Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 44

Interstitial Lung Disease 1st Edition

Edition Harold R Collard And Luca


Richeldi (Auth.)
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebookmass.com/product/interstitial-lung-disease-1st-edition-edition-harold-r-co
llard-and-luca-richeldi-auth/
More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant
download maybe you interests ...

Oxidative Stress: Its Mechanisms, Impacts on Human


Health and Disease Onset Harold Zeliger

https://ebookmass.com/product/oxidative-stress-its-mechanisms-
impacts-on-human-health-and-disease-onset-harold-zeliger/

Developing the Digital Lung: From First Lung CT to


Clinical AI 1st Edition John D. Newell

https://ebookmass.com/product/developing-the-digital-lung-from-
first-lung-ct-to-clinical-ai-1st-edition-john-d-newell/

Mining Gold and Manufacturing Ignorance: Occupational


Lung Disease and the Buying and Selling of Labour in
Southern Africa Jock Mcculloch

https://ebookmass.com/product/mining-gold-and-manufacturing-
ignorance-occupational-lung-disease-and-the-buying-and-selling-
of-labour-in-southern-africa-jock-mcculloch/

3D Lung Models for Regenerating Lung Tissue Gunilla


Westergren-Thorsson

https://ebookmass.com/product/3d-lung-models-for-regenerating-
lung-tissue-gunilla-westergren-thorsson/
Nuts and Seeds in Health and Disease Prevention Victor
R. Preedy

https://ebookmass.com/product/nuts-and-seeds-in-health-and-
disease-prevention-victor-r-preedy/

Ansible for VMware by Examples 1st Edition Luca Berton

https://ebookmass.com/product/ansible-for-vmware-by-examples-1st-
edition-luca-berton/

Blood Money: La Famiglia De Luca: Vittorio Kristine


Allen

https://ebookmass.com/product/blood-money-la-famiglia-de-luca-
vittorio-kristine-allen/

Genes, Environment and Alzheimer's Disease 1st Edition


Lazarov

https://ebookmass.com/product/genes-environment-and-alzheimers-
disease-1st-edition-lazarov/

LUNG FUNCTION. 7th Edition John E. Cotes (Editor)

https://ebookmass.com/product/lung-function-7th-edition-john-e-
cotes-editor/
Interstitial Lung
Disease
HAROLD R. COLLARD, MD
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine
Department of Medicine
University of California San Francisco
San Francisco, CA, United States

LUCA RICHELDI, MD, PhD


Division of Pulmonary Medicine
Agostino Gemelli University Hospital
Catholic University of the Sacred Heart
Rome, Italy
1600 John F. Kennedy Blvd.
Ste 1800
Philadelphia, PA 19103-2899

INTERSTITIAL LUNG DISEASE ISBN: 978-0-323-48024-6


Copyright © 2018 by Elsevier, Inc. All rights reserved.

No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic
or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system,
without permission in writing from the publisher. Details on how to seek permission, further infor-
mation about the Publisher’s permissions policies and our arrangements with organizations such
as the Copyright Clearance Center and the Copyright Licensing Agency, can be found at our website:
www.elsevier.com/permissions.

This book and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under copyright by the Publisher
(other than as may be noted herein).

Notices

Knowledge and best practice in this field are constantly changing. As new research and experience
broaden our understanding, changes in research methods, professional practices, or medical treat-
ment may become necessary.
Practitioners and researchers must always rely on their own experience and knowledge in evalu-
ating and using any information, methods, compounds, or experiments described herein. In using
such information or methods they should be mindful of their own safety and the safety of others,
including parties for whom they have a professional responsibility.
With respect to any drug or pharmaceutical products identified, readers are advised to check the
most current information provided (i) on procedures featured or (ii) by the manufacturer of each
product to be administered, to verify the recommended dose or formula, the method and duration
of administration, and contraindications. It is the responsibility of practitioners, relying on their
own experience and knowledge of their patients, to make diagnoses, to determine dosages and the
best treatment for each individual patient, and to take all appropriate safety precautions.
To the fullest extent of the law, neither the Publisher nor the authors, contributors, or editors,
assume any liability for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products
liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instruc-
tions, or ideas contained in the material herein.

International Standard Book Number: 978-0-323-48024-6

Content Strategist: Patrick Manley


Content Development Specialist: Meredith Clinton
Design Direction: Renee Duenow

Printed in United States of America

Last digit is the print number: 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1


Contributors

Danielle Antin-Ozerkis, MD Robert J. Homer, MD, PhD


Associate Professor of Medicine Professor of Pathology and Medicine (Pulmonary)
Director, Yale Interstitial Lung Disease Program Yale University School of Medicine
Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Section New Haven, CT, United States
Department of Internal Medicine
Yale University School of Medicine Kirk D. Jones, MD
New Haven, CT, United States Professor
Department of Pathology
Jürgen Behr, MD University of California, San Francisco, School of
Department of Internal Medicine V Medicine
University of Munich San Francisco, CA, United States
Asklepios Kliniken München-Gauting Comprehensive
Pneumology Center Dong Soon Kim, MD, PhD
Member, German Center for Lung Research Emeritus Professor
Munich, Germany University of Ulsan
Seoul, South Korea
Stefania Cerri, MD, PhD
Center for Rare Lung Disease Kathleen Oare Lindell, PhD, RN
University Hospital of Modena Research Assistant Professor of Medicine
Modena, Italy Clinical Nurse Specialist
Dorothy P. & Richard P. Simmons Center for
Sonye K. Danoff, MD, PhD Interstitial Lung Disease
Department of Medicine Pulmonary, Allergy and Critical Care Medicine
Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine The University of Pittsburgh
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine Pittsburgh, PA, United States
Baltimore, MD, United States
Fabrizio Luppi, MD, PhD
Janine Evans, MD Center for Rare Lung Disease
Associate Professor of Medicine University Hospital of Modena
Rheumatology Section Modena, Italy
Department of Internal Medicine
Yale University School of Medicine Richard A. Matthay, MD
New Haven, CT, United States Boehringer Ingelheim Emeritus Professor of Medicine
and Senior Research Scientist
Charlene D. Fell, MD, MSc, FRCPC Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Section
Division of Respirology Department of Internal Medicine
Department of Medicine Yale University School of Medicine
University of Calgary New Haven, CT, United States
Calgary, AB, Canada

Christine Kim Garcia, MD, PhD


McDermott Center for Human Growth and
Development
Department of Internal Medicine, Division of
Pulmonary and Critical Care
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
Dallas, TX, United States v
vi CONTRIBUTORS

Amy L. Olson, MD, MSPH Aditi Shah, MD


Assistant Professor Division of Respirology, Critical Care, and Sleep
Department of Medicine Medicine
Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep Department of Medicine
Medicine University of Saskatchewan
National Jewish Health Saskatoon, SK, Canada
Denver, CO, United States;
Department of Medicine Leann L. Silhan, MD
Division of Pulmonary Sciences and Critical Care Department of Medicine
Medicine Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine
University of Colorado, Denver Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
Aurora, CO, United States Baltimore, MD, United States

Luca Paoletti, MD Paolo Spagnolo, MD, PhD


Assistant Professor Respiratory Disease Unit
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Department of Cardiac, Thoracic, and Vascular
Medical University of South Carolina Sciences
Charleston, SC, United States University of Padua
Padua, Italy
Silvia Puglisi, MD
Regional Referral Centre for Rare Lung Diseases Jeffrey J. Swigris, DO, MS
University of Catania Associate Professor
University-Hospital Policlinico–Vittorio Emanuele Department of Medicine
Catania, Italy Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep
Medicine
Luca Richeldi, MD, PhD National Jewish Health
Division of Pulmonary Medicine Denver, CO, United States;
Agostino Gemelli University Hospital Department of Medicine
Catholic University of the Sacred Heart Division of Pulmonary Sciences and Critical Care
Rome, Italy Medicine
University of Colorado, Denver
Ami Rubinowitz, MD Aurora, CO, United States
Associate Professor of Diagnostic Radiology
Chief of Thoracic Imaging Anatoly Urisman, MD, PhD
Department of Diagnostic Radiology and Biomedical Assistant Professor
Imaging Department of Pathology
Yale University School of Medicine University of California, San Francisco, School of
New Haven, CT, United States Medicine
San Francisco, CA, United States
Jay H. Ryu, MD
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Carlo Vancheri, MD, PhD
Mayo Clinic Regional Referral Centre for Rare Lung Diseases
Rochester, MN, United States University of Catania
University-Hospital Policlinico–Vittorio Emanuele
Giacomo Sgalla, MD Catania, Italy
National Institute for Health Research
Respiratory Biomedical Research Unit
University Hospital Southampton
Southampton, United Kingdom
CONTRIBUTORS vii

Robert Vassallo, MD Zulma X. Yunt, MD


Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Assistant Professor
Departments of Medicine, Physiology and Biomedical Department of Medicine
Engineering Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep
Mayo Clinic Medicine
Rochester, MN, United States National Jewish Health
Denver, CO, United States;
Timothy P.M. Whelan, MD Department of Medicine
Professor of Medicine Division of Pulmonary Sciences and Critical Care
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Medicine
Medical University of South Carolina University of Colorado, Denver
Charleston, SC, United States Aurora, CO, United States
Preface

The interstitial lung diseases (ILDs) are a large and het- congestive heart failure, pneumothorax, or drugs. How-
erogeneous group of disease entities that differ signifi- ever, in many cases the etiology is not certain despite
cantly with respect to presentation, cause, prevention, rigorous searches. The current state of our understand-
therapy, and prognosis. Many of them have no clear eti- ing of this important manifestation of IPF is discussed.
ology. However, in recent years considerable progress Also, the mechanisms of action of current and potential
has been made in our understanding of these entities. IPF therapies are reviewed, with particular reference to
In Interstitial Lung Disease, we discuss the most impor- current disease understanding and to highlight areas of
tant of the ILDs and update the reader about their IPF disease biology that afford attractive targets for the
management. development of the new treatments. The general man-
Arriving at the correct diagnosis often requires cor- agement of a patient with IPF is described, especially
relation with clinical, radiologic, and pathologic find- the management of important comorbidities (e.g., pul-
ings. The diagnostic strategy that should be employed monary hypertension and gastroesophageal reflux) and
when faced with a patient with ILD is described. symptoms (e.g., dyspnea, exercise limitation, fatigue,
Given the important role of high-resolution computed anxiety, mood disturbance, sleep disorders) that dra-
tomography (HRCT) in the diagnosis of ILD, we intro- matically affect IPF patients’ lives. Furthermore, the
duce pulmonologists and clinicians to the imaging increasingly important role of lung transplantation in
appearances of ILDs by providing a pattern approach the treatment of patients with ILD is discussed, espe-
to the evaluation of HRCT. In addition, a focused dis- cially the evidence suggesting that patients with pul-
cussion of the HRCT findings in the common ILDs is monary fibrosis undergoing lung transplantation have
presented. a favorable long-term survival compared with other
Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is the most disease indications.
common of the idiopathic interstitial pneumonias. Finally, several chapters review important individual
Over the past decade, our thinking about IPF has been ILD entities, including inherited fibrotic lung diseases,
reshaped and guidelines have been revised using an nonspecific interstitial pneumonia, ILD associated with
evidence-based approach. A number of epidemiologic connective tissue diseases, chronic hypersensitivity
studies have identified potential risk factors for IPF. We pneumonitis, and smoking-related ILDs.
summarize the approach to diagnosing IPF and review
its epidemiology. With improved understanding of IPF, Harold R. Collard, MD
we now recognize that there may also be distinct phe- Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine
notypes among this group of patients. Furthermore, we Department of Medicine
describe how the identification and management of University of California San Francisco
comorbidities may improve the overall quality of life San Francisco, CA, USA
and well-being of these patients. It has become clear
that the clinical course of individual patients with IPF is Luca Richeldi, MD, PhD
variable and that the sudden deterioration of a patient’s Division of Pulmonary Medicine
respiratory condition during a relatively stable course Agostino Gemelli University Hospital
is possible. This deterioration can result from well- Catholic University of the Sacred Heart
known causes such as infection, pulmonary embolism, Rome, Italy

ix
CHAPTER 1

Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease


CHRISTINE KIM GARCIA

KEY POINTS

• The interstitial lung diseases (ILDs), or diffuse parenchymal lung diseases, are a heterogeneous collection of more
than 100 different pulmonary disorders that affect the tissue and spaces surrounding the alveoli.
• Many of the genes involve pathways that lead to altered surfactant metabolism, increased ER stress signaling, and
telomere shortening.
• Genetics provides a molecular framework for explaining phenotypes and, sometimes, provides information that
directly affects patient care.

