Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • "নিসর্গ নিয়ে ভাবনা : একাধিক সমবায়ী প্রয়াস"

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    337 views26 pages
    ২০১২. পার্থ চক্রবর্তী, দেবরাজ গোস্বামী, দেবপ্রসাদ বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়. "নিসর্গ নিয়ে ভাবনা : একাধিক সমবায়ী প্রয়াস". দিবাকর সরকার সম্পা. অক্ষ(র)যাত্রা. ১০: ১২. (৭-৫০ পাতা). কলকাতা. There are five parts in this booklet on non-conventional environmental science: [a] A prologue written by Bandyopadhyay on the issues of image processing and remote sensing techniques by means of which the wealth of the earth is ruthlessly extracted by hedge account holders by using satellites and surveillance helicopters with rudders that emit gamma-rays, infra red etc. According to Bandyopadhyay that type of planetary–corpo[rate]real politics led to anthropogenic climate change. He also cited Lila Majumdar’s prediction from a science fiction [1983] according which, the ice were not only melting but the axis of the earth was also displaced due to violent anthropogenic intervention into the corpoREAL of the earth. Surprisingly enough, that prediction in the eighties of the last century was subscribed by the Geo-Physical Society’s Report [2008]. [b] Bandyopadhyay then wrote a lengthy report on the basalt [a ‘minor’ mineral as per legal term] quarries of Birbhum, West Bengal, India, where a kowm [Bandyopadhyay was reluctant to use the term ‘tribe’ for a group of homo sapiens] is exploited illegally with slim wage and had become null workers—with or/and without existential status. This report, written in a feminist narrative style through the voice of a victim of West Bengal academiocracy, was published in 2008 [“pathure jiboner kOtha”.Sen, Ashok ed. Baromas. XXX. (pp.145-51)] and in this re-presentation the whole scoop was extended with many theoretical tools, viz. the question of ownership [svatva, cf. abstract IDs: 2054667 and 2032594] of land, anti-green architectural imperialism etc. He also cited new Minor Mineral Acts to show the lacuna of administration, who, surprisingly enough, [voluntarily?] did not even know it. Environmental laws are also violated and the administration was a merely a puppet. [c] Bandyopadhyay again repeatedly visited the geo-political areas of Birbhum, Bankura, Medinipur, Purulia and Bardhaman, West Bengal, India in 2010 and the report was published in a newspaper [2010. “pathore pathore nace agun”. Dances of Fire at Basalt Quarries. Post- Editorial column. Chattopadhyay, Suman ed. Ekdin. 17/09/10 (pg.4)] and here re-presented by deploying theoretical tools. The situation was worst at that time. The kowms were revolting against disembodied owners [a specter-like entity. Though they were not owners, they were enjoying the ‘tribal’ land that could not be ‘owned’ by the so-called non-tribal people. Cf. abstract Id: 2028606] in guise by means of huge money-sign] of the quarries. These disembodied owners also took revenge with armed goons. So-called Maoists were also reigning with arms and ammunition. Bandyopadhyay observed [1] the ‘Maoist’ terrorism was a construct of state-corporate-sponsored political parties-industrialist/hedge account holders collusion and the Maoists had nothing to do with the Maoism as an ideology per se [2] and thus it is a simulated war for the strategic evacuation of the land so that the collusion could establish ownership of the wealth underneath; [3] despite the fact of simulation [a la Baudrillard] or irreal, ‘real’ was the DEATH/TERMINATION/ANNIHILATION of many homo sapiens as well as flora and fauna of the ‘natural’ geography of the above mentioned four districts; [4] the Malthusian mindset of the collusion was also discussed; [5] State controlled [legal] terrorism was reflected in the mirror of state-sponsored/-branded terrorism through mutual resemblance [anyonyopratibimba] or reverse mimicry[cf.abstract ID 2016682]. [d] This self-funded qualitative survey with little bit of statistics, when was executed in the fields and with the help of Google Earth, Bandyopadhyay and Chakrabarti [at that time he was at the Boston University] were engaged in a lengthy dialogue, an ‘other’ session—they were rend

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    ২০১২. পার্থ চক্রবর্তী, দেবরাজ গোস্বামী, দেবপ্রসাদ বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়. "নিসর্গ নিয়ে ভাবনা : একাধিক সমবায়ী প্রয়াস". দিবাকর সরকার সম্পা. অক্ষ(র)যাত্রা. ১০: ১২. (৭-৫০ পাতা). কলকাতা. There are five parts in this booklet on non-conventional environmental science: [a] A prologue written by Bandyopadhyay on the issues of image processing and remote sensing techniques by means of which the wealth of the earth is ruthlessly extracted by hedge account holders by using satellites and surveillance helicopters with rudders that emit gamma-rays, infra red etc. According to Bandyopadhyay that type of planetary–corpo[rate]real politics led to anthropogenic climate change. He also cited Lila Majumdar’s prediction from a science fiction [1983] according which, the ice were not only melting but the axis of the earth was also displaced due to violent anthropogenic intervention into the corpoREAL of the earth. Surprisingly enough, that prediction in the eighties of the last century was subscribed by the Geo-Physical Society’s Report [2008]. [b] Bandyopadhyay then wrote a lengthy report on the basalt [a ‘minor’ mineral as per legal term] quarries of Birbhum, West Bengal, India, where a kowm [Bandyopadhyay was reluctant to use the term ‘tribe’ for a group of homo sapiens] is exploited illegally with slim wage and had become null workers—with or/and without existential status. This report, written in a feminist narrative style through the voice of a victim of West Bengal academiocracy, was published in 2008 [“pathure jiboner kOtha”.Sen, Ashok ed. Baromas. XXX. (pp.145-51)] and in this re-presentation the whole scoop was extended with many theoretical tools, viz. the question of ownership [svatva, cf. abstract IDs: 2054667 and 2032594] of land, anti-green architectural imperialism etc. He also cited new Minor Mineral Acts to show the lacuna of administration, who, surprisingly enough, [voluntarily?] did not even know it. Environmental laws are also violated and the administration was a merely a puppet. [c] Bandyopadhyay again repeatedly visited the geo-political areas of Birbhum, Bankura, Medinipur, Purulia and Bardhaman, West Bengal, India in 2010 and the report was published in a newspaper [2010. “pathore pathore nace agun”. Dances of Fire at Basalt Quarries. Post- Editorial column. Chattopadhyay, Suman ed. Ekdin. 17/09/10 (pg.4)] and here re-presented by deploying theoretical tools. The situation was worst at that time. The kowms were revolting against disembodied owners [a specter-like entity. Though they were not owners, they were enjoying the ‘tribal’ land that could not be ‘owned’ by the so-called non-tribal people. Cf. abstract Id: 2028606] in guise by means of huge money-sign] of the quarries. These disembodied owners also took revenge with armed goons. So-called Maoists were also reigning with arms and ammunition. Bandyopadhyay observed [1] the ‘Maoist’ terrorism was a construct of state-corporate-sponsored political parties-industrialist/hedge account holders collusion and the Maoists had nothing to do with the Maoism as an ideology per se [2] and thus it is a simulated war for the strategic evacuation of the land so that the collusion could establish ownership of the wealth underneath; [3] despite the fact of simulation [a la Baudrillard] or irreal, ‘real’ was the DEATH/TERMINATION/ANNIHILATION of many homo sapiens as well as flora and fauna of the ‘natural’ geography of the above mentioned four districts; [4] the Malthusian mindset of the collusion was also discussed; [5] State controlled [legal] terrorism was reflected in the mirror of state-sponsored/-branded terrorism through mutual resemblance [anyonyopratibimba] or reverse mimicry[cf.abstract ID 2016682]. [d] This self-funded qualitative survey with little bit of statistics, when was executed in the fields and with the help of Google Earth, Bandyopadhyay and Chakrabarti [at that time he was at the Boston University] were engaged in a lengthy dialogue, an ‘other’ session—they were rend

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    337 views26 pages

    "নিসর্গ নিয়ে ভাবনা : একাধিক সমবায়ী প্রয়াস"

