was not necessarily a
complete negation of the Two-Nation Theory. Rather, it highlighted the complexities of
nation-building, governance, and the need for an inclusive approach to accommodate diverse
linguistic, cultural, and regional identities within a united nation.
2. Unity in Diversity:
While the Two-Nation Theory emphasized religious identity, it did not ignore the diversity
within the Muslim community. The theory acknowledged the existence of various linguistic,
ethnic, and cultural groups among Muslims, which would be united under the umbrella of
Islam. However, the practical challenges of managing such diversity were not fully addressed
during the creation of Pakistan.
4. Economic Disparities:
Economic disparities between East and West Pakistan also played a crucial role in the
separation. East Pakistan was economically neglected, leading to feelings of exploitation and
deprivation. This economic disparity exacerbated the sense of injustice and fueled demands for
greater self-governance.
The separation of East Pakistan was indeed a tragic event in Pakistan's history, representing a
failure to effectively manage linguistic, cultural, and economic diversity within the framework
of the Two-Nation Theory. While it highlighted the limitations of a narrow interpretation of the
theory, it did not completely negate the idea of distinct religious identities. The tragedy
underscores the importance of inclusive governance, respect for linguistic and cultural diversity,
and the need to strike a balance between national unity and regional autonomy. The lessons
from this historical episode remain relevant for nations aiming to foster unity while respecting
the complexities of their diverse populations.
Q6. Discuss the obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan. In your view what
steps can be taken to achieve the goal of good governance?
Answer:
Good governance is a cornerstone of effective and equitable development in any country. In the
context of Pakistan, achieving good governance has been a persistent challenge due to a range
of complex obstacles. These obstacles, which include political, institutional, social, and
economic factors, have hindered the country's progress and development. To achieve the goal of
good governance, Pakistan must address these challenges and implement a comprehensive set
of measures that prioritize transparency, accountability, and the rule of law.
Political Instability:
Frequent changes in government, coups, and shifts in power have led to a lack of continuity in
policies and initiatives. This instability disrupts long-term planning and implementation,
making it difficult to achieve sustainable development.
Lack of Accountability:
Weak mechanisms for holding public officials accountable allow misconduct and misuse of
authority to go unchecked. This absence of accountability breeds impunity and encourages
further wrongdoing.
Anti-Corruption Measures:
Implementing robust anti-corruption strategies, independent anti-corruption agencies, and
whistleblower protection can help curb corruption. Emphasizing transparency in public
procurement and financial transactions is crucial.
a. Constitutional Amendment
The process of amending the constitution in Pakistan is governed by specific rules and
procedures outlined in the Constitution of Pakistan. Constitutional amendments play a crucial
role in shaping the legal and political landscape of the country and can impact a wide range of
issues, from governance structures to individual rights.
1. Process of Amendment:
The process of amending the constitution in Pakistan is outlined in Articles 238 to 239 of the
Constitution. A constitutional amendment can be proposed by either house of Parliament (the
National Assembly or the Senate) or by a joint sitting of both houses. The proposed amendment
must be passed by a two-thirds majority in the house that initiates the proposal.
2. Scope of Amendments:
The scope of constitutional amendments in Pakistan is broad, covering a wide range of topics,
including changes to the structure of government, the powers and responsibilities of various
institutions, the fundamental rights of citizens, and matters related to provincial autonomy and
federalism.
7. Judicial Review:
The constitutionality of a constitutional amendment can be challenged in the courts if it is
deemed to violate the basic structure of the constitution or infringe upon fundamental rights.
The judiciary in Pakistan has, on occasion, struck down amendments that it deemed
unconstitutional.
b. Kashmir Dispute
The Kashmir dispute is a long-standing territorial and political conflict centered on the region of
Kashmir, a picturesque region located in South Asia between India, Pakistan, and China. The
dispute dates back to the partition of British India in 1947 and has been a major source of
tension between India and Pakistan for decades. The issue has profound historical, political, and
humanitarian implications and remains one of the most contentious and complex disputes in
international relations.
1. Historical Background:
The origins of the Kashmir dispute can be traced to the partition of British India in 1947. At that
time, princely states were given the option to join either India or Pakistan, or remain
independent. The Maharaja of Kashmir, Hari Singh, a Hindu ruler of a predominantly
Muslim-majority region, chose to accede to India, triggering protests and resistance from the
local population.
2. India-Pakistan Conflict:
The accession of Kashmir to India was contested by Pakistan, leading to the first Indo-Pakistani
war in 1947-1948. The war ended with a ceasefire and the establishment of the Line of Control
(LoC), which divided the region between India and Pakistan. Subsequent conflicts in 1965 and
1999 further escalated tensions, and both countries claimed the entirety of Kashmir as their
own.
3. Humanitarian Consequences:
The Kashmir conflict has had significant humanitarian consequences, including human rights
violations, displacement, and loss of life. The region has witnessed protests, militancy, and
military crackdowns, resulting in a challenging humanitarian situation for the local population.
4. International Involvement:
The international community has been involved in efforts to resolve the Kashmir dispute. The
United Nations passed resolutions in the 1940s calling for a plebiscite in Kashmir to determine
its future, but the plebiscite has not been held due to various reasons, including disagreements
between India and Pakistan on its implementation.
5. Nuclear Implications:
The Kashmir dispute has added complexity due to the nuclear capabilities of both India and
Pakistan. The risk of conflict escalation has heightened concerns on the global stage, as both
countries possess nuclear weapons.
7. Regional Implications:
The Kashmir dispute has broader regional implications, particularly with China's involvement
in the region. China controls a portion of the territory, known as Aksai Chin, and its border with
India is a subject of contention. The complex geopolitical dynamics further complicate the
resolution of the conflict.
The Kashmir dispute remains a significant challenge that has not yet been fully resolved. Its
impact on the people of the region, the potential for military escalation, and the complex
historical and geopolitical factors involved make it a critical issue for international diplomacy.
A lasting resolution requires a commitment from all parties involved to engage in meaningful
dialogue, address the humanitarian concerns, and find a solution that respects the rights and
aspirations of the Kashmiri people while ensuring peace and stability in the region.
