Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Stanford Daily: FTC Seeks To Rein in Facebook
The Stanford Daily: FTC Seeks To Rein in Facebook
CLOSE ESCAPE
Huestis career night lifts Cardinal
INTERMISSION/INSERT
Today
Tomorrow
Mostly Sunny 63 40
Mostly Sunny 64 39
An Independent Publication
www.stanforddaily.com
Public fear over online privacy has been ramping up, and for Julie Brill, a commissioner at the Federal Trade Commission, the increased attention is warranted. In an informal talk at the Stanford Law School, Commissioner Brill said the FTC is focusing increasing attention on the privacy policies of cyber companies from Facebook to the latest smartphone applications. We have been really active over the past year or so in terms of enforcement and probably the matter that . . . in many ways could be considered the most important is the Facebook settlement, Brill said. I think Facebook, and to a certain extent the Google proposed settlement, are significant because for the first time we are calling on companies . . . by order from us, to institute a comprehensive privacy program. The FTC has taken actions against Facebook, Google and Twitter and has proposed settlements for all three. The major components of the settlements with Facebook and Google include: having in place personnel who are primarily responsible for privacy and having in place governance structures throughout the corporate entity that are thinking about privacy, Brill said. We also put in place auditing requirements . . . that last for 20 years.
FTC Commissioner Julie Brill discussed FTC settlements with Facebook, Google, Twitter and Amazon at an informal talk at the Law School. Many companies are facing complaints over consumer privacy concerns.
In the case of Facebook, Brill also mentioned that the FTC is specifically concerned with the transparency and clarity of their privacy rules. Just simply having something down somewhere in a very complicated document, we have taken the position that . . . it will not absolve a company of potential problems if consumers wouldnt have expected to find that very salient information in the place where the company put it. That was one issue that came up in the Facebook matter. Facebook is accused of deceiving consumers by telling them they could keep their information on Facebook private, and then repeatedly allowing it to be shared and made public, according to an FTC press release. Of the three major Silicon Valley companies to face action from the FTC, the action against Facebook contained the most numerous and diverse complaints. The complaints range from changing the companys privacy policies without notifying consumers, to several instances of misrepresenting such policies. For example, the FTC complaint claims that, in many instances, Facebook has shared information about users with platform advertisers by identifying to them the users who clicked on their ads, despite stating explicitly that Facebook never shares data. After relaxing privacy policies in Dec. 2009, platform ad-
The number of homicides in East Palo Alto doubled this past year, jumping from four homicides in 2010 to eight in 2011. With a goal of zero homicides in 2012, the city will rely heavily upon its Operation Fourth Quarter, a collaborative program that educates the community with the expectation of lowering the rate of homicide. The City of East Palo Alto Police Department reported a 9 percent decrease in violent crime and a 2 percent decrease in overall crime during 2011. According to Police Chief Ronald Davis, the doubling of homicides over the past year, while emotionally significant, is not statistically significant. Rather, it demonstrates the extreme fluctuation of homicide rates in the single digits. You do have to put it in context in a sense that, even though it was double last year, it was the same as the year before, Davis said. Were seeing a long-term downward trend, clearly; but I think the fact that we have these
increases and decreases, these fluctuations, really underscores how much work we have to get done. The chief referred to the five murders in June and July of 2011 as the reason this years homicide rate was unbalanced. Specifically, he believes that a violent crime spree of three individuals accounted for three of the five summer homicides, pointing to the need to curb gang violence in East Palo Alto. Contrary to this past years data, historical trends of homicide in East Palo Alto typically show an increase during the last three months of the year. Operation Fourth Quarter was established in 2007 to counter the trend of East Palo Alto homicides in the fourth quarter of 2006, during which three murders occurred in two weeks. The program focuses on enforcement of laws and prevention of crimes. It makes the community aware that this is a historical time, that we do have violence, and it provides, what we think, is
HEALTH
Entering its fifth year, BeWell, a campus incentive program to encourage healthy lifestyles for community members, has expanded to offer financial benefits to spouses and registered domestic partners of University benefits-eligible employees. In addition, BeWell has started offering employee participants the option of sharing and exchanging their BeWell records with those from an outside medical plan. Stanfords BeWell program provides participating University employees with yearly fiscal incentives, advising, nutrition workshops, gym memberships, classes and other services to help them make healthy decisions, thereby hoping to prevent heart disease, cancer, diabetes and metabolic syndrome. Undergraduates and graduate students
can also use BeWell to track their health progress and participate in events, but do not receive financial incentives. Spouses and registered domestic partners will not have access to BeWell Berries, a package of benefits including a yearly fitness assessment and classes, offered to employees in addition to the lifestyle assessment and financial incentives that make up the core of the program. It would be great to see the at least 50 percent of [participating] employees with spouses or registered domestic partners participating in the program, said Jennifer Sexton, director of fitness and wellness programs, about the new initiative. We had over 6,300 faculty and staff complete the SHALA and Wellness Profile in 2011.
