Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Monarchies and the Great War 1st ed. Edition Matthew Glencross full chapter instant download
Monarchies and the Great War 1st ed. Edition Matthew Glencross full chapter instant download
Monarchies and the Great War 1st ed. Edition Matthew Glencross full chapter instant download
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-self-and-social-relations-1st-
ed-edition-matthew-whittingham/
https://ebookmass.com/product/sparta-and-the-commemoration-of-
war-matthew-a-sears/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-belgian-army-and-society-from-
independence-to-the-great-war-1st-edition-mario-draper/
https://ebookmass.com/product/war-crimes-causes-excuses-and-
blame-matthew-talbert/
Imagining Ithaca: Nostos and Nostalgia Since the Great
War Kathleen Riley
https://ebookmass.com/product/imagining-ithaca-nostos-and-
nostalgia-since-the-great-war-kathleen-riley/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-last-great-war-of-antiquity-
james-howard-johnston/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-day-the-great-war-
ended-24-july-1923-the-civilianization-of-war-jay-winter/
https://ebookmass.com/product/sovereignty-war-and-the-global-
state-1st-ed-edition-dylan-craig/
The American Press and the Cold War 1st ed. Edition
Oliver Elliott
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-american-press-and-the-cold-
war-1st-ed-edition-oliver-elliott/
PALGRAVE STUDIES IN MODERN MONARCHY
Monarchies
and the
Great War
Edited by
Matthew Glencross
and Judith Rowbotham
Palgrave Studies in Modern Monarchy
Series Editors
Axel Körner
University College London, UK
Heather Jones
London School of Economics, UK
Heidi Mehrkens
University of Aberdeen, UK
Monarchies
and the Great War
Editors
Matthew Glencross Judith Rowbotham
King’s College London Plymouth University
London, UK Plymouth, UK
Cover credit: King George V visiting Flanders, July 1917. © Historical Images Archive/
Alamy Stock Photo
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Acknowledgements
The editors would like to thank Her Majesty the Queen for her gra-
cious permission to quote material from the Royal Archives Windsor,
for which she holds the copyright, as would (in particular) Matthew
Glencross and Antony Best. The editors and contributors would also like
to thank all Royal Archives Staff for their help in accessing the material
held there. This material has helped to make two chapters in this volume
very robust.
Our gratitude goes out particularly to the late Professor Richard
Roberts (1950–2017), a staunch supporter of Matthew Glencross who
gave permission for the conference out of which this volume arose, to be
the 2014 summer conference of the Institute of Contemporary British
History, King’s College London. His masterly book, Saving the City: The
Great Financial Crisis of 1914 (2013), also helped to set the tone for our
approach. Without him, this volume is unlikely to have happened—we
have great sadness that he will not be able to see the end result, because
of his untimely death in December 2017. Our great thanks go also to
Dr. Michael Kandiah, for his constant and informed support both dur-
ing the conference and subsequently during the time that this volume
has emerged, and to Virginia Preston, also Department of Political
Economy, King’s College London, especially for her invaluable help with
the conference.
The editors would like to thank, in the UK, The National Archives,
Kew, The British Library, the National Library of Scotland, the Churchill
Archives Centre Cambridge, the Bodleian Library Oxford, the University
v
vi Acknowledgements
many who have no doubted helped them—we are certain that each of
our contributors will have long lists of friends and mentors from whom
they drew advice and support. The editors would also like to thank our
own families, colleagues and friends for putting up with endless talk
of the intricacies and nuances of monarchical relationships and courtly
etiquette. As we, the editors, know even better than the first time we
came together on an edited collection, achieving completion of a collec-
tion of this type is, in summary, a tribute to the contributors who have
responded to the challenge set for them so magnificently, and to the tol-
erance of both the editors’ and the contributors’ various family members,
scholars and the wide range of friends who have not given up on us, yet.
