Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E Paper 10 July 2024
E Paper 10 July 2024
: UPENG/2007/19688
PREVIOUS DATA
ucknow news
BSE SENSEX: 79,960.38
(-36.22 ; 0.045%)
NIFTY 50: 24,320.55
(-3.30 ; 0.014%)
NIFTY BANK: 52,425.80
(-234.55 ; 0.45%)
NIFTY IT: 37,742.25
(+21.50 ; 0.057%)
S&P BSE SmallCap: 54,035.44
(-118.52 ; 0.22%) VOL. 18 | ISSUE NO: 309 | Wednesday, 10 July 2024 | DAILY MORNING | Page 4 | Price Rs 1.00
Editorial: Amidst Tumult Delhi min reviews preparedness of govt hospitals to tackle dengue PM Modi arrives in Moscow, to hold talks with Prez Putin
MAHARASHTRA: Flanked
by his ministers, senior party
leaders and legislators, dep-
uty chief minister Ajit Pawar
on Tuesday visited the fa-
mous Siddhivinayak temple
in central Mumbai to seek
blessings of the deity ahead
of launching the National-
ist Congress Party’s (NCP’s)
campaign for the forthcom-
ing Maharashtra assembly ity of the party’s MLAs, deal- (BJP) started having second
elections. “We are going to ing a severe blow to Sharad thoughts about him. Func-
the people seeking the man- Pawar, and joined the Shiv tionaries of the Rashtriya
date. Before that, we came Sena-BJP government. The Syayamsevak Sangh (RSS),
to seek the blessings of Lord Election Commission of In- the BJP’s ideological parent,
Ganesh,” Pawar said after dia also handed the party blamed NCP for affecting
reaching the temple along name and election symbol the Hindu nationalist party’s
with his party colleagues in to Ajit Pawar’s faction. brand value. There has also
a bus. Brushing aside the However, the results of the been speculation that sever-
debacle in the Lok Sabha recent Lok Sabha elections al of Ajit Pawar’s MLAs are
elections, Pawar is gearing have put a question mark on sending feelers to return to
up to retain his ground in the future of his faction. Ajit the Sharad Pawar camp.
the state assembly, where Pawar’s NCP could win only In this background, Ajit
his NCP has 40 MLAs. For one out of four seats it con- Pawar had no option but to
this purpose, he has hired tested, while NCP (Sharad- fight back. He went into a
Naresh Arora, co-founder chandra Pawar) won eight huddle with his colleagues,
of DesignBoxed, a political constituencies. Ajit Pawar worked out a plan for bounc-
campaign management also lost the party’s bastion ing back and hired Arora.
company that handled the of Baramati to his uncle. “The brief given is to refur-
Congress’ campaign in the Although most of Ajit bish Ajit Pawar’s image and
Karnataka and Rajasthan Pawar’s MLAs come from work out a strategy to en-
assembly elections last year. the western and northern sure that the party retains its
A year ago, Pawar led a re- Maharashtra belt, the NCP ground,” said a senior NCP
bellion against his uncle and drew a blank there. Follow- leader. “We have 40 MLAs.
NCP founder Sharad Pawar. ing the Lok Sabha results, Our aim is to reach 40-50
He walked out with a major- ally Bharatiya Janata Party seats in the next assembly.”
2 Lucknow, Wednesday, 10 July 2024 Lucknow News (English Daily)
In the Overhaul
EDITORIAL
Amidst Tumult
In 2024, India witnessed a tumultuous episode surround-
ing the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test-Undergrad-
uate (NEETUG), underscoring the incompetence of the
National Testing Agency (NTA), rampant fraud, and the
devastating impact on students’ lives. This examination,
intended to streamline admissions to undergraduate
medical programmes across the country, instead became IN THE WAKE OF THE RISING RELEVANCE OF THE SHANGHAI COOPERATION ORGANISATION, INDIA SHOULD AVOID DISTANCING ITSELF
synonymous with allegations of misconduct, a criminal
nexus, and profound inequities. AWAY FROM THE GROUPING UNDER WESTERN INFLUENCE, AND RESPOND POSITIVELY TO THE INITIATIVES AIMED AT REVIVING TRADE
Incompetence of NTA The NTA, entrusted with conduct- Last month, the NEETUG
ing fair and transparent examinations, failed egregiously results sparked a contro-
in managing NEET-UG 2024. Numerous discrepancies versy involving allegations
emerged, ranging from impossible scores awarded to can- of question paper leak,
didates to suspicions of paper leaks. awarding of grace marks to
The agency’s responses were defensive and inadequate, more than 1,500 students,
dismissing serious allegations without credible investiga- and an unusual number
tion. This incompetence exacerbated distrust among stake- of toppers with the same
holders, especially students and parents who had placed score. While the aggrieved
their faith in the examination process. students approached the
Fraud and unfair means The NEET-UG 2024 was marred apex court challenging the
by widespread fraud and un- results, the CBI has taken
fair practices. Reports sur- Reintroducing state-level over the investigation.
