Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Instant download The Identification of The City on The Legibility and Wayfinding Concepts A Case of Trabzon 2nd Edition Dr. Aysel Yavuz pdf all chapter
Instant download The Identification of The City on The Legibility and Wayfinding Concepts A Case of Trabzon 2nd Edition Dr. Aysel Yavuz pdf all chapter
OR CLICK LINK
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-
identification-of-the-city-on-the-legibility-and-
wayfinding-concepts-a-case-of-trabzon-2nd-edition-
dr-aysel-yavuz/
Read with Our Free App Audiobook Free Format PFD EBook, Ebooks dowload PDF
with Andible trial, Real book, online, KINDLE , Download[PDF] and Read and Read
Read book Format PDF Ebook, Dowload online, Read book Format PDF Ebook,
[PDF] and Real ONLINE Dowload [PDF] and Real ONLINE
More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant
download maybe you interests ...
https://textbookfull.com/product/socio-psychological-effects-of-
urban-green-areas-case-of-kirklareli-city-center-1st-edition-dr-
ezgi-tok/
https://textbookfull.com/product/belfast-the-story-of-a-city-and-
its-people-2nd-edition-feargal-cochrane/
https://textbookfull.com/product/alternative-concepts-of-god-
essays-on-the-metaphysics-of-the-divine-first-edition-andrei-a-
buckareff/
https://textbookfull.com/product/empowering-the-urban-poor-
through-participatory-planning-process-a-case-from-jhenaidah-
bangladesh-2nd-edition-dr-mahmuda-alam/
The Phenomenon of Mobility a Development Challenge for
the City Of Algiers 2nd Edition Ph.D. Candidate Ouafa
Louafi
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-phenomenon-of-mobility-a-
development-challenge-for-the-city-of-algiers-2nd-edition-ph-d-
candidate-ouafa-louafi/
https://textbookfull.com/product/encountering-development-in-the-
age-of-global-capitalism-a-case-study-1st-edition-dr-kin-ling-
tang-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/artistic-enclaves-in-the-post-
industrial-city-a-case-study-of-lawrenceville-pittsburgh-1st-
edition-geoffrey-moss-auth/
Journal of Contemporary Urban Affairs
2020, Volume 4, Number 2, pages 1– 12
A R T I C L E I N F O: ABSTRACT
Article history: The concept of wayfinding includes understanding the space and finding direction
Received 20 June 2019 within the space. But as cities and architectural spaces grow and become more
Accepted 23 July 2019
Available online 1 September complex, visitors and locals of the sapce can find it difficult to find direction. For
2019 these reasons, for visitors who speak different languages, along with these
elements, there is a need for well-designed information and direction-finding
Keywords: graphics and landmarks that have a universal quality.
Legibility; The aim of the study is to explain the concepts of wayfinding and way-finding,
Direction Designs; defined as “direction-finding” in the literature and to create awareness.
Circulation; Furthermore, to analyze the concept of wayfinding and the direction designs that
Urban Design;
aim to transform the cities that have become complex into more understandable
Trabzon.
spaces, through the city of Trabzon and to examine the problems of the city in this
context and to make suggestions.
This work is licensed under a In this study, Trabzon will be evaluated with the concepts of legibility and
Creative Commons Attribution - directability and the direction and information designs over the focal point,
NonCommercial - NoDerivs 4.0.
"CC-BY-NC-ND" regions, edges, nodes, roads with which Kevin Lynch have defined the imageable,
readable city. A survey was conducted to investigate the spatial information
elements and legibility of Trabzon city. Furthermore, to create awareness for other
This article is published with Open cities with similar problems.
Access at www.ijcua.com
www.ijcua.com
Copyright © 2019 Journal of Contemporary Urban Affairs. All rights reserved.
he states that a city is perceived and encoded to
1. INTRODUCTION our minds with “roads, monuments, regions,
1.1. Identification of The City, Legibility and borders and signs”.
Direction Finding According to Lynch (1960); “Structuring and
When the growth and resemblance of the cities to defining the environment is a very important skill for
each other by becoming ordinary started to be a all living creatures.