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    ২০১২. পার্থ চক্রবর্তী, দেবরাজ গোস্বামী, দেবপ্রসাদ বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়. "নিসর্গ নিয়ে ভাবনা : একাধিক সমবায়ী প্রয়াস". দিবাকর সরকার সম্পা. অক্ষ(র)যাত্রা. ১০: ১২. (৭-৫০ পাতা). কলকাতা. There are five parts in this booklet on non-conventional environmental science: [a] A prologue written by Bandyopadhyay on the issues of image processing and remote sensing techniques by means of which the wealth of the earth is ruthlessly extracted by hedge account holders by using satellites and surveillance helicopters with rudders that emit gamma-rays, infra red etc. According to Bandyopadhyay that type of planetary–corpo[rate]real politics led to anthropogenic climate change. He also cited Lila Majumdar’s prediction from a science fiction [1983] according which, the ice were not only melting but the axis of the earth was also displaced due to violent anthropogenic intervention into the corpoREAL of the earth. Surprisingly enough, that prediction in the eighties of the last century was subscribed by the Geo-Physical Society’s Report [2008]. [b] Bandyopadhyay then wrote a lengthy report on the basalt [a ‘minor’ mineral as per legal term] quarries of Birbhum, West Bengal, India, where a kowm [Bandyopadhyay was reluctant to use the term ‘tribe’ for a group of homo sapiens] is exploited illegally with slim wage and had become null workers—with or/and without existential status. This report, written in a feminist narrative style through the voice of a victim of West Bengal academiocracy, was published in 2008 [“pathure jiboner kOtha”.Sen, Ashok ed. Baromas. XXX. (pp.145-51)] and in this re-presentation the whole scoop was extended with many theoretical tools, viz. the question of ownership [svatva, cf. abstract IDs: 2054667 and 2032594] of land, anti-green architectural imperialism etc. He also cited new Minor Mineral Acts to show the lacuna of administration, who, surprisingly enough, [voluntarily?] did not even know it. Environmental laws are also violated and the administration was a merely a puppet. [c] Bandyopadhyay again repeatedly visited the geo-political areas of Birbhum, Bankura, Medinipur, Purulia and Bardhaman, West Bengal, India in 2010 and the report was published in a newspaper [2010. “pathore pathore nace agun”. Dances of Fire at Basalt Quarries. Post- Editorial column. Chattopadhyay, Suman ed. Ekdin. 17/09/10 (pg.4)] and here re-presented by deploying theoretical tools. The situation was worst at that time. The kowms were revolting against disembodied owners [a specter-like entity. Though they were not owners, they were enjoying the ‘tribal’ land that could not be ‘owned’ by the so-called non-tribal people. Cf. abstract Id: 2028606] in guise by means of huge money-sign] of the quarries. These disembodied owners also took revenge with armed goons. So-called Maoists were also reigning with arms and ammunition. Bandyopadhyay observed [1] the ‘Maoist’ terrorism was a construct of state-corporate-sponsored political parties-industrialist/hedge account holders collusion and the Maoists had nothing to do with the Maoism as an ideology per se [2] and thus it is a simulated war for the strategic evacuation of the land so that the collusion could establish ownership of the wealth underneath; [3] despite the fact of simulation [a la Baudrillard] or irreal, ‘real’ was the DEATH/TERMINATION/ANNIHILATION of many homo sapiens as well as flora and fauna of the ‘natural’ geography of the above mentioned four districts; [4] the Malthusian mindset of the collusion was also discussed; [5] State controlled [legal] terrorism was reflected in the mirror of state-sponsored/-branded terrorism through mutual resemblance [anyonyopratibimba] or reverse mimicry[cf.abstract ID 2016682]. [d] This self-funded qualitative survey with little bit of statistics, when was executed in the fields and with the help of Google Earth, Bandyopadhyay and Chakrabarti [at that time he was at the Boston University] were engaged in a lengthy dialogue, an ‘other’ session—they were rend

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 26

    ~ <1tt~I'1lClb ')jl~G16~GG1<tj ~~ ~:~~9ft1fJm ~~:~~~

    9~

    ~~

    Nrn <!l9fBr-'G9(rn
    <jS@ I '-!l~

    ~~
    ~

    \51~r5"W!r.~ l.!t \51~m 'GI9fBf ~


    ~ c:<PFl ~
    '8~ ~ ~

    /"5;

    ~<!l~~~~I~fR~~

    'fC\?l ~,
    ~

    ~ 1f~ c~ 81r~
    t:llfiiMc;<l>
    'G~ ~

    ~-ZMr ~,

    G'f ~~ ~
    <jS@~,

    <lJi9f'rn! \5i

    *$10
    ~

    rr1, ~

    ~illl~~~~<jS@~~~I~

    on ~

    ~C~~~I~~<fl~~~

    >ir.<fIF! t'1 ~! I
    ~' -~ ~'8~

    ~~~'>ttUt <£1%1 ~
    ~iSpIl1Hl II (~~\T\!l)

    \5G'fffi Dt9f1 ~-

    ""'fiJ
    \5l1<PrM

    ~9Gm
    'Btl ~ ~9ff,
    >ro '!3~
    <i'i~ c!l~ ~?

    ? \51113 ';5ftm

    tfl~

    <Fft\%'l
    ~?

    ~'0

    ! ~~

    C'lilG4bi<:f'f\b <i~)
    I

    9f1i:15"1<Ir~' iW!ltti'1f\b<:f'
    ~
    cw.1l (~, I C<:f'WTI ~? ~?
    i$T(P1 ~

    cwrn (C'Ff~
    ~
    i$l5f"1~:t~4, ~-~,

    ~9fil;jffi:r)--Ul~

    ';5f1'iSSrn

    :£t~

    'iSCb

    ~~
    ';5f~ ~

    (Geo-politics ~

    ego-politcs?) ~ ~
    ~
    ~

    ~fSm, ~f;5
    ~I

    ..,.:"'i'tTmI ~~
    \5~

    I GBr98f tfl~~-o=r<f'~ "It!3<f~ 'G $ ~~ ~9(fG~~<ql

    c!1V1 ~

    ~,
    (~
    'l~ C<:P#T? ~
    ~ ~Sf

    ~,
    ~

    <flUf '<[~ \'jj'@r \'5l'Bf ~ ~


    ~

    \5@-~,

    <tfCf c;<J\5"T! ~
    ~ C~ ~11J I ¥-i¥ C~

    ~~-m
    ~

    ~ ~f<J11
    ~
    ~

    6f~) I ~~
    tfl~

    >BKrlrn ~
    ~r9fOmf ~
    ~ ~~~

    m, tfl~
    ~ ~
    ~

    "<8M ~

    7fCOB' DI1<f ~ .~\

    ~-\'jj~G1

    '5fBf ~-~

    ~1~Woa'fl~JF:T~,'b~~~~,~
    ';5ff@t

    I~

    C\51

    9fI'*rr,
    I~

    ~<r>

    I ~<l>1fif;I; tfl~ ~
    ~ ~~

    ~-r<mT ~rnI ~
    ~

    ~,~m
    @f~

    '{iSrffi:C"1"'1~ I ';5f1m1te

    NaT
    ~

    oamr
    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~I

    ;;1ti'1lrpli4, ~~
    ~

    '!3~ISf{31t1
    ~
    <!i~

    ~';5f1'<rn,

    fib ~C\!)~'>tr.'i? ~G'f FPio;{


    1~
    ~~~ I~~ \5lG'1, '5fI"frn

    <wITFr!, "~,
    ! .!l~,

    ~-~~
    I <.fI~ ~
    ~'8~'

    f.Trn \'jj1~IUt'$l
    ;n·I~DC"11
    • '5f'If@

    'b\!)Ut
    ~

    ~1t"T ~
    ~ ~

    CIblm I5Ili8t4*'1 \375fi.1l1~<ii ~,


    ~ <ql~I~C\!)

    C~

    <.!1~ CIblm <:J'IV1?[

    I \5f~ ~,<.!1"<!'Bf~ ~

    ~,~

    ~I

    tfl'Q: C"iM D1~ I

    ~ ~?" ~
    ~

    I~

    '6lI"'llI,Q1 ~

    "11, D'Wl ~
    ~
    113~

    ~
    \5f@

    ~
    c~ ~

    f.t(;11ft

    <ltG'I D?Ff, "<.QVfi~:J9f?t


    ~-~

    ~D1<f1

    ...

    surveillance

    helicopter!

    ';5fj~

    <TIl ~.!l~ ~

    survelillance-a

    orr ~I

    1f<1J I
    ~ \5fl~

    <:!'Wl'

    <r('.G'f

    remote sensing ~

    Image processing!