The interstitial lung diseases (ILDs) include a wide mechanism of disease. A detailed family history also
variety of relatively uncommon disorders. Technologic provides important information about personal and
advances in sequencing and genotyping have led to an family member phenotypes, providing important
explosion of genetic discoveries, shedding new light on clues that may suggest a certain genetic diagnosis. For
the underlying pathogenesis of ILD. New monogenic example, a personal or family history of bone marrow
syndromes have been described, often with clinically failure, early graying, or liver disease in a patient with
diverse and extreme phenotypes, based on the discov- adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis suggests a short telo-
ery of single gene mutations. In addition, many appar- mere syndrome. Younger and more severely affected
ently disparate clinical presentations have been linked individuals in later generations may reflect genetic
together through the discovery of mutations in the same anticipation, which can also be seen in short telomere
gene or mutations in multiple genes sharing a common syndromes. Some diseases show a predisposition for
pathway. These genetic discoveries have only further affecting a certain gender, for example, affected males
increased the number of discrete ILDs. The genetic eti- and asymptomatic carrier females suggest an X-linked
ology provides a molecular framework for the disease disorder.
and provides patients and their treating physicians All ILDs arise from the infiltration of inflamma-
with an explanation of phenotypes that are often seen tory and fibrotic mediators into the lung parenchyma.
across multiple organs. As more cohorts of patients are Very few cells normally reside within the interstitium,
described with these rare syndromes, more information which is the delicate space between the alveolar epi-
will be gleaned about the natural history of disease and thelial cells and the capillary vascular endothelial
best practices for surveillance and treatment. The goal cells. The filling of the interstitial space with inflam-
of this chapter is to summarize (1) genetic syndromes matory cells, activated fibroblasts, and extracellular
involving multiple organs, in which ILD is one of many matrix causes irreversible architectural distortion and
different phenotypes, and (2) genetic disorders in impairs gas exchange. Most ILDs share similar clinical
which ILD is the dominant phenotype. signs and symptoms, including respiratory distress and
As a rule, manifestations of ILD even within a cough. Pulmonary restriction and a decreased diffusion
single gene syndrome are generally characterized by capacity are frequently found, as well as radiographic
a spectrum of clinical presentations, a wide range evidence of parenchymal abnormalities. However, the
in age of onset, and incomplete penetrance. Thus, a radiographic and histopathologic features of ILDs vary
high level of suspicion is needed for many of these widely. Historically, the type of infiltrating cells, the
disorders. Detecting a pattern of inheritance in large, pattern of infiltration (nodular, reticular, alveolar), the
extended kindreds across multiple generations sepa- nature of extracellular protein deposits (collagen, elas-
rated by time and space strongly supports a genetic tin, periodic acid–Schiff [PAS]-positive), the location

1
2 Interstitial Lung Disease

of abnormalities (peripheral, alveolar, peribronchio- and extrathoracic lymphatic structures. The hallmark
lar), the pattern of the fibrotic response (fibroblastic feature of the disease is the radiographically apparent
foci, temporal/spatial homogeneity, or heterogeneity), numerous, round, thin-walled cysts, generally between
and the form of lung destruction (cysts, bronchiectasis, 2 and 60 mm in diameter, which are found throughout
honeycombing) have been used to describe different the lung. Extraparenchymal lung abnormalities include
clinical forms of ILD. Now that genetic underpinnings pneumothorax and chylous pleural effusions. Eighty
of some monogenic ILDs are being established, clas- percent of patients develop a pneumothorax at some
sification by genetic etiology may ultimately supplant time during the course of their disease. Pleural effusions
historical classification schemes. This will occur most are characterized by elevated triglyceride levels and an
readily for those disorders in which the genetic clas- abundance of chylomicrons. Obstructive and mixed
sification predicts specific treatments (e.g., sirolimus obstructive-restrictive ventilator defects are observed.
for tuberous sclerosis complex [TSC]–lymphangioleio- Renal angiomyolipomas occur in ∼30% of sporadic
myomatosis [LAM]). A genetic classification of ILD is LAM patients and in >90% of TSC-LAM patients.1
also advisable for those diseases in which the genetic LAM can occur either in patients with sporadic (non-
information provides information relevant to patient inherited) disease or in 1–3% of patients with TSC, an
care. For example, regular screening may lead to ear- autosomal dominant multisystem disorder character-
lier interventions to remove premalignant renal cancers ized by hamartomas in multiple organ systems, includ-
in patients with Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome (BHDS). ing the brain, skin, heart, kidneys, and lungs. The ILD
Similarly, knowledge of a monogenic short telomere manifestation of TSC patients is indistinguishable
syndrome provides prognostic information regarding from sporadic LAM.2 TSC patients who develop LAM
the rate of ILD progression and the nature of specific are often women over 30 years of age who have little
post–lung transplant complications. or no mental retardation. Extrapulmonary features
In this chapter, I focus primarily on disorders caused include facial angiofibromas (or adenoma sebaceum),
by rare mutations and include selected common vari- hypomelanotic macules (which are most easily visual-
ants that significantly increase susceptibility to ILD. ized with a Wood light), rough, yellow thickening of
The nomenclature of diseases follows the genetic clas- skin over the lumbosacral area (shagreen patch), ungual
sification system adopted by the Online Mendelian or periungual fibromas, renal angiomyolipomas, renal
Inheritance in Man (http://www.omim.org). Other pul- cysts, subependymal giant cell astrocytomas, brain
monary genetic diseases are not covered. I refer to other cysts, hamartomas, cardiac rhabdomyomas, dental pits,
excellent resources for reviews of alpha-1-antitrypsin epilepsy, learning difficulties, and mental retardation.
deficiency, cystic fibrosis and CFTR-related disorders, TSC is characterized by autosomal dominant inheri-
primary ciliary dyskinesia, pulmonary capillary or veno- tance. However, about two-thirds of patients have de novo
occlusive disease, pulmonary malformation syndromes, mutations. There are two genes associated with this syn-
and disorders that primarily affect the thoracic cage. drome. Mutations in TSC2 occur more frequently, account-
ing for 75–80% of all cases.3 Mutations in TSC1 are less
common.3 There are no mutational hot spots within these
GENETIC DISORDERS AFFECTING MULTIPLE two genes. In general, TSC2 mutations are associated with
ORGANS, INCLUDING THE LUNG more severe disease, more frequent and severe epilepsy,
Table 1.1 lists the defined genetic disorders that are mental retardation, and cortical tubers. Inactivation of
associated with ILDs, with the lung being only one of both alleles of TSC1 or TSC2 is needed for the develop-
the many different affected organs. In this broad cat- ment of tumors. Loss of heterozygosity is frequently found
egory that encompasses many different disorders, ILD in renal angiomyolipomas and supports Knudson’s two-
may be a more severe or life-threatening manifestation hit model tumor suppressor pathogenesis.4
of disease or one of the more common features associ- Most sporadic LAM results from two somatic muta-
ated with the disease. tions in the TSC2 gene, although rare cases are caused
by germline TSC1 mutations.5–7 In contrast with TSC
Lymphangioleiomyomatosis and Tuberous patients in whom germline mutations are present in
Sclerosis Complex tumor and normal tissue, the mutations in LAM patients
Pulmonary LAM is a rare disease that almost exclu- are generally not present in normal tissues. This sug-
sively affects women. It is caused by proliferating gests that two mutations arise in a precursor cell of ori-
smooth muscle–like cells, which can involve small gin and that the mutation-carrying smooth muscle–like
airways, the pulmonary vasculature, and intrathoracic cells spread to various organs (lungs, kidneys).
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 3

TABLE 1.1
Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease (ILD): Disorders Affecting Multiple Organs, Including the Lung
Pulmonary ILD
Disease Inheritance Gene Pathogenesis Involvement Presentation
LAM/tuberous Sporadic, TSC1, TSC2 mTOR ∼100% Multiple cysts
sclerosis AD activation
Birt-Hogg-Dubé AD FLCN Loss of ∼90% Multiple cysts
syndrome folliculin
Dyskeratosis XLR, AD, DKC1, TERC, TERT, Telomere Second Inflammatory
congenita AR NOP10, NHP2, shortening most serious infiltrates and
TINF2, WRAP53, complication interstitial fibrosis
RTEL1, ACD, CTC1,
PARN
RIDDLE syndrome AR RNF168 DSB repair defect 50% Pulmonary fibrosis
Hermansky-Pudlak AR HPS1, AP3B1, Cytoplasmic or- Described Fibrosis, foamy
syndrome HPS3, HPS4, HPS5, ganelle defect for those type II
HPS6, DTNBP1, with HPS1, pneumocytes
BLOC1S3, BLOC1S6 HPS2, and
HPS4
NKX2-1 related AD NPX2-1 Transcription fac- ∼50% Respiratory
disorders tor defect distress, NEHI,
pulmonary fibrosis
Neurofibromatosis AD NF1 Loss of tumor ∼10% Pulmonary
suppressor fibrosis, bullae
Poikiloderma with tendon AD FAM111B Unknown >50% UIP
contractures and
pulmonary fibrosis
ILD, nephrotic AR ITGA3 Integrin defect 100% Abnormal
syndrome, and alveolarization
epidermolysis
bullosa
STING-associated AD TMEM173 Increased >50% Alveolitis with
vasculopathy interferon fibrosis
Autoimmune disease AR ITCH E3 ubiquitin ligase ∼90% NSIP
with facial defect
dysmorphism
Autoimmune interstitial AD COPA ER stress ∼100% Lymphocytic
lung, joint, and kidney infiltration
disease
GATA2 deficiency Sporadic, GATA2 Transcription fac- ∼60% PAP
AD tor defect
CVID syndromes Sporadic, ICOS, CD19, CD20, Variable 55–90% Bronchiectasis,
AR, AD CD21, CD81, TN- antibody GLILD, organizing
FRSF13B, TNFRS- deficiencies pneumonia
F13C, LRBA, IL21,
NFKB1, NFKB2,
IKZF1
Agammaglobulinemia X-linked, BTK, IGHM, IGLL1, B cell defect ∼25% Bronchiectasis
AR, AD CD79A, CD79B,
BLNK, TCF3
Continued
4 Interstitial Lung Disease

TABLE 1.1
Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease (ILD): Disorders Affecting Multiple Organs, Including the Lung—cont’d
Pulmonary ILD
Disease Inheritance Gene Pathogenesis Involvement Presentation
Hyper IgE syndrome Sporadic, STAT3 STAT3 defect, ∼70% Bronchiectasis,
AD Lack of Th17 cells pneumatoceles
Activated PI3K-δ AD PIK3CD Activation of PI3K ∼75% Lymphoid
syndrome aggregates
CTLA4 deficiency AD CTLA4 Activated T cells ∼75% GLILD
X-linked reticulate X-linked POLA1 Increased type 1 ∼100% Bronchiectasis
pigmentary interferons
Gaucher disease, type I AR GBA Deficiency of acid ∼65% Gaucher cell
β-glucosidase infiltration
Niemann-Pick disease, AR SMPD1, NPC1, Deficiency of acid Various GGO and septal
types A, B, C1, and C2 NPC2 sphingomyelinase; thickening
defective intracellu-
lar lipid movement
Lysinuric protein AR SLC7A7 Defect of cationic PAP, septal
intolerance amino acid thickening
transport

AD, autosomal dominant; AR, autosomal recessive; DSB, double-stranded DNA break; GGO, ground-glass opacities; GLILD, granulomatous
lymphocytic interstitial lung disease; mTOR, mammalian target of rapamycin; NEHI, neuroendocrine cell hyperplasia of infancy; NSIP, nonspe-
cific interstitial pneumonia; PAP, pulmonary alveolar proteinosis; UIP, usual interstitial pneumonia; XLR, X-linked recessive.

The proteins encoded by these two genes regulate and represent a forme fruste of BHDS.17,18 Nearly all
the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) path- mutations, including the common mutation hot spot
way.8 Inhibition of the mTOR complex corrects the that introduces a frameshift mutation (c.1285insC
specific molecular defects underlying TSC. mTOR and c.1285delC), predict a truncated protein prod-
inhibitors cause shrinkage of renal or retroperito- uct.15 The pulmonary cysts are generally bilateral, are
neal angiomyolipomas and subependymal giant cell usually located in a subpleural distribution in the
astrocytomas in TSC patients.9–11 In addition, siro- mid- and lower-lung zones, and are of varying sizes,
limus stabilizes lung function, reduces respiratory ranging from round, oval, lentiform, to multisep-
symptoms, and improves the quality of life of LAM tated shapes.19,20 Because the skin findings typically
patients.12 appear in the fourth decade and the renal malignancy
can be a late finding (mean age of 48 years), a spon-
Birt-Hogg-Dubé Syndrome taneous pneumothorax in the second or third decade
This disorder, which is also known as Hornstein- of life is often the presenting manifestation.15,18
Knickenberg syndrome,13 is characterized by the The molecular mechanism of lung cyst formation is
autosomal dominant inheritance of multiple benign incompletely understood.
skin tumors, which are usually characterized as fibro- Genetic testing is indicated for all individuals with sus-
folliculomas. Approximately 90% of affected indi- pected BHDS because the presence of a mutation prompts
viduals have evidence of lung cysts,14 and up to 34% screening for renal cancer for which surgical resection may
develop kidney tumors.15 The disease is caused by be curative. As was described in a past case,21 the pheno-
loss-of-function mutations in the folliculin (FLCN) type of familial spontaneous pneumothorax may be the
gene.16 Two different studies, one using whole- presenting feature for the index case that then leads to the
genome linkage analysis and the other a candidate identification of an occult renal malignancy in a family
gene approach, independently found that kindreds member with a FLCN mutation. All first-degree relatives
presenting solely with familial spontaneous pneu- have a 50% chance of having the same germline FLCN
mothorax and/or lung cysts have mutations in FLCN mutation.
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 5