Pakistan, as one of the founding members of the United Nations (UN), has played a significant
role in the international organization since its inception in 1945. The country's contributions
encompass a range of areas, including peacekeeping operations, diplomacy, human rights
advocacy, and global development efforts. Pakistan's engagement with the UN reflects its
commitment to promoting international cooperation, peace, and sustainable development.
1. Peacekeeping Operations:
Pakistan is one of the largest contributors to UN peacekeeping missions. Its armed forces have
been deployed in various conflict zones around the world, including Africa, the Middle East,
and Asia, to maintain peace and stability. Pakistani troops have earned a reputation for their
professionalism and dedication to upholding UN mandates in challenging environments.
Q.No.2: Highlight the main problems in the industrial sector of Pakistan and also suggest
the measures for its improvement.
Answer:
The industrial sector of Pakistan faces several challenges that hinder its growth and
development. Some of the main problems in the industrial sector of Pakistan are:
1. Energy crisis: Pakistan's industrial sector suffers from a severe shortage of electricity and
gas, which results in frequent power outages and disrupts industrial production.
2. Lack of investment: The industrial sector of Pakistan is plagued by a lack of investment
in infrastructure, technology, and research and development.
3. Inefficient management: Many industries in Pakistan suffer from poor management
practices, resulting in low productivity, high costs, and low quality products.
4. Low value addition: Pakistan's industrial sector has a limited focus on value addition and
relies heavily on raw material exports, which limits its potential for growth and
development.
To improve the industrial sector of Pakistan, several measures can be taken, including:
1. Energy sector reforms: The government can invest in renewable energy sources, such as
wind and solar power, to reduce the reliance on traditional fossil fuels. The government
can also address energy theft and reduce transmission and distribution losses.
2. Investment in infrastructure: The government can invest in infrastructure, such as
transportation, communication, and water supply, to improve the overall business
environment and attract more investment in the industrial sector.
3. Human resource development: The government can invest in technical and vocational
education and training to develop a skilled workforce that can operate modern machinery
and increase productivity.
4. Research and development: The government can encourage innovation and research and
development by providing incentives to industries and funding for research institutions.
5. Promotion of value addition: The government can encourage value addition in the
industrial sector by providing incentives for industries that add value to raw materials and
reducing tariffs on machinery and equipment imports.
Q.No.3: Allama Iqbal's writings and views of Quaid-e-Azam explain their conceptual
understanding about the Islamic State. Do you agree that their vision found some place
while explaining the constitutional development throughout the case of Pakistan's political
history?
Answer:
Allama Iqbal and Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah were two of the most prominent
figures in the movement for the creation of Pakistan, and their writings and speeches provide
valuable insights into their vision for the new state. Both men had a deep understanding of
Islamic history and philosophy, and their views on the role of religion in politics were
influential in shaping the conceptual understanding of the Islamic State in Pakistan.
Allama Iqbal's writings and speeches emphasized the importance of creating an Islamic State
that would be based on the principles of social justice, equality, and the rule of law. He believed
that Islam provided a comprehensive framework for social and political organization, and that
the Islamic State should be guided by the principles of ijtihad (independent reasoning) and ijma
(consensus).
Quaid-e-Azam, on the other hand, emphasized the importance of creating a democratic and
pluralistic State that would protect the rights of all citizens, regardless of their religion or
ethnicity. He believed that the Islamic State should be based on the principles of social justice
and equality, and that it should provide a framework for the development and progress of all
citizens.
Both Allama Iqbal and Quaid-e-Azam's views found some place in explaining the constitutional
development throughout the case of Pakistan's political history. The Objectives Resolution of
1949, which was passed by the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, recognized the sovereignty of
Allah and declared that the principles of democracy, freedom, equality, tolerance, and social
justice would guide the new state. This resolution was seen as a compromise between the
competing visions of Allama Iqbal and Quaid-e-Azam, and it laid the foundation for the
subsequent constitutional development in Pakistan.
However, the implementation of this vision has been complicated by political and social
realities, and Pakistan has struggled to reconcile its Islamic identity with its commitment to
democracy and pluralism. The Islamization policies of the 1980s and 1990s, which were aimed
at making Pakistan a more Islamic State, were controversial and resulted in the marginalization
of minority groups and the erosion of democratic institutions.
Q.No.4: The debacle of 1971 was more the result of Big Powers' leaning towards India
rather than our domestic failures. Discuss the above statement by critically evaluating
Poland's resolution in the UN Security Council.
Answer:
The debacle of 1971, which resulted in the separation of East Pakistan and the creation of
Bangladesh, was a complex event that had multiple factors at play. While there were certainly
domestic failures within Pakistan that contributed to the crisis, the role of Big Powers' leaning
towards India cannot be ignored.
The Big Powers, such as the United States, the Soviet Union, and China, played a significant
role in the events leading up to the 1971 war between India and Pakistan. The United States, in
particular, was seen as favoring India, which led to a perception that Pakistan was being isolated
on the international stage. The Soviet Union also supported India and provided military
assistance during the war, while China supported Pakistan.
The Poland resolution in the UN Security Council is an important event to consider in this
context. The resolution, which was introduced by Poland and supported by the Soviet Union
and other countries, called for an immediate ceasefire and the withdrawal of Pakistani forces
from East Pakistan. The resolution also called for the deployment of UN peacekeeping forces to
the region.
While the Poland resolution was a significant blow to Pakistan's international standing, it is
important to note that it was not solely responsible for the debacle of 1971. Domestic failures
within Pakistan, such as the military's heavy-handed approach in East Pakistan and the failure to
address the grievances of the Bengali population, also played a significant role in the crisis.
Furthermore, the international community's response to the crisis was not solely driven by a bias
towards India. The human rights abuses committed by the Pakistani military in East Pakistan
were widely reported and condemned by the international community, and the United States
was also critical of Pakistan's actions.
Q.No.5: Examine Pakistan's relation with China in the context of CPEC. How is it going
to be a game changer for the South Asian region?