    ~ C~\!}1 ~ ~
    ~~ m<f~

    C~~1,

    .,t-~ ~ ~, <Q' <Q~ ~9ftim-~ "1iilr Qj1:~ - ~ Gl\S, ~ ...~ "ll I orr,~ '8~ <]Wt~ ~ <Qrn '>trol ~~~ ~
    ""<!'<t1\!)JOjMC"1~ ~

    ~ql!:lTl1T

    ~
    c:q<r~

    ~ I <f?f~ ~I

    ~fiLI ~

    '.fi~ ~-~

    'i>ftQJ@ 9ft'<t@ ~

    ~~
    9fI'<f~,

    ~9fi<rrrn
    ()'f<r~~9fi<1Jt$f

    ~
    <!i~

    ~
    ~

    [mage processing and Pattern Recognition Unit-Cl~ tfl' ~ ~

    'J'f~UlII8i"'1 -lfl<rW qt~~

    ~f\bc<l~"'1l1M
    Cl'f<TelJftq
    ()'f<f~

    I ISFIlib C'!J1 orr~fiW:T~-~cnr

    ~
    ~

    FP=r'iff.tm ~
    8flQ_( ~
    ~~~C~

    ~~

    Ib1 ~
    ~2f

    ~9jj<unr

    \5TR11

    W~
    ~
    I~

    ~<1J C~ ~!~I\!)C'G1 ~ ~ \5i.1'ffi ~


    ~

    <rRf 11'*(>11 ~ : "Paratroopers'


    ~f 8J ~

    linguistics!"
    1Nf'ifw.~

    9[1q~,

    ~9fl~

    c!I'<R ~
    <ri.1Jl~
    <.fI~~

    I ~~

    c'iiP1 ~

    '!31Jr

    =<'_O 9.-0b---Ul <$11 0

    ~~<f.Blf~~

    '{3~G1\5ffi:~

    ::.~!~(<1")"%!rr
    ~{}I~rF1~;q ~ ~~ ~
    ~"f

    ~o;f

    Ani ~

    : c!1wrf<f<1" ~
    9rFD"J ~

    mrffl!)'!l

    C\51

    61m
    1

    Wrn

    I '5f?r9ffi ~

    ~C~ cfI<l>lJ1 ~\~

    ~f1ivr
    <rrt?fm
    @.'>I\G

    ~!.

    ..\5fI1i'lJ,
    'S:[t~

    -m~~I.!l1:R<fl'~~?

    <!l~ ~~~

    '<Til>, ~
    1l'fif."1?

    -1:15[$IHm'ST!

    l)('p'[

    <rf 0'1~I!;'"I~ -

    <I@r ~
    <P"R1"~
    ~

    ~Hl ~"f I ~4M!

    Flash ~ \SIRI ~ I .~

    ..fI1.l~

    ~r ~
    ~<lJ ~

    ',rrcm ~
    ~
    ~Tr~
    r..

    ~
    ~?z~

    <!l~<t>
    I ~-~

    \5?'iHr .~.

    @:1~"lr~~"1

    J-F1<f:'i
    I Yt,..~8

    \T'iJ~ ...
    ~

    l.!l<F-f<I'i ~

    ~r
    C"f(ftf ~

    <wIT.G1T (.\51S! <;f.~

    -a<u ?J:J9JW ~
    ~~9f1
    ~?j

    ~~rn-~
    f.tr.;rtn ~
    <!I~

    ~o;tf
    <I'm ~'lI1
    ~

    m I 4:(fr[ ~~
    '@9J'l$[ ~?
    ~I

    r~~ <t>Uf -

    -~,:m
    :J Oil'1:J-<!l

    ~~~[",I~

    --m~
    Act-Fl

    I ~~-~

    lransfer
    ~

    of land (Regulation)
    CD@! ~

    c<r"'1 C~

    ~
    ~

    f.tv3~
    ~

    \5fiU ~
    (?f~

    wr'G1 c<r ~ "f~


    ~

    <fiQ,j'f, "<!l~

    1fl~

    m~ ~ '5l~~f1q
    tV'6~

    <fHJ I ~9@

    '5!Br
    I

    >e~
    -..5f~

    G~'<1'3
    }![\!;! ~

    <r~0Bi
    1\G~ '<:[!9(i7ft

    ~W \G 'STtTIK!~
    <O!J1<l>1';£i; ~
    \!iF.jj"?l ~
    ~

    \!ir

    ~Qjffi

    f<I'C~ ;;rt

    '5lf<:R!'-rn ~
    ~iSl~C"l$l
    ~ ~ 1

    ~~

    iiRf ~~

    <lfu1~ ~
    ?~

    ~'<IW1

    ~~~

    ~
    '~'

    fi1c~~ :~,

    ~Rr,

    <FIll ~

    )~
    ~ mrt?l~

    c<f'lT.<i1 <!l~
    <wfI ~

    cfl~tG9i ~~~
    -~,~~~~~?

    CD<l?l ~

    ~r f.:r, ~
    15100 <fSf<I'i

    '5!iC'if
    ';j~-~

    cfl~

    UGC ~

    ~M:rF111
    9

    '&~Tl~

    ~~
    <!l~ ~ C~ ~ ~

    '5l@r ~
    I ..fI~

    Df.t~ ~Gi{jj(3H1 ~

    <;f.Q,j'f, <!l~ i$l5\a"j~QJpl?l ~

    ~~~tr,a"j!

    '$~Mxa"j., 1\5ffR

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~
    '~~ ~

    m
    ~~

    <n ~~~
    \Gmr.<:f1 ~

    ~
    .~

    'blJl<J>lQ;·'ij~HWB1 ~
    ...~ ~ 1.ff{3~

    c::r:rWGT 05fG'f!\5M -Simulation,"~ ~c:<P Term inate, evacuate ~ ~ (J1t<inl ~"11IC'M C\51 ~ <!l~~ ~

    ~i£C~f.h:lt11
    ~

    <prn~
    C51t"f
    ~ )0\)'18 I

    <ui 1BW1 ~
    <fi1<Jt \G~

    c<fi!:?1"'f
    '~'('*11

    C'i'fG'f I

    '13m 'G"[I'f<f"Tot<m

    ,.,~
    '¢[~

    W~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    ~.:u

    ~c.1!,~ I

    ~<fBf"1 ~,

    mm ~
    ~

    <l"f ~~ ~'f\G

    crer "f@,-c!1"?f
    -

    ~, ~~

    \5f03 cfj~

    <l>Q.f1 ~0:rc;5 ~~

    ftW;5- ~"f
    1iR\51 ~ ~ ~
    I

    1fmT i7ft"ifGf? ~

    m, \5Q)'ff9f
    -.:r:r,
    <!I~ ~

    ffi9@ ~~

    ~~,
    C~

    ~I

    N5R

    ~~"*' ~
    ?fI'81f1 <rf~
    I~ ~ l{~J~ ~

    :~
    ~

    0.Fll51iU"l"1'¥ <!l~

    C~

    rrt"ff'i ~
    I f.9~ ~
    ~!((W[

    <TAl <pfiSi ~

    Atomic

    Mineral
    c:<P ?- __ '5lir>i;;11:1
    ~ ~ C~

    ... T.v.-"?l9flffi:r I

    '5I-T ... simulation!

    Division-as

    ~~

    fS'f?]J~lsti"!lf.iWO'Hl~r;q

    Pf\$[-~~

    <iJ1"'irn
    -

    m'3 \5lJII5t~
    ~~,

    ~ ~ \5lm ~

    9fR I ~~?j"?l ~Il<fi ~

    f.t I Ct:1t':fit;lr1i ~-.:r ~


    ~
    '<rfi"g<r' ~

    ~lW,~
    .!J~~

    ~~,
    ~

    11<11, ~

    ~
    ~

    etr->Wr'\ ~
    ~ ':(~ C31

    ~
    ~I

    <fS~ <Ff 0:[1 ~,


    ~

    ~~ ~'8

    ~~~~~<!l<fi'Gi~~~~8R cfl$[ ~

    ~r ~f\!;f0~ ~
    I~
    t9~

    ~l<lll

    K><lHI%t ~\S1'I<n--.n-~
    ~<rR_, <!I<f1<1" ~ ~

    ~ ~ 9fffm Proper name-o;rn


    CfN.?f CPfI~

    'STG, ~
    '{3~

    ~~J~,

    'l(f4iS3r.T\'8

    ~~! ~ ~ \G~(j 1V1 81 ~

    m, <$iGt fi1rn <$i&l ~


    (J1 '51<rrn cfl~

    ~
    <fi~ ~

    'Offfir ~
    ~

    i£oo~ ~
    ONGC-$[
    I {3fuq;~ ~

    <I'm : ~ ~
    dry <!iFf ~
    <r!V"tI$ll;q ~~ ~I ~

    DT~

    ~
    ~

    <:ft,
    ~

    on I I!lIKS~IR<f' f4iM!(i1$1 ~
    ~ <ll~ <!I"R i8Pff~
    (I1[<f

    \Gm<!'l ~;: ~,

    0P'@ f<t,~
    I C?f.@1'V;1

    <fl~

    Cuddapah-Ce ~ I3t ~
    <!I~\Pff ~

    k@(.i"1f.j1Jl11 ~'f?l,

    ONGC-'i"1' ~

    ~ <!It:F.ii,
    ~I"?l

    c<rm ~
    <;f.f<I'i ~

    ~,

    Mt:1!Ul\}f I c<l 1S1Bl'ifW'fl

    ~
    ~I

    f4@310il~1 ~

    f.9z~, ~"'r

    -m, <m~

    ) 8/\!il'lf\"(~f)'$m

    H>io{

    f.'rrn

    iSf<M1

    <.£l'flf~

    ~/:;,

    ([ <.£l~

    "f9'5f1~ Pyudensobinog

    <:rN ~ ~~

    m, ~
    ~
    @f~

    ~
    ~~

    ~ mQJBT

    Kyl1eng CID'11<:rtGr,5R\

    \B'iI~
    ..!l"Q_ ~

    <£11111 ~
    ~

    <£I~

    C>ir?frl 1:tG-.b~ ~

    '<JI~ '1!{~ ..-

    <!l~,

    Mawthhahah

    ~.-rn
    <£I<!,

    C'1i~

    Evacuation-termination

    ~m:<L
    '8~

    ~
    D@l

    ~
    ~"frn ~~~(;

