PARTNERSHIPS Reviewer Individuals – should have the necessary legal capacity.
1767 Partnership is a contract wherein two or more
Who cannot give their consent? persons bind themselves to contribute (1) Money, (2) 1. Unemancipated Minors. Property or (3) Industry to a common fund, with the 2. Insane or demented persons. intention of dividing the profits among themselves. 3. Deaf-mutes who can’t write. CHARACTERISTICS (CNB-OCP-PC) 4. Persons suffering from Civil Interdiction. 1. Consensual – perfected by mere consent upon 5.Incomeptents who are under Guardianship. express/implied agreement of 2 or more persons. 6.Persons who are prohibited from giving each other 2. Nominate – has a special name/designation on law. Donations or Advantage. 3. Bilateral – entered into by two or more persons and the rights and obligations arising therefrom are always **Partnerships generally have no prohibition against a reciprocal. partnership being a partner in another partnership.** 4. Onerous – each of the parties aspires to procure for himself a benefit through the giving of something. 3. CONTRIBUTION OF MPI TO A COMMON FUND. 5. Commutative – undertaking of each of the partners is considered as the equivalent of the others. Existence of proprietary interest. 6. Principal – doesn’t depend for its existence or validity 1. Money – legal tender in the Philippines; checks, drafts, upon other contracts. promissory notes payable to order, are not considered 7. Preparatory – entered into as a means to an end. money. 8. Contract of Agency. 2. Property – real/personal, corporeal/incorporeal; credit and promissory notes are considered property. ELEMENTS 3. Industry – active corporation services. 1. There must be a meeting of the minds. 2. To form a common fund. NOTE: 3. With intention that profits and losses will be divided A limited partner cannot contribute mere industry among the parties. or services. Should be distinguished from a lessor of services. ESSENTIAL FEAUTRES Proof of Contribution is necessary with the 1. EXISTENCE OF VALID CONTRACT. intention of dividing the income or profits obtained. Form – no formality is required unless it falls within the Statute of Frauds. Evidenced by the terms of the contract. 4. THERE MUST BE A LAWFUL OBJECT May be expressed, implied, oral or written. Articles of Partnership – states the name, purpose, Effect of Illegality – no partnership can arise as the contract location, powers, rights, duties, and liabilities of each is inexistent and void ab initio. partner. REQUISITES: 5. PURPOSE IS OBTAINING PROFITS AND DIVIDE 1. Consent and Capacity of the contracting parties. IT AMONG PARTIES/PARTNERS. 2. Object which is the subject matter of the contract. 3. Cause which is established. Very REASON of EXISTENCE – the idea of pecuniary 4. Valid Consideration between partners. profit or gain should be principal, but not necessarily the exclusive aim. DELECTUS PERSONAE – This is where mutual agency arises. It allows them to have the power to dissolve the SHARE OF PROFITS partnership in good faith. (not necessarily the right); It 1. Not necessarily equal in shares – only necessary that there involves trust and confidence between the partners. be an intention to divide the profit among the partners. No one can be a member without the consent of 2. A stipulation excluding one or more partners from any ALL the partners; it has a fiduciary nature. participation in the profits is VOID. The presence of a period for a specific duration or 3. Profit-Sharing is merely presumptive and not conclusive, statement of a particular purpose for its creation even if cogent, evidence of partnership. cannot prevent the dissolution of a partnership by an act or will of a partner. SHARE OF LOSSES 1. A community in losses is a necessary corollary of a PRINCIPLE OF ESTOPPEL - a partnership liability can participation in profits. be imposed upon a person under estoppel where he holds 2. Not necessary to agree upon a system of sharing losses, himself out, or permits himself to be held out, as a partner in losses must be in the same proportion. an enterprise. 3. A stipulation excluding one or more partners from any - There is no actual or legal partnership relation but merely a participation in the profits is VOID. partnership liability by law in favor of third persons. - In case there is no written agreement between parties, the existence or non-existence of the partnership must be determined from the conduct of the parties. 2. LEGAL CAPACITY OF PARTIES TO ENTER INTO A CONTRACT. A partner may be a natural person, juridical person, or a joint venture. 1770 Object or Purpose of a Partnership. ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS 1776 CLASSIFICATIONS OF PARTNERSHIP: 1. Legality of the Object. 1. EXTENT: 2. Community of Benefit or interest in the partners. a. Universal Partnership EFFECTS OF UNLAWFUL PARNTERSHIP i. Universal Partnership of all present property. 