faced of organised criminal JEEs would empower The government respond-
activities, including the sale state boards to tailor ed immediately, replacing
of examination papers for examinations that align the DG of NTA and consti-
exorbitant sums, up to Rs 50 with their curricula, tuting a seven-member
lakhs. fostering inclusivity and high-level committee to re-
The involvement of or- equal opportunity for all view the conduct of exams
ganised gangs and brokers aspirants; The NEET-UG by the NTA. The commit-
highlights the deep-rooted 2024 controversy exposed tee’s mandate, inter alia, is
corruption that infiltrated the NTA’s incompetence, to suggest ways to reform
examination system. rampant fraud, and the examination process,
Instances like the raids devastating impacts on strengthen the functioning
in Godhra and Patna un- students, highlighting the of the NTA, and improve
derscored how malpractice need for systemic reforms, data safety.
permeated various exam- transparency, and a return Allegations of ‘question
ination centres, facilitated by to state-level entrance paper leaks’ or the use of
complicit insiders and inad- exams unfair means are not new
equate oversight by authori- to our education and re-
ties. cruitment systems, but
Impact on students’ lives The fallout from the NEETUG what is worrisome is that
controversies has been catastrophic for students. Many the frequency of scams en-
who prepared diligently faced uncertainties and unfair re- gineered by mafias with im-
sults due to systemic failures. punity over the years seems Despite the merits NEET-UG has in its favour, it denies equality, equity, and inclusiveness—the main pillars of the education system
Lives that were meticulously planned around medical to have become the new ernment notified a new law, sive coaching, which puts The committee needs to tionally, UCAT is only part of
careers were thrown into disarray, as the credibility of their normal. the Public Examinations aspirants from low-income adopt a holistic approach to a well-rounded admission A holistic approach
hard-earned scores came under scrutiny. Besides causing untold (Prevention of Unfair Means) groups and rural areas at a the problem instead of look- policy designed to probe to admissions with a
The mental and emotional toll on these young aspirants suffering to young aspirants Act, 2024, which prescribes disadvantage. ing for piecemeal solutions. innate skills in an aspirant. comprehensive evaluation
cannot be overstated, with many facing anxiety, depres- of higher learning, these stringent punishments for According to a survey To this end, the committee The UCAT consortium also system that gives equal
sion, and a loss of faith in the education system. Criminal scams also challenge the offenders, including impris- (https://www.careers360. needs to widen its purview provides free study mate- importance to school
mafia nexus in NEET The involvement of criminal elements professional competence of onment for 3-10 years and com), over 80 per cent of to examine and assess the rials to the aspirants for performance, aptitude,
in manipulating NEET-UG exposes a disturbing reality. both central and state agen- a fine of Rs 1 crore. successful candidates re- very admission process to preparation. reasoning skills, and
The nexus between mafia networks, coaching centres, cies responsible for holding But do laws have the defi- ceive coaching. The present begin with. The International Medical behavioural attitudes will
and corrupt officials not only subverts meritocracy but various tests and exams. nite deterrent force to guar- system seems to indirectly As long as the ‘winlose’ Admission Test (IMAT) in It- offer a level playing field
also perpetuates a cycle of exploitation and injustice. This Unfortunately, despite elab- antee that future scams in patronise the multimillion single entrance test that fo- aly is also a test of aptitude. to all
collusion undermines the aspirations of deserving candi- orate arrangements and entrance tests or recruit- coaching industry in the cuses more on elimination It includes 20 questions on ments in school and ignores
dates while enriching a few at the expense of the many, reasonable precautions by ment exams will not occur? country. than selection continues to logical reasoning and gener- the natural mental abilities
tarnishing the sanctity of education and national examina- the agencies, the possibility We already have a plethora Thirdly, unlike in Europe be the decisive factor for ad- al knowledge, and 40 on the and critical thinking of the
tions. of unfair means or fraud in of existing laws, yet exam and the US, academic per- missions, it is well nigh im- candidate’s ability to apply aspirants.
