Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT OF RAYMOND
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT OF RAYMOND
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT OF RAYMOND
INTRODUCTION:
Every business whether big, medium or small needs finance to carry on itsoperations
and to achieve its target. Without adequate finance, no enterprise can possibly accomplish its
objectives.So, this chapter deals with studying various aspects of working capital
management that is necessary to carry out the day to day operations. Working capital is the
difference between the current assets and current liabilities of a firm. Working capital is an
essential component of the corporate finance because it directly affects the liquidity and
profitability of the firm. Theprimary objectiveof any firm is to maximize their profits. But,
maintaining the liquidity of the firm is also an essential objective. The problem is that
growing profits at the cost of liquidity can bring major and effective problems to the firm.
Therefore, there must be a proper balance between these two objectives or goals of the firms.
One objective should not be met at cost of the other. If we do not care about profit, it
becomes difficult to survive for a longer period. On the contrary if we do not care about
liquidity, we may have to face the problem of insolvency or bankruptcy. For the above
reasons management of working capital should be given proper importance and asit
ultimately affects the profitability of the firm. Hence firmshave to maintain an optimal level
of working capital.
i.e., RAYMOND TEXTILE AND SIYARAM`S TEXTILE. To know the present condition
1
1.1 CONCEPT OF WORKING CAPITAL:
(A) GROSS WORKING CAPITAL- It is simply called working capital refers to the
firm’s investment in current asset so the total current assets of the firm are known as gross
working capital
(B) NET WORKING CAPITAL- It represents the difference between current asset and
current liabilities. Net working capital may be positive or negative. Positive net working
capital is that when current asset are more than the current liabilities. But when current
liabilities becomemore than current asset than it is negative working capital. In brief we can
say that working capital is too much necessary for the smooth functioning and proper
As the operating cycle is a continuous process so the need for working capital is. also
arises continuously. But the magnitude of current assets needed is not always same; it
increases and decreases over the time. However, there is always a minimum level of current
The extra working capital needed to support the changing production and sales
2
1.3 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT:
The management of working capital is concerned with two problems that arise in
attempting to manage the current assets, current liabilities and the inter relationship that
The basic goal is working capital management is to manage current assets and current
liabilities of a firm in such a way that a satisfactory of optimum level working capital is
maintained i.e. it is neither inadequate nor excessive. This is so because both inadequate as
Just as working capital has several meanings, firms use it in many ways. Most
fundamentally, working capital investment is the lifeblood of a company. Without it, a firm
cannot stay in business. Thus, thefirst, andmost critical, use of working capital is providing
A business requires a minimum cash balance to meet basic day-to-day expenses and
to provide a reserve for unexpected costs. It also needsworking capital for prepaid business
needs. Here, working capital finance supports the buildup of short-term assets needed to
Another way to view this function of working capital is providing liquidity. Adequate
and appropriate working capital financing ensuresthat a firm has sufficient cash flow to pay
its bills as it awaits the full collection of revenue. When working capital is not sufficiently
orappropriately financed, a firm can run out of cash and face bankruptcy.
needs larger investments in inventory, accounts receivable, personnel, and other items to
3
realize increased sales. New facilities andequipment are not the only assets required for
growth; firms also mustfinance the working capital needed to support sales growth.
has to take appropriate decisions, as and when required, the failure of which can result in
There are two major decisions management relating to working capital management: -
2 What should be the appropriate mix of short-term financing and long-term financing
Working capital management is crucial due to its significant effect on the profitability
of a company and thus the existence of the company in the market. Working capital
management is an effective management for the optimal use ofcurrent assets and current
liabilities to meet the short-term-obligations and to reduce the risk of liquidity problems for
efficient operations. It represents the liquidity position of business indicating the management
of short-term assets and liabilities. Basically, net working capital of a company is determined
from the deviation of current assets and current liabilities. When current assets higher than
current liabilities, that means the company is capable enough to continue its operations and it
also defines that the company have sufficient funds to satisfy its short-term debt and
It was incorporated as the Raymond Woollen Mill during the year 1925 near Thane
Creek. Lala Kailashpat Singhania took over the Raymond Woollen Mill in the year 1944. In
1958, the first exclusive Raymond Retail Showroom, kings’ corner, was opened at Ballard
4
Estate in Mumbai. In 1968, Raymond had set up a readymade garments plant at Thane. A
new manufacturing facility was set up at Jalgaon (Maharashtra) during the year 1979 to meet
The Raymond limited is $800 million company with $797 million as operating income.
The total net income of the company stood at $850 million with a total asset of $500 million
Siyaram silk mills limited is a public company. It was incorporated on 29th June 1978
and it headquarter was in the Kamala Mills Compound, Lower Parel, Mumbai. It is classified
Siyaram is one of the largest producers of polyester viscose blended fabrics selling
85.26 million meters of fabrics annually. The siyaram company Rs.241.23 core as operating
income in the year 2019. Siyaram export product to middle east and Srilanka.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Many researchers have studies working capital from different views and in different
environments. The following are the studies an useful for our research.
