Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Received July 1, 2020, accepted July 10, 2020, date of publication July 20, 2020, date of current version

July 30, 2020.


Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3010266

DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of


AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System
ZHANQING YU , (Member, IEEE), XIAORUI WANG , LU QU,
WENPENG ZHOU, (Graduate Student Member, IEEE),
AND RONG ZENG , (Senior Member, IEEE)
State Key Lab of Power Systems, Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
Corresponding author: Zhanqing Yu (yzq@tsinghua.edu.cn)
This paper was supported by National Key Research and Development Program 2017YFB0903201.

ABSTRACT AC/DC hybrid power distribution network are adopted to replace traditional AC power
distribution network with the continuous access of distributed renewable energy to power grid, which can
solve the source and load power supply as well as power consumption demand comprehensively. However,
the over-voltage characteristics of AC/DC hybrid system are quite different from traditional AC system for
their different structure. For this reason, the over-voltage generation mechanism on DC side of a proposed
AC/DC hybrid distribution system was analyzed. Then based on the system simulation model established
in MATLAB/Simulink, the over-voltage characteristics under DC side pole-to-pole short-circuit fault were
obtained. The simulation results show that the maximum over-voltage of 10kV DC pole-to-pole fault can
reach 121.8kV and the maximum over-voltage of ±375V DC pole-to-pole fault can reach 12kV. An over-
voltage suppression method by applying arresters was proposed. Simulation results show that the maximum
over-voltage of 10kV DC side drops to 12kV and the maximum over-voltage of ±375V DC side drops to
1.2kV. The above analyses provide basis for the design of over-voltage and insulation of AC/DC hybrid
distribution system.

INDEX TERMS DC distribution system, DC over-voltage, pole-to-pole short-circuit, arrester.

I. INTRODUCTION composed of power devices, is gradually applied in trans-


Traditional AC power distribution network can no longer mission and distribution system. Its multi-port characteris-
meet the requirements of efficient access of DC sources with tics facilitate the interconnection of different levels of AC
continuous access of distributed renewable energy. Using and DC distribution networks, and enable the bi-directional
AC/DC mode instead of traditional AC distribution network transmission of power between the DC distribution network
can comprehensively solve the power supply and power con- and other networks, so as to flexibly control the power flow
sumption demand of source and load [1]–[4]. DC distribution in the distribution network [11]–[13]. However, the over-
system can reduce the number of power converters and the voltage and over-current capacity of the power electronic
resulting loss, and there are no frequency stability and passive devices that make up SST is limited, we must pay attention
power problems in the DC distribution system. Researches to the fault characteristics and insulation coordination of the
on system structure, modeling simulation, fault protection, AC/DC system as in the AC system, so as to avoid the damage
insulation coordination and other related technologies for to the safety and reliability of the system in case of fault.
AC/DC hybrid distribution systems have been carried out in With the continuous development of ultra-high voltage
view of the above problems [5]–[10]. (UHV) technology, there has been some research on the
With the development of semiconductor power devices, over-voltage characteristics and insulation coordination of
such as gate turn off thyristor (GTO) and insulated gate UHVDC transmission project [14]–[17]. In [14], character-
bipolar transistor (IGBT), solid-state transformer (SST), istics, generation mechanism and dynamic process of the
DC over-voltage caused by the line fault at the near send-
The associate editor coordinating the review of this manuscript and ing of converter station in the Zhangbei Rouzhi project is
approving it for publication was Sudhakar Babu Thanikanti . analyzed. In [15], the cable fault in VSC based DC network

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
133248 VOLUME 8, 2020
Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

FIGURE 1. Topology of the AC/DC hybrid system.

