Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ARTICLE
ARTICLE
net/publication/323237829
CITATIONS READS
13 16,388
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mehrdad Zamani Khorasgani on 25 October 2018.
ScienceDirect
Article history: This paper presents an experimental study on structural performance of concrete poles used
Received 10 July 2017 in electric power distribution network (EPDN). Three full scale 12-m concrete poles were
Accepted 2 January 2018 tested; and a numerical study on a 7-span distribution line was also carried out in order to
Available online investigate lateral behavior of the network under severe weather conditions, as it is believed
EPDN has a vital role on sustainability of power transmission from the power planet to the
Keywords: consumers which might be hundreds kilometers far away. One of the main issues in EPDN is
Distribution network concrete poles' collapse under simultaneous wind and ice loads in some unreachable snow
Experimental study covered areas. However, the results show that the prescribed loading regimes by standards
Numerical study do not induce any damage into the distribution network nevertheless some unforeseen
Reinforced concrete poles loads like gust wind load in heavy weather conditions cause the poles' failure. Therefore, a
Gust wind and ice non-linear pushover analysis was carried out to find out the weakest part of the distribution
network; and finally some suggestions for increasing the EPDN's sustainability are made.
© 2018 Politechnika Wrocławska. Published by Elsevier Sp. z o.o. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
the concrete poles under the standards' prescribed loadings
over their whole life cycle time.
The electric power distribution networks are like man's Yang et al. [1] carried out a dynamic analysis on a
circulatory system. The transmission networks may be distribution network under different load cases. They estab-
compared with arteries in the human body and distribution lished a finite element model of three span conductors
network with capillaries. They play the same role of supplying employing software ANSYS [2]. They reported that increase
the consumer in the cities with the life giving blood of of ice thickness will decrease the dynamic impact factors; also,
civilization electricity. A power distribution line consists of the impact factors of conductors with accreted ice are less than
poles, cross arms, and insulators (Fig. 1). One of the those of conductors without accreted ice, considerably.
fundamental issues in electric power distribution network Khanverdi et al. [3] investigated the structural performance
which usually happens in severe weather condition areas is of high voltage distribution network's concrete poles under
concrete poles' collapse under simultaneous wind and ice wind, snow and earthquake loads. They concluded that
loads (Fig. 2). This leads to power outage which may cause earthquake loads have crucial impacts on the network; and
catastrophic human and financial losses. Therefore the the poles should be redesigned and strengthened in order to
purpose of this study is to study the structural behavior of come up with the applied loads.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: m.zeynalian@eng.ui.ac.ir (M. Zeynalian).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acme.2018.01.005
1644-9665/© 2018 Politechnika Wrocławska. Published by Elsevier Sp. z o.o. All rights reserved.
864 archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876
Although reinforced concrete poles are widely being used in It is worth mentioning the mid span poles are placed on
power distribution networks, there are very few studies on the the distribution line in which their strong axes are same as
structural performance of this system. Thus, the aim of the the line longitudinal direction as shown in Fig. 4. In contrast,
current research is to evaluate the structural performance of
the currently in-use H section reinforced concrete poles; and Table 1 – Loading in heavy weather conditions [4].
providing some suggestions in order to enhance their Loading type Temperatures Radial ice Wind
performance in order to prevent undesirable collapse in heavy (8C) thickness load
weather conditions. (mm) (kgf/m2)
It is necessary to mention that the EPDN is designed mainly
Balanced loading
based on both electrical and mechanical criteria including Standard
ground characteristics, and loading parameters. Hence, in this Moderate wind and 20 20 25
study, a distribution network located in Semirom (a heavy ice
weather region in Iran) is considered. The loading in heavy Limit state
weather conditions is shown in Table 1. Based on some Heavy winds 15 – 100
Heavy ice 5 40 –
available technical reports, 12-m concrete poles–type 400 kgf,
Unbalanced loading
are assumed to be used in EPDN. It should be mentioned that
Unbalanced 5 40 –
the nominal resistance of the pole is 400 kgf which means the longitudinal Load
pole is able to carry 400 kgf force which is applied at 60 cm Ice and wind on one 20 0–20 25
from the top of the pole without any crack. In this case, the side of the span-wind
ultimate strength of the pole is 1200 kgf. The detailed without ice on the
information of the pole is illustrated in Table 2 and Fig. 3. other side
Minimum temperature 30 – –
Maximum temperature 35 – –
a d b c e a
5 Reinforcement pattern
a e c b d a
6 a 16 L = 12 m
7 b 14 L = 9.5 m
8 c 14 L = 7.5 m
Fig. 1 – Electric power distribution network. 9 d 14 L = 5.5 m
10 e 14 L = 4.5 m
Fig. 2 – Collapse of concrete poles under simultaneous sever wind and snow loads.