SWARNKAR (2013), in her article analyse and interpret the liquidity position and
creditability of selected textile companies using ratio analysis of 5-year data of 5 companies
from 2008-12 and have found that “Vardhman and Siyaram” choose financing from own
fund and maintain high liquid ratio. Sangham (India) had a high debt exposure doesn’t
maintain good quality which may be a dangerous trend. Furthermore “RSWM and Alok Ltd.”
5
Also had a very high debt exposure and adopt being financed by creditors but they maintain
SUMATHI & NATASIMMALAH (2016) in her article have analysed the source and
uses of the working capital and to study the liquidity position of “Arvind Mills” using ratio
analysis of 5 year data from 2011-2015 and have found that Arvind exports has sufficient
funds to meetits current obligation and cash management ate receivable management are too
much good.
BHATE (2007) in her article have analysed the working capital management process,
receivable management of the company and to study the process of cash and inventory
management of “Raymond Ltd” using ratio analysis of 3-year data from 2004-2006 and have
found that company has a defensive approach as it believes in maintaining its sales in this
competitive environment. The ratio has been improving and so have been the sales, thus
CHANDRABAL & RAO (2011) in her article have analysed the working capital
management of Acc Ltd using financial ratios and statistical tools like “correlation” of five-
year data from 2004-2009 and have that working capital management of this company is
satisfactory. The company has no problem in the management of inventory, debtors, cash.
The liquidity position is too good. Financial statement shows current assets and current
liabilities in classified form. There is good collection of receivable due to good credit and
collection policy.
SWAMINATHAN &JASIM (2013) in her article have analyzed the working capital
management of select cement companies in India using ratio analysis and statistical tools and
have found that overall position of the working capital of select cement company is
6
3. OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY:
LTD. and SIYARAM`S TEXILE PVT. LTD”, has been designed to achieve the following
objective.
(B) Study the efficiency of working capital in RAYMOND and SIYARAM`S textile
company.
4. DATA COLLECTION:
4.1 NATURE AND SOURCE OF DATA: The present study is of analytical in nature
and makes use of secondary data. The relevant secondary data are collected from organisation
official website.
4.2 SAMPLE SIZE:Collected three years data of two textile companies (RAYMOND,
*Comparative Analysis
* Ratio Analysis
Current Ratio
Quick Ratio
Cash Ratio
7
5.1 COMPARATIVE STATEMENT ANALYSIS OR INTRA FIRM ANALYSIS
Table No – 1.Schedule showing changes in working capital for the financial year 2017-2018
8
Interpretations
As in the above table shows that in the year 2017 current assets increased as compared to
current liabilities but in year 2018 current assets decreased as compared to current liabilities.
Table No – 2 Schedule showing changes in working capital for the financial year 2018-2019
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 74782.1 128417.84 53635.74 71.7227
9
WORKING -12952.48 -25640.35 -12687.9 97.95707
CAPITAL(CA-CL)
*Source- Annual Report
Interpretations
As in the above table shows that in the year 2018 current assets decreased as
compared to current liabilities and also in year 2019 current assets decreased as compared to
Table No – 3 Schedule showing changes in working capital for the financial year 2017-2018
Equivalent
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 20349.65 41426.69 21077.04 103.5745
10
Trade Payables 14016.39 18106.11 4089.72 29.17813
Liabilities
Liabilities
Interpretations:
As the above table shows the current assets has a increasing trend when compared to current
Table no – 4. Schedule showing changes in working capital for the financial year 2018-2019
11
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 41426.69 27515 -13911.7 -33.5815
Trade Payables 18106.11 17533.83 -572.28 -3.1607
Other Financial 2641.71 3510.52 868.81 32.88817
Liabilities
Provisions 317.18 351.22 34.04 10.73208
Other Current 4284.4 3060.07 -1224.33 -28.5765
Liabilities
Total Current 66776.09 51970.64 -14805.5 -22.1718
Liabilities
WORKING 28807.3 40656.3 11849 41.13194
CAPITAL(CA-CL)
*Source- Annual Report
Interpretations:
As the above table shows the current assets has a increasing trend when compared to current
costs, performance, efficiency, prices and profits of undertakings in the similar industries can
be studied and oriented for better utilisation of resources leading to improved productivity
and profitability.
