Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full download Amongst the Ruins: Why Civilizations Collapse and Communities Disappear John Darlington file pdf all chapter on 2024
Full download Amongst the Ruins: Why Civilizations Collapse and Communities Disappear John Darlington file pdf all chapter on 2024
https://ebookmass.com/product/amongst-the-ruins-why-
civilizations-collapse-and-communities-disappear-john-
darlington-2/
https://ebookmass.com/product/why-we-teach-science-and-why-we-
should-john-l-rudolph/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-unofficial-big-lebowski-
cocktail-book-darlington/
https://ebookmass.com/product/language-communities-in-japan-ed-
john-c-maher/
Communities, Performance and Practice: Enacting
Communities Kerrie Schaefer
https://ebookmass.com/product/communities-performance-and-
practice-enacting-communities-kerrie-schaefer/
https://ebookmass.com/product/why-elephants-cry-john-t-hancock/
https://ebookmass.com/product/why-rivals-intervene-international-
security-and-civil-conflict-john-mitton/
https://ebookmass.com/product/british-terrorist-novels-of-
the-1970s-1st-ed-edition-joseph-darlington/
https://ebookmass.com/product/empire-of-ruins-american-culture-
photography-and-the-spectacle-of-destruction-miles-orvell/
AMONGST
THE RUINS
Why Civilizations Collapse
and Communities Disappear
John Darlington
YA L E U N I V E R S I T Y P R E S S
N e w H av e n a n d L o n d o n
p. 13: Quotes from both The Tollund Man and Bogland by Seamus Heaney,
from New Selected Poems 1966–1987 © The Estate of Seamus Heaney. Used
by permission of Faber and Faber Limited. Used by permission of Farrar,
Straus & Giroux, LLC, http://us.macmillan.com/fsg. All rights reserved
p. 13: © George Barnett, 1965, The Beaghmore Stone Circles from his collection
of poems The Wee Black Tin, by kind permission of Graham Mawhinney
p. 36: By kind permission © Nicholas Comfort 1994 The Lost
City of Dunwich published by Terence Dalton, Ltd
p. 156: Permission granted by Zehao Zhou to quote from his
dissertation The Anti-Confucian Campaign during the Cultural
Revolution, August 1966–January 1967 © Zehao Zhou
p. 180: © Bobby Troup/Warner Chappell Sync
p. 184: From The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck published by Penguin
Classics. Copyright © John Steinbeck 1939. Reprinted by permission of
Penguin Books Limited. Copyright renewed © John Steinbeck 1967
p. 257: By kind permission © Graham Fairclough 2009
Copyright © 2023 John Darlington
All rights reserved. This book may not be reproduced in whole or
in part, in any form (beyond that copying permitted by Sections 107
and 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law and except by reviewers for the
public press) without written permission from the publishers.
For information about this and other Yale University
Press publications, please contact:
U.S. Office: sales.press@yale.edu yalebooks.com
Europe Office: sales@yaleup.co.uk yalebooks.co.uk
Typesetting and eBook by Tetragon, London
Library of Congress Control Number: 2022948965
ISBN 978-0-300-25928-5
eISBN 978-0-300-27133-1
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Contents
Preface vii
1. Climate Change 9
2. Natural Hazards 53
3. Human Disaster 87
Girsu, Iraq 89
St Kilda, Scotland 100
Rapa Nui (Easter Island), Chile 110
4. War 125
Conclusion 215
Acknowledgements 261
Notes 262
Bibliography 269
Image Credits 280
Index 283
Preface
Or alternatively:
The past resembles the future more than one drop of water
resembles another.
Ibn Khaldun
That men do not learn very much from the lessons of history
is the most important of all the lessons of history.
Aldous Huxley
vii
And, of course, there is always the ever-quotable Mark Twain,
who remarked, ‘The past does not repeat itself, but it rhymes.’ My
favourite, however, and a reason for writing this book, is from an
anonymous source: ‘History repeats itself because no one was lis-
tening the first time.’ Clearly, I am firmly in the camp that claims
there are valuable lessons to learn, it’s all about asking the right
question. How can we train ourselves to pay better attention to
those voices of yesteryear, particularly during times of collapse and
crisis, or ahead of them?
