conveys the idea that people often take their freedoms, rights, and ability to express themselves for

granted until those freedoms are threatened or

restricted. When individuals experience censorship, oppression, or suppression of their voices, they become acutely aware of the significance of
speaking out, advocating for their beliefs, and participating in democratic processes.

The sentiment behind the statement emphasizes the need to cherish, protect, and defend freedom of expression as a fundamental human right and
cornerstone of democratic societies. It serves as a reminder of the power of individual voices to effect change, challenge injustice, and hold those in
positions of authority accountable.

We realize the importance of our voices only when we are silenced.

1. Anne Frank, a young Jewish girl whose diary documented her life in hiding during the
Holocaust while evading the Nazis, stands as a powerful symbol of the significance of one's
voice amidst suppression. Despite the tragic silencing of Anne's voice at a tender age, her
legacy serves as a poignant reminder, highlighting the importance of the value of one's
voice, especially when faced with attempts to silence it. Her story compellingly
underscores that we truly grasp the importance of our voices only when they are unjustly
muted.
OR,

2. The ruthless murder of Jamal Khashoggi, a Saudi Arabian journalist in 2018 in backdrop
of Khashoggi's courageous and critical writings challenging the Saudi government, had

om
drawn global attention. His tragic fate serves as a reminder, emphasizing the profound
l.c
ai
gm
significance of journalistic voices, particularly when wielded to question and critique those
0@

in power. The global outcry sparked by Khashoggi's silenced voice highlights the vital role
30
23

journalists play in holding authority accountable, and his story vividly illustrates that we
95
ik

truly comprehend the importance of our voices when confronted with attempts to brutally
an
rm

silence them.
fo
y
nl
O

OR,

3. The Jallianwala Bagh massacre in 1919, where British forces fired upon a peaceful
gathering in Amritsar, stands as a haunting example of how the silencing of Indian voices
made Indians realized the importance of their voices and fueled the flames of the freedom
struggle, which was manifested in form of huge participation of people in non-cooperation
movement. The ruthless actions of General Dyer triggered widespread outrage and became
a turning point, as leaders like Mahatma Gandhi shifted their stance towards advocating

During India's Emergency from 1975 to 1977, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi curtailed civil liberties, leading to the suppression of voices and freedoms.
This period highlighted the value of free speech and democratic principles, as citizens realized the importance of their voices only when they were
silenced. Despite the restrictions, individuals clandestinely resisted, emphasizing the need to uphold democratic values and protect fundamental rights.
 for complete independence. Therefore, it is indeed true that we realize the importance of
our voices only when we are silenced
"We realize the importance of our voices only when we are silenced" underscores the significance of free
expression and the value of speaking out against oppression or injustice. It suggests that individuals often
Brainstorming take their ability to voice opinions and advocate for change for granted until they encounter situations where
their voices are stifled or suppressed.

1. Introduction:
2. How do we realise the importance of our voices when we are silenced?
3. In what ways does silenced voice comes out?
4. Is silence always lack of speech or does it manifest in different other forms too in
current complex world?
5. Who bears the impact of silence the most?
6. Conclusion

Introduction:

om
l.c
“As a young girl in Pakistan, Malala used her voice to advocate for girls' education, standing up
ai
gm
against the Taliban's oppressive regime. When her voice became too powerful and too influential,
0@

she was brutally silenced and shot in an assassination attempt.”

30
23
95
ik

Silencing of voices is not a present day phenomena, rather human history is full of instances where
an
rm

the suppression of voices, whether through oppressive regimes, social norms, or individual actions,
fo
y

has led to a profound awakening of the significance of expression. From renaissance to any
nl
O

important movement in the modern world is actually eventually result of forceful suppression of
people’s voices. Most of the times we take our privileges of free speech and expression for granted
until they are gone and its only then collective movement for change beings.

How do we realise the importance of our voices when we are silenced?

When freedom of speech is suppressed, with passing time, people begin to sense the weight of
unspoken thoughts and unexpressed emotions, which creates a collective consesus of the value
1)Experiencing censorship, suppression, or marginalization can highlight the injustices present within society. When individuals are prevented from
expressing their opinions or advocating for their rights, they begin to recognize the systemic barriers that hinder their ability to participate fully in public
discourse and decision-making processes.

In authoritarian regimes, such as in China or North Korea, citizens may be silenced by strict government censorship and propaganda. When
individuals witness the consequences of speaking out against the government, such as imprisonment or persecution, they become acutely aware of the
value of their voices and the need to challenge oppressive systems.
 Being silenced can ignite a sense of resilience and determination to overcome obstacles and assert one's right to free expression. When faced with
adversity, individuals may find the strength to speak out against injustice, even in the face of risks or repercussions.