NEWS BRIEF
physical sciences that has taken him from a post-doctoral fellowship at Stanford in 1956 to a professorship in 1967 and a 15-year tenure as director of SLAC, from 1984 to 1999. Richter won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1976 along with Samuel Ting for their work on the discovery of a subnuclear particle. His general research focused on experimental particle physics with high-energy electrons and electronpositron colliding beams. In addition to his work in physical sciences, Richter has become a leader in energy policy and national security affairs in recent years, serving on the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board, Laboratory Operations Board and Nuclear Energy Task Force. He chaired the National Research Councils Board on Physics and Astronomy. And in 2010, Richter published Beyond Smoke and Mirrors a book that examines the issues of nuclear energy and climate change in the 21st century. The book received the 2011 Phi Beta
Lawrence Wright, author, screenwriter, playwright and staff writer for The New Yorker, spoke at an Ethics and War talk Thursday about his book, The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11.
Recycle Me
BEWELL
Congress is expected to consider two bills when it returns from recess on Jan. 24: the Preventing Real Online Threats to Economic Creativity and Theft of Intellectual Property Act (PROTECT IP Act or PIPA) and the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). The legislation is of major concern to Stanford thought leaders, in addition to nationwide legal experts, online security experts, Internet activists and the founders of many of Silicon Valleys largest companies The answer is to innovate, not to pass stupid laws that are going to screw up the Internet, said Anthony Falzone, executive director of the Fair Use Project at the Stanford Center for Internet and Society (SCIS) at a Dec. 7 event hosted by SCIS called, Whats wrong with SOPA? The panel convened experts on Internet infrastructure and security, digital intellectual property and Silicon Valley business to articulate many of SOPAs problems. More than 150 people attended the Law School event, which was not meant to give equal time to both sides, according to Falzone. The audience did include two representatives from the Motion Picture Association of America, supporters of SOPA and PIPA, who spoke up during a question and answer session. There were things about this bill that people in Silicon Valley needed to know that is lawyers, entrepreneurs and technology people, Falzone said. Our goal was to put together an array of people who could speak to each one of those sets of considerations. Professor Mark Lemley, director of the Stanford Program in Law, Science and Technology, spoke in a January interview with The Daily of the necessity of publicizing what he characterized as the incredible harm of this potential legislation. PIPA was introduced in the Senate in early 2011 and it went through the Senate Judiciary Committee unanimously . . . mostly I think because people hadnt paid attention to it, Lemley said. Lemley believes this unanimous action occurred because PIPA was a less extreme bill than SOPA a conscious legislative decision to make the lesser of two evils look like a healthy compromise. Both pieces of legislation are almost exclusively supported by traditional media companies like Viacom and members of
Recording Industry Association of America, as well as companies heavily reliant on brands such as Nike, the NBA and Pfizer. The founders of Google, Yahoo, Twitter, LinkedIn and many other Silicon Valley giants published an open letter warning of the dangers of SOPA and PIPA. The letter appeared as a paid advertisement in The New York Times, The Washington Post and other newspapers. It predicted SOPA and PIPA would, have a chilling effect on innovation and change the very basic structure of the Internet. The letter also raised the legal concern that this legislation allows the closure of websites without due process and could be used to stifle legitimate speech. If we just shut down the Internet there would be a lot less piracy, right? Lemley said. But, there is a lot of socially valuable material that we get only because of the Internet. In the most severe version of SOPA the Attorney General would have authority to bring action against websites accused of committing or facilitating online piracy. The bill also provides for a system of notifications directly from the copyright holder to web services like Internet service providers (ISP) and search engines. These web services are then able to suspend service to specific sites and are immune from prosecution for doing so in error. You wouldnt necessarily even bring anybody into court, Lemley said. So each individual ISP who gets this notice has now got to keep a separate black list. Falzone said he fears a world in which websites could be shut down, in a completely invisible way. You would have people doing these deals in the proverbial smoky backroom . . . picking up the phone and saying, Wouldnt it be so unpleasant if we had to go through an elaborate process and spend money on lawyers? Falzone said. Of further concern is that the act of physically limiting the websites that computers can access would not only fundamentally change the way the Internet currently operates, but in so doing would negate current efforts at improved Internet security. For Lemley, the physical blocking of websites has foreign policy ramifications as well. Its awfully hard to persuade the Chinas and Irans of the
the spouses and domestic partners of these employees. Qualifying spouses and registered domestic partners must complete three requirements to receive the $240 taxable wellness reward in 2013. BeWell requires that spouses or partners complete the SHALA and Wellness Profile, agree to share information in 2012 and enroll in a Stanfordsponsored medical plan in 2013. The BeWell mission is to serve as the overarching health and wellness resource for Stanford University, according to the programs website. In its mission statement, the program states that by facilitating a culture of wellness at Stanford, we encourage individuals to adopt and maintain a healthy lifestyle and behaviors to improve their health, well-being and quality of life. BeWell approaches the question of how to stay healthy by personalizing its resources to address the employees individual needs. Participating employees must first fill out the health and lifestyle assessment, which serves as the gateway to the BeWell program. BeWell reports that the assessment is not meant to be time-consuming, and takes on average 20 minutes to complete.
