Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 15 Igneous petrology and geochemistry of the southern Heritage Range, Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctic
Chapter 15 Igneous petrology and geochemistry of the southern Heritage Range, Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctic
Chapter 15
ABSTRACT
Igneous rocks exposed in the southern Heritage Range include two diabasic sills
(100 m and 300 m thick), three gabbroic stocks (outcrop areas each <0.5 km2), a
spessartite lamprophyre plug (200 m diameter), a 10-km2 sanidine quartz phytic dacite
stock, and numerous aphanitic to porphyritic dikes and lava flows. Lava flows that are
largely basaltic, but range in composition from basalt to alkali rhyolite, compose about
10 to 15 percent of the 1,000-m thickness of the Liberty Hills Formation of the Heritage
Group. Eighty-four samples have been analyzed for major, minor, and trace elements by
x-ray fluorescence. Field relations and comparison of chemical composition of intrusive
and extrusive rocks suggest that all igneous rocks in the southern Heritage Range except
the dacite stock were emplaced in Cambrian time; all have undergone pumpellyite-
actinolite or greenschist facies metamorphism. A four-point Rb-Sr isochron yields a
mid-Devonian (369 + 18 Ma) emplacement age for the dacite stock. The extrusive
igneous rock suite is dominated by basalts but also includes rhyolites, dacites, and sparse
andesites and is thus bimodal. The relict primary mineralogy, distribution of alteration-
resistant trace elements (Nb, Ti, Y, Zr), and incorporation within a thick sequence of
carbonate and clastic sedimentary rocks all suggest that the mafic igneous rocks are
continental basalts whose original chemical compositions were largely mildly tholeiitic
or transitional between tholeiitic and alkali basalt; some calc-alkaline traits are also
evident. Discrimination diagrams based on alteration-resistant trace elements and distri-
bution of large ion lithophile elements (Ba, Rb, Sr) suggest that the felsic and interme-
diate rocks also possess tholeiitic, calc-alkaline, and alkaline traits.
Age relations and comparison of chemical compositions indicate that the southern
Heritage Range igneous rocks are not correlative with either the Jurassic Ferrar Super-
group or the Jurassic Kirwan Volcanics of the Transantarctic Mountains. The most
likely possible correlatives might be diabasic sills and dikes and subordinate plugs and
sills of felsic porphyry intrusive into the upper Precambrian Patuxent Formation, which
crops out in the Neptune Range of the Pensacola Mountains 500 km to the southeast.
Vennum, W. R., Gizycki, P., Samsonov, V. V., Markovich, A. G., and Pankhurst, R. J., 1992, Igneous petrology and geochemistry of the southern Heritage
Range, Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctica, in Webers, G. F., Craddock, C., and Splettstoesser, J. F., Geology and Paleontology of the Ellsworth Mountains, West
Antarctica: Boulder, Colorado, Geological Society of America Memoir 170.
295
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
Tholeiitic suites with contemporaneous calc-alkaline and alkaline traits are unusual but
have been reported from the Yellowknife volcanic belt in Canada's Northwest Territo-
ries and from southeastern Maine. We conclude that the bimodal basaltic-rhyolitic suite
of igneous rocks from the southern Heritage Range was emplaced in a continental area
undergoing extensional tectonism and does not represent an island arc-continental
margin subduction zone complex.
INTRODUCTION
within the Heritage Group and attributes this to a burial meta- Arctic, Leningrad, USSR (sample numbers prefixed with the letter
morphic event that may have affected the entire Ellsworth Moun- S); and the Institut für Allgemeine und Angewandte Geologie der
tains range. Mafic igneous rocks from the Wilson Nunataks Universität München, West Germany (sample numbers prefixed
possess greenschist facies metamorphic mineral assemblages. All with the letter H). A variety of U.S. Geological Survey (AGVI,
other mafic igneous rocks described in this chapter contain BCR1, G2, GH, GSP1, and W l ) and Canadian Department of
pumpellyite-actinolite assemblages. R. Bauer (personal communi- Energy, Mines, and Resources (MRG) standards were utilized in
cation, 1982) suggests that the transition between these two facies the California laboratory. Quantitative spectroscopy was used to
requires burial of 8,000 m and temperatures of 350 to 400°C. determine Ba, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, and V at Leningrad. Phosphorous
The only igneous rocks known to occur in the Sentinel Range are was determined by colorimetric methods when interference from
a small outcrop of gabbro exposed at O'Neill Nunataks along the silicon prevented the use of x-ray fluorescence. Total iron was
northern edge of the Minnesota Glacier (they are not discussed in determined by x-ray fluorescence, ferrous iron by titration, and
this report). Craddock and others (1964) and Craddock (1969) ferric iron by the difference between the other two quantities.
have published more detailed accounts of the geology of the
Ellsworth Mountains. FIELD RELATIONS
sills and stocks are exposed and are also widespread throughout
the rest of the southern Heritage Range. Although some of these
dikes cannot be traced laterally to a parent intrusive body, many
are obviously satellitic to the sills and stocks; these relations are
well exposed at High Nunatak (Fig. 3). Andesitic dikes (0.5 to 1.5
m thick) crop out locally in the Wilson Nunataks and a 75-cm-
wide, 7-m-long pinkish-gray quartz latite dike extensively veined
with epidote cuts metasedimentary rock on the eastern flank of
High Nunatak. Most dikes are strongly cleaved and often are
moderately well foliated parallel to their margins.
A pyrite-bearing sanidine quartz phyric dacite stock, the j 5 j Sandiione
margin of this body was examined, but field relations and study Gabbro (G) and
Lamprophyre (U Dikes
of aerial photographs suggest that the stock crops out over a
roughly circular area of approximately 10 km 2 centered midway cn —
between Mt. Bursik and Peak 2,431 m (Fig. 2). The rock weath- j 2 j Hornblende Lamprophyre
ers into a rugged craggy topography and is often stained a dark | , py/j ;°;;'*"0*d!As,,sj'^*,<ry Br ,«i,
Sills and stocks compared groundmass in which are set < 1 percent minute green to black
amygdules and plagioclase laths, all of which average 0.5 to 1
The gabbroic stocks and erratics are petrographically identi- mm in diameter. Clinopyroxene phenocrysts are uncommon. Pet-
cal to the two sills described above. Only slight differences in rographically the dikes are composed largely of randomly orient-
mineralogy exist between the Wilson Nunataks and Hyde Glacier ed or locally trachytic-textured plagioclase laths now almost
sills. Pale brown clinopyroxene occurs only locally in the Wilson totally replaced by albite and epidote ± sericite ± carbonate. The
Nuntaks sill as relict cores of grains (1 to 3 mm) that have been groundmass is composed largely of chlorite (pennine; RIß = 1.60,
almost totally replaced by an actinolitic amphibole (RI/3 = 1.63, 8 = 0.0004, optically positive, a = ß = pale green, y = pale
2Va = 70°, ZAc = 18°, 8 = 0.021, Z = moderate green, Y = pale yellow) and lesser amounts of epidote, actinolite, sericite, leucox-
green, X = very pale yellow, Z> Y>X). Toward the interior of the ene, hematite, quartz, magnetite, and pyrite. Celadonite was
Wilson Nunataks sill the pleochroic colors of the actinolite inten- found in a single dike from the Wilson Nunataks. Clinopyroxenes
sify, and the extinction angle changes to ZAc = 25°, changes that have been almost totally replaced by chlorite. Amygdules are
suggest a higher iron content in the actinolite crystals. Grains of filled with epidote and/or chlorite ± quartz ± carbonate. The
reddish-brown amphibolite (RI/3 = 1.66, 2Va = 80°, ZAc = 18°, petrographic characteristics of these dikes very closely match the
6 = 0.020, Z = dark red brown, Y = red brown, X = pale red features of quartz keratophyres described by Williams and others
brown, Z>Y>X) occur only in the coarser grained parts of the (1982) and Nockolds and others (1978).
Wilson Nunataks sill. They occur as rims on relic clinopyroxene Type II dikes crop out only at High Nunatak and in the
grains and also apparently as primary crystals, as some grains of Wilson Nunataks. They were not found in contact with type I
this mineral exhibit the euhedral diamond-shaped amphibole dikes. Hand samples have an aphanitic to very fine grained green
cross section. Electron microprobe analyses of the reddish-brown to greenish-black groundmass in which are set scattered plagio-
amphiboles indicate that they are magnesian hastingsite (Leake, clase and hornblende phenocrysts (3 mm). Plagioclase pheno-
1978). Some of the primary magnesian hastingsite is rimmed crysts are now mixtures of epidote and albite ± sericite and
with actinolite, and in one instance a clinopyroxene core is carbonate, but the hornblende phenocrysts are fresh (RIß = 1.67,
rimmed with magnesian hastingsite, which is in turn rimmed with 2Va = 75°, ZAc = 1 I o , 5 = 0.026, Z = moderate red brown, Y =
actinolite. Pumpellyite is not present in rocks from the Wilson yellow brown, X = straw yellow, Z>Y>X). The groundmass is
Nunataks sill except for a single anomalous occurrence in a largely albite, hornblende occasionally rimmed with actinolite,
quartz-rich sample described by Bauer (1983). The pegmatitic and pyrite along with lesser amounts of sphene, actinolite, apatite,
segregations were originally essentially bimineralic (plagioclase hematite, and quartz. Trachyitic texture is locally developed, and
and magnesian hastingsite) and equigranular. Their mineralogy is a very few partially chloritized clinopyroxene crystals (1 mm)
now similar to the interior of the sill. occur in the groundmass of several of the dikes. Andesitic dikes
previously mentioned are simply slightly more siliceous variants
Spessartite lamprophyre plug of the type II dikes.
The ground mass of this rock body is an aphanitic to very Quartz latite dike
fine grained mottled green to greenish-black mixture of albite,
actinolite, epidote, calcite, chlorite, pumpellyite, pyrite, and In thin section the fine-grained quartz latite dike displays a
sphene. Adjacent to the contact with the younger gabbro the plug typical hypidiomorphic intergrowth of plagioclase (albite and ep-
contains approximately 10 percent black hornblende phenocrysts idote), quartz, mafic minerals, and pyrite. Most of the mafic
(3 to 4 mm). Toward the core of the plug the number of horn- minerals are now chloritized, but their shapes suggest they were
blende phenocrysts decreases, but their size reaches a maximum originally biotite. A trace amount of relict hornblende (RIß =
of 5 cm. The majority of the hornblende phenocrysts have been 1.65,8 = 0.020, ZAc = 14°, Z = dark green, X = moderate yellow
entirely replaced by chlorite and lesser actinolite. A few blocky green) rimmed with actinolite is present. The groundmass is a
clinopyroxene phenocrysts (5 mm) are also present; these have mixture of chlorite, albite, actinolite, pyrite, epidote, sphene, apa-
been partially uralitized. Amygdules (< 1 percent) are filled with tite, zircon, hematite, and calcite.
actinolite, quartz, and chlorite and rimmed with opaque minerals.
Soholt Peaks stock
Mafic and andesitic dikes
Fresh hand samples are dark gray to greenish-black and
Mafic dikes are largely plagioclase phyric, subophitic to poi- consist of 10 to 20 percent phenocrysts (3 to 4 mm) of feldspar
kilitic textured meta-diabases or gabbros (type I), but several of (mostly sanidine) and high-temperature (ß) quartz set in an apha-
the dikes (type II) exposed at High Nunatak and in the Wilson nitic groundmass. Many of the ß quartz phenocrysts are marginal-
Nunataks also contain magnesian hastingsite similar to that which ly resorbed or embayed, glomeroporphyritic, and occasionally
occurs in the Wilson Nunataks sill. Hand samples of type I dikes crushed and recrystallized. Feldspar phenocrysts are almost entire-
have an aphanitic to very fine grained green to greenish-black ly unaltered. The groundmass is largely microcrystalline (0.05 to
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
0.10 mm) granoblastic quartz + feldspar, minor calcite, hematite, pellyite, sericite, and sphene. Felsic flows tend to be yellowish
and rare epidote. Texture and composition suggest the ground- brown, tan, or light gray and are often plagioclase and/or quartz
mass represents devitrified glass (Lofgren, 1971). The ground- phyric. Sanidine and hornblende phenocrysts are uncommon.
mass also contains small (0.1 to 1.0 mm) anhedral porphyroblasts Except for the development of smaller amounts of actinolite and
of nearly isotropic, optically negative chlorite (weakly pleochroic the lack of pumpellyite the groundmass mineralogy of these rocks
in shades of green and pale yellow green), and abundant ragged is similar to that of the mafic flows. Patches of mosaic-textured
flakes of biotite (pleochroic in shades of dark olive to pale yel- quartz and feldspar suggest that some of these rocks were origi-
low). The biotite, and locally the chlorite, define a moderately nally largely glass. Although metamorphism has obliterated many
well developed foliation. Accessory minerals in approximate or- of the primary features, some of the felsic rocks in the Liberty
der of abundance are pyrite, magnetite, sphene, apatite, and zir- Hills appear to have been emplaced as ash flows.
con. Vennum and Nishi (this volume) have described an unusual
assemblage of secondary materials that have formed from the GEOCHEMISTRY
oxidation of pyrite concentrated in the margins of this stock.