problem, the first studies on direction finding and
legibility of the city were brought forward by Kevin *Corresponding Author:
Lynch in 1960s. In his book City Image, Lynch Department of Landscape Architecture, Faculty of Forestry,
analyses direction finding in the city by associating Karadeniz Technical University, Trabzon, Turkey
Email address: ayavuz75@hotmail.com
it with the legibility of the city and urban images;
How to Cite this Article:
Yavuz, A., Ataoğlu, N.C. and Acar, H. (2020). The Identification of The City on The Legibility and Wayfinding Concepts: A Case of
Trabzon. Journal of Contemporary Urban Affairs, 4(2), 1-12. https://doi.org/10.25034/ijcua.2020.v4n2-1
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
To do this, a variety of clues are used: smell, sound, elements, it becomes easier to move to the target
touch, gravity, and even magnetic fields and and direction finding in that environment [Sönmez
stimulants, as well as visual sensations such as & Önder, 2015, cited from Passini (1984 & 1996)].
colour, shape, motion, and light are utilized. For We perceive the place and our location with the
urbanites who live in modern cities getting questions of “Where am I, where am I going, and
completely lost is not a common situation. The how should I reach it”. Legibility and direction
presence of others and special tools such as maps, finding are two concepts associated with each
street numbers, plates, bus numbers help us to find other.
the way. The strategic ring of direction-finding Lynch, in his book “Urban Image”, describes a
process is the environmental image, an image legible city as textures which are created with
where the individual generalizes the outside world definable elements and which can be
in his/her mind. This image is the product of both comprehended visually. At the same time, by
immediate senses and past experiences, used to establishing relations with the urban images; he
interpret acquired information and to direct defined a readable city as a whole texture of
movement.” which the regions, borders and roads can be easily
Bentley defines the legibility as the ability to read identified.
and understand the environment for options. Lynch, in the continuity of the definitions of
Readable environments make it easy for people to legibility, mentions the importance of the
find their way. If people find out about the individual's ability to find his/her direction properly
environment and what is going on there, they and to move easily. According to Kevin Lynch, five
utilize the preferences and advantages of the main elements for the mental image of a city and,
environment. The meaning of readable accordingly, for the legibility and direction finding
environments is that people can obtain clear and in the city can be defined as follows:
accurate images from it. Planners can control only Roads: These can be streets, pedestrian roads,
physical planning, permanent images change public transport areas, canals and railways. These
only by user factor (Bentley, 1985; Yavuz, 2009). elements are dominant in the image of many
According to Kaplan & Kaplan (1982); legibility is people. People observe the city on the move and
an environmental feature that allows the person to perceive other environmental elements on these
explore his surroundings without getting lost (Yavuz, roads and relate to the whole.
2009). According to Evans; legibility is to enable Edges: They function as a boundary between two
people to understand the plan of a place and the regions. Coasts, railways, development zone
activities it involves (Carmona et al. 2003; Yavuz, borders and walls are examples of edge elements.
2009). The edges may be walls that allows passing at
Sternberg explains legibility in terms of being easily some of its points and that connect two regions,
understandable, comprehensible and safe for and the connecting points connecting two
either residents or foreigners by creating effective regions. The edge elements that hold the
differences in the meaningful parts of the whole generalized areas together, such as in the cities of
and between these parts in urban planning which the main lines are determined with water or
(Sternberg, 2000; Yavuz, 2009). walls; are important elements that many people
Direction finding is that individuals can find their use to find directions.
way to their targets without delaying or Regions: Regions are perceived as two-
experiencing undue worry. On the basis of the dimensional areas; they form medium or large-
concept, there is the concept of “spatial scale parts of the city. The observer feels as
orientation” which means that the individual entering into these areas psychologically. These
places himself / herself into the mental can be recognized by some of their common
representations of the environment [Sönmez & determinant characters.
Önder, 2015, cited from Peponis et al., (1990)]. One Nodal / Focal Points: Nodal points are strategic
of the most effective concepts in showing up and points; they are intense focal points when traveling
progressing of direction finding and related studies from one point to another. In particular,
is the concept of legibility. Direction finding is intersections, squares as meeting points can form
considered as a feature of readable nodal points.
environments; the environments that provide the Signal elements: They create the point reference
necessary environmental information for the source. They are often easily defined physical
direction-finding behaviour and which enable this formations that are not entered; like a building, a
knowledge to be grasped and understood are sign plate, a shop, or a mountain. They may be
expressed as the readable environment. This is within the city or at a certain distance. In this way,
possible with the fictionalization of the they symbolize a fixed direction for any practical
environment with defined and distinct elements; use; like the city's towers, golden domes or high
by means of comprehending the defined hills.