FTC
give users simplified notice and simplified choice about some of the ways that data is being collected and used online. The FTC proposal further suggests creating more strict disclosure rules for third party companies that collect data without direct interaction with the customer. The thinking is that a customer dealing directly with a vendor is aware that Amazon, for example, will have access to their personal data, but should be clearly notified if that data is collected by a third party as well. Brill said she expects the proposal to be finalized in the coming months, but for now it is open for comments. The FTC has traditionally focused on data security, but when asked about last years discovery that patient information from Stanford Hospital, including names and diagnosis codes, was online for over a year, Commissioner Brill said it would not be the FTC that would handle the case. Instead, Health and Human Services will be taking action. Brill did offer empathy for consumers over data security in general. The consumer has to trust that the company is engaging in good data security practices and when that falls down . . . the consumer is left on the sideline; but its their data. That is one of the reasons that we focused for a long time on data security, and it is only more recently that we have moved more broadly into privacy, she added. The event was hosted by the Stanford Center for Internet and Society and was put on as a part of Data Privacy Day, an effort to raise awareness about privacy. The official Data Privacy Day is Jan. 28. Contact Josh Hoyt jwghoyt@stanford.edu. at
OPINIONS
E DITORIAL
Established 1892 Board of Directors Kathleen Chaykowski President and Editor in Chief Anna Schuessler Chief Operating Officer Sam Svoboda Vice President of Advertising Theodore L. Glasser Michael Londgren Robert Michitarian Nate Adams Tenzin Seldon Rich Jaroslovsky
AN INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER
Managing Editors Nate Adams Deputy Editor Billy Gallagher & Margaret Rawson Managing Editors of News Miles Bennett-Smith Managing Editor of Sports Tyler Brown Managing Editor of Features Lauren Wilson Managing Editor of Intermission Mehmet Inonu Managing Editor of Photography Shane Savitsky Columns Editor Stephanie Weber Head Copy Editor Serenity Nguyen Head Graphics Editor Alex Alifimoff Web and Multimedia Editor Zach Zimmerman,Vivian Wong, Billy Gallagher, Kate Abbott & Caroline Caselli Staff Development
Incorporated 1973 Tonights Desk Editors Margaret Rawson News Editor Joseph Beyda Sports Editor Ian Garcia-Doty Photo Editor Charlotte Wayne Copy Editor
or students looking at organizations in the real world, whether for employment or in order to bring about an idea they have, the split between nonprofit corporations and traditional, or for-profit, companies is clear. Nonprofit must serve a societal need, often (but not solely) in a charitable, religious or research capacity. For-profit corporations can solicit investors and shareholders, but generally the law sees their primary mission as maximizing shareholder returns. This means that a for-profit companys social or environmental missions often become secondary to its profit-seeking motive. In a middle ground between these extremes a new type of corporation is emerging, with California the latest but surely not the last state to legally enshrine socalled B Corp status. The B Corp, or benefit corporation, is meant to give firms a way to prioritize social and/or environmental goals without imposing all the restrictions of nonprofit status. Californias legislation, which is similar to laws in Maryland, Vermont and a few other states, requires B Corps to have a specific public benefit, which is generally taken to mean a social or environmental mission. They must also take into account the interests of their workers, their customers, the community and the environment in addition to shareholders, and they must publish reports on their societal or environmental impact in addition to financial results. One of the best-known companies to have since applied for legal B Corp status is Patagonia, a maker of outdoor clothing and equipment, which has a long history of supporting environmental causes. In fact, although legal B Corp status is still nascent, the nonprofit organization B Lab that developed B Corp certification and promotes states adoption of benefit corporation status has certified more than 400 companies as such. The organization sees B Corp status as a
corporate social responsibility equivalent to the U.S. Green Building Councils LEED status for environmentally sustainable design and aims to support more transparent standards for companies claiming to do good. Detractors argue that it is not clear that legal B Corp status is needed at all. Legal precedent suggests that for-profit corporations must maximize shareholder value but no laws actually state that social or environmental missions must come second. Furthermore, some argue that part of the B Lab certification procedure is cumbersome and does not actually guarantee any real social or environmental impact on the part of the firms involved, defeating its stated purpose. Lastly, the relative newness of the legal status means that many questions remain as to how the B Corps will actually be treated in the context of bankruptcy, layoffs or other socially difficult, but sometimes economically necessary