Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Emailing Disturbances of Affect and Mood
Emailing Disturbances of Affect and Mood
Introduction:
Emotions are a part of everyday life and colour all human experiences. Disturbances of
emotions are seen in most of the mental disorders. Mood and affect refer to how emotional
experiences are described in psychiatric assessment.
Affect and mood are one of the key domains of mental functioning and their assessment is an
integral part of clinical examination in psychiatry. Assessment of disturbances in affect could
be challenging to the trainees in psychiatry. Hence, before embarking on assessment of
affective disturbances it is important to understand the context of use and meaning of
different terms. Various terms like ‘feelings’, ‘emotions’, ‘affect’ and ‘mood’ have been used
to describe the emotional state of an individual.
Definitions:
Frank Fish defines ‘feelings’ as positive or negative reactions to an experience or an event,
which constitute the subjective experience of emotion, and are often transitory. In simple
English, the word feeling also refers to an active experience of somatic sensation, like touch
or pain, and the passive subjective experience of emotion.
Emotion has been primarily defined in terms of response to stimuli which lead to cognitive,
physiological and behavioural changes. Lange considers emotion to arise from a person’s
self-awareness of physical and bodily changes whereas Fish considers emotion as a stirred up
state caused by physiological changes. Both these definitions highlight that a stimulus leads
to changes in the body, which on being perceived by a person are experienced as emotion. On
the contrary, Cannon and Bard suggest that emotion is the first response to a stimulus and
physiological changes occur as a consequence of the emotion e.g. one feels afraid on seeing a
lion and then physiological changes such as sympathetic over activity follow.
Affect refers to the emotional state, as judged by external reactions like laughter, crying,
anger or fear. Affect is dynamic and transitory; it changes with situations, thought processes
and external environment.
Mood, on the other hand, refers to a more pervasive and sustained emotional state, which
colours the person’s perception of the world (and thus the affective responses). The
descriptive terms used for mood and affect are generally the same like sad, anxious, angry,
happy, calm, irritable, etc.
The term ‘affectivity’ refers to the total emotional life of the individual (Fish).
Thus, mood refers to an individual’s disposition to react to situations with a certain kind of
emotion, which is prolonged, and influences all other aspects of mental life; and these
emotions are generally manifested through a range of affects, which are complex but
momentary.
The studies of recognition of facial expression on tests like facial emotional expression test
have shown the existence of six basic emotions, expressed on face, which are easily
differentiated by subjects. The six basic emotions include anger, disgust, fear, happiness,
sadness and surprise, and are considered to be universally present. Curiously, these six basic
emotions are also similar to the navarasas or nine emotions such as shringara, hasya,
adbhuta, shanta, raudra, veera, karuna, bhayanaka and vibhatsa, described in studies of
ancient Indian drama such as the Natya Sastra.
Culture contributes a lot to the variations in expression of mood and affect. There may be
customary rules within a culture which determine the cultural norms for expressing emotion.
For example, there are customary rules for who can show which particular emotion to whom
and when and which events are likely to produce a particular emotion. In certain social (e.g.
mourning) and religious contexts, a particular emotion might be expressed, or even
considered desirable, which would not be considered appropriate in another culture.
Similarly, there may be cultural differences in the descriptions of various types of mood and
affect.
The difficulty in differentiating normal from abnormal affect arises because of a number of
reasons. Normal individuals often experience a variety of emotional states, which may occur
spontaneously or in reaction to stimuli and some of these may be distressing. Also, the same
terms are often used to describe normally experienced affect and abnormal affect that
warrants clinical intervention. For example, the terms ‘anxiety’ and ‘depression’ may have a
very specific technical meaning when used by a psychiatrist, but could have a very different
meaning to the patient while describing them. In addition, in certain situations like mourning
or during religious experiences, extreme emotional expressions are culturally expected and
permissible. There may be no phenomenological differences between the reactions seen
within the context of such a situation, and those seen as a psychopathology in a mental
disorder.
Emotional reactions and expressions occur in a range of increasing intensity from normal
through abnormal to morbid in the context of socio-cultural norms, understandability,
excessiveness of the emotional response, and awareness by the person experiencing the
emotional response. Fish has described five levels of emotional reactions and expressions:
• Normal emotional reactions
• Abnormal emotion reactions
• Abnormal expressions of emotion
• Morbid expressions of emotion
• Morbid disorders of emotion
Normal emotional reactions occur as a result of events and are within the sanctioned socio-
cultural norms. Abnormal emotional reactions are excessive but understandable. Abnormal
expressions of emotion are both un-understandable and excessive to the context. Further,
emotional responses are considered to be morbid when the person is unaware of the
abnormality in addition to being un-understandable and excessive. Morbid disorders of
emotion include manic or depressive episode.
