Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Culture’s Engine: Inside Science and Technology 1st Edition William Gosling full chapter instant download
Culture’s Engine: Inside Science and Technology 1st Edition William Gosling full chapter instant download
https://ebookmass.com/product/cosmetic-science-and-technology-
theoretical-principles-and-applications-1st-edition-edition-
kazutami-sakamoto/
https://ebookmass.com/product/structure-in-the-sea-the-science-
technology-and-effects-of-purpose-built-reefs-and-related-
surfaces-william-seaman/
https://ebookmass.com/product/science-culture-language-and-
education-in-america-1st-ed-edition-emily-schoerning/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-evolution-of-music-through-
culture-and-science-peter-townsend/
Circus, Science and Technology: Dramatising Innovation
1st ed. Edition Anna-Sophie Jürgens
https://ebookmass.com/product/circus-science-and-technology-
dramatising-innovation-1st-ed-edition-anna-sophie-jurgens/
https://ebookmass.com/product/organic-coatings-science-and-
technology-4th-edition-ebook-pdf/
https://ebookmass.com/product/media-now-understanding-media-
culture-and-technology-10th-edition-joseph-straubhaar/
https://ebookmass.com/product/media-now-understanding-media-
culture-and-technology-10th-edition-joseph-straubhaar-2/
https://ebookmass.com/product/human-anatomy-color-atlas-and-
textbook-6th-edition-john-a-gosling/
Culture’s Engine
Inside Science and Technology
William Gosling
Culture’s Engine
William Gosling
Culture’s Engine
Inside Science and Technology
William Gosling
University of Bath
Bath, UK
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Singapore
Pte Ltd. 2020
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the Publisher, whether
the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of
illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and
transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar
or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication
does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant
protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book
are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or
the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any
errors or omissions that may have been made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional
claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore
Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
to
Naomi Climer
President 2015–2016
of the
Institution of Engineering and Technology
Her distinguished role is shared
with many great names from the past
but to be the first woman elected
in its one and a half centuries
is to make history
Acknowledgements
1 Introduction 1
5 Subtle Subversives 45
7 Drivers of Technology 61
10 Patterns of Innovation 95
ix
x Contents
12 Deep Design123
13 A Hazardous Business143
15 Failure Foreseen169
Index259
1
Introduction
It would be absurd to claim that science and technology are not closely
related. Many find it hard to say where one begins and the other ends.
Any activity pursued in laboratories by people with advanced technical
qualifications, using complex measuring instruments, and described in
an arcane language with a lot of mathematics, that is surely science? Not
necessarily, it may be technology. Science and technology may seem to
outsiders like identical twins, yet they are deeply different. This unfamil-
iar idea is difficult even for some scientists and technologists to grasp, yet
poles apart they are. Some people move between the two without diffi-
culty, but they cannot be both at the same time and mostly settle for one
or the other as their temperament inclines them.
Michael Faraday (1791–1867) is a good example.1 Of exceptionally
high intelligence and creativity, he is sometimes called the father of
English electrical engineering. In hope of improving their own standing,
the English electrical utilities, feeling like poor relations compared with
Gas and Water, gave him that title in the thirties of the last century. But
Faraday never was an engineer; he was one of the most distinguished
scientists of his age, and the informal scientific consultant to the British
government. His interests went far beyond electrical topics and he made
contributions to knowledge in many fields. When he built apparatus, like
were fit to be trusted. Success came faster and more reliably. Yet the basic
method is a far older way of solving practical problems than science itself,
and indeed is still in everyday and universal use.
Science would like to fathom all the workings of nature and the uni-
verse which are accessible to human understanding, everyone. What is
more, the explanations must be in a convincing, reliable and verifiable
form. The range it addresses is almost unlimited, through physics, chem-
istry, biology and medicine, on to the human sciences. Nothing is beyond
its curious eye, though some might be beyond its comprehension—that
is debated. At depth science seeks to know about things, but does not, as
its primary concern, seek to create anything material, nothing beyond a
trustworthy new and original insight. At times scientists do need to build
radically new equipment, but they do so in order to answer scientific
questions. Once these answers are known what they have built has inter-
est only to historians or technologists.