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 2
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
The elements Lynch defines create the spatial 1.2.1. Information Design
information for direction finding and legibility. Information design is a design field that organizes
Legibility is designed with spatial guidance tools and presents the information needed by its user in
that are integrated into the perception and a fast and understandable way. Making life easier,
definition process of cities. making the time used efficiently and preventing
Spatial direction tools; with the elements Kevin confusion are among its primary tasks. In this field,
Lynch has defined, can be listed as follows: which we can explain as the design of information,
Legibility of circulating arteries the primary objective is to convey the information
Focal points in the simplest, clearest and most understandable
Definable areas, squares way to others. It is necessary for the user who is in
Accessories, materials, colors, textures, constant information bombardment to perceive
lighting the environment more clearly (İlisulu, 2017).
Creating spaces with identity. Information design, which is one of the most basic
These items can be used as an effective design areas of graphic design, works on how to transfer
tool in direction. But as cities, architectural spaces information better to the user. Graphic language,
grow and become more complex, visitors and especially in metropolitans, is preferred in terms of
locals can find it difficult to find direction. For these being universal. It is the language that can be
reasons, along with these elements, there is a need accessed and understood by everyone from the
for well-designed information and direction illiterate masses to the tourists who do not know the
graphics and landmarks of a universal nature for local language of the city; the language that the
those who speak different languages. visual communication and graphic design would
recommend. Especially considering the urban life
1.2. Information and Direction Design with fast tempo, the fast transfer of this information
As cities, architectural spaces grow and become also becomes important. Simple but very well-
more complex, visitors and locals started to have designed directions, signs that can be understood
difficulty in finding directions; a need for by everyone, directional systems that can be
information boards, direction signs and landmarks associated with each other and that can be
has arisen. There is a need for well-designed followed, consistent composition, colour and
information and direction graphics and landmarks typography are the elements that should be
of a universal nature for those who speak different designed (Taşçıoğlu & Aydın, 2015).
languages. Information design and direction Highways, city entrance signs, airports, terminals,
design, as a sub-branch of graphic design, is a field campuses, Olympic facilities, shopping centres,
of expertise which is based on interdisciplinary cultural centres, hospitals, exhibition and
cooperation covering many disciplines such as fairgrounds are the places where information and
architectural design, interior design, urban design, direction designs are used to find direction. In big
landscape design, industrial design, and crowded cities, symbols and pictograms used
communication, ergonomics, psychology and in the international arena, information and
computer technologies. Information and direction direction graphics are the tools that regulate social
designs, a sub-branch of graphic design that relations and provide communication. The
makes information readable and accessible for all, pictogram or pictograph is a symbol representing
have been important components of urban a furnishing, an object, a place, a function, a
design and spatial design by creating spatial concept by way of illustration (Figure 2).
image and corporate identity (Figure 1). In the context of environmental graphic design,
pictograms are used in direction and marking
sequences, especially in large and complex
spaces. Pictograms are used to direct and inform
people in many public spaces such as airports,
train stations, bus stations, shopping centres,
business centres, museums, hotels, hospitals etc.
Therefore, it is very important that the pictograms
can be easily understood by different human
masses (Dur, 2011).
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 3
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
2. FIELD SURVEY
In this study, the city of Trabzon will be evaluated
Figure 2. Symbolic expression with pictogram (URL-1,2017). with the concepts of legibility and directability and
the direction and information designs over the
1.2.2. Direction Design focal point, regions, edges, nodes, roads with
Direction design is an information design field that which Kevin Lynch have defined the imageable,
aims to enable users to find their destination in readable city. In particular, it aims to determine
open or closed areas. The direction design consists the perceptions and direction attitudes of
of visual designs intended to guide the user in a university students for Trabzon city and the city
certain direction. The marking design is a visual sign square. A survey was conducted to investigate the
indicating the point of arrival to the user. These spatial information elements and legibility of the
marks are the markers that specify a name and a city of Trabzon.
function of that place. For example, street In this framework, the aim of the study to analyse
markings guide pedestrians, while guiding them, the concept of legibility and direction designs that
also make it easy for them to read the intend to transform the cities into more
environment. Being able to see an important understandable spaces through the city of
building far away helps pedestrians know where Trabzon, the square and its surroundings and to
they are and whether they go in the right direction. examine the problems of the city in this framework
A marked street will be much easier to perceive, and to make suggestions. Furthermore, to create
read and familiar (Kolody, 2002; Yavuz, 2009). awareness for other cities with similar problems.