LGBTQ+ activists worldwide have faced discrimination, violence, and censorship due to their advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights. Despite the challenges,
many activists have continued to raise awareness, organize protests, and advocate for legal reforms to advance equality and inclusion.

inherent in one's voice. A kid might stay silent the whole day but once you forcefully ask her to
stay silent, she starts growing restless. Similar is true for any human being.

During apartheid era in South Africa, authorities’ attempt to suppress voices only intensified the
collective yearning for freedom. The silence imposed by censorship became a powerful teacher,
reflecting the intrinsic importance of each voice and catalyzing the anti-apartheid movement.

In moments of silence, we understand how important each person's voice is. Surprisingly, when
someone tries to stop us from speaking, it helps us see how diverse ideas make our community
stronger. An example is when governments try to silence people, this shows that when we can't
express ourselves, we realize how crucial our voices are. It's not just talking; our voices are like
important parts that make our community strong, resilient, and better.
Studying history and learning about past struggles for social justice can also help individuals realize the importance of their voices when silenced.
Holocaust education and remembrance initiatives serve to educate people about the atrocities of the Holocaust and the dangers of unchecked
prejudice and discrimination. By learning about the consequences of silence and indifference, individuals are motivated to speak out against bigotry and
hate in their own communities

In what ways does silenced voice comes out? The Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa provided a forum
for survivors of apartheid-era abuses to share their testimonies, seek

om
justice, and promote national healing and reconciliation.

l.c
Once a forceful silence is imposed, there are different other forms of articulation of ideas that
ai
gm
develops. For instance, different forms of artistic expression serves as a powerful tool to
0@
30

communicate ideas, dissent, and perspectives that may be stifled in more traditional forms of
23

communication. Harlem Renaissance was such a movement in American history in which

95
ik
an

African American writers, musicians, and artists such as Langston Hughes, Hurston, Douglas, etc.
rm

used their creative expressions to challenge racial stereotypes and advocate for civil rights.
fo
y
nl

->The poetry of Maya Angelou, who wrote about the struggles of African Americans and the resilience of the human spirit, gave voice to marginalized
O

communities and inspired generations to confront racism and discrimination.

->Silenced voices often find strength in solidarity and collective action. The Black Lives Matter movement, founded in response to police brutality and
racial injustice against Black communities, has mobilized activists nationwide to demand systemic reforms, challenge structural racism, and promote
racial equality
When people whose voices are ignored or stopped come together, they become stronger and
express their dissatisfaction through peaceful protests, campaigns to speak up for what's right, or
community projects. With increasing penetration of digital or social media, these platforms have
become crucial channels for silenced voices to share their stories, opinions, and experiences
globally. For instance, #MeToo movement provided a platform for survivors of sexual
harassment, who had been silent about their encounters with harassment found the courage to
speak up and to share their experiences all across the globe.
 Silenced voices come out are diverse and evolving ways with evolving means of communication
and expressions. Whether through art, community action, online platforms, or educational efforts,
these voices play a vital role in shaping conversations, challenging norms, and contributing to the
progress of societies.
In the digital age, silence may arise from concerns about digital surveillance, data privacy, and online security, which can inhibit individuals from freely
expressing themselves online.
Whistleblowers and activists may hesitate to speak out against government abuses or corporate wrongdoing online due to fears of surveillance,
cyberattacks, or retaliation.
Is silence always lack of speech or does it manifest in different other forms too in current
Silence can also stem from the normalization of injustice, where societal apathy, indifference, or complicity
complex world? perpetuate systemic inequalities and human rights abuses.
The normalization of police violence against Black communities in the United States

In our world, silence doesn't always mean an absence of speech; it can arise from broader problems
like systemic issues, biases, exclusion, discrimination, etc. Silence is not always literal silence,
rather its feeling of being unheard or marginalized. Addressing this nuanced form of silence
requires not only acknowledging it but also actively working to dismantle systemic barriers and
Individuals may self-censor their speech or actions due to fear of retaliation, social stigma, or
biases within the society. repercussions from powerful entities. This form of silence often stems from concerns about personal
safety, livelihoods, or social standing.Journalists in authoritarian regimes may refrain from reporting on
sensitive topics or criticizing government policies out of fear of harassment, arrest, or imprisonment

om
For instance, silence of a woman in a house or in public life is not her literal silence but patriarchal
l.c
ai
gm
repression of her dreams and desires. This example underscores that silence in the modern context
0@

is often a complex interplay of structural challenges that need comprehensive and sustained efforts
30
23

to overcome. It's essential to acknowledge and tackle these subtle types of silence to promote
95

inclusivity, diversity, and fair involvement in different aspects of contemporary life.

ik
an
rm

In many parts of the world, individuals and groups face censorship and suppression of their voices by authoritarian regimes, governments, or powerful
institutions. This censorship can take the form of restricted access to information, media blackouts, or the suppression of dissenting opinions.
fo

The Chinese government's censorship of online content through the "Great Firewall" restricts access to information deemed politically sensitive, limiting
y
nl

freedom of expression and stifling dissenting voices.