is analyzed in detail, and the most serious fault phase to reliable consumption of distributed renewable energy and
avoid is determined. An efficient modular multilevel con- economic energy demand of DC load.
verter (MMC) HVDC system model is established in [16], (3) Propose an arrester suppression method, to protect the
and the transient characteristics of the system are studied main equipment in this system and limit the over-voltage
including different kinds of fault modes. In [17], the char- appearing during fault.
acteristics of switching overvoltage were analyzed and dis- (4) Analyze the over-voltage characteristics after arrester
cussed in detail including the main influencing factors and arrangement. The result reveals the effectiveness of the over-
worst-case conditions in the ±1100-kV UHVDC converter voltage suppression method.
station. Different protection or control schemes were used
based on the over-voltage characteristics of MMC in HVDC II. AC/DC HYBRID SYSTEM STRUCTURE
system [18], [19]. Different approaches are applied to limit An AC/DC hybrid system is developed aiming at reliable
the lighting over-voltage or the dynamic over-voltage in consumption of distributed renewable energy and economic
DC lines, among which, using arresters is an effective way energy demand of DC load, its topology is shown in Fig.1. For
to suppress the over-voltage [20]–[22]. Research in paper AC/DC hybrid system, its main equipment includes SST, fault
[20] shows that the extensive application of arresters in DC current controller (FCC), photovoltaic (PV), wind power,
lines has successfully solved the problem of lightning over- energy storage, light and heat, IT load (I means that there
voltage in China. In [21], the mechanism of transient over- is no working grounding on the power supply side; T refers
voltage caused by DC side to ground fault in MMC-HVDC to grounding protection on the load side electric equipment),
lines connected by cables is studied and the results reveal and etc. The system includes 10kV AC and 10kV DC, as well
that arresters are needed in the system to limit the transient as 380V AC and ±375V DC. The total capacity of the system
over-voltage. is 5.352MW, the proportion of distributed renewable energy
However, the research mainly focuses on topology, control is 64.29% (3.441MW/5.352MW), more than 60%; the total
strategy, and the flexible DC transmission which has been capacity of DC load is 50.86% (2.722MW / 5.352MW), more
put into operation because of the short development of DC than 30%. The details of the hybrid AC/DC system are shown
distribution system. As the over-voltage level significantly in Table 1.
affects the system parameter selection and manufacturing
cost, a reasonable protection scheme can ensure the safety of III. DC OVER-VOLTAGE CHARACTERISTICS ANALYSIS
the equipment under fault conditions. Therefore, for ensuring In this section, the over-voltage generation mechanism of on
the safety of the system, it is necessary to study the over- DC side is discussed based on the AC/DC hybrid system
voltage characteristics of AC-DC hybrid distribution system, given in the above section. Over-voltage characteristics are
and propose reasonable over-voltage control or suppression obtained when pole-to-pole short-circuit fault occurs in 10kV
methods. DC and ±375V DC system respectively.
The main contributions of this paper are as follows:
(1) Analyze the over-voltage generation mechanism of the A. OVER-VOLTAGE GENERATION MECHANISM
AC/DC hybrid distribution system which is the theoretical ON DC SIDE
basis of system over-voltage analysis. There are two reasons for over-voltage on the DC side of
(2) Analyze the over-voltage characteristics of DC side AC/DC hybrid distribution system: one is the over-voltage
pole-to-pole short-circuit fault in Matlab/Simulink of the passed from AC fault side to DC side; the other is the
proposed AC/DC hybrid distribution system, which aims at over-voltage generated by fault on DC line. In this paper,

VOLUME 8, 2020 133249


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 1. The type and capacity of source and storage in the scheme.

FIGURE 3. Flow path of fault current in conduction phase of diode


natural commutation.

FIGURE 4. Equivalent circuit in stage 3.

FIGURE 2. Equivalent discharge circuit in stage 1.