events. Nevertheless, it would seem that the development of B Corp status offers several benefits and few real compromises for potential, socially conscious entrepreneurs, including those at Stanford. There is no doubt that firms that want to run themselves as a business (i.e. not as a nonprofit) but do see their role as fulfilling primarily a societal beneficial function do not currently have any unique recognition. At worst then, the B Corp registration offers a niche for a few firms to occupy. At best, it allows numerous firms that are currently constrained to legally work towards enriching numerous stakeholders rather than solely their shareholders and encourages further social entrepreneurship. It does all this without restricting the rights of other corporations or giving B Corps any readily apparent unfair advantage. Blurring the line a little between the categorical extremes of for- and nonprofits with the introduction of benefit corporation status appears to be a win-win.
Contacting The Daily: Section editors can be reached at (650) 721-5815 from 7 p.m. to 12 a.m. The Advertising Department can be reached at (650) 721-5803, and the Classified Advertising Department can be reached at (650) 721-5801 during normal business hours. Send letters to the editor to eic@stanforddaily.com, op-eds to editorial@stanforddaily.com and photos or videos to multimedia@stanforddaily.com. Op-eds are capped at 700 words and letters are capped at 500 words.
SEEING GREEN
Unsigned editorials in the space above represent the views of the editorial board of The Stanford Daily and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Daily staff. The editorial board consists of eight Stanford students led by a chairman and uninvolved in other sections of the paper. Any signed columns in the editorial space represent the views of their authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the entire editorial board. To contact the editorial board chair, e-mail editorial@stanforddaily.com. To submit an op-ed, limited to 700 words, e-mail opinions@stanforddaily.com. To submit a letter to the editor, limited to 500 words, e-mail eic@stanforddaily.com. All are published at the discretion of the editor.
uring the driest December in two decades, I snuck off for a long weekend in Yosemite National Park. When I booked the trip, I expected to visit a winter wonderland, photographing snowflakes pouring down the face of Half Dome and icicles dangling from every cabin. Instead, every single road was clear, and the only sign of winter was the frost edging Bridalveil Fall. For my travel companion, a Yosemite rookie, the absence of snow proved a boon: We drove to every classic vista and hiked trails generally closed by that time of year. But if I was slightly disappointed by the lack of seasonal snowfall, I can only imagine the dismay of ski resorts across the American West. The unseasonably dry weather has left Tahoe skiers scraping gravel, Colorado and Utah resorts facing slim snowpacks and Yosemite itself still closed to snowsports. Snow-lovers with resources can still get their wintry kicks in parts of New Mexico and British Columbia; but in general, this years conditions are lamentable. Worse, a bad ski season predicts a tough year for water-users (read: everyone) living in the American West. Snowmelt from western mountain ranges form the headwaters of rivers harnessed to supply agricultural irrigation, drinking water and hydroelectric power. During low-snowfall years, our frozen mountain reservoir is diminished, and drought looms. Here on the Peninsula, 85 percent of our water comes the Hetch Hetchy Reservoir, perched within Yosemite National Park and filled
by the dammed Tuolumne River. This water flows 167 miles down from the Sierras, across Californias Central Valley, underneath San Francisco Bay, to Peninsula reservoirs like Crystal Springs (the body of water visible from I280 between San Francisco and Stanford). The pipelines connecting the flooded Hetch Hetchy Valley to our dorm room taps were laid between 1914 and 1934, and cross three active faults. (The Crystal Springs Reservoir itself lies in the valley of the San Andreas Fault.) So its no surprise that the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission is currently in the midst of a decade-long, $4.6 billion project to reinforce and enhance the water transport system before the next Big One rattles a fault between here and the Sierras. History predicts a severe earthquake along the Hayward Fault about once every 140 years, so were overdue for the next one. Geologists assign a 30-percent probability of a major earthquake within the next 30 years a slippery number for a slippery fault. But in the (likely) event that this January remains dry, we may discover that the largest threat to our water security isnt the shaky ground over which it flows. Perhaps well see that the real threat is drought. So far, weve gotten half the normal amount of precipitation, and the snowpack is 20 percent or less than normal for this time of year. Its easy to see that Californias water supply is in trouble by glancing at your nearest reservoir. The bathtub ring dirt and rock exposed along reservoir edges by falling water levels of Lake Don Pedro (also filled by the Tuolumne River), which we
Holly Moeller
Instead,every single road was clear,and the only sign of winter was the frost edging Bridalveil Fall.