Emotional responses may be primary or secondary. Primary disturbances of emotion are un-
understandable and morbid in themselves. Secondary disturbances of emotions occur as
understandable reactions to some other psychological event or psychopathology e.g. persons
experiencing delusions or hallucinations may experience anger, fear, surprise or joy, related
to the content of these delusions or hallucinations.
The definition of abnormal mood and affect has to be understood exclusively within the
context of descriptive psychopathology and the clinician must also consider a multitude of
other factors before deciding that this phenomenon represents the symptom of an illness
warranting intervention. Therefore, while determining whether mood and affect is abnormal,
few points need to be considered:
• Whether there is quantitative or qualitative change in the mood and affect?
• Whether this change is associated with other symptoms?
• Whether there is functional impairment?
• Whether the change is outside the range of culturally appropriate expressions?
• Whether the change in affect has any association with cognition and/or conation
Andrew Sims brings in two other important dimensions for ascertaining abnormality viz.,
subjective distress and social appropriateness. It may be assessed:
• Does the individual’s current mood lead to subjective distress/suffering?
• Is the individual’s mood socially appropriate?
A pathological mood state should be considered only if one of the above two questions is
answered in the affirmative.
Causes of Affective Disturbances
Disturbances of mood and affect are seen not just in the disorders considered to be primary
disorders of mood, but also in many other psychiatric disorders as well as in physical
illnesses and also in psychoactive substance use disorders:
Psychiatric disorders: Affective disturbances occur in most of the psychiatric disorders and
across all age groups. The illnesses would include mood disorders, schizophrenia and related
psychotic disorders, delirium, dementia, anxiety disorders, adjustment disorders and
personality disorders and childhood psychiatric disorders.
Physical diseases: Many physical/medical diseases may cause affective symptoms like
frontal lobe syndrome, Alzheimer’s disease, brain tumours and infections, head injury,
Parkinson’s disease, diabetes, malaria, endocrinological disorders, HIV/AIDS, etc.
Medications like corticosteroids, alpha-methyldopa, reserpine, calcium channel blockers,
antiviral agents, etc. can also cause affective symptoms.
Psychoactive substance use: Psychoactive substance abuse or withdrawal after prolonged
use may be associated with affective symptoms. Psychoactive substances that are known to
trigger affective symptoms include alcohol, benzodiazepines, cocaine, opioids etc.
Clinical Assessment of Mood and Affect
The assessment of disturbances in mood and affect in routine clinical practice is often
challenging, Reasons include an indefinite characerteristic of the emotional expressions, an
overlap between them, cultural variations, and the variety of terms that the patients may use
to describe their emotional states. Because of the complex relationship of mood with
cognition and behaviour, differentiating cognitive from affective aspects of a particular
phenomenon and ascertaining their primacy may become difficult. Berrios also gives another
reason that the cognitive aspects of psychopathology has been given more importance in the
scientific literature which has resulted in less differentiated nature of affect (as compared to
cognition) with less developed psychopathology and fewer description of affective
disturbances.
The assessment of mood and affect is done on the basis of history, physical examination and
mental status examination.
Assessment of Mood:
While assessing mood on history, one needs to enquire explicitly about the mood, with direct
questions. One could ask questions like:
Physical Examination:
Physical examination is an integral part of examination and can contribute in many ways. It
may provide clue about the emotional state of a person e.g. autonomic dysfunction in form of
moist palms and dry mouth, tachycardia, fine tremors and mild rise in blood pressure, may
indicate underlying anxiety. Sometimes, the findings on physical examination may be as a
result of disturbed mood e.g. multiple cut marks arising out of dysphoric mood. It may also
uncover signs of a physical disease like Parkinson’s disease which might be contributing to
the affective symptoms or even an independent comorbid physical disease.
Assessment of Affect:
Affect is formally assessed and recorded under a separate heading in mental status
examination. It is generally described/recorded under two headings:
Subjective
Objective
For assessment of subjective affect, generally a single direct question is asked from the
person, “How do you feel?” or “Aapka man kaisa hai?” Exact verbatim of the answer to this
question is noted as subjective affect.