Marks such as door writings, floor numbers, building
names etc. are within the scope of the marking 2.1. Study Area
design. “The direction and marking design guides Trabzon is a port city founded in the 7th century
the pedestrian or vehicle traffic in main entrances, B.C. as one of the Ionian colonies of the Miletus city
road junctions, arrival and exit points, by state on the Aegean coast of Anatolia (Aksoy,
combining graphic elements such as typography, 1997). Trabzon has a colourful identity and
symbols and arrows (Gibson, 2009: 50, cited by: geographical location with the fact that it has the
Taşçıoğlu & Aydın, 2015). largest port of the Eastern Black Sea, its
The principles of a successful direction design can geographical and topographical position, hosting
be listed as follows(Ataoğlu, 2017): many different cultures such as Persians, Romans,
It should support user and visitor experience, Byzantines, Genoese and Ottomans, and the
make finding directions easier. reflection of this dynamic diversity in the space
It should be guiding and explanatory for those (Figure 3-4).
visiting for the first time.
It should help at decision points.
It should create a sense of space.
It should create an open and consistent
information system.
The route for reaching the point of destination
and leaving the space and its guidance should
also be designed.
The message should be open and clear, should
be understood easily.
It should give direction to the target and be
supportive at each stage.
There should not be information and marking
confusion.
It should support creating corporate identity,
brand value and image. Figure 3. Trabzon City Square and its surroundings (URL-2,2019).
It should add aesthetic value to the space with its
colour, form, typeface and graphic designs.
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 4
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
Zağnos Valley
(Yavuz, 2019)
(Yavuz, 2019)
KTU campus
Museum(Yavuz, 2019)
Old Town Hall
Hagia Sophia
(Yavuz, 2019)
Square,
Atapark (Yavuz, 2019)
(Ataoğlu, 2019)
Atatürk Statue
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 5
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
Table 1. Percentage (%) distribution of demographic serious deficiencies in the number and quality of
characteristics of participants.
directional signs (Table 2).
Percentage(%)
Table 2. Percentage (%) distribution of the participants’ data
Gender Male 75 related to direction finding and direction.
Female 25
Questions Yes % No %
Age 16 -20 40
S3.Can you easily find existing structures / 71 29
21-25 52
institutions?
26-30 8
S4.Can you find your way easily? 80 20
Landscape
S5.Have you ever lost your way? 31 69
Architecture 48
S7.Is it enough the number of direction 20 80
Department Architecture 35
signs?
Interior
Architecture 17 S8.Is the quality of the signboard that 22 78
where you are and where you want to go
1st grade 26
sufficient?
Class 2nd grade 34
3rd grade 24
4th grade 16 It was intended to evaluate whether Trabzon city
Neighborhood Kalkınma 40 centre and its immediate surroundings were
Konaklar 25
Bostancı 8
readable places; what their perceivable elements
Others 27 were; what the reference points related to the city
Where are you Trabzon 28 centre were; and the presence of elements,
from? Others 72 structures or places defining the city of Trabzon. In
How long have 1 year 21 this context, the answers of the participants
you been living 2 year 23
in Trabzon? 3 year 17 showed us that the people formed images that
4 year 13 were highly visually perceivable in the study area.
More than 5 years 26 54,3% answered the question “The place you
Where are you Home 52 indicate as address in the city square and its
staying? Dormitory 48
immediate surrounding when you want to meet a
friend” as the Square Park. 8,8% of the participants
Within the scope of the study, the surveyed
stated that they preferred the cafes in the
individuals were asked to make evaluations about
immediate area, 6,9% preferred Forum AVM as the
direction finding and direction for the city they live
meeting place. According to the answers, the
in and the city centre and its immediate
most preferred values were “Nodal point” with
surroundings. 29% of the participants stated that
55,2% and “landmark” with 31% amongst the five
they could not easily find the structures or
elements defining the city. These results show that
institutions in the city square and its immediate
the nodal points and landmark locations as the
surrounding, 20% stated that they had problems in
meeting point are more preferred, easily
finding direction, 69% stated that they have lost
remembered and easily accessible places (Table
the way for their destination and experienced
3).
delays. In addition, they stated that there were
Table 3. Percentage (%) distribution of the participants’ meeting point preferences.
S1. Town square and nearby
When you want to meet a friend, where do you meet?
Number of people Paths District Edges Nodes Landmark
Items percentage%
54,3
Meydan Park
8,8
Cafes
6,9
Forum Mall
6,9
Atatürk Statue
6,0
Uzun Street
4,3
Trabzonspor Emblem
3,4
KTU (University)
2,6
Konaklar District
1,7
Point Stationery
1,7
Dormitory
,9
Arzum Market
,9
Beşirli District
,9
Lc Waikiki (Clothing Store)
,9
Tanjant Taxi Stops
100,00 6,0 7,8 0 55,2 31,2
Total
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 6
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
36,2% of the participants answered the question 17,4% amongst five elements defining the city.
