Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Official Copy of Group 9 _ Research Proposal.pdf
Official Copy of Group 9 _ Research Proposal.pdf
PAPER NAME
Summary
4
Post-Pandemic: Coping Strategies and Psychological Well-Being among
67
An Undergraduate Degree Paper Presented to the Faculty of the
Submitted By:
Maureene A. Mendoza
Research Adviser:
This thesis is the culmination of a remarkable journey and it is a pleasure to thank those
96
who have been an integral part of this academic endeavor. First of all we, the researchers, would
like to express our sincere thanks to our advisor, Prof. Mary Ana Seline L. Angolan. Her
intellectual guidance, insightful suggestions, and constant encouragement were invaluable to our
research. Her dedication and patience in guiding us throughout this process contributed to the
242
successful completion of this thesis.
We would also like to thank the professors of the Department of Psychology, Prof. Ron
43
Avila, Prof. Pete Aton and Prof. Adrian Amistad for their time, expertise, and valuable
Special thanks to our research team whose cooperation and support made this journey a
truly enjoyable experience. Interesting discussions, common challenges, and mutual support
of strength and inspiration. Their faith in us was the driving force during this journey. We are
Finally, we would like to thank other individuals who contributed to this work either
9
Thank you all for being a part of this journey.
2
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic has really disrupted educational systems globally, impacting
108 8
students' psychological well-being and coping strategies. This study aims to evaluate the coping
strategies and psychological well-being of Filipino college students in Metro Manila during the
post-pandemic period. A Sequential Explanatory Method approach was employed, starting with
8
a survey of 248 students to assess their coping strategies and levels of psychological well-being.
253
Statistical correlation analysis revealed significant relationships between social support and
psychological well-being. To further explore these findings, focus group discussions and
190
in-depth interviews were conducted with a subset of 10 students. Thematic analysis identified
key themes such as the role of virtual social interactions, the challenges of online learning, and
4
various coping strategies. The integration of quantitative and qualitative data provided a
findings suggest that “educational institutions should enhance mental health resources and
58
support systems to better assist students in the post-pandemic era.”
Mental Health
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
3
Title Page………………………………………………………………….………...……1
Acknowledgement………………………………………………………………..………2
Abstract………………………………………………………………….…………..……3
CHAPTER 1
Introduction ………………………………………………………………….…………...6
81
Statement of the Problem ………………………………………………………...……... 9
CHAPTER 2
Conceptual Framework………………………………………………………………….. 36
CHAPTER 3
106
Research Design ……………………………………………………………………….…39
4
Ethical Consideration …………………………………………………………………….50
CHAPTER 5
Conclusions ……………………………………………………………………………….101
Recommendations…………………………………………………………………………104
APPENDIX
References ………………………………………………………………………………...137
172
Chapter 1
5
The Problem And Its Background
I. Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic, a global watershed moment, has made a lasting impression on
Filipino students (Simbulan, 2023). The pandemic initiated a seismic shift in the educational
modalities, transforming schools and campuses into empty halls lacking the levity and
comradery that once characterized them. (Zagreb, 2023) It compelled students to trade in-person
interactions for virtual ones and traditional classrooms for pixels on screens. Beyond the
logistical challenges of remote learning lay a far-reaching and often concealed realm: the
1
psychological terrain. (Dan et al., 2023) In April 2020, it was reported that around “1.5 billion
learners (over 90% of total enrolled learners) and 60.2 million educators worldwide had to stay
home due to the pandemic” (UNESCO, 2020). The Philippines followed suit, implementing a
1
lockdown on March 10, 2020 (UNESCO, 2020). Schools in Greater Metropolitan Manila closed,
classes at all levels were suspended, and non-essential activities halted. “The lockdown extended
1
to the entire island of Luzon, imposing a strict 30-day enhanced community quarantine (ECQ),
61
The latest WHO figures, as of 17 January 2022, the Philippines had recorded over 3
million confirmed cases of COVID-19 with over 52,700 deaths since March 2020. In this
context, the Journal of Positive School Psychology highlighted the intricate nature of the
pandemic's psychological impact on Filipino students. This marked the onset of an uncertain
period that disrupted their academic pursuits, daily routines, and emotional resilience (Serrano,
2022). The absence of peer interactions and the loss of the traditional learning environment were
6
further compounded by widespread fears of illness, financial difficulties, and the rapid pace of
change. Loneliness, anxiety, and depression became prevalent experiences for many individuals
196
as the pandemic persisted, as reported in a study conducted by the National Library of Medicine
(Jandric, 2021).
Amidst these challenges, the Philippines has been gradually returning to a state of
normalcy. This progress began when the Philippines established an inter-agency task force to
monitor COVID-19 in January 2020. The situation escalated when local transmission started on
addressed the nation in Bacolod City on October 23, 2022. He conveyed that it was time for the
country to return to normalcy as the COVID-19 pandemic was receding. President Marcos
acknowledged the difficulties posed by the pandemic but emphasized the need to resume regular
activities, citing the gradual management of the crisis. He encouraged Filipinos to return to work
and seize pre-pandemic opportunities, marking the beginning of a period where the nation
needed to address pressing concerns (Parrocha, 2022) including the Psychological Adjustment
49
Research studies by Tabry et al. (2022) and Howell et al. (2021) have “underscored the
3
critical role of community resilience and social support networks in post-pandemic Coping
148
Strategies and psychological well-being”. Additionally, a study by the World Health
7
mental health resources during the transition to a post-pandemic environment. As we witness the
emergence of a post-pandemic Philippines, it becomes increasingly evident that our focus must
8
shift from crisis management to understanding and facilitating students' Coping Strategies and
7
In this evolving landscape, the researchers endeavor to investigate post-pandemic coping
strategies and psychological well-being among selected college students. The objectives are
52
interconnected and aimed at providing a comprehensive understanding of the students'
experiences.
8
The primary objective of the researchers is to evaluate the coping strategies and
stability, mental health, and overall resilience. Furthermore, the researchers seek to understand
how these students have coped with the post-pandemic period, considering a myriad of
influencing factors. Their commitment is rooted in understanding the distinct needs and
challenges faced by the students as they navigate this evolving landscape. To attain this goal, the
researchers will employ a strategic combination of focus group discussions and surveys,
conducted simultaneously, thereby delving into the emotional and psychological intricacies of
the students.
Ultimately, the aim of the researchers is to contribute to the long-term resilience of these
college students, assisting them not only in recovering from the pandemic's impact but also in
58
thriving as they pursue their academic and personal journeys in the post-pandemic era. This
research represents a critical step toward providing the support and insights necessary for the
8
students to flourish in the wake of these transformative times. Understanding and addressing
their well-being is essential as we transition into a post-pandemic world. Through the framework
of an Sequential Explanatory Design, this study aims to address existing knowledge gaps and
162
elucidate strategies for optimizing the positive impact of post-pandemic coping strategies on the
after COVID-19. It tackles academic changes, social isolation, financial hardship, and future
uncertainty. The goal is to improve students' mental health with focused interventions and
220
support. This study will use qualitative and quantitative methodologies to examine how students
perceive and feel these changes and their psychological impacts. This study will also examine
how students' demographics affect their recovery experiences and attitudes. This research aims to
QUANTITATIVE PHASE
1
The following questions will be used for the Quantitative portion of the research:
1.1 Age:
1.2 Gender: ▢ M ▢F
9
1.4 Student Status: ▢ Regular ▢ Irregular
106
2.) What is the level of the respondents following in terms of:
70
2.1 Coping Strategies
a. Problem-Focused Coping
b. Emotion-Focused Coping
c. Avoidant Coping
74
2.2 Psychological Well-Being
a. Positive Emotion
b. Engagement
c. Relationships
d. Meaning
e. Accomplishments
3
3.) Is there a significant relationship between the respondents’:
a. Coping Strategies
b. Psychological Well-Being
QUALITATIVE PHASE:
On the qualitative phase, the researchers will be utilizing the following objectives:
10
1. To explore how college students navigate and adapt to post-pandemic psychological
psychological well-being of the students. The information that will be obtained could
and assess the impact of these factors on their overall Coping Strategies and
Psychological well-being.
1.1 Have you encountered specific challenges? If so, how were you able to handle them?
1.2 Since returning to in-person classes, has your motivation, interest, or passion
changed?
1.3 How has the transition from distance learning to in-person classes affected your
psychological well-being?
2. Have you experienced any changes in your social connections and relationships on
11
2.1 What implications do these changes have on your current engagement with your
peers/classmates?
2.2 How have these changes affected your psychological well-being? (e.g positive
3. What are some coping strategies that have worked well for you in adjusting to the
“new normal”?
3.1 Can you share any particular situations where the presence or absence of adjustment
4. How has the pandemic affected your plans for the future and your professional
aspirations?
4.2 Are these any new-found perspectives you’ve gained throughout the post-pandemic
5. Are these any aspects of the “new normal” that you still find difficult to deal with?
5.1 Do you think there are any particular aspects of campus life that you should improve
well-being? Why?
12
III. Hypothesis
3
Null hypothesis. There is no significant relationship between post-pandemic coping strategies
3
Alternative hypothesis. There is a significant relationship between post-pandemic coping
strategies and psychological well-being among college students within metro manila.
47
Assumption. College students within Metro Manila employ a variety of coping strategies to deal
59
with post-pandemic stress, incorporating elements of PERMA (Positive Emotion, Engagement,
66
Relationships, Meaning, and Accomplishment) alongside problem-focused, emotion-focused,
The students had to experience an abrupt change into their accustomed way of education
due to the pandemic. And this abrupt change could potentially affect their psychological
well-being. Thus, through this exploration, researchers could identify how they cope in their new
way of living. This research aims to unfold the struggles that the students faced and how they
continued to strive amidst the ceaseless tragic news. Ultimately, this will fill in the current
7
knowledge gaps concerning the coping strategies and psychological well-being of students in the
13
Councilors - Through the findings, the councilors will be able to fully grasp the struggles that
every student faced, thus, it will make them be able to make a proper response plan from their
needs.
Educators - This will help the educators navigate their way of providing a suitable learning
method which could also empower and uplift the spirits of the students.
Family - This study will make the parents and guardians understand the emotional struggles that
can use as a point of reference to figure out where the literature on relevant topics is lacking.
Policymakers - This result will enable the development of context-specific and localized
Psychology Department - Findings of the study could be used to guide the Psychology
Department in building effective school management programs that can be applicable to other
Respondents - When these problems arise, this research will help them become aware of them
and develop a new solution or find another technique to overcome the difficulties.
122
School Administrators - This research will allow them to identify and meet the needs of college
students in this post-pandemic period, including tools and equipment, a laboratory to support and
develop students' skills, and skills that will enable them to thrive adapting to teaching and having
14
112
Students - This study will provide students a comprehensive awareness of how their
psychological well-being affected their lives during the post-pandemic. Furthermore, they may
recovery.
Past studies have shown reports of increased psychological distress and emotional
60
disturbances among the students during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. Hence, the
current study will predominantly focus on the prime elements of coping strategies and their
influence on the distinct dimensions of psychological well-being. This is aimed at the evaluation
The inclusion criteria for the selection of participants will cover a sample population of
college students within Metro Manila. They should experience at least a 2-year quarantine stay in
the Philippines and should be enrolled in the same university for two or more consecutive years.
60
These eligibility requirements will be established as they may potentially have a significant
impact on the psychological well-being of the participants and may elicit symptoms of various
psychological problems.
On the other hand, the exclusion criteria will include students classified as returnees,
shiftees/shifters, and those who have taken a gap year during the course of the pandemic.
those who have traveled and quarantined abroad, will not be eligible to partake in the study.
15
111
These limitations will be set as they may affect the validity and reliability of the research
findings.
While the study will examine the relationship among the presented variables, the
171
VI. Definition of Terms
To facilitate the understanding of this study, important terms are defined herein.
1
Anxiety - is an emotion characterized by feelings of tension, worried thoughts, and physical
changes like increased blood pressure. (Journal of Education and Educational Development
Covid 19 - an outbreak or sickness brought about by the extreme intense respiratory condition,
257
“SARS-CoV-2 infection”. (World Health Organization, 2021).
98
Coping Strategies - are “behavioral and cognitive tactics used to manage crises, conditions, and
147
Depression - exhaustion or loss of energy essentially consistently. Sensations of uselessness or
experience so students are effectively fostering the potential for them to have the strength.
16
Lockdown - is a mandate for individuals to restrict themselves at a particular spot, as a rule at
their home, to keep away from specific dangers to themselves or others. (Work From Home
45
Mental Health - is “a condition of prosperity wherein each individual understands their own true
capacity, can adapt to the typical burdens of life, can work beneficially and productively, and can
New Normal - is adjusting to the circumstances and accepting the present situation in our lives.
208
Pandemic - is a disease outbreak that reaches countries or continents all over the world.
63
Psychological Problem - is “a continuous broken example of thought, feeling, and conduct that
causes critical misery and that is viewed as a freak in that individual's way of life or society.”