Answer:
Pakistan's relationship with China has deepened significantly in recent years, particularly in the
context of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). CPEC is a flagship project of
China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which aims to connect China with Europe, Africa, and
the Middle East through a network of infrastructure and transportation projects. CPEC is a game
changer for Pakistan and the South Asian region in several ways.
First, CPEC is expected to significantly boost Pakistan's economy by enhancing its connectivity
with China and the broader region. The project includes the construction of transportation
infrastructure, such as highways, railways, and ports, as well as energy infrastructure, such as
power plants and transmission lines. These projects are expected to create jobs, increase trade,
and improve access to energy, which are all crucial for Pakistan's economic development.
Second, CPEC is also expected to enhance regional connectivity by linking China with South
Asia and the Middle East. This could potentially create new economic opportunities for
countries in the region, and improve their access to markets and resources.
Third, CPEC could also have strategic implications for the region. Pakistan's relationship with
China has long been seen as a counterbalance to India's growing influence in the region, and the
deepening of this relationship could shift the balance of power in South Asia. Additionally,
China's presence in the region could have implications for regional security, particularly in the
context of China's tensions with India and the United States.
However, there are also concerns about the potential downsides of CPEC. Some analysts have
raised questions about the economic viability of the project, and whether it could lead to a debt
trap for Pakistan. Others have raised concerns about the environmental and social impact of the
project, particularly in the context of the development of the Gwadar port.
Overall, CPEC has the potential to be a game changer for Pakistan and the South Asian region
by boosting connectivity, enhancing economic growth, and shifting the balance of power.
However, its success will depend on the ability of Pakistan and China to address the challenges
and concerns associated with the project.
Q.No.6: Economic development without social change generates alienation in the society.
Discuss Pakistan's economic problems in the Musharraf era, in the light of the above
statement.
Answer:
The Musharraf era in Pakistan (1999-2008) was marked by significant economic growth, with
the country experiencing an average annual growth rate of around 7% during this period.
However, this growth was not accompanied by significant social change, and as a result, it
generated alienation in the society. This is because economic growth alone cannot solve all the
problems of a society, and without addressing the underlying social and political issues, it can
exacerbate existing inequalities and injustices.
One of the main problems of the Musharraf era was the lack of investment in social
development, particularly in education and healthcare. While the government increased
spending on infrastructure projects, such as highways and dams, it neglected social sectors that
are crucial for human development. As a result, Pakistan's social indicators, such as literacy
rates and healthcare outcomes, remained low, and this generated alienation among the
population, particularly among those who were left behind by the economic growth.
Another problem of the Musharraf era was the persistence of corruption and the concentration
of wealth in the hands of a few. While the government implemented some reforms to improve
governance and reduce corruption, these efforts were limited in scope and did not
fundamentally change the power structures in the society. As a result, the benefits of economic
growth were not distributed evenly, and the gap between the rich and poor widened. This
generated alienation among the poor, who felt left behind by the economic growth and the
political system.
The Musharraf era was also marked by a lack of democratic governance and political
participation. While the government introduced some reforms to improve governance and
decentralize power, these efforts were overshadowed by the authoritarian nature of the regime.
This limited political participation and civic engagement, and generated alienation among the
population, particularly among those who were excluded from the political process.
b. Kashmir Conflict:
The Kashmir conflict is a long-standing dispute between India and Pakistan over the status of
the Kashmir region. The dispute dates back to the partition of British India in 1947, which left
the Kashmir region divided between India and Pakistan. Both countries claim the entire region,
leading to multiple wars and ongoing tensions between the two countries.
The conflict has had significant consequences for the people of Kashmir, who have faced
violence, human rights abuses, and political repression for decades. The situation in the region
has also impacted regional stability, with the potential for the conflict to escalate into a larger
conflict between India and Pakistan.
Efforts to resolve the Kashmir conflict have been ongoing for many years, but progress has been
limited. The United Nations has called for a peaceful resolution to the conflict based on the
principle of self-determination for the people of Kashmir, but this has not been implemented.
To fully address the Kashmir conflict, both India and Pakistan will need to engage in
meaningful dialogue and find a peaceful and sustainable solution that addresses the concerns of
all parties involved.
Q.No.2: Aligarh Movement injected a new life in the dead body of the Muslim nation and
helped to regain its lost glory and prestige. Discuss.
Answer:
The Aligarh Movement, led by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, played a significant role in the revival of
the Muslim community in India during the 19th century. The movement injected a new life in
the dead body of the Muslim nation and helped to regain its lost glory and prestige. This was
achieved through a number of measures, which are discussed below.
Firstly, the Aligarh Movement emphasized the importance of education, particularly modern
education, for the Muslim community. Sir Syed believed that education was the key to progress
and development, and he established the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College in Aligarh in
1875 to promote modern education among Muslims. The college later became the Aligarh
Muslim University, which is now one of the leading universities in India. The focus on
education helped to equip the Muslim community with the skills and knowledge necessary for
social and economic advancement.
Secondly, the Aligarh Movement promoted the idea of social and religious reform among
Muslims. Sir Syed believed that traditional Islamic practices and beliefs were hindering the
progress of the Muslim community, and he encouraged Muslims to adopt a more modern and
rational approach to religion. This helped to break down the rigid social and religious structures
that had been holding Muslims back, and created a more open and progressive society.
Thirdly, the Aligarh Movement encouraged Muslims to participate in the political and social life
of the country. Sir Syed believed that Muslims needed to engage with the broader Indian
society, and to work towards their own interests within the framework of the Indian political
system. This helped to create a sense of political consciousness among Muslims, and paved the
way for the formation of the All India Muslim League, which played a key role in the
movement for Muslim political representation and eventually led to the creation of Pakistan.
Overall, the Aligarh Movement injected a new life in the dead body of the Muslim nation by
promoting education, social and religious reform, and political participation. These measures
helped to equip Muslims with the skills and knowledge necessary for social and economic
advancement, and created a more open and progressive society. They also created a sense of
political consciousness among Muslims, which played a key role in the movement for Muslim
political representation and the eventual creation of Pakistan. Therefore, the Aligarh Movement
is widely regarded as a significant turning point in the history of the Muslim community in
India.