Moving forward To restore faith in the medical entrance exams always looms large, mafias continue to jeop- formance up to class 12 is possible to prevent the use scientific knowledge from Even increasing the num-
examination system, fundamental reforms are imperative. especially where cutthroat ardise the sanctity of exams. of no consequence in our of unfair means and the re- school science. ber of seats or regulating
First and foremost, there must be a thorough overhaul of competition exists for lim- The larger question is admission process. Only the currence of scams in the ex- Most importantly, if two the coaching business can-
the NTA’s practices, including enhanced transparency, rig- ited seats in institutions of how to make the selection NEET ranking is decisive, ig- ams. The admission system candidates score equally, not protect the system from
orous monitoring of examination centres, and swift action higher education. process for admission to noring the possibility that a in most Western countries their respective scores in malpractices.
against malpractice. NEETUG is one such en- institutions of higher learn- consistently bright student focuses on selection rather Logical Reasoning and Gen- The system needs radi-
Public confidence can only be regained through proac- trance test, held for seats ing or for recruitments not may fail in the entrance test than elimination. eral Knowledge will serve as cal changes. A holistic ap-
tive measures that prioritise integrity and fairness. Rever- 20 times fewer than the only transparent and fair while an average student There is neither a roar- the tiebreaker. proach to admissions with
sal to state-level JEEs The shift from state-level Joint En- number of aspirants. While but also inclusive, as op- with the best coaching may ing coaching industry nor The Medical College Ad- a comprehensive evaluation
trance Examinations (JEE) to NEET centralised the process hundreds of thousands of posed to the narrative of succeed (we are not even mafias running paper leak mission Test (MCAT) in the system that gives equal im-
but disenfranchised many state board students. aspirants go through a gru- meritocracy propagated by discussing the manage- rackets. The University Clin- US, Australia, and Canada portance to school perfor-
Unlike their CBSE counterparts, state board students of- elling process of coaching, the urban-centric coaching ment quota). ical Aptitude Test (UCAT), is a medical ability test of- mance, aptitude, reasoning
ten lack access to expensive coaching and resources tai- spending their parents’ industry, which is one of the No wonder criminal ma- followed by a consortium fered by the Association of skills, and behavioural atti-
lored to NEET’s format. Reverting to state-level JEEs would hardearned money, and chief reasons for the crimi- fias find it profitable to of universities in the United American Medical Colleges tudes will offer a level play-
cater to regional diversity in education and alleviate the even as the number of sui- nal sabotage of the system corrupt the system and en- Kingdom, Singapore, Aus- (AAMCs), with a 50 per cent ing field to all.
financial burden on students from nonCBSE backgrounds. cide deaths increases over by mafias. snare young aspirants with tralia, and New Zealand for chance of success com- In other words, entrance
Fairness to state board students NEET’s bias towards the years, paper leak scams Despite the merits promises of shortcuts to medical and dental degree pared to the 5-7 per cent for tests should only be a part
CBSE curriculum and coachingcentric preparation disad- further add to the miseries NEETUG has in its favour, it success. “The first priority programmes, is only a test NEET. (of qualifying nature), and
vantages state board students. of not only the young stu- denies equality, equity, and for us is to elicit from the of aptitude and attitude, not Admission criteria should not the whole and soul of
The emphasis on a standardised syllabus and format dents but their families as inclusiveness—the main students and parents in of academic performance, be more like a marathon the admission process, sim-
overlooks the diverse educational backgrounds across In- well. pillars of the education sys- the country their concerns which the candidate already rather than a hundred-me- ilar to the CSAT in the Civil
dia. The current NEET-UG cri- tem. and suggestions,” Dr. Rad- acquires in the A-Level ter sprint, allowing aspirants Services exam by UPSC.
Reintroducing state-level JEEs would empower state sis may pass soon as the Firstly, the entrance test hakrishnan, the head of the (school leaving qualification from diverse backgrounds Such an overarching and
boards to tailor examinations that align with their curric- government initiates action is largely biased in favour of high-level committee con- in the entire UK). enough space to prove their all-embracing admission
ula, fostering inclusivity and equal opportunity for all aspi- at the necessary levels. But CBSE schools, whereas the stituted by the government UCAT assesses be- mettle. policy will leave no room for
rants. In conclusion, the NEETUG 2024 controversy expos- can we rest assured that vast majority of aspirants in this matter, is reported to havioural attributes and Selection solely based on unfair practices. A review of
es deep-seated flaws in India’s approach to conducting exam scams will not recur in hail from State Boards. have said. This is a practical mental abilities such as one grand but nightmarish the admission system by
national examinations. the future? Secondly, the rigors of the approach to understanding critical thinking, logical rea- entrance test disregards the high-level committee
The NTA’s incompetence, coupled with fraud and a crim- A few days ago, the gov- exams necessitate expen- the problems firsthand. soning, and inference. Addi- years of academic achieve- may help improve matters.
Delhi min reviews by 1M1B (One Million for One Billion)—promotes green
skills among the youth through 5,000 internship oppor-
preparedness of govt
tunities across colleges in India. According to Linke-
dIn’s Global Green Skills Report 2023, job seekers with
Rahul urge PM to visit violence-hit Manipur, ists initiated the assault with
a grenade followed by gun-
the Jammu region. Director
General of Police R R Swain
agencies have been on high
alert following a recent am-
three from AJSU. Celebrat-
ing the trust vote victory,