1 Introduction 1
Matthew Glencross, Judith Rowbotham
and Christopher Brennan
ix
x Contents
11 Epilogue 297
Judith Rowbotham and Matthew Glencross
Index 305
Notes on Contributors
xi
xii Notes on Contributors
Introduction
M. Glencross (*)
Department of Political Science, King’s College London, London, UK
e-mail: matthew.glencross@kcl.ac.uk
J. Rowbotham
Plymouth University, Plymouth, UK
e-mail: Judith.Rowbotham@Plymouth.ac.uk
C. Brennan
London School of Economics, London, UK
1 ‘Social Gossip’, Daily Mail, 26 July 1914. Princess Patricia of Connaught was the
younger daughter of Prince Arthur, Duke of Connaught (third son of Queen Victoria)
and his wife, Princess Luise Margarete of Prussia, Duchess of Connaught (known after her
marriage as Princess Louise Margaret). Born in 1886, she was 28 in 1914, and considered
beautiful and charming. A highly eligible Protestant princess, her possible marriage had
been for the previous decade a matter of speculation with a range of royal candidates being
mooted. She eventually married a commoner in 1919, at Westminster Abbey. (Admiral)
Alexander Ramsay had been her father’s aides-de-camp.
2 ‘Court Circular, 26 July’, The Times, 27 July 1914.
3 As Grand Admiral, Prince Heinrich was Commander of the Baltic Fleet from August
1914 until the conclusion of peace with Russia in 1918, after which he retired from
active duty, resigning entirely from the German Navy when his brother abdicated. See
F. W. Wile (1913) The Men Around the Kaiser (London: William Heinemann) p45 in par-
ticular. George V’s perception of Prince Heinrich as being a fellow naval officer, and so a
man he could deal with directly, explains why it was through Prince Heinrich that George
V sought to appeal to Wilhelm II as part of the last minute efforts to avoid war. See Marina
Soroka (2016) Britain, Russia and the Road to the First World War: The Fateful Embassy of
Count Aleksandr Benkendorff (1903–1916) (Abingdon: Routledge) pp253–4.
4 For instance, members of the Greek royal family, including the Crown Prince and the
Queen of the Hellenes, were amongst the royal personages in Britain in late July, expecting
to enjoy Cowes Week before departing (in their case) to resorts on the South of France.
See ‘Court Circular, 27 July’, The Times, 28 July 1914.
5 Comment was made on the delay Poincaré’s absence, along with that of his key min-
isters, had caused to diplomatic negotiations to resolve the ‘crisis’, see ‘The Prospects of
Intervention’, The Times, 28 July 1914.
1 INTRODUCTION 3
was the crisis in Ulster, rather than the one potentially engulfing Europe.6
Things changed in the last days of July and early August, as the danger
of a pan-European war was finally acknowledged. Consequently, not
only Poincaré but other eminent figures, including members of the var-
ious European royal families, felt forced to cancel engagements in order
to rush home.7 The Dowager Empress Marie of Russia had been stay-
ing with her sister, Queen Alexandra, at Marlborough House in London,
planning to spend August with her at Sandringham in Norfolk. Her last
minute return to Russia saw her forced to make a roundabout journey
through Denmark and Finland as her usual route via Berlin was blocked.8
In August 1914, European royals found themselves on opposing sides to
relatives who had been part of their social as well as formal diplomatic
circles in peacetime.9 This was far from unusual, of course, as an exami-
nation of the dynastic wars of the eighteenth century underline. But this
time, there was a difference.
6 Most senior figures still took weekend breaks, however. See, typically, ‘Ministers Leave
staying with the Queen Dowager, Alexandra, on 1 August, to return to Russia by train,
departing London Victoria on the afternoon’s boat train—the lateness of the departure
underlining the hopes of avoidance of war up to the last minute. See ‘The Empress Marie’s
Return’, The Times, 3 August 1914.
9 This split families, as in the example of Sweden, which remained officially neutral in the
Great War. Princess Margaret of Connaught had married Prince Gustav Adolf of Sweden
in 1905; as Crown Princess of Sweden, Princess Margarete (as she was known in Sweden)
was pro-British in her sympathies, while her parents-in-law, King Gustav V and his con-
sort, Queen Viktoria (born Princess Viktoria of Baden) were pro-German, leading to real
tensions within Swedish royal circles. See John Gilmour (2011) Sweden, the Swastika and
Stalin: The Swedish Experience in the Second World War (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press) p8.
4 M. GLENCROSS ET AL.
what monarchs should and could do, and the implications of that for the
monarchic style of government. Using the First World War as the frame,
the case studies in this collection explore the pressure that war placed
upon individual monarchies, the public reactions to their performances,
and how these do (or do not) relate to the survival or collapse of the bel-
ligerent monarchies involved. What was, we believe, different about the
events of July to September 1914 was the fact that, as the opening para-
graphs to this Introduction underline, there was, as late as the last week
of July, no expectation of war on a pan-European (let alone global) scale.
