Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Implementation and Assessment
Implementation and Assessment
2013
PED20Supp. 210.1177/1757975913483337Original ArticleS. Tereno et al.
Original Article
Abstract: Attachment is a long-term emotional link between infants and their mothers. Attachment
quality influences subsequent psychosocial relationships, the ability to manage stress and, consequently,
later mental health. Home intervention programmes targeting infant attachment have been
implemented in several contexts with varying degrees of efficacy. Within the CAPEDP study (Parental
Skills and Attachment in Early Childhood: reduction of risks linked to mental health problems and
promotion of resilience), a subsample of 120 families were recruited with the objective of assessing
the impact of this home-visiting programme on infant attachment organisation using the Strange
Situation Procedure. The present paper describes the methodology used in this ancillary study. (Global
Health Promotion, 2013; 20 Supp. 2: 71–75).
Keywords: children, youth, health promotion, maternal, mental health, prevention, risk factors
1. Institut de Psychologie, Université Paris Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Laboratoire de Psychologie et Processus de
Santé (LPPS-EA4057), Paris, France.
2. Institut Mutualiste Montsouris, Paris, France; Université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France.
3. AP-HP, Hôpital Bichat-Claude Bernard, Université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France.
4. Laboratoire de Recherche, Etablissement public de santé Maison Blanche, Paris, France.
5. Institut national de prévention et d’éducation pour la santé (Inpes), Paris, France.
6. Département de Psychologie, Université du Québec, Montréal, Canada.
7. AP-HP, Hôpital Bichat, Département d’Epidemiologie et Recherche Clinique, Paris, France; Université Paris Diderot,
Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France; INSERM CIE 801, Paris, France.
8. AP-HP, Hôpital Bichat-Claude Bernard, Université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, INSERM U669 PSIGIAM,
Paris, France. Correspondence to: Antoine Guedeney, Policlinique Ney, 124 blvd Ney, 75018 Paris, France. Email:
antoine.guedeney@bch.aphp.fr
(This manuscript was submitted on 15 February 2012. Following blind peer review it was accepted for publication on 5
August 2012)
Global Health Promotion 1757-9759; Vol 20 Supp. 2: 71–75; 483337 Copyright © The Author(s) 2013, Reprints and permissions:
http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/1757975913483337 http://ghp.sagepub.com
to be an important early indicator of infant mental in Paris area from December 2006 to March 2009.
health (4), amongst other reasons because it Participation in the study was proposed to eligible
influences the child’s ability to manage situations of future mothers prior to a maternity check-up at the
alarm or distress. Intervention programmes targeting hospitals. To be eligible for inclusion, women had to
psychosocially high-risk populations have been be i) under 26 years old, ii) less that 27 weeks
developed in North America and in other contexts pregnant, iii) able to speak French well enough to
from as early as the 1960s. Since Olds’ initial work give truly informed consent to participate in the
in Elmira (7), other studies have confirmed the study and to benefit from the intervention, and iv)
efficacy of home-based preventive interventions. present one or more of the following psychosocial
With high-risk mothers, several studies have shown vulnerability factors: low income, low educational
that home-based interventions conducted jointly by level and/or intending to bring up the child without
nurses and infant mental health workers yield the best the child’s father. Women who already had a social
results, particularly with regard to reducing or medical follow-up for another reason than the
externalising behaviour problems (8). Moss et al. (9) above criteria – for example, a mental disorder such
underline the fact that extensive training of those as schizophrenia calling for a close long-term
providing the intervention, backed up by frequent follow-up – were not included, to avoid bias on the
supervision, are essential ingredients for the success of effect of intervention. Similarly, women or families
this kind of programme. A meta-analysis on the impact who refused to participate or who were going to be
of attachment-focused interventions by Bakermans- impossible to follow up (typically, who intended
Kranenburg et al. (10) showed that these interventions moving away from the Paris area in the short term)
can indeed increase attachment security through were not included.
enhancing maternal sensitivity, although generally The families were then randomly assigned to
with a small effect size. According to these authors, either the control group, receiving care as usual, or
short interventions with precise goals seem to be more to the intervention group, receiving the
effective than lengthy, multifocal interventions. Despite supplementary CAPEDP home visits. Randomisation
these encouraging results, little is known concerning was centralised by fax in the clinical research unit to
the mechanisms behind these effects: is reducing ensure allocation concealment, using a computer-
postnatal depression the key issue, or is it rather a generated randomisation sequence. All participants
question of reducing disorganising behaviour (8)? received assessment visits at the 27th week of
The CAPEDP study, a randomised controlled trial pregnancy, and then when the child was three, six,
promoting infant mental health, began in Paris in 12, 18 and 24 months old.
