Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4. Tyre Design Ncdas 2018
4. Tyre Design Ncdas 2018
ITTAC
Design Need Identification
A tyre design process starts when a request for a particular size and type
of tyre is received from marketing department (either for OEM customer
or Replacement market).
For the sizes not already defined in above “Tyre Industry Standards”; a method
based upon empirical formulae is used to derive load-deflection tables for that
particular size (which later on standardized and added in relevant tables of “Tyre
Industry Standards”). 145/70R12
L=Load in kg.
k=6.67*10^(-5)…..(50 series 0.0000667
through 80 series)
P in Kpa 240
P^0.50 15.491933
Sd in mm (reduced tyre 116.4782
equivalent section width)
Aspect ratio in fraction 0.7
S 0.70 (Nom sec. width) in mm 145
Sd ^1.39 744.8694
Dr (Rim dia. in rounded mm.) 304
Dr (Rim dia. in inch) 12
(Dr+Sd) 421.27821
L=Load in kg. 324.25044 Kg.
325 Kg.
The relationship between Load, Inflation Pressure and
geometry can be given as under, for a Bias Tyre:
L = k A S P1 (D R + S)
1.39 0.525
9:00 20 14 PR Truck tyre having section with on rim having design rim
width =10.2// , design rim width = 7 //, inflation pressure =100 psi
Calculate the load carrying capacity of this tyre.
Design Goal Finalisation continued ...
MOULD DESIGN
Rim can be regarded as the basis of the tyre section and mould cavity design.
(i) The rim width as a fraction of section width is a prime parameter. The
performance in stability, cornering and wear improves with increase in the
fraction. The new basis is about 70 -65 % for passenger car tyres.
(ii) The actual rim diameter of tyre is kept with a +ve overlap with Nominal
Rim Diameter ensuring proper as well as ease of fitment.
(iii) The flange height and contour is highly influenced by the rim the tyre is
going to be fitted on.
Sectional Height and Width
The single most parameter that influence them is the Aspect Ratio. Both an
increase and decrease in this value has its own merits and demerits.
Allowance in dimension is kept for (a) thermal and mechanical shrinkage and
(b) effect of inflation. The allowance themselves change with construction
material and aspect ratio. Typically with an aspect ratio between 1.02 - 1.05, a
mould width equal to 90-95% of the recommended figure, on the
recommended rim, produces the desired inflated width.
In cases where alternate rims are provided, experience and estimate says that a
40-50% of the difference in rim width to be adjusted for tyre width.
Tread Depth Consideration (NSD)
Tread Depth of a tyre (NSD - Non Skid Depth) design is a careful
investigation of a number of considerations
(i) life or mileage expected (the more the life, deeper the NSD)
(ii) application (more traction from deeper groove)
(iii) heat generation at the thickest
(iv) traction and lug (tread element shuffle)
etc.
The tread depth is perhaps the most important parameter for rubber envelope
design as this is considered to be the base for all other thickness.
But, finally the application rules. An aircraft tyre even with a high IP has a
shallower depth and a race tyre with no pattern have roughly 1/15 inch.
Tread Depth Consideration (NSD)
continued ...
Naturally, a tyre rated to run with a low IP must keep a lowed NSD
Tread Curvature Determination
The considerations for an appropriate tread curvature is a fine balance
(i) more the curvature radius, flatter the tread, thus more of footprint area leading
to better mileage and handling.
(ii) flatter tread also allows shoulder thickness to be kept on lower side thus
avoiding excess heat build-up.
(iii) where an absolutely flat tread may lead to tread-edge effect leading to
localized flexing and consequent rupture / failure
(iv) a modification is done to avoid the above is the introduction of double radius
(v) a fully circular shoulder is an advancement of the same logic leading (iv)
Tread Curvature Determinationcontinued ...
Once the tread width (max.) is fixed, the central arc is drawn with the crossing
point of CL and nominal rim diameter. The presence of secondary arc is put at
1/4th. of tread width from shoulder side, with a 25% of main arc radius.