Apart from anything else, this meant that monarchs and their families
(including sisters, cousins and aunts who might be married into families
who would turn out to be on the opposing side) were, to a considera-
ble extent, taken by surprise by the late summer escalation of tensions.
Consequently, rulers and their relations had to react to the rapidly devel-
oping crisis on, essentially, a ‘spur-of-the-moment’ basis, including when
engaging their subjects in what they felt to be an appropriate reaction
to this suddenly looming major conflict. In Britain, for instance, news-
papers reported that, according to an announcement by the Prime
Minister, George V had been in contact with Tsar Nicholas II and Kaiser
Wilhelm II to try to resolve the crisis—but until after the formal decla-
ration of war, the constitutionally conscious King’s main positive public
initiative (besides cancelling attendance at Goodwood Races and Cowes
Week) was to organise a day of prayer on Sunday 2 August, in which
he took the lead.10 As this volume reveals, the intricacies of monarchi-
cal reactions to the imminent conflict depended heavily upon their char-
acter and the political framework in which they operated. The majority
of case studies included here focus on European examples, but not
exclusively—the Ottoman Empire is also considered, as is Japan, as part
of the process of exploring the impact and implications of modern war-
fare for the institution of monarchy throughout the twentieth century,
and the extent to which there are common threads across those states
possessing a monarchical form of government. In the Ottoman Empire,
for example, Palabıyık argues that, as with Britain, it was the politicians
(what he describes as the ‘ruling triumvirate’) who made the decision
10 The Archbishop of Canterbury led the public service attended by the King, and it was
widely reported that George V had set this national example. See ‘A Nation at Prayer’, The
Times, 3 August 1914.
1 INTRODUCTION 5
that the Empire could not be neutral and had to choose a side.11 Did
this make the institution of monarchy substantially irrelevant in either
of these two imperial states, foreshadowing a further diminution in the
power of the one, and the disappearance of the other as a feature of the
post-war political landscape? We argue that, rather than showing that
monarchy was no longer a robust institution, unsuitable for the world
that emerged from the chaos of the Great War, this volume illustrates
the complexity of choices that were made in a post-war world. Further,
that a serious consideration of the institution of monarchy, accompanied
by positive assessments of its performance within particular states, needs
to be intrinsic to both micro, or individual state, histories of the war and
the more macro global assessments of its impact.
‘Civil-Military Relations’; Richard Bessell ‘Revolution’, in Ibid., Vol II: The State.
6 M. GLENCROSS ET AL.
14 See for example Robert Service (2017) The Last of the Tsars: Nicholas II and the
Russian Revolution (London: Pan Macmillan); John Van der Kiste (1999) Kaiser
Wilhelm II: Germany’s Last Emperor (Stroud: Sutton Publishing).
15 Key works in English on this theme include: Dominic Lieven (2016) Towards the
Flame: Empire, War and the End of Tsarist Russia (London: Penguin Books); Dominic
Lieven (2016) The End of Tsarist Russia: The March to World War I and Revolution
(London: Penguin Books); Dominic Lieven (1993) Nicholas II: Emperor of All the Russias
(London: John Murray, 1993); John Röhl (1994) The Kaiser and His Court: Wilhelm II
and the Government of Germany (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press); John Röhl
(2004) Wilhelm II: the Kaiser’s Personal Monarchy, 1888–1900 (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press); John Röhl (2014) Wilhelm II: Into Abyss of War and Exile, 1900–1941
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
16 Lieven, Towards the Flame, Chapter 5.
1 INTRODUCTION 7
of more general works on German history, including most notably Jonathan Petropoulos
(2008) The Royals and the Reich: The Princes von Hessen in Nazi Germany (Oxford: Oxford
University Press). See also Jonathan Boff (2018) Haig’s Enemy. Crown Prince Rupprecht and
Germany’s War on the Western Front (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
6 large apples
3 eggs
6 table-spoons powdered sugar
1 pint milk
Pare and core the apples. Fill the centre of each with sugar and
bake, being careful that they do not break. Or they can be stewed
whole.
Make a custard (see p. 15) of the yolks, milk and half the sugar.
Pour it over the apples, which should be arranged in a dish. Bake
slowly until the custard is firm. Whip the whites till frothy. Add the rest
of the sugar gradually, and beat well together. Spread this over the
custard, and put in a moderate oven. Remove directly the meringue
is browned.
*Cherry Pudding
4 eggs
1 pint milk
2 table-spoons of flour
Cherries
Sugar
Stone enough cherries to fill a basin, which must be well buttered.