Dyskeratosis Congenita with the catalytically active RNA and protein compo-
Dyskeratosis congenita (DC) is a rare multisystem dis- nent of telomerase.34 Mutations in both genes encod-
order characterized by the classic triad of a lacy reticular ing telomerase (hTR, encoded by TERC gene and TERT)
pigmentation on the upper chest and neck, nail dystro- have been found in patients with autosomal dominant
phy, and oral leukoplakia. The prevalence is approxi- DC35,36; biallelic mutations in TERT have been found
mately 1 in 1,000,000, with death occurring at a median in patients with autosomal recessive DC.37,38 Germ-
age of 16 years.22 Patients are usually healthy at birth line mutations in TINF2, a component of the shelterin
and then develop different organ dysfunction, includ- complex that protects the telomeric ends of chromo-
ing bone marrow failure, pulmonary fibrosis, and eye, somes, mostly occur de novo and are found in patients
tooth, gastrointestinal, endocrine, skeletal, urologic, and with autosomal dominant DC.39,40 Mutations in the
immunologic abnormalities. Significant developmental gene ACD, encoding another member of the shelterin
delay is found for the more severe clinical variants of DC. complex, TPP1, have been found in two kindreds with
There is a wide variation in the severity and spectrum of DC.41,42 Compound heterozygous mutations in CTC1
clinical findings, which is only partly explained by locus were first described in patients with Coats plus and in
heterogeneity. The mode of inheritance varies by gene the phenotypically similar disorder cranioretinal micro-
mutation. Most patients in a large international registry angiopathy with calcifications and cysts and then were
are male with X-linked recessive inheritance.23 Kindreds later described in patients with autosomal recessive
with autosomal recessive and autosomal dominant pat- DC.43,44 CTC1 is part of the trimeric telomere capping
terns of inheritance are less common. For affected male complex that cooperates with the shelterin complex to
patients, the classic skin and nail findings are present in protect telomeres. Homozygous mutations in NOLA2
∼90%. The abnormal skin findings have been described and NOLA3 account for less than 1% of DC mutations;
as poikiloderma vascularis atrophicans or a latticework these genes encode NHP2 and NOP10, respectively,
hypo- and hyperpigmentation defect found especially which maintain the stability and proper trafficking of
on the neck, upper chest, and proximal limbs.23,24 Bone a complex of H/ACA small nucleolar RNAs, including
marrow failure is very common (>85%) and is the lead- the telomerase RNA, hTR.45–47 Mutations in WRAP53
ing cause of death. have been described linked to DC; this gene encodes
After bone marrow failure, pulmonary fibrosis is TCAB1 that binds telomerase and directs its localiza-
the most serious and life-threatening complication of tion to nuclear Cajal bodies, an important step in telo-
DC. In most cases it presents either after hematopoietic mere maintenance.48 Whole exome sequencing has led
cell transplantation25,26 or as a later manifestation of to the identification of heterozygous or compound het-
disease in those over the age of 30 years.27–29 Patients erozygous mutations in RTEL1.49–51 This gene encodes
with pulmonary disease have rales, digital clubbing, a a DNA helicase that is crucial for telomere maintenance
restrictive pulmonary defect, a reduced diffusion capac- and DNA repair. Homozygous or compound hetero-
ity, and diffuse interstitial markings on high-resolution zygous mutations in PARN have most recently been
computed tomography (HRCT) imaging of the chest. linked to autosomal recessive DC.52–54 The PARN pro-
Lung histopathology generally features a mixture of tein belongs to a family of conserved exoribonucleases
cellular inflammatory infiltrates and interstitial fibro- that shorten the poly(A) tail of messenger RNA through
sis.30,31 Clinical survival of DC patients after the devel- deadenylation. One of the RNA species that is modi-
opment of ILD is poor as pulmonary disease is generally fied by PARN is hTR or the RNA component of telo­
rapidly progressive. Death is usually 12–40 months merase.54 Thus, mutations in PARN lead to defective
after the onset of clinical symptoms.28 hTR and telomerase biogenesis and telomere disease.
Mutations in 11 different genes have been described Genetic anticipation has been seen in DC kindreds
in DC patients. Regardless of the pattern of genetic with TERC and TERT mutations. Inheritance of pro-
inheritance or the individual genetic mutation, all gressively shorter telomere lengths in each subsequent
DC patients exhibit short telomere lengths for their generation of mutation carriers provides a molecular
age.32 Telomeres are specialized structures essential for explanation for the observation of an earlier age of
maintenance of integrity of chromosomal ends com- onset in more severely affected individuals with each
posed of nucleotide repeats (TTAGGG)n and telomere- successive generation.36,55 Siblings who do not inherit
specific accessory proteins. Positional cloning first led the mutated gene can inherit short telomere lengths
to the identification of mutations in the DKC1 gene from the affected parent.56 Thus, DC patients have to
in those with the X-linked recessive form of the dis- inherit both short telomere lengths and a deleterious
ease.33 Dyskerin is a nucleolar protein that copurifies telomerase mutation to demonstrate anticipation.
6 Interstitial Lung Disease

RIDDLE Syndrome a peripheral distribution of HRCT reticulations with a


Patients with this very rare autosomal recessive disorder trend toward increasing involvement of the central por-
have a syndrome of increased sensitivity to radiation, tions of the lungs with progressive severity as a result of
immunodeficiency, learning difficulties, dysmorphic peribronchovascular thickening and bronchiectasis.73
features, short stature, and pulmonary fibrosis in later Surgical lung biopsies demonstrate lung remodeling,
years.57,58 The syndrome is caused by homozygous or numerous chronic inflammatory cells, and distinctive
compound heterozygous mutations in the RNF168 clusters of clear vacuolated type II pneumocytes with
gene, an E3 ubiquitin ligase critical for double-stranded florid foamy swelling and degeneration (“giant lamel-
DNA break (DSB) repair. It promotes ubiquitination of lar body degeneration”).78,79 Despite an early positive
H2A and H2AX, which, in turn, mediates accumula- study,76 a follow-up clinical trial showed no benefit of
tion of 53BP1 and BRACA1 at DSBs to promote DNA pirfenidone for the treatment of Hermansky-Pudlak
repair.59,60 It also has a role in TRF2-mediated protec- pulmonary fibrosis.80
tion of telomeres.61 Pathogenesis of pulmonary fibrosis is incompletely
understood. Studies of a mouse model of disease that is
Hermansky-Pudlak Syndrome homozygous for both HPS1 and HPS2 mutations dem-
Hermansky-Pudlak syndrome (HPS) is an autosomal onstrate additive effects of the genetic defects toward
recessive disease first described in 1959.62 It is character- the development of spontaneous pulmonary fibrosis.81
ized by oculocutaneous albinism, a bleeding diathesis Subpleural reticulations begin at 3 months and exten-
resulting from platelet storage pool deficiency, and in sive fibrosis is seen by 9 months.82 The histology of
some cases, pulmonary fibrosis.63 It is now known that the mouse lung replicates the human phenotype with
HPS is caused by defects of multiple cytoplasmic organ- “giant lamellar body degeneration” of the type II cells
elles, including melanosomes, platelet-dense granules, and demonstrates decreased phospholipid and surfac-
and lysosomes leading to diverse clinical features. tant protein (SP)-B and C secretion.81,83 The underlying
Other clinical features of the disease include granulo- molecular mechanism of murine HPS-associated pul-
matous colitis, neutropenia, immunodeficiency, cuta- monary fibrosis seems related to endoplasmic reticu-
neous malignancies, cardiomyopathy, and renal failure. lum (ER) stress and chronic alveolar epithelial type II
Currently the diagnosis is confirmed by the absence of cell injury.82
dense bodies on whole-mount electron microscopy of
platelets.64 Mutations in nine different genes cause this NKX2-1–Related Disorders
disease. Each of these genes functions in trafficking of These disorders include benign hereditary chorea, neo-
vesicular cargo proteins to cytoplasmic organelles or in natal respiratory distress, and congenital hypothyroid-
organelle biogenesis and maturation.65–70 HPS is the ism; it is also known as brain-lung-thyroid syndrome.
most common single gene disorder in Puerto Rico with Childhood-onset chorea is the hallmark clinical feature
an estimated frequency of about 1 in 1800 and a carrier of this disorder. Pulmonary disease is the second most
frequency of 1 in 21.71 Mutations in HPS1 and HPS3 common presentation, with nearly half of the patients
are found in 75% and 25% of Puerto Rican patients, having some type of pulmonary manifestation.84 These
respectively. include neonatal respiratory distress with or without
ILD generally causes symptoms in the 30s and, pulmonary hypertension, neuroendocrine cell hyper-
when it occurs, is generally fatal within a decade. plasia, ILD in children between the ages of 4 months
Patients have progressive restrictive disease with a to 7 years, and pulmonary fibrosis in older individu-
highly variable course.63,72 Pulmonary fibrosis has been als.85–87 Defective surfactant homeostasis and recurrent
described most frequently in patients with HPS1 muta- respiratory infections have been found to be a promi-
tions, and more rarely in patients with HPS2 or HPS4 nent feature in some subjects.86,88 Mutations include
mutations.72–77 In this regard, molecular subtyping is missense, nonsense, and deletions of the NKX2-1 gene.
important to assess the risk of developing pulmonary
fibrosis. In one of the largest studies, the mean age of Neurofibromatosis
onset was 35 years with a range of 15–53 years.72 The Neurofibromatosis (NF1) is an autosomal dominant
variability of pulmonary findings was generally not disorder that affects all ethnic groups. Type I, von
attributable to prior environmental exposures. Over Recklinghausen disease or classic NF1, is character-
80% of patients had abnormalities on CT scans, which ized by multiple (>6) café au lait spots, axillary and
were generally predictive of the degree of physiologic inguinal freckling, multiple cutaneous neurofibromas,
impairment and mortality. Most patients demonstrate and iris Lisch nodules. Pulmonary manifestations
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 7

are less common. The incidence of ILD in NF1 has Stimulator of Interferon Genes–Associated
been estimated at 6–12%.89–91 It is characterized by Vasculopathy, Infantile-Onset
lower lobe–predominant diffuse interstitial fibrosis Patients with this autosomal dominant disorder have
and honeycombing. Thin-walled bullae are present in an autoimmune vasculopathy that causes severe skin
almost all patients with ILD or may be seen in isola- lesions affecting the face, ears, nose, and digits, result-
tion; they are large, asymmetric, and typically involve ing in ulceration and necrosis beginning in infancy.
the upper lobes.91 Histologic evidence of an alveoli- Over 85% have an ILD apparent on HRCT chest imag-
tis and interstitial fibrosis has been found in patients ing. Lung biopsy samples demonstrate a scattered
with normal chest X-rays or those with only apical mix of lymphocytic inflammatory infiltrate, follicular
bullae.90 Although there is near complete penetrance hyperplasia and B-cell germinal centers, interstitial
of the disease after childhood, the ILD is not observed fibrosis, and emphysematous changes.97,98 Patients can
until adulthood, typically in patients older than have livedo reticularis, Raynaud phenomenon, myosi-
40 years of age.90 The disease is often progressive and tis, joint involvement, immune complex deposition,
may lead to pulmonary hypertension and right-sided hypergammaglobulinemia, leukopenia, and autoan-
heart failure.92 The pathogenesis of NF-associated ILD tibodies (antinuclear, antiphospholipid, anticardio-
is unknown. lipin). All cases are caused by heterozygous, missense,
gain-of-function mutations in the TMEM173 gene,
Poikiloderma, With Tendon Contractures, which encodes the STING (stimulator of interferon
Myopathy, and Pulmonary Fibrosis genes).97,98 Mutations lead to activation of STAT1.97
This rare disorder usually affects individuals from
early childhood; presenting features include thin hair, Autoimmune Disease With Facial
telangiectasias and pigmentary abnormalities on sun- Dysmorphism
exposed areas, and tendon contractures frequently This autosomal recessive disease has been described
involving the ankles and feet.93 There is incomplete only in children with features of failure to thrive, devel-
penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis; >50% of cases have opmental delay, dysmorphic features, autoantibodies,
lung involvement. When it is present, the pulmonary and inflammatory cell infiltration of the lungs, liver,
fibrosis generally develops during the second decade of and gut. Chronic lung disease was found in 9 of 10 chil-
life, is progressive, and can lead to death. The histopa- dren. Three had a chronic oxygen requirement and died
thology for at least one case was consistent with usual of respiratory failure. Surgical lung biopsy from one
interstitial pneumonia.93 Different missense mutations case showed a cellular, nonspecific interstitial pneumo-
in the FAM111B gene have been found in unrelated nitis (NSIP). All affected children in one large Amish
cases of different ancestry.94 The function of this gene kindred were homozygous for a frameshift mutation in
is unclear. the ITCH gene that is predicted to cause a truncation
of an E3 ubiquitin ligase.99 Of note, mice with a small
Interstitial Lung Disease, Nephrotic genomic inversion that disrupts the Itch and agouti
Syndrome, and Epidermolysis Bullosa genes develop a similar spectrum of immunologic dis-
Infants with this congenital autosomal recessive disor- ease of the spleen, lymph nodes, stomach, and skin,
der present with disease in multiple organs. The pul- as well as chronic pulmonary interstitial inflammation
monary and renal features cause significant morbidity and alveolar proteinosis.100,101
and mortality, although dermatologic features are
common (epidermolysis bullosa, thin hair, dystrophic Autoimmune Interstitial Lung, Joint, and
nails, onycholysis). The lung involvement is character- Kidney Disease
ized radiographically by diffuse ground-glass opacity This rare syndrome was recently elucidating by whole
and interlobular septal thickening. Histology demon- exome sequencing of patients from five unrelated
strates abnormal alveolarization with poorly septated families with autoimmune interstitial lung, joint, and
(“simplified”) alveolar spaces.95,96 All mutations are kidney disease.102 All patients had high-titer autoanti-
homozygous deletion/frameshift or missense muta- bodies, ILD, and inflammatory arthritis. The average age
tions in ITGA3, which encode an integrin alpha chain at presentation was 3.5 years, with a range of 6 months
belonging to a family of cell surface adhesion proteins. to 22 years. Some patients presented with pulmonary
One of the missense mutations prevents proper post- hemorrhage that required immunosuppression. Lung
translational modification of the integrin alpha chain biopsies showed lymphocytic interstitial infiltration
with defective cell surface expression. with lung-infiltrating CD4+ T cells and CD20+ B cells
8 Interstitial Lung Disease