Mafic rocks
Lava flows
Sixty-four new analyses (37 from stocks and sills, 14 dikes,
Mafic flows are generally purple to green, are locally pil- and 13 lava flows) of major, minor, and trace elements are re-
lowed and amygdaloidal, and are usually plagioclase phyric. Clin- ported in tables 1A-D and 2A. CIPW norms for all 64 analyses
opyroxene phenocrysts are uncommon, and olivine phenocrysts are listed in the same tables and are plotted on Figure 4; the
are rare. Plagioclase phenocrysts have been converted to a mix- normative basalt classification is from Yoder and Tilley (1962).
ture of albite, epidote, and sericite ± calcite, whereas olivine has Norms were calculated after the analyses were converted to a 100
been completely pseudomorphed by calcite, chlorite, opaque percent anhydrous total. As the oxidation state of iron has a
minerals, and epidote. Clinopyroxene phenocrysts are generally significant effect on the amount of normative quartz, these com-
relatively fresh but are commonly rimmed by actinolite and/or putations were completed using an Fe203:Fe0 ratio of 0.15
opaque minerals or partially replaced by chlorite + calcite. (Brooks, 1976). When calculated in this fashion, 9 analyses are
Amygdules are filled with epidote, chlorite, calcite, and/or pum- silica-saturated tholeiites (quartz normative), 28 are olivine tho-
pellyite, and the groundmass often displays a pilotaxitic to tra- leiites (normative hypersthene and olivine), and 27 are alkali
chytic texture where plagioclase laths are enclosed in a matrix of basalts (normative nepheline). Analyses from High Nunatak plot
actinolite, albite, epidote, calcite, chlorite, opaque minerals, pum- mainly in the olivine tholeiite field, but those from other centers
Ne-
Intrusives
Edson Hills
High Nunatak o
Lamprophyre •
Wilson Nunatak Group A
Volcanics x
Figure 4. Plot of CIPW norms calculated from chemically analyzed samples of mafic igneous rocks from
the southern Heritage Range. Classification is from Yoder and Tilley (1962).
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
of igneous activity are not confined to any particular part of the element mobility during metamorphism to nonoceanic basalt.
diagram. On an alkali-silica diagram (Fig. 5), all but 8 analyses Due to the apparent mobility of silica and the alkali elements
fall inside the alkali basalt field of Macdonald and Katsura during metamorphism, the FeO*/MgO ratio (where FeO* is
(1964). On an AFM diagram (Fig. 6) the analyses form a large total iron expressed as FeO + 0.9 Fe203) is apparently a much
cluster of points near the center of the triangle and are approxi- better indicator of fractionation than the more commonly used
mately equally divided between the tholeiitic and calc-alkaline Harker diagrams or solidification index (Saunders and others,
fields of Irvine and Barager (1971). Similar results are obtained 1979). FeO* is plotted against FeO*/MgO in Figure 8 and
from a plot (Fig. 7) of weight percent AI2O3 versus normative against Si02 in Figure 9. Although some calc-alkaline character-
plagioclase composition [100An/(An+Ab+5/3Ne)]. The dikes are istics are still evident, these two diagrams suggest that the suite of
generally higher in Si02 than the rest of the analyses, and al- mafic igneous rocks from the southern Heritage Range is much
though there are exceptions, they also have a tendency to be more strongly tholeiitic than indicated by Figures 6 and 7, both of
lower in AI2O3, MgO, CaO, and total iron oxides and higher in which are partially based on abundance of alkali elements. Figure
Na 2 0 than the other rock types. 8 also shows that as the FeOVMgO ratio increases, there is an
It is, however, now well known that ocean-floor basalt is accompanying increase in the amount of total iron, a feature
prone to extensive chemical modification when subjected to considered to be indicative of a tholeiitic differentiation trend
either hydrothermal alteration (Bass and others, 1973) or green- (Miyashiro, 1974). Irvine and Barager (1971) have previously
schist facies metamorphism (Pearce, 1975). The oxides that are commented that in tholeiitic series, andesites and/or more felsic
most mobile during metamorphism appear to be CaO and AI2O3 rocks are greatly subordinate to basalts, but that in calc-alkaline
and, to a lesser extent, Na20, K2O, Si02, and FeO. Although suites, this situation is reversed. As discussed in a later section of
Bass and others (1973) and Pearce (1975) dealt with ocean-floor this chapter, igneous rocks of the southern Heritage Range are
basalt, it seems safe to extend Pearce's conclusions regarding dominantly basaltic in composition. Cr and Ni and, to a lesser
10-
9-
8 -
ALKALI BASALT
1-
CM
6 -
O
CM c
CO 3
Z
#
I- 4-
x
(D
ÜJ 3
£
2
THOLEIITIC BASALT
1-
40 45 50 55
WEIGHT % SiO.
Figure 5. Variation between total alkalies and Si02 in chemically analyzed samples of mafic igneous
rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Classification is from Macdonald and Katsura (1964).
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
CM s ¡o C
Ms C M g L O MW
C
cn co C ooo 8 JS C M R
W MIO co o o CO d o CO O) o cn io
o CO —
iTf C
M
CM Tf io
<O
O
to co
O
a> a> co CM
CM OlfiCONÜltÜT-CMOJiONi-
oCM oo
aiTfco^nr-eOTfoiNflw oo CO CM CM
^ U) (0 IO CM O
IO CM
CM
O>
O
R-
co
03 cocÜTtTroöiocdpjööco CO CM
T* r-
CM CMIco
O io CM CO C MIO to O) co00 C
oaD 1
co co t-> co co •t r- O to
< CO TT CM' co CO CM
oo° •>* O o C M
in
ai o CO o CM CO co
T o
io CM
CO
CO
oCrO
» co o CO CO
ni CM co
CM co CM in co
CM 00
o O ) T- CO CO co CM
I- MO N O 5T o
00 CM 00 •O co
co o to c\i to D in CO OI
cn
o
CO
CO o CM
CO co oo
CM IO CM
co
O)
CO
o 00
CM
TT t- co CM CM
CM co IF o C CO o co co C»
oM CM C TI-
CM
XI M CO o CO M cn CM IO EN
H- < CO CM co' co' co O co aj CM O 00 CM TT CM CO O CO CM oo
TT cn T— CM O LO CM T- 0> CM LO
CM
R- CM IO
CM LO LO y— ID Tf CO C
t- C
co
oO LO in Mo
00 C
o in MO 0) ocn o o> o
co
o
W cd CM1Tf CO T— o CO co' CM CM oY— r-- o C Mo CMC
co
McoTt oC>
M
o
co
->T IO CO in CO CO
CM oco in CO co q oo C
MCO 0) IOO) CM •T CO
LO O) co Tf CM CO
co'
TT CM oo co' o C
O oo' CM o o co A ooo ® o st
•i ^ CM
0) co
CO
C/) O) T
CM_ C
<D
r-- cn IO co in co CM o oo co
CM O) o CM CM o> o> m a»
—
,
CM
co co' co co d CO co o O o> co ooo
> ioo o l c o oo
c o o o olOo •a- CM CM
CM LO -<T
TT F- o> (O Tt
CM
CM
1 CMr-
oo CMr- C
M CJ> PI 05 oC>
cn co CO C
M OCO
C
M oo
co
co C
Mco C MC Mo co' co o o 8 o O) oco sCOo T-
n co O
OS
w C
M •t C
CM
M C
M 00
CM 00 T- CM oo co co CM m
co CM ^— ooo IoO co T CM oR-
>
T lO
cry CD CM io" oo o ö aj co' o o co oi o T- CO IO
CM CO 00
CM
oo co
Ti a> 00 io in n 00 IO
CM o o LO co C O CO o IO •q- co CO
o00 co o Tf r-- CM o co
io CM co co o
co CO —
CM o o T co O O co
o oo io co <I- T-
00 T CO C
T- io co
^ N M -TR 1- CO
CM
0) O) in
T- co io
o cn o 8 CM co o CO O oco CM
co
LO M N. C Mo
cn <
X i * 'co
io — oT
— CO o C
ai
MIO
CO o co' oo co co co
co co
co O) CO IO CO
CO LO •<T
— o> (O ID C M CM
C
M C
<O 8 oIO g oo ai co
CM Ol io S5 O tt
3 in CMcd co O CO Ti o o s n in^ R- CM T- O CO CO
•M- IO ® co co
o
OJ
Q. io io
£
.O) K i f n o i N c o n s i o o f N CD
M
< i O
.g
l^OIOO'-OfflS'ii-lO
TT ^ TT c\I oo Ö C> to CM -r^ Ö co
A
•tO
£ ss C T t1c oT-o o-Rm
O - C^
NJc j ^Cc
MMO)
CM CM 00
CM 0> T-
SS w —
t CM T- -3-
.C
I co o in Si in co C CM co cn «
cn H- OO) oM m co o 5 CO 0)
T o 8 C CM 00 o cri co CM d in o> !J LO CM CO O CO CO O O xr T- 00 CM
(Ü cn •4» co IO -TF CM R- CM CO CO CO 00 CO
T- CO 5
8§ «J
U
<n IC<U
S
O s
2L 3 Si
co ^
O o n ° N ° 9 9 9 , ° ° 0 0 0 Ö
o
cr !5 B O I. 3 • H .O -O O c/5 I— > >- N rsi
YUJMJ,"JC01(T CO CM CM CM RcOOOOOOZZO.CCCOC/5
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
CM co h» co O N O) O
«o> CD co CD CM T- CM 0> F- O
ai co •G O CO CM •>*' C\I
CMC M
CM 0) lO CM co loo
O h* co C
M
O
CM
•>»
CO co CO r-. co
CO lO 1 c\i ci C
M
CMC M — 1— 1—
CM co (0
co C
t^ > 00
M om r-- m
cq
CO m
< CO T— oco oC0 co* CM <o cvi
w iri
co ci
C
M
CM PI O) s oo lO o o m m
CM CM
5 ci K t— CO K c\i lO CM
« CMCM
CM
CMco •q- co C
CM
O
m in r- co
co
oo
m co o C O)
J3 < -<*o KM ci K CM co Tf
CM co ci
CMCM
CM o to CO co co co oo
o r- a> U) in O) o
w lO Tf ui CO co CM' ^
CMC M
r--
co lO
o t^ co in m
00 or-- co
a> co o
w CO CMlO c\i
CMC M
CMco h- oo <JJ co
CM_ ci -a- -s-
m
< r-: O
co) h- co O CM
CM^
CM CMco co ci
C
M m T T O CD 0> h.
Tf i- r~ co
W
o CO rS
CO CM
r- o co oo O)
S ID C\i O
co <o
rr O) CMCO o> co
co o •<t
oo co' O
a> O) r-- 00 0)
^ co tri
M co' cvi ci
CMCM ""
CM co o a> 00 O) r-- o
h- CJ) CMai co co r» CO
O
00 o ai K co
CM
ai co' co co o
•a-
lO m 5 co u
co> t o PI
o> < o> O
co) o co c\i o
X CM
CM
m
f» R CO CO S oo Of- O T-
s < Tf C CM CO tri •>ï CO T^
CMM CM
CO C MCM co o <o 00 U) co
m
<
oo T— co CMm co
co' IN co IRI CMCMo
c CM CM
88.