passed on our drive home from Yosemite, must have been meters high. Even Crystal Springs here on the Peninsula is looking low. Across California and across the world were growing on borrowed water, outstripping the ability of our freshwater supply to replenish itself. Its a problem exacerbated by climate change. Not only will precipitation patterns change, potentially reducing the absolute amount of water that rains down on Californian watersheds, but warmer temperatures will mean less snow and more rain. Thus, rather than accumulating a large snowpack that melts in spring just in time to meet agricultural demand, well have to find ways of capturing immediate runoff from winter storms by adding capacity to existing liquid reservoirs. Scientists expect the Sierra Nevada snowpack to decline by 40 percent by 2050 and by up to 90 percent by 2100, assuming we keep up our current rates of fossil fuel use. Since it seems that, short of running out of those fuels, our carbon dioxide emissions are unlikely to slow, well be dealing with significant dry-downs within our own lifetimes. Time to start practicing. One week after my visit to Yosemite, I found myself in another National Park: Death Valley. Water that flows into Death Valley doesnt leave: The annual evaporation rate is 150 inches per year, and the valley floor is covered by salt deposits up to 5 feet deep. Our hotel room was plastered with warnings about heat and dehydration, and equipped with water conservation measures, like a rotating hourglass to time five-minute showers. Its amazing how quickly you learn to soap up (and how grateful you become for shorter haircuts) while watching sand trickle through the glass aperture. It was a lesson I took home with me: the perfect New Years Resolution shaped by two National Parks, one at elevation, the other (partly) below sea level, linked by water, or rather, its absence. Holly encourages you to try out the five-minute shower and to send water-saving tips, comments and critiques to hollyvm@stanford.edu.
value free speech. Reading otherwise-controversial ideas rarely bothers me, but I struggle to read The Atlantic because its tone is so moralizing. In my days at school, especially among those who term themselves socially aware, I have not found that mindset a common one. Instead, I have met an army of white knights, always at the ready to descend with righteous anger on those who say the wrong thing, and others who are less impassioned but share the sentiment. Attitudes toward speech heavily favor the shaming, if not censorship, of certain varieties of speech. Saying something insensitive, whether true and to the point or not, is universally decried. Oftentimes, this is a reasonable reaction. Most would rather write something bland, boring and uninformative than offend someone else even if just by challenging their beliefs. The consequences are by no means limited to mere social shaming. They reach deep into personal, professional and public life. When gaffes of that sort are made in the public and private spheres, reactions are harsh and swift. When words reflecting attitudes of unadulterated selfishness, a desire for needless excess or a cavalier attitude towards violence come up in conversation, people shake their heads in disappointment. Many see it as necessary that politicians resign after
faux pas that imply wrongheaded values. A wide array of statements we term insensitive or coarse is thought to reflect so strongly on the character of their speakers that they are put beyond public redemption. But consider the music that will be ringing in bars and clubs across the country this Friday night. That we should delight in lyrics so blatantly wrongheaded when upholding a culture so sensitive it often oppresses controversial debate is so ridiculous it defies explanation. At parties and at home, about a third of the soundtrack of the budding 10s is comprised of music whose lyrics not only make no pretense to being moral, but actively glorify actions that alarm even the most apathetic among us. Which is really strange in this day and age. Everything is analyzed for undertones of malice and immorality. What is found lacking is harshly critiqued. Yet the role of drugs, violence and inhumane behavior in music has never been so large as it is today. Yes, theyve always been a part of our music, but no one would guess what Day Tripper is about (the immaculately clean Paul McCartney is singing about a prostitute). Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds is riddled with drug references, but never do Ringo, John or George declare their love for codeine syrup and a host of serious drugs. Never do they give violence and manipulation a clear
endorsement. What is at the core of this double standard, that allows the veneration of casual immorality and insensitivity in one realm and not in every other? I could never pretend to know. It does, however, seem doubly absurd that this realm of clemency be music the chosen form of entertainment, consolation and information about the adult world for teens, tweens and age groups too young to have a hip moniker. This is not to say our music needs to change, and I certainly do not advocate censorship. I will continue listening to the same things I always do. I merely want to point out how ludicrous it is that in a world where a police officers sexist, dumb, but apologizedfor sentence at a 10-person public safety seminar at a law school in Toronto spurred an international movement, we not only abide by but encourage, admire and promote words reflecting much worse attitudes. Well pounce on statements that show the slightest signs of poor judgment, and do nothing but bob our heads while violence and carelessness are elevated onto our most prominent stages. We believe in free speech, but we also viciously attack that speech we deem unacceptable; then why is music exempt from our scrutiny? The realization of our own inconsistency forces us to ask questions of the sincerity of our values.
