Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full download Eratosthenes and the Measurement of the Earth's Circumference (c.230 BC) Christopher Matthew file pdf all chapter on 2024
Full download Eratosthenes and the Measurement of the Earth's Circumference (c.230 BC) Christopher Matthew file pdf all chapter on 2024
https://ebookmass.com/product/trapped-brides-of-the-kindred-
book-29-faith-anderson/
https://ebookmass.com/product/out-of-the-ether-matthew-leising/
https://ebookmass.com/product/hierarchy-of-needs-and-the-
measurement-of-poverty-and-standards-of-living-joseph-deutsch/
https://ebookmass.com/product/ancient-supercontinents-and-the-
paleogeography-of-earth-lauri-j-pesonen/
The Rise and Fall of Peace on Earth Michael Mandelbaum
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-rise-and-fall-of-peace-on-
earth-michael-mandelbaum/
https://ebookmass.com/product/origins-of-the-earth-moon-and-life-
an-interdisciplinary-approach-akio-makishima/
https://ebookmass.com/product/sparta-and-the-commemoration-of-
war-matthew-a-sears/
https://ebookmass.com/product/habitability-of-the-universe-
before-earth-richard-gordon/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-primacy-of-metaphysics-
christopher-peacocke/
Eratosthenes and the Measurement of the
Earth’s Circumference (c. 230 BC)
Eratosthenes and the
Measurement of the
Earth’s Circumference
(c. 230 BC)
C H R IST O P H ER A . M AT T H EW
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
© Christopher A. Matthew 2023
The moral rights of the author have been asserted
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above
You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2023930924
ISBN 978–0–19–887429–4
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198874294.001.0001
Printed and bound by
CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY
Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and
for information only. Oxford disclaims any responsibility for the materials
contained in any third party website referenced in this work.
Acknowledgements
Abbreviations viii
Ancient Sources viii
Journals xiii
Illustrations xvi
Tables xxi
Preface xxii
1. Historical Background 1
1.1 The Sources 1
1.2 Eratosthenes, The Man 9
1.3 Alexandria 14
1.4 Greek Astronomical Thought Before The Time Of
Eratosthenes 28
2. The Experiment 74
2.1 Eratosthenes’ Experiment 74
2.2 Eratosthenes’ Sundial 86
2.3 Time And The Solstices In Ancient Egypt And Greece 88
2.4 Ancient Egyptian And Greek Sundials To The Time Of
Eratosthenes 94
2.5 A Replica Of Eratosthenes’ Skaphe 112
3. The Analysis 129
3.1 The Angle 129
3.2 Errors In Eratosthenes’ Methodology 139
4. The Stade 205
4.1 The Size Of The Stade 205
4.2 Previous Estimates Of The Size Of Eratosthenes’ STADE 220
5. The Re-Examination 233
5.1 Eratosthenes And The 180 m Stade 233
5.2 The 180 m Stade And The Circumference Of The Earth 269
6. The Circumference 283
6.1 The Accuracy Of Eratosthenes’ Circumference 283
6.2 Eratosthenes’ Legacy 286
References 302
Ancient And Medieval Sources 302
Modern Sources 309
Electronic Sources 319
Index 320
Abbreviations
Ancient Sources
Continued
x ABBREVIATIONS
Continued
Continued
xii ABBREVIATIONS
Continued
Journals
Abbreviation Title
Continued
Abbreviation Title
Br. J. Hist. Sci. The British Journal for the History of Science
BSA Biblioteca di Studi Antichi
BZ Byzantinische Zeitschrift
Centaurus Centaurus
Chiron Chiron
CJ Classical Journal
Cl. Phil. Classical Philology
Class. Antiq. Classical Antiquity
Configurations Configurations
CQ Classical Quarterly
DHA Dialogues d'histoire ancienne
G&R Greece & Rome
H. M. Inst. R. Fr. Histoire et mémoires de l'Institut royal de
France
Hesperia Hesperia
HIST MATH Historia Mathematica
Historia Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte
Isis Isis
J. Astron. Hist. Herit. Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage
J. Forensic Leg. Med. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine
J. Hist. Astron. Journal for the History of Astronomy
J. Inst. Navig. Journal of the Institute for Navigation