2006. The study aimed to reduce the incidence of When their child reached 12 months of age, all
infant mental health problems by reducing maternal families participating in the main CAPEDP trial (N
postpartum depression and promoting parenting = 440) were consecutively invited to participate in
skills, infant–mother attachment security and social the CAPEDP-A study. The mothers were informed
and professional integration. Within the main about this ancillary study, and if they accepted to
CAPEDP study, an ancillary study, the CAPEDP participate with their child, they signed an informed
Attachment (CAPEDP-A) study, evaluated a consent form and an appointment was given to
subsample of families using more specific measures them for a two hour assessment procedure within
of child disorganisation and attachment status as the following two weeks. Inclusion was terminated
well as maternal disorganising behaviour and when the required 120 mother–infant dyads had
mentalising abilities. The present paper describes the accepted to participate. Mothers received 50 euros
methodology used in this ancillary study. gratification for participating in the CAPEDP-A
assessment.
CAPEDP-A received ethical approval from the
Method
Comité de Protection des Personnes Ile de France IV
Participants Institutional Review Board and from the Commission
nationale de l’Informatique et des Libertés (CNIL,
Participants in the main CAPEDP study were 907255), with the Clinical Trial registration number:
recruited at maternity wards in 10 public hospitals NCT00392847.
designed to activate and/or intensify the attachment 2007 with the team that created the instrument (14).
behaviour of one-year-old infants. The procedure The IA interviews took place at the same time as the
involves two brief separations and two reunions SSP, when the infant was from 12 to 15 months of
between the infants and their attachment figure, in age.
the present case, their mother.
The Strange Situation identifies three categories
Discussion
of attachment behaviour patterns. The insecure-
avoidant group (A) is characterised by the infant The present study describes the methodology used
avoiding manifesting attachment behaviour towards in the first French study of infant attachment quality
the attachment figure. The secure group (B) includes in a multi-risk population. It is also the first in France
infants who evidence active proximity-seeking and to evaluate the impact of an early preventive home-
interaction with the attachment figure, especially in based intervention on infant attachment security.
reunion episodes. The insecure resistant/ambivalent The study presents several limitations. Firstly, the
group (C) is characterised by the coexistence of control group cannot be considered to have received
active contact resistance behaviour and proximity- no intervention, ‘care as usual’ being particularly
seeking or contact-maintaining behaviour with the generous in the French health and social care system.
attachment figure. The disorganised/disoriented In future studies in such contexts, closer monitoring
group (D) includes infants that, in the context of the of the use of existing community services and of the
Strange Situation, show seemingly misdirected or nature of the input from these services would clarify
undirected behavioural responses in the presence of the intervention effects of the current programme.
the attachment figure. Secondly, at the point during the project at which
The assessment team implemented and filmed the mother–infant dyads were assessed for infant
SSP for each family. Coding was conducted using attachment quality, the home-visiting team had
these video clips of the parent–child interactions. completed only two-thirds of the total number of
Coders had no direct contact with any dyad and planned home visits. In the second phase of the
were not aware of the group (intervention or project (CAPEDP-A II), which will monitor families
control) to which the dyads belonged. Two up to the child’s fourth birthday, it is possible that
independent coders coded a random selection of benefiting from the entire intervention and the
30% of the cases. Inter-observer concordance existence of a possible sleeper effect may well have
calculated using Cohen’s Kappa coefficient was an impact on the attachment distribution.
satisfactory (Kappa = 0.79). Disagreements were Furthermore, it must be remembered that women
discussed and a consensus category was attributed who were not fluent enough in French to give
to the dyads in question. informed consent to participate or who were already
The AMBIANCE scale is a five-dimension scale receiving other types of clinical interventions were
scored on the SSP procedure video. Higher scores not eligible for inclusion in the present study.
reflect mothers’ lack of self-reflection and the Generalising from results from this study to all
quality of mothers’ responses when attachment mother–child dyads in multi-risk social situations
issues are raised. The scoring team was trained by would therefore be hazardous. Future work should
Karlen Lyons Ruth and Elisa Bronfmann in a take into account the fact that socially vulnerable
training session in Paris (2008) and demonstrated populations include large numbers of different
full reliability. immigrant populations. Developing intervention and
The Insightfulness Assessment (IA) is a semi- research programmes that take into account their
structured interview assessing the mother’s cultural and linguistic specificities is an essential step
mentalising abilities after she has viewed a video clip towards addressing their specific needs.
of herself with her child (nappy changes, free play,
feeding or SSP). The IA is scored using 10 scales, and
Conclusion
results in a classification into four categories. Each
dyad was videotaped for SSP, nappy change, feeding A primary pathway to enhancing children’s well-
and free play. The IA coders achieved reliability on being is through interventions designed to increase
IA rating during specific training sessions during the quality of their parents’ parenting skills.
