Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ajol-file-journals_567_articles_214245_submission_proof_214245-6661-529121-1-10-20210910
ajol-file-journals_567_articles_214245_submission_proof_214245-6661-529121-1-10-20210910
ajol-file-journals_567_articles_214245_submission_proof_214245-6661-529121-1-10-20210910
Original Article
Inventory Management Practices and Supply Chain Performance of
Antiretroviral Medicines in Public Hospitals in Nyamira County, Kenya
Anyona Johnson1*, Karimi Peter2, Maru Shital2
1EAC Regional Centre of Excellence for Vaccines, Immunization, and Health Supply Chain Management, College of
Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Rwanda, Kigali, Rwanda.
2 University of Nairobi, Nairobi, Kenya.
*Corresponding author: Anyona Johnson. EAC Regional Centre of Excellence for Vaccines,
Immunization, and Health Supply Chain Management, College of Medicine and Health Sciences,
University of Rwanda, Kigali, Rwanda. Email:omaejohnson89@gmail.com
Abstract
Background
Unreliable supply systems have plagued the provision of an uninterrupted supply of life-
saving medicines in many developing countries, with antiretroviral (ARV) medicines having
the worst repercussions.
Objective
To identify the inventory management practices used, evaluate the supply chain
performance, and determine the challenges affecting inventory management of ARV
medicines in public hospitals.
Methods
The study used a descriptive cross-sectional design, gathering snapshot data on inventory
management practices happening in all the 8 public hospitals across Nyamira County. Data
collection was done using structured questionnaires, key informant interviews, checklists
and data from the national health information system.
Results
The response rate was 97.3% for the questionnaires and 100% for the key informant
interviews. The prevailing inventory management practices were: use of scheduled
inventory control model (80.95%), forecasting demand using previous consumption data
(100%), keeping accurate and updated stock records for each commodity (92.31%), having
essential logistical data in reports (100%), including safety stock (61.54%) when ordering
and keeping ARV medicines in dedicated stores (75%). With the exception of order lead time
(17.98 days), the other supply chain performance metrics namely stock out rate (52.12%),
stock wastage rate (43.2%), and reporting rates (70.84%) were found to be deficient. The
challenges mostly affecting inventory management included inadequate staff and training,
lack of proper storage, and unreliable supply of medicines.
Conclusion
Inventory management practices were according to the recommended best approaches
despite various challenges. The supply chain performance metrics evaluated, with the
exception of order lead time, were all found to be unsatisfactory owing to the high stock out
rates, below par reporting rates and high stock wastage rate due to expiries discovered.
Adoption of an electronic inventory system, use of data for decision making, dedicated
storage of ARV medicines, and inclusion of buffer stock, are some strategies to improve
inventory management.
Rwanda J Med Health Sci 2021;4(2): 257-268
Keywords: Inventory Management Practices, Supply chain performance, stock availability, order
lead time, safety stock
1
257
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
258 2
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
interview guide, and checklists. for completeness, coded and fed into the
Secondary data was also collected from Statistical Package for Social Sciences
the Kenya Health Information System (SPSS) version 25. The entered data was
(KHIS). The KHIS is Kenya’s National then analyzed using descriptive
health information system for data statistics to generate frequency
management that provides a platform distribution, percentages, averages and
for reporting, analysis and standard deviations.
dissemination of data for all health Qualitative data collected from the key
programs. informant interviews was recorded and
transcribed and organized into themes
Measurement as per the study objectives. They were
The independent variable of the study then used to provide a narrative
was inventory management practices of alongside the quantitative data.
which the parameters were: inventory
control model, determination of order Ethical consideration
quantities, stock keeping records and Ethical clearance to conduct the
reporting and safety stock policy. The research was sought from Kenyatta
dependent variable was supply chain National Hospital/University of Nairobi
performance which was measured with Ethical Review Committee (KNH/UON
the following indicators: stock out rates, ERC) in Nairobi, Kenya. Written
order lead times, stock wastage rates approvals to conduct the study were also
and reporting rates. sought for all the 8 facilities from their
Data collection procedure respective in charges. Informed consent
The first phase of data collection form was used to tell eligible
involved questionnaires being participants about the study. Eligible
distributed by the principal investigator staff who were voluntarily ready and
to the respondents using the “drop and willing to participate in the study were
pick later” technique. This method each required to sign the informed
involved the principal researcher hand consent form.