J. R. Asiat. Soc. The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great
Britain and Ireland
Jahrb. Berlin Museen Jahrbuch der Berliner Museen
Janus Janus
JHS Journal of Hellenic Studies
JRS Journal of Roman Studies
Klio Klio
Math. Mag. Mathematics Magazine
MDAIK Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen
Instituts, Abteilung Kairo
MedAnt Mediterraneo Antico
Mém. Acad. Inscript. et belles-lettres Mémoires de l’A cadémie de Inscriptions et
belles-lettres
Mem. Acad. Sci. Inst. Fr. Mémoires de l’A cadémie des sciences de l’Institut
de France
Mil. Psychol. Military Psychology
MMAB Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin
Nikephoros Nikephoros
Orb. Terr. Orbis Terrarum: Journal of Historical
Geography of the Ancient World
PAPS Publication of the American Philosophical
Society
ABBREVIATIONS xv
Fig. 18. Computer modelling of the design of the gnomon for the
replica sundial. 114
Fig. 19. Computer modelling of the arachne for the replica sundial. 114
Fig. 20. Laser etching the lines of the arachne onto the replica sundial. 115
Fig. 21. The complete replica skaphe. 115
Fig. 22. The replica sundial set onto a Dobsonian mount. 116
Fig. 23. The shadow of the gnomon when the sundial was set to
replicate noon on the Summer Solstice. 117
Fig. 24. Satellite image of the location of Crescent Head. 118
Fig. 25. The equation of time for the southern hemisphere. 120
Fig. 26. Data for the solar culmination time on the Summer Solstice
at Crescent Head, taken from suncalc.org. 124
Fig. 27. The compass and spirit levels used to align the sundial. 125
Fig. 28. The location of the shadow cast by the gnomon of the replica
sundial fifteen minutes prior to noon (LAT) on the Summer
Solstice in Crescent Head. 126
Fig. 29. The shadow cast by the gnomon of the replica sundial at noon
(LAT) in Crescent Head. 127
Fig. 30. The spherical problem with Eratosthenes’ angle identified by
Goldstein. 130
Fig. 31. In Eratosthenes’ experiment, angles X and Y are equal. 131
Fig. 32. Walkup’s method of calculating the circumference of the
Earth (with angles exaggerated). 132
Fig. 33. Plan view (top) and cross section through the noon line
(bottom) of a hemispherical skaphe calibrated for Syene. 134
Fig. 34. Plan view (top) and cross section through the noon line
(bottom) of a hemispherical skaphe calibrated for Alexandria. 135
Fig. 35. The strip of paper used to measure the positions of points GA ,
SA , and HA on the replica sundial. 136
Fig. 36. Egypt, showing the location of Alexandria, Syene (Aswan)
and the Tropic of Cancer. 141
Fig. 37. Determination of the longitudinal distance between
Alexandria and Syene (with the angles and curvature
exaggerated). 142
Fig. 38. The relationship between geocentric latitude on a spherical
Earth (red line/black circle) and the geographical latitude on
a geodic Earth (blue line/dotted ellipse). 151
Fig. 39. Aristarchus’ proof that a larger sphere illuminates more than
a hemisphere of a smaller sphere—from Commandino’s 1572
xviii ILLUSTRATIONS
Fig. 58. The stadium at Olympia, Greece. The line of stones at the end
of the ‘track’ in the foreground are the starter’s ‘blocks’ for the
running races. The finish line, one stade length away, is just
beyond the location of the people in the distance. 206
Fig. 59. Satellite image of the stadium at Olympia, Greece, with the
length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 208
Fig. 60. Satellite image of the Panathenaic stadium at Athens, Greece,
with the length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 209
Fig. 61. Satellite image of the stadium at Aphrodisias, Turkey, with
the length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 210
Fig. 62. Satellite image of the stadium at Delphi, Greece, with the
length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 211
Fig. 63. Satellite image of the stadium at Epidaurus, Greece, with the
length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 211
Fig. 64. Satellite image of the stadium at Messene, Greece, with the