D.S. Nelson
Saying something insensitive,whether true and to the point or not,is universally decried.
While I know plenty of Stanford students who wont stomach a single word out of line, perhaps rightfully so, none of them takes issue with the music that inundates our airwaves. Neither do I, really. But it seems truly absurd that we can campaign against innumerable social ills and then give them tacit sponsorship by popularizing artists who make it central to their work. Its not a problem I can properly address. But it certainly seems to have some hefty implications about our endorsement of our values and our beliefs about the media we let define our culture. Is Tyler, the Creator not your ideal music? Let Spencer know at dsnelson@stanford.edu.
EPA
year. Davis said he views this trend as promising, noting that factors such as the caliber of weaponry and the proximity of the shooter were likely more responsible for the deaths than an overall increase in gun violence. I think [Operation Fourth Quarter has] made a tremendous difference. We havent seen those kinds of numbers since then, Davis said, noting that even so, violence usually remains highest during the fourth quarter. The city has seen a decline of homicides over the past decade. While the count was often in the double digits during the 1990s, reaching a record of 42 homicides in 1992, recent years have been relatively peaceful, ranging between four and 15 killings in the past six years. Were small enough that four is outrageous, Davis said. There is no reason why we cannot have zero homicides in a year. Contact Jordan Shapiro at jordansh@stanford.edu.
BRIEFS
SOPA
Wiley brings a depth of experience overseeing performing arts organizations and an enthusiasm for the importance of the performing arts in the life of the university, said Matthew Tiews, Stanford s executive director of arts programs, in a statement. Hausam will manage the operations and management of Bing Concert Hall, in addition to coordinating programming. The hall, expected to open in Jan. 2013, will be used by student groups and Stanford departments for performances. In addition to his duties with Bing Concert Hall, Hausam will work with the Stanford Arts Initiative to help promote the arts around campus. It is a pleasure to welcome Wiley to Stanford, and I look forward to working with him as we count down to the opening of the hall, said Jenny Bilfield, director of Stanford Lively Arts. Stanford hopes the Bing Concert Hall will develop into a showcase for local artists and student groups, as well as being a valuable rehearsal venue for the music and drama departments. According to the University, the hall will be the main venue for presentations and performances by any visiting artists, as well as campus and offcampus programs.
Brendan OByrne
AFRICA
There needs to be a public investment strategy that will expand access to land in areas that are currently underutilized to allow some kind of natural migration to be going into these areas, to relieve the population pressures, Jayne said. Following Jaynes speech, Derek Byerlee, director of the 2009 World Development Report, provided additional commentary. He agreed with Jaynes main points and,in addition, emphasized the need to address the current system of land markets and land rights. At present, 80 percent of the land is under customary rights and under this informal system transactions are not recorded. Byerlee argued for the need for transparency in these transactions, and like Jayne presented the tie between land rights issues and other social problems. I think its going to be really critical for maintaining peace and reducing conflict. I think a lot of the big conflicts weve seen in Africa, trace them back, and they reduce to problems of land, Byerlee said. Contact Lucy Musson at lucyfina@ stanford.edu.
gluten-free
Gluten-Free Menu Available Now!
Paninis are grilled with a certified gluten free, dairy free, soy free and nut free whole grain bread (brown rice, tapioca and potato) served with a side of organic spring mix greens, delicately dressed with balsamic vinaigrette.
LIVE STORYTELLING
COHO CAFE 8PM TUESDAYS
BIG SHORTS
This Week January 17 TOBIAS WOLFF SKIP HORACK XANDRA CLARKE
storytelling.stanford.edu
SPORTS
STANFORD EDGES STRUGGLING UTAH
MILES BENNETT-SMITH
MANAGING EDITOR
Joseph Beyda
Despite a very tough night from the freethrow line Stanford went 5-17 at the charity stripe the mens basketball team staved off a scrappy Utah team to continue its run of conference success with a 68-65 win on Thursday night. The Cardinal (14-3, 4-1 Pac-12) was favored by 23 heading into the contest, but struggled to contain the Utes offense, which came into the game 333rd in the country averaging just 56.9 points per game. Guard Chris Hine scored a career-high 21 points for Utah (4-12, 1-3), routinely splitting the defense for layups.