Objective assessment of affect is made throughout the interview on the mental status
examination. Objective affect is examined in various dimensions to enable a comprehensive
assessment of affect, which include:
• Quality
• Range
• Reactivity
• Appropriateness
• Intensity/depth
However, intensity/depth is not always commented upon during routine mental status
examination.
• Nonverbal cues, verbal content, thought process and direct questioning. Nonverbal
cues come from observation of general appearance, choice of clothing, facial
expression especially the eyes, gestures, posture, spontaneity, tone, volume and flow
of speech, and flow and content of thought process. For example, a person with
mania, due to expansive mood and resultant pleasure seeking behavior, may exhibit
dressing in gaudy clothes, increased psychomotor activity, excessive use of gestures,
over familiarity, increased volume and tone of speech with rapid flow of thoughts
with grandiose content in addition to cheerful affect.
• Questions asked to assess higher mental status functioning may give clue to the
affect. For example, a person having severely depressed affect and depressive
cognitions, when being tested for personal judgment, may give an answer, coloured
by his/her prevailing depressed affect, that he/she would sit on a road and let passing
by vehicles hit him as there was no hope of his/her becoming alright.
• Empathic evaluation also helps in the assessment; it means that the interviewer must
imagine him/herself in the situation of the interviewee and try to understand what
he/she is feeling.
• Sometimes, the affect is infectious which means that the interviewer feels with the
person being interviewed; he/she is infected with the same emotion. This
infectiousness is generally noted while interviewing persons having mood disorder
e.g. the interviewer may feel cheerful without any reason while examining an elated
person with mania, as if the elation has rubbed on to him/her.
Quality of affect:
Happiness: The gradients of happiness have been described as elevated affect, euphoria,
elation, exaltation and ecstasy.
Elevated affect is an air of confidence and enjoyment, experienced as being more cheerful
than normal, but may not be pathological.
Euphoria is subjective experience of over cheerfulness and heightened wellbeing. It is
characterized by increased enjoyment and a reduction in restraint imposed by the self or by
societal norms. There may be changes in activity levels and appetitive behaviours that reflect
heightened mood state. It is an exaggerated feeling of well-being and is not explicable by real
events. The affect in this state is, also noted as being ‘expansive’. On assessment, feelings are
expressed relatively easily and without restraint. Euphoria is frequently associated with an
overestimation of reality.
Elation is subjective experience of feelings of joy, euphoria, triumph and optimism, along
with intense self-satisfaction. This state is usually associated with an increase in activity
levels beyond that usually experienced by the person and is inappropriate for the context, and
not usually experienced as being uncomfortable or distressing.
When elation is associated with increasing self-esteem to the extent that it alters the person’s
ties with reality, it is referred to as exaltation.
Ecstasy is emotional state lying on the same spectrum, but is somewhat different. It usually
involves a state of extreme well-being associated with a feeling of rapture, bliss and grace.
This is subjectively experienced as a transcendental state where the person feels at one with
the universe. There may be a feeling of being in tune with the whole of nature and at one with
the universe. Ecstasy is often a part of normal religious or spiritual experiences, when it is
associated with a pervasive feeling of communion with God or some religious figure. It can
also occur in mania and sometimes the result of a psychotic, dissociative or drug-induced
disorder.
Depression: It is a feeling of dejection that colours all thoughts, behaviour and activity. It
may occur in response to chronic frustration and disappointment, loss or bereavement or as a
part of depressive disorder. Depression, as an affect, may vary quantitatively from normal
sadness as associated with bereavement or qualitatively as profound gloominess as in severe
morbid depression. The state of persistent mood in depression may be sadness, decreased
emotional reactivity, a heightened experience of negative affect or irritable mood and ill-
humour. In morbid depression, there may be marked and severe inhibition of psychomotor
activity which may result in stupor. Due to severe retardation, a person with morbid
depression may appear indifferent to the events happening around him/her. This needs to be
differentiated from emotional indifference of a person with chronic schizophrenia. A person
with severe depression understands the significance of the events around him/her but is
unable to act due to his/her mental state. This inability to act is experienced as very painful
and makes him/her fell guilty. Depression, mild to morbid, may be seen in adjustment
disorders, mood disorders, schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders, anxiety disorders,
dissociative disorders and personality disorders, and has also been reported in children. It
may be difficult to diagnose depression in patients with physical disorders as symptoms of
depression like insomnia, loss of appetite, anergia may also occur because of discomfort and
pain associated with the physical illness itself. In this situation, it is useful to discern
persistent pervasive sadness and cognitive symptoms of depression for making diagnosis of
depression. Similar problem may arise while assessing depression during pregnancy and
postpartum period.
