Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Private Print Media, the State and Politics in Colonial and Post-Colonial Zimbabwe 1st Edition Sylvester Dombo (Auth.) full chapter instant download
Private Print Media, the State and Politics in Colonial and Post-Colonial Zimbabwe 1st Edition Sylvester Dombo (Auth.) full chapter instant download
Private Print Media, the State and Politics in Colonial and Post-Colonial Zimbabwe 1st Edition Sylvester Dombo (Auth.) full chapter instant download
https://ebookmass.com/product/colonial-terror-torture-and-state-
violence-in-colonial-india-deana-heath/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-portuguese-escudo-monetary-
zone-its-impact-in-colonial-and-post-colonial-africa-1st-ed-
edition-maria-eugenia-mata/
https://ebookmass.com/product/language-as-identity-in-colonial-
india-policies-and-politics-1st-edition-papia-sengupta-auth/
https://ebookmass.com/product/explaining-foreign-policy-in-post-
colonial-africa-stephen-m-magu/
Planned Violence: Post/Colonial Urban Infrastructure,
Literature and Culture 1st ed. Edition Elleke Boehmer
https://ebookmass.com/product/planned-violence-post-colonial-
urban-infrastructure-literature-and-culture-1st-ed-edition-
elleke-boehmer/
https://ebookmass.com/product/scottish-presbyterianism-and-
settler-colonial-politics-empire-of-dissent-1st-edition-valerie-
wallace-auth/
https://ebookmass.com/product/social-media-and-digital-
dissidence-in-zimbabwe-trust-matsilele/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-rule-of-law-and-emergency-in-
colonial-india-judicial-politics-in-the-early-nineteenth-
century-1st-ed-2021-edition-inagaki/
https://ebookmass.com/product/love-and-revolution-in-the-
twentieth-century-colonial-and-postcolonial-world-1st-edition-g-
arunima/
Private Print
Media,
Colonial and
Post-Colonial Zimbabwe
SYLVESTER DOMBO
Private Print Media, the State and Politics in
Colonial and Post-Colonial Zimbabwe
Sylvester Dombo
vii
Preface
ix
x Preface
However, the power of the fourth estate can be easily diluted and weak-
ened by several factors ranging from legislations such as the Access to
Information and Protection of Privacy Act (AIPPA), which hamstrung
the operation of journalists and the private media in Zimbabwe. My
argument is that the ZANU PF government, much like the colonial
government, has continued to control the public media and when chal-
lenged, its representatives quickly used their majority in the legislature to
come up with laws that entrenched their rule and muzzled the press.
But the closure of the daily newspapers in both epochs, though
disastrous, allowed for the growth of a vibrant underground media that
continued to challenge authorities. Such underground media in both
instances continued to provide information as well as to act as a check
on the excesses of the governments of the day. They provided a differ-
ent challenge to the authorities as they couldn’t be shut down like the
African Daily News and the Daily News. To me this shows that the
newspapers are not a weak force in politics. Because of their malignant
influences, the authorities are always wary of an independent and vibrant
press of the calibre of the African Daily News and the Daily News.
This study was made possible by partial funding I received from the
Council for the Development of Social Science Research in Africa
(CODESRIA) through a small grant I received for a thesis writing
competition. I also acknowledge the Ph.D. bursary I received from the
School of Social Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal that enabled me
to carry out fieldwork in Zimbabwe.
I also recognise the support I received from many people, whose
input went a long way towards making this thesis a success. First and
foremost I appreciate the unending support and encouragement I got
from my Ph.D. supervisor, Thembisa Waetjen. She kept checking on the
status of the project. To you I say it is finally done!
I would like to thank Dr. Joseph Mujere for encouraging me to
pursue this topic. The journey started in his “dungeon” at the University
of Edinburgh in 2010, where he encouraged me to enroll for a Ph.D.
Since then he has been my mentor and friend, and I would like to thank
him for the “open heart surgery” that he taught me when things were
not going particularly well for me.