In this stage, the capacitor and inductor will be in the state
we mainly analyze the over-voltage caused by DC fault. of alternating charge and discharge. During this process,
When fault occurs in DC side, the SST will go through three the DC side of converter station will appear over-voltage phe-
stages. nomenon. Until the converter station is unlocked, DC voltage
(1) Stage 1: DC side capacitor will inject current into the gradually returns to normal level. Flow path of fault current
fault point before power electronic device blocking; in conduction phase of diode natural commutation is shown
(2) Stage 2: AC side injects current into the fault point in Fig.3.
through anti-parallel diode and DC side capacitor inject cur- In stage 3, this stage can be divided into two parts: three-
rent into the fault point at the same time before fault removal phase short-circuit and DC side discharges, as shown in Fig.4.
and after power electronic device turning off. The diode’s natural commutation and full conduction will
(3) Stage 3: after fault removal and before unlocking of keep a continuous alternating state, while the overall fault
power electronic device. current and voltage level will gradually decrease and finally
In stage 1, at the beginning of the fault, the DC voltage tend to be stable. In this stage, current in the converter is
(udc ) is greater than the AC side line voltage, the DC line fault impacted by the three-phase short-circuit current at the AC
current will mainly discharge from DC capacitor to the failure side and the short-circuit reactance continuous current at the
point. The discharge circuit of SST is shown in Fig.2. DC DC side at the same time, resulting in sharp over-current and
capacitor discharge is a second-order under-damped oscilla- over-voltage.
tion process because the small value of the loop resistance,
and the capacitor voltage will attenuate to zero. The dynamic B. OVER-VOLTAGE CHARACTERISTICS ANALYSIS OF
process in this stage can be expressed as: AC/DC HYBRID SYSTEM
Simulation analyses of the DC side pole-to-pole short-circuit
d2 udc dudc fault are conducted without consideration of DC protection
LC 2
+ RC + udc = 0 (1)
dt dt strategy in order to study the characteristics of DC side over-
where R, L and C are the loop resistance, inductance and voltage in AC/DC hybrid system, thereby providing reference
capacitance respectively. for voltage suppression method.
In stage 2, when the udc drops to the AC side line voltage, The AC/DC hybrid distribution power system simulation
the AC side power supply will start to inject fault current to model is established in MATLAB/Simulink. The steady-state
the fault point through the free-wheeling diode. At this time, operation characteristics of the DC power distribution system
the conduction of diode is based on the natural commutation are simulated. The voltage levels at each key position of the
principle of uncontrolled rectifier bridge, so this process can system are shown in Table 2. As pole-to- pole short-circuit
be called the diode natural commutation conduction stage. fault is the most serious condition among all DC line faults,

133250 VOLUME 8, 2020


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 2. Key node voltage during stable operation.

FIGURE 7. Over-voltage of 10kV DC pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.

send out the breaking instruction to isolate the whole 10kV


FIGURE 5. 10kV DC pole-to-pole short-circuit fault. area, thereby matching the action of other DC fault isolating
devices.
(2) Step 2: FCC completes fault separation after 3ms of
step 1 (3ms is the action time of the hybrid DC circuit
breaker in FCC). During this period, the system protection
configuration shall be able to complete the identification of
the fault area and give the breaking command to the DC fault
isolation device at both ends of the fault area.
(3) Step 3: The mechanical DC circuit breaker in the 0kV
line completes separation after 7ms of step 2.
The voltage level at each key position of the system is
shown in Table 3 in the case of pole-to-pole short-circuit fault
FIGURE 6. Time sequence after fault, where t1 is the time at the end of of 10kV DC system. Table 3 shows that over-voltage with
the step 1, so as to t2 and t3. DCCB (DC circuit breaker). the extreme value of about 121.8kV is generated on 10kV
DC output port in the process of FCC breaking, which is
over-voltage generated under DC side line pole-to-pole fault 12 times of that in stable operation. Simulation result is shown
is mainly discussed in the paper. in Fig. 7.
According to standard [24], the line breaker shall not break
1) POLE-TO-POLE SHORT-CIRCUIT FAULT IN 10KV DC the no-load line when line-to-ground voltage is no more
SYSTEM than 1.3 p.u., which means over-voltage shall not appear.
It is assumed that the pole-to-pole short-circuit fault is intro- Therefore, arresters should be arranged in these parts, inside
duced at the time of 1.1s in the 10kV DC system as shown in of FCC, valve side of electric reactor, and FCC side of electric
Fig.5. reactor. Because of the high-frequency isolation of the SST,
The time sequence after fault is shown as follows and in there is no obvious over-voltage in ±375V DC side.
the flowchart in Fig.6:
(1) Step 1(10-19µ s): In 10-19 µs after the fault occurs, 2) POLE-TO-POLE SHORT-CIRCUIT FAULT
the short-circuit current will trigger the over-current protec- IN ±375V DC SYSTEM
tion of FCC, FCC will input its current limiting reactor unit When pole-to-pole short-circuit fault occurs at the ±375V
to limit the increase speed of the short-circuit current, and DC line side of the system at 1.5s after the system enters into

VOLUME 8, 2020 133251


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 3. Key node voltage during 10kV DC system pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.