£ U5 CMm CMTf co lO 0)
ai t-. co ¡ô CMco CMlO O
•<t s> C
M
Mco co
C ci o cô CMC MO
!
.s
w
2L
& I
s^
•S 0. _Q C CD ._ CL
o O < < O OO z a ÎÔ = I <
cc
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
*cb nofti^ooowtMinr-oi Ol
h- oi^r-^cocDcyoo-r-h-M-ioco 01
03 o)N(\iWfliòffi'o>(\iòdri OL io
oco
Cco
O O CO O 1- ffi in o N h
o co co T- o) CM CO F- CO <M o> co co
o co
CJ ffl 6 N oi ö oo oo ^ c\i ö oi CM O s ^ oo TI* CM T- LO CM 1— CO
<- ^ CM ^
X IO CJ T-
CO CM co co
CO m oi-q-coioi-oowcoocooico
< ^ ^ r - O N i - W W O O O O oi co co CM
io co co co CJ o CO CM CO n oO
oi^Nwooaiuiowd^ OL n s
00
T- CM CJ
1- CO
CM O^-OO Ol 00 t- O CO CO
CM <
CO io CM io n io to o t ui
X oo ci T - io oiriK^r^o co CO CM H- •J ID N CO oi N Ol
^ r - CM
CO lO IO T- CO io CO
IO o -a- co co
% oicoh-coiocotoioiotoiio
M m
C < OU)fflOWT->illJffiO)IO® oo O M CM CM CM T-
w IO CO 03 s co T- O) lH-
O o
CM co
CO K CO
co m NCMiOfflmioNminin^ffl -a-
CO < co
N^iriioiodirimriwdw o oo> O CM o S o
w y— o 00 ^S" CO 00 CM OT-IOR^
^
CO
oo o o o o CM o o M co oo oo
i- io T- N n CJ CM H- CM
O I-» cj co c\i Ò S T-' N Ò Ò OL IS- CO OL CO
X co co ^t CO to
IO
CM
coc h-o)^riot-oo(otoc\iocoio co
00
< lomnwoiT-sss^oo oi
io s d r1 i w s d dT—d T—^ N d r i oi o co co ^ 00 CO IO CO CO CO CO IF
CM CO CO CJ CO CO OL 00 C
CO
M CM O CM
CO IO
mnvosiDNNoooin'-
C
<O ^ N H J f f l r - i - O O T H J O ^
^s ^ T f N s d d*—o r i o d r i T-
Ti
C J C O O J C O T - C J C O C M
CO CO 00 T - I O
00
O)
T— CO I--. CM
C
M h- o CM O o W N (O O) io CO
r- co •t o W IO N V N
CO O cj to id CO coO iotoin CO co
O IO CO CO Ò Ò CM CO io CO 00 CO
X -a- oi -a- CJ
co N in
"Ì -r-
T» m oi in CM t RT CJ
Ol < N Ifl CI ••- CO O IOö ö io co oo »-CO Ol o to 00 CO o
X Tf T- T-
ci oi co co CM
co co CO 00 R-- CJ co co
CO
CO co o oo TT r- oi oo
8 CO
< s a C\I
CO TT
IO IO
(II O) ID p
ö id aj co
co co
ö
X C CO o oi t to h- H- H- CO
.o co IO ti Tt to CC
O in
CO
co io 1-
^
s. =5 M
£
CoO •S> o co o o I- O CO CO CO CO io cu
<n
< i CJ CJ O io CJ in oi co co in Q.
co
X t^ evi r-^ co 6 in' N ^ ^ o CO C M CO O CO CM LO IO o co io CO
.5 €g .ig
« co IO 1 - CO CO ^
co co
«
C
M o o o w cu t^ cjT- TC
CM CM
fO oi i/l
C
CM
O C
<O 8 O) CM I- OL OL cu
X CD CO CM F^CO ò io to ri ^ ò oi
oi <? CO •q- o oo O l IO O io00
^ CM to C
M co
8§ cco ^ O) CJ 1- C
M 1 co co 1-
o« CO
c
01 CD
E
^CL
Specimen
C
.D
CO
JoC O n | 0
" 0 0 0 0 0
N 0 0 0 8
£oE YS2_CJ£"GJCOI(O CO CJ co co Sa o o o o o
O 3 CO -S O
EL CC to M W I - > >- N N
-C C
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
co o co co
v> co 00 R-- tco CO lC
OM r-- oC>
O MT T
CM
w co' CM' CM H-' co CM T
—
CM CM T- CM
C
MT — r* •o<t co co co
co
co m t o «o 00
CM Tf CM oo h-
to *—
00 CO
ci T~ o
X co
CM00 o o o co C M1—
CO m
< CO en co co CO r-- co CJ\
m CM y— ô CMC Mci
CMCM C
M
co co t*. o O ) oo> co en in
CM m
CM < 00 00 y— co o>o> •"i
cri c\i
W
•<* en 00 C
MC M CMCO CMCO
m C
COm o
M CO lO C
M
MoCMco
CM < CD CD CMCM
W C
O co
o co O
<OC M
O
CO O) m
o CO co
co 00 C
CD
M lO C Mo
CMC M
coc CMco h- g 0) co co 1
m
<
co C
M co o co o —
10 ci
T—
C
M CM CD o' c\i O
C
M CM CM
co •t co lO co 00 C
M
m llO m co co llO o
< CO
MTf iri ci co CO
M C
M CM ci
CM
CM a> co
mo o 00 oo o>
f^
co CMco o 00 O
X K iri CO iri CD C M
C
MC M
m T —
co h- W
co O —
, co r-- T-
MCJ\ co co P
C
CM3 oi oi r-' C M
•q- C
MlO 1co 8 o co y—
m
< oo CO O) CM co CO co
en oi iri ô r- iri co CMci
CMCM CM
CM y—co OT
CM0) lco —
m
< T— co 0) en
X ci co ai •>» C
Mci
CM 10 O) lO oo C
MC M
O m o u-> a> o> co C
MlO CO
CO < o ri O N co ci ci evi ci
X C CM CM CM
Q>
a R- R- CM co CM
CM £
CM m
< o o co CMO) 5 cô CO 5
CO •S> co evi cri ci •qrevi o
i CM CM CM
.s
«
C 8. I
o s^
E
'8 •8
CL o a. .Q c œ ._
C0 cc o < < O OO Z Q i ô = I £
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
¡P^OJOltOls^iflotOT-o o>
«¡•»W^lDr-olCMWtOtMS oi
o o ^ w a i d o i N N w o r i O) oco Ol O Ol oto oCO
01
in T- T^- o 8 CM
in
OlfflSffl'jT-i-oliiios^
ffl'-^Noidsnti^dri oi S ffl Ol ^
CO O T- CM OL CO CM CO CM CO OL 1
Ol CM lO 7 ^ CO CM CM co M
^T T—
£°<$r--mT-coor^toooi'<j- CO
NOLNR-TOI-NTOR-O^LO 0)
wdriNfflddSNoio'ri oi O O O T- O CM OL cn o
Ol CM in in m CO T-
CM to
"tf —
i r* CM
in pi ^t m ID CO IN TT Q
to CM co co
00 N i - CO
ri ö ö K oo O CM o o O CM CM o CM
in to co TT CO T- m co co
CM in r-
CO N (O N O) N (O O CM ID
N IO ^ ^ r - M ID in S o (O ID oi
o ri oi Tf ri o N ri 3 C\I
oi O co o o O CM N o
^ T
— T
— oi O -q- CO CO CM co r-.
r-. co co
poiooioNnnwioNio
NLDFFLOVI-OLO'-O^O to
in
Hi'-ftiujirid^oddditi oi o öl O Tj O O CD Is- o
01
CM in co
i- 10 CM CO oi co
^r T
— T CM
w ^ ^ ^ q r - w o ^ o i o s T
co
ioit'insofflodooin N O to O CM CM O O
r- T- CO CM OL CO CO CO
co T
wgoto^oiooiwioNoi CM
CMocq^'r-cMT-coinT-CMO CO
«¡"-iriioodsBciddiij oi oo Ol oCM oO 0 II) Tf h- O
en ^ 01 CM T- CD CO
CM CO co
( D N l O l f i ^ O ' - f t l O C O N « )
p oCM
i *—
i oCOCOOCNJIOCVI
qoNipsinnoi* O CM
in CM
O ^ n O l O f f l N i - B O ^ O co
•sf
CO
in Ö TT C\I IRI Ö CO CO C\I CLI Ö CM ö Tf oco co CM o
o co oi CD o
o co o o n ^ jj a) o ro
co in co ^ R; in N M « V o01
CM co c\i in Ö in to ^ Ö Ö O CO X- CM
in f- in co to
T-
o o co
•<t öco -a- co
co oi
o ^ n n o ^
T- oi co CM to CM
d N « ii ^ o
s
CO CO co CM o in m •r- m lO Ol
01 CO CM ~
R
— CD T- tD w CM CM
m 3
oco CM M CM CM
O N O (\I R- O cO C
oM CM CO io to sCO CM CM in
a
co co O I to CM in
CMco CO
W T- T-
-c
•9> co o rr co o s in n co 01
1- | 8 <q s n r- in o CM CO CM to TT a
o •s 8 NCOIRIÖIRICDCMCMÖCO oi co o
co oi 01 £
w m co CM
0)
I- co
od(öc\j(od(do)(\ir-d(vj to
O CM in CM r- CM CO CM CO CM T
— in
t— CO
co to ai o
«S CM CM 00 CM
!c
d)
S
a> •S
E ai
oo O O 9 9 O O 9oO O O 2 8
CL
CO tr — O 1-
ooooazzo-trwoiw
3 _Q _Q „O O t _
> >• N N
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
CO o to co M
co 3 co co co C
CO 5 S
*
O)
CM s •«r o co cJ o ci
W
in oo
T
w f~ Oi S CT
O
f oo o
C
wM COm co
co d oi o co C\i
o co in CO
CO co T—m o CO co
oo *
O oo CM T— CO
CM
« COCM CM CM *— CM o
CM 1— 1—
1— O) o>CO
in o> m
co oo co co
co N. i-. oo
r-
CM F-
W o CM co co ai £ *- o
CM
CM m co CM O) o CO co
CO F- 00 00 5 in
CM o CM CO co' co' co'
W CO
CM o O) 00 co CM O) 00 v-
m mC Moo co T—
C\l
CM F- N.' o CO in 5 co CM
CO
co
CM
CO
o m
CO *— C
oo
co
, O) in 05 om oo
oMrt CO CM C M
«
CM 1- -cf O! CM C
M
CO co CO
o CM CO r— <71v— R-
'rt lO f^ 8 G CJ) m a> co
CM fe CM' cJ y—
CM co oi CM IN CM' O
CO
CO CM T— lO
(-- CO O ) C
MC M
o> 1- CM 00 T—co in m •t
in d •>» C
M Cvi
CO C
M C
M
•"t a> o m in r^
co CM m -a- m co oo cq 5
1- CM CM in o * o
CÔ CM CM C
M
CM O CM CM•<* in
O h- y— O) lO o>
co co co' s co CM
X CM
CO O) co cq m
Tt in o
•<f 1- t W Os
o oi o oi
co
oo C
co o
X CM
CO rf oo m m r^
oo K o co co o co m oo oo S
X o oi oo
CM
in
oo —
i o
00 K MCJ\ 00 0) r--
C co mo
oo •q- co m r^ in
%
W & 0> d K
co
co co cvi o
S tr 25
S
Q. CO co co o co
co 1- CO CM m O) CM in
o f--
cp 00
o lC
O
O
o 1 8
co' o 1
co iri CM
i —
«
c 8. g
0) o
E ^c
1
Q_ •8
o CL r> ( - k -
CO CE O < < o o o Z QX O = 1 £
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
T CMCO •t CO oo co o CMI-»
JD o 00 co 05 o oo in
d oi Ö
Ol co •i— o CO
r^ in o d id o o CT) 1 C M 00 CO co h- in CM CO o>
oi t
f- Ol — C
y— y— T M C MCMin 00
Ul
(3
z< Tt
o
f- Q
co co o co 1*. -A- C
CMCO C
p d
O T-
MTI CO co 00
o> TJ- M O in
T- CO d O T- C Mcd
—
. CO
oto
o
co to
co r- cn h- h- N
•i n in
DC CM 00
111 CO
O <
P co CMCO co om co co co in o oo
T— CO
DC O)
*
IO oin r-» O
o ) I-- o CO in o oo co ( D O S co oo •q- in T- CM
1X11 m o CO
co CO id c\i o> O O) co y— cn •in
R- CM CM CM <t O) CO CO
zDC
UJ CMco co in 00
X co
co
*
CO oco oco m
co co
r- co o>
co in oco
1-
Z3 % z< c\i o cd C
Mco d o cd cd o oi
o> C
MC
T- CO
M CO
oCO
oCO CO
1X11 CM z* 8 CO o co
o> CO in in h-
H CO <
X
c\i o in
oo id o CoO c\i
in Ooo) oCO O to co co COC
T- O) cn
M o co oo
S
o
CO CM 00 CO T- CO CM O> LO
CC
u.