This book explores some of the ways that we can draw from
the past, both philosophically and practically, to help plan for and
guide the future.
Ruins lie at the heart of this book. Mutely eloquent reminders of our
immortality, they are memento mori on the grandest scale. They are
the architectural car crashes of the past which we rubberneck from
the present, whispering ‘there but for the grace of God go I . . .’.
Ruins represent our failures: civilizations that have collapsed, commu-
nities who moved out or were forced to move on, or the abandoned
dreams of despots, democrats and the divine. But, given that time is
relative, and all buildings will eventually end as dust, they are also
our successes, notices marking the extraordinary achievements of
humankind. Ruins prompt questions: what person visiting the red
sandstone facades of Petra’s Treasury would not ask why or how?
Machu Picchu, Chichen Itza and Angkor Wat inspire because we
want to know more about the people who built them. And, while
they signify lives lived long ago, they also tell us something about
where we are heading. Ruins are libraries, abandoned books that
divulge stories about what happened decades, centuries or millennia
ago, and which are repeated today. The outcome may not be the
same, but we would be arrogant to ignore the lessons of history.
This book is a search for the present and future in the past. In
it we will explore the loss of ancient civilizations, the collapse of
ruling elites and the disappearance of more recent communities.
This is a vast subject. Edward Gibbon needed six volumes for his
History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (1766–89),
1
which has now been reprinted countless times. A search of the
internet using the phrase ‘fall of empire’ will bring up thousands of
books, videos and films documenting the stumble, trip and sprawl
of the powerful, from the Aztecs and Incas through to the empires
of the British, Soviets and Americans. Flick through the pages of any
atlas of world history and be overwhelmed by the growing bloom
and subsequent shrivelling of colours depicting the tread of ancient
Mesopotamians, Mongols, Umayyads, Spaniards and Portuguese,
amongst many, many others. The last imperial Chinese dynasty
stretched over nearly 15 million square kilometres at its greatest
extent (the Qing Dynasty in 1790 ce), and doubtless more still
will be written about modern China, the twenty-first-century global
superpower, when its time has passed.
These are fascinating approaches, but I am interested in the
explanations that underpin why ancient and more recent civilizations
disappeared. How did we reach the ruin? What are the reasons behind
the fall, or the shrinking frontiers in the atlas? And, as importantly,
is there a commonality to that loss that might help us today?
In response to that challenge, I have selected seventeen places
from across the globe that illustrate specific stories of decline and
Fig. 1 ‘Destruction’ by Thomas Cole from The Course of Empire series, 1836. This,
the fourth in a series of five paintings on the subject of the rise and fall of civilizations,
shows barbarians sacking a classical city. It is followed by ‘Desolation’.
Climate Change
9
preservation, with rising sea levels sweeping away both European
and earlier culture, and thawing permafrost accelerating the discov-
ery and destruction of once frozen archaeology. Permafrost covers
almost a quarter of the Northern Hemisphere, including Alaska,
much of Canada, and Siberia. It contains within it the remarkably
preserved remains of earlier peoples: evidence that is desiccated and
lost as the permafrost disappears. This will be one of the biggest and
least appreciated losses of global cultural heritage in future times.
Coastal climate change is graphically illustrated in our third story,
using the example of Dunwich off England’s Suffolk coast. Listed in
the Domesday Book of 1086 as one of the ten largest towns in the
country, Dunwich once had a population of over 5,000 people and
eighteen churches and religious institutions. Now, just two churches
remain, and fewer than 200 residents, the remainder of the town
being lost to the sea. Again, the question is asked, how did the people
of Dunwich respond to the slow death of their town?