Sophomore forward Josh Huestis had a career-high 13 points and shot 6-6 from the field, leading the Cardinal to a surprisingly close win over new Pac-12 addition Utah.
Mens Gymnastics
With often-intimate connections formed through the recruiting process and four years or more of training and competition, it s rarely easy for coaches to say goodbye to graduating seniors. When you graduate five All-Americans on the heels of winning the NCAA championship, like men s gymnastics
coach Thom Gilelmi did this year, it can be overwhelming. Faced with that daunting task, the No. 4 Cardinal kicks off its defense of last season s title tonight when it takes on No. 5 California on the road in Berkeley, Calif. The rival Golden Bears regularly prove a stiff test for Stanford, and last year saw the Cardinal rebound nicely from a season-opening loss to Cal, winning the Big Flipoff and
the last dual-meet of the season to enter the postseason with plenty of momentum. But the loss of All-Americans Alex Buscaglia, Josh Dixon, Tim Gentry, Ryan Lieberman and Abhinav Ramani all of whom graduated after competing for the Cardinal in last year s NCAA meet and Buscaglia s win of an NCAA Individual Title
Last night the Stanford womens basketball team extended its unbeaten streak in the Pac12, defeating Utah 62-43 in Salt Lake City. Again the No. 4 Cardinal (14-1, 5-0 Pac-12) started the game slowly, allowing the Utes (8-7, 1-3) to tie the game eight minutes into the contest, and the score stayed level at 10-10 for almost three whole minutes. From there, however, the Card noticeably improved, and the half ended with an 11-point lead. After the break, an eight-point unanswered run in the first two minutes of the second period put the game out of Utahs reach, and it was relatively simple for Stanford from there on out.
Sophomore forward Chiney Ogwumike had her sixth double-double of the season against Utah in a relatively low-production night for the usually powerful Cardinal offense. Stanfords 62 points were just one above a season low, and the squad has been held below 70 points in two straight games, a cause for concern heading into tomorrows meeting with Colorado.
Wrestling
Audubon Green Empowerment Rocky Mountain Institute United Nations Foundation World Resources Institute
Border Green Energy Team Natural Resources Defense Council Union of Concerned Scientists U.S. Green Building Council Worldwatch Institute
This Sunday the Stanford wrestling team heads to San Luis Obispo to take on a Pac-12 foe, the Cal Poly Mustangs. The Cardinal (5-5, 1-1 Pac-12) and the Mustangs (3-2, 2-1) have been to the same tournaments this year the Vegas Invitational, the Reno Tournament of Champions, and the Midlands Tournament. In the two earlier tournaments, Vegas and Reno, Cal Poly finished higher than Stanford. But since then Stanford has wrestled much better. At the Midlands Tournament Stanford finished 25th, eight spots better than Cal Poly. The Cardinal and the Mustangs have wrestled three teams in common so far this season, and both are 2-1. Both teams dominated Cal State Bakersfield and won close meets against Boise State. But against American, Stanford almost pulled out a win while Cal Poly lost by double digits. The main event of Sunday s dual will be the match between Stanford s No. 1 Nick Amuchastegui (13-0) and Cal Poly s No. 4 Ryan DesRoches (19-0). DesRoches, a two-time NCAA Tournament qualifier who has twice finished third in the Pac-12 Tournament, has already won three tournaments this year. Amuchastegui has won the Pac-12 Tournament and finished second on two occasions, including last year. This match will undoubtedly be the toughest test so far for both Amuchastegui and DesRoches. There is a lot at stake because the winner of this match will likely have the No. 1 seed at the Pac-12 tournament and a top-three seed at the NCAA Tournament. Stanford s other ranked
wrestler, No. 7 Ryan Mango at 133 pounds, looks to improve upon his 19-5 record and keep his 10-0 perfect. The Mustangs have two ranked wrestlers other than DesRoches No. 2 Boris Novachkov at 141 pounds and No. 16 Ryan Smith at 197 pounds. Novachkov has had an extremely successful career at Cal Poly, winning two tournaments this season and finishing fifth at another. He has lost just two matches this year, has won the Pac-12 Tournament twice and last season finished second at the NCAA Tournament. Smith recently defeated the No. 14 197-pounder in the country, Danny Mitchell of American. Smith will be a tough match for Alan Yen, Stanford s starter at 197 pounds. This match is crucial in determining momentum for the remainder of the rest of the season for the Cardinal. Although the squad is wrestling very well maybe the best it has all year it is coming off of a loss. A win this weekend would greatly boost the team s confidence and would be a great reward for the team s hard work and improvement, while individual wins are also very important for seeding in the Pac-12 Tournament. The key to the dual will be the Cardinal wrestlers ability to put multiple moves together. Against Boise State and American, they were able to execute one move after another, reshooting after an opponent s attack and going for pinning combinations after gaining control. The Cardinal has the ability and the talent to win this Sunday, and it is crucial that it takes care of business against its Pac-12 opponent. Contact Palani Eswaran at palani14@stanford.edu.