Anxiety: In day to day English language use, one hears commonly the word ‘anxiety’ which
means ‘uneasy preoccupation with some personal matter’ or ‘worrying about something’. But
in psychiatry it is used in a different way. Anxiety is ‘an unpleasant affective state with the
expectation but not the certainty of something untoward happening. It is characterized by
apprehension in anticipation of a danger (external or internal)’or ‘fear for no adequate
reason’. Anxiety is also described as an emotional reaction to a threat that is ill-defined,
internal and conflictual. This definition serves to differentiate anxiety from the state of fear,
related to the perception of a threat that is external, clear and non-conflictual. Anxiety and
fear, as with all emotional states, contain both psychic and physical concomitants. The
psychic symptoms of anxiety are feelings of inner restlessness, ‘bechaini’, ‘ghabraahat’,
apprehension or ruminations. The physical response in these states is the state of the
adrenergic “fight-or-flight” response, where autonomic and somatic symptoms like
palpitations, shortness of breath, muscular tension resulting in headache or chest pain,
diarrhoea and dryness of mouth may be seen. Morbid anxiety is often accompanied by one or
more symptoms like inability to sleep, poor concentration, irritability, etc.
Fish also describes anxious foreboding in which a person has a fear that something very bad
will occur but he/she cannot identify it. A related concept is panic. Panic attack is an episode
of severe anxiety characterized by feeling of choking, difficulty in breathing, symptoms of
sympathetic overactivity and physical weakness. Phobia is a fear restricted to a specific
object, situation or idea. Phobias are associated with physical symptoms of anxiety and
avoidance of the phobic object or situation.
Anxiety symptoms are seen in anxiety disorders including generalized anxiety disorder, panic
disorder, specific phobias, mood disorders especially depressive disorders, psychotic
disorders, adjustment disorders and psychoactive substance/alcohol intoxication or
withdrawal and many physical diseases.
Anxiety seen in patients with psychosis is usually intense and improves with the
improvement of psychosis. Sometimes, intense anxiety may be present in patients receiving
antipsychotics which may be due to akathisia, a side effect of antipsychotics.
Range of Affect:
On clinical examination, the emotional state of a person is discussed under separate domain
of mood and affect. Mood is a pervasive and sustained emotion state whereas the affect is the
emotional responsiveness or state as on now. Mood is examined on history and affect on
mental status examination throughout the interview. Mood and affect may be considered
abnormal or morbid in the context of socio-cultural norms, understandability, excessiveness
of the emotional response, awareness by the person experiencing the emotional response,
association with other symptoms and functional impairment. A variety of affective
disturbances are seen in patients with psychiatric and medical disorders.
Bibliography
American Psychiatric Association, 2013. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 5th Edition: DSM-5, 5 edition. ed. American Psychiatric Publishing, Washington,
D.C.
Berrios, G.E., 1996. The History of Mental Symptoms: Descriptive Psychopathology since
the Nineteenth Century, 1 edition. ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge England ;
New York, NY, USA.
Cannon, W.B., 1987. The James-Lange theory of emotions: a critical examination and an
alternative theory. By Walter B. Cannon, 1927. Am J Psychol 100, 567–586.
Casey, P., Kelly, B., 2007. Fish’s Clinical Psychopathology, 3rd Edition, 3rd edition. ed.
RCPsych Publications, London.
Fish, F., 1974. Clinical Psychopathology, Revised edition. J. Wright, Bristol.
Gelder, M., Andreasen, N., Lopez-Ibor, J., Geddes, J. (Eds.), 2012. New Oxford Textbook of
Psychiatry. Also available as: Online.
Jaspers, K., 1997. General Psychopathology, Reprint edition. ed. Johns Hopkins University
Press, Baltimore.
Oyebode, F., 2008. Sims’ Symptoms in the Mind: An Introduction to Descriptive
Psychopathology, 4 edition. ed. Saunders Ltd., Edinburgh ; New York.
Sadock, B., Sadock, V.A., Ruiz, P., 2009. Kaplan and Sadock’s Comprehensive Textbook of
Psychiatry, 9th Revised edition edition. ed. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia.
Shorter, E., 2005. A Historical Dictionary of Psychiatry, 1 edition. ed. Oxford University
Press, New York.