Add sufficient sugar to sweeten well. Make a smooth batter of the
well-beaten eggs, flour and milk. Pour it over the cherries, filling the
basin. Cover with a cloth, and boil one and a half hours. Serve with a
fruit sauce.
Fig Pudding
Friar’s Omelet
Apples
3 eggs
1 cup sugar
Juice of half a lemon
Bread crumbs
Steam several sour apples. Mash them and then drain them until
quite dry. Take one pint of this pulp, and when cool add to it the three
well-beaten yolks, the sugar, lemon juice, and the whites beaten to a
stiff froth. Brown some very fine bread crumbs in a little butter.
Sprinkle the bottom and sides of a well-buttered pudding dish with
them. Pour in the mixture. Cover with bread crumbs. Bake twenty
minutes. Serve with brown sugar and cream.
*Gooseberry Pudding
3 cups gooseberries
³⁄₄ lb. butter
³⁄₄ lb. powdered sugar
8 eggs
4 sponge-fingers
Stew the gooseberries in water until tender. Do not let them break.
Take them out and drain. Then put them through a fine sieve.
Beat the butter to a cream. Add the sugar and beat again. Stir in
the gooseberry pulp, the well-beaten eggs and the sponge-fingers
finely crushed. Mix well and bake in a pudding dish for thirty minutes.
Ginger Pudding
*Italian Mousse
12 yolks
4 wine glasses Madeira or light white wine
6 ozs. powdered sugar
A pinch of powdered cinnamon
A little lemon juice
Beat well together. Pour into an enamelled sauce-pan and stand it
in a larger vessel containing hot water. Beat continually with a whisk
until the mixture froths and rises. Serve immediately in glasses.
Marmalade Pudding
2 eggs
Their weight in flour, butter and powdered sugar
1 table-spoon marmalade
1 tea-spoon baking-powder
Sift the flour and baking-powder together. Beat the butter to a
cream. Add the sugar and beat again. Add the flour, marmalade and
well-beaten yolks. Beat the whites to a stiff froth and add them last.
Pour into a buttered basin and steam for an hour and a half. Turn out
and spread with a little marmalade. Serve with a sweet sauce.
Mousse à la Mangara
Palace Pudding
Plum Pudding
*Strawberry Shortcake
Banana Sauce
1 cup water
4 table-spoons powdered sugar
4 bananas
1 dessert-spoon maraschino or
1 wine-glass of wine
Put the water and sugar in a sauce-pan and stir until the sugar is
dissolved. Add four bananas which have been mashed with a silver
fork. Boil for two minutes. Put through a sieve, and add the wine or
maraschino.
Chocolate Sauce
Foam Sauce
Fruit Sauce
1 cup juice of fresh or stewed fruit
1 tea-spoon arrowroot
¹⁄₂ cup powdered sugar
Let the juice boil, add gradually the arrowroot (which must be
smoothly mixed with a very little water), and boil for five minutes.
Strain.
If jam is used, half a cup will be sufficient. It should first be well
beaten and then passed through a sieve. Half a cup of water should
be added to it, and less sugar will be required.
Golden Sauce
4 ozs. butter
¹⁄₂ cup powdered sugar
Yolks of 2 eggs
1 table-spoon boiling water
Juice of ¹⁄₂ a lemon
Wine-glass of wine or brandy
Beat sugar and butter together until creamy. Put the bowl in hot
water and stir until liquid. Add the well-beaten yolks and hot water,
and stir until the mixture thickens. Add lemon juice and wine. Beat
well together.
Hard Sauce
2 ozs. butter
2 ozs. castor sugar
¹⁄₂ tea-spoon vanilla
1 table-spoon brandy
Beat the butter to a cream. Add the sugar gradually. Beat well.
Then add the brandy, a very little at a time. Pile the sauce lightly on a
dish and keep it on ice until required. This sauce is excellent with
plum puddings.
Jelly Sauce
Lemon Sauce
Grated rind and juice of a lemon
1 cup powdered sugar
3 tea-spoons cornflour
1 pint hot water
Boil the water and sugar together for five minutes. Mix the
cornflour in a cup with a little water until it is perfectly smooth, and
then add it gradually to the syrup, stirring quickly all the time. Let it all
boil again for ten minutes. Add the grated rind and juice of the
lemon. Strain.