58
Psychological Well-being - the experience of positive feelings like satisfaction and happiness as
17
Chapter 2
262
Psychological Well-Being. “The components of well-being, according to Seligman's
113
(2011) theory, are PERMA (Positive Emotion, Engagement, Relationships, Meaning, and
Accomplishment).” Strong evidence that subjective well-being is the ultimate common path of
34
such elements was reported by Goodman, Disabato, Kashdan, and Kaufmann (2017), and their
findings are fully consistent with Seligman's theory. But they mistakenly claimed that he implied
that PERMA was more than just its constituent parts and that it represented a distinct form of
36
In the words of Levi (2017), “psychological well-being is a dynamic state characterized by
some degree of harmony between a person's strengths, needs, and aspirations, as well as
concept, it is crucial to identify the characteristics that are associated with psychological
well-being. Identity, purpose, and relatedness are all part of a bigger framework that supports
psychological well-being (Ryff & Singer, 2019). Having psychological well-being is about
36
attaining one's potential and leading a fulfilling life; "it is not so much an outcome or end state as
it is a process of fulfilling or realizing one's daimon or true nature" (Deci & Ryan, 2016, p.2).
18
11
Each individual strives to be in good physical, emotional, and psychological health. In the
recent Pandemic crisis, which resulted in a complete lockdown across the nation, university
students' perceptions of the outside world in resolving day-to-day issues have been impacted.
3
Some researchers from across the world anticipated that “COVID-19 will have an impact on the
disorders in the general population, including acute stress, post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety,
198
depression, irritability, insomnia, and impaired attention. (Martin & Collie, 2022). These
symptoms were especially prevalent in people who had experienced the pandemic.
A parallel pandemic of psychological disorders like stress, panic, anxiety, worry, and
depression is now more likely as a result of COVID-19 (Ebharhim & Dhahi, 2022). Community
members' limited social connections, social isolation, and personal interactions are emotionally
damaging. The spread of COVID-19 disease has restricted social interactions, freedom of
movement, and daily life functioning. Coping strategies include adopting online socializing,
maintaining physical distance, and minimizing outdoor activities intended for sport, shopping,
30
Every aspect of life for humans has been influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic, including
educational institutions. Online education undertaken prior to, throughout, and after COVID-19
pandemic undoubtedly possesses a positive and negative aspect, particularly when it comes to
192
students' mental health (Barrot, Llenares, & Del Rosario, 2021). Students are dissatisfied with
19
their lives as they currently stand and feel let down by their circumstances. According to Petrie et
al. (2020), students encounter challenges while using an online or hybrid learning strategy. Social
isolation and loneliness were highly related to “Having a strong support system and a sense of
belonging are linked to bad mental health students' psychological health and happiness both
6
during and after the COVID-19 Pandemic” (Voltmer et al., 2021).
Positive Emotion. Within the intricate fabric of human well-being, positive emotions
stand as foundational threads, imbuing life with color and significance. In the post-pandemic
Philippines, the resilience of the Filipino spirit is notably apparent, thriving in the face of
challenges (Tabuga, 2020). Rooted in Martin Seligman's PERMA framework, positive emotions
take a pivotal role in shaping individual and collective experiences. Seligman's model identifies
flourishing (Madeson, 2020). This research aims to compile findings elucidating how these
positive emotions, as defined by PERMA, have decisively impacted the journey of the Filipino
Consider the "Bayanihan spirit," a cultural treasure close to Filipino hearts. It represents
values like compassion, mutual support, and voluntary cooperation, expressed through
comforting words like "Tulungan" and "Damayan." This spirit isn't just inspiring; it turns regular
folks into community heroes, sowing the seeds of positive emotions such as hope and unity
(GOVPH, 2020). Acts of kindness, initiated by ordinary individuals, resonate like heartbeats
83
across the islands, building resilience and optimism in the face of challenges.
20
As the research delves into this research, there is a proactive response from the
government and healthcare sectors, working hand in hand with successful vaccination efforts.
When these aspects come together, they create a sense of security and optimism, spreading hope
across the Filipino landscape (Chan, 2021). The government's actions become more than just
The economic part of this journey unveils a story of recovery, job opportunities, and
financial stability. It doesn't just offer financial security; it brings relief and rejuvenated hope.
With job opportunities appearing on the horizon, Filipinos once again see a brighter future
(Diokno, 2022).
But this research isn't just about numbers and policies. It dances through the streets,
embracing stories of families reuniting, friends sharing laughter, and communities reviving
cultural and religious traditions. These are the moments where positive emotions truly flourish,
In this Filipino tale of resilience and hope, positive emotions are the brushstrokes,
painting the canvas with hope, gratitude, and optimism. These emotions aren't solitary travelers;
they are woven into the fabric of Filipino culture, holding the nation together. They rise like the
201
As we reach the conclusion, it's clear that the Filipino story is ongoing. The findings in
this research serve as a testament to the unyielding spirit of the nation. The symphony of positive
emotions continues to play, serving as a soundtrack of hope and resilience in an uncertain world.
21
In the face of challenges, Filipinos stand as an exemplary demonstration of how positive
emotions can be more than a reaction; they can serve as guiding lights toward a brighter, safer,
Engagement. In the unique background of the after the pandemic Philippines, the
active and enthusiastic participation of Filipinos in a diverse array of activities that exert a
profound and transformative impact on the recovery and rejuvenation of their communities (Dela
Cruz, 2021). This dynamic engagement closely corresponds to the "E" component of the
PERMA model in psychology, which signifies a profound state of immersion and flow, whereby
individuals find themselves fully absorbed in their actions and experiences (Soots, 2023).
Perception of Government Responses to COVID-19”, delves into the intricate interplay between
governance and citizen engagement. This research highlights “how Filipinos' active involvement
pandemic and implementing comprehensive recovery plans” (Verzosa, 2020). The intricate
connection between governance and engagement underscores the pivotal role of well-structured
(2023), assumes a significant role in the post-pandemic Philippines. This study meticulously
examines how Filipinos have exhibited a remarkable entrepreneurial spirit, actively engaging in
22
the establishment of online businesses and adroitly harnessing digital technologies to sustain
their livelihoods. This economic engagement is not only a testament to adaptability but also
stands as a formidable driving force in the nation's economic recovery endeavor (Haferkamp,
2023).
comprehensive understanding of the role of active engagement among Filipinos in the recovery
and revitalization of their communities. Their findings emphasize the depth of involvement
resilience and adaptability in the face of formidable challenges (Merca, 2021). Furthermore,
122
research from the “Philippine Journal of Social Development provides valuable insights into the
Filipinos' engagement extends beyond mere involvement to catalyze a profound sense of unity
47
Relationship. In Seligman’s PERMA model, a positive relationship is about the
connection of an individual from the other and it is inherent for humans to seek close contact
with other people, to build relationships, and to connect to them. This relationship can be built
between two people who encourage, support, and care for one another. Heshmati et. al. (2020)
noted that positive emotions and relationships are fundamental well-being factors for young
adults. Positive relationship can lessen the stress of an individual and can improve their lifestyle
99
as they are being encouraged by someone who cares for them. “Having a positive relationship
23
with others and one's environment is critical to one's well-being and success in life” (Nadlifah,
As Filipinos are in the post-pandemic phase, it is inevitable that they would immediately
seek for relationships. As stated by Seligman (2011), it is our basic human need to feel belonged,
173
to feel loved and understood, and to be supported. “Positive Relationships include Parent
positive relationship can have a great contribution to feelings of positive emotions and achieving
At some point during the pandemic, the relationship that was made face-to-face has been
reduced and communication was cut-off. As a result, some developed anxiety and felt alone.
5
“Loneliness has been positively associated with depressive and anxious symptoms while hope
has been negatively linked to these symptoms” (Vasileiou et. al., 2020). However, now that the
country is now facing the effects of post-pandemic, the feeling of loneliness will gradually
vanish. With people beside them, feelings of loneliness could be lessened. The well-being of the
5
people will depend on the well-being of the people they connect with. That’s why when they
associate themselves with people who are generally good will also affect them. It is suggested
24
5
that is why “positive relationships as a particular component of wellbeing were found to be
positively predicted the highest by love and hope but also by social intelligence, gratitude,
Meaning. What is the intended significance behind individuals' assertion of personal life
231 139
meaning? “Meaning is belonging to and serving something greater than ourselves. Having a
139
purpose helps people stay focused on what matters most when faced with major obstacles or
260
misfortune.” (Seligman, 2012). The concept of meaning in life is frequently characterized as an
dedicating time and effort towards the achievement of deeply valued objectives (Ryff & Singer,
1998). Some scholars contend that an individual experiences purpose in life when he or she
realizes that one's life makes sense (Reker & Wong, 1988). Meaning, as defined by another
engagements with artistic expressions and the natural world (Frankl, 1984). “The acquisition of
32
meaning can also be achieved by aligning one's self or one's existence with a broader framework
32
of meaning, such as a religious belief system or a personal philosophy of life” (Allport, 1961).
32
There is an argument suggesting that “the subjective experience of finding meaning in
32
life is dependent on the satisfaction of four psychological demands, namely purpose, value,
efficacy, and self-worth” (Baumeiste, 1991). Life is full of unexpected challenges and hardships
that can test our own strengths and resilience. The difficulties encountered often prompt
individuals to contemplate their meaning and purpose of their existence. In the same way that the
25
pandemic forces us to constantly question our ability to persevere in the face of the numerous
challenges it presents, each new day brings new uncertainties about how we will manage to cope
209
with them. terms of careers, education, and employment (Hartung et al. 2020).
Many factors that the COVID-19 Pandemic hinders many factors of their lives (Mugo,
179
et.al 2020). The sudden transition to remote learning has posed challenges for students who are
accustomed to in-person instruction (Anwar et al., 2020). It hinders students to socialize and
230
engage with other people. “Lack of access to necessary technology and reliable internet
52
connection has hindered students' ability to fully engage in online classes” (Brownstein &
52
Havens, 2021). The absence of a structured learning environment and the difficulty in
can hinder students' ability to concentrate, Because of the pandemic, college students are
confused and disoriented about their futures in stay motivated, and effectively engage in their
coursework” (Cao et al., 2020). Despite every challenge students can find their purpose in life in
6
reflecting on their personal values and aspirations in life. “Engaging in activities that align with
their values and purpose can provide a sense of meaning and fulfillment” (Damon, 2019).
42
“Encouraging students to reflect on their core values and aspirations can help them gain clarity
about what truly matters to them” (Steger et al., 2019). Pursuing passions and exploring their
own personal growth can lead them to find the real meaning of life after experiencing a handful
of challenges brought by the pandemic. “Encouraging students to take risks and embrace new
272 224
experiences can lead to personal growth and a greater sense of meaning in their lives” (Iasiello et
26
al., 2021). There are still numerous reasons to find the meaning, purpose and drives to continue
overarching goal is to help people feel better emotionally and thrive in life. There are five basic
components to the approach that all work together to promote health and happiness. The model
shows that putting an emphasis on these factors can help people live happier, more contented
lives (Seligman, 2023). It pertains to the perception of attaining objectives and reaching
194
significant milestones that contribute to an individual's holistic state of well-being and sense of
satisfaction. The process entails establishing precise objectives, advancing towards them, and
growth and the acquisition of skills. The significance of participating in activities that require
individuals to push their limits and expand their capabilities is underscored, resulting in
accomplishments and the notion of achievement has been extensively acknowledged as essential
for the psychological well-being and adaptation of individuals. The act of establishing and
attaining objectives has been found to be linked with heightened levels of motivation, self-worth,
and a feeling of direction in one's life (Locke & Latham, 2006). The attainment of goals serves to
furnish individuals with a feeling of purpose and orientation, as well as facilitating progress
27
towards desired objectives. Accomplishments that align with a person's values and interests
59
Participating in activities that hold personal significance and provide a sense of
170
fulfillment contributes to psychological adaptation and subjective well-being. The COVID-19
pandemic has had a multifaceted impact on college students, particularly in terms of their
155
capacity to attain academic achievements. The transition to online education and the subsequent
closure of educational institutions have significantly altered students' academic habits and
155
objectives. The transition to online education and the temporary shutdown of educational
institutions have significantly altered the established academic routines and objectives of
students. Their ability to succeed academically may be hindered by less access to resources,
restricted interaction with peers and teachers, increased stress, and distractions (Browne et al.,
2021). Numerous extracurricular activities and events, encompassing sports, organizations, and
2021). Moreover, the occurrence of the COVID-19 pandemic poses obstacles for students in their
overseas, which traditionally represent noteworthy accomplishments and act as sources of pride
28
167
As we approach the second anniversary of the initial wave of school closures caused by
the epidemic, a return to typical academic conditions continues to elude several kids, instructors,
38
and parents. In addition to growing COVID-19 cases by the end of 2021, schools have
experienced acute staff shortages, high rates of absenteeism and quarantines, and rolling school
closures. In addition, it is worth noting that both students and instructors persistently grapple
with mental health difficulties, heightened occurrences of aggression and misconduct, and
213
apprehensions regarding the loss of instructional time (Kuhfeld et al., 2022). The evidence
suggests that “the outbreak has a detrimental impact on kids' academic performance, which is
consistent with their achievements. Despite the multifaceted impact on students' academic
achievements, there remains a compelling rationale for students to assert themselves and
embrace the opportunities that enable them to attain personal triumphs.” According to research,
college students' psychological reactions to the epidemic have a substantial impact on how they
students' ability to adjust and persist in the face of challenging circumstances (Li et al., 2021). By
developing resilience, students are more effectively prepared to sustain their motivation and
83
effectively manage obstacles, promoting a sense of achievement even in the face of difficult
circumstances. College students showed exceptional flexibility in reframing their objectives and
221
devising alternate strategies to achieve success (Heslop et al., 2020). The concept of academic
resilience capacity refers to the inherent power of students to persevere and enhance their
academic performance in the face of significant challenges or the existence of substantial risk
29
108
factors (Dwiastuti et al., 2022). The COVID-19 pandemic has undeniably caused disruptions to
the conventional routes of achievement for college students. However, these individuals have
demonstrated their ability to persevere, adjust, and utilize available resources in order to navigate
through these difficult circumstances. College students are discovering alternative pathways to
and engaging in online skill development. As the global community navigates the post-pandemic
era, the competencies and proficiencies acquired throughout this period will establish a solid
6
Coping Strategies. Following the assessment of an individual's threat to their well-being
and the available resources to manage the threat, we take into account situations that are
dependent on both situational and individual factors. Coping strategies are applied (Carver et al.,
119
1989, Korbmacher & Wright, 2020). Coping strategies play an important role in the physical and
71
mental health of an individual, especially during adapting to stressful situations. In the
71
transactional theory of stress, stress is about the relationship between an individual and their
environment which they appraise whether or not it is relevant to their well-being. According to
50
Lazarus, he defined coping with stress as “constantly changing cognitive and behavioral efforts
to manage specific external and/or internal demands that are appraised as taxing or exceeding the
62
resources of the person”. Based on the definition, it can also be assumed that coping is dependent
on personality patterns and perceptual experiences. The strategies one chooses for adapting to a
situation are highly individualized. Coping is never the same for two people (Chowdhury, 2023).