A guidance says that the footprint width to be 90% of the tread width, it’s natural
to have a tread width roughly 75-80% of the tyre width in case of bias tyres.
It’s also recommended that the shoulder edges extends no further than the outer
most point of contact of the tyre with the rim.
But it’s imperative that the tread radius, tread depth and tread width be
considered simultaneously.
Sidewall Curvature
The design of the sidewall is made in two portions separately
for the upper sidewall, an arc is drawn with centre on horizontal centre line,
making a tangent to the line from tread extremity midway between shoulder and
horizontal centre line.
For the lower sidewall, again an arc is drawn with a centre on horizontal centre
line, making a tangent to the upper sidewall arc and cuts the line of the curve
flange of the rim near it’s highest point. The two intersecting curves are filleted
by a curve with one quarter of radius as that of the lower sidewall radius.
Design Goal Finalisation continued ...
TREAD PATTERN
(Groove and Pattern Geometry)
The decision about tread pattern is almost done concurrently with previous step
(i.e., deciding Geometrical Dimensions of the tyre).
1. Service : Lug, Rib, Semi lug, Agricultural, Sand, Snow, Rain or Sports. Each
service forces it’s own requirement and constraint.
Speed, traction and wear are the three principle parameters governing the pattern,
groove angle together with NSD. Noise reduction is another important feature
while designing the pattern.
Tread cracking, carcass pounding, heel and toe wear, irregular wear etc. are other
important factors to be considered.
Design Goal Finalisation
TREAD PATTERN
(Groove and Pattern Geometry)
2. Manufacturability : Consideration on ease of filling and mould release. Groove
angles are required to be no less than 10º.
Specific customer requests (particularly in OEMs’ case) are also very important
in tread pattern selection.
LUG PATTERN : The groove pattern perpendicular to the circumference of the tyre
Good points : Excellent braking & driving power. Superior traction.
Bad points : Noisy at high speed. It's not suitable for high speed driving
because of high rolling resistance.
Uses : For dirt roads, rear wheels of buses, industrial vehicles and dump
trucks .
SEMI-LUG PATTERN : The combination of Rib-shape & Lug-shape
Features : The rib in the centre provides directional control whilst the shoulder
lug gives good braking & driving power.
Uses : Good for both paved and dirt roads. Usually used in both front & rear
wheels of trucks and buses.
BLOCK PATTERN : The pattern of independent block which the groove is connected with
each other
Good points : Good steering control and stability on snow covered and wet
roads. Good water dispersal properties on wet roads.
Bad points : Tyre wear is heavy as tread blocks are finer.
Uses : Suitable for winter or all-season passenger car tyres. Suitable for back-
wheel of Radial tyre of ordinary car .
ASYMMETRIC PATTERN : Tread pattern differs on either side
Good points : Good for high speed cornering thanks to greater contact area.
Reduces tread-wear on outside of tyre.
Bad points : You must position them the right way around.
Uses : High performance and motorsport tyres.
DIRECTIONAL PATTERN : Lateral grooves on both sides point the same direction.
Good points : Good driving force and braking performance. Good water dispersal
means good stability on wet roads. Correct choice for fast driving styles.
Features : mounted in direction of tread pattern.
Uses : the passenger car tyre for high speed usage.
Design Goal Finalisation continued ...
CONSTRUCTIONAL LAYOUT
Once major tyre cavity dimensions are finalised, we generate cavity profile
drawing.
The next step is to finalise a tyre layout. With the help of competitive
information generated through benchmarking & team experience, designer next
defines construction details both in terms of geometry as well as material. It
involves decision like which reinforcement material, what angle / EPI, what
cured rubber gauges at various locations across the cross-section etc. Using
available material usage information of the company and with the help of
empirical formulae / thumb rule these constructional parameters are finalised.
Knowledge of concepts like “stress-free carcass” proves valuable here.