Q.No.3: Examine Allama Iqbal's concept of Muslim nationalism in the light of Allahabad
address.
Answer:
Allama Iqbal's concept of Muslim nationalism can be examined in the light of his famous
Allahabad address, which he delivered in 1930. The address was a significant event in the
history of the Indian subcontinent as it outlined Iqbal's vision for a separate Muslim state.
In his address, Iqbal emphasized the need for a separate Muslim state as he believed that
Muslims were a separate nation with their own distinct culture and values. He argued that the
Hindus and the Muslims were two different nations and could not live together under a single
government. He proposed the creation of a separate Muslim state that would provide the
Muslims with the opportunity to develop their own culture and values.
Iqbal's concept of Muslim nationalism was based on the idea of a shared Islamic identity that
transcended geographical and cultural boundaries. He believed that Islam was the defining
factor of the Muslim community, and it was this shared identity that made them a separate
nation. He argued that Muslims needed to rediscover their Islamic heritage and values and
create a new Muslim identity that was based on their shared religious beliefs.
Iqbal's concept of Muslim nationalism also emphasized the importance of modern education
and scientific knowledge. He believed that Muslims needed to embrace modern education and
scientific knowledge to compete with the dominant Hindu community of the region. He
emphasized the importance of education in creating a new generation of Muslim leaders who
were well-versed in both Islamic theology and modern science.
Overall, Allama Iqbal's concept of Muslim nationalism, as outlined in his Allahabad address,
was based on the idea of a shared Islamic identity that transcended geographical and cultural
boundaries. He believed that Muslims needed a separate state to preserve their cultural and
religious identity and to compete with the dominant Hindu community of the region. He
emphasized the importance of modern education and scientific knowledge in creating a new
generation of Muslim leaders who were able to navigate the challenges of the modern world.
Q.No.6: The Objective Resolution (1949) satisfied both orthodox and modernists by
combining the features of Western and Islamic democracy.
Answer:
The Objective Resolution was a significant milestone in the constitutional history of Pakistan. It
was passed on March 12, 1949, and laid down the fundamental principles that would guide the
future governance of the country. The resolution was presented by the then Prime Minister,
Liaquat Ali Khan, and was unanimously adopted by the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan.
The Objective Resolution is significant because it sought to reconcile the traditional Islamic
values of Pakistan with modern democratic principles. The resolution declared that the
sovereignty of the state belonged to Allah, and that the Constitution of Pakistan would be based
on the principles of democracy, freedom, equality, tolerance, and social justice, as enunciated by
Islam. This was a bold attempt to combine the features of Western democracy with Islamic
principles.
The Objective Resolution was seen as a compromise between the orthodox and modernist
sections of Pakistani society. The orthodox sections wanted a constitution that was based solely
on Islamic principles, while the modernist sections wanted a constitution that was modeled on
Western democracy. The Objective Resolution satisfied both groups by combining the two
features.
The resolution laid down the basic principles of governance, which would be followed in
Pakistan. It declared that the Muslim community of Pakistan was a separate nation, and that
they had the right to govern themselves according to their own principles. It also declared that
the fundamental rights of all citizens would be protected, regardless of their religion, caste, or
creed.
The Objective Resolution also had a significant impact on the future governance of Pakistan. It
paved the way for the adoption of an Islamic constitution in 1956, which further reinforced the
Islamic principles enshrined in the resolution. It also provided a framework for the subsequent
amendments to the Constitution of Pakistan, which have been guided by the principles laid
down in the resolution.
b. Unemployment in Pakistan:
Unemployment is a significant issue in Pakistan, contributing to the country's economic and
social challenges. The main reasons for unemployment in Pakistan are:
1. Lack of Education and Skills: Many young people in Pakistan are unable to secure jobs
due to a lack of education and skills. They do not have the necessary qualifications or
experience to secure well-paying jobs.
2. Slow Economic Growth: Pakistan's economy has not been growing at a sufficient rate to
provide employment opportunities for its growing population.
3. Low Investment: Pakistan has a low rate of investment in its economy, resulting in a
limited number of job opportunities.
4. Corruption: Corruption is a significant problem in Pakistan, which impedes the growth of
businesses and discourages investors from investing in the country.
5. Political Instability: Political instability in Pakistan has a negative impact on the economy
and discourages foreign investment, which results in a limited number of job
opportunities.
Q.No.3: How do you substantiate that the speech of Quaid-i-Azam on 11 August 1947 was
a great vision that designed the futuristic political and social structure of Pakistan.
Answer:
The speech delivered by Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah on 11th August 1947, just a day
before the creation of Pakistan, was a remarkable vision that laid out the foundations for the
futuristic political and social structure of the newly created state. In this answer, we will
substantiate how this speech was a great vision that designed the future of Pakistan.
Firstly, the speech was a visionary call for unity and equality for all citizens of Pakistan,
regardless of their religion, caste, or creed. The Quaid-i-Azam emphasized that all Pakistanis
were equal citizens, with equal rights and duties, and that the state would ensure that all
individuals would be treated fairly and justly. This vision of a secular state was a remarkable
departure from the religious and communal divisions that had plagued the Indian subcontinent
for centuries.
Secondly, the speech laid out the economic and social policies that the government of Pakistan
would pursue. The Quaid-i-Azam recognized that Pakistan was a poor country with limited
resources, and he called for a focus on economic development and progress. He emphasized the
need for the government to prioritize education, healthcare, and social welfare, and to ensure
that all citizens had access to basic necessities such as food, clothing, and shelter.
Thirdly, the speech was a blueprint for a democratic and progressive political system. The
Quaid-i-Azam recognized the importance of democracy and the need for a political system that
was transparent, accountable, and responsive to the needs of the people. He called for the
establishment of a parliamentary system of government, with an independent judiciary and a
free press, and emphasized the importance of the rule of law and constitutionalism.
Finally, the speech was a call to action for all Pakistanis to work together to build a prosperous
and peaceful nation. The Quaid-i-Azam recognized that Pakistan faced many challenges,
including poverty, illiteracy, and sectarianism, but he was confident that these challenges could
be overcome through hard work, determination, and a commitment to national unity.