135
“It involves conscious, purposeful actions employed when an individual appraises a situation as
30
stressful” (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984 as cited in Biggs, et al. 2017). Coping has two major facets:
153
problem-focused or active coping and emotion-focused or passive coping.
197
Problem-focused. Problem-focused coping involves actively addressing the root causes
of stress, as noted by Ogilvie (2023), who highlights efforts to generate solutions and adopt new
This coping strategy may encompass activities such as seeking advice from objective
Lazarus and Folkman (1988) emphasize that individuals often possess internal and external
resources to effectively manage or diminish stress. In response to the sudden transition to online
learning, students have demonstrated adaptive behaviors by developing time management skills,
seeking academic support, and establishing new study routines, as observed by Smith (2020).
111
These adaptive strategies are consistent with the problem-focused coping approach. Further
support for the efficacy of problem-focused coping comes from Baker (2019), whose research
well-being among students”. Ageing (2015) also emphasizes “the crucial role of
49
problem-focused coping in mitigating the adverse effects of stress on mental health outcomes.”
31
238
challenging circumstances. These studies collectively reinforce the importance and effectiveness
fear, anger, sadness, or shame when they are under emotional stress. They might even have an
excessively strong or insufficient emotional reaction to the circumstances, making them feel
numb or "spaced out." They may attempt to control their emotions in different ways if they are
They might try to understand what’s behind their feelings so they don’t feel so
overwhelmed. They might try to reduce the intensity of their feelings through distraction or
relaxation.
117
Lazarus and Folkman’s transactional model of stress and coping offers a valuable
framework to understand how individuals appraise stressors, employ coping strategies, and
200
Cognitive Appraisal. “cognitive appraisal is a process by which Individuals examine a
48
certain interaction and determine the potential stressors” (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). “Cognitive
appraisal happens when people examine two important aspects that influence how they respond
to stress” (Chishima et. al, 2018). Two views describe the correlation between emotion and
32
97
cognitive appraisal. First, it is said that cognitive appraisal causes emotion. This view suggests
“that the way we interpret the eliciting event determines our emotions” (Yarwood, n.d.). As a
264 207
result, different interpretations of the same event could elicit different emotions.” The second
view is that emotions cause appraisal. Meaning, that cognitive appraisal could be felt after the
48
felt emotion (Yarwood, n.d.). These two factors are the risky characteristics of the stressor to the
person and the assessment of the resources required to minimize, endure, or eliminate the
174
stressor and the stress it causes. Lazarus and Folkman classified it into two kinds: primary
Primary Appraisal. During the primary appraisal, “individuals assess whether or not
there's anything at stake in this encounter. Individuals assess situational demand and personal
119
relevance to decide whether external stressors are threatening or challenging” (Lazarus &
Folkman, 1984) Lazarus and Folkman's theory proposes three main types of evaluation: (1) an
appraisal that the situation is potentially harmful or involves a risk of loss for the person, (2) an
appraisal interaction in which the person feels emotionally or physically threatened, and (3) a
challenge to the assessment that has some form of opportunity for growth or mastery. The most
appraisal, understood as the evaluation of whether the event represents a negative emotional
theory, plays a pivotal role in assessing individuals' resources and options in coping with
33
stressors (Sharifabad, 2020). It serves as a reliable predictor of positive emotional outcomes.
appraisals, reflecting individuals' beliefs in their ability to effectively manage and overcome
future challenges. This process involves a thorough evaluation of available resources to tackle
stressful experiences (Noret, Hunter, & Rasmussen, 2018). For instance, when faced with a poor
grade, undergraduates may initially perceive it as either "annoying" or "important" during the
primary cognitive appraisal phase. Subsequently, they may transition to acknowledging their
capability to "overcome this situation" during the secondary appraisal stage (Chishima et al.,
2018). Extending upon these foundational concepts, recent studies by Velichkovsky (2024) “shed
9
light on the role of secondary appraisal in fostering resilience and adaptive coping mechanisms
in the face of adversity. Velichkovsky's research further emphasizes the significance of secondary
stressors.”
2
Avoidant Coping. Traditionally, “coping has been defined as a special category of
adaptation elicited in normal individuals by unusually taxing circumstances” (Costa, et. al 1996).
The most influential model of psychological stress response is the one proposed by Lazarus and
Folkman (1984). According to the authors, “the process of coping was defined as constantly
changing cognitive and behavioral efforts which are undertaken by an individual in order to deal
with demands which are especially challenging and are probably exceeding individual capacities
1
and/or resources” (Lazarus and Folkman, 1984). “Avoidant coping is characterized by the
34
self-blame” (Better Mind, 2024). “Avoidant Coping is associated with poorer physical health
2
among those with medical conditions”. It suggests that “it would allow a gradual recognition of
the threat, which might also be positive in the case of uncontrollable situations” (Rodríguez, et.
26
al, 1993). Avoidance coping is attempting to remain out of stressful situations instead of handling
them. Although it might seem like avoiding stress is a great way to become less stressed, this
isn't always the case. The majority of the time, the only way to truly lessen the stress that an
158
issue or stressor causes is to face it head-on. Although we can't always avoid stress, we can
manage it with useful coping mechanisms, which is why it aims for "stress management" as
opposed to "stress avoidance". (Scott, 2024). College students were given the Pittsburgh Sleep
Quality Index (PSQI), the Brief COPE, and the PSS. This study supported the well-established
pattern of students reporting high levels of perceived stress. They also discovered a correlation
between higher perceived stress and poorer sleep quality and avoidant coping mechanisms.
66
Numerous other studies have demonstrated the connection between coping strategies and
perceived stress, particularly in students who exhibit higher levels of perceived stress.
25
(Brougham et al., 2009). Lastly, because avoidance coping ignores the underlying causes of
stress and, when overused, exacerbates anxiety and tension, it is generally considered unhealthy
and ineffective. The majority of avoidant coping strategies are attempts to obtain short-term
stress relief, even when doing so exacerbates the situation over time. According to research,
avoidance coping has a number of negative effects, such as increased stress, lowered self-esteem,
35
Conceptual Framework
7
Figure 1. Conceptual Framework on the Post-Pandemic Coping Strategies and Psychological
240
In implementing an Sequential Explanatory Design, the sample population was calculated
using the sample size calculator (Calculator.net, 2024) resulting in 248 participants for the
quantitative phase. This phase aimed to collect comprehensive data on demographic information
255
and assess participants' coping strategies and well-being in the aftermath of the pandemic.
quantitative analysis. The obtained quantitative data underwent rigorous correlation analysis,
244
offering a statistical perspective on the variables involved in the study.
Following this, the study seamlessly transitioned to the qualitative phase, engaging
participants through focus groups and in-depth interviews. For this phase, we conducted focus
31
groups with 10 participants. This qualitative exploration was designed to provide a nuanced
36
understanding of the challenges students faced during the transition to online learning. Thematic
analysis was applied to extract meaningful patterns and themes from the qualitative dialogues.
182
The interpretation of the study's findings was systematically conducted, following the
252
principles of the Sequential Explanatory Design. The integration of qualitative and quantitative
Theoretical Framework
The post-pandemic era has brought forth a significant need to understand students'
51
Coping Strategies and Psychological well-being (Heliyon, 2023). The theoretical underpinnings
71
of the current study were anchored on the Transactional model of Stress and Coping Theory and
160
PERMA Model.
Lazarus and Folkman’s transactional model of stress and coping (1984) has been
49
instrumental in understanding Coping Strategies. It emphasizes cognitive appraisal, involving
primary and secondary appraisal. Primary appraisal evaluates stressors as threats or challenges,
276 126
while secondary appraisal assesses coping resources. Coping strategies include problem-focused
coping, which addresses the stressor directly, and emotion-focused coping, which regulates
92
emotional responses. “Avoidance coping, also referred to as avoidant coping, avoidance
behaviors, or escape coping, is an effective method of coping where an individual alters their
actions to steer clear of confronting, feeling, or dealing with challenging situations” (Scott,2024).
By recognizing the pivotal role of cognitive appraisal and the subjective nature of stress, their
37
framework sheds light on how individuals not only cope with stressors but also cope
psychologically. The emphasis on perception and interpretation aligns with the process of
Coping Strategies, illustrating how individuals, armed with coping, can effectively navigate and
178
find equilibrium in the face of life's challenges (Biggs,2024).
Inversely, The PERMA model developed by Seligman (2011) will provide a deeper
59
comprehension of students' well-being. It emphasizes five key elements: Positive Emotion,
emotions and sustaining meaningful relationships. By employing the PERMA model, the current
47
study encourages a profound knowledge of how fostering positive emotions, engagement in
meaningful activities, and nurturing social connections can contribute to students' post-pandemic
psychological well-being.
With the integration of the two theories, the researchers posit that students who
demonstrate high resilience are better equipped to engage with the dimensions of PERMA. For
instance, students may be more capable of building and maintaining meaningful relationships or
38
Chapter 3
Research Methodology
Research Design
68
The researchers employed an Sequential Explanatory Design to assess the Psychological
Well-Being and Coping Strategies of college students in Metro Manila. Initially, quantitative data
were gathered using Likert scale surveys – specifically, the Brief-COPE Scale comprising 28
items and PERMA-Profiler with 23 items, both acknowledged for their reliability (Riope, 2019).
This quantitative phase involved a sample of 384 participants and was distributed online using
google forms. After filtering out ineligible respondents, the final sample size was 248,
For the qualitative phase, researchers conducted focus group discussions with 10
incorporating these dual methodologies, as suggested by Bhandari (2020), the researchers aimed
to comprehensively explore the research topic from various perspectives. After conducting the
24
focus group discussions, the qualitative data obtained were transcribed and analyzed using
13
thematic analysis. Themes and patterns emerging from the data were identified and interpreted to
67
complement and enrich the quantitative findings, offering deeper insights into the psychological
well-being and coping strategies of college students in Metro Manila. This Sequential
Explanatory Design approach enhanced the overall quality of the study and ensured a thorough
206
and nuanced understanding of the psychological well-being and coping strategies of college
39
Population, Sample Size and Sampling Technique
37
Quantitative Phase. For the quantitative survey portion of the study, the researchers
targeted college students enrolled in universities within Metro Manila. Initially, they aimed to
recruit 384 participants but finalized a sample size of 248 after filtering out ineligible
respondents. The sampling technique employed was purposive sampling, ensuring that
participants met specific criteria relevant to the study. This deliberate selection method allowed
the researchers to focus on individuals who could provide valuable insights into the research
topic.
17
Purposive sampling is widely recognized in research for its effectiveness in selecting
participants who possess the characteristics or experiences relevant to the study's objectives
17
(Heath, 2024). By using purposive sampling, researchers can strategically gather data from
individuals who can offer in-depth understanding and perspectives on the phenomena under
focus group with a sample of 10 participants selected from the pool of 248 survey respondents.
The focus group comprised college students within Metro Manila who met predefined inclusion
criteria, ensuring that participants could offer relevant and detailed perspectives. Randomized
sampling was employed to deliberately select individuals who could provide insightful data
40
Face-to-face focus group discussions are often considered more effective than other
used a dual moderator type of focus group discussion. In this method, two moderators perform
138
different roles within the focus group. “One moderator ensures a smooth progression of the
session while the other one ensures that all of the topics will be covered” (Nyumba et. al., 2018).