Cavity Profile
Layout
Design Goal Finalisation
CONSTRUCTIONAL LAYOUT
Tc = Ft / ( M Sin 2 b )
Ft Transverse Radial Force (lb./inch)
ß Carcass Cured Crown Angle (Degree)
M Total number of cords in one linear inch of carcass
' 1
2
P 4 D - D Dr D tan 90 - a
2 2 '
- D tan 90 - a
2 '
Tcc =
M 16 D 2Tr 2
P Inflation Pressure (psi)
D Inflated Tyre Outer Diameter (inch)
Dr Nominal Rim Diameter (inch)
Tr Tread Radius (inch)
M' Cured EPI of Ply (No. of Ply x EPI)
a' Cured Ply Angle
PD 4D 2 - D D r 2
Tbc = 1 -
2 M Cos a 16 Tr D
2
The design of the reinforcement is based on the assumption that the ratio of
bursting pressure to inflation pressure is equal to breaking (or yielding) strength
of reinforcement to it’s max. load in the tyre
From the safety factor calculations, it’s prominent that the maximum strength
transversely is, theoretically, when cured crown angle is 90 degree without
circumferential stretch. However, manufacturing considerations prevents its
adoption.
Reinforcement Angle, EPI etc.continued ...
Stability and cushioning - A high means that the cords are short in transverse
direction, there is little resistance to sideways forces and stability is poor. The
distortion is also high under load and impact. Naturally, low gives a better
handling.
Flexing, Tread Wear etc. - With the similar argument, the lower the , the more
resistant is the tyre against tread shuffle and flexing and thereby lesser tendency
of tread wear.
Reinforcement Angle, EPI etc.continued ...
High crown angle is advantageous for
(a) carcass strength
(b) cushioning and normal deflection under load
(c) flex resistance in the tread compound
Tb ={P×W (3Dr+D)}/16N
The expected inflated profile at the beginning of the design cycle is suitably
converted into mould dimensions at the mould design step.
The NSD as stated earlier, together with the mould dimensions are the staring
point.
The “Undertread” or sub-tread or tread base can be, of course with deviation
from pattern to pattern, kept 40-50% of the NSD.
In both the cases the current manufacturing practice influences the ultimate
values. However a gauge between 0.8-1.1mm is common.
The thickness of the sidewall rubber at the horizontal centre line varies from
1/16" to 1/4". In a similar fashion the rubber gauge at rim line is also fixed.
Techniques like Natural Inflated Profile and Stress Free Carcass conceptualize
the carcass path.
R Sin b
Cos = (1 + )
1+ E
Assuming,
The mean diameter of the carcass on building drum = X
The mean diameter of the carcass in tyre = D
The Lift is = D/X = R
The mean fabric stretch during shaping = E
= Cured crown angle
b = Green crown angle
= -0.015 to -0.030
Green Cord EPI Calculation
Sin
m' = m
R Sin b
tan
Gg = R 2 Gc
tan b
Where
= cured angle
b = green angle
R = Lift Ratio
Gg = Green gauge
Gc = Cured gauge
Building Drum Width (Drum Set)
Calculation
Cured Cord Length (for per unit development length)
1
Cosec =
R 2 Cos 2 b
1-
(1 + E) 2
Where,
Reference Distance from Nom.Rim Dia line = X
Dia of Station =DR + 2X (mm)
Lift Ratio R=(DR+2X)/Drum OD
2 Cosec
Green Cord Length =
(1 + E) 2 Cosec
Green Cord Width Over Flat Portion of Drum = Sin b - Drum Contour
(1 + E)
(Where Drum Contour is fixed for a certain type)
continued ...