MGYM
2012
Applications are now being accepted for MAP Sustainable Energy Fellowships. Nineteen Sustainable Energy Fellowships are available with:
Washington, D.C. (in conjunction with Green Empowerment) Thailand Beijing; Chicago; New York; San Francisco; Washington, DC
Audubon
high-pressure competition Penev is in fact the only returner to post an All-Around score last season in a meet the defending NCAA champs have plenty to prove early on. Glielmi acknowledged the high expectations his squad faces, but the two-time College Gymnastics Association National Coach of the Year said that he fully expects to make a deep run in this year s postseason. Our goal is always an NCAA championship, he said. Regardless of how we finish in the dualmeet and regular season, the guys need to come away from each competition knowing what they need to do to improve and be the best they can be at their events. Well be strategic when we use guys and be ready to go come postseason. Against the Bears, who finished fourth at the 2010 NCAA Championships, it will be important for Stanford to start strong and not fall behind early. Cal boasts two members of the U.S. senior national team, Donathan Bailey and Glen Ishino, and had three members of the team compete at either the World Championships or Pan American Games during the fall. Coach Tim McNeill s team also returns four All-Americans. The Cardinal, which has finished in the top three at the NCAA Team Championships for six consecutive seasons, gets its season underway tonight at Haas Pavillion at 7:30 p.m. Contact Miles Bennett-Smith at milesbs@stanford.edu.
Applications are due January 27, 2012. For more information, contact fellowships@maproyalty.com.
The loss of Alex Buscaglia, who won a NCAA individual title on the horizontal bar, and four other All-Americans will set the Cardinal up for a tough defense of its national championship.
MBBALL
Senior forward Josh Owens had 11 points, including this energetic dunk, and made one of his two free throws of the night. Stanford struggled from the line, converting on just five of its 17 free throw opportunities.
SPORTS BRIEF
the CONCACAF Qualifying Tournament in early March. Forward Lindsay Taylor and defender Camille Levin, both seniors, will travel to Florida for the U.S. Under-23 team s camp starting Sunday. Levin had the assist on senior midfielder Teresa Noyola s game-winning goal in the College Cup Final on Dec. 4, while Taylor was the Cardinal s leading scorer with 20 tallies last season. Meanwhile, Noyola and junior defender Alina
OF TRUE PASSION?
Your boundless energy, enthusiasm and unwavering support helped push the Cardinal to yet another historic season at Stanford Stadium. Thanks to all of the spirit groups and students that made The Red Zone the best 12th man in college football. Lets do it again in 2012!
RED.
THANK YOU
WBBALL
BRIEFS
AVCA All-Pacific Region and All-Pac-12 First Teams. In addition, she was second on the team with 3.16 kills and 4.08 points per set, while becoming the first player to be named Pac-12 Offensive and Defensive Player of the Week this season. While the Cardinal was upset in the second round of the NCAA Tournament, Wopat whose twin sister Samantha is also on the team posted a career-high 13 blocks in Stanford s first round victory over Sacred Heart.
Miles Bennett-Smith
BEYDA
CLASSIFIEDS
GET NOTICED BY THOUSANDS.
(650) 721-5803
www.stanforddaily. com/classifieds
Senior forward Lindsay Taylor is one of three Cardinal players who will be at various U.S. national team camps this month. Taylor finished 2011 with a team-leading 20 goals, many of which came late in the season.
WANTED
$$ SPERM DONORS WANTED $$ Earn up to $1,200/month. Give the gift of family through California Cry-
obanks donor program. Apply online: SPERMBANK.com ISO Babysitter for campus faculty family; chwest@gmail.com
Level: 1
2 3 4
SPECIAL PROMO:
All first time guests receive 20% off for a single service
SOLUTION Complete the grid so each row, column and 3-by-3 box (in bold borders) contains every digit, 1 to 9. For strategies on how to solve Sudoku, visit www.sudoku.org.uk
2011 The Mepham Group. Distributed by Tribune Media Services. All rights reserved.