This is because face-to-face interactions allow participants to pick up on nonverbal cues and
body language, facilitating deeper understanding and communication (Wooll, 2022). Moreover,
the immediacy and presence in face-to-face discussions can enhance rapport and trust among
participants, thereby enriching the qualitative data collection process (Horsfall, 2021).
goals of the study, improving the validity and profundity of the qualitative findingsStewart,
2024).
270
Research Locale
The study was carried out in the Philippines within Metro Manila. Survey forms were
distributed via online Google Forms to universities in Metro Manila, consisting of quantitative
10
scales. After gathering the quantitative data, the researchers invited the selected 10 participants
to participate in the focus group discussion. The participants were gathered at the Lyman C.
Ogilby Hall at Trinity University of Asia. The researchers believed that by using these
distribution and participation strategies, the participants would be able to comprehend the
41
psychological challenges and changes that college students faced in the post-pandemic era, as
well as the factors that influenced their process of adjustment. The entire 2023–2024 academic
254
year was utilized for the execution of this study.
Research Instrument
Quantitative Phase: In the initial stage of the sequential explanatory design, two scales
191
were administered: the Brief COPE scale, comprising 28 items with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.82,
68
and the PERMA Profiler, comprising 23 items with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.91. The intended
104
sample size was 384 college students from Metro Manila. However, following the exclusion of
participants who did not meet the predefined criteria, the final sample size comprised 248
124
respondents. The removal of ineligible participants was deemed essential to safeguard the
validity and reliability of the data, as their inclusion could potentially introduce bias and
The survey was conducted using Google Forms, accompanied by a consent form to
ensure participants' informed consent. This inclusion of a consent form was imperative to
guarantee that participants fully understood the study's nature, their rights, and the confidentiality
Attitude and rating scales, widely employed in various disciplines including sociology,
104
psychology, and information systems, were utilized in this study. Participants were asked to rate
110
their degree of agreement with the statements provided using the Likert scale, which was
228
developed by Rensis Likert in 1932 and ranges from strongly agree to strongly disagree.
42
83
(Taherdoost, 2019). Carver's (1997) Brief COPE scale, featuring a 4-point response option, was
utilized to assess a broad spectrum of coping responses among students. Furthermore, the
PERMA Profiler developed by Martin Seligman (2011), utilizing a 10-point response option,
select 10 participants for the subsequent qualitative phase's focus group discussion. This
selection process aimed to ensure that participants in the qualitative phase represented the
4
broader sample, thereby facilitating a comprehensive understanding of the research questions.
Qualitative Phase: participants were selected via random sampling, ensuring alignment
with specific study criteria. Selected participants were tasked with responding to a series of
were designed to last only 1-2 hours, ensuring participants were not excessively questioned.
Utilizing focus group methodology, the qualitative phase aimed to delve into student
perceptions effectively. Focus groups, according to George (2023), unearth the opinions, beliefs,
and ideas of individuals who share common attributes. Emphasizing the importance of a relaxed
and open environment for discussion, Kaluza (2023) further accentuated the need for facilitators
to foster such an atmosphere. For this phase, an onsite focus group was conducted, enabling
accessibility to a diverse range of participants across different geographic regions, time zones,
43
The focus group was held in Lyman C. Ogilby Hall at Trinity University of Asia. All
students enrolled in universities within Metro Manila, aged between 19-29 years, and with at
least two years of residency in the Philippines, were eligible to participate. Initially, researchers
emailed the 10 selected respondents to confirm their availability for the focus group session.
195
Before the actual discussion, participants were asked to sign a consent form to ensure that their
participation was protected and confidential. Informed consent, anonymity, and data storage were
crucial considerations before focus group discussion (Kang, 2023). Participants provided
informed consent to join the focus group (Kang, 2023), and their names were anonymized to
ensure privacy and encourage candidness. To protect the identities of professors, participants
were instructed not to mention specific classes or teacher names. Data from the face-to-face
107
focus groups were recorded electronically, transcribed, and analyzed using thematic analysis.
Themes and codes were developed from the data, and results from the questionnaire were
analyzed for categories and themes, which were then subsequently clustered together. All data
After providing informed consent, the selected participants were assisted by the group
facilitators in being seated at the designated location to begin the actual discussion. These
118
respondents were chosen based on their responses to the quantitative questionnaire.
Face-to-face focus group discussions are typically more impactful compared to written or
audio-only interactions. This is attributed to the ability to observe nonverbal cues and body
44
mutual understanding among participants (Wooll, 2022). This in-person method also enables
facilitators to better manage group dynamics and foster a more cohesive discussion.
Validated questions, which encouraged participants to express their ideas comfortably (Baba,
2022).
72
For the quantitative analysis in this study, two established scales were utilized: the Brief
176
The Brief COPE scale, designed to assess coping strategies, demonstrated good internal
consistency reliability with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.814. This suggests that the scale items
145
reliably measure various coping strategies among the respondents, with the Cronbach's alpha
slightly increasing to 0.822 based on standardized items. With 28 items comprising the scale, its
239
reliability suggests that it effectively captures the nuances of coping behaviors employed by
college students within Metro Manila. Each dimension represents moderate to high coping
strategies of the students. Researchers can confidently use this scale to explore and analyze
157
different coping mechanisms such as problem-focused, emotion-focused, and avoidant coping
45
The PERMA scale, designed to measure dimensions of psychological well-being,
68
demonstrated excellent internal consistency reliability with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.907. This
high alpha coefficient indicates strong coherence among the scale items, reflecting consistent
185
measurement of positive emotion, engagement, relationships, meaning, and accomplishment
256
among the respondents. The Cronbach's alpha based on standardized items further supports this
reliability, slightly increasing to 0.913. With 23 items in the scale, its strong internal consistency
250
suggests that it effectively captures the multidimensional aspects of psychological well-being
experienced by college students in Metro Manila post-pandemic. Researchers can rely on this
scale to assess and analyze the various facets of psychological well-being and their associations
with coping strategies, providing valuable insights into student mental health outcomes during
challenging times.
Quantitative Phase. The researchers opted for purposive sampling with the intention of
selecting participants according to particular qualities that are pertinent to the study (Heath,
2023). The chosen assessment tools, including the Brief cope for coping strategies (Carver, C. S.
1997) and the PERMA model for assessing overall well-being, were distributed via Google
Forms (Kovich, 2022), helping to create a thorough understanding of the mental health of those
surveyed. To uphold ethical standards, formal permission was obtained, and participants were
assured of confidentiality. The researchers initially sent invitation emails to college students
whom they knew personally and who met the study's criteria. Additionally, the survey was
46
posted on an online platform, specifically the "Thesis Questionnaire Filing Group," targeting
college students enrolled in universities within Metro Manila. This group operated on a
survey-swapping basis, allowing participants to exchange surveys without the need for tokens,
although either party could decline participation if the criteria were not met.
241
A follow-up message was also sent to remind participants to complete the survey. Upon
responding to the survey, students received a message thanking them for their time and
collected, including gender, age, year level, and student status (e.g., regular or irregular).
After collecting the data, the researchers used Microsoft Excel to tally the results. This
involved organizing the responses into categories and calculating frequencies and percentages for
each demographic. Finally, the researchers conducted statistical analyses to interpret the findings
participants who could provide relevant and insightful data (Palinkas et al., 2020; Mertens &
216
Wilson, 2023). Randomized sampling, also known as probability sampling, is a sampling method
that selects a portion of a target population randomly where researchers intentionally select
participants randomly from a larger set. This method is used to ensure that the sample includes
118
individuals who are best suited to provide relevant and detailed information related to the
research question (Johnson et al., 2020). Out of the 248 participants who answered the survey, 10
47
210
respondents were chosen for the focus group based on their survey responses. Informed consent
Participants were assured that their identities would be completely anonymous, which is
crucial for protecting the confidentiality and integrity of the data, especially since the data
originated from the researchers' home organization (Creswell, 2022). To maintain anonymity, the
researchers disaggregated the names of participants. Initially, students were informed about the
value of their participation in understanding the process of online education and the benefits of
interacting with others who share similar experiences. They were also briefed on the significance
3
of their perspectives regarding post-pandemic coping strategies and psychological well-being.
After the focus group discussion, the researchers provided snack tokens as a gesture of
appreciation for their participation. This approach ensured that the qualitative data collected was
13
both rich and relevant, offering a deeper understanding of the challenges and coping mechanisms
interviews or focus group discussions, thematic coding was applied to identify recurring themes
and patterns. A comprehensive codebook was developed to guide the coding process. The entire
dataset was then coded, and data reduction techniques were applied to summarize and highlight
key themes. This process ensured a thorough exploration of qualitative insights (Abbadia, 2023).
The researchers opted for deductive analysis which follows a theory which served as a theme.
48
120
Data Analysis Procedures
Manila. Initially, descriptive analysis was utilized to summarize the sample characteristics and
measure various aspects of the research variables. The raw responses from survey questionnaires
were systematically organized and translated into numerical values using tools such as Google
Sheets and Excel, facilitating efficient data handling and preparation for statistical analysis.
To ensure the appropriateness of subsequent statistical tests, the data underwent normality
128
testing using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Shapiro-Wilk tests. These tests are standard methods
used to assess whether data distributions adhere to a normal curve. Results from these tests
Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistics ranging from 0.064 to 0.130 and Shapiro-Wilk statistics ranging
161
from 0.924 to 0.988, all with associated p-values below the conventional significance level of
.05. Furthermore, descriptive statistics including mean and standard deviation were computed for
277
each research variable. This provided insights into the central tendency (mean) and variability
(standard deviation) of the data points across all variables examined. Specifically, the mean
67
scores for Problem-focused Coping (PFC), Emotion-focused Coping (EFC), Avoidant Coping
28
(AC), Positive Emotion (PosEm), Engagement (Engagement), Relationship (Relationship),
Meaning, and Accomplishment fell within the ranges of 2.25 to 7.24, highlighting the varying
49
Subsequently, the researchers utilized Pearson product-moment correlation analysis,
conducted using SPSS software, to explore relationships between coping strategies (PFC, EFC,
(PFC) showing positive correlations with all well-being dimensions, Emotion-Focused Coping
(EFC) correlating positively with Engagement, Relationship, and Meaning, and Avoidant Coping
These findings underscore the utility of both descriptive and correlational analyses in
7
elucidating the relationships between coping strategies and psychological well-being among
4
college students in Metro Manila post-pandemic. The robustness of these analyses ensures a
insights for future research and practical interventions aimed at promoting mental health in
educational settings.
Ethical Considerations
Researchers value the comfortability and well-being of participants; thus, they ensure that
they will conduct the data gathering with integrity. In addition, the TUA-IERC will also be
involved in the process of reviewing and ensuring the safety and identity of the participants.
Prior to answering the survey, participants will have to sign the consent letter to protect their
232
identity and privacy. If the participants wish to withdraw from the study, they are free to do so
50
after answering the withdrawal letter. Both letters are provided to assure participants that their
of their identity and the assurance that their answers will only be used for academic purposes and
for this particular study only. Participants will not be subjected to any physical or psychological
activities during the course of the data gathering. Their answers will be greatly helpful for the
future of this study and for the better understanding of the students who experienced a pandemic.
144
Informed Consent
The informed consent was provided to the college students within Metro Manila prior to
43
the survey, in accordance with the research. This served as an agreement for participation in the
study. The confidentiality and intervention of the study, as well as the details and responsibilities
of the researchers, were all covered in accordance with the consent. Finally, the consent form
This functioned as an outline for the entire procedure. The researchers assessed
Also included were the signature, date, and the names of the researchers.
51
137
Chapter 4
The findings, analysis, and interpretation of data collected using the instruments used in
this study are presented in this chapter. In response to the problems mentioned in Chapter 1, the
Quantitative Result
1
Problem 1. What is the profile of the respondents in terms of:
1.1 Age:
1.2 Gender: ▢ M ▢F
Age 19 27 11
20 43 17
21 70 28
52
22 61 25
23 26 10
24 10 4
25 7 3
26 2 1
27 2 1
28 0 0
29 0 0
248 100
Sex Male 63 25
Female 185 75
248 100
2nd year 45 18
3rd year 92 37
4th year 83 33
248 100
Irregular 0 0
248 100
10
Table 1. Demographic Profile of the Participants
53
that the majority of participants are between 19 and 23 years old, with the highest frequencies
observed at ages 21 (28%) and 22 (25%). This concentration within a relatively narrow age range
indicates a cohort largely composed of young adults in the early stages of their college education.
Notably, participants aged 24 to 29 represent smaller percentages, with ages 28 and 29 having no
11
Regarding gender, the majority of participants are female, comprising 75% of the total
sample, while male participants account for 25%. This gender distribution reflects a typical trend
in higher education contexts where female students often outnumber male students.