Melted Butter
2 table-spoons butter
2 tea-spoons flour
1¹⁄₂ cups of hot water (or water and milk)
1 cup brown or powdered sugar
Flavouring
Melt the butter in a saucepan, being careful not to brown it. Add
the flour and mix until quite smooth. Then add the hot water (or milk
and water) gradually, stirring well all the time, and when it boils add
the sugar. Stir continually for five minutes. Remove from the fire and
add a small half tea-spoonful of vanilla or a little nutmeg if milk has
been used, but two tea-spoonfuls of fresh lemon juice, if it has been
made with water.
Sabaillon
The yolks of 4 eggs
1¹⁄₂ wine-glasses madeira or sherry
4 table-spoons castor sugar
A little cinnamon
This can be made in two ways.
I. Put eggs, wine and sugar into a saucepan on a good fire. Beat
continually until the mixture thickens. It must not boil.
OR,
II. Beat eggs and sugar very thoroughly together for five minutes.
Then add the wine. Put into an earthenware pot and stand this in a
large saucepan of very hot water. Beat over the fire until the mixture
thickens.
Wine Sauce—I
Wine Sauce—II
1 cup white wine
Yolks of 4 eggs
1 tea-spoon lemon juice
The rind of ¹⁄₄ of a lemon
Heat the wine, sugar, lemon juice and peel. Beat the yolks
thoroughly in a large basin. Directly the wine comes to the boil, pour
it over the yolks. Beat with an egg-whisk until very frothy.
Jellies
PAGE
Calf’s Foot Jelly 91
Gelatine Jelly 91
Claret Jelly 92
Cranberry Jelly 92
Gelée Fouettée 93
Lemon Froth 93
Maraschino Jelly 94
Orange Baskets 94
Orange Jelly 94
Prune Jelly 95
Rhubarb Jelly 95
General Instructions
It has been found difficult in the receipts which follow, owing to the
variation of the quantity of juice in lemons, etc., to give the exact
quantity of gelatine required. A safe rule in making jellies is to use 2
ozs. of gelatine to every one and three-quarter quarts of liquid. In
summer 2 ozs. of gelatine will be needed to each quart and a half.
(This must include all liquid flavourings and be very carefully
measured.)
The best gelatine is now so pure, that it is practically unnecessary
to go to the trouble of making jelly from calf’s feet, a receipt for which
has, however, been given.
More elaborate jellies are made by the addition of fruit. To do this,
pour jelly into a mould to the depth of half an inch. When set,
arrange on it a layer of perfectly fresh ripe fruit—strawberries,
cherries, grapes, pine-apple, peaches, oranges, etc.—adding
another layer of jelly, and when that is set, more fruit, and so on, until
the mould is full. During the process the mould should be kept on
ice, so that the jelly will set quickly.
Before putting jelly into a mould, dip it in very cold water, and
invert for a moment. Pour in the jelly while still wet.
Use a silver or wooden spoon for stirring, and do not stir jelly while
it is cooling.
To colour jelly pink, add a few drops of cochineal.
To loosen the jelly when ready to serve, dip the mould quickly into
hot water. Dry the mould before turning out.
Cranberry Jelly
Stew some cranberries in plenty of water until they are soft. Rub
them through a sieve. Put the pulp into an enamelled saucepan.
When it boils add sugar in the proportion of one pound to every pint
of pulp. Stir continually for a few minutes and pour into a mould.
*Claret Jelly
1 bottle claret
1 lemon
1 gill red currant jelly
¹⁄₂ lb. loaf sugar
A little over 1 oz. isinglass
1 gill brandy
Soak the gelatine in a very little water. Add it to the claret with the
juice and rind of the lemon, jelly, the crushed loaf sugar and brandy.
Boil altogether for five minutes. Put once through a jelly bag. Dip a
mould with a hollow centre into cold water. Pour in the jelly. Serve
with whipped cream in the centre of the mould. Instead of claret and
red currant jelly, a white wine and quince jelly can be used.
*Gelée Fouettée
*Lemon Froth
1 oz. gelatine
¹⁄₂ pint boiling water
¹⁄₂ pint cold water
3 lemons
6 ozs. lump sugar
Whites of 6 eggs
Dissolve the gelatine and sugar in the boiling water with the finely-
pared lemon peel. Add the cold water and the juice of the lemons.
Skim with a silver spoon. Strain into a large basin. When beginning
to set, add the whites beaten to a stiff froth. Beat well together and
pile up in a glass dish. Serve with sweetened whipped cream.
Maraschino Jelly