FIGURE 8. Time sequence after fault, where t1 is the time at the end of
the step 1, so as to t2.

FIGURE 10. Operation over-voltage generated on the pole line of the


solid-state DC circuit breaker when the opening time is not synchronous.

FIGURE 9. Simulation result in the ±375V DC line when the current


limiting inductance of FCC is 1mH-5mH.
FIGURE 11. Time sequence after fault, where t1 is the time at the end of
the step 1, so as to t2.
steady state, and the fault sequence is as follows and in the
flowchart in Fig.8:
(1) After the fault occurs, input the current limiting reac- (1) Step 1: The current limiting reactor in the output port
tance of all FCCs to suppress the rise of short-circuit current; of SST acts to limit the increase of the short-circuit current
(2) 1 ms after the previous step (the assumed time required after the fault occurs;
for differential protection), after determining the fault loca- (2) Step 2: SST will be locked after the fault occurs for 5ms
tion and giving the breaking command to the controller, in order to protect the power devices in case of over-current.
the controller is disconnected instantly to isolate the fault SST provides fault current for the fault point through
area. DAB, and ±375V bus voltage drops at the moment of short
Simulation results, shown in Fig.9, reveal that over-voltage circuit. It is assumed that the converter on the fault side is
fluctuation with the extreme value of 600V occurs in the blocked to isolate the fault area at 5ms, and the internal bus
375V DC line when the current limiting inductance of FCC is voltage returns to normal value. There is slight over-voltage
1mH-5mH. What’s more, over-voltage generates on the pole in the SST output port due to the rapid change of energy
line of the solid-state DC circuit breaker when the opening distribution. The simulation results are shown in Fig.12 and
time is not synchronous. The extreme value of the operation Table 4. Similarly, due to the high frequency isolation of SST,
over-voltage is about 12kV when the asynchronous time is no obvious over-voltage can be observed at 10kV DC side.
1ms as Fig.10 shows. Arresters are needed to suppress the
over-voltage here. IV. DC OVER-VOLTAGE SUPPRESSION METHOD AND
When pole-to-pole short-circuit fault occurs at the valve EFFECTIVENESS
side of SST at moment of 1s, and the time sequence after the The over-voltage suppression method by applying arresters
fault is as follows and in the flowchart in Fig.11: is discussed in this section. Firstly, arrester configuration

133252 VOLUME 8, 2020


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 4. Key node voltage during ±375V DC system pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.

TABLE 5. Function of various arresters.

FIGURE 12. Slight over-voltage in the SST output port in ±375V system.

TABLE 6. Typical arrester parameters for power station.

FIGURE 13. Basic process of arrester selection.

scheme is given based on the analysis of last section. Then,


effectiveness of this method is verified by simulation. TABLE 7. Parameters of arrester for 750V DC system.

A. DC SIDE OVER-VOLTAGE SUPPRESSION METHOD


Arrester is commonly adopted as a key equipment of the
over-voltage protection in modern power system. Arrester
has high impedance characteristics under normal circum-
stances, and it has low impedance characteristics when
external over-voltage is applied. Reasonable arrester config- TABLE 8. Selection basis of arrester parameters.
uration can effectively protect the devices inside the con-
verter station, improve the reliability of the system, reduce
the cost of the devices, and achieve the optimal perfor-
mance in terms of technology and economy. Over-voltage
protection measures of reasonably configuring arresters
are mainly studied in this paper. The basic process of
arrester selection is shown in Fig.13, including configuration
principle, configuration scheme and selection of arrester (2) DC side over-voltage is limited by DC side arrester as
parameters. far as possible. For example, DC line arrester and DC bus
arrester;
1) CONFIGURATION PRINCIPLE OF ARRESTER (3) The key equipment of the system should be directly
The principles are listed as follows: protected by arrester close to them, such as transformer,
(1) AC side over-voltage is limited by AC side arrester as power sub-module, AC/DC electric reactor, AC/DC cable and
far as possible; other important equipment.