In conclusion, the speech delivered by Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah on 11th August
1947 was a visionary call for a secular, democratic, and prosperous Pakistan. The speech laid
out the foundations for the futuristic political and social structure of the newly created state and
continues to inspire Pakistanis to this day. The speech was a remarkable vision that designed the
future of Pakistan, and it remains an important and enduring legacy of the Quaid-i-Azam's
leadership.
Q.No.4: How did the partition of Punjab in 1947 affect the communal harmony?
Answer:
The partition of Punjab in 1947 was one of the most tragic and traumatic events in the history of
the Indian subcontinent. The partition led to the displacement of millions of people, the loss of
countless lives, and the destruction of communal harmony that had existed for centuries.
The partition of Punjab was a direct consequence of the division of India into two independent
states, India and Pakistan, on August 15, 1947. Punjab was divided along religious lines, with
the western part of Punjab going to Pakistan and the eastern part of Punjab going to India. The
division of Punjab was based on the religious majority of the areas, with Hindus and Sikhs in
the east and Muslims in the west.
The partition of Punjab had a profound impact on the communal harmony in the region. Prior to
the partition, Punjab was a region where Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs had lived together in
relative harmony for centuries. The partition of Punjab, however, shattered this harmony and led
to widespread communal violence and hatred between the different religious communities.
The partition of Punjab led to a mass migration of Hindus and Sikhs from West Punjab to East
Punjab, and Muslims from East Punjab to West Punjab. The migration was accompanied by
widespread violence and bloodshed, with members of each community attacking members of
the other community. There were incidents of rape, murder, and looting on both sides, and entire
villages were set on fire.
The communal violence was not limited to the migration of people. It continued even after the
partition, with members of each community seeking revenge for the atrocities committed
against their own community. The violence and hatred between the different religious
communities became deeply ingrained in the psyche of the people and continued to influence
their attitudes towards each other for years to come.
The partition of Punjab also had a profound impact on the economic and social fabric of the
region. Many businesses and industries were destroyed, and the agricultural economy was
severely disrupted. The partition led to the displacement of millions of people, many of whom
were forced to leave behind their homes and properties. This led to a loss of livelihood and
economic opportunity for many families.
Q.No.6: Discuss the important developments and events which shaped the Kashmir
Liberation Movement during the last one decade.
Answer:
The Kashmir Liberation Movement has been a long-standing struggle for self-determination and
autonomy in the region of Jammu and Kashmir. In the last decade, several important
developments and events have shaped the movement, including:
1. 2010 Kashmir unrest: In 2010, a series of protests and demonstrations erupted in
Kashmir, following the killing of a young man by security forces. The protests were met
with violence, resulting in the deaths of over 100 people. The unrest highlighted the
deep-seated grievances and frustrations of the Kashmiri people, and sparked renewed
calls for self-determination.
2. Burhan Wani's killing: In 2016, the killing of Burhan Wani, a popular militant
commander, sparked widespread protests and violence in Kashmir. Wani's death led to a
surge in militant activity and renewed calls for independence from India.
3. Abrogation of Article 370: In 2019, the Indian government revoked Article 370, which
granted special status to Jammu and Kashmir. The move was met with widespread
protests and criticism, with many Kashmiris viewing it as an attack on their autonomy
and identity.
4. Human rights abuses: The last decade has seen a significant increase in reports of human
rights abuses in Kashmir, including extrajudicial killings, torture, and arbitrary detention.
These abuses have fueled resentment and anger among the Kashmiri people, and have
further fueled calls for self-determination.
5. Diplomatic efforts: In recent years, there have been several diplomatic efforts to resolve
the Kashmir conflict, including talks between India and Pakistan, as well as international
mediation efforts. However, these efforts have yet to yield a lasting resolution to the
conflict.
6. Militant activity: Militant activity has continued to be a significant factor in the Kashmir
Liberation Movement, with several militant groups operating in the region. While some
groups have sought to achieve independence through peaceful means, others have
resorted to violence and terrorism.
In conclusion, the Kashmir Liberation Movement has undergone several important
developments and events in the last decade, including unrest, killings, abrogation of Article 370,
human rights abuses, diplomatic efforts, and militant activity. The movement continues to be a
complex and multifaceted struggle for self-determination and autonomy, with no clear
resolution in sight.
2017
Q.No.1: Give an account of the services of Sir Syed Ahmed Khan for the educational and
social uplift of the Muslims of the Sub-continent.
Answer:
Sir Syed Ahmed Khan was a visionary Muslim leader who dedicated his life to the educational
and social uplift of the Muslim community in India during the British colonial era. He was a
strong advocate of modern education and social reform and believed that education was the key
to the progress and prosperity of the Muslims.
Sir Syed founded the Aligarh Movement, which aimed to provide modern education to Muslims
and to promote the social and economic development of the Muslim community. He established
the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College in Aligarh in 1875, which later became the Aligarh
Muslim University, to provide modern education to Muslims in India.
Sir Syed also played an important role in promoting interfaith harmony and cooperation
between Muslims and Hindus. He believed that the two communities could work together for
the common good and that the future of India depended on their cooperation and understanding.
Furthermore, Sir Syed was a strong advocate of women's education and believed that women
should have access to modern education to enable them to play a more active role in society. He
established the Women's Association in Aligarh to promote the education and welfare of
Muslim women.
In addition, Sir Syed wrote extensively on various social, political, and educational issues,
advocating for reforms that would benefit the Muslim community. His book, "The Causes of the
Indian Revolt," is considered a seminal work on the causes of the Indian Rebellion of 1857.
Overall, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan's services for the educational and social uplift of the Muslims of
the Sub-continent were immense. His efforts paved the way for the modernization and progress
of the Muslim community in India and helped to promote interfaith harmony and understanding
between Muslims and Hindus.
Q.No.2: Discuss the background, text and importance of Pakistan Resolution 1940.