Finally I would like to extend my gratitude to my family for the s tanding
by me, especially Donald Dombo and his family, and all my brothers and
sisters for their prayers and all kinds of support. Special mention goes also
to my DP Evangelist “Masvosve” Kandemiri for your prayers and belief
in me. Last but not least I would also want to thank my wife, Shylet, our
lovely daughter, Cassandra Jahdiel Dombo, and the man of the house,
Takunda Dombo, for all the support and comfort. Be blessed.
xiii
Contents
1 Introduction 1
xv
xvi Contents
References 259
Index 275
Abbreviations
xvii
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
This book takes a look at the lives, experiences and times of two privately
owned daily newspapers in a southern African country to judge the rela-
tionship between the state and the private press in two different periods
of political crisis. It focuses on the interface between the state and the
private owned newspapers in colonial Rhodesia and post-independence
Zimbabwe: the African Daily News (1956–1964) and the Daily News
(1999–2003) respectively. The historical account presented helps to
explain the lack of trust and a continued enmity between the state and
the independent press, especially in situations where state legitimacy
is questioned. It discusses the challenges of operating an independent
press in a restrictive environment under both colonial and post-colonial
regimes. Such challenges are, in the case of the African Daily News and
the Daily News, closely related to the democratic aspirations of the coun-
try’s citizens. Broadly, this book analyses what happens to a newspaper
when it resists and opposes state power, as well as the reasons behind
such opposition, and what happens to state power when it suppresses
the voice of the fourth estate. Such a study helps to round out histori-
cal understandings of the struggle for democracy in Southern Rhodesia/
Zimbabwe before and after independence respectively, and helps our
understanding of how the media shapes and is shaped by the struggle.
The two dailies, belonging to two distinct historical epochs, with seem-
ingly differing aspirations, and operating with different business mod-
els and ownership structures, share the same fate: They got into serious
troubles with the state which culminated in their closures.
Note
1 Amanda Hammer and Brian Raftopoulos, Zimbabwe’s Unfinished Business:
Rethinking Land, State and Nation in the Context of Crisis, Weaver Press,
Harare, 2003.
CHAPTER 2
Introduction
This chapter maps out a history of the private press in colonial Rhodesia.
It does this by identifying and elaborating four different phases and
domains of activity in the development of the African press. The first
phase was dominated by missionary press and a few newspapers the
colonial government established. The second phase is contextualized
by events in South Africa and was shaped by how major benefactors,
Bertram and Cedric Paver, became involved in the press in Rhodesia
by buying off government stake in early newspapers for Africans. I dis-
cuss their ideological groundings and modus operandi in South Africa,
and how this influenced the organisation they were to run in Southern
Rhodesia. The third phase focuses on the birth of African newspapers in
Rhodesia in 1936, when the Paver Brothers purchased the weekly Native
Mirror and renamed it the Bantu Mirror. This phase is important as it
offers a rich background to the financiers of the newspapers, the political
temperatures obtaining in the country that in the long run had a bear-
ing on the performance of the Central African Daily News. Finally, the
fourth phase identifies key personalities who helped transform African
newspapers into a force with which to be reckoned. Prominent figures
include the Paver brothers, journalists and editors like Lawrence Vambe,
Jaspar Savanhu, Nathan Shamuyarira and Bill Saidi. These African jour-
nalists would, in a later period, also be vital agents in the country’s strug-
gle for independence. How they shaped and were themselves shaped by
Only Europeans knew what was in the ‘best interests’ of Africans, and so
it was essential that Europeans should monitor gradual African progress
based on a racially differentiated educational policy which placed ‘empha-
sis’ on what Europeans felt was most suitable for a ‘primitive people’.5
It is within this context that the drive to provide newspapers for Africans
was made. It also allowed the government to be in cahoots with the
missionaries to determine what content was suitable for the Africans.
Following the recommendations of the Phelps-Stokes Commission, the
DRC in 1926 formed a semi-secular press called the Rhodesia Native
Quarterly, then Mashonaland Quarterly and later Rhodesia Quarterly.
According to Diana Jeater, the main purpose of the Quarterly was to
provide reading material for converts, but more importantly, to help mis-
sions move toward a standardisation of the vernaculars.6 The govern-
ment, through the Department of Native Education, commissioned the
DRC to produce this newspaper for Africans. Under the arrangement
the government paid a grant of 25 pounds, which would cover the total
costs of publishing each issue, while mission personnel carried on the
business of editing and printing the paper.7
As far as the content of the Quarterly was concerned, Jeater notes
that the newspaper represented an alliance between missionaries and
government officials as a means of communicating state policy to liter-
ate Africans.8 Contributors were therefore predominantly of European
descent whilst the voice allowed to African contributors was very limited.