    ~
    <!'@ :

    '<f["'ff<fi

    GiGJ ~' C1lWfr~iI~ cmr.l WR


    :fr~
    \5'IT~ ~

    <rTIT

    ~I

    ~m?J

    .. Preface

    Pcstfacel ~

    ()~\rS)

    9rfWql ~
    1 '1~

    C~

    .~

    >fWIrP'i, ~ ~

    fiN

    ~
    ~Qj

    l5Tt-sr111"

    -!I~

    c91<:Jbfu1,*I~"1

    <:fi1.PJ1<>f<f-'<Ff $~~,
    ~Q5 ?f~
    1 ~ ~

    elm ~
    ~<!;

    c~~
    ~I

    ~
    ~,~

    .~

    <rrnI <!I<fffi Geophysical


    ~I

    ~ t1~t'1\ff:1

    (~OOb-)
    ~

    1f~ '<JJ'f~ ~
    -f,f; ~Gr~?
    <ff ~~I

    Society-

    ~"1~!l.<i
    <£I~ ~~

    ~ ~-mw
    ,
    ~I
    ~

    <£101 9i'5ffi •

    NilPfllG
    1 ~

    CfI'<rWt ~

    9N~ '6 ~
    <£I~ ~

    ll~iIII9j ~
    ~

    ~ \5ff<fBl"
    '1roIT'

    '5TPf(S5
    ~

    (?: 1)-

    <m['frn ~

    (lA?

    iii ~
    ~N3m

    ~
    ~

    ~
    em

    5'ftSTt-~

    ~
    1

    9f1~I-~ ~

    '&I~

    l;f@ ~~

    Jj~"1i9f ~'~r
    ~

    W~

    ~fi1 ~9ftqj
    .~

    ~Wsi1-Pr~-~-~
    ~ ~'>i ~

    c~
    I

    9(tQ,1 '5Tr-msr 'ii.IT.\5t


    l5[lff~

    'f'irn <!I1'f'1" em ~

    ~
    \51~ ~ Cl'm ~
    ~~Uffi

    ><f1\Z
    ~ C~ ~

    m~
    ~

    <T1?

    'N.~If9f1'i~
    <jl:gj(.'>!J ~

    i5Rf~ '5T-~ 21m ~ ~ I C"l<r ~,


    ~),

    m.,( ~
    ~
    ~

    iIM
    C<!

    ~
    ~-~

    ~'Wit> M\'21Rh

    '8lii, ~

    [9\00 ('1RiIII9f'5T,I'1\5ffi~<'f~~

    de facto ~
    ~WIi

    ~1:fllffi I' <!I~ ~

    fu"tn

    Ilf.~

    w:F<r «@ ~ 1 ~ ~ '8<,>ffi ~ : 159f~ ejf0M~fA1 ~ \5Tt1" ~ ~


    I~ ~ ~

    '&!~

    M\'21R1~ <rrt'<lJm~
    ~ ~

    m~'-~~I ~~ -$ZPRi,_Q~
    8[ ~ ~)'f~

    \'!1rmn~K1-m~
    GI"1:'>1 ~

    C'*1~o:rt - ~

    1P'I~r ~I
    ..!l~

    Abstract Expren ion ist ~ '51Br 159f~-l1"'(~-~f\bM'.\lUi !


    8--<!1"?r ~
    ~ ~ ~ ~ ~I

    Paintings
    ~ ~ ..-"
    ~~

    c~,
    ~

    i58r ~ NGO, ~
    ~~'8

    I~

    ~'8
    1~

    <£I~t, <!,~'8

    <it

    "$:"1 ~

    ~ "1~
    ~

    Jj~w31{:1 'llj-';iUel ~

    ~I ~

    <!I1R~ ~ ~ ~
    ~,

    <£I<;P "1~

    ~~

    ~~ N@-@ <!iFf, '~

    "?rtfj ~
    ~ ~

    G~~

    '>j<3\P'I'41ft1'-C'Rf

    9ffill:~
    ~(~)
    @lJl.~!

    9ft'Bm C~

    ~~~
    <£I 0fI~

    'Wf~ ~
    ~

    C<P ~
    C?fiZ
    ~

    mf~?
    ~

    ~'l[il
    G~~

    Cl'm @?~,
    <Q<fl~

    c!l.,-R
    I;>

    AK47 ~
    ~~ I

    \'5roft<Er ~
    1 ~-~

    \~)IFrl1 ~ ~I
    QJ (Fl"li <!l~

    m
    ~

    '-;rN3~'

    mL'*!

    orr

    'B ~ <EW-cf[ I~-

    <flQJII "P!:~:?l"-~moo

    8l~ <£I @f~

    "Gi'51"fC"i mM C'\>[(31\0:("11 <rfC~'5jf?f


    ~

    1 Yb- ~

    'm<flr
    1Jt~N3

    'ff1T I C<flt~

    9f1t<f ~
    <!<l~

    ~ \5T1\?T

    MBBS CQJl:4 "1<r~

    OJ'I<I ~
    @'f~ ~ ~

    <rr.:R~ ~,
    1~

    Gi"'f ~

    (m-<{l<fRf-~-Jfflf.'l)
    C'ffiJTI c£j<fl '&If1J
    (\5US (J5(iS I
    (/f \5R!Bf ~

    m
    ~

    -.:mm ~
    1 ~

    $Ii';? ~

    "101 C~
    1<!<l<if1-1J ~
    1 ~
    ~

    if.'I"rrn ~
    ~@ ~
    ~I
    '<~

    Nc<:r ~
    ~
    ~ ~

    W-W
    '<rn'¥ "-Bf-

    'B ~-"l1~

    ~Uffi"?r

    ~'B
    \5f@ ~~

    <!lti'8

    ~:1)~iBt-~"'flg"{J1"1 ~
    ~ ~

    1"fl'i5lSfl 'Ern ~
    ~
    ~

    "1m ~

    1 c.£!~

    m~
    '"ti1f:1~~~

    0fG1TM IS'M) ~~
    ~
    (F1~.

    I o;:j~~

    I iSt5f"1"I~@1 ~
    ~ ~~

    '5R-~ ~9fI<fi

    mI... ~

    'OW, ~

    ~~

    ~ '5Q.~

    ~I

    ?fl~
    '5f-'5 I

    <£I .~

    fP%f ~~
    ~~~·l'll

    ~
    "1~, ~~

    'bll>jC~<i, ~

    \5Ui"t>I\9·t CP;~

    Wi0tW! ... ~. ~

    r~

    ~~

    CG~;;

    ~~

    I '5TRf~

    Ri<!l ~
    ~ ~

    (~~.~.f<I:<rG!

    I "f..tr;r1ffl

    <it ~

    ) 'b j'5j'lf.(

    ~)<mr1

    ~ ~

    <rf'{3m I"
    ~
    ~'8f

    ~ Nrrr C~ 1~ (}1\!3m ~, \!5Irn~,


    ~f ~ ~

    "~
    ~ ~

    (pfqf

    x~ ~
    «(1..9'1'1

    C'<Wfi m1-~

    ~~?ff[9f

    <Wfrn ~
    ~

    '8 \5l1\jl1'l~F1<t>

    1itil
    <;jJt~lGi('\!l <il$f ~

    C'1~Vi>
    0~

    I~
    ~

    "'Ff1 ~

    C"'f1Bt ~

    c!lt<f> ~
    I ~~
    ~oo9.