“The first place / object that comes to your mind in These results show that the places and regions that
the city square and its immediate surroundings” as have a landmark feature are preferred more in the
Atatürk statue, 15,5% as Trabzonspor emblem, 9,5% city square, and that they are places that can
as Uzun Street and 6% as cafes and restaurants. easily form an image in memory and be
According to the answers, the most preferred were remembered (Table 4).
“landmark” values with 77,7%, and “Regions” with
Table 4. Percentage (%) distribution of place / object preferences of the participants that first comes to mind on the city square and
its close vicinity
S2. Town square and nearby
What is the first place / object to think
Number of people Paths District Edges Nodes Landmark
Items
percentage%
Atatürk Statue 36,2
Cafes-Restaurants 6,0
Atapark 1,8
My home 1,7
Boztepe 1,7
Point Stationery ,9
Arzum Market ,9
Coast ,9
Airport ,9
Keloğlan Statue ,9
Cephanelik Restaurant ,9
Zağnos Valley ,9
Kanuni Home ,9
37,1% of the participants answered the question and “landmark” with 29,3% amongst the five
“Where would your reference point be when you elements defining the city. These results show that
describe an address in the city square and its the nodal points and places with a landmark
immediate surrounding to someone?” as the feature are mostly preferred related to reference
square park, 14,7% as Uzun Street, 8,6% as Atatürk point preferences, that they are important for
statue and 6,9% as KTÜ (Karadeniz Technical direction in urban spaces as they are places that
University). According to the answers, the most form an image in the memory and can be easily
preferred values were “Nodal point” with 39,7% remembered (Table 5).
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 7
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
Table 5. Percentage (%) distribution for participants’ preference of reference point when describing an address in the city square
and its immediate surroundings.
S6. Town square and nearby
Where is your reference point when describing an address?
Number of people Paths District Edges Nodes Landmark
Items
percentage%
Square 37,1
Uzun Street 14,7
Atatürk Statue 8,6
KTU (University) 6,9
Cafes-Restaurants 6,1
Sea 5,2
Arzum Market 3,4
Old Town Hall 2,6
Taxi Stops 2,6
Meydan Mosque 1,7
Kalkınma District 1,7
Trabzonspor Emblem 1,7
Coast 1,7
Atm 1,7
Ziraat Bank 1,7
Koton (Clothing store) ,9
Forum Mall ,9
Maraş Street ,9
Total 100,00 15,6 8,6 6,9 39,7 29,3
25% of the participants answered the question “Regions” with 34,6% amongst the five elements
“What is the place/structure you mostly use in the defining the city. These results showed that places
city square and its immediate surroundings?” as with a landmark value and regions were mostly
Square park, 21,6% as Uzun Street, 13,8% as KTÜ preferred with regards to the most used
(Karadeniz Technical University), 9,5% as cafes and place/structure in the city square (Table 6).
restaurants. According to the answers, the most
preferred were “landmark” values with 40,8% and
Table 6. Percentage (%) distribution of the mostly used place/structure preference of the participants in the city square and its
immediate surroundings.
S9. Town square and nearby
Your favourite place / structure
Number of people Paths District Edges Nodes Landmark
Items
percentage%
Meydan Park 25,0
Dormitory 2,6
Stationery 1,8
My Home ,9
Ganita ,9
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 8
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
Sanat Street ,9
Kalkınma District ,9
Gym ,9
Theater ,9
Ayasofya Museum ,9
Maraş Street ,9
Participants were asked to rank the place / Technical University) with 10,3% and Sümela
structure / elements that define Trabzon in order of Monastery with 9,5% were prominent. These results
importance. In the rank of the 1st choices, the showed that the Square Park was an important
Square Park with 24,1%, Uzungöl with 10,3% and nodal point, and that Sümela Monastery, Uzungöl,
Sümela Monastery were prominent. Amongst the KTÜ, Boztepe and Uzun Street were the most
second choices of the participants that define important places/structures/elements that define
Trabzon, Uzungöl with 12,9%, the Square Park with the city.
11,2%, Sümela Monastery with 10,3% were
emphasized. In the 3rd choice of the participants,
the Square Park with 18,1%, KTÜ (Karadeniz
Table 7. The percentage (%) distribution of place / structure / item preferences that define Trabzon in order of importance of the
participants.