Thus, the newspaper served its instrumental role of making things easier
for employers and administrators. For example, many pieces were con-
tributed by Emory Alvord, the agricultural editor of the Quarterly, who
made regular contributions in English and Chindau, providing detailed
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
Poniatowski (in Lander’s Imaginary Conversations), x. 250.
Ponsonby, John, xi. 471.
Pont Beau-Voisin (a town), ix. 185.
—— Neuf, The, ix. 156.
Ponte, Jacopo da. See Bassano, Il.
Pontius Pilate, vii. 36.
Pool of Bethesda (Hogarth’s), viii. 147; xii. 367.
Poole, Miss, viii. 240, 244.
—— Tom, xii. 272.
Poor Gentleman, The (George Colman, the younger), viii. 319; xi.
375.
—— Robin (Franklin’s), x. 314.
—— Susan (Wordsworth’s), v. 156.
Pope, Lord Byron, and Mr Bowles, xi. 486.
—— Alexander, v. 68;
also referred to in i. 8, 18 n., 26, 39, 40–1, 56, 71, 80, 138, 162, 171,
176, 318, 324, 380, 399; ii. 79, 166, 199, 370, 397; iii. 46–7, 408,
416, 424; iv. 259, 277, 309, 350, 356, 359, 365; v. 8, 13, 32, 43,
45, 61, 63, 79, 88, 92, 98, 100, 104, 119, 125, 161, 369, 373, 374,
375; vi. 30, 195, 204 n., 210, 222, 223, 250, 336, 351, 359, 363,
367, 413, 414, 440, 444, 454, 464; vii. 6 n., 24, 36, 40, 93, 102,
103, 105, 124, 168, 203, 206, 209, 226, 234, 290, 303, 363, 380;
viii. 14, 18, 24, 29, 30, 53, 62, 79, 93, 96, 134, 152, 158, 160, 273,
359, 401, 416, 555; ix. 37, 76, 233, 391; x. 77, 108, 134, 155, 161,
172, 204, 232, 250, 375, 416; xi. 233, 240, 256, 272, 275, 375,
430, 436, 457, 486, 606; xii. 31, 32, 50, 78, 154 n., 207, 208,
245, 251, 273, 375, 388.
Pope was a Poet, On the Question Whether, xi. 430.
—— Anecdotes of (Spence’s), vi. 30; vii. 209; xi. 498.
—— Alexander (actor), viii. 224, 249, 250, 264, 272, 301, 302, 403,
465; xi. 399.
—— Mrs Elizabeth, viii. 515.
—— Miss, viii. 389; xi. 367; xii. 24.
Popular Opinion, On the Causes of, xii. 316.
Population, Essay on (Malthus’s), iv. 288.
—— Extracts from the Essay on, with a Commentary and Notes, iv.
105.
—— On General Tendency of, to Excess, iv. 26.
—— Principle of, as affecting Schemes of Utopian Improvement, iii.
367; iv. 18.
—— The Principle of, whether Vice and Misery are the necessary
Consequences of, and the only checks to, iv. 52.
—— Queries Relating to the Essay on, iii. 381.
Porchester, Lord, xi. 386.
Pordenone (Giovanni Antonio Licinio of), ix. 34, 35.
Porlier, General, iii. 119.
Porlock, x. 416.
Porretta, Jeronymo della, ix. 59.
Porridge Island, ii. 90.
Porson (Richard), ii. 169, 176; iv. 233; vi. 73, 199, 208; vii. 198; viii.
17; x. 214, 244; xi. 288; xii. 75.
Porteous (Scott’s Heart of Midlothian), iv. 248.
Port Royal Logic, The (Anthony Arnaud’s), xi. 289.
Porta di Popolo, vi. 379.
Portalis, Jean Étienne Marie, xi. 123.
Porter, Miss Jane, x. 296.
—— Walsh, ix. 13, 65.
Portia (Shakespeare’s Julius Cæsar), i. 198.
—— (in Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice), i. 391; iv. 260; viii. 180.
Portland, Duke of (D—— P——, the), ii. 169, 216.