CO C
M •<t o> CM co co co o CO co
^ CM z
hi co co
o> o
co CMco N. CO o to
o 8 < in CMC Md d CO co' co d C
M oi
O)
r--
o Tf
oo in
05
CO
O)
oDC h- co
1>11
(0
C
M
m
o
o>
o 0)
CO y—
CO T—C Mto CO co ,
AB*
T
X CO oi oT
— T — CO o
cd CO T-'
—
io co o oi co CO o to 00 O) m oh-
CC in o cn CO C M CMco CO Mo>
C 00 C
M
H
Z
CC •>i 5 C
O p o m o •q- 00 CM O) OL oi
oLi. C
M oi
AB*
co oO) o o CM cd d t r i co' to o
CO
1- o CO
<
CO CO
o co co cn
o o>
Tt (O in o
CM o
CO
_ -a-
< in CO CM Y- 00 in tn
T- CO
S
DC
oZ
co co in •a- AQ ooo CM T —TT
oo co in 8 Cco
—
.
Q
Z
<
£ f-
O I0)
cd
in
CM
CM T-' id d id oo •cf V
—*d CO
M CD
oo C
OC
Ä
M
O C
M
lCOCO O CM
CM
co oo oiI - 3oo Oin C00M co
in
co
co
co oco i*.
o
co
Q.
< is o m co CD
o C
M i
CM
CM
Ti- o> oCM O) CCMO CM O) Q.
s O) CD cvi ed co o o in
1X11 co
X < CM' CO CM
o £a co
!S -R- F- CM
CO CO R-
CM M CM
CM Y- CO
TT CM
co to T
of T-
co co i-
IO r:
§. ™ CO CO CM
o .CD
.c
Q CoO T-
CO 00 C O oco oo in CO
T -
F- 8 to co m q cn O) C
MC M * -
0)
HI 55 o co d cd co' d Mco' o co'
id C d
o to oco
o<o £ CIo
8 co m
co CM
H a !c
o
CD
c 8. 6
o •S
<]>
E co ^
'8 ^o (i'^qO.o o o o ° o o o 8
Q. o CO OJ CO CM ,5 « o oO oi_ o3 oCO -Oz ja S o ._ c v_
CO EC « F < U . U . 5 5 Ü Z Y Q . I CL CC GO CO CO > >• N N
K CQ
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
T.O
f
Q
s cn
to
co •fl- C T
M00 CM
CO
to O oo
co) CM
0
© o o
•
•fl- T-* • f l in CO
1 5
-g =s
uu co o 0) o o."
o
z< o co 01 oo CO co co co io
oo co ©" o-o
r- co ri io oo' ò ò ò .t:
OC •fl- co uj e
© o
111 ? Q.
0
g
coOI * — ,
r-. to
IO o
CM oCO O
co) f".
S ®
CO k-
c o
OC lO O o> ri ri O < f
ILI CM ¿c
cp aic
X
z •i E
.2 ©
EC O 0)
Ui co o O O O o o o o c o
X co «
z< CO CO co r- •fl- oo IO
H ò Tf evi • * * o eo evi o ra ©
S3 C
M © 12
O © o
(0
UI
É
C
M *
z 8 at
at s 05
o> •fl
•fl
CMTf
O IO
¡2
•B ©
co
co < ri c\i T
—• f l Ò
s X
ooc £§ Oo
u.
(0 C
M o o oCM o o O o g a.
* CM z* o> N! co CO C (A
8
oc
< o> CCMM'
IO
ri CM' o
JO
cü
Ui
>
<fí
C
M
l•fl-
O «
m
co IO
co o> 00 IO
co CM
•fl- —
,MTf
C
ü a
0 ra
£ ©
X < IO —
.
CM' ai CO o io' CM' © o-
c ü
1 5
oc
o co
*
m
<
o CM CM
IV. •fl-
io' eo
co—
, t£>
CM CM
o co
co R-.
0)
o o
K Í2.
O ?
ri ri o' o"
W ® fl
< JO
= ra
3c
o
111
> CO
o
«
C
<D
f-. C
oMCTI —
. —
. CcoM cn CMC
co Ma>
CO
x:
o. z
ri- ri ò ri CNJ ri 1
— ò
lí
•fl
E ra co
oc É «
o oo •fl- oIO oo CM
z co
& IO •A o>eo IO co
•fl- o
fl
o o C M ri O) Ò evi ò ÍT ra
z< S CM
ra §
ra 2
-o c
2 CM co oco •fl- 00 00 co
•fl- co co
co
O) «
C •fl- tv
E co <O cri eo' io evi •fl ra 5
X c
UI
X
o
Q
ss. co o oCM IIOO CO oo R--
CD C
l|
M
% co co co oq co ra x
r-
Ui
_J
S3 f-
o •9> CM ri
CM CM ri
ò co' O ò "D c
m
< i CM ©
W oOí
« 3 TJ
«0 wC
-Q
8. i I. .i
Specimen
« ra
è 1 e
•8 o. -O c
o
cc o < < ODO - o. o
ÍO = 2 < <
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
co o C Mo co CO o CM•t oo in o
CO H f- CMco co co
r-.
X o in r—
m in 1 oo ö CO I--.' in C
M oi «I N IO
n M io ih-O-i-CMOCDmOOl
C - l O C O i n O O l C D O l O
— Ol 01 co r- i- T-
co co
UJ co OT s00
m
co
CM
£ s ß r co •a-
O CM
cxi o co i n o o oi lO C
CO
D N
05 00 CM W ^l 00TTC(0 CO ts
z
<
I 01 1- 00 •>* C
OO CMM COT-I -
OC
LU
a< o CMo o co m
m co
oo o Tj mco
oo in co Ol C
oMin C
MCO
CO
m
K X < co'
m co' d
T— Tf CO o o co o m
o CO Tt in o
co C
r--
o CO Tj-
£ CO Mt co
s w
UJ
X
z
EC
UJ
co
co
o l-
o CO o CCT!M
m co o O w —
,
TF o o
CM m CD m co m
CM
T
o n o int
X C
mO - oi oi O TF in co c\i o o co co o c M w - i T t o c - c o i o
CMTtoOCOCMlOCMh-lO
I- X *—
co T- Tf C
M -r-
o
CO
Ol m o o o 1— co co co CO in
CO 00
UJ in co co T o T— 1— CMco •a- T-
AB
m o
H
X
CO oo
m d c\i co CMCO d c\i 8 co o
T- m
Ol T-
CM
oC
M
£
o
oc
LL co oCO co
co 001 Ol CO m co co
co CM m
Ol
§
5
I- co' Ol co o 00
V)
* X m i n co' o o
01
• » D 0 0 ) 0 1 O U ) ' - O U ) ' - ( \ I N O
COCMLOR-COTFCOCMOOCOCOCMOO
o T- -T- CM CM
o
oc
o co o 00 o co Tt Ol CD Ol m C
M oo
z Xs 1-
o
CO co oo
CO co oi
oo co m
o co in Tf d oo m T- Tf 00 co in co co m CO
<
o in TT co m o o CO in C M co
o
> CMOl T o co co TT oo m
00 m
T— 00 Ol
o m m CMCO Ti- o O l Ol CM
11. CO < CMo ed co' in co d co oi C
CO O TT T-Ol CmC
O O
W O
< m Ol OC1-
M M W C
M
C
M CO
s
o coo
oc
o oo o o TI- •a- Tf Ol o 0
LL m co C Tf
O 00 o o C Mm 01
o o oi Mco' co o
g < C CM
oo O O O ^ ^ - ' - N N I O ' t f O
X in C
<
o
TO
f COCOCO T- 01C0 CO
Ol 00 Ol C
MM CO 00
C
a
UJ
> CD Tf m oOl C M ch-o m cmo oo
C
oMTi C MTt o imn cC
M C
Mo c o C
oM
AB
< %
co T— i n c d
T
T o' Tf C
O CM oN nCM io in
oo w
ci co oco r^ o o
m T~ o oo-r-
s
oc
co r- K) (M ID
O
z
o
C M O l i n i O ^ O l O C M C M Q ^ C O
CO m §K C M c o c o c M o q i - r ^ ^ r ^ i n i n h - ;
z V) < oidiricowdinoicocNio^ co omccoooio- rc ^
o^T-ji-occM
o O
inl TTo
< s. •S co CO CM
< •c
o •S> oo o CM CM m <u
s
o oo co co co
m I co o co CO CM co Tf m co a
UJ CO
Tf or-»
X
co < c d co N.' o co r^l o o co
8 t 8 co
TF T-
Ü
<
CM
UJ i-
O
0)
8
o
£ CO CM
N.
oCM o
CO
—
, r-« oi o ino
CNJ c o
t—
co m
01
CM
m
CM
.c
101/1
-1 s, 05 s s
CM
co oi oo co oo
m
co CO o oo CM d o CM
X «S Tt Ol 00 CM CM CM
< "c5 oi CM CM
i- Is« !
c
01
c
Q) 8. § .3s021
E
'Q.8 o O n 0 9 9 , 0 ° O O oCM rä .gcooi-s — ^jgo^. ci_
yCO F -< il
o
CO cc >< u- « i " « 2nSCJCMCM
-XL a. X -g P c G O O O Z Q . C C t O W > > N N
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
co co (D CD CO O) IO C
MO C M
CO LO (D CO N C
N CO co C oO C
My—
O CO
C
M evi
X O -ST —
i
"
CO CO O CM CM o co O) -r-
co H IO CD M r- M U O
CM O •fl IO • f l (S O d i <- »"
IO
X
CM co CO co h - 0) IO •fl-
co m CO (D •fl; CM IO co O CO
"fl- < co IO CT) CM' CM CM
X CM
CC
D A •fl- CO t co
•co O) CMCO CO
OO 1- cri
LO CO
LO O X-'
CM
CO
LO h-
evi
X CMC MT- CM
IO oo> C
•fl- D
Ci co
o O)
P-» CD
CM
IO m
<
•fl-
co
w ed co co CM
CM
LO
co CM E» co
co H
CD CM LO S LO o>
co o •fl- LO CM IO io evi ò
X eo CM
CO co LO •fl; o C O •fl-
co
co H o>Ico
O
co O co co C
M
io
X O CO Ò
CM
o co j; L ò C M
io CM •fl- CO CM CO IO oco
> •fl-
-fl- m
< CO LO o> T—CO CMC O x- C
r- M
V) CM CO • f l ci
Ò
•fl-
CM CM
co CM •fl- co co co CD LO LO co
o m CM O cn o O LO 00
co < r»' co
CM ò
X CM" LO c\i
T— CM
L O •fl- O co y— o S S2 S
co m
<
co o) co CM
w oCM eo LO co Ò
CM LO
IO co o
o•fl; co y— co CD -r-
co m
< O) LO co LO CM co o
w LO
co o CO LO Ò o>
C CM
O
QJ
.
h* CO O) •fl- o LO o 1—
co co o> co CM e»
M H
C O
« N CM
•S> CM co o •fl" co evi o
X co 1
—
i
.--—
c
co
o g
Specimen
CL O
P
O Q.