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876 865
the dead-end and corner poles are located in which their and corner poles, the wire tensions are the major loads
strong axes are perpendicular to the EPDN direction. Dead- which should be tolerate by the poles in the longitudinal
end poles are used at the beginning and the end of the line. direction.
Dead-end poles usually have higher structural capacity than The details of the cross arm and the insulator are also
the middle poles. Corner poles are used where there is a presented in Fig. 5.
deviation in the distribution line; so the corner poles should
be more resistant than the mid span poles. This is because in
2. Experimental program
the mid span poles, the wires' tensions which are applied to
the poles are opposite to each other and make them balance;
thus, the wind loads which are applied to the network The program consisted of three 12-m concrete poles to
transversely, is the predominant loads. But, in the dead-end investigate the lateral performance of the poles as shown in
866 archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876
Figs. 6 and 7. The general configuration of the testing rig is using Lab View Signal Express software [6]. The load–
shown in Fig. 6. Each specimen was installed on the rig displacement curve of each frame was then plotted.
horizontally between the fixed concrete platform walls at the It should be noted that the pole test was carried out at three
bottom. Three hydraulic jacks were employed to fix the levels, including: normal strength, elastic strength and
specimens in the platform employing some pieces of timbers. ultimate strength. The pole test in normal stage is successful
Also, as shown in the figure, a wire rope puller which was if: (I) no crack is seen in the pole, (II) the displacement at the top
connected to a load-cell was used at the 0.6 m from the top of of the pole is proportional and uniform, and (III) after removal
the specimen in order to load the pole monotonically. The wire of the allowable applied force, the pole returns to the original
rope puller was fixed to a fixed base; and a linear potentiome- position of the pole. If the force exceeds until some hairline
ter was installed close to the top in order to determine the cracks appear in the pole, then it reaches to its elastic strength.
specimen's drift during the loading. The load-cell was used to Finally, while the load increases gradually, the pole reaches to
measure the pole's resistance. All data from the transducers its ultimate strength when some cracks occur in the pole
and the load-cell were analyzed and transferred to a computer decreasing the pole's strength.
The prescribed resistance levels for the 12-m–400 kgf pole highly effective on the outcomes. In this study, concrete
are shown in Table 3. Also, the experimental results of the damaged plasticity model (CDP) is employed to define the
three tested specimens are illustrated in Table 4. characteristics of plastic behavior of the concrete in Abaqus.
The damaged plasticity model is able to show a nonlinear
behavior and failure characteristics of quasi-brittle materials
3. Finite element analysis such as concrete. In this model, Drucker–Prager modified
criterion was used [8]. In order to introduce the Drucker–Prager
The electric power distribution line consists of various space, compressive and tensile stress–strain curves are
structural components; hence, it must ensure the individual defined into the software as shown in Figs. 8 and 9. It should
components behave properly before the network installation. be mentioned that for the compressive stress–strain curve,
In order to employ proper FE models to analyze and study the Hognestad equations were applied [9] assuming compressive
performance of the EPDN, the first step was to model a single strength of the concrete is 22.5 MPa. Also, a multi-linear model
concrete pole and a 7-span electric wire, separately; then, the was employed in order to simulate the concrete tensile stress–
whole electric line was analyzed and studied considering the strain curve [10]. The Young modulus andqthe ffiffiffiffi Poisson ratio of
poles and wires interactions. For this purpose, a nonlinear the concrete were considered as 3925 f 0c (MPa) and 0.2,
push-over analysis was carried out using software Abaqus [7]. respectively [11,12]. The structural properties of the employed
It should be mentioned that a size effect analysis was longitudinal and transverse rebars are presented in Table 5.
performed in order to find out the best mesh sizes for the
structural components. While decreasing the elements sizes 3.2. Modeling of the concrete poles
leads to more accurate results, it takes more time for the
analysis. Therefore, a compromise was made between C3D8R is an eight-node general purpose linear brick element
accuracy and the analysis time. with reduced integration which is proposed by Abaqus for
developing the meshes for the concrete slabs. This element is
3.1. Material behavior suitable for nonlinear large-deformation analysis; and is used
here to model the concrete poles. Fig. 10 shows the un-
Reinforced concrete is one of the most complex materials deformed shape of a typical finite element unmeshed concrete
which should be introduced into the finite element modeling pole.
software, accurately. The correct definition of the behavior of It is noteworthy to mention that embedded region
materials in compression and tension, elastic and plastic is constraint was used for insertion of the rebars into the
concrete. In this model, the longitudinal and transverse rebars
were embedded in a host region like concrete as shown in
Fig. 11. T3D which is a 2-node linear 3-D truss element is
employed for modeling of the rebars. Boundary conditions
Fig. 12 – Size effect analysis on concrete poles. (a) Fine mesh (0.05 m), (b) medium mesh (0.1 m), and (c) coarse mesh (0.15 m).
concrete pole with the fine mesh, often takes several hours in order to validate the accuracy of the numerical model.
