Professional Documents
Culture Documents
hu2016
hu2016
PII: S0020-1383(15)00732-9
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.injury.2015.11.010
Reference: JINJ 6497
Please cite this article as: Hu S-J, Chang S-M, Zhang Y-Q, Ma Z,
Du S-C, Zhang K, The anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach for plating
posterolateral tibial plateau fractures: a novel surgical technique, Injury (2015),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2015.11.010
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
The anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach for plating posterolateral
Sun-Jun Hu, Shi-Min Chang, Ying-Qi Zhang, Zhuo Ma, Shou-Chao Du, Kai Zhang
t
ip
Sun-Jun Hu, Shi-Min Chang, Ying-Qi Zhang, Zhuo Ma, Shou-Chao Du
cr
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Yangpu Hospital, Tongji University School of Medicine,
us
450 Tengyue Road, Shanghai 200090, People’s Republic of China
an
Kai Zhang
Department of Human Anatomy, Tongji University School of Medicine, 1239 Siping Road,
M
Shanghai 200090, People’s Republic of China
d
e-mail: shiminchang11@aliyun.com
Page 1 of 46
The anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach for plating posterolateral
ABSTRACT
t
ip
Objective: The posterolateral (PL) tibial plateau quadrant is laterally covered by the fibular
head and posteriorly covered by a mass of muscle ligament and important neurovascular
cr
structures. There are several limitations in exposing and fixing the PL tibial plateau fractures
us
using a posterior approach. The aim of this study is to present a novel anterolateral
an
Methods: Five fresh and ten preserved knee specimens were dissected to measure the
following parameters:1) the vertical distance from the apex of the fibular head to the lateral
M
plateau surface, 2) the transverse distance between the PL platform and fibula collateral
ligament (FCL), and 3) the tension of the FCL in different knee flexion positions. Clinically,
d
supra-fibular-head approach and lateral rafting plate fixation. The outcome of the patients was
p
Results: The distance from the apex of the fibular head to the lateral condylar surface was
12.2±1.6 mm on average. With the knee extended and the FCL tensioned, the transverse
Ac
distance between the PL platform and the FCL was 6.7±1.1 mm. With the knee flexed to 60º
and the FCL was in the most relaxed position, the distance increased to 21.1±3.0 mm.
Clinically, a series of 7 cases of PL tibial plateau fractures were treated via this anterolateral
supra-fibular-head approach. The patient was placed in a lateral decubitus position with the
knee flexed to approximately 60 degrees. After the posterior retraction of the FCL, the plate
was placed more posteriorly to provide a raft or horizontal belt fixation of the PL tibial
plateau fragment. After an average of 14.3 months of follow up, the knee range of
Page 2 of 46
motion(ROM) was 121.4°±8.8° (range: 105°-135°), the HSS score was 96.7±2.6 (range:
90-100), and the SMFA dysfunction score was 22.4±3.8 (range: 16-28) points.
of the posterolateral tibial plateau quadrant and put the plate more posteriorly to provide a raft
t
for the fragments such that good clinical outcomes can be anticipated.
ip
cr
Keywords: Tibial plateau fracture, Posterolateral fracture, Surgical approach,
us
an
M
d
p te
ce
Ac
Page 3 of 46
Introduction
A posterolateral(PL) tibial plateau fracture, either isolated or combined with another tibial
morphological study, the PL articular fragment has an average depression depth of 10.5 mm;
t
ip
inadequate reduction and fixation of these fractures may result in knee flexion instability and
significant morbidity[5,6].
cr
Conventionally, it is difficult to reduce PL tibial plateau fractures through the usual
us
anterolateral approach because of the inadequate visualization of the typically posterior
displaced fragment and anatomic barriers of the fibular head and the fibular collateral
an
ligament(FCL). However, direct posterior approaches require dissection of the common
peroneal nerve, have deep and limited exposure, are vulnerable anterior tibial vessel or
M
popliteal vessel injury, and require the dissection of the ligamentous PL corner structure; some
approaches even require a proximal fibular osteotomy, which may cause iatrogenic
d
injury[7–12].
te
We present a novel technique to reduce and fix PL tibial plateau articular fractures
p
through an anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach, which can provide simple and effective
ce
exposure with rigid raft support for the depressed articular surface.