within germinal centers. All mutations affect the same This genetically heterogeneous group of diseases
functional domain of the COPA protein, impair intra- includes those with variable antibody and B-cell,
cellular ER-Golgi transport, and lead to ER stress and T-cell, and NK-cell deficiencies, as well as defective
upregulation of cytokines. responses to vaccination. Mutations in multiple genes,
including ICOS,113 TNFRSF13B (encoding the trans-
GATA2 Deficiency membrane activator and CAML interactor TACI),114,115
Haploinsufficiency of the hematopoietic transcrip- TNFRSF13C (encoding the B-cell activating factor),116
tion factor GATA2 leads to a wide spectrum of diseases CD19,117 CD20,118 CD81,119 CD21,120 LRBA,121,122
including primary immunodeficiency syndromes such IL21,123 NFKB1,124 NFKB2,125 and IKZF1 (encoding the
as dendritic cell, monocyte, B lymphocyte, and NK hematopoietic zinc finger transcription factor),126,127
lymphocyte deficiency (DCML) and monocytopenia lead to sporadic, autosomal recessive, and autosomal
and mycobacterial infection syndrome (MONOMAC); dominant patterns of disease.
primary lymphedema with myelodysplasia (Emberger X-linked agammaglobulinemia (XLA) is an immuno-
syndrome); and susceptibility to myelodysplastic syn- deficiency disorder that occurs almost exclusively in
drome and acute myeloid leukemia. Besides immu- males from a failure of B-cell maturation. Although
nodeficiency (with predisposition especially to severe there is a high prevalence of pneumonia in XLA, there
viral, disseminated nontuberculous mycobacterial, and is a lower prevalence of chronic lung disease with 47%
invasive fungal infections), pulmonary disease, vascu- and 25% demonstrating abnormal pulmonary function
lar/lymphatic dysfunction, and hearing loss are com- studies and bronchiectasis, respectively.109 Although
mon.103–107 Most individuals have some manifestation the degree of immune dysregulation may be lower,109
of pulmonary disease; 79% have a diffusion defect, 63% the rate of progression of lung function decline is
with abnormal pulmonary function tests, 18% with greater for those with XLA.128 Between 85% and 90% of
biopsy-proved pulmonary alveolar proteinosis (PAP), cases are caused by mutations in BTK, the gene encod-
and 9% with pulmonary arterial hypertension.107 All ing Bruton tyrosine kinase and a key regulator in B-cell
lack anti–GM-CSF antibodies and are resistant to sub- development.129 The remaining cases include a geneti-
cutaneous or inhaled granulocyte-macrophage colony– cally heterogeneous group of patients with mutations
stimulating factor (GM-CSF) therapy. Chest CT findings in IGHM (encoding the mu heavy-chain),130 IGLL1
include reticulonodular opacities, “crazy paving,” and (encoding immunoglobulin lambda-like-1),130,131
paraseptal emphysema. Median age at first presentation CD79A,132 BLNK,133 CD79B,134 and TCF3.135
is 20 years, but is highly variable (5 months to 78 years). Autosomal dominant hyper-IgE syndrome is an immune
Most mutations are predicted to cause a loss of function deficiency disorder characterized by the triad of recur-
of the mutated allele, leading to haploinsufficiency and rent staphylococcal skin abscesses, pneumonias, and
autosomal dominant inheritance.106,108 Hematopoietic elevations of IgE (usually >2000 IU/mL). Survival is
stem cell transplantation is indicated for severe disease. typically into adulthood, but death is usually secondary
to infections. Diagnosis requires a high level of suspi-
Immunodeficiency Syndromes cion due to variability of phenotypic features. A clini-
Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) syndromes cal scoring system has been developed that combines
are all associated with an increased susceptibility to immunologic (elevated IgE, eosinophilia >700/μL,
recurrent infections, especially sinopulmonary infec- decreased T-helper [Th]17 cells, recurrent infections)
tions. There is a high variability of clinical features. and nonimmune features (retained primary teeth, sco-
Respiratory complications are frequently responsible liosis, joint hyperextensibility, bone fractures following
for patient morbidity and mortality and include acute minimal trauma, a typical facial appearance, and vascu-
infections, sequelae of infections (bronchiectasis), lar abnormalities). Pneumatoceles and bronchiectasis,
noninfectious immune-mediated infiltrates such as which result from aberrant healing of the pneumonias,
granulomatous lymphocytic interstitial lung disease are seen in ∼70% of patients and lead to significant
(GLILD) and lymphoma, and progressive respiratory mortality.136,137 Patients have heterozygous missense,
failure.109,110 When severe, bronchiectasis is gener- splice site, or small deletions in the STAT3 gene.138 Most
ally associated with obstructive lung disease; GLILD mutations cluster in the DNA-binding domain of this
is typically associated with restrictive physiology and transcription factor, which regulates responses to many
decreased diffusion capacity.111 Lung disease is fre- different cytokines. Patients’ purified native T cells are
quently found in patients with CVID, as >90% have unable to differentiate in vitro into IL-17–producing
radiographic abnormalities apparent on chest CT.112 Th17 cells, which play a critical role in the clearance of
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 9

fungal and extracellular bacterial infections of the lung and bone manifestations including osteopenia, lytic
and skin.139 Most patients represent sporadic cases, but lesions, bone crisis, and skeletal deformities. Infiltra-
autosomal dominant transmission has been seen in tion of Gaucher cells into the alveoli, interstitium,
some kindreds. and pulmonary capillaries can lead to lung involve-
Activated PI3K-delta syndrome is a monogenic auto- ment. Over 65% of patients with type I disease have
somal dominant disease that leads to overactivation pulmonary function abnormalities, but only a fraction
of the PI3K signaling pathway and lymphoprolifera- (<5%) have diffuse lower lobe linear infiltrates, restric-
tion. This autosomal dominant disease is character- tive physiologic impairment, and a reduced diffusion
ized by recurrent sinopulmonary infections, reduced capacity consistent with ILD.148,149 Enzyme replace-
IgG2, increased serum IgM, and impaired vaccine ment therapy can reduce organ volumes and improve
responses. In one series, 75% of patients had CT evi- the hematologic parameters and bone pain but is usu-
dence of bronchiectasis or mosaic attenuation.140 The ally poorly effective in treating the lung manifestations
lymphoid aggregates within the lung and can lead to of this disease.150 Other therapeutic treatments, such
the compression of nearby bronchi.110 Heterozygous as substrate reduction therapy as well as others, are in
missense mutations in PIK3CD result in increased development.151
phosphorylation of AKT, consistent with a gain of Niemann–Pick disease types A and B are caused by
function.140,141 an inherited deficiency of acid sphingomyelinase activ-
CTLA4 deficiency syndrome is an autosomal dom- ity. Type C is caused by defective movement of lipids,
inant immunodeficiency characterized by T-cell including cholesterol, from endosomes and lysosomes.
immune dysregulation. Pulmonary manifestations Patients demonstrate a range of ages and can have
mirror CVID with recurrent respiratory infections and diverse symptoms affecting the lung, liver, spleen, bone
GLILD. Lymphocytic infiltration is found for other marrow, skeleton, brain, muscle, mental ability, and
organs, including the bone marrow, kidney, brain, movement. The pulmonary manifestations include ILD
liver, spleen, and lymph nodes. Heterozygous loss- and recurrent lung infections. In some patients the ILD is
of-function mutations in CTLA4 have been recently predominantly in the bases with thickened interlobular
described.142,143 septa, interlobular lines, and ground-glass opacities.153
X-linked reticulate pigmentary disorder is a rare Lysinuric protein intolerance is an autosomal reces-
immunodeficiency disorder with features of recurrent sive disease caused by an inherited defect of cationic
infections and systemic sterile inflammation. Affected amino acid transport. There is excess urinary clear-
patients typically develop recurrent pneumonias in ance of these amino acids and deficient intestinal
the first few months of life. By childhood, affected absorption, which leads to depleted body pools.
males develop diffuse skin hyperpigmentation with Most patients present in infancy with failure to thrive,
a distinctive reticulate pattern, bronchiectasis, hypo- growth retardation, protein aversion, muscular hypo-
hidrosis, corneal scarring, enterocolitis, and recur- tonia, hepatosplenomegaly, and osteoporosis. In one
rent urethral strictures.144–146 A recurrent intronic study, all patients who developed a fatal respiratory
mutation has been found that disrupts the expression insufficiency, usually PAP, were children less than
of the catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase-alpha 15 years of age.154 Most adult patients have evidence of
(POLA1) and leads to increased production of type I an ILD on CT scans with interlobular and intralobular
interferons.147 septal thickening and subpleural cysts, but only a few
are symptomatic.154
Inborn Errors of Metabolism
Gaucher disease is an autosomal recessive lysosomal
storage disease characterized by the accumulation of GENETIC DISEASES IN WHICH
the glycolipid glucosylceramide due to the deficiency INTERSTITIAL LUNG DISEASE IS THE
of the enzyme acid-beta glucosidase. Diagnosis relies DOMINANT PHENOTYPE
on the demonstration of deficient enzyme activity in Table 1.2 lists the genetic disorders in which an ILD is
cells or the identification of two disease-causing muta- the dominant clinical feature. Included in this group
tions in the GBA gene. Patients can display a large are the surfactant disorders. Pulmonary surfactant is
variety of symptoms, ranging from patients who are a mixture of phospholipids and associated proteins
completely asymptomatic to those who present with that covers the alveolar surface at the gas-alveolus
perinatal lethality. The usual clinical findings include interface, where it functions to reduce surface tension
hepatosplenomegaly, anemia, thrombocytopenia, and prevent atelectasis. A group of genetic disorders
10 Interstitial Lung Disease

TABLE 1.2
Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease (ILD): Disorders in Which ILD Is the Dominant Phenotype
Disease Inheritance Gene Pathogenesis Presentation
Surfactant metabolism AR SFTPB Absent SP-B Neonatal respiratory failure
dysfunction 1
Surfactant metabolism AD SFTPC Lack of SP-C and Neonatal respiratory
dysfunction 2 ER stress distress, NSIP, UIP
Surfactant metabolism AR ABCA3 Phospholipid Neonatal respiratory
dysfunction 3 transport defect distress, PAP
Surfactant metabolism AR CSF2RA GM-CSF signaling PAP
dysfunction 4 CSF2RB defect
Interstitial lung and liver AR MARS Methionine tRNA PAP
disease ligase defect
Pulmonary fibrosis, AD TERT Short telomere Pulmonary fibrosis
telomere related, type 1 length
Pulmonary fibrosis, AD TERC Short telomere Pulmonary fibrosis
telomere related, type 2 length
Pulmonary fibrosis, AD RTEL1 Short telomere Pulmonary fibrosis
telomere related, type 3 length
Pulmonary fibrosis, AD PARN Short telomere Pulmonary fibrosis
telomere related, type 4 length
Pulmonary fibrosis, Various DKC1, TINF2, NAF1 Short telomere Pulmonary fibrosis
telomere related length
Pulmonary fibrosis and AD SFTPA1, SFTPA2 ER stress Pulmonary fibrosis,
adenocarcinoma adenocarcinoma, respiratory
distress in infancy
Pulmonary fibrosis Sporadic MUC5B ER stress? UIP, ILAs
susceptibility
Pulmonary fibrosis Sporadic TERT, TERC, OBFC1 Short telomere UIP
susceptibility length
Pulmonary alveolar AR SLC34A2 Phosphate trans- Microliths
microlithiasis port defect

ER, endoplasmic reticulum; GM-CSF, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor; ILA, interstitial lung abnormalities; NSIP, nonspe-
cific interstitial pneumonia; PAP, pulmonary alveolar proteinosis; SP, surfactant protein; UIP, usual interstitial pneumonia.