Whether there was a difference in answers given answers, the quantity (and strength) of the effect
to the questions in the questionnaire according to of the departmental differences were analysed
departments was evaluated with Crosstab. with ‘Cramer’s V’ test. The Cramer V values range
Amongst the questionnaire questions, it was from 0 to 1, the values between 0-30 (or 0-40)
observed that the differences of the departments indicate the presence of a weak relationship,
of the students were effective only on the values between 31-60 (or 41-70) indicate a
questions of S1, S2, S7, S8 and S9. Amongst the moderate relationship, and values between 61-
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 9
JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY URBAN AFFAIRS, 4(2), 1-12/ 2020
100 (or 71-100) indicate a strong relationship The majority of the participants, as Lynch stated, it
(Özbay, 2008). S1 Cramer V value was 50, S2 was shown that a city would be perceived and
Cramer V value was 57, S3 Cramer V value was 50 encoded to our minds with “roads, monuments,
and the effect of Landscape Architecture, regions, borders and signs”. When the elements of
Architecture and Interior Architecture Kevin Lynch were analysed for the city of Trabzon
departments on the answers to these questions in the light of the surveys, it can be explained as
was moderate. S7 Cramer V value was 23, S8 follows:
Cramer V value was 25, and these showed that Roads: Uzun Street, where the urban
the effect on the answers to these questions was transportation is provided and which was
low according to the departments (Table 8). pedestrianised, Maraş Street and the Tanjant Road
where the vehicle passage is provided were
Table 8. The effect of departmental differences on the prominent as the dominant elements.
questions Chi-Square and Cramer V values. Edges: For Trabzon, which is a sea city, the
Value df Asymptotic Kramer
coast, seaside and historic city walls constitute
Significance V
(2-sided) important points of reference as border elements.
S1 Pearson 59,704 38 ,014 ,507 Regions: The city square and the coastal region
Chi- in its surrounding and Karadeniz Technical
Square University campus, which is the residential area of
S2 Pearson ,566
Chi- 74,193 46 ,005 Trabzon, which is a university city, the shopping
Square centre region near its surroundings attract
S7 Pearson ,232 attention as the regions. Uzungöl, which is far from
Chi- 6,246 2 ,044 the city, makes its presence felt with its different
Square
S8 Pearson ,257 character.
Chi- Nodal / Focal Points: The squares, which are
Square 7,676a 2 0,022 urban open spaces surrounded by buildings,
S9 Pearson ,499 where various activities take place, are important
Chi- 57,856a 36 ,012
Square triangulation points that give character and
identity to cities. In the city centre of Trabzon,
3. RESULTS AND SUGGESTIONS Atatürk Square Park has created a city image as a
Legibility is an important issue in our developing nodal and a reference point.
cities with rapid urbanization and population Signal elements: There are many natural and
growth. In this study, which addressed this artificial elements marked as a landmark and
problem, a total of 116 university students from the attract attention in the deep-rooted history of
departments of Landscape Architecture, Trabzon, which is a coastal and port city. The most
Architecture and Interior Architecture participated prominent of these were Sumela Monastery,
to determine the university students’ perception of Ganita, Boztepe, Hagia Sophia, the statue of
Trabzon city and city square and their direction Atatürk in the Meydan Park and the TS emblem.
attitudes. In the field study, urban images, legibility, spatial
Within the scope of the study, the surveyed information gained through past experiences and
individuals were asked to make evaluations about the importance of direction and information
direction finding and direction for the city they live boards were noteworthy.
in and the city centre and its immediate In addition, they stated that there were serious
surroundings. deficiencies in the number and quality of
It was evaluated whether Trabzon city centre and directional signs (Figure 5).
its immediate surroundings were readable places;
what their perceivable elements were; what the
reference points related to the city centre were;
and the presence of elements, structures or places
defining the city of Trabzon.
In this context, the answers of the participants
showed us that the people formed images that
were highly visually perceivable in the study area.
Dr. Aysel Yavuz , Dr. Nihan Canbakal Ataoğlu and Dr. Habibe Acar 12
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
Era la primera volta que l’Adela sentía aquest llenguatje; la primera
volta que sa imaginació acostumada á esplayarse ab los esplendors
de la riquesa, entreveya altres celistias que no tenian per única base’l
diner; los horitzons que en Félix li descubria, li eran completament
nous; era un pais verge, que jamay havia somniat que existis. Mes, en
un moment no s’enderrocan las obras aixecadas ab l’escarpra del
temps, y més quan aquestas sostenen ab més ó menos forsa un fondo
de rahó; per lo que la pobra noya, entremitj del nou oassis que
acabava de descubrir, hi sentia ressonar la veu del seu pare, dientli:
Devant del encés altar, l’escolá major resava las últimas denas del
Rosari, ab lo reduhit acompanyament de deu ó dotze donas, alguna
criatura y un sol home, que per sas encorvadas espatllas, se veya
clarament lo feix d’anys que havia fer torce sa espina dorsal. Al esser
aprop del altar major, se deixava veure que al temple hi havia més
il·luminació de la que de primer moment se descubria, com era la de
una llántia que cremava devant d’un alt Sant Crist, col·locat devora
de la porta xica de l’esglesia, y la de una altra que, espeternegant per
falta d’oli, donava sas darreras guspiras, penjada á la esquerra del
altar del Santíssim, enclavat en la part de la nau, que sustentava la
esbelta y esculpturada trona de noguera, que acusava la má d’obra de
las darrerias del sigle XVII.