length of the stade between the start and finish lines. 212
Fig. 65. A photograph (top) and line drawing (bottom) of the
metrological relief found on Salamis (now. Piraeus Museum
#5352). 213
Fig. 66. Photograph of the metrological relief in the Ashmolean
Museum, Oxford. 214
Fig. 67. The routes between the Caspian Gates (Shahr-e-Rey) and
Hecatompylos (Damghan). 240
Fig. 68. The route between Hecatompylos (Damghan) and
Alexandria Aerion (Herat). 244
Fig. 69. The route between Alexandria Aerion (Herat) and
Prophthasia (Farrah). 246
Fig. 70. The route between Prophthasia (Farrah) and Arachoti Polis
(Qalat-el-Gilzay). 248
Fig. 71. The route between Alexandria Aerion (Herat) and Arachoti
Polis (Qalat-el-Gilzay). 249
Fig. 72. The route between Arachoti Polis (Qalat-el-Gilzay) and
Hortospana (Kabul). 250
Fig. 73. The route between Alexandria Aerion (Herat) and
Bactra-Zariapsa (Balkh). 252
Fig. 74. The route between Alexandria and Syene (Aswan), following
the course of the Nile. 263
Fig. 75. The route between Alexandria and Syene (Aswan), avoiding
the bend in the Nile at Luxor. 266
Fig. 76. The linear distance between Alexandria and Syene (Aswan). 267
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
She realized suddenly of what he had been babbling. As she
disembarked at the water-stairs, she looked up at the balcony.
There, beside the stately Contessa Albrizzi, an old man was leaning,
hawk-eyed, white-haired and thin. He blew her a kiss from his sallow
fingers.
Her nervous tension relaxed in a sudden quiver of aversion.
“No, no!” she said in a choked voice, with clenched fingers. “I will not
marry till I choose! Why must every one be in such haste?”
And with these broken sentences, that left her father standing in
blank astonishment, she hurried before him into the house.
CHAPTER XXVIII
THE HAUNTED MAN
All night Gordon’s gondola floated over the dark lagoon. All night the
star-silvered dip of the oar broke into ripples the glassy surface. All
night Gordon sat silent, goring out across the low islands that barred
the sea.
Something had touched his life which, sooner met, might have made
existence a boon. A woman’s soul had roused him—but only to a
rayless memory of what burned and rankled, as the touch of a hand
wakes a prisoner from nightly lethargy to a sense of bolt and chain.
Lines from his poem which she loved—which had called forth her
prayer—recurred to him:
“A light broke in upon my brain,—
It was the carol of a bird;
It ceased, and then it came again,
The sweetest song ear ever heard;
And mine was thankful till my eyes
Ran over with the glad surprise,
And they that moment could not see
I was the mate of misery;
But then by dull degrees came back
My senses to their wonted track,
I saw the dungeon walls and floor
Close slowly round me as before.”
So she had come and gone, and his hands touched only walls of
adamant, his ears heard only an echo rolling across blank infinities!
The moon sank. The great, linked lamps of the heavens burned
brighter, faded at length, and a breath of sea-breeze, harbinger of
the dawn, struck coldly on his cheek. Night became soft twilight,
twilight grew to warm amethyst. Little milky clouds dappled the
zenith, slowly suffused by a flush of rose that grew to vivid splendor
gray-streaked, as the sun’s climbing edge touched the humid
horizon.
The occupant of the gondola stirred and looked about him. The air
was full of mewing swallows, and a sandy island lay before him from
which rose clumps of foliage and the dim outlines of brown stone
walls, gilded by the growing light. The gondolier’s voice broke the
long silence:
“It is the Armenian monastery of Saint Lazarus, Excellence.”
The island lay lapped in quiet. Not a sound or movement intrenched
upon its peace. Only the swallows circled shrilly about slim bell-
towers, lifting like fingers pointing silently. A narrow causeway
through an encircling dike led to the wharf, and beyond, by a gate, to
an orchard where gnarled fruit-trees sniffed the salt air. From a
chimney at one side a strand of smoke sheered slenderly.