—— Place, vi. 235; ix. 158, 479.
Portman Square, vii. 68; ix. 158; xi. 385.
Portrait (by S. del Piombo), xi. 238.
—— of an English Lady, On a (by Vandyke), vii. 280.
—— of a Female (Rembrandt’s), ix. 50.
—— of a Lady (Maratti’s), ix. 21.
—— of a Man (Leonardo da Vinci’s), ix. 26.
—— of the Prince of the Austurias (Velasquez’s), ix. 23.
—— of a Youth (Gainsborough’s), xi. 202.
—— of a Youth (Parmegiano’s), ix. 41.
Portsmouth, ii. 85, 185.
—— Duchess of (Lely’s), ix. 38.
Portugal, iii. 216, 228.
Posa, Marquis of (in Schiller’s Don Carlos), ii. 178.
Possessed Boy (Domenichino’s), xii. 367.
Posthumous Fame, On; Whether Shakespeare was Influenced by a
Love of it, i. 21.
Posthumus (in Shakespeare’s Cymbeline), viii. 539; xi. 291, 293.
Pot of Basil, The Story of the (Boccacio’s), i. 163; xi. 517.
Poticary, The (in Heywood’s Four P’s), v. 274, 276.
Potier, Charles, ix. 153.
Potter, Paul, ii. 187; ix. 63, 301.
—— Robert, xi. 284.
Poulterer’s Shop (G. Dou’s), ix. 355.
Poure Persone (Chaucer’s), v. 24.
Poussin, Gaspar, ii. 318; vi. 15; ix. 14, 35, 51, 239; x. 278, 300; xi. 17;
xii. 272.
(See also references under Nicholas Poussin.)
—— Lines on a picture of (Southey’s), v. 164.
—— Nicholas, i. 149, 163; iv. 277; v. 38, 98; vi. 74, 171, 173 n., 174; vii.
103, 291–2; viii. 314; ix. 7, 13–4, 24, 30, 36, 51, 59, 72, 107–10 n.,
113, 128, 133, 232, 237, 311, 323, 384, 387, 389, 393, 409, 473, 477;
x. 77, 192, 278, 281, 303; xi. 188, 191, 197, 199, 200–1 n., 240 n.,
242, 543; xii. 189, 207.
—— On a Landscape of Nicholas, vi. 168.
Pontoppidan, Eric, ii. 252.
Povey, Miss, viii. 460.
Powel, Mr (an Oxonian), ii. 196.
Powell, William, viii. 280, 286; ix. 149.
—— Mr (a racket player), vi. 88, 89, 286, 451.
Power, Tyrone, xi. 381.
Pozzo Borgo (a town), ix. 227.
Practice of Piety (Lewis Bayly’s), iii. 111; xi. 254.
Pradere (a musician), ii. 234.
Præfatio ad Bellendenum (Parr’s), ii. 196.
Prague, viii. 363.
Pratt, Charles (Earl Camden), iii. 418.
—— Sir John, iii. 418.
—— Samuel Jackson, xi. 460.
Pratt’s Hotel, Dieppe, ix. 92.
Praxiteles, ix. 237; x. 341, 343.
Preaux, Guillaume de, x. 54.
Predominant Principles and Excitements of the Human Mind, On
the, xi. 258.
Preface to an Abridgment of Abraham Tucker’s Light of Nature
Pursued, iv. 369.
Prefaces, Dryden’s, vi. 217.
Prejudice, On, xii. 391–6.
Presbyterians, viii. 62, 66; x. 362 n.; xi. 420.
Present Discontents (Burke’s), iii. 421.
Presentation in the Temple, The, (Guido’s), vii. 283, 292; ix. 111.
Press, The—Coleridge, Southey, Wordsworth, and Bentham, xi. 411.
Press-yard, iv. 195.
Prestor John, iii. 142.
Pretender, iii. 117, 408; x. 377; xii. 31.
Priam, xii. 155.
Price, Mrs, ii. 228.
Price, Dr Richard, iii. 225, 401; iv. 9 n.; xii. 358, 359, 405.
Pride (in Spenser), v. 39.
Prideaux, Humphrey, vi. 76, 476.