O •Q C L. œ ._ x> . — S CL
CC O < < O = 2 <
O OO2 Q
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
co oin oTT co
co in CO in
CO oi co CM O
00l
CO o tri
TT
co TT' CMco
X
IT t-. o' d CM iri CM O oi
Ol
in ^ co oi m
CM Ol T- 00 COS CO CO
LO R-
CD
CO
D O
rv CI oo Ol TT oco y— IV
o co C M •A
CO T
oT in o o C M O
y-^C
l *— |v
rv tri Mo o C
M W N
CM
OL
CM
CO CM CO CO CO CO
T - O O C O O T -
01 C
O (M ^ ^ U)
co oTT en C
Mco
TT Ol £ CD O01l 9. Ol
IV
o TT o 00 co
co
X DC rv O CM' to CM
oo •a-
C
CO
M
co -A in
CO CD TT
N
r- (gO Ol OW co
co
co
CC
DO o in 0 Ol
CM in
CO in co co co o
01 in co co •A fv
CM cr CO O d iri o o o TT' d in |V CM CO O CO CM
RV 01
CO f N
1- 01 r-
*- N toO)
Cin
O o CD o y— MTT o 00 C
C OC M
co in o C
M cq
cr
o oCO y-^ O
col y-^ o
'—
CO < CMo o CD 00 o o n in Ol T- COTf T-
iv 01 C
M T- TT 1- «1 o O 00
o coT oTT Ol o IV 0 co 01 co C
coO
N. T
CO
m oc o TT 01 co in
C
M o co o in c\i CM' O oi
oi M
co CD co N in N CD 00 O OD TT
X CM
cMom
•A
T- ^ oo w
•fl-
oi
co
TO
T CO CoM CM o m
CO TT
CD
C *—
Ol CO
CO C
O CDCOC
MC
d CM cvi o co MO O 11) N
CO ID
O)O
Ö CO
Ol ¡8 C
M CO
oo tt
co o CO en
o in oco C
M
Mm
C O l
IV
Ol cr o tri co o T" C Mo
MCO C CO co tv rv a
X Ol oTT CM 8 £ 8 S 8 8 CM «
CM
CM
co o CMo u
MCD co
01 C
"> T—
O
—
,
Ol Ol •A o1— O
ol
C
inD cr ci d tri co o in CO TT Ol
d o iri ö CD CM 00 CO 00 y- tv co co co
X CO — Ol Ol T- CD CO CM
TT o
m
CD 5 00 00 m Ol o C O -A C
co C
OC
M rvO C
OD in
Ol
U) oi o CD CM" o d d co o in eg tv o in
oi
CO CO
CM
rv
in 2 O i-f- O C
Ol •C
A M
CO in CMin
co co 8 CM
TT
o" < d tri ^ CM o o CoMiri CM' o iri ö
o CM -a- •A
CM CM 0 CM O
CO CM
T- CO
CM CO CM
01 co
CO C O co D •oA o Ol o co f
o 5 •A in tn T
co
in in 01 oo C in T CD
iv tri o Cvi tri
0Q.1 CD
o co d CM oi c o tT
CMo|vy—o O O
OT Ol .O
S TT C
M
CM
CM
co •Si o co 01
o oin co m co 0
CM FV
in 1 in Ol 00 tn •A TT 01 a
CC o CO CD
X .c CO
in
IV ai CM O
8 I
T- "T 1
lO T- CO CM 00
CO
CO
T- OL CD CO
10 W
T-
CD N
•R-
IB
a
TT -A
01
FV
" I IV co
co co co Ol
co co
O TT 0
CM co 01
CM .c
«011
inCO co
1 CD o tri tri o co co CO o Tf CM T—
O
OT <0 in
§ c§o co
OO
•fl- Tf
CM N
co oi^ Iv
CM
IV
Ol
S
oc/i
a
a:
| s
'8 oo n N o N 0 0 0 O O o ^O o o 2 .5 (0 — o i. 3 n £ — . o - o o w j e ci_
CL cr y O i 1 ® B £ S1 « o w PI w ,o
Kmoüooüz2o.a:(/)o)h>>-NN
W WF<u-U-22ozi<:o-X
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
oo m Tf C O fS Tco
f
O Tf TI- o> in R
R DC rv.' CO oi
Tf
oo oi ci o ' ©
CoO co Ti- co 00 CO in co cn
co
co co a>co CO O) 0) o CM
co in iri CO o' o
oo Tf ^
lO o CM o CO in
co
Q o
CM oi
co
T f co
oi
co CM
in T f
cn co 8
ci
X cr co
o o
CO o r-- in -a- Tf co Tf
co f» T t oo co TT o o CM
DC K co O T f ó Ó O
co co
CO CO Tf oo o 00
in cc Tf Tf 00 00 05 o CM CM
co < in c> T f ci co Ô
CM m
co CO CO at t- CM
co
CO CO
in Tf Tf o I-». m
CM
X
CM*
CM
in CO
CO
co o' o o'
C-a-
O (S CO m o
CM o CM
co
oo in in
CM CO
co K r^ T f T í
8 ci
CM co
co CO in O Ti- CO
co co O) CO CO
m m T f co
co CO CO
at K o CM in CO co Ó o o
x CM CO
Cco
O m cô co 00
co o
m Tf Tf
cn
co
Tí
CM
in f^ CO T f ci o o
X TT
^ ^ CM
m
O
m
oh- Oco ocp oi--. oCM oco oCM oCM
«CO co
m
ci CM CO
CM
c\i o' CM' Ó
o•a; h- r-
CM
cn co
$ 8 C O co
o
o> CO
V— o ci
cd co co' oo'
iñ CM
in
o O
co in
o oin o•a; oT f oT f o oCM
00
CM" T f oi in CM 05 o'
CO •q- CM
CO co CO CO
CO
ocq co
co
O) r^ T f
in
o O)
co T T co' CM
0>
C Oo
T — 1—
X c CM CM
^
8&
10 j; h- o co oo
co oo
co I-» T f
oo CO CO
s CO Tt
co
W •2> CM' co' 00
oi co' co CO ci o
i
CO
.c
e o
<o s
E
'o iO S:
<
D o CL Jî C J: _
CL O) ~
W CC O < < O O O Z O X O = 2 <"
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
FeO + 0.9 FSgOg diagram (Fig. 12) fall in or just outside the "within-plate field"
(Pearce and Norry, 1979).
It should be pointed out that the validity of the above-
mentioned discrimination diagrams, especially the Ti-Zr-Y dia-
gram, has been recently questioned (Holm, 1982; Prestvik, 1982).
Some of these misgivings apparently result, however, because the
precautions mentioned by Pearce and Cann (1973) were not
followed (Brooks and Cole, 1980). In order to circumvent this
problem, only analyses with CaO + MgO between 12 and 20
percent and total alkalis < 20 percent after calculations are made
for presentation in an AFM diagram (Fig. 6) are plotted in Fig-
ures 11 and 12.
The scarcity of olivine and the relatively large amount of
plagioclase relative to pyroxene are suggestive of tholeiitic chemis-
try. Although titanaugite is apparently not present, optical proper-
ties of relict clinopyroxenes suggest a calcic augite composition.
This feature, the apparent lack of orthopyroxene, and the pres-
ence of magnesian hastingsite, are all characteristics of alkali
basalts. Thus, study of alteration-resistant trace-element abun-
Figure 6. Ternary plot showing variation of total alkalies, magnesium, dances and relict primary mineralogy suggests that the mafic
and iron expressed as oxides in chemically analyzed samples of igneous
rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Classification is from Irvine and igneous rocks of the southern Heritage Range are continental
Barager (1971). basalts, the original chemical compositions of which were mildly
tholeiitic or transitional between tholeiitic and alkali basalt. Their
intrusion into a thick sequence of carbonate and clastic sedimen-
tary rocks is not compatible with an oceanic island setting.
extent, Co, Cu, and V are the only trace elements with behaviors Felsic and intermediate rocks (>56 percent S1O2)
that correlate (negatively) with the FeO*/MgO ratio. Amounts
of alkalis, alkali earths, and various alkali/alkali-earth ratios fluc- Twenty analyses (14 lava flows, 4 dikes, and 2 from the
tuate randomly; this is believed due to mobility of these elements Soholt Peaks stock) of major, minor, and trace elements are
during metamorphism. reported in Tables ID and 2B. CIPW norms are listed in the
In 1970, Cann was able to show that amounts of Nb, Ti, Y, same tables and are plotted on Figure 13, the quartz-feldspar
and Zr in ocean-floor basalt fall within a fairly restricted range normative volcanic rock classification scheme of Streckeisen
and that abundances of these elements are strongly resistant to (1979). As some of the analyses reported total iron as Fe203,
modification by secondary processes. A number of other penolo- norms were calculated on the same basis as those for the basaltic
gists (Jakes and Gill, 1970; Pearce and Cann, 1971; Floyd and rocks (on a 100 percent anhydrous base with an Fe203:Fe0 ratio
Winchester, 1975; Pearce and others, 1975) have since devised a of 0.15). Analzyed samples span the complete range of interme-
variety of geochemical methods utilizing these four elements as diate to felsic compositions from andesite to alkali rhyolite. It
well as Cr, P, Sr, and the rare earths to determine the original should be emphasized that these rocks are present in the field in
chemistry and tectonic setting of altered basaltic rocks. Pearce far smaller amounts, relative to the basalts, than is indicated by
and Cann (1973) used the Y/Nb ratio to indicate whether a the number of analyses presented here. When these analyses are
specific rock is alkalic or tholeiitic; Y/Nb s£ 1 is indicative of plotted on an AFM diagram (Fig. 6) they appear to define a
alkaline chemistry and Y/Nb 5= 2 is indicative of tholeiitic chem- calc-alkaline differentiation trend. Plots of vanadium versus
istry in their scheme. Examination of a Ti-Y/Nb plot (Fig. 10) chromium (Fig. 14), vanadium versus FeOVMgO, and weight
indicates that all analyzed Ellsworth Mountains mafic rocks have percent Si02 versus chromium (the latter two not shown) all
Y/Nb ratios that fall in the transitional basalt chemistry range indicate that the felsic and intermediate rocks display both tholeii-
(Y/Nb 1, but < 2). When these analyses are plotted in a tic and calc-alkaline traits. These are apparently misleading ob-
Ti-Zr-Y discrimination diagram (Fig. 11), 22 of 26 points plot in servations, as several petrologists (Noble, 1968; Lipman and
or along the edge of the "within-plate basalt" field, a category that others, 1969; Kochhar, 1977) have shown that glassy felsic rocks
includes both ocean island and continental basalt (Pearce and are prone to modification of their chemical composition, espe-
Cann, 1973). On the previously mentioned Ti-Y/Nb plot, all cially of the alkali elements, by a variety of pre- and post-
analyzed samples fall in the continental tholeiite field but in areas consolidation mechanisms. Indeed the possibility of alkali
overlapped by the fields of either oceanic tholeiites and continen- exchange during hydration while these rocks were still glassy
tal alkali basalt. Twenty-five of 27 points plotted on a Zr/Y-Zr (Lipman and others, 1969) is supported by two lines of evidence.