1. Contract is void ab initio and the partnership never i. Universal Partnership of profits. existed before the law. b. Particular Partnership – A partnership formed for a 2. Profits shall be confiscated in favor of the government. specific undertaking, or exercise of a vocation or profession. 3. Instruments or tools and proceeds of the crime shall also be forfeited in favor of the government. 2. LIABILITY: 4. Contributions of the partners shall not be confiscated a. General – consists of general partners who are liable pro unless they fall under number 3. rata and subsidiarily, sometimes solidary with their separate property for partnership debts. (Equally Liable) **JUDICIAL DECREE is not necessary to dissolve an b. Limited – formed by two or more general partners + one unlawful partnership. or more limited partners. Limited partners are not personally liable for the obligations of the partnership. 1771 Form of Partnership Contract. 3. DURATION: GR: No special form is required for the validity or existence a. At Will – no time is specified and is not formed for a of the contract. The contract may be made orally or in particular undertaking or venture. writing. b. With a Fixed Term – existence is fixed or agreed upon or XPN: Where contribution is immovable property, or real formed for a particular undertaking. rights, a public instrument is necessary. 4. LEGALITY: 1772 Registration of Partnership. a. De Jure – complied with all the legal requirements for its A Partnership with a capital of Php. 3,000.00 or more establishment. REQS: b. De Facto – has not complied with all legal requirements 1. Contract must appear in a public instrument. for its establishment. 2. Must be recorded or registered with the SEC - However, failure to do so will not prevent the formation of 5. REPRESENTATION TO OTHERS the partnership, nor affect its liability. a. Ordinary/Real – one which actually exists among the partners and also to 3rd persons. PURPOSE OF REGISTRATION b. Ostensible/By Estoppel – in reality is not a partnership 1. For the issuance of licenses to engage in business or trade. but has the liability of a partnership. 2. So the tax liabilities cannot be evaded. 3. Public can also determine their membership and capital 6. PUBLICITY before dealing with them. a. Secret – existence to certain persons as partners is unknown to the public and or any of the partners. b. Open/Notorious – Existence is known to the public. 1773 Contribution of immovable property. REQS: 7. PURPOSE 1. Contract must be in a public instrument. a. Commercial/Trading – for transaction of business. 2. Inventory of property contributed must be made, signed b. Professional/Non-Trading – exercise of profession. by the parties and attached to the public instrument. * Absence of these will render the contract VOID. KINDS OF PARTNERS * Intended primarily for 3rd persons, a de facto partnership 1. Capitalist – contributes money/property to common fund. or by estoppel may exist. 2. Industrial – contributes only industry/service. 3. General/Real – liability to 3rd persons extends to his When Inventory is NOT required. separate property; may be capitalist or industrial. 1. When immovable property is possessed or owned by the 4. Limited/Special – liability is limited to his capital partnership but NOT contributed by the partners. contribution. 2. Personal Property. 5. Managing - manages affairs or business this guy is appointed. Importance of Inventory. 6. Liquidating – takes charge of the winding up of a 1. To show how much is due from each partner to complete partnership upon dissolution. his share in the common fund. 7. Continuing - continues business after it has been 2. How much is due to each of them in case of liquidation. dissolved by REASON of (1) Admission of new partner; (2) Retirement; (3) Death; (4) Expulsion; of one or more 1774 Acquisition/Conveyance of Property. – immovable partners. property may only be acquired and conveyed in the 8. Surviving – remains after a partnership has been partnership name. dissolved by death of any partner. 9. Subpartner – not being a member of a partnership, 2. If there is no agreement. contracts with a partner with reference to a latter’s share in a. Proportionate to profit-sharing ratio. the partnership. b. Industrial partners shall not be liable for losses. 10. Estoppel/Nominal – not a Real partner, not being a 3. If no profit-sharing is stipulated party to a partnership agreement, BUT is liable as a partner a. Losses shall be borne by the partners in for the protection of 3rd persons. proportion to their capital contributions. b. Purely industrial partners will not be liable for losses. 1782 Limitations in Forming a Partnership Persons who are prohibited from giving each other 1808 Prohibition Against Partner Engaging in Business. donations or advantage cannot enter into a universal Capitalist – RELATIVELY prohibited to engage in the partnership. Otherwise, it is void. same/similar line of business. 