involving the production, processing, and clearance surfactant dysfunction disorders, patients with muta-
of surfactant has been recognized as an important tions in SFTPC display the broadest range in age of
cause of neonatal and pediatric respiratory illness. onset, with affected neonates to older adults.
This group, collectively referred to as surfactant dys-
function disorders,155 encompasses a variety of muta- Surfactant Metabolism Dysfunction, Type 1:
tions involving the genes that encode SP-B (SFTPB), SFTPB Mutations
SP-C (SFTPC), the ATP-binding cassette transporter SP-B deficiency is inherited in an autosomal reces-
A3 (ABCA3), and the receptor for granulocyte-mac- sive manner, and the majority of affected patients
rophage colony–stimulating factor (CSF2RA and develop respiratory failure in the neonatal period
CSF2RB). ABCA3 deficiency is the most prevalent for with rapid progression of disease and death at
the surfactant disorders that present in the neonatal 3–6 months.156–161 A few mutations that seem to con-
period with severe respiratory distress. Mutations in fer a milder phenotype have been found. Children
SFTPB, SFTPC, and NKX2-1 are more rare. Of all the with these mutations have partial expression of the
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 11

SP-B protein, survive longer, and go on to develop a in ABCA3 are the most common inherited defects in
chronic ILD.162,163 surfactant metabolism presenting either with severe
neonatal disease or as diffuse lung disease in infancy
Surfactant Metabolism Dysfunction, Type 2: or childhood.155,174,179,180 ABCA3 is an ATP-binding
SFTPC Mutations cassette transporter that localizes to the limiting mem-
Autosomal dominant lung disease due to mutations in brane of lamellar bodies where it functions in translo-
the gene encoding SP-C, SFTPC, was first described in cating phospholipids, primarily phosphatidylcholine,
2001 by Nogee and colleagues.164 The index case was a into these organelles for assembly and storage of surfac-
full-term infant who developed respiratory symptoms tant in type II AECs.181,182 The functional consequences
at 6 weeks of age. An open lung biopsy revealed his- of the ABCA3 mutations include decreased expression
tologic features of NSIP. The child’s mother had been of the protein, abnormal localization of the protein to
diagnosed with desquamative interstitial pneumonitis the lamellar membrane, production of surfactant that
at 1 year of age, and the child’s maternal grandfather is deficient in phosphatidylcholine, and increased alve-
had died from lifelong respiratory illness of unknown olar surface tension.183–185
cause. Both the mother and her infant had a hetero-
zygous mutation at the splice donor site in intron 4 Surfactant Metabolism Dysfunction, Types
(c.460+1G > A), which resulted in skipping of exon 4 4 and 5: CSF2RA and CSF3RB Mutations
and deletion of 37 amino acids.164 In the next year, a Protein alveolar proteinosis (PAP) is a rare form of
large five-generation kindred was described with 14 lung disease characterized by intraalveolar accumula-
affected family members.165 The age at diagnosis for the tion of surfactant, which results in respiratory insuffi-
affected individuals ranged from 4 months to 57 years ciency. Histopathology specimens from affected patients
and included four adults with surgical lung biopsy evi- demonstrate distal airspaces filled with foamy alveolar
dence of usual interstitial pneumonitis and three chil- macrophages and a granular, eosinophilic material that
dren with NSIP. Genomic sequencing revealed a rare stains positively with PAS reagent. In general, the under-
heterozygous missense SP-C mutation (L188Q) in all lying lung architecture is normal unless infection is pres-
analyzed individuals. Human type II alveolar epithelial ent.186 When the accumulated surfactant is removed, as
cells from one of the patients and mouse lung epithe- is done with whole-lung lavage, the gas exchange proper-
lial cells producing the mutant SP-C protein showed ties of the lung improve.186 Approximately 90% of PAP
abnormal lamellar bodies. Since these two studies, over cases are acquired and are referred to as primary PAP.187–
30 different mutations in SFTPC have been identified in 189 Circulating autoantibodies to GM-CSF can be found

children and adults. A missense mutation (c.218T > C) in over 92% of patients with primary PAP.190–193 These
that changes a conserved isoleucine at position 73 to antibodies block GM-CSF signaling in vivo, reduce
a threonine is one of the more common and accounts alveolar macrophage surfactant catabolism, and impair
for 25–35% of abnormal alleles.155,166–171 There is surfactant clearance.186,193–196 Secondary PAP occurs in
incomplete penetrance of the ILD phenotype and phe- several different clinical settings, such as in association
notypic heterogeneity. The disease ranges from severe with hematologic malignancies, immunosuppression,
respiratory distress in infants to IPF in older adults. inhalation of inorganic dusts, and certain infections.
Mutations of SFTPC are rare in individuals without a The GM-CSF receptor is composed of an α- and a
family history of pulmonary fibrosis.171–173 At present, β-chain, encoded by the CSF2RA and CSF2RB genes,
the disease phenotype is thought to be caused by aber- respectively.197 Mutations in both CSF2RA and CSF2RB
rant protein-folding, which elicits the unfolded protein have been identified in children with PAP.198,199 In
response, ER stress, and apoptosis of alveolar epithelial 2011, a case of adult-onset hereditary PAP was reported
cells.155,174–178 in Japan.200 Here, a 36-year-old woman with PAP had
elevated circulating levels of GM-CSF, no measurable
Surfactant Metabolism Dysfunction, Type 3: anti-GM-CSF antibodies, and reduced expression of the
ABCA3 Mutations GM-CSF receptor β-chain. Genetic sequencing revealed
There is a significant amount of phenotypic overlap a homozygous, single-base deletion at nucleotide 631 in
between patients with SFTPB mutations and those with exon 6 of CSF2RB. Both of the patient’s parents were het-
defects in ABCA3. Like SP-B deficiency, the disease is erozygous for the mutation. Hereditary PAP follows an
inherited in an autosomal recessive manner. Since autosomal recessive pattern. Mice with deletion of the
the first mutation was discovered in 2004, more than gene encoding GM-CSF or its receptor demonstrate a phe-
200 different mutations have been found. Mutations notype very similar to adults with primary PAP.186,201–204
12 Interstitial Lung Disease

Interstitial Lung and Liver Disease biopsies.210,218 While approximately half of patients
A specific and severe type of PAP has been described carry a diagnosis of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF),
affecting infants and children on Réunion Island.205 others have diagnoses of another idiopathic interstitial
Since 1970, 34 children have been diagnosed and pneumonia, unclassifiable lung fibrosis, chronic hyper-
treated, giving rise to an incidence of disease of 1 in at sensitivity pneumonitis, pleuroparenchymal fibroelas-
least 10,000 newborns. The lung disease progresses to tosis, idiopathic fibrosis with autoimmune features, or,
lung fibrosis despite regular whole-lung lavage. It has rarely, a connective tissue disease–associated ILD.218
recently been found that patients have biallelic muta- Many TERT mutation carriers with pulmonary fibro-
tions in MARS, the gene encoding methionine tRNA sis report past cigarette smoking or an exposure to a
ligase.205 Compound heterozygous mutations in the fibrogenic environmental insult, suggesting that injuri-
same gene have been found in one patient with mul- ous environmental exposures in conjunction with the
tiorgan disease, predominated by liver failure.206 The underlying inherited genetic predisposition lead to the
increased prevalence of disease on Réunion Island and lung disease. Disease progression is inexorable, with a
in nearby Tunisia and France is due to founder muta- mean transplant-free survival of <3 years after diagno-
tions. A potential benefit of high-dose methionine sis. TERT mutation patients undergoing lung transplant
supplementation has not yet been studied in these generally have a higher risk of cytopenias and other
patients. extrapulmonary complications.219–221
Genetic anticipation is seen for TERT mutation
Pulmonary Fibrosis, Telomere Related, patients, with an earlier age of diagnosis of lung fibrosis
Type 1 in subsequent generations.218 Similar to DC, progres-
Heterozygous mutations in the gene encoding the pro- sively shorter telomere lengths are found in subse-
tein component (TERT) of telomerase have been found quent generations of TERT mutation carriers, and these
in ∼15% of patients with autosomal dominant famil- shorter telomere lengths explain genetic anticipation
ial pulmonary fibrosis.207,208 The frequency of TERT seen in kindreds.36,210,218
mutations in patients with sporadic adult-onset ILD is
less common.208,209 Telomerase is a multimeric ribo- Pulmonary Fibrosis, Telomere Related,
nucleoprotein enzyme that catalyzes the addition of a Type 2
repetitive DNA sequence to the ends of chromosomes Heterozygous mutations in the gene encoding the RNA
known as telomeres. Each of the mutations is rare and component (TERC) of telomerase have been found in
associated with decreased in vitro activity of telomer- ∼3% of patients with autosomal dominant familial pul-
ase and short leukocyte telomere lengths. TERT muta- monary fibrosis.207,208 Each of the mutations is rare and
tions are the most common genetic mutations found associated with decreased in vitro activity of telomerase
in adult patients with ILD.210 In addition, adult-onset and short leukocyte telomere lengths. A wide range of
pulmonary fibrosis is the most common manifestation progressive adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis subtypes
of TERT mutations.211 Other clinical manifestations of are seen in patients with TERC mutations.218 Patients
TERT mutations include DC (see earlier discussion), with TERC mutations are generally diagnosed with ILD
aplastic anemia and other forms of bone marrow fail- at an earlier age (51 years) than TERT mutation carri-
ure,212 liver disease including liver cirrhosis,213,214 early ers (58 years). In addition, they have a higher incidence
graying of hair,215 and an increased risk for myelodys- of hematologic comorbidities, especially leukopenia,
plastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukemia.216,217 thrombocytopenia, aplastic anemia, or myelodysplas-
Altogether, disparate clinical presentations and dis- tic syndrome.
eases linked together by defects in telomere-related
genes and characterized by short telomere lengths are Pulmonary Fibrosis, Telomere Related,
known as monogenic short telomere syndromes or Type 3
telomeropathies. Autosomal dominant pulmonary fibrosis with incom-
The penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis in TERT plete penetrance has been linked to rare mutations
mutation carriers is age and gender dependent.210 The in RTEL1.222–224 RTEL1 surpassed the threshold for
penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis for men aged 40–49, genomewide significance when comparing the num-
50–59, and >60 years is 14%, 38%, and 60%, respec- ber of observed versus expected novel damaging or
tively. Women show the same age-dependent increase conserved missense mutations in familial pulmonary
in penetrance. Microscopic honeycombing and fibro- fibrosis cases and controls.223 Across independent
blastic foci are commonly found in surgical lung studies, RTEL1 mutations are rare and associated with
CHAPTER 1 Genetic Interstitial Lung Disease 13

short leukocyte telomere lengths. This gene encodes Pulmonary Fibrosis, Other Telomere Related
the regulator of telomere elongation helicase 1 and has Genes found to be mutated in DC patients are candidate
a known role in telomere maintenance. Mutations in genes for patients with adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis and
RTEL1 were previously shown to cause Hoyeraal-Hre- short telomere lengths. Similar to the other short telomere
idarsson syndrome, a severe variant of DC (see earlier syndromes mentioned earlier, many individuals have clin-
discussion), in which affected children generally have ical features that overlap with DC, including bone marrow
very short telomere lengths and biallelic mutations. In abnormalities and skin changes. A missense mutation in
contrast, those affected with adult-onset pulmonary the DKC1, encoding dyskerin, has been reported in a kin-
fibrosis are heterozygous for rare missense or loss-of- dred with two affected older males with interstitial fibro-
function RTEL1 mutations. Similar to patients with sis, hyperpigmented skin changes, dyskeratotic nails, and
TERT mutations, ∼50% of heterozygous RTEL1 muta- macrocytic anemia.225 Blood leukocyte telomere lengths
tion carriers have hematologic manifestations such as were short. The expression of hTR in a lymphoblastoid
anemia or macrocytosis.218 A wide range of progressive cell line derived from the proband was lower than that
adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis subtypes are seen in of controls, even though expression of DKC1 was not
patients with RTEL1 mutations. Genetic anticipation is reduced. Female mutation carriers were unaffected.
also seen in RTEL1 kindreds. TINF2 encodes one of the shelterin complex pro-
teins that functions to protect the telomeric ends of
Pulmonary Fibrosis, Telomere Related, Type 4 chromosomes. Exome sequencing revealed a complex
Exome sequencing has linked autosomal dominant spice acceptor site and missense mutation on the same
pulmonary fibrosis with incomplete penetrance to TINF2 allele, with predominant expression of the mis-
mutations in PARN, the gene encoding a polyadenyl- sense mutation in lung-derived DNA from a female
ate-specific ribonuclease.223 PARN surpassed the thresh- patient with pulmonary fibrosis and infertility.226
old for genomewide significance when comparing the Heterozygous loss of function mutations in NAF1
number of observed versus expected novel damaging have most recently been linked to pulmonary fibrosis-
mutations in cases and controls.223 Most mutations are emphysema, short telomere lengths, bone marrow fail-
predicted to cause protein loss of function (splice site, ure, and liver disease.226a NAF1 has been shown to be
nonsense, and frameshift). One large kindred was iden- essential for the biogenesis of telomerase RNA.
tified by linking together two smaller and previously
unknowingly related kindreds with familial pulmonary Pulmonary Fibrosis and Adenocarcinoma,
fibrosis and an identical splice-site PARN mutation. The Related to Surfactant A Mutations
kinship of the two families was confirmed by demon- Novel missense mutations in the gene encoding SP-A2
strating that the two probands share ∼6% of their over- (SFTPA2) were discovered by genomewide linkage
all genome, including the genomic segment on which followed by sequencing candidate genes within the
the PARN mutation is located. As a further test for the linked region.227 Affected individuals have evidence of
relevance of the PARN mutations, the cosegregation of pulmonary fibrosis and/or lung adenocarcinoma with
the mutations with pulmonary fibrosis was compared features of bronchoalveolar cell carcinoma. A second
across extended kindreds. The overall backward LOD study reported three additional rare SFTPA2 mutations
score across all informative PARN kindreds was 3.6, in patients with adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis and
reflecting an odds ratio of 1:4096 in favor of linkage. a personal or family history of adenocarcinoma.228 A
Other clinical manifestations of PARN mutations third study has recently described the cosegregation
include DC (see earlier discussion), in which biallelic of ILD and lung adenocarcinoma in an extended kin-
mutations in the gene are frequently found.52–54 Patient dred with a germline mutation in SFTPA1 that is pre-
cells show deficiencies in trimming of small nucleolar dicted to change a conserved tryptophan at position
RNAs, including abnormally adenylated hTR.54 In general, 211 (Trp211Arg).229 While most of the affected indi-
leukocyte telomere lengths of PARN mutation patients are viduals in the SFTPA1 kindred were affected with an
shorter than in controls, but longer than in subjects with ILD after age 30 (range 31–69 years at diagnosis), one
TERT, TERC, or RTEL1 mutations.223 Patients with PARN was diagnosed at 7 months of age and died of respira-
mutations are generally diagnosed with ILD at an older tory failure 2 months later.229 Thus, a wide range of age
age (64 years) than TERT mutation carriers (58 years).218 at the time of diagnosis is observed, from respiratory
However, once pulmonary fibrosis is diagnosed, the respi- insufficiency in infancy to lung fibrosis and adenocar-
ratory disease progresses and patients have a mean trans- cinoma in adulthood. All known mutations in the sur-
plant-free survival of 5.7 years from diagnosis. factant A genes affect highly conserved residues in the
14 Interstitial Lung Disease