delivering the questionnaires to the
respondents at the health facilities and Results
retrieving them after a couple of days. Sociodemographic characteristics Out of 37
The second phase involved going to questionnaires distributed, 36 were filled
collect the questionnaires as well as and retrieved representing a response
serving as a site visit to collect additional rate of 97.3%. The participants comprised
data on medicine availability and stock of 13 (36.1%) pharmacists, 8
wastage rate using the checklist. (22.2%) ART nurses and 15 (41.7%)
The third phase involved conducting key administrators (Table 1). Majority were
informant interviews with the county male (28, 77.8%) and a substantial
and sub county pharmacists of Nyamira number (24, 66.7%) were 25-35 years
County to provide in-depth information. old. Nineteen (52.8%) participants had
Finally, secondary data on reporting worked for between 1-5 years.
rates and order lead time was retrieved
from the KHIS. This was done by the
principal investigator with the
permission of the County Health
Records and Information Officer.
Data analysis
Quantitative data generated from the
questionnaires was validated to check
259
3
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
260 1
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
261 2
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
time were accurate use of stock keeping achieved by stock keeping and use of a
records and use of a formula in formula in determining re-order
determination of order quantities at quantities (13, 100%) followed by reports
92.3% and 76.9% respectively. (12, 12.3%).
Reduction in stock wastage was better
Table 3. Effect of Inventory Management on Supply Chain Performance (n=13)
Inventory management Effect on Supply Chain Frequency n (%)
Practice performance
Inventory control model Reduction in stock out rates 10(76.9%)
Reduction in order lead time 10 (76.9%)
Reduction in stock wastage rate 9 (69.2%)
Increase in reporting rates 12(92.3%)
Use of formula in Reduction in stock out rates 12(92.3%)
determination of order Reduction in order lead time 10(76.9%)
quantities
Reduction in stock wastage 13(100%)
Increase in reporting rates 11(84.6%)
Stock keeping Reduction in stock out rates 12 (92.3%)
Reduction in order lead time 8 (61.5%)
Reduction in stock wastage 13 (100.0%)
Increase in reporting rates 11 (84.6%)
Reports Reduction in stock out rates 11(84.6%)
Reduction in order lead time 8(61.5%)
Reduction in stock wastage 12(92.3%)
Increase in reporting rates 13(100%)
Safety stock policy Reduction in stock out rates 11(84.6%)
Reduction in order lead time 6(46.2%)
Reduction in stock wastage 10(76.9%)
Increase in reporting rates 9(69.2%)
2622
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
263
1
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
YES NO
100
86.96
90 82.61
80
70 65.22
60 56.52
Percentage (%)
50 43.48
40 34.78
30
17.39
20 13.04
10
0
Experienced stock Experienced expiries Order lead time is Reporting rates meet
outs in the last in the last quarter short target
quarter
Variable
The reporting rates ranged from a lowest 75% in Hospitals A, B, C, E and F with
of 58.3% in Hospital G to joint highest of an overall average reporting rate for all
2641
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
2651
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
users having the latest updated distribution system for ARV medicines
information necessary for decision was efficient. The unsatisfactory
making and developing a sense of reporting rates is consistent with an
ownership of decisions pertaining to assessment of health commodities
orders.[5] supply chains in Kenya done in 2001 by
Inadequate training, inadequate staff, JSI that unearthed poor reporting
oversight and staff turnover unveiled as particularly on consumption patterns
the causes of inaccurate stock records and levels of stock.[13] USAID|DELIVER
may have an adverse impact on the recommends that for supply chain
performance of inventory at other levels managers to make good use of data, just
according to a study done in the United like the products, the right data of the
States.[9] right quality, must be in the right
The prevalent methods used in quantity, at the right time, in the right
preventing stock outs like use of buffer place and at the right cost.[5]
stock and conducting regular stock Notably, the below par reporting rates
counts, were complementary to the were attributed to a major health
recommendations of a study done in workers strike that happened in the year
Tanzania. It advocated for reliable 2018 in Nyamira County.