Building Drum Width (Drum Set)
Calculation
Certain Thumb Rules are also available
DL Sin b
Drum Set = - Drum Contour
+ b b -
(1 + E) Sin Cos
2 2
Bead Compression Calculation
EFFECTIVE LEDGE (ELW ) = Ledge W idth - (Toe Radius / 2)
PLY COMPACTNESS (PC) = 1+ (Drum OD - Station Dia) / Station Dia
Lateral Bead Compression= [(A-B)/A]*100
Total Green Gauge of Plies etc. (A)
Space available sidewise (B)
A step off of 25 mm as in layout is maintained and ply widths for all other plies are calculated
Breaker and squzee widths are calculated from layout width. Per unit cured width will produce
2 Cosec
Sin b where Cosec a will differ from
(1 + E) point to point according to following
1
Cosec =
R 2 Cos2 b
1-
(1 + E) 2
M
'
=
M
R
S
S
i
n
i
n
b
G
g
=
t
t
a
a
n
n
b
R
2
G
c
4 EPI
M' Cured EPI = From Layout = 22/17/15
M Green EPI
S in b
M' = M
R S in
M =1.5*22*0.64278 / 0.8571
= 24.7466
~=25
5 IL Width
= Cured Dev. Length + (1/2 * Bead Width)*2
=635+40
~=675 mm
~=680 mm (kept)
6 Cured Gauge
tan
Gg = R2 Gc
tan b
Gg = Green Gauge
Gc = Cured GAuge = From layout = 1.2mm for Ply 1
Gg = 1.2*1.5*1.5*0.83909/1.66427
=1.36
~=1.33 (kept)
Which could be distributed as 1.08 for ply and 0.25 for squeezee
7 Length
Inner Liner length =(Drum OD*pi)*0.94 (Considering a total of 6-7% pull in
turret and application)
=25.75 * 3.414*25.4*0.94
=1931.47
~=1925 (kept)
The length of first ply is kept same.
For every succeeding plies a step-off = pi*Ply Gauge is applied
For the current case it's about 7 mm.
Radial Stretch = [{(Tyre Dev. Length + Rim Dev. Length - 2*Bead Width)/Perimeter}-1]*100
Allowable ( 10-35 %)
Circular Stretch ={( Tyre ID / Tube O.D.) - 1}*100
Allowable ( 0-10 %)
So, deciding the Stretches to be kept we can calculate back the Tube Perimeter and Tube O.D.
(when Tyre and Rim Dimensions are known).
Tube Inside Dia is calculated as Tube I.D.= Tyre Nominal Dia. + (0 - 50)mm.
...(varies for Pass. / L.T. / Truck)
A thumb rule says that as the Tyre Size increases the above value increases. It also depends on
the type of Rim being used (Well Base / Flat Base).
Overall Stretch =[{{(Tyre Dev. Length+Rim Dev. Length-(2*Cured Bead width))/Cured tube Perimeter}*(Tyre ID./Tube OD)}-1]*100
Tube Weight Calculation
INPUT
TUBE OUTER DIAMETER
TUBE INNER DIAMETER
MAJOR AXIS
MINOR AXIS
DRAWING/MOULD HIGHER RADIUS (R2)
DRAWING/MOULD LOWER RADIUS (R1)
Mould Parting Angle (Acute angle with Vertical) (ß)
Cured Base Gauge = Green Base Gauge
AVERAGE GAUGE (Cured)
Density of Cured Rubber
Valve Weight
Clearance
Development Length of Tyre (Nom.)
Rim Development Length (Nom.)
Cured Bead Width
Tyre Inner Diameter
Tube Weight Calculation
OUTPUT
OUTPUT
A details of the calculation of Section Perimeter Considering
Elliptical Section
Length of a quadrant = 2
a 1 - e 2 Cos 2 d
Hence perimeter of the ellipse =
0
1 2 e 2 1 .3 2 e 4 1 . 3 . 5 2 e 6
2a 1 - - - ...
2 1 2.4 3 2.4.6 5
Design Verification
• Pulley Wheel Tests
- High Speed Test
- Deflection Test
- Plunger Energy Test
• Check Tyre Analysis
Design Validation
• Outdoor Tests
- Accelerated Test
- Field Test
- Test at Institutions (Includes stiffness test, handling etc.)
Commercial Release
• Released in PDRM (Product Development Review Meeting)
• Quality Planning Sign Off (RQG is discussed / signed)
RADIAL TYRE DESIGN PROCESS
• Before the tyre engineer begins the design process, he must assemble
a list of product goals, including customer performance expectations,
manufacturing requirements, internal company performance standards
and regulatory requirements.