carbohydrate recognition domain of the proteins. Two lead to increased susceptibility to lung fibrosis through
of the mutations are predicted to alter the same glycine its effects on increased mucin expression and ER stress.
at amino acid position 231 (Gly231Val, Gly231Arg). The GWAS study confirmed the association of IPF
Cells expressing mutant proteins fail to secrete with variants in the TERT237 and TERC genes, with meta-
mature protein into the culture media.227,229 In addi- analysis p values of 1.7 × 10−19 and 4.5 × 10−8, respec-
tion, expression of these mutant proteins led to fewer tively.232 Overall, common variants in three telomere
intracellular oligomers, greater protein instability, and length–related genes (TERT, TERC, and OBFC1)238–240
increased markers of ER stress.230 Family members were found to be associated with lung fibrosis in this
with these heterozygous mutations secrete comparable study. The GWAS study also found seven new loci that
amounts of total SP-A into the alveolar space, as com- reached genomewide statistical significance.232 These
pared with control family members, suggesting that the loci are located near genes involved with host defense,
pathogenic mechanism may be related to ER stress of cell-cell adhesion, and DNA repair.
the resident epithelial alveolar cells.230
Pulmonary Alveolar Microlithiasis
Susceptibility to Pulmonary Fibrosis, Pulmonary alveolar microlithiasis (PAM) is a rare dis-
Common Variants order characterized by laminated calcium phosphate
Using a genomewide screen, a common variant located concretions within the alveoli. PAM is inherited in an
3 kb upstream of the MUC5B transcription start site autosomal recessive manner and is particularly prevalent
(rs35705950) was found to be present at a higher fre- in Turkey, Italy, the United States, and Japan.241 The chest
quency in IPF patients. This variant is found in ∼9% of radiographs of patients with PAM show diffuse, bilateral,
controls (an overall allele frequency of 0.10) and 38% of micronodular opacities, which obscure the heart border,
patients with IPF. The odds ratio for IPF disease among mediastinum, and diaphragmatic surfaces. Despite the
subjects who are heterozygous or homozygous for the “sandstormlike” appearance, the clinical presentation
minor allele of this single nucleotide polymorphism of PAM is variable.242–245 Early in the disease course,
(SNP) was 9.0 (CI 6.2–13.1) and 21.8 (5.1–93.5), patients are often asymptomatic, but over time develop
respectively.231 The variant allele was associated with cough, dyspnea, and a restrictive defect with reduced
upregulation of MUC5B expression (up to 37.4 times diffusion. In 2006, Corut et al. reported the discovery
as high when compared with those homozygous for the of several mutations in the gene encoding the type IIb
wild-type allele) in lung tissue of unaffected subjects.231 sodium-phosphate cotransporter protein (SCL34A2)
A genomewide association study (GWAS) was per- in individuals with PAM.246 The group used linkage
formed comparing the frequency of common SNPs in analysis of a large consanguineous family in which six
patients with fibrotic idiopathic interstitial pneumonia members were affected by PAM, and ultimately identi-
(n = 1616) with controls (n = 4683). A replication anal- fied six homozygous mutations in SCL34A2 that predict
ysis included 876 cases and 1890 controls. A MUC5B loss of protein function. A separate group in Japan used
promoter variant (rs868903) was again found to be sig- genomewide SNP mapping to identify candidate genes
nificantly associated with fibrotic lung disease, with a in six patients with PAM, and they independently identi-
metaanalysis P value of 9.2 × 10−26.232 A broad region fied SCL34A2 as a gene of interest.247 Two patients had
on 11p15, including the MUC5B, MUC2, and TOLLIP homozygous frameshift mutations and four had splice-
genes, was found to demonstrate genomewide signifi- site mutations of the gene. None of the mutations was
cance. After adjusting for the MUC5B promoter SNP identified in normal controls. Since these initial discov-
found in the earlier study (rs35705950),231 most of the eries, additional missense and frameshift mutations, as
variants in this broad region were no longer significantly well as intragenetic deletions, have been identified.248–250
associated, suggesting that the associations seen for the The gene is expressed in high levels in the lung, pre-
other SNPs may be due to linkage disequilibrium. The dominantly in type II epithelial cells.251–253 Epithelial
MUC5B promoter (rs35705950) has been found in the deletion of the mouse Npt2b gene in the lung leads to
Framingham Heart Study233 to be associated with inter- a progressive pulmonary process characterized by diffuse
stitial lung abnormalities, thus linking it to an early alveolar microliths, restrictive physiology, and alveolar
manifestation of IPF. Mucins undergo a complex matu- phospholipidosis.254 Microliths are readily dissolved by
ration process in airway cells, with glycosylation and whole-lung EDTA lavage. A low-phosphate diet prevents
disulfide multimerization, before secretion. As genetic microlith formation in young mice and decreases the
perturbations leading to increased mucin production burden of pulmonary calcium deposits in older mice.
cause elevated ER stress signaling,234–236 it is interest- The effectiveness of such a diet has not yet been studied
ing to speculate that the MUC5B promoter variant may in human patients.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
some, though not in all, parts of the country. Here and there, as
Jeremy surmised, where small-holders and market-gardeners had
taken a firm grip, the landowning class had little power. But
elsewhere it was strong, and drew great revenues from the soil, from
corn, from tobacco, and from wool.
These revenues were spent by the ruling families—Roger called
them “the big men”—in enlarging the gardens of their houses in
London. They cared little to build. Houses stood in plenty, many even
now unclaimed. But gradually the deserted houses were pulled
down, their materials carted away and their sites elaborately planted.
Jeremy walked in a great shrubbery of rhododendrons where
Charing Cross Station had been and in a rose-garden over the deep-
buried foundations of Scotland Yard. He observed that this fashion,
which was becoming a mania, was creating again the old distinction
between the City of London, which was still a trading center, and the
City of Westminster, which was still the seat of government, although
a revolutionary mob of somewhat doctrinaire inclinations had burnt
down the Houses of Parliament quite early in the Troubles.
These excursions fascinated Jeremy, and he endeavored to make
them useful by cross-examining Roger, as they walked about
together, on the condition of society. But that typical man of far from
self-conscious age had only scanty information to give. Even on the
government of the country he was vague and unsatisfactory, though,
when he had nothing better to do, he worked with the other clerks on
the Speaker’s business. Jeremy sometimes saw him and his
companions at work, copying documents in a laborious round-hand
or making entries in a great leather-bound and padlocked ledger. He
felt often inclined to reintroduce into a profession which had forgotten
it the blessed principle of the card index; but, after consideration, he
abstained from complicating this idyllically simple bureaucracy.
Besides, there was no need for labor-saving devices. Clerks
swarmed in the Treasury. A few years in the Speaker’s service was
the proper occupation for a young man of good family who was
beginning life; and the tasks which it involved weighed on them
lightly.
The business of government was not elaborate or complex.
Apparently the provinces looked very much after themselves under
the direction of a medley of authorities, whose titles and powers
Jeremy could by no means compose into a system. He heard
vaguely of two potentates, prominent among the rest and typical of
them, the Chairman of Bradford, who seemed responsible for a great
part of the north, and the President of Wales, who had a palace at
Cardiff. Jeremy guessed that the titles of these “big men” had
survived from all sorts of “big men” of his own time. The Chairman of
Bradford for example might inherit his power from the chairman of
some vanished revolutionary or reactionary committee, or perhaps
even, since he was concerned in a peculiar way with the great
weaving trade of Yorkshire, from that of an employers’ federation or
a conciliation board. The President of Wales, whose relations with
his tough, savage, uncouth miners were unusual, Jeremy suspected
of being the successor of a trade union leader. The names and
figures of these men lingered obscurely, powerfully, menacingly in
his mind. The Speaker rarely interfered with them so long as they
collected his taxes regularly and with an approach to completeness.
And his taxes were moderate, for the public services were not
exigent.
Jeremy caught a glimpse of one of these public services one day
when Roger was taking him on a longer expedition than usual, to
see the great northwestern quarter of old London. This district was
one of the largest of those which, by some freak of chance, had
escaped fire and bombardment and had been merely deserted, left
to rot and collapse as they stood. Jeremy was anxious to examine
this curiosity, and pressed Roger to take him there. It was when they
were walking between the venerable and dangerously leaning
buildings of Regent Street that they passed a column of brown-clad
men on the march.
“Soldiers!” cried Jeremy, and paused to watch them go by.
“Yes, soldiers,” Roger murmured with a smile of good-natured
contempt, trying to draw him along. But Jeremy’s curiosity had been
aroused. He suddenly remembered, and then closed his lips on an
enigmatical remark which the Speaker had made about guns; and he
insisted on staying where he was until the regiment had gone out of
sight. Their uniforms, an approximation to khaki, yet of a different
shade, their rifles, clumsy and antiquated in appearance, their feet
wrapped in rags and shod with rawhide sandals, combined with their
shambling, half-ashamed, half-sulky carriage to give them the air of
a parody on the infantry of the Great War.
“Whom do they fight?” he asked abstractedly, still standing and
gazing after them.
“No one,” Roger answered, with the same expression of
contemptuous tolerance. “They are good for nothing; there has been
no war in England for a hundred years.”
“But are there no foreign wars?”
“None that concern us.” And Roger went on to explain in an
uninterested and scrappy manner that there was always fighting
somewhere on the Continent, that the Germans and the Russians
and the Polish were forever at one another’s throats, that the Italians
could not live at peace with one another or with their neighbors on
the Adriatic, and that the peoples of Eastern Europe seemed bent on
mutual extermination. “But we never interfere,” he said. “It isn’t our
business, though sometimes the League tries to make out that it is.
And we need no army. It’s a fad of the Speaker’s, though he could
always get Canadians if he wanted them.”
“The League? Canadians?” Jeremy interjected.
“Yes; the Canadian bosses hire out armies when any one wants
them. They do say that that ruffian who is staying with the Speaker
came over for some such reason. But I can’t see why we should
want Canadians.”
“But you said ... something ... the League?”
“Oh, the old League!” Roger answered carelessly. “Surely that
existed in your time, didn’t it? I mean the League of Nations.” And,
as Jeremy said nothing, he continued: “You know, they sit at Geneva
and tell every one how to manage his own affairs. We take no notice
of them, except that we send them a contribution every year. And I
don’t know why we should do even that. The officials are always all
Germans ... so close, you know....”
Jeremy fell into a profound reverie, out of which he presently
emerged to ask, “Does your army have any guns ... cannon, I
mean?”
Roger shook his head. “You mean the sort of big gun that used to
throw exploding shells. No; I don’t believe there’s such a thing left in
the world. I never heard of one.”
In order to draw Jeremy away from his meditations in Regent Street,
Roger had taken him by the elbow, and from that had slipped his arm
into Jeremy’s own. They walked along together in an amicable
silence. Unexpected and violent events had drawn these two young
men into a friendship which otherwise they would never have
chosen, but which was perhaps not more arbitrary and not less real
than the love of the mother for the child. Though their minds were so
dissimilar, yet Jeremy felt a sort of confidence and familiarity in
Roger’s presence; and Roger took a queer pride in Jeremy’s
existence.
The district into which they entered when they got beyond the
wilderness that had been Regent’s Park was a singular and striking
reminder of the time when London was a great and populous city.
Every stage of desolation and decay was to be seen in that appalling
tract, which had lost the trimness and prosperity of its flourishing
period without acquiring the solemn and awful aspect of nobler ruins.
Every scrap of wood and metal had long been torn from these slowly
perishing houses. Some had collapsed into their own cellars and
were gradually being covered over. Some, which had been built of
less enduring bricks, seemed merely to have melted, leaving only
faint irregularities on the surface of the ground. Others stood gaunt
and crazily leaning, with ragged staring gaps where the windows had
been. Even as they passed one of these they heard the resounding
collapse of a wall they could not see, while the outer walls heaved
visibly nearer to ruin.
And here and there enterprising squatters had cleared large spaces,
joining up the old villa-gardens into fair-sized fields. These people
lived in rude huts, made of old timbers and rough heaps of
brickwork, in corners of their clearings. Some distaste or horror
seemed to keep them from the empty houses in the shadow of which
they dwelt. Jeremy saw in the fields bowed laborious figures
wrapped in rags which forbade him to say whether they were men or
women, and troops of dirty, half-naked children. Roger followed the
direction of his glance and said that the squatters among the
deserted houses were people little better than savages, who could
not get work in the agricultural districts or had mutinously deserted
their proper employers.
Jeremy shuddered and went on without replying. The plan of these
old streets was still recognizable enough for him to lead the way, as
if in a dream, through St. John’s Wood to Swiss Cottage. Here they
had to scramble across a tumbled ravine, which was all that was left
of the Metropolitan Railway, and up the steep rise of Fitzjohn’s
Avenue to the little village of Hampstead clinging isolated on the
edge of the hill. As they came into the village, Jeremy drew Roger
into a side-track which he recognized, from one drooping Georgian
house standing lonely there, as what he had known under the name
of Church Row. The church remained, and beyond it Jeremy could
see a farm half-hidden among trees. But he went no further. He
turned his face abruptly southwards and stayed, gazing across
London in that moment of perfect clearness which sometimes
precedes the twilight of early summer.
For a moment, what he saw seemed to be what he had always
known. At this distance the slope below seemed still to be covered
with houses, and showed none of the hideousness of their decay.
Farther out, in the valley, rose the spires and towers of innumerable
churches, and beyond them came the faint blue line of the Surrey
hills. But as he gazed he realized suddenly the greater purity of the
air, the greater beauty of the view. London blackened no longer all
the heaven above it, and the green gaps in the waste of buildings
were larger and greener. Almost he thought he saw a silver line
where the Thames should have been; but perhaps he imagined this,
though he knew that the river was no longer dark and foul.
In his joy and contentment at the lovely scene he began to speak to
Roger in a rapt, dreamy voice, as though he were indeed the
mouthpiece and messenger of a less fortunate time. “You are
happier than we were,” he said, “though you are poorer. Your air is
clean, you have room, you live at peace, you have time to live. But
we were forced to live in thick, smoky air; we fought and quarreled,
and disputed. The more difficult our lives became, the less time we
had for them. This age seems to me,” he continued, warming to his
subject and ignoring Roger’s placid silence, “like a man who has
been walking at full speed on a long dusty road, only trying to see
how many miles he can cover in a day. Suddenly he grows
exhausted and stops. I have done it. I can remember how delicious it
was to lie down in a field off the road, to let the business all go, not to
care where one got to or when. It was this peacefulness we should
have been aiming at all the time, only we never knew....” Roger’s
silence at last stopped him, and he turned to see what his
companion was thinking. The expression of trouble on Roger’s face
brought up a question on his own.
“It has just occurred to me,” Roger said slowly and reluctantly, “that it
will be quite dark before we can get through all those houses....” He
paused and shivered slightly. “I don’t quite like....”
They set off homewards, and darkness overtook them in the middle
of Finchley Road. Roger did not speak again of his fears. Jeremy
could not determine whether they were of violent men or of dead
men. But he felt their presence. Roger hardly spoke or listened until
they were once again in inhabited streets.
It was on the following morning that the Speaker again sent for
Jeremy.