Priestley, Dr Joseph, xii. 357;
also referred to in i. 49 n.; ii. 415; iii. 225; iv. 216; vii. 445–6; x.
315, 316; xi. 53, 54, 65, 66, 70, 72, 472 n., 579; xii. 405.
Primrose, Dr (Goldsmith’s Vicar of Wakefield), v. 119.
Primrose-hill, vii. 66; viii. 463; ix. 158, 336.
Prince and The Pretender; or, The Year 1745 (a short play), xi. 387.
—— Arthur (in Spenser), v. 35; x. 74.
—— Athanase, a Fragment (Shelley’s), x. 267.
—— Maurice’s Parrot, iii. 101;
also referred to in vi. 284.
—— of Painters, The (Parrhasius), i. 162; vii. 61.
—— Prettyman (in Duke of Buckingham’s Rehearsal), vii. 205.
—— Regent, The, i. 416; iii. 218; ix. 479.
—— Regent leading a Horse (Gainsborough’s), xi. 203.
—— of Wales, The (passage boat), ii. 242.
Prince’s Street, ii. 314; ix. 324.
Princess of Cleves, The (Madame de la Fayette), xii. 62, 169.
—— of Arragon, A (Raphael’s), vii. 287.
Principia (Newton’s), ii. 379; iii. 141; xii. 26, 279, 402.
Principle of Population as affecting the Schemes of Utopian
Improvement, On the, iii. 367.
Prior, Matthew, i. 80; iv. 359; v. 83, 104, 106–7, 369, 373; viii. 56.
—— Aymer (in play from Scott’s Ivanhoe), viii. 410.
Prioress, The (in Chaucer), v. 32, 82.
Pripscovius, iii. 266.
Priscilla, Tomboy (in The Romp), viii. 539.
Prison Thoughts (Dodd’s), xii. 348.
Pritchard, Mrs, i. 157; vi. 275; xii. 33.
Prize, The (Prince Hoare’s), i. 155; viii. 230, 388, 416.
Procession of the Passions, The (Spenser’s), v. 35, 39, 40.
Proclus, iv. 217; x. 145; xii. 164 n.
Procrastination, Lines on (Young), v. 114.
Procrustes, i. 176; iv. 374 n.; v. 150.
Prodigal Son, The, v. 184.
Progress of Finance, xi. p. vii.
Project for a New Theory of Civil and Criminal Legislation, xii. 405.
Prologue in Heaven, The (Shelley’s, from Goethe), x. 271.
Prometheus, vi. 424; ix. 135; xii. 222.
—— The picture of (Salvator’s), x. 283, 296.
—— (Æschylus’s), iv. 216; v. 64; viii. 420; x. 93; xii. 347.
—— (Titian’s), ix. 273.
—— Unbound (Shelley’s), vi. 148.
Promissory Note, The (a play), viii. 464.
Prophet Ezra (Hayter’s), xi. 245.
—— Samuel (Reynolds’s), ix. 24.
Prophets and Sybils (Michael Angelo’s), ix. 241, 366.
Prose-Style of Poets, On the, vii. 5.
Proserpine (a frigate), ii. 227.
Prospects of Mankind, Nature, and Providence (Wallace’s), iv. 291.
Prospero (Shakespeare’s Tempest), i. 245, 346; iv. 202; v. 48, 187;
vii. 213; viii. 235, 236; xi. 119, 417, 451.
Proteus, iii. 325.
—— (Shakespeare’s Two Gentlemen of Verona), i. 319.
—— (Spenser), v. 38.
Provençal Poetry, x. 46 et seq.
Provence, viii. 126; ix. 182.
Provincial Letters (Pascal’s), xii. 169.
Provoked Husband, The; or Journey to London (Vanbrugh’s), vi. 15,
414, 444, 453.
—— Wife, The (Vanbrugh’s), viii. 79, 81, 83.
Prussia, iii. 68, 71; xi. 333.
—— King of, ii. 185; iii. 106.
Psalmanazar, George, vii. 198.
Psalmody (Arnold’s), ii. 44, 50, 54.
Psalms, The, vi. 392; xi. 489.
Psyche (in Apuleius’s Golden Ass), vi. 201.
Public Opinion, On, xii. 311.
Pucelle (Voltaire’s), i. 292.