Answer:
The Pakistan Resolution, also known as the Lahore Resolution, was passed on March 23, 1940,
at the All India Muslim League's annual session held in Lahore, British India. The resolution
was presented by A.K. Fazlul Huq, the Chief Minister of Bengal, and seconded by Chaudhry
Khaliquzzaman. The resolution called for the creation of an independent Muslim state in the
northwestern and eastern regions of British India.
The background to the resolution was the growing sense of dissatisfaction among the Muslim
community in India with the prevailing political situation. Muslims felt that their interests were
not adequately represented in the Indian National Congress, which was dominated by Hindus,
and that their political and economic rights were being neglected by the British colonial
authorities.
The text of the Pakistan Resolution declared that "the Muslims of India desire a separate
homeland for themselves in which they can live according to their faith, customs and
traditions." It called for the creation of an independent Muslim state comprising the
Muslim-majority provinces of British India in the northwest and east. The resolution also
emphasized that the proposed state should be based on the principles of democracy and social
justice.
The importance of the Pakistan Resolution lies in its role in galvanizing the Muslim community
in India and giving them a clear and concrete goal to work towards. The resolution became the
basis for the demand for a separate Muslim state, which was eventually realized with the
creation of Pakistan in 1947. The resolution also highlighted the importance of the Muslim
community's distinct cultural and religious identity, and the need for a separate state to protect
their interests.
The Pakistan Resolution was a significant turning point in the history of India and paved the
way for the creation of Pakistan. It remains an important document in the political history of
South Asia, and its anniversary is celebrated in Pakistan as Pakistan Day.
Q.No.3: Compare and contrast the Islamic provision of the 1956, 1962 and 1973
Constitution of Pakistan.
Answer:
The Islamic provisions of the 1956, 1962, and 1973 Constitution of Pakistan represent the
changing attitudes towards the role of Islam in Pakistani society and politics. While all three
constitutions declared Pakistan an Islamic Republic, they differed in the degree of emphasis
placed on Islamic principles and their implementation.
1956 Constitution:
The 1956 Constitution declared Pakistan an Islamic Republic but did not provide a clear
definition of what that meant in practice. The constitution recognized Islam as the state religion
but also guaranteed the rights of minorities to practice their religion. The constitution did not
specify the role of Islamic law in the legal system, although it did state that no law would be
enacted that was repugnant to Islamic principles.
1962 Constitution:
The 1962 Constitution, drafted during the presidency of General Ayub Khan, placed greater
emphasis on the role of Islam in Pakistani society. The constitution established an Islamic
Advisory Council to advise the government on matters related to Islam, and Islamic principles
were to be the guiding force behind legislation. The constitution also established the office of
the President as the guardian of Islamic ideology and required all public officials to take an oath
of loyalty to Islam.
1973 Constitution:
The 1973 Constitution, adopted under the government of Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto,
made even more explicit provisions for the role of Islam in Pakistani society. The constitution
recognized Islam as the state religion and declared that all laws would be enacted in accordance
with the Quran and Sunnah. The constitution also established a Council of Islamic Ideology to
advise the government on matters related to Islamic law and ensured the protection of the rights
of minorities to practice their religion.
In contrast, the 1956 Constitution was relatively secular, with little emphasis placed on Islamic
principles. The 1962 Constitution placed greater emphasis on the role of Islam in Pakistani
society, although its implementation was largely symbolic. The 1973 Constitution went further
than either of its predecessors in establishing a clear role for Islam in the legal system and the
governance of the country.
In summary, while all three constitutions declared Pakistan an Islamic Republic, they differed in
their approach to the implementation of Islamic principles in Pakistani society and politics. The
1973 Constitution placed the greatest emphasis on the role of Islam, establishing clear
provisions for the implementation of Islamic law in the legal system and governance of the
country.
Q.No.4: What are the agricultural problems of Pakistan and what steps have been taken
by the government to overcome these problems?
Answer:
Pakistan is an agricultural country, and agriculture is the backbone of its economy. However,
despite its agricultural potential, Pakistan faces several challenges in this sector. Some of the
significant agricultural problems in Pakistan are:
1. Water Scarcity: Water scarcity is a significant problem in Pakistan, which limits
agricultural production. The country heavily relies on the Indus River system, but due to
poor water management, increasing population, and climate change, the availability of
water is decreasing rapidly.
2. Soil Fertility: Soil degradation and low fertility are other critical challenges for
agriculture in Pakistan. Overuse of fertilizers, soil erosion, and waterlogging have
reduced the productivity of the soil, making it difficult for farmers to grow crops.
3. Farm Mechanization: The use of modern farm machinery and technology is low in
Pakistan, leading to low productivity and high production costs.
4. Lack of Research and Development: The agricultural research and development sector in
Pakistan is underfunded, leading to a lack of innovation and technology adoption in the
sector.
To overcome these problems, the government of Pakistan has taken several steps, including:
1. Water Management: The government has started several initiatives to address water
scarcity, including the construction of new dams and the expansion of irrigation
networks.
2. Soil Conservation: The government has initiated various programs aimed at conserving
soil and improving its fertility. These include the promotion of organic farming, reducing
the use of chemical fertilizers, and encouraging crop rotation.
3. Farm Mechanization: The government is providing subsidies to farmers to purchase
modern farm machinery, such as tractors and harvesters, to improve productivity.
4. Research and Development: The government is investing in research and development in
the agriculture sector to improve crop varieties, introduce new technologies, and develop
efficient irrigation systems.
Overall, the government is making efforts to overcome the agricultural problems in Pakistan,
but much more needs to be done to improve productivity, reduce poverty, and ensure food
security in the country.
Q.No.5: What do you know about "The Punjab Protection of Women against Violence
Act-2016". Write in detail about the different court orders which can provide relief to
women under this Act.
Answer:
The Punjab Protection of Women against Violence Act 2016 is a landmark legislation enacted
by the Punjab government of Pakistan to provide legal protection to women against various
forms of violence, including domestic violence, emotional abuse, and harassment. The act
recognizes violence against women as a violation of their fundamental rights and seeks to
provide them with a safe and secure environment.