2
Jeremy answered the second summons with a little excitement but
with a heart more at rest than on the first occasion. He found the
Speaker leaning at his open window, his head thrust out, his foot
tapping restlessly on the ground. It was some moments before the
abstracted old man would take any notice of his visitor. When he did
so, he turned round with an air of restless and forced geniality.
“Well, Jeremy Tuft,” he cried, rubbing his hands together, “and have
you learnt much from your friend?”
Jeremy replied stolidly that Roger had answered one way or another
all the questions he had had time to ask. Some instinct kept him to
his not very candid stubbornness. He was not going to be bullied into
deserting Roger, of whose intellectual gifts he had nevertheless no
very high opinion.
But the Speaker nodded without apparent displeasure. “And now you
know all about our affairs?” he enquired.
Jeremy, still stolidly, shook his head but made no other answer. The
Speaker suddenly changed his manner and, coming close to
Jeremy, took him caressingly by the arm. “I know you don’t,” he
murmured in a voice full of cajolery. “But tell me—you must have
seen enough of our people—what do you think of them? What do
you think can be done with them?” He leant slightly back and
regarded the silent young man with an expression of infinite cunning.
Then, as he got no response, he went on: “Tell me, what would you
do if you were in my place—you, a man rich with all the knowledge
of a wiser time than this? How would you begin to make things
better?”
“I don’t know.... I don’t know....” Jeremy cried at last, almost
pathetically. “I can’t make these people out at all.” And, with that, he
felt restored in his mind the former consciousness of an intellectual
kinship between him and the old Jew.
But the Speaker continued with his irritating air of a ripe man teasing
a green boy. “You remember the time when the whole world was full
of the marvels of science. We suffered misfortune, and all the wise
men, all the scientists, perished. But by a miracle you have survived.
Can you not restore for us all the civilization of your own age?”
Jeremy frowned and answered hesitatingly. “How can I? What could
I do by myself? And anyway, I was only a physicist. I know
something about wireless telegraphy.... But then I could do nothing
without materials, and at best precious little single-handed.” He
meditated explaining just how much one man could know of the
working of twentieth-century machinery, opened his mouth again and
then closed it. He strongly suspected that the Speaker was merely
fencing with him. He felt vaguely irritated and alone.
The old man dropped Jeremy’s arm, spun his great bulk round on his
heel with surprising lightness and paced away to the other end of the
room. There he stood apparently gazing with intent eyes into a little
mirror which hung on the wall. Jeremy stayed where he had been
left, forlorn, perplexed, hopeless, staring with no expectation of an
answer at those huge, bowed, enigmatic shoulders. He was almost
at the point of screaming aloud when the Speaker turned and said
seriously with great deliberation:
“Well, I am going to show you something that you have not seen,
something that not more than twenty persons know of besides
myself. And you are going to see it because I trust you to be loyal to
me, to be my man. Do you understand?” He did not wait for Jeremy’s
doubtful nod, but abruptly jerked the bell-pull on the wall. When this
was done they waited together in silence. A servant answered the
summons; and the Speaker said: “My carriage.” The carriage was
announced. The silence continued unbroken while they settled
themselves in it, in the little enclosed courtyard that had once been
Downing Street. It was not until they were jolting over the ruts of
Whitehall that Jeremy said, almost timidly:
“Where are we going?”
“To Waterloo,” the Speaker answered, so brusquely that Jeremy was
deterred from asking more, and leant back by his companion to
muster what patience he could.
He had already been to Waterloo under Roger’s guidance. It was the
station for the few lines of railway that still served the south of
England; and they had gone there to see the train come in from
Dover. But it had been so late that Roger had refused to wait any
longer for it, though Jeremy had been anxious to do so. They had
seen nothing but an empty station, dusty and silent. At one platform
an engine had stood useless so long that its wheels seemed to have
been rusted fast to the metals. Close by a careless or unfortunate
driver had charged the buffers at full speed and crashed into the
masonry beyond. The bricks were torn up and piled in heaps; but the
raw edges were long weathered, and some of them were beginning
to be covered with moss. The old glass roof, which he remembered,
was gone and the whole station lay open to the sky. Pools from a
recent shower glistened underfoot. Here and there a workman sat
idle and yawning on a bench or lay fast asleep on a pile of sacks.
This picture returned vividly to Jeremy as he rode by the Speaker’s
side. It seemed to him the fit symbol of an age which had loosened
its grip on civilization, which cared no longer to mend what time or
chance had broken, which did not care even to put a new roof over
Waterloo Station. He reflected again, as he thought of it, that
perhaps it did not much matter, that the grip on civilization had been
painfully hard to maintain, that there was something to be said for
sleeping on a pile of sacks in a sound part of the station instead of
repairing some other part of it. “We wretched ants,” he told himself,
“piled up more stuff than we could use, and though the mad people
of the Troubles wasted it, yet the ruins are enough for this race to
live in for centuries. And aren’t they more sensible than we were?
Why shouldn’t humanity retire from business on its savings? If only it
had done it before it got that nervous breakdown from overwork!”
He was aroused by the carriage lurching into the uneven slope of the
approach. The squalor that had once surrounded the great terminus
had withered, like the buildings of the station itself, into a sort of
mitigated and quiescent ugliness. As, at the Speaker’s gesture, he
descended from the carriage, he saw a young tree pushing itself with
serene and graceful indifference through the tumbled ruins of what
had once been an unlovely lodging-house. A hot sun beat down on
and was gradually dispelling a thin morning haze. It gilded palely the
gaunt, harsh lines of the station that generations of weathering could
never make beautiful.
The Speaker, still resolutely silent, led the way inside, where their
steps echoed hollowly in the empty hall. But the echoes were
suddenly disturbed by another sound; and, as they turned a corner
Jeremy was enchanted to see a long train crawling slowly into the
platform. It slackened speed, blew off steam with appalling
abruptness and force, and came to a standstill before it had
completely pulled in. Jeremy could see two little figures leaping from
the cab of the engine and running about aimlessly on the platform,
half-hidden by the still belching clouds of steam.
“Another breakdown!” the Speaker grunted with sudden ferocity; and
he turned his face slightly to one side as though it pained him to see
the crippled engine. Jeremy would have liked to go closer, but dared
not suggest it. Instead he dragged, like a loitering child, a yard or two
behind his formidable companion and gazed eagerly at the distant
wreaths of steam. But he only caught a glimpse of a few passengers
sitting patiently on heaps of luggage or on the ground, as though
they were well used to such delays in embarkation. He ran after his
guide, who had now passed the disused locomotive rusted to the
rails, and was striding along the platform and down the slope at the
end, into a wilderness of crossing metals. Here and there in this
desert could be seen a track bright with recent use; but it was long
since many of them had known the passage of a train. In some
cases only streaks of red in the earth or sleepers almost rotted to
nothing showed where the line had been. They passed a signal-box:
a man sat placidly smoking at the top of the steps outside the open
door. They went on further into the desolation that surrounds a great
station, here made more horrible by the absence of movement, by
the pervading air of ruin and decay.
When they had walked a few hundred yards from the end of the
platform, they came to a group of buildings, which, in spite of their
dilapidation, had about them a certain appearance of still being used.
“The repairing sheds,” said the Speaker, pointing through an open
door to a group of men languidly active round what looked like a
small shunting-engine. Then he entered a narrow passage between
two buildings.
As they went down this defile, a noise of hammering and another
noise like that of a furnace grew louder and louder; and at the end of
the passage there was a closed door. The Speaker paused and
looked at Jeremy with a doubtful expression, as though for the last
time weighing his loyalty. Then he seized a hanging chain and pulled
it vigorously. A bell clanged, harsh and melancholy, inside the
building. Before the last grudging echoes had died away, there was a
rattling of bolts and bars, and the door was opened to the extent of
about a foot. An old man in baggy, blue overalls, with dirty, white hair,
and a short, white beard, stood in the opening, blinking suspiciously
at the intruders.
He stood thus a minute in a hostile attitude, ready to leap back and
slam the door to again. But all at once his expression changed, he
shouted something over his shoulder and became exceedingly
respectful. As Jeremy followed the Speaker past him into the black
interior of the shed he bowed and muttered a thick incoherent
welcome in a tongue which was hardly recognizable as English, so
strange were its broad and drawling sounds.
Inside, huge shapes of machinery were confused with thick
shadows, which jerked spasmodically at the light from an open
furnace. It was some moments before Jeremy got the proper use of
his eyes in the murky air of the shed. When he did he received an
extraordinary impression. A group of old men, all in the same baggy
blue overalls as the first who opened the door, had turned to greet
them and were bowing and shuffling in an irregular and comical
rhythm. Round the walls the obscure pieces of mechanism resolved
themselves into all the appurtenances of a foundry, hammers, lathes
and machines for making castings, in every stage of neglect and
disrepair, some covered with dust, some immovably rusted, some
tilted drunkenly on their foundation plates, some still apparently
capable of use. And behind the gang of old men, raised on trestles in
the middle of the floor, were two long and sinister tubes of iron.
The Speaker stood on one side, fixing on Jeremy a look of keen and
exultant enquiry. Jeremy advanced towards the two tubes, a word
rising to his tongue. He had not taken two steps before he was
certain.
“Guns!” he whispered in a tense and startled voice.
“Guns!” replied the Speaker, not repressing an accent of triumph.
Jeremy went on and the old men shuffled on one side to make way
for him, clucking with mingled agitation and pride. He examined the
guns with the eye of an expert, ran his fingers over them, peered
down the barrels, and rose with a nod of satisfaction. They seemed
to be wire-wound, rifled, breech-loading guns, of which only the
breech mechanism was missing. They resembled very closely the
sixty-pounders of his own experience, though they were somewhat
smaller. When the breech mechanism was supplied, they would be
efficient and deadly weapons of a kind that he well knew how to
handle.
CHAPTER VII
THE LADY EVA