    P;;(~I(~"'1 I ~~

    m9f ~I
    ~ 1

    'JtGi '111 c<fi01 WI ~


    <il"T\!l ~

    rfi<;fjq",

    m-$f

    <Jl i"l'* Cll '!1 \9 GtP.W1Sl 1>QJI ~ C~ '3r! <rrr~ ~::>fI'3~ ~'~~
    1 ~ ~

    ~\5ftGJl~~~9f\5J,~~"fl~~~~-~

    ~
    ~
    ~

    r.~1
    R"1 ~
    <il$f

    'i5R~
    (]f<1 W1$f

    ~
    ~~

    ~<IJ 1?W5fiS'iR!
    <J~

    c:~
    <I'~

    \"j~~

    ~<JfG<f!

    ~
    C~
    ~ ~

    <TIi?fti.f ~,
    ~, \!l~j;j ~

    <il~ ~ ~

    C!M ~

    ~~
    <ilOO ~~ ~ I
    ~~

    '$b11b~ ~ c£l\5f~
    <il~

    f.Trn

    ~
    ~
    <!['i)J ~ -!l<t>

    ~
    ;;:rn,
    \!ll$f ~ ~! ~~

    fi1I<t>
    (pf~

    '~j-~$f 9f <t>Q,~ ~

    f.1l>!~, "11 fl
    '5f@ -

    '5f11Btt

    '5f8f

    ~-(pf~

    Wl'qf

    cm~~
    C~
    ~

    ~"Mit
    I c<P'l<f ~
    1

    M6'lIi1lot'!1 (c!l~

    <r~

    <rrn ~?)
    MC%JGt![<'1, c!l~

    'ft-5:ft@l~ ~

    ~~

    Q71"<JB.r ~

    :!lC~Jt:<!'$1~

    illWTl't
    ~

    1,,\S.'j~11
    ~ ~

    uWtJ'11(!'IC<I

    'W!i

    ~,
    ~~
    \!ll$f

    '3~ <rf\¥@ iSRI <frnl1ffiiT,~

    ~
    ~

    ·~l[I9tC"'1~<t> I \5\.<f C<J ~ QX<r c!l~ -

    9ff~ "<fj.QJl ~

    $I11St4lNt(,<t> ~1

    f5R-~, ~

    ft";r, ~

    'Tl'SJ Real Politic I

    ~<fl

    ~~~\ ~~ ~ ~9\ m:r ~.,


    - --~fu>re'B~mmiffl,,-m~
    -: ~ ~9j'1umOlTtl ~ ~ ~ D1 ~ ~ Co/f ~~! ~ ~9j, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    Mf1CI3'~~,
    ~I

    ~~GfIR,
    ~~ I \5(\3<fl-;q~ <flD11Wf ~ ~ ~~ ~
    ~

    c'\Iv.J~Pf~~~~~~~
    ~
    ~

    ~1)11C'G'~ ~ 9frlf'~

    _ -; ~ ~,~
    ~ <".'

    f11.'?>;ij~11I \5l~WHl <fl~ ~1'21Silfib<t'


    '<J@

    :"'~<p ~!Q,~rr;r Xf1"'t"'~


    ~

    ~fi;b~\bij

    =-"'~

    \')jfbeslO<1~ ~

    c'<K<fl <fl~ ~ ~ 0fCi'1 ~ ~ I

    ~~ ~
    ~

    ~I ~~
    : <gf ~

    ~fitq> "110(1C<11 I 'i5m ~

    ~
    '6ltG~

    ~ft~9jt<1"'l<J;t>il1 ~
    '>IT ~ <fCJ1 ~,

    <rrn
    ~fC1 ~
    ~
    (/i~

    ru r<1l[fil?l Gf1Q
    mWfIl ~

    I ~I)OjIU't1 <Q~

    ~F1~I~ <fl~

    ~.1~~
    ~9j-~9f

    Bur

    <fl(;ti
    >1~ZFi1
    OIT:~
    ~

    GWff(;\5\8 ~

    G'ftc'ii

    on ~'U ~ ~;

    '6! ~I O'nl R">I9M<f.iij

    ~9f~~

    I~

    f.TD1: >re$
    c<fClf ~ ~

    9ffv.Rf ~~

    ~
    '8~

    ~"1f.'" ~'?F ~

    I Uj~ ~

    fu

    \5lBf <fl<Wr "'l~~ ~

    ~pfis
    Uj~ ~

    <P\~

    15!1<tl101fi14> ~\ ~ ~ ~

    I ~'f

    ~~

    9ff~

    frlnr FIT;r ~
    ~ca;t ~

    *,-

    'itfnll
    ~ ~CJi1 -

    cq~IICG41 ~
    \!ffi'f~

    c<f.t'41'8 ~

    lfliQ <flM

    <rrn ~1);(Wt1 \5lIMJ4>ICG41 ~~

    m,<f19ff~~~~I~~~Uj~\5~~

    c-rn ~
    ~

    - fu~
    fitul<®$ ~
    05t ~
    ~m'Sl <rr9ff ~

    ~
    ~.9f

    "<fl~ ~ ~
    cQ~ ~

    <'f;r9\1 ~

    ~ ~
    c'<t[q>

    ~9fI ~
    <t»I G'ftc'if

    ~!

    on

    \!iB"~
    ~~?

    <fV'1,

    Uj~C'ff cQ~

    ffi ~,
    ~
    ~

    <fl~ ~?

    9ftM1'
    ~

    c~
    ~

    l' ~~.ft;

    UJUt ~
    ~

    1<1 <r»r <P\~


    ~r;lC~ -

    \5lt1" ~
    ~

    C'<K<fl~9f

    crrc<I C~

    ",I

    _~

    ::,b-

    /1!iT:lP(~)<rr~1
    ~!

    fi'A'Jj'
    <.!l~
    \G~

    m ~ :<i]:;qsrf<r<fl ~
    ~ ':iR1", ~
    <WI ~1?

    .mJPl/::' '"

    (~~

    ~~,~

    ~~

    ~I"

    Fm5r1 ~
    9ft~ ~
    ~?

    <jiCfJJ\')(ft'1 -15fl"r~

    ~
    D(',G1 ~

    ~
    ~~ '~<f[\5 ~

    f9!D-~
    :

    ~()~~C~~'~c:~,~~~~ '1~()i'1\')I01'51 DTC9f I

    ~ <.!l~lm ~

    tim;! \5fPf "<11f.'I


    O'lf~IC:;I'5I,

    <ffi'~ ~
    c!1~ ~,

    mre

    "<.!l'Q: ~I
    13~

    9ftW I "iIT, "iIT -

    f5:r
    ~
    c<1 I

    \5fPflf'<~

    <.!l'5lBr?

    ~
    ~

    ~\!i (<1'BlIH<1\CtBl

    9ftrn ~

    G'ff~

    <.!l~ 'H&1 c.'G1 '5

    ~'i

    ~ C\!itm ~

    <Tf \5f1T.I1i ?

    "'1ffi-C$Bf ~-~f!>1~\prr r.i<I<r ~? ~~ 0Drn '9f1TIPf DTC9f ~ "'-(I,?


    ('1,

    ~<ff<r CI31
    9f'1\5 -:Jf<[..£f
    /

    Jy ?fi'<Wf ~'>11~~
    <.!l':iR <1W ~
    (/11~

    <rFl1 ()'Sl?fA1~

    '" wrn~~ ~~
    9fl~

    C 'Iu

    """'~~

    <rt<rt ~

    I ~ 11l>~ ~ 11.,.1)

    ~~

    ~
    cfF!9fr

    iSJiG'fl ~
    I"

    ~
    ~

    @'8i9tlJ1 GR 9fl~~
    ~,
    ~<r\

    ~rn
    (green '¢11);1101'51 ,~

    "J1G'fl «'1 -

    <mf<rBr <.!l~

    9ftQ@,

    C~~

    <.!l<rf'51 ~

    ~
    I

    '&("'81" archi-

    9rl~~

    ...Oh Illy Holy Mother!

    I wish to witness

    your fragblasphemy our Nation

    05TIf\f3 ~ tecture) (\'Jl\')C1!'5I


    "Yj\SJ\')f'5I

    'i-wEt ~
    ~ ~

    fu l1\e ~ "Rnr 1@R ~

    urented body-parts
    ~
    '¢I"\!j~~

    ~~

    l'hat is nothing

    - the corporeals. .. alas, that's more than imagination. State ~ Sacred ~~ <.!l1?l ~ ~I (IRt5f ~

    <n~ ~
    ~ ~

    ~
    ~

    '~
    ~

    ~ m, <f'CGi
    Co'rn I" ffi9f ~ ~

    State is also said to be an imagination!

    c<m~ "l1? ~,
    Geography of

    i"'l'i'.1lEl1, ~

    <.!l~

    o:rt, <.!ltl
    "~

    tl~
    ~
    l~

    and <r~ 'Ife~


    I ~1i'1C"IC'G1

    ..."
    ~

    ~
    ~

    "TIl,

    fu
    ~
    ~

    'f'ffil "~"

    <l>~ I ~

    <rm ~~~ '!ilt~ ~


    ~ ~
    9ff$ ~

    <r'~~?