Under the act, women who have experienced violence can seek relief from various courts,
including the magistrate court, the family court, and the sessions court. The different court
orders that can provide relief to women under this act are:
1. Protection Orders: The magistrate court can issue protection orders to provide immediate
protection to women who are in danger of violence. The order can require the abuser to
stop the violence, stay away from the victim, and not communicate with them.
2. Residence Orders: The magistrate court can issue a residence order that requires the
abuser to vacate the shared residence and allow the victim to reside there.
3. Monetary Relief: The family court can award monetary relief to the victim to cover
expenses related to medical treatment, legal fees, and other costs incurred due to the
violence.
4. Compensation Orders: The sessions court can issue compensation orders requiring the
abuser to compensate the victim for the harm caused by the violence.
5. Recovery of Dowry: The family court can order the recovery of dowry, which is often a
source of domestic violence in Pakistan. The court can order the return of the dowry or its
value to the victim.
6. Restitution of Conjugal Rights: The family court can order the restitution of conjugal
rights, requiring the abuser to resume marital relations with the victim.
7. Divorce: The family court can grant a divorce to the victim if the violence has resulted in
the breakdown of the marriage.
The Punjab Protection of Women against Violence Act-2016 is a progressive legislation that
recognizes the need to provide legal protection to women against violence. The various court
orders that can provide relief to women under this act offer a range of options for women
seeking to escape violence and ensure their safety and security. However, the effective
implementation of this law is crucial, and there is a need for greater awareness among women
and society as a whole about this law and its provisions.
Q.No.6: Discuss the obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan. In your view
what steps can be taken to achieve the goal of good governance.
Answer:
Good governance is essential for the development and prosperity of any country, and Pakistan is
no exception. However, achieving good governance in Pakistan has been a significant challenge
due to various obstacles, including:
1. Corruption: Corruption is widespread in Pakistan and has a significant impact on
governance. It affects the allocation of resources, hinders economic growth, and
undermines public trust in the government.
2. Political Instability: Political instability is a major obstacle to good governance in
Pakistan. Frequent changes in government, political polarization, and weak democratic
institutions have led to a lack of continuity and consistency in policy making and
implementation.
3. Weak Institutions: Pakistan's institutions, including the judiciary, law enforcement, and
civil service, are often weak and under-resourced, leading to a lack of accountability,
transparency, and efficiency.
4. Lack of Public Participation: Public participation in decision making is limited in
Pakistan, leading to a lack of ownership and accountability in governance.
5. Terrorism and Security Issues: Pakistan is facing security challenges due to terrorism and
extremist ideologies, which have hampered economic growth, affected social cohesion,
and undermined the rule of law.
To achieve good governance in Pakistan, several steps can be taken, including:
1. Strengthening Democratic Institutions: Strengthening democratic institutions such as the
parliament, judiciary, and civil service is crucial for good governance. This can be done
by increasing their autonomy, ensuring their independence, and providing them with the
necessary resources.
2. Anti-Corruption Measures: Corruption can be addressed by strengthening anti-corruption
institutions, enforcing strict laws and regulations, and promoting transparency and
accountability in public institutions.
3. Public Participation: Encouraging public participation in decision making can lead to
greater ownership and accountability in governance. This can be done by ensuring
transparency in decision making, promoting public consultations, and engaging citizens
in policy making.
4. Investing in Education and Health: Investing in education and health is critical for human
development, and it can also lead to economic growth and good governance.
5. Addressing Security Issues: Addressing security challenges such as terrorism and
extremism requires a comprehensive approach, including law enforcement,
counter-terrorism measures, and addressing the root causes of violence.
Overall, achieving good governance in Pakistan is a long-term process that requires sustained
efforts, political will, and the involvement of all stakeholders, including the government, civil
society, and citizens.
Q.No.2: Lucknow Pact 1916 is considered the culmination of Hindu-Muslim Unity? What
circumstances led to this historic pact?
Answer:
The Lucknow Pact of 1916 is widely regarded as a significant moment in the history of
Hindu-Muslim unity in India. The pact was signed between the All India Muslim League and
the Indian National Congress, and it represented a rare moment of collaboration between the
two major communities in the country.
The circumstances that led to the signing of the Lucknow Pact were complex and multi-faceted.
One major factor was the growing sense of alienation among Muslims in India, who felt that
they were being marginalized and ignored by the Hindu-dominated Congress. This was partly
due to the Congress's emphasis on secularism and its reluctance to take up Muslim-specific
issues, such as the demand for separate electorates.
In response to this situation, the Muslim League had been advocating for greater Muslim
representation in the political system, including the introduction of separate electorates.
However, this had led to tensions between the League and the Congress, which saw the demand
for separate electorates as divisive and a threat to the idea of a united India.
The turning point came in 1916, when the Congress and the Muslim League held their annual
sessions in Lucknow. The two sides were able to find common ground on several key issues,
including the demand for self-government for India, the abolition of the Council of India, and
the inclusion of more Indians in the civil service.
Perhaps most importantly, the Congress agreed to support the Muslim League's demand for
separate electorates, as long as they were not used to create permanent communal divisions.
This was a significant concession by the Congress, and it helped to bridge the gap between the
two communities.
The Lucknow Pact was seen as a major achievement for both the Congress and the Muslim
League, and it was celebrated as a symbol of Hindu-Muslim unity. However, the pact was not
without its critics, and there were some who felt that it did not go far enough in addressing the
concerns of Muslims.
Despite these criticisms, the Lucknow Pact remains an important milestone in the history of
Hindu-Muslim relations in India, and it is remembered as a moment of cooperation and
collaboration between two communities that have often been at odds with each other.
Q.No.3: Give a brief account of constitutional and political developments in Pakistan from
1947 to 1956.
Answer:
Pakistan became an independent nation in 1947 after the partition of India, and in the years that
followed, the country underwent significant constitutional and political developments. Here is a
brief account of some of the key events during this period:
● 1947: Pakistan's first Constituent Assembly is formed to draft a new constitution for the
country. The assembly is dominated by the Muslim League, which had been instrumental
in the creation of Pakistan.