Ac
Page 4 of 46
Anatomic considerations
Five fresh and ten preserved knee specimens were used. None of these knee joints had signs
of previous injury, abnormality, or disease. The mean age of the donors was 61 years (range:
t
44-78 years).Five fresh knee specimens were from thigh amputations at the time of operation,
ip
while the preserved knee specimens were from the Department of Human Anatomy, Tongji
cr
University School of Medicine.
Each lower limb was dissected using the anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach.
us
Along the incision, the distal fibre bundles of the iliotibial band were released from Gerdy’s
an
tubercle to expose the deeper structure. The coronary ligament of the meniscus was cut open
to visualize the posterolateral tibial plateau. The fibular collateral ligament(FCL) was then
M
mobilized, and the tension of the FCL in different knee flexion angles was manually tested.
The FCL was most relaxed when the knee was flexed to 60º. With retraction of the FCL, the
d
max and mini transverse distance between the posterolateral platform rim and the FCL were
te
measured. The soft tissue structure was removed to measure the distance from the apex of the
Page 5 of 46
Surgical technique
The patients were placed in a lateral decubitus position with the injured limb maintained in a
slightly flexed position (Fig.2). A thick pad was applied under the distal femur; thus, the
t
weight of the lower leg can be used to open the lateral compartment of the knee.
ip
After sterilization, preparation and draping, the tourniquet was inflated. A 10-cm-long
cr
oblique skin incision was made, starting from Gerdy’s tubercle and extending
posterosuperiorly to cross over the fibular head to the joint line(Fig.3 a).The superficial
us
dissection was performed as usual. Then, the space between the FCL and the lateral condylar
an
was developed, and the FCL was mobilized to retract posteriorly with knee flexion to
approximately 60 degrees. The inferior border of the coronary ligament and joint capsule
M
were opened, and the lateral meniscus was proximally retracted using sutures (Fig.3 b). After
clearing the hematoma in the articular cavity, the posterolateral tibial plateau fracture can be
d
fully visualized, with supplementary manoeuvres of slight internal rotation and inversion of
te
below the articular surface. The depressed articular fragment was elevated using an osteotome
ce
to restore the congruence of the tibial plateau. Fine K-wire was used to maintain the reduction.
Alternative bone void fillers can be used to fill metaphyseal defects and add stability to
Ac
articular surface reductions, iliac crest autografts or allogeneic bone grafts. A 3.5-mm lower
profile lateral proximal tibia locking compression plate (3.5 mm LCP, Synthes Inc., Oberderf,
Switzerland) was used. The transverse arm of the L-shaped plate, 4 holes in length and 10 mm
in width (Fig.3 c), was placed as posteriorly as possible, through the superior fibular head
space (Fig. 3 d). Typically at least 2 screws can cross the posterolateral fragment, and the
posterior-most screw should be no more than 40 mm in length, i.e., long enough to cross the
Page 6 of 46
lateral condyle. As the articular surface was reduced and fixed, the broken posterolateral
cortex did not require further reduction or fixation. The opened coronary ligament and the
released iliotibial band fibre were sutured back before incision closure.
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
p te
ce
Ac
Page 7 of 46
Patient series
From Feb 2012 to Dec 2013, a consecutive series of seven patients who sustained isolated
posterolateral tibial plateau fractures were treated by open reduction and plate fixation using
the anterolateral supra-fibular-head approach. There were five men and two women, with an
t
ip
average age of 53 years (range: 29-76). Five cases were fixed using a 3.5 mm locking raft
plate (Fig. 4), and two cases were fixed with a horizontal belt plate by using a 3.5 mm distal
cr
radial volar plate (Fig. 5).