Don Francisco sentí que una mena d’agredols invadia son cor de
trenta vuyt anys, y desitjós de conservarli per una estona més, torná
enrera y se dirigí envers un banch de fusta, col·locat entre dos altars
de la paret de la dreta, ahont s’assentá y clogué’ls ulls pera que la
il·lusió fos més acabada. Allavors, entre’l ritme del Ora pro nobis, li
semblá veure las vellas parets de la casa, ahont havia nascut; lo llit al
que’l seu avi l’havia acompanyat pera besar la má al cadavre del seu
pare; la fesomia trista de sa bona mare vestida de negre; més tart las
taulas de la escola; las caras rodonas, vermellas y alegres dels
companys de la seua edat; las berenadas á la vinya; los cups plens de
rahim; las revolcadas y tomballons á la sorra de la platja, cremosa de
l’escalfor del sol; los capbussons dins las onadas, los crits dels
pescadors al treure las xarxas; després un barco de vela mar endins;
després… després en Cuberta, no pogué continuar la peregrinació de
sos recorts: lo sonido d’una improvisació d’acorts arpegiats en un
armonium, li feu obrir los ulls y tornar a la realitat de sa existencia
actual. En lo breu temps que sa imaginació havia navegat per los
mars dels recorts de sa infantesa, los resos havian finit y l’esglesia
havia quedat completament deserta. Sols en lo chor s’hi veya un llum
y se sentian acompanyadas per l’armonium las primeras notas del
Ave María de Gounod, cantadas á mitja forsa per una veu de mezzo
soprano poch voluminosa, pero agradablement timbrada y d’una
dolsor y ductilitat incomparables. Als pochs moments D. Francisco
pogué convencers que la persona que cantava en lo chor, hi era sols
per ensajar, ja que al ésser al mi del Gratia plena, allargant la nota,
trencava la frase, per mancarli fiatto pe’l la, si, la, del compás segon.
La veu repetí per tres ó quatre voltas l’ensaig y ja segura de la
correcció, seguí ab facilitat fins al re, si, del Sancta, quinas notas no li
sortian prou lligadas; corretjit altra volta’l defecte, seguí sens
interrupció, fins al si del Ora mortis, que repetí també duas ó tres
vegadas, per semblarli, sens dubte, que li eixia massa oberta la nota.
Després altre colp ressonaren per una estona los acorts arpegiats y
tot seguit se sentí lo soroll de la tapa cayent sobre’l teclat, lo remor
d’una cadira al rascar demunt dels rajols y’s vejé la claror de la llum
passant desde’l centre del chor á la part esquerra, y després d’un
instant de desapareixer, tornar á reeixir, dalt del tram de grahons
d’una escala, que la foscor de la esglesia no li havia deixat veure fins
aquell instant, al costat de la capella, que s’esqueya devant per
devant del lloch ahont estava assegut en Cuberta.