In terms of year level, the participants are distributed across various stages of their
academic journey. The largest groups are in the 3rd year (37%) and 4th year (33%), indicating a
significant presence of upperclassmen in the sample. Additionally, there are participants from the
1st year (11%) and 2nd year (18%), providing a diverse representation of academic progression
265
among college students in Metro Manila. All participants are classified as regular students,
highlighting that they are enrolled full-time in their respective academic programs. This
classification excludes irregular students from the study, ensuring a focus on students who follow
130
These demographic insights are crucial for understanding the characteristics and
composition of the study sample, which is essential for interpreting findings related to
180
psychological well-being and coping strategies among college students in Metro Manila.
54
Quantitative Result
a. Problem-Focused Coping
b. Emotion-Focused Coping
c. Avoidant Coping
10
Figure 6. Level of the Respondents’ Coping in Terms of Problem-focused, Emotion-focused
The Brief COPE Inventory assesses various coping strategies across multiple dimensions,
43
revealing how people handle stress. In terms of student coping strategies, the findings for the
92
three primary dimensions—Problem-Focused Coping, Emotion-Focused Coping, and Avoidant
261
Problem-Focused Coping. The result of Problem-focused dimension includes strategies
163
for directly addressing and resolving stressors, has a mean score of 3.17 and a standard deviation
of 0.55. This high mean indicates that students primarily use problem-solving strategies, such as
55
planning, seeking instrumental support, and actively addressing the issues that cause stress. The
relatively low standard deviation suggests that the students surveyed used these strategies
consistently.
strategies for managing the emotional response to stress, and has an average score of 2.88. This
186
high mean indicates that students frequently use emotion-focused coping strategies, such as
seeking emotional support, venting, and using positive reframing. Although not as high as the
Avoidant Coping. The result of the Avoidant coping dimension includes strategies for
268
avoiding dealing with stress directly, such as denial, substance use, and behavioral
156
disengagement, has a mean score of 2.25 and a standard deviation of 0.52. This moderate mean
251
indicates that, while students use avoidant strategies, it is to a lesser extent than problem-focused
and emotion-focused strategies. The moderate use of avoidant coping strategies indicates that,
while not the primary methods used by students, they do form part of their overall coping skills.
which are closely followed by methods for managing their emotions. Avoidant coping strategies
are used less frequently, indicating a more balanced approach in which students prefer to
confront and manage stress directly rather than avoid it. This pattern of coping strategies
56
demonstrates the students' proactive and constructive approach to dealing with stress in both
74
Problem 3. Psychological Well-Being
a. Positive Emotion
b. Engagement
c. Relationships
d. Meaning
e. Accomplishments
2
Figure 7. Level of the Respondents’ Psychological Well-being in Terms of Positive Emotion,
102
PERMA is a model of well-being developed by psychologist Martin Seligman,
177
representing five essential elements that contribute to a fulfilling and flourishing life. Positive
Emotion, Engagement, Relationship, Meaning, and Accomplishment are the five dimensions of
110
coping that are shown in the table along with their mean scores, standard deviations (SD), and
57
qualitative descriptions. Every component is assessed to comprehend how people are handling or
1
Positive Emotions. The mean of 6.89 and the standard deviation of 1.77 indicate a
significant level of analysis in the results. High levels of positive emotions have been described
246
by respondents as a coping strategy. Although there is some variation in the responses, as
indicated by the relatively high standard deviation, the overall mean indicates that most people
166
Engagement. High levels of engagement, with a mean of 7.21 and a standard deviation
of 1.44, indicate that respondents are actively involved and turn to their interests and hobbies as a
coping mechanism. A lower standard deviation suggests that respondent's coping mechanisms
Relationship. Strong results in the relationship dimensions with mean 7.24 and standard
deviation 1.85, imply that support and relationships with respondents have significance for
coping. The higher standard deviation indicates that there is an extensive amount of variability
among the ways that respondents view or apply relationships as a coping mechanism.
Meaning. Another high-scoring dimension with mean of 7.08 and standard deviation
32
1.75 in finding meaning in experiences and situations in life. This suggests that respondents find
58
meaning in life as a coping mechanism for stress. There is some variability in this dimension, as
128
Accomplishments. The results indicate that the respondents had a high sense of
accomplishment with mean of 7.15 and standard deviation of 1.48, suggesting the importance of
acceptable level of consistency among respondents in this area, as indicated by the moderate
standard deviation.
The study participants generally report strong coping mechanisms across various
dimensions, as evidenced by the high ratings for all five coping dimensions. Since the means
vary from 6.89 to 7.24, it is unlikely that any one dimension is significantly higher or lower than
the others. This thorough high score across the board suggests that the participants have a
well-rounded coping strategy. While Positive Emotion and Relationship are more consistently
used across individuals, Engagement and Accomplishment tend to be less consistently used, as
59
188
Problem 4. Is there a significant relationship between the respondents’:
a. Coping Strategies
b. Psychological Well-Being
3
The correlation Matrix shows significant relationships between the respondents' coping
strategies and various dimensions of psychological well-being. The following sections will detail
these correlations, demonstrating how increases in dimensions of Brief Cope are associated with
dimensions of psychological well-being. The Pearson correlation coefficients for PFC with
125
Positive Emotion, Engagement, Relationship Quality, Meaning, and Accomplishment range from
0.421 to 0.507, with all p-values less than 0.01. This suggests that students who engage in
60
problem-focused coping strategies, which involve actively addressing and solving problems, tend
229
to have higher levels of positive emotions, are more engaged in activities, maintain better quality
248
relationships, find greater meaning in life, and feel a stronger sense of accomplishment (Walinga,
2014).
On the other hand, Emotion-focused Coping (EFC )presents a more nuanced picture. EFC
142
shows significant positive correlations with Engagement (r = 0.160, p < .05), Relationship
Quality (r = 0.141, p < .05), Meaning (r = 0.146, p < .05), and Accomplishment (r = 0.173, p <
.01). However, it does not significantly correlate with Positive Emotion (r = 0.091, p = .152).
211
This indicates that while emotion-focused coping, which involves “managing emotional
responses to stress, can enhance interpersonal relationships and a sense of achievement, it might
-0.164 to -0.210, with all p-values less than 0.01. This suggests that students who tend to avoid
or deny stressors experience lower levels of positive emotions, are less engaged, have poorer
quality relationships, find less meaning in life, and feel less accomplished. Thus, avoidant coping
93
These findings highlight the important role of coping strategies in shaping the
beneficial across various well-being dimensions, while avoidant coping shows consistent
61
negative effects. Emotion-focused coping has selective positive effects, particularly in relational
and achievement domains. These insights can inform interventions aimed at promoting effective
8
coping strategies to enhance psychological well-being among students in post-pandemic
contexts.
Qualitative Result
Triangulation Data
sources or methods to enhance accuracy and reliability (Creswell & Miller, 2000). Member
checking, a key aspect of triangulation, involves validating data with participants to ensure its
alignment with their experiences or perspectives (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). Additionally,
integrating insights from existing literature provides a broader context for understanding the
phenomenon under study (Patton, 2002). Subject matter experts contribute valuable insights that
complement the data analysis process, enriching the interpretation of findings (Miles &
Huberman, 1994). To maintain accuracy, it's essential to cite information from reputable sources,
ensuring the credibility of the research (Polit & Beck, 2017). In simple terms, triangulation
means using different angles or approaches to confirm and strengthen research conclusions. By
combining member checking, literature review, and subject matter expertise, researchers can
87
In the Qualitative Findings, “a combination of thematic analysis and deductive analysis
was employed to examine the data collected from focus groups” (Braun & Clarke, 2006).
62
42
“Thematic analysis helped identify recurring patterns and themes in the qualitative data,
222
providing a deep understanding of participants' perspectives and experiences” (Faster Cap,
2024). Deductive analysis involved applying established theories to the transcribed data,
115
specifically the PERMA model (Seligman, 2011) and the Transactional Stress and Coping
Theory (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). By integrating these theories into the analysis, the research
aimed to understand how participants' experiences and coping strategies related to these
established psychological theories. This approach allowed for a nuanced exploration of the
research topic, shedding light on both emerging themes and their connections to established
psychological theories.
PERMA
and sense of fulfillment. “I would say, mataas yung motivation ko since, nakakapag isip
isip ako.” This statement highlights the intrinsic motivation experienced by an individual,
indicating a strong sense of drive and purpose derived from their internal thoughts and
encompasses various constructs, including ability self-concepts, task values, goals, and
achievement motives.
● "Na ma-motivate yung sarili ko". According to Davidovitch and Dorot (2023),
"Motivation drives a person and leads them to achieve their goals and behave in a certain
63
way" (p. X). This assertion encapsulates the essence of motivation as a dynamic force
motivation is not merely a transient feeling but a deliberate choice individuals make to
pursue their aspirations. Moreover, Davidovitch and Dorot's findings highlight the
process of maturation that accompanies aging. This suggests that as individuals grow
older, their motivational drive tends to increase, further reinforcing the positive focused
● "Nagkaron akong time for myself" underscores the importance of self-care and dedicating
9
personal time to activities that nurture positive emotions (Smith et al., 2021). During
times of heightened stress and uncertainty, such as the pandemic, self-care becomes
relaxation, hobbies, and personal reflection can effectively enhance positive emotions and
serve as a buffer against stressors (Smith et al., 2021). “By actively cultivating positive
225
emotions, individuals can develop effective coping mechanisms to navigate stressors
Theme 2: Engagement
● "Nandun pa rin yung excitement ko na makipag usap sa ibang tao honestly" signifies an
64
Socialization serves as a process through which individuals learn to adapt to group
● "Lahat finifriends ko ganon, parang lahat kinoclose ko" reflects the importance of
friendship in fostering well-being and satisfaction in life. Choi et al. (2020) conducted a
study demonstrating that individuals with friends and close confidants tend to report
higher life satisfaction and lower rates of depression. Friendships provide emotional
136
support, companionship, and a sense of belonging, which are essential for overall
psychological health. The statement also alludes to the formation of new friendships
isolation and loneliness (Smith et al., 2021). Abrams (2023) suggests that the initiation of
acquaintanceships can lead to positive outcomes for individuals. These connections can
● The statement "Siguro yung.. naging coping strategy ko is..yung pag meet ng friends sa
labas" suggests that socializing with friends outside serves as a coping mechanism for the
individual. This coping strategy can be explored within the context of engagement in the
65
88
crucial for coping with stress and adversity. Research indicates that “social support
buffers the negative impact of stressful life events and promotes psychological resilience”
(Thoits, 2011). Engaging in social activities with friends allows individuals to share
experiences, receive emotional support, and gain perspective on their challenges, thereby
Theme 3: Relationship
● The statement "Socially, I was dependent on my social friends" suggests a strong reliance
on social relationships for support and companionship. Dependence on social friends can
6
be an indicator of a supportive social network, which plays a crucial role in promoting
friends enhances relationship satisfaction, buffers against stress, and fosters emotional
● The statement "Nung nag post-pandemic, parang, sa school, like in terms of the people in
school, gigil ako magkaroon ng, like, interaction with friends" reflects a desire for social
interaction and connection following the pandemic, particularly within the school
environment. The eagerness to interact with friends post-pandemic reflects resilience and
22
adaptive coping mechanisms in response to social challenges. Resilience refers to the
ability to bounce back from adversity and adapt positively to life changes (Masten, 2001).
Seeking social interaction with friends demonstrates a proactive approach to coping with
the social disruptions caused by the pandemic, indicating a capacity for social adaptation
66
● The statement "Nung nag F2F na, nung first meet na naming lahat, dun ko sila parang
mas nakilala ganun. Mas nag-bond kami tas naging close" describes the experience of
and interpersonal rapport (Tidwell & Walther, 2002). Meeting in person allows
52
individuals to pick up on subtle cues, such as facial expressions and body language,
Theme 4: Meaning
● "Nung pandemic, lahat ng tao natuto maging malinis" reflects the widespread adoption of
95
hygiene practices during the COVID-19 pandemic. “In the early stages of the pandemic,
there was heightened concern about the transmission of the virus through surfaces and
awareness regarding personal hygiene practices. The pandemic served as a catalyst for
settings but also in everyday life. However, it's essential to acknowledge that while the
(UNICEF, 2021).
67
● "So, binigyan ako ng time na makapag isip isip, ganyan. and then, nag pursue na ako ng
6
psychology" reflects an individual's journey towards finding meaning and purpose in life,
personal goals and encompasses contributing to something larger than oneself, fostering a
deep sense of fulfillment and resilience. Research by Heintzelman and King (2014)
199
supports the notion that individuals who perceive their lives as meaningful are more
87
likely to experience positive mental health outcomes, including lower levels of
● The statement "Ayun yung nakapagpabago sakin ng perspective ko na, kaya, na mag
psychology nalang. so far, hindi ko naman siya pinagsisisihan” reflects the transformative
impact of a career decision on the individual's perspective and sense of fulfillment. This
sentiment can be examined within the context of career decision-making and its
implications for well-being and personal satisfaction. A meaningful career not only
fulfills economic needs but also aligns with personal values and contributes to a broader
sense of purpose (Duffy & Dik, 2013). During the pandemic, many people re-evaluated
their career paths, seeking professions that provided greater personal satisfaction and a
understand human behavior and help others, which can be profoundly fulfilling. This
249
aligns with research suggesting that careers in helping professions are often associated
with higher levels of job satisfaction and perceived meaning (Allan et al., 2015).