VOLUME 8, 2020 133253


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 9. Key node voltage of 10kV DC pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.

TABLE 10. Arrester action condition during 10kV DC system pole-to-pole


short-circuit fault.

FIGURE 14. Arrester arrangement scheme of multi-port SST.

FIGURE 16. Arrester arrangement scheme of VSC.

arrester configuration of dual port DC transformer for IT


load access is shown in Fig.15. The protection is realized by
DB375 arrester, thereby ensuring that DC bus voltage of grid
side is not too high. Arrester arrangement scheme of VSC is
shown in Fig.16.
FIGURE 15. Arrester arrangement scheme of IT load interface.
The FCC used in AC/DC hybrid power grid can be divided
into three types of topology: mechanical structure, solid-
2) CONFIGURATION SCHEME OF ARRESTER state structure, and hybrid structure. FCC is equipped with
Multi-port power electronic transformer, dual port DC trans- arrester, which is used to: (a) discharge the over-voltage
former, VSC and FCC are considered in the system arrester caused by the operation of DC circuit breaker; (b) pro-
configuration. tect the power electronic devices in the circuit breaker;
The arrester arrangement of 10kV DC port is shown (c) protect the capacitor devices in the circuit breaker. For
in Fig.14(a). It’s protected by DB10k arrester in the main the operation over-voltage generated by other equipment,
converter area at both ends, thereby ensuring that there line arrester (DL, as shown in Fig.17) shall be added to
is no pole-to-pole over-voltage in the high-voltage side the system to suppress the invasion of system over-voltage.
of DC bus. DB375 is used for suppressing the impact of Details of arresters used in the system are summarized
±375V DC system operation over-voltage to converter. The in Table 5.

133254 VOLUME 8, 2020


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 11. Key node voltage during ±375V DC system pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.

FIGURE 17. Arrester arrangement scheme for FCC.

FIGURE 19. Over-voltage of ±375V DC pole-to-pole short-circuit fault


after configuration of arresters.

the selection basis for parameters of arresters configured in


the project is shown in the Table 8. CCOV is the crest value
FIGURE 18. Over-voltage of 10kV DC pole-to-pole short-circuit fault after of continuous operating voltage of arrester.
configuration of arresters.

3) SELECTION OF ARRESTER PARAMETERS B. OVER-VOLTAGE CONDITION AFTER CONFIGURATION


The general design method based on the chargeability is OF ARRESTER
used to determine the parameters of the arrester, and the Based on the arrester configuration scheme, and the protec-
factors such as the chargeability, lightning impulse, operation tion scheme proposed above, a new simulation model with
impulse and the capacity of the arrester are comprehensively arresters is built and pole-to-pole fault characteristics of 10kV
considered. DC and ±375V DC are analyzed in detail.
The chargeability of DC arrester is defined as the ratio
of peak value of continuous operation voltage (PCOV) to 1) POLE-TO-POLE SHORT-CIRCUIT FAULT IN 10KV DC
reference voltage Uref; the selection of chargeability must SYSTEM
consider the stability of arrester, the value of leakage current, When not taking H-bridge converter blocking (or blocking
peak value of continuous operation voltage, DC voltage com- failure) at the outlet of SST 10kV DC into consideration,
ponent, and other factors. For DC arresters, the chargeability the fault area is isolated by FCC configured on the 10kV pole
can be taken as 0.8-1.0 according to the different voltage line and the mechanical DC circuit breaker configured on the
waveforms and installation positions of the arresters. 0kV pole line. The over-voltage of key node in the AC/DC
According to the national standard GBT 28547-2012 guide system is shown in Table 9. The acting condition of the
for selection and use of MOA, the parameters of typical power arresters in the system after the acting of DC circuit breaker
station arresters are shown in Table 6. The arrester chosen for is shown in Table 10. The electromagnetic energy generated
10kV DC system is YH5WZ-17-45kV, and the rated voltage is absorbed by arresters by 3.89kJ, and the rest energy is dif-
is 17kV. For 750V DC system, the residual voltage limit is fused to the rest energy storage elements, such as inductors,
1.2kV according to parameters of arrester for 750V DC sys- capacitors, etc., thereby causing high-frequency electromag-
tem in Table 7. According to the above selection principles, netic oscillation until the energy is consumed by resistive