O

Who bears the impact of silence the most?

It often the marginalized sections of society that bear a disproportionate impact when their voices
are stifled, reinforcing existing inequalities. In India, for example, tribal communities are often left
out of talks about how to use land or manage resources. The rules made without their ideas often
don't help them and continue the historical injustices.

Not being able to talk or share ideas can also make economic disparities worse. Imagine some
people are not treated the same way when it comes to education, jobs, or fair pay. The gender pay
gap is a good example of this. Women sometimes get wage for doing the same job because of
Racial and ethnic minorities, indigenous peoples, LGBTQ+ individuals, persons with disabilities, and other marginalized groups often experience
systemic discrimination, exclusion, and violence that silences their voices and perpetuates social inequalities.

Children and youth may lack agency and autonomy to speak out against injustices, abuse, or exploitation due to power imbalances and societal
expectations of obedience and deference to authority figures
Individuals living in poverty or socioeconomically disadvantaged circumstances often face barriers to accessing education, healthcare, employment,
and legal protections, which can silence their voices and perpetuate cycles of marginalization and exclusion.

Migrant workers, refugees, and displaced populations often face exploitation, discrimination, and marginalization that silence their voices and limit their
ability to access legal protections, social services, and avenues for redress.

longstanding and systemic biases. Minority communities experienced systemic issues in

healthcare access and disparities in socioeconomic conditions, highlighting the silent impact on
health outcomes.

In the justice system, silence can lead to unjust outcomes for marginalized individuals. People
from minority groups often face unfair treatment from police and in court. All these examples
show that when some voices are not heard, it hurts certain groups more, making things even more
unfair for them. An apt example of it would be decades of injustices and atrocities inflicted on
LGBTQ+ communities worldwide and in India. counter argument
while experiences of silence can indeed highlight the significance of one's voice, it is not the sole determinant.
Recognition of the importance of our voices can arise from various sources, including empowerment, education, and
collective action, underscoring the multifaceted nature of individual and collective agency in advocating for change
Conclusion and promoting social justice.

The attempt to suppress voices, whether through historical atrocities or contemporary injustices,
serves as a catalyst for a collective awakening regarding the intrinsic value of expression. As we

om
navigate the complexities of our modern world, recognizing the multifaceted nature of silence

l.c
ai
becomes imperative. The true importance of our voices is most profoundly realized when faced
gm
0@

with attempts to suppress them. It is not merely the absence of speech but a nuanced interplay of
30

structural challenges, discrimination, and exclusion. Addressing this form of silence demands a
23
95

commitment to dismantling systemic barriers, fostering inclusivity, and ensuring fair involvement
ik
an

in various aspects of contemporary life.

rm
fo

The quote "We realize the importance of our voices only when we are silenced" suggests a need for proactive measures to ensure that all individuals
y
nl

have the opportunity to express themselves freely and participate in decision-making processes.
O

Uphold and protect the fundamental right to freedom of expression for all individuals, regardless of their background, beliefs, or status. Enact laws and
policies that safeguard freedom of speech and create environments where diverse voices are respected and valued.

Create spaces for inclusive dialogue and participation where marginalized and underrepresented groups can share their perspectives, concerns, and
aspirations.

Challenge censorship, suppression, and intimidation tactics that seek to silence dissenting voices and stifle public discourse.

Empower vulnerable communities, including marginalized groups, women, youth, and indigenous peoples, to amplify their voices and advocate for
their rights. Provide access to resources, education, and opportunities for civic engagement to build their capacity to advocate for social change and
address systemic injustices.

Protect press freedom and support independent media outlets, journalists, and citizen journalists who play a vital role in exposing corruption, holding
power to account, and amplifying marginalized voices. Invest in media literacy programs to promote critical thinking and empower individuals to discern
credible information from misinformation and propaganda.

Foster a culture of solidarity, empathy, and allyship where individuals stand in solidarity with those whose voices are silenced or marginalized.
Recognize the interconnectedness of social justice struggles and work collaboratively to address intersecting forms of oppression and discrimination.

Promote civic education and engagement initiatives that empower individuals to become informed, active citizens who participate in democratic
processes, advocate for social change, and hold elected officials and institutions accountable to the public interest.