1. Between persons guilty of adultery or concubinage at Industrial – ABSOLUTELY prohibited to engage in the the time of donation. same/similar line of business. 2. Made between persons found guilty of the same criminal offense in consideration thereof REMEDIES: 3. Made to a public officer or his wife, descendants, and 1. Bring to Common Fund all profits ACCRUED during his ascendants by reason of his office. own transactions. 2. Bear for ALL the losses. Husband and Wife may enter into a PARTICULAR 3. Be EVICTED. partnership. - Where partners retained their separate interests – capital contributions were separately owned and 1810 Extent of Property Rights of a Partner: contributed before marriage. A. PRINCIPAL RIGHTS 1. Specific Partnership Property 1783 Particular Partnership 2. Interest in the Partnership Scope – limited and well-defined, being confined to an 3. Participate in the management. undertaking of a single, temporary, or ad hoc nature. Examples: B. RELATED RIGHTS: 1. Acquisition of immovable property for the purpose of 1. Reimbursement of advanced amounts and indemnification reselling it a profit. of risks as consequences of management. 2. Professional Partnership 2. Access and inspection of partnership books. 3. Joint Ventures – created for a temporary or limited 3. True and full information affecting partnership affairs. purpose. 4. Formal Accounting. 5. Dissolution under certain conditions. OBLIGATIONS OF PARTNERS PROPERTY PARTNERSHIP PARTNERSHIP CAPITAL 1. Relations among the partners themselves. Variable Consent Depends of Market Value Depends on Agreement. 2. Relations of the partners with the partnership. All original contribution + Aggregate of the individual’s 3. Relations of the partnership with 3rd persons with whom it subsequently acquired contributions contracts. +/- upon partnership’s unanimous 4. Relations of the partners with such 3rd persons. consent. GR: Property used, when there is no express agreement, will not be partnership property. 1784 Commencement and Term of a Partnership GR: commences form the time of execution of the contract. XPN: Implied intent of the partners. XPN: when there is a contrary stipulation. 1. Property is listed as an asset in partnership books. NOTES: 2. Income generated by property is RECEIVED by 1. Registration with the SEC is not essential to give it partnership. juridical personality. 3. Taxes are also paid by partnership. 2. Necessary that all requisites are present. 3. Partners may stipulate some other date for XPN to XPN: Repair and Maintenance of property Only. commencement – makes the partnership inchoate (not fully developed but has already begun.), or unperformed, thus not GR: Property used when there is no express agreement will yet consummated, has not started yet. not be partnership property.
1797 Rules for Distribution of Profits and Losses (among XPNS:
partners) 1. Equal Rights to possess specific partnership property for partnership purposes. Distribution of Profits 2. No right to Possess of for other purpose without the 1. Partners share the profits according to their agreement. consent of the partners. 2. If there is no agreement: 3. Not assignable. a. Proportionate to capital contribution. XPN: In connection with assignment of rights of all b. Industrial partner will first receive his share partners in the same property. before the capitalist partners; amount is not fixed as long 1812 Nature of Partners Interest. as it is just and equitable under the circumstances. Formula: Distribution of Losses 1. Distributed according to agreement. Undistributed Shares of PROFITS + Undistributed Shares d. Expulsion of any partner done in Good Faith of SURPLUS (Excess of assets – liabilities) = interest. e. If any of the abovementioned are done in bad faith, such affected members may claim damages. Done by: f. May be vested in 1 partner exclusively. 1. Agreement 2. Proportion to contribution. 2. Effected in contravention of partnership agreement. a. Partner can withdraw any time without consent of others if there is sufficient reason (must be done expressly) b. Delectus Personae 3. Business becomes UNLAWFUL – involuntary; 1815 Requirement of Firm Name appointment of a position; conflict of interest; contrary to Firm – Name, Title, Style under which a company transacts law to continue business. business. Importance: To distinguish the partnership which has a 4. Loss of a specific thing personality separate and distinct from individuals or ither a. BEFORE delivery partnerships. - Partnership is dissolved; no contribution as to the thing Right to choose name – may choose any name contributed cannot be substituted with another. PROVIDED it is not misleading and it does not use the b. AFTER delivery name of deceased partners. - Partnership is NOT dissolved; but it assumes the loss of a thing having acquired ownership; may contribute additional Use of Name of Deceased Partners – Allowed only when the capital to save venture. firm indicates in all its communications that the said partner c. USE/ENJOYMENT only CONTRIBUTED is deceased. - Partner who reserved ownership cannot fulfill his undertaking to make available the sue of the specific thing LIABILITIES OF INCLUSION OF NAME – persons contributed. who are not partners but include their names in the firm - Partner bears loss; considered in default with respect to his name do no acquire a partner’s right. Only the liabilities contribution. insofar as 3rd persons without notice are concerned. 