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
When these analyses are plotted in a Na20-K20-Ca0 triangle erals could easily have been originally incorporated in glassy
(not shown), they outline a random distribution pattern scattered groundmasses. Contents of large ion lithophile elements (Ba, Rb,
over most of the diagram but concentrated toward the Na20 Sr) fall between those reported for calc-alkaline and shoshonitic
corner (50 to 85 percent relative Na20). In addition, rocks with associations (Jakes and White, 1972) and thus support the above
high Na20 contents generally have low K2O contents. conclusion, but as these elements are also prone to mobility this
Discrimination diagrams such as those used with basaltic criterion must be used with caution.
rocks have not been used extensively with altered igneous rocks
of other compositions. Winchester and Floyd (1977) and Floyd GEOCHRONOLOGY
and Winchester (1978) have, however, utilized several immobile
elements (Ce, Ga, Nb, Sc, Y, Ti, Zr) to construct a series of Lack of either unaltered rocks or minerals of suitable com-
diagrams relating altered intermediate and felsic volcanic rocks to position has restricted radiometric geochronology in the Ells-
their original chemical composition but not to tectonic setting. worth Mountains. Four whole-rock K-Ar dates from intrusive
Their plot of SiC>2 percent versus the ratio Zr/TiC>2, reproduced rocks reported earlier by Yoshida (1982) and six new K-Ar dates
as Figure 15, suggests that the intermediate and felsic volcanic performed on three intrusive rocks and three lava flows in the
rocks of the southern Heritage Range are in part calc-alkaline and German Democratic Republic (DDR) are listed in Table 3. Two
in part alkalic, i.e., that the high alkali contents present in the of Yoshida's dates and all six of the DDR dates are clearly
whole rock analyses are not entirely due to alkali element mobil- anomalous, most likely due to Ar loss. The three DDR dates
ity but are in part a primary magmatic characteristic of these from the Hyde Glacier sill range from 161 to 245 Ma and are
rocks. Granted none of these rocks apparently contain the modal much lower than Yoshida's 396-Ma date from the same body.
indicators of high alkalinity (feldspathoids, sodic amphibole The three dated alkali basalt flows from High Nunatak (242 to
and/or pyroxene, aenigmatite), but the components of these min- 303 Ma) are all interbedded with Cambrian sedimentary rocks of
2 2 —1
CALC-ALKALINE
10 -
9 -
8 -
100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
1 1 1 1 1
1 2 3 4 5
FeO*/MgO FeO*/MgO
Figure 8. Plot of FeO* versus FeO*/MgO for chemically analyzed Figure 9. Plot of FeO*/MgO versus SiC>2 for chemically analyzed sam-
samples of mafic igneous rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Clas- ples of mafic igneous rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Classifica-
sification is from Miyashiro (1974). tion is from Miyashiro (1974).
the Heritage Group. The two dikes dated by Yoshida give ages of event, and the age is close to the two K-Ar ages reported by
237 and 254 Ma. These two dikes intrude sedimentary rocks of Yoshida (1982) from the Hyde Glacier and Wilson Nunataks
the lower Heritage Group but are in turn truncated by a con- sills. Interpretation of the isochron is, however, problematic. If
glomeratic unit that is also part of the Heritage Group. The the samples were fresh and unmetamorphosed, the preferred ex-
significance of Yoshida's dates from the Wilson Nunatak sill (381 planation would be that 369 ± 1 8 Ma represents the time of
± 19 Ma) and the Hyde Glacier sill (396 ± 20 Ma) is discussed crystallization of the stock, in which case the high initial
87
below. Sr/ 86 Sr ratio would be ascribed to magma genesis by anatexis
Although igneous rocks of the Heritage Range are also or assimilation of older crustal material (either the exposed Cam-
generally unsuitable for Rb-Sr whole rock dating, a four-point brian strata of the Heritage Range or a hypothetical Precambrian
whole-rock isochron was obtained from the Soholt Peaks stock. basement). Yoshida (1982) has also reported a K-Ar date of 935
The available hand samples were small (about 500 g each) and ± 47 Ma from a fine-grained meta-pelite from the Wilson Nuna-
exhibited a moderate amount of groundmass alteration but con- taks, the only radiometric evidence of Precambrian rocks in the
tained reasonable fresh feldspar phenocrysts. Rb/Sr ratios were Ellsworth Mountains. In view of the altered nature and small size
determined on whole-rock powders by x-ray fluorescence (Pank- of the samples, however, it is equally possible that the data reflect
hurst and O'Nions, 1973), and Sr-isotope compositions were isotopic homogenization on a hand-specimen scale during low-
determined with a fully automated VG Micromass 30 mass spec- grade metamorphism, a phenomenon frequently claimed to occur
trometer at the Institute of Geological Sciences in London. Suffi- in fine-grained felsic volcanic rocks. This would imply a mid-
cient spread in Rb/Sr (Table 4) was found to define an age fairly Devonian phase of metamorphism, an event earlier postulated by
precisely, but some scatter of the data points outside analytical Yoshida (1982).
error is indicated by the MS WD figure of 7.3. If this scatter is Most geologists who have worked in the Ellsworth Moun-
used to define the uncertainty of a best fit line, an age of 369 ± 1 8 tains feel that the range was deformed and metamorphosed by a
Ma and an initial 87 Sr/ 86 Sr ratio of 0.7148 ± 0.0003 are ob- single orogenic event (Ellsworth Orogeny) that is presently no
tained (Fig. 16). These data clearly represent a discrete geological more closely dated than Late Permian to early Mesozoic (Crad-
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
dock, 1972; Ford, 1972). It is thought by Craddock (1983) to be dates and the age of emplacement of the Soholt Peaks stock
probably Triassic in age. Hjelle and others (1982) and Yoshida would imply the lack of a genetic link between these three intru-
(1982) have postulated other earlier periods of folding and/or sive bodies and the volcanic rocks of the Heritage Group. All
low-grade metamorphism. volcanic rocks discussed in this report are interbedded with sedi-
In choosing between the two alternative interpretations of mentary rocks containing Cambrian fossils (Webers, 1972; Hjelle
the Rb-Sr isochron, we are impressed by the fact that the Rb-Sr and others, 1978, 1982; Webers and Sporli, 1983). All plutonic
data are apparently unaffected by the Ellsworth Orogeny, and hypabyssal rocks discussed in this study are intrusive only
whereas this event apparently had a profound effect on the K-Ar into Heritage Group sedimentary rocks. The lack of intrusive
whole-rock ages. Because the earlier phases of metamorphism rocks, especially dikes, in the overlying Minaret Formation and
postulated by Yoshida (1982) are of low grade, it would seem Crashsite Quartzite and the close correspondence in chemical
illogical that almost total resetting should have occurred in an composition between the intrusive and extrusive rocks strongly
earlier phase but none at all during the later Ellsworth Orogeny. suggests that the intrusive igneous rocks of the southern Heritage
We, therefore, consider it more likely that the Rb-Sr age repre- Range, except for the Soholt Peaks stock, are cogenetic with the
sents a mid-Devonian intrusive emplacement of the Soholt Peaks volcanic rocks and were emplaced no later than Late Cambrian
stock and that low-grade metamorphism accompanying the Ells- time. We regard the K-Ar dates obtained from the Hyde Glacier
worth Orogeny slightly disturbed the Rb-Sr systematics but had a and Wilson Nunataks sills by Yoshida (1982) to be reset min-
much greater effect on the K-Ar whole-rock systems. imum ages of emplacement, and their close correspondence to the
In relation to the three anomalously low DDR K-Ar dates emplacement age of the Soholt Peaks stock to be coincidental.
from the Hyde Glacier sill (161 to 245 Ma), Yoshida's (1982)
COMPARISON WITH TRANSANTARCTIC
K-Ar dates of 381 ± 19 Ma from the Wilson Nunataks sill and
MOUNTAINS IGNEOUS ROCKS
396 ± 20 Ma from the Hyde Glacier sill must be considered
minimum ages of emplacement and also to have been partially Mesozoic basalt and dolerite, generally tholeiitic in composi-
reset. The apparent close correspondence between Yoshida's two tion and Jurassic in age, are widely distributed on Southern Hem-
\
OTB Oceanic tholeiitic basalts
OAB Oceanic alkati basalts
OAB CTB Continental tholeiitic basalts
CAB Continental alkali basalts
OTB
i 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 r
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Y/Nb
Figure 10. Variation between TiC>2 and Y/Nb in chemically analyzed samples of mafic igneous rocks
from the southern Heritage Range. Fields of various basalt types from Floyd and Winchester (1975).
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
10 —
1. W i t h i n - p l a t e b a s a l t s
2. Mid-ocean ridge basalts
3 . Island arc b a s a l t s
5 —
>-
N
i r
10 50 100 500
ppm Zr
Figure 12. Zr/Y-Zr discrimination diagram from chemically analyzed samples of mafic igneous rocks
from the southern Heritage Range. Fields of various basalt types from Pearce and Norry (1979).
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
are similar to some of the Kirkpatrick Basalt (Kyle, 1980). well as "average" Kirwan Volcanics (Faure and others, 1979),
Chilled margins of sills from the Pecora Escarpment in the Pen- are given in Table 5 for comparison purposes. The basalts from
sacola Mountains are intermediate in composition between Queen Maud Land have noticeably lower Si02, K2O, Rb, and
Gunn's (1966) hypersthene and pigeonite tholeiite, and average Rb/Sr and higher Ti0 2 , MgO, CaO, Sr, and K/Rb than Kirk-
composition of mafic dikes from the Cordiner Peaks (also in patrick Basalt.
the Pensacola Mountains) corresponds closely to hypersthene Metamorphism of the Ellsworth Mountains basaltic rocks
tholeiite (Ford and Kistler, 1980). Analyses of these rock types, as hinders comparison of their chemistry with nonmetamorphosed
Ferrar Supergroup and Kirwan Volcanics. It should be pointed
out, though, that some Kirkpatrick Basalt has been zeolitized and
thus has also probably undergone some geochemical mobility
(Elliot, 1970, 1972; Kyle, 1980). Consequently, only chilled
margins of Heritage Range sills (analyses 7f, S10, SI4, 14g, and
141 in Table 1A) are used for comparison, as these rocks should
be the least differentiated and should thus more closely approxi-
mate original magma composition. These five analyses are also
listed in Table 5 but are not averaged because there are significant
chemical differences between margins of the Hyde Glacier and
Wilson Nunataks sills. Compared to basaltic rocks of the Ferrar
Supergroup, the Ellsworth Mountains sills have much lower SiC>2
(43.96 to 46.55 percent versus 50.40 to 56.60 percent), Cu, and
Rb/Sr ratios and higher total iron oxides, Sr, and K/Rb ratios.
Figure 13. Ternary plot of normative quartz (Qz), orthoclase (A), and The Hyde Glacier sill also has a much higher MgO content than
albite plus anorthite (P) from chemically analyzed samples of felsic and
intermediate (>56 percent SiC^) igneous rocks from the southern Heri- all Ferrar Supergroup rocks except the rare olivine tholeiite
tage Range. Classification is from Streckeisen (1979). magma types. Na20 is also generally higher in the Ellsworth
Mountains rocks than in the Ferrar Supergroup, although this
element's distribution is prone to mobility. There are thus signifi-
500 n cant chemical differences between the Ellsworth Mountains
mafic rocks and those of the Ferrar Supergroup. The same con-
clusion was reached earlier by Hjelle and others (1978, 1982).
THOLEIITIC
100 -
E
a
a O O
E
3
C A LC-ALKALINE
co
c
>co
CALC-ALKALINE and THOLEIITIC
10
1000 100 10
Chromium (ppm)
Figure 14. Plot of vanadium versus chromium for chemically analyzed samples of felsic and interme-
diate (>56 percent Si0 2 ) igneous rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Classification is from
Miyashiro and Shido (1975).
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
1 1
1 » 1 1
87Sr/86Sr
SOHOLT PERKS ^-
0.730
.—•
s*
•
0.720-
0.710
AGE 3G9 + 18 Ma (2-sigma)
Intercept 0.7148 + 0.0003
MSWD 7.3 Enhanced Errors
87Rb/86Sr
Zr/TiO_
2 1 1 1 , 1
Figure 15. Si02-Zr/Ti02 discrimination diagram for chemically ana- 1.0 2.0 3.0
lyzed samples of felsic and intermediate (>56 percent Si02> igneous Figure 16. Rubidium-strontium whole-rock isochron diagram for the
rocks from the southern Heritage Range. Symbols used are A, rhyolite; Soholt Peaks dacite stock.
B, dacite and rhyodacite; C, comendite and pantellerite; D, trachyte;
E, andesite; F, trachyandesite; G, phonolite. Fields of various rock types
from Winchester and Floyd (1977).
When compared to average Kirwan basalt (Faure and oth- intrude Cambrian-Ordovician sandstone in the Shackleton Range
ers, 1979) the Ellsworth Mountains rocks are lower in Si(>2, (northeast of the Pensacola Mountains) yield K-Ar dates between
Ti02, and CaO but higher in AI2O3 and Na20. The Hyde 297 and 457 Ma (Clarkson, 1981) but do not appear to be close
Glacier sill has a much higher MgO and K2O content, and the chemical equivalents of the Ellsworth Mountains mafic rocks.