Puck (in Shakespeare’s Midsummer Night’s Dream), i. 241, 424; v.
53.
—— ix. 177.
—— (Reynolds’s), ix. 329, 400.
Puff (a horse), ii. 39, 40.
Puffendorf, Samuel, Baron von, iv. 283; vi. 76; xii. 378.
Pugh, Mr (a surgeon), ii. 225.
Pulci, Luigi, x. 69.
Pulpit Oratory—Dr Chalmers and Mr Irving, xii. 275.
Pulteney, Sir William (Earl of Bath), iii. 389, 410, 412, 465; vi. 449.
—— Sir William Johnstone (Plug Pulteney), ii. 217; iv. 2 n., 298.
Punch and the Puppet Show, ii. 396; vii. 25; xii. 17, 205, 353.
Punishment of Death, On the, xii. 466.
Purcell, Henry, ii. 176; iii. 311; v. 384.
Purgatorio (Dante’s), ix. 251; x. 63.
Purgatory (Salvator’s), x. 297.
Puritans, i. 49; viii. 54; x. 356.
—— History of the (Neale’s), iii. 265; iv. 217; xi. 443.
—— The, or Widow of Watling Street, i. 356; v. 289.
Purley, Diversions of, On (Tooke’s), xi. 119.
Purple Island (P. Fletcher’s), v. 311.
Putney Bridge, viii. 201 n.
Pye, Henry James, iii. 109, 113, 258; viii. 160.
Pygmalion (fable of), ii. 400; ix. 222; xi. 241.
Pym, John, iii. 394; iv. 61; vii. 320.
Pyne, Mr (singer), viii. 240, 244, 301.
Pyramids, The, i. 110; iii. 246; vi. 188; vii. 255; ix. 350.
Pyrochles, The Shipwreck of (in Sir P. Sidney’s Arcadia), v. 323.
Pyrrhus, xii. 204.
—— (in Phillips’s Distressed Mother), viii. 334.
—— (referred to in Shakespeare’s Hamlet), xi. 395.
Pythagoras, iv. 37, 384; vii. 243; x. 338; xi. 491.
Q.
B.
Babylon, by the waters of, vii. 122.
Back and side, go bare, go bare, Both foot and hand go cold, etc., v.
288.
bade the lovely scenes at distance hail, And, vii. 304.
Bailey, that unfortunate Miss, iii. 160.
balsam of fierabras, xi. 304.
bambouzled and bit, iii. 156.
bane and antidote, its, iv. 8; xi. 524
Bann’d be those hours when ’mongst the learned throng, etc., v.
283.
barbarous kings, iii. 111.
bard whose soul is meek as dawning day, i. 429.
bared his swelling heart, iii. 338.
bare trees and mountains bare, the, etc., i. 113; iii. 168; v. 163.
ball of dazzling fire, xii. 342.
base cullionly fellow, xii. 285.
Be every day of your long life like this, etc., viii. 75.
Be mine to read eternal new romances of Marivaux and Crebillon,
v. 118; viii. 106; x. 25; xi. 333.
Be niggards of advice on no pretence, etc., v. 75.
Be silent always, when you doubt your sense, etc., v. 75.
Be to her faults a little blind, etc., iii. 217.
Be wise to-day; ’tis madness to defer, etc., v. 114.
beaker full of the warm South, Oh for a, etc., ix. 174.
bear a charmed life, xii. 151.
Bear thou that great Eliza in thy mind, etc., iii. 112, 278.
beautiful is vanished, and returns not, the, etc., vi. 186; xii. 293.
Beautiful mask! etc., xii. 321.
beauty and grandeur of the art, The whole, etc., vi. 134.
beauty, By their own, etc., x. 349.
beauty in creatures of the same species, etc., vi. 137.
Beauty, Love, and Truth lie here, etc., ii. 75.
Beauty out of favour and on crutches, vi. 221.
beauty, rendered still more beautiful, xi. 212.
Beauty the lover’s gift? Dear me, what is a lover that it can give?
etc., viii. 73.
Beauty, When he saw nought but, etc., iv. 217.
because he was a lord, firstly, etc., xi. 487.
because it would do that in verse, etc., xi. 491.
because on earth their names, etc., i. 23; x. 63.
Because you think me a savage, viii. 442.