From too much water, to drought, the final story under the
theme of climate change describes the equally destructive impact
of a warming, drier environment on heritage. The Garamantes’
empire once stretched for 647,500 square kilometres in the Saharan
area of Libya and North Africa. Originating from Berber tribes in
the Iron Age (200 bce) and rising to regional prominence in the
second century ce, the Garamantes were described by Herodotus
as ‘a very great nation’. Despite Roman propaganda which sought
to depict the Garamantes as barbarians, they inhabited a powerful
and sophisticated kingdom with a capital that was home to 10,000
people. The Garamantes’ success was built on their sophisticated
water management system, but in the fourth century ce a drying
climate, coupled with the overexploitation of a diminishing supply
of water and the increasing numbers of slaves required to maintain
it, led to their slow decline and eventual disappearance. Depleting
water supplies, or their salinification, and the loss of civilization
to sand, is a little-told story that can be repeated across the desert
regions of the world.
Climate change will be the biggest global driver of loss of her-
itage over the coming decades, whether through inundation by
water, sand and salt, or because places that were once inhabitable
are no longer so, leading to their abandonment. These four stories
Fig. 2 Beaghmore circles from the air showing a variety of stone circles, cairns and
alignments. The contrast between the remaining russet-covered peat and green grass
of the excavated area is stark.
Climate Change11
11
landscapes since the end of the last glaciation some 15,000 years
ago; from a modern perspective it therefore has the appearance of
permanence, a soft version of geology. But it is inextricably linked
to humans who lived before its formation, and whose world lies
buried under its dense brown blanket.
Fortunately, a bog is a goldmine for archaeologists because it
locks in so much information not only about its own origin and
growth, but also about what went on in the wider landscape. Any
water-saturated deposits have the potential to preserve evidence from
the past that desiccates, disintegrates and disappears elsewhere. The
cold, wet and oxygen-lite nature of peat slows down the rate of
decay of organic matter, so preserving many things that fall within
its damp, fibrous grasp. It is estimated that archaeologists working
in peatlands may find up to 90 per cent of the material culture of
ancient communities contained within it, as opposed to 10 per cent
of those working on dry land.2 A peat bog can therefore be a library
of the past holding airborne pollen that precisely documents changes
to the surrounding vegetation; seeds and plant material telling us
about diet and materials; the wooden posts and platforms of ancient
homes; even the bodies of people themselves, often beautifully pre-
served but disconcerting victims of prehistoric ritual. The carbon in
the peat gives us dates, while the identifiable marks of bog growth
and contraction tell us something about the climate over millennia.
But peat is selective, in overly acidic conditions the soil can quickly
eat away bone and antler and destroy certain metals, particularly if
they are subjected to repeated wetting and drying.
Bogs don’t just appear, they are living things, requiring the right
combination of wet, cold and poor drainage, and the right type of
wet – in this case acid rich and nutrient poor, mainly falling as rainfall.
There are several different types of peat bog in the UK and Ireland
and their growth is complex, but they may be simplified according
to how they form. Raised bogs, as seen in the west of Ireland, tend
to form from the slow infill of lakes where marginal plants slowly
decompose to slowly choke and absorb the water body. Sphagnum
moss gradually takes over, growing and dying back annually, with
new sphagnum mounting the rotting but partially preserved former
growth. Raised bogs or fen peat can be as much as ten metres deep,
many forming at the end of the last Ice Age around 8000 bce. Blanket
Language: English
AN ANTHOLOGY SELECTED BY
FLORENCE B. HYETT
Anonymous
THE LAMB CHILD
TAR high
Baby low:
’Twixt the two
Wise men go;
Find the baby,
Grasp the star—
Heirs of all things
Near and far!
George Macdonald
THE CHRISTMAS CHILD
George Macdonald
THE LAMB
William Blake
SONG
Eugene Field
THE HOLLY
He has beamed all the year, but bright scarlet he’ll glow
When the ground glitters white with the fresh fallen snow.
Edith King
CAROL
William Canton
SHEPHERD’S SONG
Old Song