New equipment or instruments scientists produce in the course of
their investigation may later prove useful to others and be widely repro-
duced, like Galileo’s telescope. It was not the first of its kind: several were
seen in the previous year in Italy. Galileo was in Venice in 1609, where he
picked up the idea. However, his creation of an improved product was
not science, but technology. Indeed, in the mid-eighteenth century two
technologists—the inventor Chester Moore Hall (1703–1771) and the
optical technician John Dollond (1706–1761)—improved Galileo’s tele-
scope, rendering his older version obsolete.
So technologists and scientists do similar things at times, and are of
great assistance to each other, but what they aim at is different. The objec-
tive of scientific research is ideas: new insights into the nature of the
universe. The outcome of technology is new products, processes or ser-
vices, intended, one hopes, to improve the human condition by material
means. Science wants to know; technology wants to create. Science works
towards the great ‘aha’ moment and a published paper, technologists
want to fire it up and see if it flies. When it does they feel a deep craftsman-
like satisfaction.
Their different objectives give the communities of scientists and tech-
nologists different attitudes to innovation. In science, the priority of the
new idea is greatly honoured, and rightly so, because that is precisely
8 W. Gosling
log-burner out, then again with it lit. In the second place I tried was a
success, so I fixed it there permanently. Using the doxastic method the
time taken was a couple of hours—the scientific style could have
taken days.
Doxastic Delivers
Many technology advances of the past were wholly doxastic, without any
benefit of scientific understanding. That was how technology first got
started, and a little continues like that to this day, yet it should do so only
when relevant scientific insights are just not available. In that case a
hunch, a guess, an intuition, a tradition perhaps, but frankly little more,
2 The Odd Couple 11
Using every last insight science offers before taking a step beyond it
into the unknown, as we do now, greatly reduces the empirical failure
rate. And there are heartening times when science comes up with some-
thing new and helpful at the last moment, like the US Cavalry in old
cowboy movies, appearing over the hill, flags flying and bugles sounding.
A great experience, but even so, doxastic methods will never be redundant.
The ultimate challenge to all designs is from the social environment.
Will society allow what is proposed to go forward, or would its impact
prove intolerable? The early telegraph, using inconspicuous wires along
railway tracks, did not threaten the quality of life in the mid-nineteenth
century, and evoked negligible social objection. One of its competitors
proved less benign.
In 1837, effective signalling between London’s Euston station and a
stationary winding engine was vital to operating the London and
Birmingham Railway. Sited at Camden Town, nearly 3 km to the North,
the winding engine cable-hauled trains up the difficult initial gradient,
but needed a signal when to pull. William Cooke offered his telegraph for
the task. The London and Birmingham’s directors opted for something
less exotic and much cheaper: a pneumatic whistle at Euston powerful
enough to be heard all the way to Camden Town. Soon life in the 3 km
radius around Euston became unbearable from the frequent piercing
whistle blasts. Protest was vociferous, and before long the silent telegraph
took over.
This simple and beautiful psalm does not exist in Hebrew, but is
found, in Greek, in some psalters of the Septuagint version, headed
“A Psalm of David when he had slain Goliath.” S. Athanasius
mentions it with praise, in his address to Marcellinus on the
Interpretation of the Psalms, and in the Synopsis of Holy Scripture. It
was versified in Greek in A.D. 360, by Apollinarius Alexandrinus.[656]
The subjoined shield of David is given in a Hebrew book on the
properties and medicaments of things. It is said to be a certain
protection against fire. A cake of bread must be made, and on it
must be impressed the seal or shield of David, having in the corner
the word ט״ירand in the middle ( אנ״לאThou art mighty to everlasting,
O Jehovah); and it must be cast aside into the fire with the words of
Psalm cvi. 30, “Then stood up Phinees and prayed; and so the
plague ceased;” and also Exod. xii. 27, “It is the sacrifice of the
Lord’s pass-over, who passed over the houses of the children of
Israel in Egypt, when He smote the Egyptians, and delivered our
homes.”[657]
XXXVIII.