Table No.-5 Inter-firm analysis between RAYMOND& SIYARAM`S textile ltd. in the year
of 2016-2017
12
PARTICULARS Raymond Siyaram Increase or % of
Decrease Increase or
Decrease
CURRENT ASSETS
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 81223.34 20349.65 60873.7 74.9460561
This table shows that the Raymond company working capital is in negative form. Siyaram
company working capital is better than the Raymond company. The Raymond company does
13
Table No.-6 Inter-Firm analysis between RAYMOND & SIYARAM’S textile ltd in the year
of 2017-2018
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 74782.1 41426.69 33355.4 44.6034679
Interpretation-
In the year of 2017-2018 the working capital of Siyaram company is better than the Raymond
company. So, this table shows that the Raymond company is inefficient to operate his day to
day expenses
14
Table No.-7 Inter-Firm analysis between RAYMOND & SIYARAM textile ltd. in the year of
2018-2019
CURRENT
LIABILITIES
Borrowings 128417.84 27515 100903 78.5738492
This table shows the Raymond company current asset amount is not sufficient to cover the
current liability. But the siyaram company current asset is sufficient to cover the current
liability.
15
5.3 RATIO ANALYSIS:
financial statements. It is a very powerful analytical tool useful for measuring the
performance of the firm and to make further project. A ratio is a statistical yardstick that
provides a measure of the relationship between two variables, the relationship can be
A. Current Ratio
Current ratio defined as the relationship between liquid assets and current liabilities.
This is a measure of general liquidity & is most widely used to make analysis of short-term
CURRENT RATIO
1.5
0.5
0
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
RAYMOND SIYARAM’S
16
Interpretations:
The current ratio is the measure of liquidity. An arbitrary standard of current ratio is
2:1 indicates that for every one rupee of current liability two rupee of current assets is
available. The above analysis shows that the both companies’ current ratio is low, which
B. Quick Ratio
a company’s ability to meet its short-term obligations with its most liquid assets.
Quick Ratio=
Chart Title
2
1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
RAYMOND SIYARAM’S
17
Interpretation
A standard of quick ratio is 1:1. The above analysis shows that SIYARAM’S quick
ratio in 2016 to 2019 is greater than 1 which indicates the SIYARAM’S company has enough
quick assets to pay for its current liabilities. But in RAYMOND company quick ratio is less
than 1 which indicates they have not sufficient quick assets to pay its current liabilities.
C. Cash Ratio
company's total cash and cash equivalents to its current liabilities. The metric calculates a
company's ability to repay its short-term debt with cash or near-cash resources, such as
Cash Ratio=
Chart Title
0.2
0.18
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
RAYMOND SIYARAM
18
Interpretation
A standard of quick ratio is 1:1. The above analysis shows that both the company cash
ratio is less than 1 which indicates both the company shall not be paid its current liabilities
with cash and cash equivalents. So, both the company needs more cash reserves.
Inventory turnover is a ratio showing how many times a company has sold and replaced
Chart Title
6
0
2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
RAYMOND SIYARAM
19
Interpretation
The performance of of Raymond Company from 2016-2019 the stock turnover ratio is going
to be reduced. It indicates that the clearance of stock is going to reduced and more days need
The working capital turnover ratio is also referred to as net sales to working capital. It
20
Chart Title
15
10
5
0
-5 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
-10
-15
-20
-25
-30
RAYMOND SIYARAM
Interpretation
The ratio indicates a company’s effectiveness in using its working capital in a year. In 2016-
capital but in 2017-18 and 2018-19 the RAYMOND company does not maintain their
efficiency in all three years i.e., 2016 to 2019 which indicates that SIYARAM company
6. FINDINGS:
With the reference of the study, working capital management of Raymond Company
finance.
In this gross working capital of both the firms, a major part is occupied by
inventories.
Current Ratio of Raymond company is not satisfactory but the Siyaram company is
quite satisfactory.
21
Quick Ratio of Raymond Company is not good but according to Raymond company
Cash ratio of Raymond company does not full fill rule of thumb but Raymond
22
7. CONCLUSION:
Raymond &Siyaram are no doubt a well performing company producing cloth and
cotton. According to increase in competition in garment industry both are declining their
performance gradually. Still now Raymond turnover comparatively decreasing more than
siyaram. so both company should give importance towards; changing marketing strategy,
enhancing their stock turnover, applying global marketing and cost reduction programme by
Besides that, from inter firm comparison in Balance Sheet the rule of thumb in current ratio is
2:1. The Siyaram’s company maintain current ratio 1.57 and Raymond company maintain
current ratio 0.81. So, both companies are not good prospective for working capital
management facing problem in liquidity of the company. This report has studied in 2016-17.
inventory management.
23
7. REFERENCE:
Volume-IV, p.g-78-92
sector; With GLS Model, International Journal of Economics and Empirical Research,
Volume-3, p.g-543-549
7. Channar, Ram (2011), Impact of financial crisis on the textile industry of Pakistan; A
case study of Fatch Textile Industry, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied
24
ABSTRACT
The paper studied the Working Capital management of Raymond and Siyaram
from 2016-2017 to 2018-2019. The study uses the comparative analysis and
ratio analysis for studying the performance of the Working Capital of Raymond
management.
25
CONTENTS
CHAPTER TITLE
PAGE
1 INTRODUCTION
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
4 DATA COLLECTION
6 CONCLUSION
REFERENCE
LIST OF TABLES
26