forecasting and proper inventory
management as strategies to prevent Strengths and weaknesses of the study
supply interruption of ARV This study had a number of strengths to
medicines.[10] highlight. First, mixed research methods
namely, key informant interviews,
Challenges affecting Inventory Management questionnaires, checklist, and
The challenges unveiled in this study secondary data from the national health
were comparable to those found in other information systems were used. This
studies.[8,11] To overcome these provided rich and comprehensive
challenges, the key informants notably findings on the inventory management
recommended: facilitating more training, practices and supply chain performance
recruiting more pharmaceutical that were being evaluated. Secondly, we
personnel and continuous mentorship received a high response rate for both
and supervision which are in line with the questionnaires and key informant
recommendations from other similar interviews which makes the data
studies.[8,11–13] The possible causes of received representative. Third, all
the high stock out rate discovered in this relevant health workers involved in ARV
study are: short duration of expiry, commodity management were invited to
inaccurate quantification and poor take part in the study, boosting the
supply systems. The moderately high reliability and accuracy of the findings.
stock wastage was attributed to the The study also had some limitations
change of treatment guidelines since worth acknowledging. Firstly, since the
majority of the expired ARV medicines study was only limited to public
such as hospitals in Nyamira County due to cost
Zidovudine/Lamivudine/Nevirapine and time constraints, the findings may
discovered on the day of site visit were not give a general picture of the
no longer preferred in HIV/AIDS inventory practices in the entire County
treatment. The relatively short order of Nyamira since majority of the public
lead time which was also perceived to health facilities offering ARV medicines
be reasonable by the respondents seems are of lower levels, namely dispensaries
to suggest that the central store and and health centers. Secondly, the study
2661
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
focused only on ARV medicines and (BMZ) through KfW Development Bank
therefore the findings may not be and the East African Community
generalized to the inventory practices Regional Center of Excellence for
and supply chain performance of other Vaccines, Immunization, and Health
health commodities such as Supply Chain Management. In addition,
reproductive health commodities, other this research would not have been
essential medicines, laboratory possible without the assistance of the
commodities, vaccines and medical College of Medicine and Health Sciences,
supplies in public hospitals. University of Rwanda. I would also like
to thank health workers involved in the
Conclusion health supply chain management of
medicines in Nyamira County and all the
Inventory management practices were respondents and facility in charges who
according to the recommended best provided and allowed me to collect data
approaches despite various challenges. used in this study.
The supply chain performance metrics
evaluated, with the exception of order This article is published open access under the
lead time, were all found to be Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial
unsatisfactory owing to the high stock No Derivatives (CC BYNC-ND4.0). People can
copy and redistribute the article only for non-
out rates, below par reporting rates and commercial purposes and as long as they give
high stock wastage rate due to expiries appropriate credit to the authors. They cannot
discovered. The relatively short order distribute any modified material obtained by
lead time which was also perceived to be remixing, transforming or building upon this
article. See
reasonable by the respondents seems to
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-
suggest that the central store and nd/4.0/
distribution system for ARV medicines
was efficient.
References
1. World Health Organization. WHO
Conflict of interest
Medicines Strategy. 2004.
The authors certify that they have no
affiliations with or involvement in any
2. MOH. Kenya HIV Prevention
organization or entity with any financial
Revolution Road Map. Natl Aids
interest or non-financial interest in the
Control Counc. 2014;371:204.
subject matter or materials discussed in
this manuscript.
3. Schaecher KL. The Importance of
Contribution of Authors
Treatment Adherence in HIV. Am J
JA conceived the study, collected,
Manag Care. 2013;19:231–7.
analyzed the data, and drafted the
manuscript. PN & SM conceived the
4. County Government of Nyamira.
study and reviewed data. All authors
County HIV & AIDS Strategic Plan
revised the manuscript critically and
2014/15-2018/19. 2014;
approved the final version.
5. Project UD, USAID Deliver
Acknowledgement
Project. The Logistics Handbook A
The authors of this paper gratefully Practical Guide for the Supply
acknowledge the funding of the Masters Chain Management of Health
of Health Supply Chain Management by Commodities. 2011;
the German Federal Ministry for
Economic Cooperation and Development 6. Dias V. MDS-3: Managing Access
2671
Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences Vol.4 No.2, https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/rjmhs.v4i2.5
August 2021
2681