us
The average operation time was 78±9 min (range: 60-98). All incisions healed with no
cases of deep infection or osteomyelitis. None of the patients developed vascular injury,
an
peroneal nerve paresthesia or compartment syndrome. The fractures were healed at 3 months
After a mean of 14.3 months (range: 12-18)of follow up, all patients had normal knee
d
extension and returned to their pre-injury jobs. No patient manifested knee inflexion
te
in the injured joint that did not affect the patient’s daily work. According to the final
ce
assessment, the average knee range of motion(ROM) was 121.4°±8.8° (range: 105-135), the
average HSS score was 96.7±2.6 (range: 90-100), and the average SMFA dysfunction score
Ac
Page 8 of 46
Discussion
t
mm [13]. Although isolated posterolateral fractures consist of a small proportion
ip
(approximately 7 %) of all tibial plateau fractures, the treatment of choice is controversial.
cr
Traditional anterolateral approach is simple and familiar to orthopaedic surgeons.
However, the AL approach cannot provide full visualization of the posterior articular surface
us
(can be added with arthroscopy), cannot utilize the buttress plate, and has the risk of
an
iatrogenic injury of the popliteal vessels by K-wire or screw placement [14]. Lateral femoral
The posterior approach, using various types of skin incisions, was favoured by many
d
authors for direct visualization of the fragment and rigid fixation with a buttress plate
te
[7–10,16–19] but also has limitations [11, 20]. The posterior approach can be classified as
posterolateral with/without osteotomy (fibular neck, fibular head, and lateral femur condyle),
p
posteromedial, or posterocentral. The typical anterolateral approach has also been modified by
ce
2.
According to our study, a certain amount of space between the apex of the fibular head
and the lateral condylar surface exists and is approximately 12 mm in height on average,
which allows the possibility of placing the plate more posteriorly. Typically, two holes scan
be used to capture the posterior part of the articular fragments. With the knee flexed to 60º-70º,
the PL articular surface could be easily visualized by the internal rotation of the tibia and
Page 9 of 46
posterior retraction of the FCL. The reduction and plating of the PL fragment can be
manipulated through this interspace. Direct visualization of the articular surface can guarantee
The ideal indication of this approach is a pure PL articular depression fracture (Schatzker
t
type III) or an articular depression with a minimal posterior cortex displacement that does not
ip
need reduction. For a significant posterior cortex rupture and a PL cortical wall requiring
cr
reconstruction, a direct PL approach[7]or Frosch approach[16] of one skin incision with two
us
The advantages of the supra-fibula-head approach include the following: (1) the patient
an
in a lateral position rather than a prone position, (2)a simple and easy anterolateral approach,
reduction, and (5) can be used for isolated PL quadrant fractures or combined PL and AL
d
visualization of the posterolateral tibial plateau quadrant, place the plate more posteriorly to
p
provide a raft for the fragments such that good clinical outcomes can be anticipated.
ce
No funding was received in support of this study. None of the other authors have any
Page 10 of 46
References
posteromedial and posterolateral approaches for the treatment of tibial head fractures.
Unfallchirurg 1997;100(12):957–67.
t
ip
[2] Stallenberg B, Gevenois PA, Sintzoff SA Jr, Matos C, Andrianne Y, Struyven J. Fracture
of the posterior aspect of the lateral tibial plateau: radiographic sign of anterior cruciate
cr
ligament tear. Radiology 1993;187:821–5.
us
[3] Luo CF, Sun H, Zhang B, Zeng BF. Three-column fixation for complex tibial plateau
an
[4] Johnson EE, Timon S, Osuji C. Surgical technique: Tscherne-Johnson extensile approach
[7] Carlson DA. Posterior bicondylar tibial plateau fractures. J Orthop Trauma
2005;19(2):73–8.
Ac
[8] Solomon LB, Stevenson AW, Baird RP, Pohl AP. Posterolateral transfibular approach to
2010;24(8):505–14.
[9] Chang SM, Zheng HP, Li HF, Jia YW, Huang YG, Wang X, et al. Treatment of isolated
posterior coronal fracture of the lateral tibial plateau through posterolateral approach for
direct exposure and buttress plate fixation. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg
2009;129(7):955–62.