Perfecting study designs to detect the mechanisms in 6. Flaherty EG, Sege RD, Hurley TP. Effect of early
play is crucial if these interventions are to succeed. childhood adversity on health. Arch Pediatr Adolesc
Med. 2008; 160: 1232–1238.
7. Olds D. Prenatal and infancy home visitation by
Acknowledgements nurses: a program of research. In: Rovee-Collier C,
The authors would like to thank the CAPEDP study group, Lipsitt L, Hayne H (eds). Advances in Infancy
the 120 families who accepted to participate in the study, Research. Stanford, UK: Ablex Publishing Corporation;
the assessment and coding teams, the members of the 1998: 79–130.
home-visiting team and the research assistants, without 8. Guedeney A, Guedeney N, Tereno S, Dugravier R,
whom this project would have been impossible. Greacen T, Welniarz B, et al, the CAPEDP Study
Group. Infant rhythms versus parental time:
promoting parent–infant synchrony. J Physiol. 2011;
Funding
105: 195–200.
CAPEDP was supported by research grants from the 9. Moss E, Karine D-C, Cyr C, Tarabulsy S-L, Bernier A.
French Ministry of Health (Hospital Clinical Research Efficacy of a home-visiting intervention aimed at improving
Programme: PHRC AOM05036), the French National maternal sensitivity, child attachment, and behavioral
institute for prevention and health education (Inpes), the outcomes for maltreated children: a randomized control
French National Institute of Health and Medical Research trial. Dev Psychopathol. 2011; 23: 195–210.
(INSERM), and the French Public Health Research 10. Bakermans-Kranenburg MJ, van IJzendoorn M, Juffer
Institute (IReSP, PREV0702). F. Less is more: meta-analyses of sensitivity and
attachment interventions in early childhood. Psychol
Conflict of interest Bull. 2003, 129: 195–215.
11. Saias T, Greacen T, Tubach F, Dugravier R, Marcault
None declared. E, Tereno S, et al, the CAPEDP Study Group.
Supporting families in challenging contexts: the
References CAPEDP project. Global Health Promot. 2013; 20
(Supp.2): 66–70.
1. World Health Organization. Caring for Children and 12. Ainsworth MDS, Blehar M, Waters E, Wall S. Patterns
Adolescents with Mental Disorders. Geneva, of attachment: a psychological study of the Strange
Switzerland: WHO; 2003. Situation. Hillsdale, NJ, USA: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1978.
2. Cléry-Melin P, Kovess V, Pascal J. Plan d’Actions pour 13. Lyons-Ruth K, Bronfman E, Parsons E. Atypical
le Développement de la Psychiatrie et la Promotion de maternal behaviour and disorganized infant attachment
la Santé Mentale. Paris, France: Ministère de la Santé; strategies: frightened, frightening, and atypical maternal
2003. behaviour and disorganized infant attachment
3. Fombonne E. The Chartres study: I Prevalence of strategies. In: Vondra J, Barnett D (eds). Atypical
psychiatric disorders among French school-aged Patterns of Infant Attachment: Theory, Research and
children. Br J Psychiatry. 1994; 164: 69–79. Current Directions. Monographs of the Society for
4. Bowlby J. Developmental psychiatry comes of ages. Research in Child Development. New York, NY, USA:
Am J Psychiatry. 1988; 145: 1–10. Wiley & Blackwell; 1999; 258: 67–96.
5. Hecht DB, Hansen DJ. The environment of child 14. Oppenheim D, Koren-Karie N. Mothers’ insightfulness
maltreatment: contextual factors and the development regarding their children’s internal worlds: the capacity
of psychopathology. Aggress Violent Behav. 2001; 6: underlying secure child–mother relationships. Inf
433–457. Ment Health J. 2002; 23: 593–605.
Résumés