Wilson Nunataks sill has a much higher total iron oxide content. Porphyritic metafelsic rocks also crop out in the Queen Maud
There is, however, considerable overlap in the values of Rb, Sr, Range of the central Transantarctic Mountains. These include the
K/Rb, and Rb/Sr. Thus these two groups of rocks do not seem late Precambrian Wyatt Formation, which contains both extru-
to be chemical equivalents either, but the disparity is less and it sive and hypabyssal rocks as well as porphyritic metarhyolites
should be pointed out that only a few samples are being com- and minor metabasalts that occur in the lower part of the Cam-
pared. The transitional to mildly tholeiitic original chemistry of brian Taylor Formation along the Shackleton Glacier (Stump,
the Ellsworth Mountains mafic rocks predicted earlier by the use 1982).
of alteration resistant trace elements is not a feature of either the
Ferrar Supergroup or the Kirwan Volcanics. Felsic and inter- TECTONIC SETTING
mediate rocks are relatively rare in both Ferrar Supergroup and
Kirwan volcanic terranes but have been reported locally Earlier in this paper, discrimination diagrams utilizing im-
(Marshak and others, 1981). mobile trace elements were employed in an attempt to determine
as much as possible about the original chemistry and tectonic
CORRELATION setting of the metamorphosed igneous rocks of the southern Her-
itage Range. We concluded on their basis and on the basis of field
Only a few tentative correlations can be attempted between setting (an associated thick sequence of carbonate and clastic
igneous rocks of the Ellsworth and Transantarctic mountains, the sedimentary rocks) and scarcity of andesite that the mafic rocks
closest possible comparisons being in the Pensacola Mountains. were continental in setting and largely tholeiitic in composition
Schmidt and others (1978) and Schmidt and Ford (1969) have but that they also displayed some calc-alkaline tendencies even
mapped an extensive suite of basaltic and diabasic sills and dikes when plotted on diagrams (FeO* versus FeO*/MgO) designed to
and subordinate plugs and sills of felsic porphyry of uncertain, but totally negate the effect of alkali mobility. The Ti02-Y/Nb dia-
probable, late Precambrian age that are intrusive into the late gram, however, suggests that some of the mafic rocks are transi-
Precambrian Patuxent Formation in the Neptune Range of the tional in composition between tholeiitic and alkali basalt.
Pensacola Mountains. Unpublished chemical analyses of these Intermediate to felsic igneous rocks are much less abundant than
mafic rocks are similar to those from the southern Heritage Range mafic igneous rocks in the southern Heritage Range, and the
(A. B. Ford, personal communication, 1982). Dolerite dikes that intermediate rocks are far less abundant than the felsic ones. The
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
Diabase-upper part
Hyde Glacier Sill* 1.39 88.6 0.569 0.415 220.0 ± 9.4
Diabase-central part
Hyde Glacier Sill (S16)* 0.84 52.2 0.246 0.251 161.6 +11.2
Diabase-lower part
Hyde Glacier Sill* 1.24 88.7 0.565 0.370 245.2 ±11.2
Diabase-
Hyde Glacier Sillt 0.43 86.3 0.740§ 396 ± 20
Diabase-
Wilson Nunataks Sillt 0.785 90.8 1,295§ 381 ±19
Andesite Dike-
Edson Hülst 4.88 97.6 4.805§ 237 ±12
Basaltic Dike-
Edson Hillst 2.35 96.4 2.495§ 254 ±13
Note: 'Samples analyzed by I. Pilot, G. Kaiser, and V. Klemm, German Democratic Republic.
Constants: Xß = 4.72 X 10" 10 a" 1 , ^ = 0.584 X 10" 10 a" 1 .
tSamples from Yoshida (1982), analyzed by Teledyne Isotopes Co., New Jersey.
Constants: Xß = 4.962 X 10" 10 a" 1 , = 0.581 X 10- 1 0 a" 1 , K 4 0 = 1.167 X 10' 4 atom/atom of natural
potassium.
§ s c c A r 4 0 R a d / g X 10"5.
Sample Rb Sr 87 R b/86 Sr 87 S r / 86 S r
Number (ppm) (ppm)
TABLE 5. COMPOSITION OF FERRAR SUPERGROUP AND KIRWAN VOLCAN ICS COMPARED TO ELLSWORTH
MOUNTAINS SILL MARGINS
A B C D E F G H I J
Si02 50.40 53.75 55.65 53.3 54.6 56.50 48.07 55.86 46.34 44.45
Ti0 2 0.44 0.70 1.03 0.65 0.75 1.28 2.06 1.35 2.44 1.13
AI 2 O 3 15.51 14.33 13.95 15.5 14.5 12.92 13.03 13.55 13.99 15.87
Fe203 1.5 1.8 3.2 3.64 2.89 2.63
FeO 8.72* 9.65* 10.30* 8.0 8.2 8.5 9.33 11.51* 12.21 8.94
MnO 0.17 0.18 0.17 0.13 0.18 0.22 0.19 0.18 0.21 0.17
MgO 10.60 6.64 4.50 6.6 5.6 3.44 8.59 3.50 6.12 10.33
CaO 10.87 10.60 8.51 10.3 9.5 7.91 9.70 8.12 8.08 7.35
Na 2 0 1.42 1.83 2.50 1.9 1.8 2.29 2.44 2.24 3.55 2.64
K2O 0.37 0.81 1.45 0.72 0.82 1.29 0.51 1.43 0.56 1.38
P2O5 0.08 0.18 0.23 0.15 0.12 0.16 0.22 0.15 0.33 0.09
Note: A = chilled margin olivine tholeiite sill, Gunn (1966); B = average 5 analyses chilled margins hypersthene tholeiite sills,
Gunn (1966); C = average 4 analyses chilled margins pigeonite tholeiite sills, Gunn (1966); D = average 12 analyses Cordiner
Peaks dikes, Ford and Kistler (1980); E = average 5 analyses chilled margins Pecora Escarpment sills, Ford and Kistler (1980);
F = average 12 analyses Kirkpatrick Basalt, Storm Peak, Faure and others (1974); G = average 17 analyses Kirwan Volcanics,
Faure and others (1979); H = average 14 analyses Kirkpatrick Basalt, Mt. Falla, Faure and others (1982); I = average 3 analyses
chilled margins Wilson Nunataks sill; J = average 2 analyses chilled margins Hyde Glacier sill.
*Total iron as FeO.
igneous rocks thus constitute a bimodal suite characterized by alkaline, and alkaline volcanism can occur simultaneously in dif-
large amounts of mafic rocks and very few of intermediate com- ferent parts of the same terrane.
position. Discrimination diagrams, although not as extensively Basaltic or strongly bimodal basaltic-rhyolitic suites with
developed for use with more siliceous rocks, and content of in- scarce andesite are characteristic of continental areas subjected to
compatible trace elements suggest that the felsic and intermediate plate separation and extension. In direct contrast, igneous rock
rocks also show both tholeiitic and calc-alkaline tendencies along suites developed along converging plate boundaries usually are
with some alkaline traits. unimodal and display a wide range of compositions often domi-
It is well known that igneous rock suites, especially volcanic nated by andesite (Christiansen and Lipman, 1972; Lipman and
ones, often grade from tholeiitic through calc-alkaline to sho- others, 1972; Miyashiro, 1974). Bimodal convergent suites have
shonitic through time and/or space across island arc-continental been noted (individual Cascade volcanoes and individual islands
margin situations (Jakes and White, 1972). This is not the case of the Lesser Antilles), but in these cases, andesite is an abundant
here, however. Igneous rocks in the southern Heritage Range are rock type (McBirney, 1968; Brown and others, 1977). We there-
interlayered with, or intrusive into, the same portion of the sedi- fore conclude that the igneous rocks of the southern Heritage
mentary section and are thus regarded as being contemporaneous Range were emplaced in a continental area undergoing exten-
in time and space. If the conclusions based on the discrimination sional tectonism and do not represent an island arc-continental
diagrams are valid, then the igneous rock association discussed in margin subduction zone complex.
this paper is somewhat unusual. Similar sequences have, how-
ever, been reported from the Yellowknife volcanic belt in ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Canada's Northwest Territories (Irvine and Barager, 1971) and
from southeastern Maine (Gates and Moench, 1981). In addition, This project was funded by National Science Foundation
Arculus and Johnson (1978) have shown that tholeiitic, calc- grant DPP78-21720 to Gerald Webers of Macalester College.
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
Logistical support was provided by the Antarctic Research Pro- State College Press, p. 301-325.
gram of the National Science Foundation and U.S. Navy squad- , 1972, Major oxide chemistry of the Kirkpatrick Basalt, central Transant-
ron VXE-6. We thank Philip Fenn of the University of Califor- arctic Mountains, in Adie, R. J., ed., Antarctic geology and geophysics: Oslo,
Universitetsforlaget, p. 413-418.
nia, Davis, for his help with the chemical analyses and Ronald Faure, G., Hill, R. L., Jones, L. M., and Elliot, D. H., 1972, Isotope composition
Leu of Sonoma State University for preparing the thin sections. of strontium and silica content of Mesozoic basalt and dolerite from Antarc-
Discussions in the field with Bernard Sporli and over many tica, in Adie, R. J., ed., Antarctic geology and geophysics: Oslo, Universitets-
glasses of beer with Arthur Ford were especially helpful. All forlaget, p. 617-624.
figures were drafted by Marc Druckman of Sonoma State Uni- Faure, G., Bowman, J. R., Elliot, D. H., and Jones, L. M., 1974, Strontium
isotope composition and pedogenesis of the Kirkpatrick Basalt, Queen Alex-
versity. A previous version of this manuscript benefited from
andra Range, Antarctica: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, v. 48,
reviews by Paul Weiblen of the University of Minnesota and p. 153-169.
Glen Himmelberg of the University of Missouri. Faure, G., Bowman, J. R., and Elliot, D. H., 1979, The isotopic composition of
strontium of the Kirwan Volcanics, Queen Maud Land, Antarctica: Chemi-
cal Geology, v. 26, p. 77-90.
Faure, G., Pace, K. K., and Elliot, D. H., 1982, Systematic variations of 87Sr/86Sr
REFERENCES CITED
ratios and major element concentrations in the Kirkpatrick Basalt of Mount
Arculus, R. J., and Johnson, R. W., 1978, Criticism of generalized models for the Falla, Queen Alexandra Range, Transantarctic Mountains, in Craddock, C.,
magmatic evolution of arc-trench systems: Earth and Planetary Science Let- ed., Antarctic geoscience: Madison, University of Wisconsin Press,
ters, v. 39, p. 118-126. p. 715-723.
Bass, M. N., Moberly, R., Rhodes, J. M., Shih, C., and Church, S. E., 1973, Floyd, P. A., and Winchester, J. A., 1975, Magma type and tectonic setting
Volcanic rocks cored in the central Pacific, leg 17, deep sea drilling project, discrimination using immobile elements: Earth and Planetary Science Let-
in Winterer, E. S., and Ewing, J. L., eds., Initial reports of the Deep Sea ters, v. 27, p. 211-218.
Drilling Project: Washington, D.C., U.S. Goverment Printing Office, v. 17, , 1978, Identification and discrimination of altered and metamorphosed
p. 429-503. volcanic rocks using immobile elements: Chemical Geology, v. 21,
Bauer, R. L., 1983, Low-grade metamorphism in the Heritage Range of the p. 291-306.
Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctica, in Oliver, R. L., James, P. R., and Ford, A. B., 1972, Weddell orogeny; Latest Permian to early Mesozoic deforma-
Jago, J. B., eds., Antarctic earth science: Canberra, Australian Academy of tion at the Weddell Sea margin of the Transantarctic Mountains, in Adie,
Science, p. 256-260. R. J., ed., Antarctic geology and geophysics: Oslo, Universitetsforlaget,
Brooks, C. K., 1976, The Fe 2 03/Fe0 ratio of basalt analyses; An appeal for a p. 419-425.
standardized procedure: Geological Society of Denmark Bulletin, v. 25, Ford, A. B., and Kistler, R. W., 1980, K-Ar age, composition, and origin of
p. 117-120. Mesozoic mafic rocks related to Ferrar Group, Pensacola Mountains, Antarc-
Brooks, E. R., and Cole, D. G., 1980, Use of immobile trace elements to deter- tica: New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, v. 23, p. 371-390.
mine original tectonic setting of eruption of metabasalts, northern Sierra Gates, O., and Moench, R. H., 1981, Bimodal Silurian and Lower Devonian
Nevada, California: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 91, pt. 1, volcanic rock assemblages in the Machias-Eastport area, Maine: U.S. Geo-
p. 665-671. logical Survey Professional Paper 1184, 32 p.