68
Theme 5: Accomplishment
comprehension and engagement with the subject matter. This sentiment can be explored
within the context of academic growth and the pursuit of knowledge, which are integral
components of the "accomplishment" aspect of the PERMA profiler. Research has shown
happiness. When students achieve their academic goals, they experience a sense of
fulfillment that positively impacts their mental health and overall well-being (Butler &
Kern, 2016). This sense of achievement can serve as a motivator for continued effort and
● The statement "alam mo yun kahit ano mangyari lagi pa rin may business. Kumikita ka
pa rin kahit ano mangyari. Kaya ito na yung pinursue ko as my college degree" reflects
the individual's recognition of the resilience and financial stability associated with
skills and experiences gained from entrepreneurship are transferable to various aspects of
professional life. This entrepreneurial success can inform and enhance academic pursuits,
131
leading to a more comprehensive educational experience (Komarraju et al., 2009).
● The statement "nakakapag isip isip ako. and, gusto ko na yung course ko" indicates a
sense of introspection and satisfaction with the individual's chosen course of study. The
well-being. Achieving goals and finding satisfaction in one's course of study enhances
self-esteem and reduces stress. This positive psychological state is essential for
69
215
maintaining motivation and resilience in the face of academic challenges (Bandura,
1997). Moreover, the feeling of accomplishment from liking and committing to a course
can improve overall life satisfaction and happiness. It fosters a positive outlook on the
future and encourages continued personal and professional growth. This holistic sense of
2011).
Coping Strategies
● Research indicates that effective time management skills significantly influence academic
success among students (Lee, 2020). The ability to set and adhere to a schedule is
the participant's statement, "Siguro, isa sa pinaka nakatulong sa akin is yung magseset
actively addressing stressors and taking direct action to manage them (Lazarus &
Folkman, 1984). Research by Thompson and colleagues (2018) suggests that students
227
who effectively manage their stressors tend to experience lower levels of academic stress
● Engaging in hobbies has been recognized as a beneficial practice for enhancing mental
health and overall well-being. “I started doing my hobbies more.” Enjoyable leisure
70
activities have been extensively studied in the literature, with findings consistently
showing their positive association with various psychosocial and physical measures
affecting health and well-being (Pressman et al., 2009). Participating in hobbies not only
provides individuals with a source of enjoyment and fulfillment but also contributes to
217
their overall sense of happiness and life satisfaction. Moreover, research by Mak et al.
(2023) highlights the social benefits of engaging in hobby groups, emphasizing their role
in fostering social support networks and reducing feelings of loneliness and social
isolation. By dedicating more time to hobbies, individuals can proactively seek out
enjoyable and meaningful activities that serve as effective distractions from stressors and
engagement in hobbies a valuable strategy for coping with stress and promoting
psychological resilience.
10
● Engaging in activities such as journaling has been recognized as an effective coping
emotions, gain clarity on their feelings, and develop insights into their experiences (Klein
& Boals, 2001). Through journaling, individuals can identify and confront their stressors,
explore potential solutions, and develop effective coping strategies to deal with them.
Studies have shown that regular journaling can lead to improvements in emotional
71
well-being, stress reduction, and enhanced problem-solving abilities (Pennebaker &
Beall, 1986). Moreover, journaling has been associated with increased self-awareness,
● The statement "kahit papaano naging lesson naman yung pandemic ngayon" reflects the
learned (Garnefski et al., 2001). This coping mechanism allows individuals to transform
Garnefski et al. (2001) supports the notion that positive reinterpretation facilitates
events. Viewing adversity through the lens of learning and growth contributes to
growth (2004). By acknowledging the lessons gleaned from the pandemic, individuals
adopt a constructive perspective that promotes emotional well-being and adaptive coping.
● The statement "sobrang stressful nung pandemic" encapsulates the profound emotional
127
toll experienced during the COVID-19 pandemic. The widespread disruption caused by
the pandemic significantly heightened stress, anxiety, and uncertainty for individuals
worldwide. This sentiment aligns with the findings of numerous studies “highlighting the
12
unprecedented psychological challenges brought about by the pandemic” (Smith et al.,
72
8
2021). Emotion-focused coping strategies play a vital role in promoting psychological
well-being by helping individuals manage and regulate their emotions amidst adversity
133
(Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). By employing such strategies, individuals can mitigate the
from mental health professionals (Linehan, 2018). Additionally, building coping skills
and fostering self-awareness can empower individuals to recognize and address triggers
● The statement “Hindi ako nakikipag socialize talaga.” reflects a profound reluctance to
73
perspectives and behaviors. However, persistent avoidance of socializing activities may
hinder this developmental process, limiting opportunities for interpersonal growth and
129
connection. Daily reports suggest that repeated experiences play a crucial role in shaping
individuals grappling with avoidant coping may struggle to realize these benefits,
significantly impact an individual's social and emotional well-being. “Nag struggle ako
17
mag make friends nung face-to-face.” Social interaction plays a crucial role in shaping
one's learning experiences, with active participation in classroom discussions and group
activities fostering collaborative learning environments (Hurst et al., 2013). However, for
some individuals, such as the participant mentioned, difficulties in socializing may result
avoidance behaviors (Compas et al., 2001). When individuals struggle to make friends or
engage socially, they may resort to avoiding social interactions altogether to protect
themselves from potential rejection or discomfort. This avoidance behavior can further
exacerbate feelings of loneliness and isolation, creating a cycle of social withdrawal and
124
negative emotions.In light of the participant's struggle with making friends in face-to-face
74
● Struggling to engage in conversations even until now reflects ongoing challenges in
social interaction that can profoundly impact an individual's sense of belonging and
connection with others (Basaran & Demir, 2017). “Hanggang ngayon nag struggle pa rin
avoidance behaviors (Compas et al., 2001). When individuals struggle with social
interactions, they may adopt avoidant coping strategies to shield themselves from
isolation and hinder opportunities for social connection, further exacerbating the sense of
9
loneliness and disconnection experienced by the individual. Recognizing the profound
The joint display table is a reliable and effective tool for sequential explanatory design,
facilitating the integration of quantitative and qualitative data. Research by Teddlie and
Tashakkori (2009) supports its utility in synthesizing diverse data sources, leading to deeper
insights and more robust conclusions. Integration of the results below indicates high levels across
75
all dimensions of PERMA, correlating with qualitative findings of enhanced well-being.
Additionally, the Brief COPE dimension interpretation reveals high scores for problem-focused
coping strategies and moderate scores for avoidant coping, further emphasizing positive
psychological outcomes.
Result Description
PERMA Scale
85
Positive Emotion High 1. Finding motivation from within oneself can
76
person and leads them to achieve their goals and
et al., 2021).
77
Engagement High 1. "Nandun pa rin yung excitement ko na makipag usap
78
3. The statement "Siguro yung.. naging coping strategy
79
against stress, and fosters emotional resilience (Cohen
2001).
80
emotional expression, and interpersonal rapport
practices.
81
goals and encompasses contributing to something
82
the pursuit of knowledge, which are integral
83
131
academic pursuits, leading to a more comprehensive
Brief Cope
84
sa pinaka nakatulong sa akin is yung magseset ako ng
et al., 2021).
85
constructive ways to navigate through difficult
101
experiences. Journaling allows individuals to express
86
evidenced by Tedeschi and Calhoun's work on
87
directed towards oneself, often stemming from
Avoidant Coping Moderate 1. The statement “Hindi ako nakikipag socialize talaga.”
88
process, limiting opportunities for interpersonal growth
2022).
2001).
89
3. Struggling to engage in conversations even until now
90
Recognizing the profound impact of avoidant coping
The qualitative insights gleaned from students' narratives provide a rich understanding of
3
how university students in Metro Manila cope with stress and maintain their psychological
PERMA Scale
Positive Emotion. Students shared numerous experiences that highlighted their ability to
maintain positive emotions despite challenging circumstances. They described moments of joy,
personal growth, and gratitude, indicating a resilience that allowed them to find brightness even
amidst adversity. For instance, students recounted how they formed close bonds with peers and
pets, engaged in fulfilling hobbies, and found meaning in their academic pursuits, all of which
contributed to their overall sense of positivity and well-being (Fredrickson, 2021; Howell et al.,
2023).
brought them joy and fulfillment, such as hobbies and social interactions. They spoke of
moments of flow and passion, indicating a deep engagement with their interests and
91
surroundings. “Students emphasized the importance of staying connected with friends and
pursuing activities that brought them joy, highlighting how engagement served as a coping
Relationship. Close relationships with peers, family members, and pets emerged as crucial
sources of support and comfort for students. They described relying on these relationships for
emotional and practical assistance, emphasizing the importance of companionship and validation
in navigating challenges. Students expressed gratitude for the presence of supportive individuals
in their lives, highlighting the role of relationships in promoting their well-being and resilience
Meaning. Qualitative accounts revealed students' reflections on their values, aspirations, and
life goals, indicating a strong sense of meaning and purpose. They spoke of finding fulfillment in
their academic pursuits and personal growth, as well as in moments of self-discovery and
perseverance. Students emphasized the importance of pursuing activities that aligned with their
values and passions, underscoring how meaning served as a guiding force in their coping
and personal endeavors, highlighting moments of success and self-discovery. They spoke of
92
celebrating individual successes, underscoring how accomplishment contributed to their overall
to address stressors directly and find solutions to challenges they encountered. They highlighted
the importance of taking proactive steps to manage academic pressures and personal issues. For
instance, students mentioned actively planning and seeking instrumental support to address
203
Emotion-focused Coping. Qualitative narratives revealed students' use of emotion-focused
coping strategies to manage their emotional responses to stress. They described seeking
emotional support from peers, engaging in activities that brought them comfort, and using
positive reframing to reinterpret stressful situations. Students emphasized the role of emotional
expression and self-soothing techniques in coping with challenging experiences (Folkman &
Moskowitz, 2020).
Avoidant Coping. While students acknowledged using avoidant coping strategies to some
extent, such as distraction or denial, they also reflected on the limitations of these approaches.
Some students described how avoiding stressors temporarily relieved their distress but ultimately
hindered their ability to address underlying issues effectively. They highlighted the importance of
93
confronting challenges directly and seeking support when needed, indicating a nuanced
Overall, the qualitative data provided rich insights into the coping mechanisms and
well-being of university students in Metro Manila. By capturing students' lived experiences and
perspectives, qualitative research deepened our understanding of how they navigate challenges
51
and maintain their psychological well-being. These insights can “inform the development of
interventions and support systems tailored to students' unique needs, ultimately fostering a
campus environment that promotes well-being and resilience.” (Cox, C., 2020)
245
In conclusion, the integration of quantitative and qualitative data provides a broader
72
understanding of the coping strategy used by college students in Metro Manila and their impact
202
on their psychological well-being. This dual approach allows for a more definite and thorough
analysis, capturing both the measurable aspects of coping mechanisms and well-being, and the
personal, subjective experiences of the students (Johnson, R. B., & Christensen, L. 2022).
By integrating these two types of data, the research provides a holistic view of coping
29
strategies and their impacts. This comprehensive understanding is crucial for developing targeted
support systems and interventions. For instance, the research might identify a particular coping
strategy that is statistically effective but requires a specific contextual support to be truly
favorable. Interventions can then be designed to foster this strategy within the appropriate
94
4
The unification of quantitative and qualitative data in this research not only provides a
detailed understanding of coping strategies and their impacts but also lays the preliminaries for
developing effective support systems (Creswell & Plano Clark, 2021). These systems can
improve psychological well-being and academic performance, contributing to the overall health
coping strategies and psychological well-being, while the qualitative data offered depth and
context to these patterns (Creswell & Creswell, 2021; Smith & Johnson, 2022).
Understanding the nuances of how engagement and relationships enhanced well-being informed
targeted interventions. For example, the quantitative data highlighted high levels of engagement,
but the qualitative data revealed that students often engaged in extracurricular activities and
hobbies as coping mechanisms, which provided them with a sense of accomplishment and
community. This insight suggested that promoting involvement in campus activities could be
beneficial for student well-being (Seligman, 2020). The mixed-methods approach allowed the
researchers to identify not only the prevalence of different coping strategies but also the
underlying reasons for their use. Quantitative data indicated that students used emotion-focused
29
coping strategies frequently, while qualitative insights highlighted “specific techniques such as
95
seeking emotional support from peers, venting, and using positive reframing to manage stress”
187
(Raypole, 2022). Integrating these data sources enabled the researchers to develop a nuanced
understanding of the coping mechanisms and well-being of university students in Metro Manila.
223
This comprehensive analysis informed the development of effective support systems and
interventions tailored to their needs, such as stress management workshops, enhanced counseling
services, and initiatives to foster peer support networks (Taylor & Stanton, 2021).