SOLOMON.[658]
1. HOW SOLOMON OBTAINED POWER.
After Solomon had executed the last offices for his father, he rested
in a dale betwixt Hebron and Jerusalem, and fell asleep. As he
returned to himself, there stood before him eight angels, each with
countless wings, diverse in kinds and colours; and the angels bowed
themselves before him three times.
“Who are ye?” asked Solomon, with eyes still closed.
“We are the angels ruling over the eight winds of heaven,” was their
reply. “God hath sent us to give thee dominion over ourselves and
over the winds subject to us. They will storm and bluster, or breathe
softly, at thy pleasure. At thy command they will swoop down on
earth, and bear thee over the highest mountains.”
The greatest of the angels gave him a jewel inscribed with “God is
Power and Greatness,” and said, “When thou hast a command for
us, then raise this stone towards heaven, and we shall appear before
thee as thy servants.”
When these angels had taken their departure, there appeared four
more, of whom each was unlike the other. One was in fashion as a
great whale, another as an eagle, the third as a lion, and the fourth
as a serpent. And they said, “We are they who rule over all the
creatures that move in the earth, and air, and water; and God hath
sent us to give thee dominion over all creatures, that they may serve
thee and thy friends with all good, and fight against thine enemies
with all their force.”
The angel who ruled over the winged fowls extended to Solomon a
precious stone, with the inscription, “Let all creatures praise the
Lord!” and said, “By virtue of this stone, raised above thy head, canst
thou call us to thy assistance, and to fulfil thy desire.”
Solomon immediately ordered the angels to bring before him a pair
of every living creature that moves in the water, flies in the air, and
walks or glides or creeps on the earth.
The angels vanished, and in an instant they were before Solomon
once more, and there were assembled in his sight pairs of every
creature, from the elephant to the smallest fly.
Solomon conversed with the angels, and was instructed by them in
the habits, virtues, and names of all living creatures; he listened to
the complaints of the beasts, birds, and fishes, and by his wisdom he
rectified many evil customs amongst them.
He entertained himself longest with the birds, both on account of
their beautiful speech, which he understood, and also because of the
wise sentences which they uttered.
This is the signification of the cry of the peacock: “With what
measure thou judgest others, thou shalt thyself be judged.”
This is the song of the nightingale: “Contentment is the greatest
happiness.”
The turtle dove calls, “Better were it for some created things that
they had never been created.”
The peewit pipes, “He that hath no mercy, will not find mercy
himself.”
The bird syrdar cries, “Turn to the Lord, ye sinners!”
The swallow screams, “Do good, and ye shall receive a reward.”
This is the pelican’s note: “Praise the Lord in heaven and earth.”
The dove chants, “The fashion of this world passeth away, but God
remaineth eternal.”
The kata says, “Silence is the best safeguard.”
The cry of the eagle is, “However long life may be, yet its inevitable
term is death.”
The croak of the raven is, “The further from man, the happier I.”
The cock crows before the dawn and in the day, “Remember thy
Creator, O thoughtless man!”
Solomon chose the cock and the peewit to be his constant
companions—the first because of its cry, and the second because it
can see through the earth as through glass, and could therefore tell
him where fountains of water were to be found.
After he had stroked the dove, he bade her dwell with her young in
the temple he was about to build to the honour of the Most High.
This pair of doves, in a few years, multiplied to such an extent, that
all who sought the temple moved through the quarter of the town it
occupied under the shadow of the wings of doves.
When Solomon was again alone, an angel appeared to him, whose
upper half was like to earth, and whose lower half was like to water.
He bowed himself before the king and said, “I am created by God to
do His will on the dry land and in the watery sea. Now, God has sent
me to serve thee, and thou canst rule over earth and water. At thy
command the highest mountains will be made plain, and the level
land will rise into steep heights. Rivers and seas will dry up, and the
desert will stream with water at thy command.” Then he gave to him
a precious stone, with the legend engraved thereon, “Heaven and
earth serve God.”