    ~1U:i~r ~
    ~ <l\\:!f ~
    C'Pl1 ~

    ~~? "i'G ~

    \5fF'I1~ ~

    \5lf~

    ~<fl
    ~~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    \G~

    ;:rn I" ~
    ~ ~

    <Tf

    Nrn f.to:r
    !;(rrt<r,

    '5[f?ff.j-

    ~
    G.T@r -

    \5l1R,

    '1ft qGr
    ~

    <r~"\5Bf ¥ WI'A ':ifm ~tFI1


    C~ <.!l~

    "'1f~ \5l19M1Sf ~
    ~ ~

    <lt~
    ~

    9ff~
    ~

    ~G:! <r~ I~ ~ ~ .~ ~ 05V1 ~


    ~~ <l\1iFr1~ '89f~ <fl~j ~ ~

    'iP'1 \5l"Hl\')C'if'L!1
    ~ ~
    ~

    orr, ~
    : <Q~

    ~
    W\~'?-l,
    Pi~If\W<1\1

    <ra.1

    I <.!l~ ~ ~~

    «j\fOT m-lSiL<iI\!J<1\

    05tr~
    ~

    \5'$1 ~ \5lf.i.$! ~

    <flMi "?T1">l!'~ ~
    ~ ~

    f.trn
    <Tf I \5B19~ c<J~ (~

    ·ro I c:<fl~
    ~CGi ~
    ~81 ~

    1'-f ~
    1J:<r ~~
    \S® ~

    cQ~,

    I" <.!l<j\f<jWr

    c<J>f!l.1rn' c<.R

    '~~?

    cfI<!i\(ij ~

    "PIViC11, <flm ~
    '¢11Vf ~ ~~,

    15rf<lsur ~ ~ (%Pf.i fu ~ ~ ~ \5i'1(j'ffi ~

    -wm ~
    ~

    <.!l'<lS ~"irn ~~,

    C"Ilf

    \5l1~j\')0f'1!I1 ~
    ~9f(;~

    \5fi{l\')0f'L!11;1

    !ill"'l'~
    'Itij~,

    \5f~\Prn ~~~\5.j~\Prn

    ~\fS1

    \51'\l<j1Jt ~,
    ~

    "?!t:iT9~,
    ~j*'I!PI<n.f.'jI<t>t!i ~

    \WIT ?fIQfi, \5fQj<TI c<J~

    (Q[[<$ ~

    ~-

    ~~W<1J,

    ~~

    I ~f<f;-~~~
    \5P.'r-<m] ~

    '''''l'l; ~ <.!l~
    <f£@ ~

    o:rt ~
    ~~

    : c<m~ (~~
    iSf~ ..-I" ;;rj,<.!l~~~~~?~\~~~~

    ~rn

    ~-9fI~? ~

    (~r.~ lJ¢i ~:
    YfIQfi ~ \Y'~
    3~1 ~

    o;ifu I m~ <ra.1, "~


    <Q~ ~

    ~'>i

    ~
    I <fl<Wt ~

    ~
    ~ ~ ~~

    <!l@

    '<lS1'1Pli \?l~~;
    '¢11"?T <.!l<r'Gi AA ~

    '5lBf ~<r'Gi ~ c:<Pf1""(; I ~

    ~\fS"5I' (~ I

    ~~Jf{C'1 c~

    "1Br<1 C<1\R f.<IS'R

    '11~

    \5M3~;
    ~(31' ~

    <il<rtt ~
    ~f
    ~

    ~I
    ~

    \5l1"?T <.!l~

    (~~

    ~
    I"

    <f.19ft ~

    'iSlOO, '~

    ~,

    ~
    ~

    ... I"

    9ft@~~9(11f1f¥5G~ ~, ~ C<t>'1ci'jJJ11!1 ~
    ~? '~"

    ~~~I 2f81I~(fl ~ ~

    ('<It<1\~, ,q?( 'IfI<lJ ~

    <l\mt?
    ~M\')ci'jr,

    "'{3m" -wrm? -H-Dr 1M

    '5I1<ic.\!i~~,

    ~, "li <fC9 ~
    ~ t" ~

    f.to:r~)

    ''oa't <.!l~

    \5f~

    ~'SJt(:<j\

    f<tS ~

    <.!l~ ~9(1~8C$[Cci'j

    C'fi\S'~,

    «\(ffiI, ~,

    f.?a;r ~ <rm f<l;? "9fl9f, 9fl9f -

    <!1R> 9ft9f -

    ''f~J'j~~8tC11~~~~?~\'ifoU~~?

    ~ 0 1'5I"j'l{~)~

    f.'Pl9{ f.TrA ~
    'l5[q3Fl ,~~ ~

    :; ,!:r;f1f~~
    1 (J( ~~,

    $Pf/ ~~
    dJ ~

    ~
    ~'1 ~ ~

    C"fRI,
    ~~

    <!I~ lBfro"tr$J GlT~f.01

    @~!

    >!ll~~~

    ~?

    \5l.:;urik~ 4l"l¥OF'l
    -~

    ~~mr
    C~ 8R ~

    1 <!I~r.ai1 ~?

    Q,f1"<P 9f't~
    \5pf\~

    ;mo---<p~
    ~:q>~

    \51Na011G ~
    ~Q,n ~ ~
    ~fiSr~ ~'>"'I 'llf

    ~~

    :'Cil'1.<i>-<Q<:f

    1IZl$J<tS~<''''ffl ~ '1~

    2jfu~[;~.'b1"1(;Bl ~

    <r>Q(t ~
    ~~7.1
    ~~?

    I ... <!l~

    ~.c<r

    \5lT<rrn :i'1'lustCG ~ __ cfl~


    ~

    01fu1:! ~

    ~ ...I!l~U7f1 ~?

    ,.,W1 ~
    ><tf1r<f> ~ <!I~ <rt.Gi ~

    (Czt;:r C151~1);Q~ c:G"rn


    1

    '51m"ii1'it

    Null
    ~

    iflt81- ~
    \5I1?f

    ~,

    <Q~U7f1 ~ CQ,[T.<f> 1 ~?f


    ~

    C'f.910.f5 "'"~
    ~ ~

    00 ~
    <l'Bf, ~~
    '@9f~

    ~f<rtl;f ~

    \5j<p1~1 \5l(~;;rt

    <fiT.1" ~~

    Frv:! ~ ~
    <p@ ~,

    ";Q<ffi:I\5ff@1
    ~U7f1

    fficiJ(.G'f'Jl ~

    ~'{J

    9J"Pl ~?
    <ftpf, ~

    cfr

    0FP!f~-PT~
    <IIiOO, '~,

    C$l

    051~
    ~

    1Sffiti.1'l'j
    \S!1'l1'5

    \5f1~

    ~~"ll ~
    (pJ ~
    ~

    *~ ~
    ~

    firW10!1
    ~
    ~

    'Of.if~1i1 ~
    ~<n~~~~~?"
    ~~,

    '>"'1m, ~
    t!l)l7f ~

    ~
    ~~~

    r.~ ~\~
    c<r~
    ~~I

    ~,

    D@M 7.1N (-m9fm)

    wwtl (~)

    01 ~
    (F!1,

    i@'f1

    ~ ... ~
    ~
    (,57J[

    ~rm ~
    ~ CIf<! ~
    I I"

    ~
    mV1 <Q~

    <rftWl" ~

    (pJ

    ~
    ~

    ~'<f

    lJf<1St orTr."ft
    <Ii ~
    ~ :~

    ~\Sf'i[}F1

    '~~m~~
    m-c;{ ~

    Rol ~
    ;;rt ~

    cQj"«tS i.!l~
    :