VOLUME 8, 2020 133255


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

TABLE 12. Arrester action condition during ±375V DC system excellent V-A characteristics of MOA, different kinds of
pole-to-pole short-circuit fault.
arresters are applied to different equipment and key nodes.
4) Reasonable arrester configuration can suppress the over-
voltage effectively. Simulation results show that the maxi-
mum over-voltage of 10kV DC bus drops to 12kV and the
maximum over-voltage of ±375V DC bus drops to 1.1kV.
5) For a new structure of power system, analyses have to
be taken to ensure the safety and reliability of the system,
of which over-voltage characteristics and insulation coordi-
nation are necessary. The analyzing method of the proposed
AC/DC distribution system can be applied to analyzing other
AC/DC hybrid system.

REFERENCES
elements in the system. The maximum over-voltage of 10kV
[1] S. Jiang, C. Fan, N. Huang, Y. Zhu, and M. He, ‘‘A fault location method for
DC bus drops from 121.8kV to 12kV shown in Fig.18. DC lines connected with DAB terminal in power electronic transformer,’’
IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 301–311, Feb. 2019.
2) POLE-TO-POLE SHORT-CIRCUIT FAULT IN ±375V DC [2] W. Wei, Y. Zhou, J. Zhu, K. Hou, H. Zhao, Z. Li, and T. Xu, ‘‘Reliability
assessment for AC/DC hybrid distribution network with high penetration
SYSTEM of renewable energy,’’ IEEE Access, vol. 7, pp. 153141–153150, Oct. 2019.
Simulation result of the pole-to-pole short-circuit fault occurs [3] L. Mackay, E. Vandeventer, and L. Ramirez-Elizondo, ‘‘Circulating net
in ±375V DC system with arresters configured is shown currents in meshed DC distribution grids: A challenge for residual ground
fault protection,’’ IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 1018–1019,
in Table 11. The acting condition of the arranging arresters in Apr. 2018.
the system after the breaking operation of DC circuit breaker [4] H. M. A. Ahmed, A. B. Eltantawy, and M. M. A. Salama, ‘‘A planning
is shown in Table 12. According to the previous analysis, approach for the network configuration of AC-DC hybrid distribution sys-
tems,’’ IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 2203–2213, May 2018.
when the breaking time of the solid-state DC circuit breaker [5] X. Liu, P. Wang, and P. Chiang Loh, ‘‘A hybrid AC/DC microgrid and its
is not synchronous, the operating overvoltage on the pole line coordination control,’’ IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 278–286,
of the circuit breaker can be observed to be about 12kV. The Jun. 2011.
[6] N. Eghtedarpour and E. Farjah, ‘‘Power control and management in
residual voltage limit of the arrester in 750V DC system is
a hybrid AC/DC microgrid,’’ IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 5, no. 3,
1.2kV. The arrester acts to absorb over-voltage after fault. pp. 1494–1505, May 2014.
Because the photovoltaic side is short-circuit after action, [7] P. Wang, C. Jin, D. Zhu, Y. Tang, P. C. Loh, and F. H. Choo, ‘‘Distributed
the fault area is isolated by the circuit breaker. And after control for autonomous operation of a three-port AC/DC/DS hybrid micro-
grid,’’ IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 62, no. 2, pp. 1279–1290, Feb. 2015.
the circuit breaker acts, energy absorbed by arrester is about [8] S. Bifaretti, P. Zanchetta, A. Watson, L. Tarisciotti, and J. C. Clare,
