GED0035 Module 8 Subtopic 1 The North and South Divide Objectives
1. Differentiate the Global North from the Global
South. 2. Identify the characteristics of Global North and Global South nations. 3. Analyze what causes countries to become part of the Global North or the Global South. The Global North and the Global South What is the North-South Divide? • The North-South Divide is a socio-economic and political division of the world. It divides the world into the Global North and the Global South and this division, as a concept, was created by the Brandt Foundation. • The foundation wanted to bring attention to the fact that there are wide disparities between certain privileged parts of the world and their less privileged counterparts. The line that divides the world into the Global North and the Global South is called the Brandt Line. The Global North and the Global South An important clarification • What then are the Global North and the Global South composed of? It must be clarified that the term Global North and Global South do not necessarily refer to geographical locations. There are countries that are in the Southern Hemisphere that are part of the Global North and vice versa. • The basis instead is on a country’s status of development. The Global North and the Global South First World, Second World, Third World • In the subject matter of countries’ development status, the terms “First World”, “Second World”, and “Third World” are often used. • Within the context of the North-South Divide, saying that Global North countries are First World and Global South countries are Second World and Third World may be correct depending on the usage of those terms. The Global North and the Global South The Three-World Model • The Three-World Model uses the terms First World, Second World, and Third World to identify allegiances during the Cold War. o First World – the Western Bloc (USA, UK, Japan, and their allies) o Second World – the Eastern Block (USSR, China, and their allies) o Third World – neutral countries The Global North and the Global South The Three Worlds Theory • The Three Worlds Theory by Mao Zedong uses the same three terms but they refer to a country’s status of development. o First World – superpowers o Second World – developing powers o Third World – exploited nations The Global North and the Global South Updated Terminologies • Between the two ways to use First World, Second World, and Third World, the Three Worlds Theory is developed more applicable to the North-South Divide. • However, in today’s standards, it has developing become more appropriate to use the terms developed, developing, and underdeveloped to refer to underdeveloped First World, Second World, and Third World respectively. The Global North and the Global South Specific Criteria • The North-South Divide categorizes countries based on economic development, often using standards like the World Bank's income classifications or GDP per capita thresholds. • Different scholars propose varying income thresholds for defining developed countries, ranging from $12,000 to $25,000 per capita. • However, developed countries typically share common characteristics such as a high quality of life, advanced economies, and sophisticated technological infrastructure. General Characteristics The Global North
• The Global North is:
o Composed of 1/4 of the world’s population; o Controls 4/5 of the income earned anywhere in the world; o 90% of manufacturing industries are owned by and located in the North; and o 95% of the North has enough food and shelter. General Characteristics The Global North • The Global South is: o Composed of 3/4 of the world’s population; o Controls 1/5 of the income earned anywhere in the world; o Typically lacks appropriate technologies; o Sometimes has no political stability; and o Foreign exchange earnings depend heavily on primary product exports. General Characteristics A Necessary Comparison • The Brandt Foundation aimed to highlight the stark disparity between the Global North and the Global South, where a small percentage of the population holds majority of the world's wealth. • This imbalance results in poverty being a central issue in the Global South, where limited resources are spread thinly across a large population. General Characteristics A Necessary Comparison
• While there are various other
issues stemming from the North- South Divide, poverty remains at the core, necessitating coordinated action to address it, especially in countries with limited means to combat it. The Fight Against Poverty The World Bank’s Efforts • The fight against poverty: o Extreme poverty is living below $1.90 per day (World Bank definition). o In 1990, around 1.9 billion people lived in extreme poverty. o In 2015, the number has been reduced down to 734 million people. o Significant progress is being made but more work needs to be done. Causes of the North-South Divide Overview Modernization • A group of theories, known as the theories of global stratification, attempt to explain Theory why there is such a huge gap in the level of development between the Global North and the Global South. Dependency • The term global stratification refers to the Theory hierarchical arrangement of individuals and groups in societies around the world. • The most common of these theories are Modern World the modernization theory, the dependency theory, and the modern System Theory world system theory. Causes of the North-South Divide Modernization Theory Modernization • According to this theory: o All societies progress through Theory a similar pattern of development. Dependency o Underdeveloped countries simply began their Theory development process late. Developed countries started Modern World their development process earlier. System Theory Causes of the North-South Divide Dependency Theory Modernization • According to this theory: Theory o Some societies are underdeveloped because of certain features and/or Dependency characteristics that prevent them from developing. Theory o These underdeveloped societies depend on other Modern World societies to achieve development. System Theory Causes of the North-South Divide Modern World System Theory Modernization • According to this theory: Theory o Some societies are disadvantaged because of the role they play in a global economic system. Dependency o These societies only have the capacity to supply raw materials and cheap Theory labor which both have lower economic value compared to the Modern World finished products that other countries are capable of producing. System Theory Causes of the North-South Divide The Brain Drain • Aside from the theories of global stratification, scholars also point out that immigration contributes to the widening gap between the Global North and the Global South. This is referring to the phenomenon known as the brain drain. • The brain drain occurs when individuals with desirable qualities (educated, skilled, experienced, etc.) depart from one country to another in search of better pay or better living conditions. Causes of the North-South Divide Business Clustering • Another possible cause that scholars take into consideration is business clustering otherwise known as agglomeration. • Business clustering occurs when interconnected businesses operate close to each other. Their businesses are typically complementary to each other. • Forming a cluster allows the businesses to strengthen each other and become better suited to compete internationally especially against the un-clustered businesses of the Global South. Comprehension Check If you can answer these without coaching, you are ready for the next lesson. 1. What is the basis for classifying a country as part of the Global North or the Global South? 2. In your own words, briefly describe the common characteristics of the Global North and the Global South. 3. Differentiate the modernization theory, the dependency theory, and the modern world system theory. 4. What is the brain drain and how does this contribute to widening the gap between the Global North and the Global South? 5. What is business clustering and how does this contribute to widening the gap between the Global North and the Global South? Module 8 Subtopic 2 Sustainable Development Objectives