5. DEATH of a partner – any deceased partner ceases to be DISSOLUTION AND WINDING associated in the carrying of business. UP GR: Ipso facto dissolution of partnership. 1828 Effects of change in membership. 3 Stages during the end of a partnership. XPN: Clause in the articles of partnership providing for the continuation of the partnership even after death of one of the 1. DISSOLUTION – change in the relation of partners partners. caused by any partner ceasing to be associated in the carrying on of a business. Does not necessarily mean that 1831 Judicial Dissolution. the business ceases to exist for the partners. 1. Application by a partner Partnership is not terminated. a. Insanity Partnership continues for a limited purpose. b. Incapacity - making good all outstanding engagements, c. Misconduct and persistent breach of partnership settling all accounts, collecting all property, agreement (permanent mischief) Transactions of new business are prohibited. d. Business can be carried out only at a loss. - No new business should be undertaken, but e. Other circumstances Affairs should be liquidated and distribution - abandonment of business made to those entitled to a partner’s interest (1812) - Fraud in the management of business - Refusal w/o justifiable cause to render accounting of 2. WINDING UP – actual process of settling the partnership partnership affairs. affairs after dissolution; involves collection and distribution 2. Application by a purchaser of a partner’s interest: of partnership assets, payment of debts, and determination of a. After termination of a specified term/particular the value of each partners’ interest (1812) in the partnership. undertaking b. Any time if Partnership was at will when the interest was 3. TERMINATION – all partnership affairs are completely assigned when the changing issue was issued. wound up and finally settled; signifies the end of the partnership life. 1839 PRIORITY SYSTEM FOR DISTRIBUTION OF 1830 Causes of Dissolution (Extra Judicial) PARTNERSHIP PROPERTY / SETTLING ACCOUNTS: 1. Assets of partnership: 1. Effected without violation of Partnership Agreement in Partnership property (including good will) GOOD FAITH Contributions of partners for payment of all a. Termination of definite term/particular undertaking liabilities b. Express WILL of ANY partner in Good Faith 2. Order of application of assets: c. Express WILL of ALL partners (may also be Owing to partnership creditors implied/unanimous) Owing to partners other than for capitals and profits such as loans / advances Owing for the return of capital contributed by the partners If any asset is left, shall be contributed as profits to partners proportionally 3. Loans and advances by partners: Capital contributions are returnable only on dissolution Loans are payable at maturity Accumulated profits may be withdrawn at any time by majority’s consent L & A = amounts paid into the partnership in excess of a partner’s capital contribution 4. Capital contributed by partners: If assets are insufficient to repay capital investments, the deficit is a capital loss w/c requires contribution Return of amount equivalent to capital contribution of each partner shall be increased by his share of undistributed profits / decreased by his share of net losses Industrial: GR: not entitled to any of firm capital on dissolution XPN: if there is an agreement Total capital contribution is not equal to gross assets to be distributed to the partners during dissolution 5. Rights of partner where assets are insuffici ent: A partner / his legal rep (to the extent of amount w/c he has paid in excess of his share of liability) Assignee, for the creditor’s benefit Any person appointed by court Will have the right to enforce the contributions of the partners If any partner does not pay, others will have to pay REMEDY: can sue non-paying partner for indemnification 6. Liability of deceased partner’s individual property Liable for his share of contribution necessary to satisfy the liabilities of the partnership incurred while he was a partner 7. Priority of payments: DOCTRINE OF MARSHALLING ASSETS: a. Partnership property – pay first the partnership creditors b. Individual property – pay first separate creditors 8. Distribution of insolvent partner’s property: PRINCIPLE OF EQUITY: a. Owing to separate creditors b. Owing to partnership creditors c. Owing to partners thru contribution REMEDY OF SEPARATE CREDITOR: Can execute against asset of the firm only to the extent of the interest of the partner in firm assets