Gordon drew a long breath. “Put me ashore,” he said.
The gondola shot alongside the tiny wharf, and he stepped on to its
stone flags. He stood silent a moment, feeling the calm upon him like
a tangible hand. Far to the north, half a league’s distance, glowing
through the bluish winter haze, shone the towers and domes of
Venice, a city of white and violet, vague and unsubstantial as a
dream, a field of iris painted upon a cloud.
“Go back to the city.”
The servant was startled. “And leave you, Excellence?”
“Yes, I shall send when I need you.”
The boatman leaned anxiously on his oar. “When they question,
Excellence?”
“Tell no one but Fletcher where I am. Say to him it is my wish that he
shall not leave the palazzo.”
He watched the gondola glide away over the lightening waters, till it
was only a spot on the dimpling lagoon. He took a black phial from
his pocket and threw it far out into the water. Then he turned his
gaze and walked up the wharf toward the monastery, still soundless
and asleep.
At the corner of the sea-wall, the stone had been hollowed with the
chisel into a niche, in which, its face turned seaward, stood a small
leaden image of the Virgin. He noted it curiously, with the same
sensation of the unartificial he had felt at sight of the wooden shrine
at La Mira. And yet with all its primitive simplicity, what a chasm
between such a concrete embodiment of a personal guardianship
and that agnostic altar his youth had erected “to the unknown God”!
He looked up and saw a figure hear him.
A man of venerable look stood there, bareheaded, with a wide gray
beard which swept upon his coarse dark robe. His eyes were deep
and pleasant, and his countenance spiritual, gracious and reserved.
An open gate in the wall showed the way he had come.
For a moment neither spoke. The lucent gaze confronting him
seemed to Gordon to possess a strange familiarity: it was the same
expression of unworldly sincerity that had shone in those London
days from Dallas’ face.
“What do you seek, my son?”
Perhaps the friar had already had time to study the visitor.
Perchance the clear scrutiny had read something beneath that
cryptic look bent upon the shrine. What did he not seek, indeed!
When Gordon answered it was simply, in Italian as direct as the
other’s question.
“The peace of your walls and fields drew me, Padre. By your leave, I
would rest a while here.”
The friar’s look had not wavered. Contemplation teaches one much.
It was easy to read the lines of dissipation, of evil indulgence, that
marked the white face before him; but the padre saw further to the
soul-sickness beneath.
“We are Armenians, Signore,” he proffered, “a community of
students, who have poor entertainment; but to such as we have, the
stranger is welcome. He who comes to us stays without question
and fares forth again at his own will.”
As he spoke, a bell’s clear, chilly chime rose from somewhere within
the walls. At the note the padre turned, bowed his knee before the
leaden Virgin, and rising, with arm raised toward the lagoon, blessed
the waters and the land. Then he held out his hand to Gordon.
“I am Padre Sukias Somalian,” he said. “I will go and inform the prior.
I will call you presently.”
He disappeared through the wall-gate.
Gordon’s eyes, following him, saw the worn motto deeply cut in the
stone above it.
“O Solitudo, sola Beatitudo.”
Was it solitude that had brought that look of utter peace to the friar’s
face? Or was it rather the belief that made him bow before the niche
yonder?
His gaze wandered back to the shrine. Prayer to him was a fetish—a
plastic rigmarole of symbols and formulæ—the modern evolution of
the pre-Adamite, anthropomorphic superstition. It was far more than
that to the friar. He knelt each day to that little leaden image. And
before such an image she, Teresa, whose pure soul had been
wounded last night, had laid that written petition.
A singular look stole to his face, half-quizzical, half-wistful. He took a
leaf of paper from his pocket. He hesitated a moment, folding and
unfolding it. He glanced toward the gate.
Then he went to the niche, stooped and lifted one of the loose flat
stones that formed the base on which the image rested. He brushed
away the sand with his hand, put the paper in the space and
replaced the stone over it.
As he stood upright, a voice called to him from the gate. It was the
padre, and he turned and followed him in.
CHAPTER XXXI
AT THE FEET OF OUR LADY OF SORROWS