● 1948: The first governor-general of Pakistan, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, passes away,
leading to a power vacuum in the country. Khwaja Nazimuddin is appointed as his
successor.
● 1949: The Objectives Resolution is passed by the Constituent Assembly, which lays out
the guiding principles of the new state, including the establishment of an Islamic system
of governance.
● 1951: The first general elections in Pakistan are held, which are won by the Muslim
League. Khwaja Nazimuddin becomes the prime minister of the country.
● 1954: The Anti-Ahmadiyya riots break out in Punjab, which lead to a wave of sectarian
violence across the country. The government responds by declaring the Ahmadiyya
community as non-Muslims.
● 1955: The first Constituent Assembly is dissolved, and a new one is formed to draft a
new constitution for the country. The assembly is composed of delegates from all of
Pakistan's provinces and regions.
● 1956: The new constitution is adopted, which establishes Pakistan as an Islamic republic
with a parliamentary form of government. Iskander Mirza is elected as the country's first
president, while Chaudhry Muhammad Ali becomes the prime minister.
Overall, the period from 1947 to 1956 was marked by significant political and constitutional
developments in Pakistan. The country underwent a process of nation-building, which involved
the establishment of new institutions and the drafting of a new constitution. At the same time,
Pakistan was grappling with a range of social and political challenges, including sectarian
violence and the struggle to define the role of Islam in the country's governance.
Q.No.5: "The initial years of Pakistan were very crucial for its existence". Discuss.
Answer:
The initial years of Pakistan were indeed very crucial for its existence as a newly created nation.
Pakistan was formed as a result of the partition of India in 1947, and the country faced a range
of political, economic, and social challenges in its early years.
One of the biggest challenges that Pakistan faced in its early years was the issue of identity. The
country was created as a homeland for Muslims, but its population was diverse, comprising
people from different ethnic, linguistic, and religious backgrounds. The challenge for Pakistan
was to forge a common national identity that would transcend these differences and unite the
country.
Another major challenge that Pakistan faced in its early years was the issue of territorial
integrity. The country was geographically divided into two parts, with the eastern part (East
Pakistan, now Bangladesh) separated from the western part by India. This created a range of
logistical and security challenges for the country, which had to grapple with issues such as
transport, trade, and communication across the border.
Pakistan also faced economic challenges in its early years, as it had to build a new economy
from scratch. The country had limited resources and infrastructure, and it had to invest heavily
in areas such as agriculture, industry, and energy in order to create a sustainable economic base.
This was complicated by the fact that Pakistan was also struggling with issues such as inflation,
currency devaluation, and balance of payments deficits.
Finally, Pakistan faced a range of security challenges in its early years, including the issue of
territorial disputes with India and regional conflicts such as the Kashmir conflict. The country
also had to deal with internal security threats, such as sectarian violence and separatist
movements.
Despite these challenges, Pakistan managed to survive its early years and establish itself as a
sovereign nation. The country made significant progress in areas such as economic
development, education, and social welfare, and it played an active role in regional and global
affairs. However, the challenges that Pakistan faced in its early years continue to shape its
political, social, and economic landscape to this day.
Q.No.6: "Separation of East-Pakistan, though a tragic part of History of Pakistan, was not
the negation of Two Nations Theory." Discuss
Answer:
The Two Nations Theory was a concept that formed the basis of the demand for the creation of
Pakistan. It posited that Muslims and Hindus were two separate nations with distinct cultural,
linguistic, and historical identities, and that they could not live together in a single unified state.
The theory was used to argue for the creation of a separate Muslim homeland in the form of
Pakistan, which was established in 1947.
The separation of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971 was a tragic event in the history of
Pakistan. It was the result of a complex set of factors, including economic disparities, political
marginalization, and cultural differences between East and West Pakistan. The events leading up
to the separation of East Pakistan were marked by political unrest, protests, and military
intervention, culminating in a war between India and Pakistan that resulted in the creation of
Bangladesh.
Despite the tragedy of the separation of East Pakistan, it did not necessarily negate the Two
Nations Theory. The theory was based on the idea that Muslims and Hindus were two separate
nations, and it did not necessarily presuppose that Muslims were a single unified group with no
internal differences. The separation of East Pakistan was not a rejection of the idea that Muslims
and Hindus were two separate nations, but rather a reflection of the fact that within the Muslim
community there were different regional, linguistic, and cultural identities that needed to be
recognized and accommodated.
In fact, the separation of East Pakistan could be seen as an affirmation of the Two Nations
Theory, as it demonstrated that Muslims in different parts of the Indian subcontinent had
distinct identities and aspirations that needed to be recognized and respected. The fact that East
Pakistan ultimately became an independent country with its own national identity and culture is
a testament to the power of the Two Nations Theory in recognizing the diversity of Muslim
communities and their aspirations for self-determination.
In conclusion, while the separation of East Pakistan was a tragic event in the history of
Pakistan, it did not negate the Two Nations Theory. Rather, it demonstrated the need to
recognize and accommodate the diversity of Muslim communities and their aspirations for
self-determination. The Two Nations Theory remains an important concept in the history of
Pakistan and continues to shape its political and social landscape to this day.
b. Kashmir Dispute:
The Kashmir dispute is a longstanding territorial conflict between India and Pakistan over the
region of Jammu and Kashmir. The dispute dates back to the partition of India in 1947, when
the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir was given the option of acceding to either India or
Pakistan. The state's Hindu ruler opted for India, but Pakistan disputed the accession and sent
troops to occupy part of the region.
Since then, India and Pakistan have fought three wars over the region, and the dispute has
remained unresolved. The situation in Jammu and Kashmir remains volatile, with ongoing
violence, human rights abuses, and political unrest. India and Pakistan both claim the region in
its entirety, but control different parts of it, with India administering the majority of the region
and Pakistan controlling a smaller part.
The international community has been involved in efforts to resolve the Kashmir dispute, with
the United Nations playing a key role through its Security Council resolutions. However, a
resolution to the conflict remains elusive, and the situation in Jammu and Kashmir continues to
pose a significant challenge to regional stability.