Per altra part Mossen Jaume, apesar d’haver nascut de una familia
rica y poguér firmar de Villadó, de Llinás y de Mascorp, era senzill
com un modest menestral; la seua vocació religiosa y un decidit
entussiasme per l’estudi d’humanitats y escorcollament de las obras
dels autors clássichs llatins, l’havia fet mirar ab certa indiferencia tot
lo que’s relacionava ab los bens materials. Son luxo, en sa jovenesa
havia estat en la seua biblioteca, ahont entre diversas edicions de la
Biblia, de la Summa de Sant Tomás y de las obras de Sant Agustí, s’hi
veyan escampadas, ab verdadera profusió, las creacions d’Horaci y
de Virgili, las obras filosóficas de Aristóteles, las del sever Tito Livi,
las del retórich Quintiliá; y en fí, tot lo brillant estol de las lletras
llatinas, en tota la riquesa de sas diversas manifestacions. Mes feya
deu ó dotze anys que eixas obras, delectansa de sa pensa jovenil, no
s’havian tret del prestatje de sa vella llibrería; la obra del immortal
Pare Kempis, las meditacions del Pare Lapuente y’l Croisset,
escampadas sobre sa taula d’escriure, eran las únicas que gosavan lo
privilegi d’ésser llegidas per Mossen Jaume; las primeras, pera
confortació de son esperit, las altras pera revivar son zel, que en sa
delicada susceptibilitat, creya sempre esmortuhit, en pró de las
ovellas á sa custodia encomanadas ó pera cercar material pera
amenisar ab la historia dels Sants, que l’esglesia conmemora durant
la setmana, la plática que endressava als fidels los dias festius. A las
obras dels sabis seglars, es á dir, las purament literarias ó filosóficas,
feya alguns anys que’l bon rector de Larrua’ls havia declarat poch
menos que la guerra; y si no havia resolt ferne un foch era perque
apesar seu las estimava; cada una li enclohía’l recort d’una diferenta
época de sa existencia; totas havian estat sas amigas; ab totas havia
disfrutat y viscut; li semblava que á cada una li debia un tros de son
pensament y fins un bossí de son cor, per aixó no havia determinat sa
exterminació, pero deixava indiferentment que’ls corchs y la pols las
roseguessin. ¿Qué n’havia tret de la ciencia, de las máximas, de la
sabiduría ab ellas adquirida, si no havia sapigut trobar paraulas y
rahons de prou virtut, de prou eficacia pera dissuadir á duas
dotzenas de visionaris de Larrua que se’ls havian pujat al cervell las
doctrinas de Allan Kardech, creyentse com article de fé los falsos
prodigis atribuhits al mon dels esperits? Mossen Jaume comprenía
ab més ó menos pena de son cor cristiá, que hi haguessen esperitistas
en la vella Alemania, en la Inglaterra, en los Estats-Units, fins en sa
estimada patria Barcelona; pero ¡que n’hi haguessin á Larrua, y que
hagués brotat aquesta filoxera d’ánimas essenthi ell de Pastor, y que
no sols anás aumentant lo número, si no que’l error invadís lo camp
femení arrivant fins á las mares de familia!… Pera’l bon rector aixó
era’l máxim de la desesperació; los ateos, los lliure-pensadors, que de
tot desgraciadament hi havia en aquell reconet de costa catalana, li
inspiravan la pena que causa al metje la vista del malalt incurable;
pero aquestos, á més d’ésser pochs eran pera las donas objecte de
repulsió sas doctrinas materialistas despossehidas de tota idea
d’ultra tomba; la negació desapiadada de las hermosas y
consoladoras veritats del cristianisme, distava molt de fer adeptes
entre ellas; pero l’esperitisme, ab sos punts de maravellós, ab sas
máximas de caritat y amor al próxim, que tantas y tantas voltas
havian sentit en la mateixa doctrina cristiana, no’ls inspirava recels;
l’huracá seguia sa devastadora carrera y l’apesarat rector devant de la
inutilitat de las seuas tentativas y de lo poch ó gens profitosa que
havia estat per ell l’estudi de la ciencia terrena, fondament
descoratjat de las forsas de la seua inteligencia, ab pany y clau tancá
per sempre més los llibres d’aquells ingenis que tantas cosas sabian,
que tan gran coneixement entranyavan de la humanitat, que tantas
reglas de conducta donavan als pobles y ab tants concells il·lustravan
als Céssars; y que á ell no havian sapigut donarli de sa ciencia de la
vida humana una llum, un camí, un remey, pera acabar ab aquella
pérdua d’ovellas que tan fondament l’aclaparava.
—L’ he fet esperar sense volguer… Tenia á dalt á Da. Rosalía que no
acabava may de despedirse… Per fí ja n’estich lliure. ¿Qué’m vol?
Feya un bon rato que Mossen Jaume tenia devant dels ulls una carta
que ja no llegía y que deixá demunt la taula pera dir á la seua nevoda
ab certa solemnitat que no passá desapercebuda á la noya:
Mossen Jaume endolsí encara més son accent y agafant entre’ls seus
dits ossosos la aristocrática má de la Montserrat, digué colpejantli
carinyosament:
—Ja veurás, ja veurás; es que aquest bon senyor que, segons m’han
contat, tots los pares de la colonia forastera se’l disputan per las
seuas fillas, los ha donat mitja volta á l’esquerra y ha vingut á
cercarte á tú. A tú, la més pobreta de totas; ¡á tú que ningú ’t veu en
forat ni en finestra! Res ¡com lo del qüento de la Cendrereta! ó
mellor dit, quan Nostre Senyor té una cosa destinada…