123
The joint display analysis is reported to give depth and emphasis on the related findings
which provide the key context for answering the why and how of the quantitative or qualitative
145
data (Nessle et. al., 2023). In addition, in a study by Haynes-Brown and Fetters, they provided
key information for their detailed process of how joint display was built and interpreted. Thus in
3
this research, it revealed that college students in Metro Manila primarily used coping strategies
30
such as problem-focused, which is definitely associated with the dimensions of psychological
236
well-being. By integrating both methods, this research provides a refined understanding of these
43
There is a significant positive relationship between problem-focused coping and various
267
dimensions of psychological well-being, such as life satisfaction, positive affect, and reduced
stress and anxiety. (Folkman & Moskowitz, 2021). Participants report that they feel more in
control and more optimistic about their future when they engage in problem-focused coping.
96
218
In conclusion, the integration of quantitative and qualitative data provides a comprehensive
72
understanding of the coping mechanisms used by college students in Metro Manila and their
targeted support systems and interventions. These can significantly enhance the well-being and
academic success of students, contributing to a healthier and more resilient student population.
97
31
Chapter 5
This chapter provides a summary of the research conducted, the conclusions drawn,
Summary of Findings
Quantitative Findings
Filipino college students, with a mean score of 3.17, indicating a strong inclination towards
support and positive reframing. Avoidant coping had the lowest mean score of 2.25, indicating
less frequent use but still part of the overall coping strategy.
274
Psychological Well-being. “Students exhibited high levels of psychological well-being
189
across all dimensions measured by the PERMA model” (Positive Emotion, Engagement,
Relationships, Meaning, and Accomplishments). This suggests that students generally maintain
positive emotional states, are actively engaged, value relationships, find meaning in experiences,
coping had selective positive effects, particularly in engagement and relationships, but didn't
98
significantly boost immediate positive emotions. Avoidant coping showed negative correlations
Qualitative Findings
pressures and personal issues. For example, students actively planned and sought instrumental
well-being.
provided valuable context about the circumstances under which students resorted to avoidant
4
Overall, the integration of quantitative and qualitative data allowed for a nuanced
7
understanding of coping mechanisms and well-being among college students in Metro Manila,
99
Conclusion
7
This research investigated post-pandemic coping strategies and psychological well-being
among college students in Metro Manila, utilizing both qualitative and quantitative
37
methodologies. For the quantitative survey portion of the study, the researchers targeted college
students enrolled in universities within Metro Manila. This survey was administered through an
online Google Form. For the qualitative phase, the researchers conducted focus group
qualitative insights. The qualitative phase took place at the Lyman C. Ogilby Hall at Trinity
University of Asia. By examining how students perceive and experience changes due to the
pandemic, we aimed to understand the psychological impacts and how demographics affect their
recovery experiences and attitudes. The ultimate goal was to enhance students' mental health
through focused interventions and support, addressing information gaps, and improving
post-pandemic outcomes.
Our study revealed that the combination of quantitative results with qualitative insights
3
provided a comprehensive understanding of how university students cope with stress and
maintain their psychological well-being. The quantitative data offered a broad overview,
205
indicating high use of problem-focused coping strategies and high engagement in positive
relationships. The qualitative data added depth by uncovering specific challenges and contexts
that prompted these strategies. Students reported actively planning and seeking instrumental
extracurricular activities, and relying on friends and family for emotional support.
100
146
The mixed-methods approach, Sequential Explanatory Design, highlighted a significant
well-being, such as life satisfaction, positive affect, and lower levels of stress and anxiety. This
These findings have important implications for both brief cope Scale and PERMA Scale.
148
For Brief Cope Scale, the effectiveness of problem-focused coping in managing stress and
improving psychological well-being suggests that interventions promoting these strategies can be
particularly beneficial. For PERMA Scale, the high engagement and positive relationships
observed among students underscore the critical role of engagement (E) and relationships (R) in
enhancing overall well-being. The research emphasizes the need for interventions that foster
these elements, supporting the holistic development of students in alignment with the principles
of PERMA Theory.
214
Additionally, these findings have significant implications for future research, policy, and
practice. Future research should continue to use mixed-methods approaches to capture the
51
complexity of coping mechanisms and psychological well-being, exploring specific coping
strategies across diverse student populations. In terms of policy, educational institutions may
consider incorporating structured stress management programs and peer support initiatives into
their wellness policies to promote a supportive campus environment. Practically, counselors and
204 4
educators can leverage these insights to design tailored interventions that address the unique
101
challenges faced by students, thereby fostering resilience and enhancing overall student
well-being. This comprehensive approach ensures that interventions are grounded in a robust
understanding of student needs, ultimately contributing to more effective support systems and
Despite the valuable insights gained, this study is not without its limitations. The primary
limitations include the selection of participants, which covered a sample population of college
students within Metro Manila who experienced at least a two-year quarantine stay in the
Philippines and were enrolled in the same university for two or more consecutive years. These
60
eligibility requirements were established as they may potentially have a significant impact on the
psychological well-being of the participants and may elicit symptoms of various psychological
shiftees/shifters, those who took a gap year during the pandemic, and students whose current
curricula involve internships or duties abroad. These limitations were set as they may affect the
120
validity and reliability of the research findings.
4
Overall, this study contributes to a deeper understanding of post-pandemic coping
strategies and psychological well-being among college students within Metro Manila,
highlighting the need for ongoing inquiry and development in this field.
102
Recommendations
38
Based on the findings from this mixed-methods study, several recommendations can be
115
made to enhance the effectiveness of post- pandemic learning programs in universities, the
following recommendations are proposed to support and enhance these coping mechanisms in
educational settings:
schools. This can involve establishing calm common areas, providing extracurricular
activities like sports, music, and art, and integrating breaks through the school day so that
students can relax and engage in activities that they personally choose to be comforting.
Aside from these activities, there should also be an opportunity for students where they
can do volunteer work. It has been proven that volunteer activities can positively impact
mental health when engaged for long-term as it promotes higher levels of psychological
in order to assist students acquire the ability to perceive stressful situations in a more
chances for personal development. Students had the capacity to develop both individually
103
and socially as they proved tolerant of ambiguity and uncertainty. Building coping
mechanisms in the educational setting for students who seek out peers for emotional
support, engage in comfort-seeking activities, and use positive reframing when faced
with stressful situations are some ways to support student success. (Reed & Sokonie,
2023)
schools. This can involve stress management seminars and courses, where students study
66
the differences between problem-focused, emotion-focused, and avoidant coping as well
as the long-term benefits of facing challenges head-on. Students with effective coping
9
mechanisms are better able to handle stress, anxiety, and other mental health issues.
(Fegley et. al., 2021) This can foster a healthier learning environment by preventing the
environment, which is offered by schools. Peer support groups, regular check-ins, and a
mental health-focused school culture are all ways to achieve this. Promoting open
discussions about stress and coping mechanisms can give students confidence to face
their problems. In time, avoidant coping can worsen stress and anxiety as it leads to
emotions to be bottled up. Students can express these emotions in a safe environment,
104
which lessens their emotional load and enhances mental health. In order to effectively
manage their emotions, they must first learn to become more aware of them, which is a
skill that a safe environment fosters. ( Hair, Joseph F., Jr.; Smith, Kenneth J. 2023)
properly utilize these tools may encourage students to reach out for support as opposed to
emotion-focused coping seeks to address the psychological response to stress. With the
support of a professional counselor, students can process and control their emotions in a
safe and healthy environment by using accessible counseling services. This can lessen
stigma and motivate more students to make use of the resources at their use, encouraging
the development of a mental health-aware and supportive culture (Martinez-Garcia et. al.,
2022).
indivimplementing these suggestions into practice. This will help students develop and
strengthen their coping mechanisms. Based on the reflections of the students, these suggestions
make sure to address the nuances of coping mechanisms and encourage long-term wellbeing. As
a result, students perform more effectively academically and are more engaged. These
105
presented by blended learning as they are based on a thorough analysis of both quantitative and
qualitative data.
APPENDIX
4
Figure 1. Conceptual Framework on the Post-Pandemic Coping Strategies and Psychological
114
Reliability Statistics
.814 .822 28
121
Reliability Statistics
.907 .913 23
106
269
Descriptive Statistics
107
Avoidant Pearson -.210 -.175 -.176 -.179 -.164
Coping Correlation
258
Dimensions of Coping Mean SD Description
108
Dimensions of Mean SD Description
Well-being
116
Emotion Pearson .091 .160* .141* .146* .173**
Focused Correlation
Coping Sig. (2-tailed) .152 .012 .027 .021 .006
N
248 248 248 248 248
109
Avoidant Pearson -.210** -.175** -.176** -.179** -.164**
Coping Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed) .001 .006 .005 .005 .010
N
248 248 248 248 248
5
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
152
Tests of Normality
Kolmogorov-Smirnov Shapiro-Wilk
110
Figure 10. Triangulation Data
111
Informed Consent
168
Good day! We are Group 9 of 3PSY02, third-year students from the Department of Psychology
175 27
and we would like to invite you to participate in an interview for our research project. Before
you decide to participate, it is important for you to understand the title, purpose of the study, the
144
procedures involved, and your rights as a participant.
4
Post-Pandemic Coping Strategies and Psychological Well-Being among College Students within
Metro Manila
140
Purpose of the study:
93
The purpose of the study is to investigate and understand the Coping Strategies and well-being
of college students in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic. The study will be conducted
275
within Metro Manila, and this aims to explore how the unique challenges and experiences
4
related to the pandemic have influenced the mental health and overall well-being of 384 college
students specifically located in Metro Manila. Through conducting interviews, the researchers
seek to gather valuable insights into the post-pandemic psychological landscape, shedding light
on the factors that may impact college students' adjustment and well-being during this period.
13
The goal is to contribute to a deeper understanding of the psychological effects of the pandemic
112
on this demographic and to provide valuable information that may inform support mechanisms
Procedures:
The interview will involve a brief description of the interview format, questions, and expected
27
duration. The interview is expected to take approximately 10 minutes.
There are minimal risks associated with participating in this interview. The benefits include
112
contributing valuable information to students and a comprehensive awareness of how their
psychological well-being affected their lives during the post-pandemic. Furthermore, they may
recovery.
64
Confidentiality:
Your identity will be kept confidential to the extent permitted by law. Your name will not be
64
associated with any quotes or information shared in any reports or publications resulting from
85
this study. Rest assured that your individual responses will also remain confidential and will not
be disclosed in the research summary or any related publications. All information will be
29
If you have any questions or concerns regarding access to the study results, please do not hesitate
113
Voluntary Participation:
13
As a token of appreciation for your participation in our study, you will receive non-monetary
incentives. This compensation is provided to acknowledge the time and effort you dedicate to
11
Please note that participation in this study is voluntary, and you are not obligated to continue if
233
you feel uncomfortable or decide to withdraw. Your decision will not affect any compensation
13
If you have any questions or concerns about compensation or medical care, please feel free to
This research is conducted by individuals affiliated with Trinity University of Asia, specifically
47
the department of Bachelor of Science in Psychology under the College of Arts and Sciences
149
Contact Information:
If you have any questions about the interview or the research, please feel free to contact us
235
anytime at any of the information listed below. If you have concerns about the study and wish to
114
contact someone independent, you may reach our professor Mr. Ronn Mikhael Avila.
(rmaavila@tua.edu.ph)
raizzaicenoalbandia@tua.edu.ph
chrisandreajbiteno@tua.edu.ph
lizamariesevangelista@tua.edu.ph
sineadayannamflorendo@tua.edu.ph
patriciakayeaguanzon@tua.edu.ph
maureeneamendoza@tua.edu.ph
Consent:
134
By participating in this interview, you indicate that you have read and understood the
184
information provided, and you freely give your consent to participate. You may withdraw from
159
I have read and understood the information provided, and I freely give my consent to participate
in this interview.
115
Participant's Name: ____________________
Date: ____________________
Brief Cope
116
117
118
119
Second Validator: Prof. Pete Aton
120
121
122
Third Validator: Prof. Victorius Bibera
123
124
125
PERMA Profiler
126
127
Second Validator: Prof: Adrian Amistad
128
129
Third Validator: Prof. Victorius Bibera
130
131
Validation Form (Qualitative)
132
Second Validator: Prof. Dawnie Dela Cruz
133
Third Validator: Prof. Adrian Amistad
134
Curriculum Vitae
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
105
References:
Abbadia, J. (2023, October 3). Mastering Analysis: The Role of Codebook Qualitative
https://mindthegraph.com/blog/codebook-qualitative-research/
82
Biggs, H., Reid, S., Attygalle, K., Wishart, R., & Shields, J. (2020). MCR pathways
16
Chen, C., Guan, Z., Sun, L., Zhou, T., & Guan, R. (2021). COVID‐19 exposure,
among the frontline medical staff and gender differences in coping processes.
https://eric.ed.gov/?q=importance+of+Providing+Students+Coping+Mechanisms
%3a&id=ED646394
41
Garcia-Alvarez, D., Soler, M. J., & Achard-Braga, L. (2021, December 16).
142
Psychology Interventions. Frontiers in Psychology, 12.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.769363
2
Hidayat, R., Habibi, A., Mohd Saad, M. R., Mukminin, A., & Wan Idris, W. I. (2018).