Brown, G. M., Holland, J. G., Sigurdsson, H., Tomblin, J. F., and Arculus, R. J., Gizycki, P., 1983, Die magmatischen gesteine der Ellsworth Mountains, West-
1977, Geochemistry of the Lesser Antilles volcanic island arc: Geochimica et Antarktis: Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie, Abhandlungen,
Cosmochimica Acta, v. 41, p. 758-801. Band 167, Heft 1, p. 65-88.
Cann, J. R., 1970, Rb, Sr, Y, Zr, and Nb in some ocean floor basaltic rocks: Earth Gunn, B. M., 1966, Modal and element variation in Antarctic tholeiites: Geo-
and Planetary Science Letters, v. 10, p. 7-11. chimica et Cosmochimica Acta, v. 30, p. 881-920.
Christiansen, R. L., and Lipman, P. W., 1972, Cenozoic volcanism and plate Heier, K. S., Compston, W., and McDougall, I., 1965, Thorium and uranium
tectonic evolution of the western United States; 2, late Cenozoic: Philosophi- concentrations and the isotopic composition of strontium in the differentiat-
cal Transactions of the Royal Society of London, ser. A, v. 271, no. 1213, ed Tasmanian dolerites: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, v. 29,
p. 249-284. p. 643-659.
Clarkson, P. D., 1981, Geology of the Shackleton Range; 4, The dolerite dikes: Hjelle, A., Ohta, Y., and Winsnes, T. S., 1978, Stratigraphy and igneous petrology
British Antarctic Survey Bulletin 53, p. 201-212. of southern Heritage Range, Ellsworth Mountains, Antarctica: Norsk Polar-
Compston, W., McDougall, I., and Heier, K. S., 1968, Geochemical comparison institutt Skrifter, v. 169, p. 5-43.
of the Mesozoic basaltic rocks of Antarctica, South Africa, South America, , 1982, Geology and petrology of the southern Heritage Range, Ellsworth
and Tasmania: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, v. 32, p. 129-150. Mountains, in Craddock, C., ed., Antarctic geoscience: Madison, University
Craddock, C., 1969, Geology of the Ellsworth Mountains, in Bushnell, V. C., and of Wisconsin Press, p. 599-608.
Craddock, C., eds., Geologic maps of Antarctica: New York, America Geo- Holm, P. E., 1982, Non-recognition of continental tholeiite using the Ti-Y-Zr
graphical Society, Antarctic Map Folio Series, Folio 12, Plate 4, scale diagram: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, v. 79, p. 308-310.
1:1,000,000. Irvine, T. N., and Barager, W.R.A., 1971, A guide to the chemical classification of
, 1972, Antarctic tectonics, in Adie, R. J., ed., Antarctic geology and geo- the common volcanic rocks: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 8,
physics: Oslo, Universitetsforlaget, p. 449-455. p. 523-548.
, 1983, The East Antarctica-West Antarctica boundary between the ice Jakes, P., and Gill, J. B., 1970, Rare earth elements and the island arc tholeiite
shelves; A review, in Oliver, R. L., James, P. R., and Jago, R. B., eds., series: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 9, p. 17-28.
Antarctic earth science: Canberra, Australian Academy of Science, p. 94-97. Jakes, P., and White, A.J.R., 1972, Major and trace element abundances in
Craddock, C., Anderson, J. J., and Webers, G. F., 1964, Geological outline of the volcanic rocks of orogenic areas: Geological Society of America Bulletin,
Ellsworth Mountains, in Adie, R. J., ed., Antarctic geology: Amsterdam, v. 83, p. 29-40.
North-Holland, p. 155-170. Kochhar, N., 1977, Post-emplacement modifications in rapidly cooled acid vol-
Elliot, D. H., 1970, Jurassic tholeiites of the central Transantarctic Mountains, canic rocks; American Mineralogist, v. 62, p. 333-335.
Antarctica, in Gilmour, E. H., and Stradling, D., eds., Proceedings of the Kyle, P. R., 1980, Development of heterogeneities in the subcontinental mantle;
second Columbia River Basalt Symposium: Cheney, Eastern Washington Evidence from the Ferrar Group, Antarctica: Contributions to Mineralogy
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
and Petrology, v. 73, p. 89-104. Nb variations in volcanic rocks: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology,
Kyle, P. R., Elliot, D. H., and Sutter, J. F., 1981, Jurassic Ferrar Supergroup v. 69, p. 33-47.
tholeiites from the Transantarctic Mountains, Antarctica, and their relation- Pearce, T. H., Gorman, B. E., and Birkett, T. C., 1975, The Ti0 2 -K 2 0-P 2 05
ship to the initial fragmentation of Gondwana, in Cresswell, M. M., and diagram; A method of discriminating between oceanic and non-oceanic
Vella, P., eds., Gondwana Five: Rotterdam, A. A. Balkema, p. 283-287. basalts: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 24, p. 419-426.
Kyle, P. R., Pankhurst, R. J., and Bowman, J. R., 1983, Isotopic and chemical Prestvik, T., 1982, Basic volcanic rocks and tectonic setting; A discussion of the
variations in Kirkpatrick Basalt Group rocksfromsouthern Victoria Land, in Zr-Ti-Y discrimination diagram and its suitability for classification purposes:
Oliver, R. L., James, P. R., and Jago, J. B., eds., Antarctic earth science: Lithos, v. 15, p. 241-247.
Canberra, Australian Academy of Science, p. 234-237. Saunders, A. J., Tarney, J., Stern, C. R., and Dalziel, I.W.D., 1979, Geochemistry
Leake, B. E., 1978, Nomenclature of amphiboles: American Mineralogist, v. 63, of Mesozoic marginal basin floor igneous rocks from southern Chile: Geolog-
p. 1023-1053. ical Society of America Bulletin, v. 90, pt. 1, p. 237-258.
Lipman, P. W., Christiansen, R. L., and Van Alstine, R. E., 1969, Retention of Schmidt, D. L., and Ford, A. B., 1969, Geology of the Pensacola and Thiel
alkalies by calc-alkalic rhyolites during crystallization and hydration: Ameri- Mountains, in Bushnell, V. C., and Craddock, C., eds., Geologic maps of
can Mineralogist, v. 54, p. 286-291. Antarctica: New York, American Geographical Society, Antarctic Map
Lipman, P. W., Prostka, H. J., and Christiansen, R. L., 1972, Cenozoic volcanism Folio Series, Folio 12, Plate 5, scale 1:1,000,000.
and plate tectonic evolution of the western United States; 1, Early and Schmidt, D. L., Williams, P. L., and Nelson, W. H., 1978, Geologic map of the
middle Cenozoic: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of Lon- Schmidt Hills Quadrangle and part of the Gambacorta Peak Quadrangle,
don, ser. A, v. 271, no. 1213, p. 217-248. Pensacola Mountains, Antarctica: U.S. Geological Survey Antarctic Geo-
Lofgren, G. E., 1971, Experimentally produced devitrification textures in natural logic Map A-8, scale 1:250,000.
rhyolitic glass: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 82, p. 111-124. Splettstoesser, J. F., and Webere, G. F., 1989, Geological investigations and
Macdonald, G. A., and Katsura, T., 1964, Chemical composition of Hawaiian logistics in the Ellsworth Mountains, 1979-80: Antarctic Journal of the
lavas: Journal of Petrology, v. 5, p. 82-133. United States, v. 15, no. 5, p. 36-39.
Marshak, S., Kyle, P. R„ Mcintosh, W. C., Samsonov, V. V., and Shellhorn, M., Streckeisen, A. L., 1979, Classification and nomenclature of volcanic rocks, 1am-
1981, Butcher Ridge igneous complex, Cook Mountains, Antarctica: Antarc- prophyres, carbonatites, and melilitic rocks; Recommendations and sugges-
tic Journal of the United States, v. 16, p. 54-55. tions of the IUGS subcommission on the systematics of igneous rocks:
McBirney, A. R., 1968, Petrochemistry of the Cascade andesite volcanoes, in Geology, v. 7, p. 331-335.
Dole, H. M., ed., Andesite Conference Guidebook: Oregon Department of Stump, E., 1982, The Ross supergroup in the Queen Maud Mountains, in Crad-
Geology and Mineral Industries Bulletin 62, p. 101-107. dock, C., ed., Antarctic geoscience: Madison, University of Wisconsin Press,
Miyashiro, A., 1974, Volcanic rock series in island arcs and active continental p. 565-569.
margins: American Journal of Science, v. 274, p. 321-355. Webers, G. F., 1972, Unusual upper Cambrian fauna from West Antarctica, in
Miyashiro, A., and Shido, F., 1975, Tholeiitic and calc-alkalic series in relation to Adie, R. J., ed., Antarctic geology and geophysics: Oslo, Universitetsforlaget,
the behavior of titanium, vanadium, chromium, and nickel: American Jour- p. 235-237.
nal of Science, v. 275, p. 265-277. Webers, G. F., and Sporli, K. B., 1983, Palaeontological and stratigraphic investi-
Noble, D. C„ 1968, Systematic variation of major elements in comendite and gations in the Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctica, in Oliver, R. L.,
pantelleritic glasses: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 4, p. 167-172. James, P. R., and Jago, J. B., eds., Antarctic earth science: Canberra, Aus-
Nockolds, S. R., Knox, R. W., and Chinner, G. A., 1978, Petrology for students: tralian Academy of Science, p. 261-264.
New York, Cambridge University Press, 435 p. Williams, H., Turner, F. J., and Gilbert, C. M„ 1982, Petrography, 2nd ed.: San
Pankhurst, R. J., and O'Nions, R. K., 1973, Determination of Rb/Sr and Francisco, California, W. H. Freeman, 626 p.
87
Sr/86Sr ratios of some standard rocks and evaluation of x-ray fluores- Winchester, J. A., and Floyd, P. A., 1977, Geochemical discrimination of differ-
cence spectrometry in Rb-Sr geochemistry: Chemical Geology, v. 12, ent magma series and their differentiation products using immobile elements:
p. 127-136. Chemical Geology, v. 20, p. 325-343.
Pearce, J. A., 1975, Basalt geochemistry used to investigate past tectonic environ- Yoder, H. S., Jr., and Tilley, C. E., 1962, Origin of basalt magmas; An experimen-
ments on Cyprus: Tectonophysics, v. 25, p. 41-67. tal study of natural and synthetic rock systems: Journal of Petrology, v. 3,
Pearce, J. A., and Cann, J. R., 1971, Ophiolite origin investigated by discriminant p. 342-532.
analysis using Ti, Zr, and Y: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 12, Yoshida, M., 1982, Superposed deformation and its implication to the geologic
p. 339-349. history of the Ellsworth Mountains, West Antarctica: Tokyo, Memoirs of
, 1973, Tectonic setting of basic volcanic rocks determined using trace National Institute of Polar Research Special Issue 21, p. 120-171.
element analysis: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 19, p. 290-300.
Pearce, J. A., and Norry, M. J., 1979, Petrogenetic implications of Ti, Zr, Y, and MANUSCRIPT ACCEPTED BY THE SOCIETY M A R C H 1,1989
Printed in U.S.A.
Downloaded from memoirs.gsapubs.org on June 18, 2015
Email alerting services click www.gsapubs.org/cgi/alerts to receive free e-mail alerts when new
articles cite this article
Subscribe click www.gsapubs.org/subscriptions to subscribe to Geological Society of
America Memoirs
Permission request click www.geosociety.org/pubs/copyrt.htm#gsa to contact GSA.
Copyright not claimed on content prepared wholly by U.S. government employees within scope of their
employment. Individual scientists are hereby granted permission, without fees or further requests to
GSA, to use a single figure, a single table, and/or a brief paragraph of text in subsequent works and to
make unlimited copies of items in GSA's journals for noncommercial use in classrooms to further
education and science. This file may not be posted to any Web site, but authors may post the abstracts
only of their articles on their own or their organization's Web site providing the posting includes a
reference to the article's full citation. GSA provides this and other forums for the presentation of diverse
opinions and positions by scientists worldwide, regardless of their race, citizenship, gender, religion, or
political viewpoint. Opinions presented in this publication do not reflect official positions of the Society.
Notes