Page 11 of 46
[10]Yu GR, Xia J, Zhou JQ, Yang YF. Low-energy fracture of posterolateral tibial plateau:
1416–23.
[11]Huang YG, Chang SM. The posterolateral approach for plating tibial plateau fractures:
t
problems in secondary hardware removal. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2012;132(5):733–4.
ip
[12]Solomon LB, Stevenson AW, Lee YC, Baird RP, Howie DW. Posterolateral and
cr
anterolateral approaches to unicondylar posterolateral tibial plateau fractures: a
us
[13]Xiang G, Zhi-Jun P, Qiang Z, Hang L. Morphological characteristics of posterolateral
an
articular fragments in tibial plateau fractures. Orthopedics 2013;36(10):e1256–61.
[14]Hsieh CH. Treatment of the Posterolateral Tibial Plateau Fractures using the Anterior
M
Surgical Approach. Int J Biomed Sci 2010;6(4):316–20.
[15]Yoon YC, Sim JA, Kim DH, Lee BK. Combined lateral femoral epicondylar osteotomy
d
and a submeniscal approach for the treatment of a tibial plateau fracture involving the
te
[16]Frosch KH, Balcarek P, Walde T, Stürmer KM. A new posterolateral approach without
p
fibula osteotomy for the treatment of tibial plateau fractures. J Orthop Trauma
ce
2010;24(8):515–20.
for the treatment of posterior bicondylar tibial plateau fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma
Surg 2013;133(1):23–8.
tibial plateau: Reconstruction of tibial plateau fractures and avulsions of the posterior
[19]Chen WT, Zhang YQ, Chang SM. Posterolateral approach for plating of tibial plateau
Page 12 of 46
fractures and the risk of injury to the anterior tibial vessels. J Orthop Trauma 2013;27(9):
e228–9.
[20]Yu B, Han K, Zhan C, Zhang C, Ma H, Su J. Fibular head osteotomy: a new approach for
t
[21]Sassoon AA, Torchia ME, Cross WW, Cass JR, Sems SA. Fibular shaft allograft support
ip
of posterior joint depression in tibial plateau fractures. J Orthop Trauma
cr
2013;28(7):e169–75.
[22]Chen HW, Zhou SH, Liu GD, Zhao X, Pan J, Ou S, et al. An extended anterolateral
us
approach for posterolateral tibial plateau fractures. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc
an
2014[Epub ahead of print].
[23]Chang SM, Hu SJ, Zhang YQ, Yao MW, Ma Z, Wang X, et al. A surgical protocol for
M
bicondylar four-quadrant tibial plateau fractures. Int Orthop 2014;38(12):2559–64.
[24]Chang SM. Selection of surgical approaches to the posterolateral tibial plateau fracture by
d
Page 13 of 46
Table 1
Anatomic data.
t
to the lateral plateau surface
ip
Maximum transverse distance between the
posterolateral platform and the FCL with knee 21.1±3.0 mm 16-28 mm
cr
flexion in 60 degrees
Minimum transverse distance between the
posterolateral platform and the FCL with knee 6.7±1.1 mm 5-9 mm
us
extension
an
M
d
p te
ce
Ac
Page 14 of 46
1 Table 2
t
2 Trans-fibular [8] Good visualization Need osteotomy and dissection of
ip
Posterior buttress plate fixation CPM
3 Modified anterolateral No dissection of neurovascular structures Difficulty in exposure and
Cortical window [14] insurance of fracture reduction
cr
Screw fixation
4 Lateral femoral Direct visualization Need osteotomy and fixation
epicondylar osteotomy No injury to FCL Screw fixation
us
[15 ]
5 Direct posterolateral Direct visualization Limit visualization and space for
[7,9,10] Posterior buttress plate fixation manipulation
Need osteotomy and dissection of
an
CPM
Injury to PLC
6 Extensile lateral [16] Direct visualization Massive dissection
Posterior buttress plate fixation Need dissection of CPM
M
Can fix the AL fragment Injury to PLC
7 Posteromedial [17] No dissection of neurovascular structures Difficulty in exposure and
Posterior buttress plate fixation insurance of fracture reduction
8 Postero-central [18] Good visualization Need dissection of popliteal
d
3
4 PL: posterolateral, PLC: posterolateral corner, CPN: common peroneal nerve
5
6
Ac
7
8
Page 15 of 46
8 Figure Legends
11 a Schematic drawing to show the measurement. AB: The vertical distance from the apex
t
12 of fibular head to the lateral condylar surface rim. AC: The transverse distance between
ip
13 the posterolateral plateau rim and the FCL.