656.52J. The over-voltage is suppressed within 1.1kV. The ‘‘Advanced power electronic conversion and control system for universal
voltage response at both ends of arrester is consistent with and flexible power management,’’ IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 2, no. 2,
pp. 231–243, Jun. 2011.
the waveform of 750V DC output port, while the over-voltage [9] D. Boroyevich, I. Cvetkovic, D. Dong, R. Burgos, F. Wang, and F. Lee,
value is about 600V as shown in Fig.19. ‘‘Future electronic power distribution systems a contemplative view,’’
in Proc. 12th Int. Conf. Optim. Electr. Electron. Equip., Basov, Russia,
May 2010, pp. 1369–1380.
V. SUMMARY [10] A. Q. Huang, M. L. Crow, G. T. Heydt, J. P. Zheng, and S. J. Dale,
For the demand of continuous access of distributed renewable ‘‘The future renewable electric energy delivery and management
energy, AC/DC distribution system network becomes more (FREEDM) system: The energy Internet,’’ Proc. IEEE, vol. 99, no. 1,
pp. 133–148, Jan. 2011.
and more important and widely known. As over-voltage pose [11] J. Shi, W. Gou, H. Yuan, T. Zhao, and A. Q. Huang, ‘‘Research on voltage
great threat to power system and power equipment, over- and power balance control for cascaded modular solid-state transformer,’’
voltage characteristics and insulation coordination should be IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 1154–1166, Apr. 2011.
analyzed comprehensively. In this paper, an AC/DC hybrid [12] J. E. Huber and J. W. Kolar, ‘‘Volume/weight/cost comparison of a 1 MVA
10 kV/400 V solid-state against a conventional low-frequency distribution
system structure is proposed. Analyses are conducted based transformer,’’ in Proc. IEEE Energy Convers. Congr. Exposit. (ECCE),
on the simulation model established in Matlab/Simulink. Pittsburgh, PA, USA, Sep. 2014, pp. 4545–4552.
Conclusions can be drawn from the above analyses: [13] T. Guillod, F. Krismer, and J. W. Kolar, ‘‘Protection of MV converters in
the grid: The case of MV/LV solid-state transformers,’’ IEEE J. Emerg. Sel.
1) Over-voltage generation mechanism of AC/DC hybrid Topics Power Electron., vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 393–408, Mar. 2017.
system is obtained by dividing into three stages; [14] Y. B. Li, G. Q. Bu, and S. S. Wang, ‘‘Analysis of DC over-voltage in the
2) Pole-to-pole short-circuit fault of the proposed structure process of DC line short circuit in Zhangbei Rouzhi power grid project,’’
Proc. CSEE, vol. 12, pp. 33–41, Jun. 2017.
is simulated. Over-voltage in 10kV DC system can reach
[15] J. Yang, J. E. Fletcher, and J. O’Reilly, ‘‘Short-circuit and ground fault
121.8kV when FCC operates. Over-voltage in ±375V DC analyses and location in VSC-based DC network cables,’’ IEEE Trans. Ind.
system can reach 12kV when the solid-state DC circuit Electron., vol. 59, no. 10, pp. 3827–3837, Oct. 2012.
breaker on the pole line operates asynchronously by 1ms. [16] X. Han, W. Sima, M. Yang, L. Li, T. Yuan, and Y. Si, ‘‘Transient charac-
teristics under ground and short-circuit faults in a ±500 kV MMC-based
3) Measures have to be taken according to related standards HVDC system with hybrid DC circuit breakers,’’ IEEE Trans. Power Del.,
when high over-voltage appears in power system. For the vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 1378–1387, Jun. 2018.