39
Korbmacher, M., & Wright, L. (2020). What can we learn from exploring cognitive
https://doi.org/10.53841/bpsptr.2020.26.1.48
183
Leadership Development and Analysis. LeadershipNow.
https://www.leadershipnow.com/leadershop/5021-3.htmll
266 86
Nessle, N., Ghazal, L., Sung, Choi, & Fetters, M. (2023). Joint Display of Integrated Data
Nyumba, T., Wilson, K., Derrick, C. J., & Mukherjee, N. (2018). The use of focus group
https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.12860
143
84
Ocampo, L., & Yamagishi, K. (2020, December). Modeling the lockdown relaxation
https://www.oecd.org/coronavirus/policy-responses/enhancing-public-trust-in-cov
id-19-vaccination-the-role-of-governments-eae0ec5a
12
Odriozola-González, P., Planchuelo‐Gómez, L., Muñiz, M. J. I., & De Luis‐García, R.
(2020, August 1). Psychological effects of the COVID-19 outbreak and lockdown
165
Our People | Positive Psychology Center. (n.d.). https://ppc.sas.upenn.edu/people
103
Parrocha, A. (2022, September 12). PBBM approves voluntary use of face masks
outdoors. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1183454
73
Philippine Journal of Social Development Volume 15 2022. UP Diliman College of
https://cswcd.upd.edu.ph/knowledge-hub/philippine-journal-of-social-developme
nt/pjsd-15-2022/
37
Robinson, MD, J. (2022, April 18). Pandemics: Definition, prevention, and preparation.
WebMD.
https://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/what-are-epidemics-pandemics-outbreaks
144
44
Rotas, E., & Cahapay, M. (2020). Difficulties in Remote Learning: Voices of Philippine
20
Ruggeri, K., Garcia-Garzon, E., Maguire, Matz, S., & Huppert, F. A. (2021, June
https://hqlo.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12955-020-01423-y
46
Sandhu, S. (2021). Environmental Governance in the Philippines A Pathway to
https://ncpag.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/SANDHU_Environmental-Governa
nce_09242021.pdf
80
Scott, E., PhD. (2024, January 12). Avoidance coping and why it creates additional stress.
Verywell Mind.
https://www.verywellmind.com/avoidance-coping-and-stress-4137836
56
Smith, J., & Jones, A. (2023). Social media use for coping with stress and psychological
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1140
312/full
145
94
Soots, L. (2023, June 3). PERMA - E is for Engagement. The Positive Psychology
People.
https://www.thepositivepsychologypeople.com/perma-e-is-for-engagement/
14
Stangor, C., & Walinga, J. (2022, October 17). 13.1 psychological disorder: What makes
https://opentextbc.ca/introductiontopsychology/chapter/12-1-psychological-disord
er-what-makes-a-behavior-abnormal/#:~:text=associated%20with%20disorder.-,A
%20psychological%20disorder%20is%20an%20ongoing%20dysfunctional%20pa
ttern%20of%20thought,%2C%20psychological%2C%20and%20social%20causes
33
Steger, M. F., O’Donnell, M. B., & Morse, J. L. (2021, January 1). Helping Students Find
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-64537-3_22
91
Svanholm, A. G. (n.d.). The Impact of COVID-19 on Study Abroad: April 2020 Survey
Results.https://institutions.educations.com/insights/student-survey-covid-19-and-s
tudy-abroad
24
Taherdoost, H. (2019). What Is the Best Response Scale for Survey and Questionnaire
hal-03741841.
146
15
Talabis, D. A. S., Babierra, A. L., Buhat, C. A. H., Lutero, D. S., Quindala, K. M., &
https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-021-11746-0
#:~:text=Conclusions,was%20brought%20by%20the%20pandemic
19
Tee, M. L., Tee, C. A., Anlacan, J. P., Aligam, K. J. G., Reyes, P. W. C., Kuruchittham,
V., & Ho, R. C. (2020, December 1). Psychological impact of covid-19 pandemic
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7444468/
11
The Construction of Meaning from Life Events: Empirical Studies of Personal
154
Narratives. (n.d.). https://www.its.caltech.edu/. Retrieved October 21, 2023, from
https://www.its.caltech.edu/~squartz/_meaning_chapter_baumeister_sommer_still
man.pdf
how-multistakeholder-engagement.pdf
57
The Impact of Academic Resilience on Academic Performance in College Students
https://knepublishing.com/index.php/KnE-Social/article/view/10198/16714
147
23
The pandemic has had devastating impacts on learning. What will it take to help students
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-pandemic-has-had-devastating-impacts-on
-learning-what-will-it-take-to-help-students-catch-up
54
Truschel, J. (2022, August 26). Depression definition and DSM-5 diagnostic criteria -
psycom.)
https://www.psycom.net/depression/major-depressive-disorder/dsm-5-depression-
criteria
76
Unicef, BankOECD, U. O. of R.-I., Unesco. (2021, September). Education: From school
https://www.unesco.org/en/covid-19/education-response
109
Up Diliman College of Social Work and Community Development. (n.d.-b).
https://cswcd.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/PSJD-Vol-14_all-pages_fin
al-2.pdf
18
Vasileiou, D., Μoraitou, D., Papaliagkas, V., Pezirkianidis, C., Stalikas, A., Papantoniou,
G., & Sofologi, M. (2021). The Relationships between Character Strengths and
148
77
View of “Sana all”: Netizens’ perception of government responses to covid-19:
53
Cosmopolitan Civil Societies: An interdisciplinary journal. View of “Sana All”:
https://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/journals/index.php/mcs/article/view/7961/7938
35
Vus, V., Syurina, E., Brückner, T., Fradelos, E., Papathanasiou, I., Omelchenko, L., &
Vakulich, T. (2021). Youth and Mental Health: Life Satisfaction, Wellbeing, and
74(7). https://doi.org/10.36740/WLek202107123
75
Wong, P. (2018, March 26). Positive Psychology of Meaning in Life & Well-Being. Dr.
Paul Wong.
http://www.drpaulwong.com/the-positive-psychology-of-meaning-in-life-and-well
-being/#:~:text=According%20to%20Steger%20
79
World Health Organization. (2021). Health and well-being. World Health Organization.
https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/major-themes/health-and-well-being
141
World Health Organization. (2023, September 27). Who coronavirus (COVID-19)
90
World Health Organization. (2023) Coronavirus disease (covid-19) pandemic. World
Health Organization.
149
https://www.who.int/europe/emergencies/situations/covid-19#:~:text=The%20CO
VID%2D19%20pandemic%20is,%2DCoV%2D2)%20virus.
150
Similarity Report
TOP SOURCES
The sources with the highest number of matches within the submission. Overlapping sources will not be
displayed.
coursehero.com
1 <1%
Internet
link.springer.com
2 <1%
Internet
mu on 2024-04-03
3 <1%
Submitted works
mdpi.com
5 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
researchgate.net
11 <1%
Internet
dergipark.org.tr
12 <1%
Internet
velez on 2024-05-20
13 <1%
Submitted works
ejcop.scholasticahq.com
18 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
dspace.pacuniversity.ac.ke:8080
24 <1%
Internet
pedagogika.leu.lt
28 <1%
Internet
lume.ufrgs.br
30 <1%
Internet
pdfcoffee.com
31 <1%
Internet
Laura A. King, Joshua A. Hicks, Jennifer L. Krull, Amber K. Del Gaiso. "...
32 <1%
Crossref
Sources overview
Similarity Report
isdesr.org
36 <1%
Internet
listens.online
38 <1%
Internet
fastercapital.com
42 <1%
Internet
itu.int
44 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
fliphtml5.com
45 <1%
Internet
positivepsychology.com
50 <1%
Internet
essay.utwente.nl
54 <1%
Internet
ejournal.iai-tribakti.ac.id
55 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
discovery.dundee.ac.uk
59 <1%
Internet
repository.library.carleton.ca
60 <1%
Internet
theglobalfight.org
61 <1%
Internet
esp.apacsci.com
65 <1%
Internet
scholarship.shu.edu
68 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
ses.library.usyd.edu.au
69 <1%
Internet
epress.lib.uts.edu.au
77 <1%
Internet
park.dnp.go.th
78 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
ebin.pub
83 <1%
Internet
jurnal.fkip.unila.ac.id
84 <1%
Internet
velez on 2024-03-07
85 <1%
Submitted works
journals.sagepub.com
87 <1%
Internet
paralife.narod.ru
88 <1%
Internet
storage.googleapis.com
89 <1%
Internet
hallum.creative-b.eu
92 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
philssj.org
93 <1%
Internet
schs.dph.ncdhhs.gov
95 <1%
Internet
jees.umsida.ac.id
99 <1%
Internet
nova.newcastle.edu.au
104 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
worldciticolleges on 2023-05-28
109 <1%
Submitted works
Abear, Mary Grace Antonette Lavina. "Mental Health Care Providers' C...
110 <1%
Publication
digitalarchive.boun.edu.tr
114 <1%
Internet
eprints.usq.edu.au
115 <1%
Internet
hdl.handle.net
116 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
ojs.jdss.org.pk
117 <1%
Internet
Chen Chen, Ziqi Guan, Liqun Sun, Ting Zhou, Ruiyuan Guan. " ‐19 expo...
119 <1%
Crossref
Davis Louis, Shavon | Scott, April | Burley, Rachel. "The Impact of Distri...
120 <1%
Publication
dspace.uii.ac.id
121 <1%
Internet
files.eric.ed.gov
122 <1%
Internet
annfammed.org
123 <1%
Internet
Muhammad Hanif, Endang Sri Maruti. " The role of traditional music ‘ i...
127 <1%
Crossref
Sources overview
Similarity Report
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
132 <1%
Internet
ijeais.org
133 <1%
Internet
mseuf-candelaria on 2023-12-20
134 <1%
Submitted works
onlinelibrary.wiley.com
135 <1%
Internet
slidelegend.com
136 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
garuda.kemdikbud.go.id
142 <1%
Internet
gwp.org
143 <1%
Internet
Samuel Shye. "Chapter 2975 Systemic Quality of Life Model (SQOL)", S...
145 <1%
Crossref
eprints.walisongo.ac.id
150 <1%
Internet
dspace.um.edu.mx
152 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
scielo.org.za
153 <1%
Internet
answeregy.com
158 <1%
Internet
cettrivandrum on 2024-05-07
159 <1%
Submitted works
digital.library.unt.edu
160 <1%
Internet
hqlo.biomedcentral.com
161 <1%
Internet
mu on 2024-04-12
162 <1%
Submitted works
scholarum.dlsl.edu.ph
163 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Andersen, Brittany B. | Brooks, Janelle A. | Ruth, Edwin T.. "The Impact ...
166 <1%
Publication
bghtraining on 2024-06-04
169 <1%
Submitted works
esp.ieconom.kz
170 <1%
Internet
fcci on 2024-05-27
171 <1%
Submitted works
mmc on 2022-11-07
172 <1%
Submitted works
scholars.cityu.edu.hk
173 <1%
Internet
whatsyourgrief.com
174 <1%
Internet
worldciticolleges on 2022-08-17
175 <1%
Submitted works
diva-portal.org
176 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Ann Marie Roepke. "Gains without pains? Growth after positive events"...
177 <1%
Crossref
sigma.nursingrepository.org
184 <1%
Internet
theses.gla.ac.uk
185 <1%
Internet
ashwinanokha.com
186 <1%
Internet
donaldbeasley.org.nz
187 <1%
Internet
irejournals.com
188 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
nordangliaeducation.com
189 <1%
Internet
5dok.net
191 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
cdn.slideserve.com
203 <1%
Internet
csu on 2024-05-24
204 <1%
Submitted works
digital.library.txst.edu
205 <1%
Internet
journal.uad.ac.id
206 <1%
Internet
psu.pb.unizin.org
207 <1%
Internet
quieora.ink
208 <1%
Internet
globalscientificjournal.com
209 <1%
Internet
medrxiv.org
210 <1%
Internet
tandfonline.com
211 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Neese, Bethany Marie. "How Older Adults Describe How Musical Engag...
224 <1%
Publication
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Sources overview
Similarity Report
benguetstate on 2024-05-27
239 <1%
Submitted works
consortiacademia.org
240 <1%
Internet
discovery.ucl.ac.uk
241 <1%
Internet
eprints.port.ac.uk
242 <1%
Internet
etd.dbu.edu.et
243 <1%
Internet
etd.uum.edu.my
244 <1%
Internet
kclpure.kcl.ac.uk
245 <1%
Internet
mobt3ath.com
246 <1%
Internet
open.library.ubc.ca
247 <1%
Internet
pubhtml5.com
248 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
repository.paramadina.ac.id
249 <1%
Internet
s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com
250 <1%
Internet
uhra.herts.ac.uk
251 <1%
Internet
vital.seals.ac.za:8080
252 <1%
Internet
wiadlek.pl
253 <1%
Internet
worldciticolleges on 2024-06-06
254 <1%
Submitted works
eecera.org
255 <1%
Internet
eed.state.ak.us
256 <1%
Internet
www2.mdpi.com
257 <1%
Internet
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Northcentral on 2018-04-12
262 <1%
Submitted works
Sources overview
Similarity Report
Sources overview