cr
14 b Fresh specimen.
15
us
16 Fig. 2. A lateral decubitus position with the injured limb maintained in a slightly flexed
an
17 position was used during the operation.
18
M
19 Fig. 3. Intra-operative illustration of the supra-fibula-head approach.
20 a Skin incision, starting from Gerdy’s tubercle, extending posterosuperiorly to cross over
d
22 b The coronary ligament and lateral meniscus was retracted proximally by sutures, and
23 the PL fragment has been elevated. Note the opened anterolateral cortical window.
p
24 c An L-shaped 3.5 mm LCP for the proximal tibiacan beput more posteriorly to raft the
ce
26 d Schematic diagram showing the raft fixation of the PL fragments by a more posteriorly
Ac
28
29
30 Fig.4. Case 1 Anterolateral supra-fibula-head fixation with a 3.5-mm lower profile lateral
32 a,b AP and lateral pre-operative views showed a typical posterolateral tibial plateau
Page 16 of 46
33 fracture.
34 c–e Pre-operative CT scan showed the fragment on the posterolateral quadrant of the
35 tibial plateau.
36 f,g AP and lateral view post-operation showed that the fracture was anatomically reduced.
t
37 h–j CT scan post-operation. Note that the posterolateral fragment was fully elevated and
ip
38 rafted by screws.
cr
39 k Three-dimensional reconstruction images post-operation showed that the plate was
us
41
an
42 Fig. 5. Case 2 Anterolateral supra-fibula-head fixation with a 3.5 mm horizontal belt plate.
43 a, b AP and lateral view before operation showed a typical posterolateral tibial plateau
M
44 fracture.
45 c, d Images of CT scan and reconstruction before the operation showed that the fragment
d
47 e Intraoperative photograph showed that the fracture was reduced and fixed by a
49 f,g AP and lateral intraoperative fluoroscopy images showedthat the fracture was
ce
50 anatomically reduced.
51 h–j Images of CT scan and reconstruction after operation. The fragment was elevated and
Ac
53
54
55
Page 17 of 46
55 Conflicts of interest
56
57 We declare that there were no financial or personal relationships with other people or
59
t
60
ip
61 Shi-Min Chang, M.D., Ph.D.
62 Department of Orthopaedic Surgery
cr
63 Yangpu Hospital, Tongji University School of Medicine
64 450 Tengyue Road
us
65 Shanghai 200090, P.R. China
66 Email: shiminchang11@aliyun.com
67
an
68 M
d
p te
ce
Ac
Page 18 of 46
1a.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 19 of 46
1b.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 20 of 46
2.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 21 of 46
3a.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 22 of 46
3b.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 23 of 46
3c.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 24 of 46
3d.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 25 of 46
4a.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 26 of 46
4b.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 27 of 46
4c.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 28 of 46
4d.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 29 of 46
4e.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 30 of 46
4f.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 31 of 46
4g.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 32 of 46
4h.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 33 of 46
4i.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 34 of 46
4j.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 35 of 46
4k.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 36 of 46
5a.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 37 of 46
5b.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 38 of 46
5c.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 39 of 46
5d.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 40 of 46
5e.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 41 of 46
5f.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 42 of 46
5g.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 43 of 46
5h.tif
i
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 44 of 46
5i.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 45 of 46
5j.tif
t
ip
cr
us
an
M
d
te
p
ce
Ac
Page 46 of 46