133256 VOLUME 8, 2020


Z. Yu et al.: DC Side Over-Voltage Characteristics Analysis of AC/DC Hybrid Distribution Power System

[17] D. Wang, H. Zhou, and D. Xu, ‘‘Switching overvoltage characteristics of LU QU was born in 1987. He received the Ph.D.
±1100 kV UHVDC converter station,’’ IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 30, degree in electrical engineering from the Uni-
no. 3, pp. 1205–1212, Jun. 2015. versity of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Hefei,
[18] R. Li, L. Xu, and L. Yao, ‘‘DC fault detection and location in meshed in 2016. He currently holds a postdoctoral posi-
multiterminal HVDC systems based on DC reactor voltage change rate,’’ tion at Tsinghua University. His research interests
IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 1516–1526, Jun. 2017. include dc grid and dc breaking technology.
[19] H. Tian, Y. W. Li, and P. Wang, ‘‘Hybrid AC/DC system harmonics control
through grid interfacing converters with low switching frequency,’’ IEEE
Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 65, no. 3, pp. 2256–2267, Mar. 2018.
[20] S. Gu, S. Wan, J. Wang, J. Chen, and T. Li, ‘‘Development and application
of ±500 kV DC transmission line arrester in China power grid,’’ IEEE
Trans. Power Del., vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 209–217, Feb. 2018.
[21] F. Badrkhani Ajaei and R. Iravani, ‘‘Cable surge arrester operation due
to transient overvoltages under DC-side faults in the MMC–HVDC link,’’
IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 31, no. 3, pp. 1213–1222, Jun. 2016.
[22] J. Hu, K. Xu, L. Lin, and R. Zeng, ‘‘Analysis and enhanced control of
Hybrid-MMC-Based HVDC systems during asymmetrical DC voltage
faults,’’ IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 1394–1403, Jun. 2017.
[23] X. Li, Q. Song, W. Liu, H. Rao, S. Xu, and L. Li, ‘‘Protection of nonperma- WENPENG ZHOU (Graduate Student Member,
nent faults on DC overhead lines in MMC-based HVDC systems,’’ IEEE IEEE) was born in Heilongjiang, China, in 1995.
Trans. Power Del., vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 483–490, Jan. 2013. He received the B.S. degree from the Department
[24] Power Quality-Temporary Over-voltage and Transient Over-voltage, of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University,
Standard GB/T18481-2001, 2002. Beijing, China, in 2017, where he is currently
pursuing the Ph.D. degree. His current research
ZHANQING YU (Member, IEEE) was born in interests include the power semiconductor devices,
Inner Mongolia, China, in 1981. He received the including IGCTs and IGBTs, as well as their appli-
B.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees from the Department of cation in multilevel modular converters and dc
Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Bei- circuit breakers.
jing, in July 2003 and July 2008, respectively.
After graduation, he held a postdoctoral, lecturer,
and an associate professorship positions with the
Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua
University, Beijing, in July 2008, July 2010, and
December 2012, respectively. His research inter-
ests include dc grid, dc breaker, electromagnetic environment, electro-
magnetic compatibility, and lightning protection. He has participated in RONG ZENG (Senior Member, IEEE) was born
several projects sponsored by the High-Tech Research and Development in Shanxi, China, in 1971. He received the B.Eng.,
Program (863 Program), the National Basic Research Program of China M.Eng., and Ph.D. degrees from the Department of
(973 Program), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China. Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Bei-
jing, China, in 1995, 1997, and 1999, respectively.
XIAORUI WANG was born in Henan, China, He was a Lecturer, an Associate Professor, and a
in 1993. She received the B.S. degree from the Professor with the Department of Electrical Engi-
School of Electric and Electronic Engineering, neering, Tsinghua University, in 1999, 2002, and
Huazhong University of Science and Technology, 2007, respectively. He is currently the Dean of the
Wuhan, China, in 2016. She is currently pursu- Electrical Engineering Department, Tsinghua Uni-
ing the Ph.D. degree with Tsinghua University. versity. He is currently working in the fields of air gap discharge, lightning
Her current research interests include reliability protection, and electromagnetic compatibility in power systems, electric and
of power semiconductor devices and dc circuit magnetic field measurement by integrated electro-optical sensors, power
breaker. semiconductor, HVDC systems, and direct current circuit breaker.

VOLUME 8, 2020 133257

You might also like