    Null Worker I!ifrn \!lI<Bl<l~<l


    I!l~

    ()1.;<tSCG1?1 C<i'elL,&~ ~ I!lWs ~ ~

    9ftf<f

    r~ ~-~
    ~-~ ~ ~

    I!l~ I <fl"<I\

    \:Jl \5I(~<ql'i:;1<.!1~
    ~ CQfC<I> ~

    m~ m ~
    r;~ C11'<f ~
    ~~, J:fr@1C8i1 ~ $1\5 "1<;51~$1~ ~, ~

    ~m
    ~
    ·~I(.~

    '$f~G'f17.9f$l <i><l CGlIlG

    ~
    ~ >It('$l<ll~ ~
    ~

    ~l5(lt~<tS~
    I <Q~Q,fl~~~

    ~ ~

    cml!!> ~
    C~

    c<P~

    ~-~
    <Q~ ~

    GDP-GNP-~ 1'f\~ 'Tt~ dlm I" ~


    CDC'>"'I ~
    ~ ~"? ~

    ~"'?11C8i1 1!1~

    ~~, ~
    1

    <lW.~

    WGi

    0IT3f <J1$I, ~

    ''mL<1, ~
    -mt1J~
    ~1@

    ~
    ~

    ~105
    ~

    Null Worker~ 'i"ff'l c'ii81 '!3~, '~

    Disembodied
    ~ • ~

    ~nm~~?
    ~

    <!I~

    <mT \5f1t5T "It ...H011f'{3 <rt.Gi, "dJ~ ~. ~, ~,

    'fl"~~

    trt@ C~

    c$ <Q~:q>'<I8f

    'i~ ~
    ~ ~ ~

    ~~tl:i@I'
    ~~

    ~,

    ~
    ~
    ~ ~

    ~N<tS('t1 9fW't 'fC>I ~ ~ I~ M8f ~ ~ ~1\5 C<.[«tS ml\$W'fl ~ ~ ~, \5'<f'l" 9fTt"f <Pff ~ <!I~
    <1>Q,fl '~"

    '5ltSlIUHl ~~

    crw:m ~
    ~

    'm:"1 ~I"
    ~
    ~?l '1.~

    fifrn

    m
    -

    \5l1)jICq?,l ~

    $~~ 9f1r"t ~ W<Rf


    <!I~

    ~ 1 <!l~
    <fSl"3r ~

    \5~"'lj>'11~~

    C~ ~

    \51i@j ~

    '5ffi:'>B1" <!l<Wr
    <!I<!$ ~

    I fu 'fG~
    '{3'J>8f 'fj'8[ ~

    I~
    '{3~

    W~
    ~Qf ~

    <jiqrn ~
    ~
    \5~

    ~
    <!l~ ~ (7f ~
    ~ ~

    CiT@ <r(i7[, "<Q~

    ~'11~
    <Q~

    ~
    ~~

    mm
    ~
    1

    <:[l!l11 ~
    ~ I~

    :~
    ~~

    <@tR11iJ1

    G'f "'"~ -

    c~

    wr -

    I"
    ~ ~ I I

    ~<tSmpml<l1
    ~

    C<tS~?
    ~"'""af

    ~~>ll11(J11'5l~~~~I(7fot9ff~~

    vrtFt, ~
    ~

    ""1C<l 9f't9fG1"<fCG1
    ~ ~ ~

    c<ffirGr ~~
    ~
    '~"!

    ~
    ~
    '~

    ejQjV:j" ~

    ~~~~Jf-TIJVl~~9f'tQBf~~IT;<'f<fiiiSf 1 f@!CG4$'l

    ~Qf

    osr.<f <1V! ~ C<ftt~


    ~'1

    I ~,

    9f@

    1~<lI~(~r

    1!1P1 \!lM ~

    <Mfu Of ~
    ~f~?

    c~

    ~
    ~

    ~,
    "~"
    1...

    :~
    ~

    -uWr~
    ~, ~

    "1"fmli ~ C\5Ult N<7f


    ~ ~

    <r~ ~,

    ~
    I "S.1T(;1

    <em ~

    051~

    Rr<l'M"

    '~9J1~"

    ~~'R

    RGr

    ~@T ~

    ~1T.'&'G~

    .n11'fm'.2f ~

    -<-</~(~)<n;m ~
    ~

    f;M.,f

    m~
    1.5R11'1Cm ..

    ,~<J>1f'f'l$11~

    ~/-<~
    ~
    113

    tP'ft<l> ~
    I" \5Br<.>M! <f~~

    '~"fl'" ~
    "~C\)

    o:rt I 113-m<:1 ~ru

    ~~

    <W1 ~

    '~I"lf~ "'1" 0\Ff

    \S~

    ot<f.~

    "$j\~

    ~
    ~\~
    1 ~MJ
    <.!l<l"

    <!I~f(Jl1I3 -

    <mr, ~
    ~,

    <=mTRvJ ~
    ~ C\)"I C\)-<!I~

    ~
    <r>Mr?ff~, '5foTJ '¢[Q)<Ii
    ~

    ~1I.!~1I3 ~ 1'11".\5
    ?\"f$1<i"

    1 <r>""WfI~

    ~
    ~

    tilW1 .~"i"1

    8ft"! 0.1111

    <rrn \5l'i*'li

    ul>R
    ~
    ~

    <rrJi'T "57?1,

    it (;J~~

    rn

    (Q[1'"

    <'f5?>1ii1\l1li1<:fi ~

    .~<"[ "1~

    7fM,
    ~
    •

    • c!J1''<lt ~'i i11<ftt ~-..r~ ~


    1

    C~

    ~dl ~ 0 [oo-s: 1'Pf~, <fl?Jql'fta ~<i\ <!r '¢[~~

    'r'l1l C~
    \5T@1-.:r[o'! }If~<:' (?) ~ 1('11f<W'B ~

    ~
    ~ ~,
    .Q""~

    c5t~
    -rl ~
    ~ <rI 9f~ ~

    1'1 ~~

    9f@

    1f~~

    <£lJf<T

    ~ m.o:l
    ~

    ~rf<f, ~,
    m'G

    '1~~~F'1ffi

    1<1 ~

    9ffPt, i3Bf ~

    "%11 I5wt> 1,
    1~

    ~OOIr-~~

    'l!tJ<U',{CdJ1 ~

    ~-.n
    ESI-~

    .Q<!>~ ~-.m:l-

    f.i!; "1~ \511'TI ~?


    ~ ml ~ ~

    4f~
    ~

    ~ 7f'f.

    ~~

    "<l">@'G,

    C!2ll:1' c<!'R

    ~~
    '¢[~

    \S "1'~(.'lH<il

    PF-Gratuity-~,
    1~

    ~-~,

    '11- s:)'GIM11 ~
    ~~ ~ i5ffi:,,!

    ~
    ~ ~

    :i19f~~ '11b~?

    C~ ~

    9fl~~

    <it <f>1WlBf
    113 ~

    m~DiFl
    '1i'\ ~
    <MlSi ~

    CYffim ~,

    cm ~

    t~ si-n

    <Jf.tt
    ~

    \$f-~~f;1>'3 ~

    ro Nn:r ~
    <!I~ ~ m.o:l ~
    1

    mQrrf9~ ~
    '~'{3

    ~"'"!fu;
    ~

    C~ \'iH:~<'f5fi1'l
    ~

    <!1~ \51~~? "<i'rnl ~,;:r;:!,

    <mJ '5Bf ~
    1

    "I~r.'>11519fj9fWt ~

    <5l:Q.)<ff Q,@ ~

    Vrrt9fWIT ~
    CAfit 1

    \'I~

    <!W

    Gr9fmm"<fCG1

    C"R~I

    ~ IJ<WtlC11t

    ~
    113m ~

    Null Worker~~ ~~ c<T1I3~G'fM1 ~ I'lJ.fWHI ~ 9frr:; 'StI'i8f .!I<r> \Stt'i'8M <r»r C9fBI
    11@1 'q~

    om
    "f~
    11l'G~

    I~
    ~-~

    ~ct
    ~
    ~~

    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~\}@

    ~/ 8 ~'11 <Rrrn 1 ~
    <fiii;T I
    ~ 'ijltmf

    ~
    9jLQ,! ~

    ~?