1
THE Speaker’s reception was a gorgeous and tedious assembly,
held in the afternoon for the better convenience of a society which
had but indifferent resources in the way of artificial light. A great hall
in the Treasury had been prepared for it; and here the “big men,” and
their wives and sons and daughters, showed themselves, paid their
respects to the Speaker and to the Lady Burney, paraded a little,
gathered into groups for conversation, at last took their leave.
Jeremy walked through the crowd at the Speaker’s elbow and was
presented by him to the most important of the guests. This was a
mark of favor, of recognition, almost of adoption. He had at first been
afraid of it and had wished to avoid it. But the Speaker’s
determination was unalterable.
“If it were nothing more,” he said, with a contemptuous smile on his
heavy but mobile mouth, “I shall be giving them pleasure by
exhibiting you. You are a show, a curiosity to them. They are all
longing to see you—once.... Only you and I know that you are
something more. And to know it pleases me; I hope it pleases you.”
This explanation hardly reconciled Jeremy to the ordeal; but the
Speaker had easily overborne his reluctance. They walked through
the room together, a couple strangely unlike; and the old man
showed towards the younger all the tenderness, all the proud
complaisances of a father to a son.
From this post of vantage Jeremy could at least see all that was to
be seen. The assembly seemed to be gay and animated. The men
wore the dress of ceremony, the latter-day version of evening dress;
and some of them, especially the more youthful, were daring in the
colors of their coats and in the bravado of lace at throat and breast
and wrist. The women wore more elaborate forms of the gown of
every day, simply cut in straight lines, descending to the heel and
tortuously ornamented with embroideries in violent colors. Jeremy
saw one stout matron who was covered from neck to shoes in a
pattern of blowsy roses and fat yellow butterflies, like a wall-paper of
the nineteenth century, another whose embroidery took the shape of
zigzag stripes of crimson, blue and green, adjoining on the bodice,
separated on the skirt.
But he was impressed by a certain effect of good breeding which
their behavior produced and which contradicted his first opinion,
based on the strangeness of their dress. They nodded to him (for the
shaking of hands had gone quite out of fashion), stared at him a
little, asked a colorless question or two, murmured politely on his
reply, and drifted away from him. Where he expected crudity and
vulgarity, he found a prevailing vagueness, tepidity, indifference,
almost fatigue.... He was forced to conclude that the flamboyancy of
their appearance was mild to themselves, that they had no wish to
appear startling, and did so only as the result of a universal lack of
taste.
He moved among them, steadfastly following the Speaker, but
feeling tired and stiff and inert. His limbs ached with unaccustomed
labor, his left hand was torn and bandaged, and he had still in his
nostrils the thick, greasy smell of the workshops in which he had
spent the morning. Here, after his first shock of surprise at the sight
of the guns, he had soon understood that he was expected to do
much more than admire and approve. These, the Speaker said, were
by no means his first experiments in the art of gun-casting. And, after
that, the old man had recounted to Jeremy, assisted by occasional
uncouth ejaculations from the aged foreman of that amazing gang of
centenarians, a story that had been nothing less than stupefying.
The last men in whose fading minds some glimmer of the art still
remained had been gathered together, at the cost of infinite trouble,
from the districts where machinery was still most in use, chiefly from
Scotland, Yorkshire, and Wales. They had been brought thither on
the pretense that their experience was needed in the central
repairing-shops of the railways; and apparently it had been
necessary in all possible ways to deceive and to reassure the
principal men of their native districts. Once they had been obtained,
they had slaved for years with senile docility to satisfy the demands
which the Speaker’s senile and half-lunatic enthusiasm made on
their disappearing knowledge. Somehow he had created in them a
queer pride, a queer spirit of endeavor. That grotesque chorus of
ancients had become inspired with a single anxiety, to create before
they perished a gun which could be fired without instantly destroying
those who fired it.
They had had trouble with the breech mechanism, the Speaker
nonchalantly remarked; and Jeremy had a vision of men blown to
pieces in the remote and lonely valley where the first guns were
tried. The immediate purpose for which Jeremy’s help was required
was the adjustment of the process of cutting the interrupted screw-
thread by which the breech-block was locked into the gun. He had
toiled at it all the morning, surrounded by jumping and antic old men,
whose speech he could hardly understand and to whom he could
only with the greatest exertion communicate his own opinions. He
had wrestled with, and tugged at, antiquated and dilapidated
machinery, had cursed and sworn, had given himself a great cut on
the palm of his left hand and had descended almost to the level of
his ridiculous fellow-workers. And yet, when he had finished, the
difficult screw-thread was in a fair way to be properly cut.
He came hot from these nightmare experiences to the Speaker’s
reception; and when he looked round and contrasted the one scene
with the other, he had a sense of phantasmagoria that made him feel
dizzy. It was almost too much for his reason ... on top of a transition
that would have overbalanced most normal men.... He was recalled
from his bewildering reflections by the Speaker’s voice, low and
grumbling in his ear.
They had drifted for a moment away from the thickest of the crowd
into a corner of the room, and the old man was able to speak without
fear of being overheard. “It is as I have noticed for years,” he said,
“but it gets worse and worse. These are only from the south.”
Jeremy started and replied a little at random: “Only from the
south...?”
“Listen carefully to all I say to you. It is all useful. These people here
are only from the south, from Essex, like that young Roger Vaile, and
Kent and Surrey and Sussex and Hampshire. The big men from the
north and west come every year less often to the Treasury. And yet
these fools hardly notice it, and would see nothing remarkable in it if
they did.”
“You mean ...” Jeremy began. But before he could get farther he saw
the Speaker turn aside with a smile of obvious falsity and
exaggerated sweetness. The sinister little person, whom Jeremy
knew from a distance as “the Canadian,” was approaching them with
a characteristically arrogant step and bearing.
The Speaker made them known to one another in a manner that
barely concealed a certain uneasiness and unrest. “Thomas Wells,”
he explained in a loud and formal voice, “is the son of one of the
chief of the Canadian Bosses, whom we reckon among our subjects
and who by courtesy allow themselves to be described as such. But I
reckon it as an honor to have Thomas Wells, the son of George
Wells, for my guest in the Treasury.”
“That’s so,” said the Canadian gravely, without making it quite clear
which part of the Speaker’s remark he thus corroborated. Then he
stared keenly at Jeremy, apparently controlling a strong instinct of
discomfort and dislike by an effort of will. Jeremy returned the stare
inimically.
“I believe we have met before,” he suggested, not without a little
malice.
“That’s so,” the Canadian agreed; and as he spoke he sketched the
sign of the cross in an unobtrusive manner that made it appear as
though it might have been a chance movement of his hand. The
Speaker hung over them with evident anxiety, and at last said:
“You two are both strangers to this country. You ought to be able to
compare your impressions.”
“I would much rather hear something about Canada,” Jeremy
answered.
Thomas Wells shrugged his shoulders. “It isn’t like this country,” he
said carelessly. “We can’t be as easy-going as the people are here.
We have to fight—but we do fight and win,” he concluded,
momentarily baring his teeth in a savage grin.
“The Canadians, as every one knows, are the best soldiers in the
world,” the Speaker interpolated. “They are always fighting.”
“And whom do you fight?” Jeremy asked.
“Oh, anybody.... You see, the people to the south of us are always
quarreling among themselves, and we chip in. And then sometimes
we send armies down to Mexico or the Isthmus.”
“But the people to the south ...” Jeremy began. “Haven’t you still got
the United States to the south of you? And I should have thought
they’d be too many for you?”
“There are no United States now—I’ve heard of them.” Thomas
Wells’s dislike of Jeremy seemed to have been overcome by a
swelling impulse of boastfulness. “From what I can make out, they
never did get their people in hand as we did. They’ve always been
disturbed. Their leaders don’t last long, and they fight one another.
And we’re always growing in numbers and getting harder, while they
get fewer and softer. Why, they’re easy fruit!”
Jeremy could find nothing for this but polite and impressed assent.
Thomas Wells allowed his lean face to be split by a startling grin and
went on: “I suppose you’ve never heard of me? No! Well, I’m not like
these people here. I was brought up to fight. My dad fought his way
to the top. His dad was a small man, out Edmonton way, with not
more than two or three thousand bayonets. But he kept at it, and
now none of the Bosses in Canada are bigger than we are. It was
me that led the raid on Boston when I was only twenty.”
Jeremy turned aside from the last announcement with a feeling of
disgust. He thought that Thomas Wells looked like some small
blood-thirsty animal, a ferret or a stoat, with pale burning eyes and
thin stretched mouth that sought the throat of a living creature. He
was saved from the necessity for an answer by the Canadian turning
sharply on his heel, as though something had touched a spring in his
body. Jeremy followed the movement with his eyes and saw the
Lady Eva making her way towards them through the crowd.
Thomas Wells went to meet her with an air of exaggerated gallantry,
and murmured something with his bow. She seemed to be to-day in
a mood of modest behavior, for she received his salutation with
downcast eyes and no more than a movement of the lips. As he
watched them Jeremy again became aware of the Speaker standing
beside him, whom he had for a moment forgotten. He stole a look at
the old man and saw that his brow was troubled and that, though his
hands were clasped behind his back in an apparently careless
attitude, the fingers were clenched and the knuckles white. As he
registered these impressions, the Lady Eva, still with downward
glance, sailed past Thomas Wells and approached him. When he
saw her intention, a faint disturbance sprang up in his heart and
interfered with his breathing.
She had already halted beside him when he realized that now, in the
presence of this company, her deportment being what it was, he
must make the first speech. He stuttered awkwardly and said: “I
have been hoping to see you again.”
She raised her eyes a trifle, and he fancied that he saw the shadow
of a smile in the corners of her mouth. Her reply was pitched in so
low a tone as to be at first incomprehensible, and there followed a
moment of emptiness before he realized that she had said, “You
have been with Roger Vaile.”
He interpreted it as in some sort of a reproach, and was about to
protest when he saw the Speaker frowning at him. He did not
understand the frown, but he moderated his vehemence. “I have
been learning,” he said in level tones. “I have been learning a great
deal.” And then he added more quietly, “Not but what you could
teach me much more.”
At this she raised her head and laughed frankly; and he, looking up
too, saw that the Speaker had drawn Thomas Wells away and that
the backs of both were disappearing in the throng. A strange,
uncomfortable sense of an intrigue, which he could not understand,
oppressed him. He glared suspiciously at the girl, but read nothing
more than mischief and merriment in her face.
“I was well scolded the last time I spoke to you,” she said, “but I have
behaved well this time, haven’t I?”
Exhilaration chased all his doubts away. He gazed at her openly,
took in the wide eyes, the straight nose, the sensitive mouth, the
healthy skin. Then he tried to pull himself together, to recover a dry,
sane consciousness of his situation. It was absurd, he told himself—
at his age!—to be unsettled by a conversation with a beautiful girl
who might have been, if he had had any, one of his remote
descendants. He felt unaccountably like a man glissading on the
smooth, steep slope of a hill. Of course, he would in a moment be
able to catch hold of a tuft of grass, to steady himself by digging his
heels into the ground.... But meanwhile the Lady Eva was looking at
him.
“What do you think I could teach you?” she asked.
“I know so little,” he answered haphazard. “I know nothing about any
of the people here. I suppose you know them all?”
“They are the big men and their wives. What can I tell you about
them?”
“What do you think of them yourself?”
She eyed him a little askance, doubtful but almost laughing. “What
would you think ... what would they think—if I were to tell you that?”
“But they will never know,” he urged, in a tone of ridiculously serious
entreaty.
“Don’t you know that I am already considered a little ... strange? I
don’t think I could tell you anything about our society that would be
any use to you. My mother tells me every day that I don’t know how
to behave myself; and I daresay all these people would say the
same.”
“But why?”
“Oh, I don’t know....” She half swung round, tapped the floor with her
heel and returned to him, grown almost grave. “I hate the ... the ...
the easiness of everybody. They all stroll through life, and the
women do nothing and behave modestly—they’re not alive. I
suppose I am like my father. He is odd too.”
“But I am like him,” Jeremy said earnestly. “If you are like him, then I
must be like you. But I don’t know enough to be sure how different
every one else is. They seem very amiable, very gentle....”
“I hate their gentleness,” she began in a louder tone. But instead of
going on, she dropped her eyes to the ground and stood silent.
Jeremy, perplexed for a minute, suddenly became aware of the Lady
Burney beside them, an expression of dull disapproval on her
brilliantly carmined face. He had the presence of mind to bow to her
very respectfully.
“I am glad to see you again, Jeremy Tuft,” she said with a heavy and
undeceiving graciousness. As she spoke she edged herself between
him and the Lady Eva; and Jeremy could quite plainly see her
motioning her daughter away with a gesture that she only affected to
conceal. He strove to keep an expression of annoyance from his
face and answered as enthusiastically as he could. She spoke a few
more listless sentences with an air of fighting a rearguard action.
When she left him he sought through the room for the Lady Eva,
disregarding all who tried to accost him; but he could not come at her
again.

2
Roger Vaile was divided between disappointment and pride at
Jeremy’s favor with the Speaker, and expressed both feelings with
the same equability of demeanor.
“I hope I shall see you again some time,” he said; “but the Speaker
has always disliked me.”
Jeremy experienced an acute discomfort and sought to relieve
himself by replying with warmth, “But you saved my life. I told him

You might also like