which is not applicable. Figs. 14 and 15 show that the finite element solutions and the
experimental results are in reasonable agreement. Fig. 16 also
3.3. Verification of the finite element model of the concrete demonstrates the damages occurred in the concrete pole
poles corresponded to three force levels including: 400 kgf (normal
strength load), 600 kgf (limit of elasticity load) and 1200 kgf
The experimental results related to the 12-m–400 kgf poles (ultimate strength load). These results are reasonably in the
which are based on the results provided in Table 4, were used agreement of the observations during the tests. In experimen-
870 archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876
tal tests, no crack occurred up to 400 kgf which conforms to the the pole is collapsed. This proves that the pole is able to
numerical results. Then, up to 600 kgf, there were just one or tolerate even more forces than the nominal ultimate strength.
two cracks happened; and finally for the ultimate force, several
cracks were occurred. 3.4. Modeling of the wires in electric power distribution
Fig. 17 shows the rebars' stress in the pole at 1500 kgf when network
the pole is totally collapsed. In this force, the tension stress of
the steel rebars is greater than the yield stress which means Another important component in EPDN is the wires; thus, it is
important to ensure the accuracy of the finite element analysis
of the wires by the software. In order to verify the numerical
model of the wires, the results presented by Yang et al. [13]
were employed. It is worth mentioning that Yang et al.
performed a numerical study on a seven continuous span
conductor string as shown in Fig. 18. They studied the
Fig. 14 – Modeling the concrete pole test. Fig. 16 – Damage at 400, 600 and 1200 kgf.
Fig. 15 – Experimental and numerical load–displacement curves for 12 m–400 kgf concrete poles.
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876 871
Fig. 18 – The FEM model for wires proposed by Yang et al. [13].
Fig. 19 – Tensions distribution of the conductors (unit: N), reported by Yang et al. [13].
unbalanced tensions and the inclinations of the suspension The loading regime and the boundary conditions were also
strings under different load cases; and the unbalanced introduced to the software as defined by Yang et al. then, a
tensions of the conductors were analyzed for the suspension nonlinear analysis was performed by Abaqus. The results are
tower and tension tower in heavy icing areas. They considered presented in Fig. 20. Comparing Figs. 19 and 20, a good
a span length of 450 m; and the other specifications of compliance between the results of the numerical model of
the conductors are illustrated in Table 6. Structural length of wires and the results presented by Yang et al. is highlighted.
the suspension insulator was 11.7 m. It was assumed that
the equivalent diameter and the equivalent density of the 3.5. Parametric study on electric power distribution
insulators are 100 mm and 8814.7 kg/m3, respectively. network
The Elastic modulus and the Poisson ratio of the ceramics
in the insulator were assumed 118 GPa and 0.16, respectively. After the numerical models of the two main components of
Also, the thickness of the accreted ice was 20 mm and the wind the EPDN were validated, it was time to assemble and model a
velocity was 10 m/s. They reported that the tension distribu- whole distribution line numerically. For this purpose, a 7-span
tions of the conductors are as shown in Fig. 19. continuous network was considered. It should be mentioned
B31 is a 2-node linear beam element in space with linear that the number of spans was selected based on Yang et al.
interpolation, which is proposed by Abaqus for analyzing recommendation; and the other parameters of the network
cables and wires. This element is suitable for non-linear large- were chosen based on a real constructed network in Semirom
deformation analysis, and is used here to model the wires as illustrated in Section 1. As depicted in Fig. 21, the length of
employing the structural parameters introduced in Table 6. each span is 80 m and the flash is 1 m. 1.68 m of the 12 m pole
872 archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876
3.6. Pushover analysis of the electric power distribution structure are found. It is understood that if the results of this
network analysis show the collapse occurs in the concrete poles, the
strength of the poles is considered as a limiting factor for the
Considering the fact that the concrete poles under the service whole EPDN.
loads have no problem, it is concluded that unusual loads such It is necessary to mention that in this analysis, the ice
as gust wind load in heavy weather conditions cause the pole thickness was assumed to be 40 mm covering the wire and the
collapse. Hence, a non-linear pushover analysis was carried wind load was incrementally increased. The location of the
out using the software Abaqus to find out the weakest part of damages and plastic hinges are shown in Fig. 26.
the distribution network. Push-over analysis is a static, non- As shown in Fig. 26, the plastic hinges and damages are
linear procedure in which the magnitude of the structural occurred at the top of dead-end poles. For the middle poles, the
loading is incrementally increased in accordance with a plastic hinges and damages occur in the bottom and middle of
certain predefined pattern. With the increase in the magnitude the poles. It should be mentioned that there were no failure in
of the loading, weak elements and failure modes of the the cross arms and straps at all.
Fig. 26 – Location of the damages and plastic hinges in the proposed EPDN.
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 18 (2018) 863–876 875
though this is not in the scope of this paper. The authors hope
that this work will stimulate further research and will lead to
more effective and reliable EPDN.