Professional Documents
Culture Documents
09 HPGD3103 T5
09 HPGD3103 T5
Theories into
5 Practice
LEARNING OUTCOMES
By the end of the topic, you should be able to:
1. Apply three main instructional system design models in designing
instruction; and
2. Apply appropriate strategies to design instruction.
INTRODUCTION
In topic 4, we looked at some ISD models. If you recall, instructional design models
describe the process by which a product or a learning environment can be created
(Gibbons, Boling & Smith, 2014). ID procedures can be used for developing
education and training materials in a consistent, reliable and iterative process. ISD
models are systematic and iterative methods for creating a learning experience that
develops and enhance skills and knowledge through the phases of analyse, design,
develop, implement and evaluate.
If so, do we apply the basics of instructional systems design (ISD) and use the
framework of the ADDIE model (analyse, design, develop, implement and
evaluate) while designing teaching and learning materials for our instruction?
know about ID. The majority (65.2 per cent) did not quite understand ID models
and theories, while only 13 per cent had some idea of the ID concept. Most of the
instructors evaluated their instruction, but all were unsure about its design (see
Table 5.1).
We will be considering all the stages in the model, and an example in designing a
lesson using this model is shown in Table 5.2. This model is a systems approach
for designing instruction, where instructional goals are identified at the beginning,
and it ends with a summative evaluation. This model has also been used for
constructivist learning environments (Dick, Carey & Carey, 2014).
Conduct Goal analysis. Goal analysis to break the goal into tasks
instructional and subordinate skills (see Figure 5.1).
analysis Identifying domain of
learning. Domain of learning
Performing a task − Verbal information: Identify
analysis. ingredients.
The Dick and CareyÊs model involves refining the goal from a fuzzy goal to ensure
a better-refined goal can be produced. The domains of learning can be determined,
and an instructional analysis can be conducted. After conducting the learning
analysis, the instructor will be able to determine the entry level skills of the
students. Knowing the context of the instruction will also enable planning for the
instruction. Based on the goal analysis, a terminal objective can be stated, and from
the task analysis, the performance objectives can be determined. In the Dick and
CareyÊs model, the criterion-referenced test items are designed after writing the
objectives, to ensure the objectives are tested. An example of a test item to test
learned skill is shown in Figure 5.2.
Next, the instructional strategy which comprises the delivery system, how the
content will be clustered and sequenced, and what are the components of
instruction, as well as student groupings. The components of instruction are
elaborated in Figure 5.3. The instructional package consists of a set of quiz
questions and a link to a video to show the process of baking a butter cake. A recipe
sheet will be provided and checklists to assist students in self-evaluation of the
procedures. During implementation, these checklists and recipe list will be
referred to. At the end of the lesson, a summative assessment with test items on
intellectual skills and cognitive strategies (example as per Figure 5.2) will be given
to students. To transfer learning, discussions can be made on how to bake a
different cake, such as chocolate and fruit cake, and an assignment can be given to
continue baking at home, and viewing the video again to recall.
SELF-CHECK 5.1
Problem Task for Science Form 2: You are given a tooth. From the tooth, make
appropriate analysis to identify what animal it is, and what diet the animal
probably had.
The ASSURE model starts with learner analysis, followed by the objectives. In
formulating the objectives, the rubric for assessment would be designed. The
condition of the learning would be specified in the objective.
Based on the objective, the methods, media and materials would be selected. For
this purpose, a problem-based learning approach with inquiry and investigation
is used to achieve the objective. Hence, instructional material included real or
models of tooth and skulls of named animals, as well as online photos of the same.
Next, the instructional strategy for using the media employed a problem-based
learning approach with inquiry and investigation which comprises of the scientific
approach. Worksheets would be used to support the process. The instructional
strategy would also ensure learnerÊs participation in the scientific investigation. In
the R, or require learner participation phase, the form of participation is specified.
Finally, the evaluation is done to see if the objectives were met during the
instruction. At this phase, any revision would be suggested to implement in the
next cycle of development.
SELF-CHECK 5.2
Table 5.4: Elements of the Morrison, Ross, Kalman and KempÊs Model
Instructional Objectives for the cognitive, The trainee will be able to:
Objectives psychomotor and affective (a) Greet a potential customer.
domain.
(b) Answer customersÊ queries on
five different models of phones.
(c) Respond to the need of the
customer to convince suitability
of a phone model.
Content Instruction sequenced Sequencing of content
Sequencing according to the learner,
(a) Greeting potential customer.
which is familiarity and
according to difficulty. (b) Answering queries.
(c) Responding to a customer who
needs the following:
(i) A basic communication
device;
(ii) Communication and
camera/video; and/or
(iii) Others.
(d) Responding to a customer who
are:
(i) Uncertain of his needs;
and/or
(ii) Upset.
Instructional (a) Procedure for teaching The instructional strategy used
Strategies cognitive procedures: (a) Watching videos of the process
(i) Demonstration; (demonstration and modelling
(ii) Organisation; of behaviour);
(iii) Elaboration; and (b) Take notes and pointing out key
behaviours (Organisation);
(iv) Practice.
(c) Mental image on process
(b) For teaching (Elaboration); and
interpersonal skills:
(d) Problem situations to practice
(i) Model; with their colleagues.
(ii) Verbal and
imaginal models
(Organisation);
(iii) Mental rehearsal
(Elaboration); and
(iv) Overt practice.
All the components of the model are interrelated and can be changed and
sequenced at any time. For example, formative evaluation can occur during
instruction, and if required, the tasks may be redesigned so as to enable it to fit the
objective required. Content sequencing is important so that what is familiar to the
learner is given first, and more difficult situations are given at a later stage.
Although evaluation takes place at different parts of the instruction, the design of
instruments, and for this purpose the checklist is done to determine if the
objectives can be achieved.
SELF-CHECK 5.3
(a) What is the focus of the Morrison, Ross, Kalman and KempÊs
model?
ACTIVITY 5.1
Ć The Dick and Carey Model comprises of nine stages: identify instructional
goal, conduct goal analysis, identify entry behaviour, write performance
objectives, develop criterion reference test, develop instructional strategies,
develop and select instructional materials, develop and conduct formative
assessment, and develop and conduct a summative assessment.
Ć The ASSURE model has six phases: analyse learners; state objectives; select
methods, media and materials; utilise media; require learner participation; and
evaluate and revise.
Ć The Morrison, Ross, Kalman & Kemp model has four main components as the
framework for systematic instructional planning: learners, objectives,
methods, and evaluation. There are nine elements within the process:
instructional problems, learner and context, task analysis, instructional
objectives, content sequencing, instructional strategies, designing the message,
development of instruction, and evaluation instruments.
Dick, W., Carey, L., & Carey, J. O. (2014). The systematic design of instruction.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.
Gibbons, A. S., Boling, E., & Smith, K. M. (2014). Instructional Design Models. In
J.M. Spector et al. (eds.), Handbook of research on educational
communications and technology, (pp. 607-615). DOI 10.1007/978-1-4614-
3185-5_48, © Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014.
Morrison, G. R., Ross, S. M., Kalman, H. K., & Kemp, J. E. (2011). Designing
effective instruction (6th ed.). New York, NY: Wiley.