1. Identify the different theories of development used by
countries as a basis for national development. 2. Define sustainable development and analyze how it is an improved version of earlier theories of development. 3. Understand the history of sustainable development and where it currently stands in terms of global implementation. Theories of Development What is Development? • Development is defined as the manifestation of growth, progress, and positive change. • In principle, this is the core goal of governance and it is fair to assume that countries all over the world want to achieve this. • But when can it be said that a country has achieved development? Throughout history, various theories of development have been introduced and they each have their points of emphasis serving as the basis for what constitutes development. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development
• The earliest theories of development
presented the idea that a country is considered developed if it performed well economically. • Some of the well-known development theories under this group include the modernization theory, the structuralism theory, the dependency theory, the basic needs model, and the neoclassical growth theory. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development 1. Modernization Theory o This theory suggests that all countries go through a similar process of development, leading to eventual development for all nations over time. o Some countries just started earlier, others started late. o It argues that given enough time, today’s less developed countries will eventually develop. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development 2. Structuralism Theory o This theory attributes underdevelopment to systemic structural characteristics, such as unequal distribution of wealth and resources, social stratification, and economic dependency. o This existing system/structure favors some and puts others at a disadvantage. o For the disadvantaged to achieve development, this structure/system must be changed. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development 3. Dependency Theory o This theory posits that underdevelopment in poorer countries results from their economic and political dependency on wealthier nations within the global capitalist system. o This relationship perpetuates economic subordination and exploitation, hindering the development prospects of poorer countries. o For poor countries to develop, they must break away from their dependency. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development 4. Basic Needs Model o This model of development emphasizes that a society can be considered developed if its citizens have access to essential basic needs such as food, clean water, shelter, healthcare, and education. o Therefore, development efforts should focus on ensuring universal access to these necessities, regardless of economic status or social standing. Theories of Development Economics-based Theories of Development 5. Neoclassical Growth Theory o This theory is based on neoclassical economics, which emphasizes the role of factors such as labor, capital, and technology in driving economic growth. o Its argument is any country will inevitably achieve development as long as it possesses labor, capital, and technology. Theories of Development Human Development Theory • The human development theory, pioneered by Mahbub ul Haq and Amartya Sen, marks a departure from traditional development approaches focused solely on economics. • It argues that a country cannot be considered developed based solely on economic indicators like GDP, GDP per capita, or GNP if its people experience poverty, lack of education, unemployment, and other hardships. Theories of Development Human Development Theory
• This shift led to the creation of
metrics like the Human Development Index and the World Happiness Report, which assess development by considering both economic prosperity and human well-being. • The Human Development Index embodies this theory. Theories of Development Post-development Theory • The post-development theory is a meta-theory because it criticizes popular standards of development. • It suggests that popular standards for development were established and defined by Western societies and may be patterned after their cultures. There is a potential mismatch when these standards are applied to culturally different Eastern societies. Theories of Development Sustainable Development
• Sustainable development represents
another shift in how the concept of national development is interpreted. • The decades prior focused on economics first, then gradually included human development. • But the effects of human activity on the environment were becoming more and more undeniable. Theories of Development Sustainable Development • Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. • This emphasizes the importance of balancing the economy, society, and the environment. The focus should not be on one area only. Development in all three areas must be accomplished: economic growth, societal development, and environmental sustainability. Evolution of the Sustainable Development Concept Important Events • Stockholm Conference (1972) – sustainable development was recognized by the UN as a very important goal to pursue. • Rio Summit (June 1992) – Agenda 21 was established to solidify the UN recommendation that its members must pursue sustainable development. • Commission on Sustainable Development (December 1992) – established to monitor progress in sustainable development. Evolution of the Sustainable Development Concept Important Events
• Millennium Development Goals
(2000) – established 8 goals for UN members to accomplish by 2015. • Sustainable Development Goals – replaced the MDGs with 17 more specific goals; UN members are expected to accomplish these by 2030. The 17 Sustainable Development Goals Comprehension Check If you can answer these without coaching, you are ready for the next lesson.
1. Name two development theories that focus on economics and
explain each. 2. What differentiated the human development theory from economics-based theories of development? 3. What three things must be balanced in order to achieve sustainable development? This serves as a visual aid. For a more detailed discussion, you can watch the video courseware prepared by the course designer.