Finally, an angel presented to him another stone, whereon was cut,
“There is no God save God, and Mohammed is the messenger of
God.”
“By means of this stone,” said the angel, “thou shalt have dominion
over the whole world of spirits, which is far greater than that of men
and beasts, and occupies the space between earth and heaven. One
portion of the spirits is faithful, and praises the One only God; the
other portion is unfaithful: some adore fire, others the sun, others
worship the planets, many revere winter. The good spirits surround
the true believers among men, and protect them from all evil; the evil
spirits seek to injure them and deceive them.”
Solomon asked to see the Jinns in their natural and original shape.
The angel shot like a column of flame into heaven, and shortly
returned with the Satans and Jinns in great hosts: and Solomon,
though he had power over them, shuddered with disgust at their
loathsome appearance. He saw men’s heads attached to the necks
of horses, whose feet were those of an ass; the wings of an eagle
attached to the hump of a dromedary; the horns of a gazelle on the
head of a peacock.[659]
2. HOW SOLOMON FEASTED ALL FLESH.
When Solomon returned home, he placed the four stones, which the
angels had given him, in a ring, so that he might at any moment
exercise his authority over the realms of spirits and beasts, the earth,
the winds, and the sea.
His first care was to subject the Jinns. He made them all appear
before him, with the exception of the mighty Sachr, who kept himself
in concealment on an unknown island in the ocean, and the great
Eblis, the master of all evil spirits, to whom God had promised
complete liberty till the day of the last Judgment.
When all the demons were assembled, Solomon pressed his seal
upon their necks, to mark them as his slaves. Then he commanded
all the male Jinns to collect every sort of material for the construction
of the temple he was about to build. He bade also the female Jinns
cook, bake, wash, weave, and carry water; and what they made he
distributed amongst the poor. The meats they cooked were placed
on tables, which covered an area of four square miles; and daily
thirty thousand portions of beef, as many portions of mutton, and
very many birds and fishes were devoured. The Jinns and devils sat
at iron tables, the poor at tables of wood, the heads of the people at
silver tables, the wise and pious at tables of gold; and these latter
were served by Solomon in person.
One day, when all spirits, men, beasts, and birds rose satisfied from
the tables, Solomon besought God to permit him to feed to the full all
created animals at once. God replied that he demanded an
impossibility. “But,” said he, “try, to-morrow, what thou canst do to
satisfy the dwellers in the sea.”
On the morrow, accordingly, Solomon bade the Jinns lade a hundred
thousand camels and the same number of mules with corn, and lead
them to the sea-shore. He then cried to the fishes and said: “Come,
ye dwellers in the water, eat and be satisfied!”
Then came all manner of fishes to the surface of the water, and
Solomon cast the corn to them, and they ate and were satisfied, and
dived out of sight. But all at once a whale lifted his head above the
surface, and it was like a mountain. Solomon bade the spirits pour
one sack of corn after another down the throat of the monster, till all
the store was exhausted, there remained not a single grain. But the
whale cried, “Feed me, Solomon! feed me! never have I suffered
from hunger as I have this day!”
Solomon asked the whale if there were any more in the deep like
him. The fish answered: “There are of my race as many as a
thousand kinds, and the smallest is so large that thou wouldst seem
in its belly to be but a sand-grain in the desert.”
Solomon cast himself upon the earth, and began to weep, and
prayed to God to pardon him for his presumption.
“My kingdom,” called to him the Most High, “is far greater than thine.
Stand up, and behold one creature over which no man has yet
obtained the mastery.”
Then the sea began to foam and toss, as though churned by the
eight winds raging against it, and out of the tumbling brine rose the
Leviathan, so great that it could easily have swallowed seven
thousand whales such as that which Solomon had attempted to feed;
and the Leviathan cried, with a voice like the roar of thunder:
“Praised be God, who by His mighty power preserves me from
perishing by hunger.”[660]
3. THE BUILDING OF THE TEMPLE.[661]