• But mold profile items like tread, center and shoulder radii
and skid depth can also significantly affect tyre
performance.
• Beginning with size, load capacity, speed rating, body and belt
materials, compounds, tread designs and construction variations, how
do we choose? Obviously, industry-wide guidelines exist (TRA, DOT,
ETRTO, etc.), and guidelines and standards have been developed by
individual tyre manufacturers as well. They serve as a starting point.
• Handling and wet traction are improved but ride, rolling resistance and
weight have suffered.
ITTAC
Design Need Identification
OEMs mostly supply additional information which is very useful input for tyre
design. One such sample is demonstrated next.
TABLE-1 TIRE REQUIREMENTS
BENCHMARKING
This is first step towards design goal finalization. It consists of thorough examination of
available product (in the size and application of target product) in all possible ways like
Geometrical Dimension, Cross-Section analysis, Reverse Engineering w.r.t. material and
compound as well as performance evaluation through destructive testing (like Step Load
endurance testing on Pulley wheel for reliability estimation). Some specialized tests (like
Force and Moment Testing) can also be included in Benchmarking studies if need so felt.
Tyre Designer tries to include best products available in target market in his study. This
exercise greatly helps him in defining bogey as well as detailed Design Goals. Specialised
Tyre Benchmark reports available from various labs (like Smithers; USA) are also very
informative and helpful.
COMPETITORS TYRE ANALYSIS DETAILS
TYRE Tyre Size/PR 10.00-20/16 10.00-20/16
DETAILS Make Company A Company B
Name Product A Product B
Mfg. CODE Serial No *** ***
Tyre Weight (Kgs) 55.1 57.0
WEIGHT
continued
WIDTH
1st Brk dir wrt Last Ply Parallel Opposite
Ply 1680/2 1260/2
TYPE OF
Breaker 840/2 840/2
FABRIC
Chaffer Sq.Wo.Nyl. Sq.Wo. Nyl.
Benchmarking
DAT A FROM ST ANDARDS PRODUCT / PROCESS ASSUMPT IONS PRELIM. SPECIAL CHARACT ERIST ICS PRODUCT RELIABILIT Y ST UDY
S.NO. DESIGN GUIDE DESIGN RANGE NSD
O.D. S.W. O.D. S.W. HIWAY T RACT ION 1) RIM T O BE USED IS 4.0 J 1) T READ LENGT H 1) SHLDR. WEAR IN 145/70R12 PatternY
1 JAT MA 537 145 530 ~ 544 152 MAX - - 2) NO WEIGHT RESTRICTIONS 2) PLY WIDHT 2) ST ONE T RAPPING
2 ET RT O - - - - - - - FROM OEM 3) FABRIC GAGUE 3) FAILURE LEVELS ARE WIT HIN
3 IT T AC 537 145 530 ~ 544 152 MAX - - 4) INFLAT ED DIMENSIONS : OD , SW T ARGET S.
4 T &RA - - - - - - -
5 ANY OT HER - - - - - - -
REMARKS : RIM 4.0 J X 12 "
CUST OMER REQUIREMENT S GOAL SET
NOT AVAILABLE DIMENSIONS FIXED BASED ON :
OD AS PER DISCUSSION WIT H OEM & INT ERNAL
SW AS PER DISCUSSION WIT H OEM & INT ERNAL
T AW MORE T HAN 145/70R12 Pattern Y AS OEM IS MORE POWERFUL CAR.
TR IN LINE WIT H 145/70R12 Pattern Y
NSD MORE T HAN 145/70R12 Pattern Y T O HAVE MORE MILEAGE IN OEM
CHANGE REQUIRED IN: RIM FIT MENT RIM 4.0" (101.6 MM)
REVISION HIST ORY INIT IALS SIGN DAT E
ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MM UNLESS OT HERWISE NOT ED. REV NO DAT E REASON FOR CHANGE ORIGINAT OR APPD.