    <fill" <!I.,s ~

    ~ ~ ~

    C'6\'5r.M 1~

    ~cG'11l.15
    (I5t ~

    cifJ;
    9\1'<1Sl

    ~GlR~
    21~

    f.trn 'Rtal ~
    ~

    <rm ... "

    ~
    \i)~

    ~
    9j~ ~

    0i1m 1
    <:f'~
    ~

    9fFi~

    'lf~,14'ti 9lt?f
    '.)~~ 9fjQ.J"?l" ~

    Q$!(fl~<fJ:1

    '5Bf "IDPf ~
    ~ ~I
    00 ~

    jJ~~"f,

    'm"-tm ~
    ~1.<!1~ C9f\3 I

    ~r,\5~~<!1~QjG1I<!1"1'<!I~fGWl~
    ~

    )Q/~o

    GR?
    ~

    CQ[t<!l" ~ ~

    W ~ 'iJf:rt ~
    ~ r{11

    - '1~ ~
    ~ ()j[<f ~

    ~<rJ <rt <rt ~ ~

    '¢[~

    c.<J ~
    \90

    W\Ff
    1&'&11'(@

    :1'Jt"i[ 113 ~oo ~

    <!1":lfil" ~

    ~~-~~;:HII~~~~~i.l1tG I~

    ~"1~~~~~-~~~'C~9f"til

    ~<rJ ~
    ~lTRr <1i?) ~~ ~
    <£l~

    XfGT'\"1 ~
    ~
    'G~

    (A~

    OTWfS<l11<fcC11(3jU,\ ~~

    l"i5l"~

    c<I ~

    :Et~~~

    ~~I

    ~~m
    sand-filling ~
    M"l1l1Sl_1\S~
    ~ ~ <£l'lR -

    ~o:rt
    ~

    (€Plt

    <H)",

    "r~lm"
    II'~ _

    ~
    ~~

    C1"'l? c<Fl

    'Abandoned'
    \1:10

    <5!BI ~ I 9f1~ ~~ ~ ~ <prIOl cm~'i ~ astharna - ~1Cl'l~f>tJ1


    ~ ~ ~ <!l~ '¥.ii1~ra; O'R I ~
    (}K<R L!I~ ~ ~ ~
    \i)~

    mt'$1~rnn,I5~~~~~~~~1 C~ b-o 'i51m ~


    ~~, -~,
    Q1 ~ ~

    r.1rr.~ ~
    I,I,~

    1~
    ~~

    oro <!>"1iC'flI~, 'l'~


    ~ ~? ~ CMlii1~~

    <n ~1~
    <£l":lR ~I

    ~ (\)9. '!)-<.Q~ <fl'<l1

    9fW11 C~ ~1@l~l'?lct! ~ ~ ~-

    ro<r
    ~

    I <!I~ ~

    J11<1J'?S ~
    191\1'1~ ~

    <fl11 ~
    ~ I~ CQj""«fl ~

    cmc'>h1"~ Tm~ ~
    ~
    C"'~

    8ltt'iBl ~

    \$1 ~

    O'R -

    I'}[~~ ~ ~~
    "Il~
    ~I~"<R

    PlfGiC1'IP1~ ~

    ~
    ~I

    031 ~
    <.flJf<f

    1f$ ''f«~' <n 9f1~


    1

    f.t8r ~

    '11 F<wtifi01?l JiC4fC~fl ~

    ~?

    oo:'f ~ ~

    "f~
    I}t;~.,s!<lt

    1o/f"
    ~

    m~ ~
    ~

    ''fit<£''

    orr ~~

    '!)'l,

    "1<!l'Gi 191CW'Gtfu

    -~~lf.~~!~~~~

    <mx 151\~lC"l?l1 ~",~.({-C\5

    <'f5~~Ciilf'\

    ':"8/~("1)<mrt ~~ D'R'8~~~:

    f.;p:jo;f f;rGI ~ Wait Until Death,.~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    <fl<Plf~ ~

    $.Wl/~&

    cl5t!I!i'(Xl~$lrn
    ~~I

    ~ilftr.11519jl

    ~
    Gff~ ~

    ~~ PiMc<l>t~CJi~ M<I>rn mWl:(.i>I~ 'ffdF1)lfiI.,~! I D1~


    ~Wi(,1'IPPI ~
    GI1.,>!~

    f~

    em'>! I"
    ~
    ~ I ~~~

    'TIlIm I ~
    I ~~

    ~Oj:
    :;1~Y."1 ~ ~<1~"

    NG! ~

    I~ <n "<fWff" ~

    ~n:rr

    '(['1J! ~
    I ~~ ~~-\£l~
    I ~~

    %lie'"
    ~"f

    C~

    o:rt ~

    <it ~
    ~ ~

    c-<fi'R 151m!
    0Wf <!TIl I ~

    ~1J.'ft
    ~-~
    I~
    ''1,jg

    00

    \£lfflJ'jg

    ~GPfI~,
    cQ<fi ~';;/~~ ~

    ''lI'f ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    cQlA

    'G~-q{ ~ / ~ ~

    ":8f~,

    I <.£j~7P1nf

    Jt~ ~
    ~ ~~

    -f.luI ~
    ~

    •
    O1'Bm ~

    9fG'1m~
    ~9(rn ~

    181c:wlJIBlCI!l cQlTR

    ~<l\"I'1r~

    ~ ~ ~

    VI om I ~ ~
    <J>G11 <fl"1"~~

    jJ(~

    _III ~9fr~~~

    c<P1~ 8!~<.£jV1~) iffi1c.G?I~ ~, ~~


    ~
    ~ ~

    1!l1<?1 Gl'R

    ~
    ~
    ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
    <.p@?

    ~
    C'1t~

    ~
    ~
    ~9f>lj>

    ~ICW11?1 ~

    c<I"R ~~9 ~ f<t;? ~ '1i I ~ on cG~\!?c'q~mQ COI*l61.,C1'<fI 41 ?1'i! UBI \!iP1\'<1J


    I <fl~ ~ ~~

    <mr

    I 9fr~

    Pl~~1
    ~

    ~1!51
    81, ~ ~

    -d~ ~
    <£l~ ~

    1m&1N<i <.£j~ ~

    l~
    (, <f~,

    c<llm
    ~

    j)1L&11!l'IR I!l<fi ~
    ~ <!lGi ~

    CWfrI ~~"f <fl~ OTt ~ ~


    ~ ~~, '{3~,

    '1i I 0t~
    ~ ~ ~ ~
    !~ ~. \'if ~l\2S1Uil'ljJ

    I <fl <.£j<fi '>li~-~ c

    Gft~,
    ~

    [GP ~

    ~t'IJ! I \31 <fl~

    <fl~

    em'>! ~

    ~1WIt ~
    ~~

    m,

    CJiI:<fl <:fI1J••.

    lfl'PW11-l \31 cQ<Trn ~

    ~ll '>fV5

    ~r-fr
    ~'i'frn

    C~I1C1&1I~DtFI~~~-\£l~~~1 9fr~

    ~TWrn cQ1Jl1 ~

    <ri't'Rl ~

    11C$!fV'1t 9fr~

    ''fitoo'' ~
    fu-~.,8Pi~

    ~
    ~

    "~"
    I \3~

    m f<t;

    9j'<}3M_~~~~,~'!lo/8om~'{3~I~0fG~

    .~1mt 9J1~ I \5!t?I ~

    c~
    8/
    <?; ~

    ~
    *fij I ~

    C~

    ~
    ~

    c<P1~'2
    ~

    ~~~

    r:~ ~
    'O~ ~~~

    ~~,

    C'5t

    ()ffif1"1 ~

    ,o/'!lO

    I W8f

    <!>,$lCG?1 ~

    ~
    ~

    <ifr-~
    c~rr.iUr;lJi:r ~

    "\5 (jj 1?Ff"

    ~ M1> f1~C:il(,"1-l ~ lfl'lf<r ~ ~ <t>@ ;;rtf<!;! 15l~f\S{G ~


    ~ ~ C~

    c<Pdi
    ~1J.'ft
    ~? ~~-~

    (.~

    qt~

    m~
    ~~
    "'{3~

    ~
    rrI
    ~

    9fffi~ ~
    I

    m <.£j~
    <BI

    115("?l"~ ~

    ..!r <r11i51

    <nk"3fI~I<flblQ
    ~?

    M'%hWt?1 ~
    ~

    (.1"!J':f.1(AU1~T.i7f1 ~

    (\5l1<1\5llrro

    ~.,Rr>oH:;) c~ om ~
    C'lfc1! '8~

    <fl otvrl ~

    ott, ~
    ~C1l C~ ~15~
    '8~

    N?'
    '{3~

    ~JI(j1\SfI?l~,
    ~ 161;1 CGi ~

    C5t, ~
    ~

    00i
    f.tr.";q
    9f~

    ~ rer ~
    ~~lf@C~~~~!

    ~fij5j~lij1j ~

    <fl'1"~ '!l(t-'!l9. "~" ~

    on

    c!l<fi1fi( I" ~

    '~TIt15

    ~~~? I"

    ~9\H1MC~a>1 ~~G'flO!tt~ ~ ~ 8!~,"Gi I~

    1.!iI"i~
    ~

    c!I<mf ~~
    <1S~ ~

    Wrn -~ rn~
    <£l~

    ~Nrn~
    I <.£j~ CDI~ ~

    _ ~_~

    <l1\~ ~ ~'>Ii -

    WI ~~~
    ~9{t~

    ~
    ~ ~\.C'if1
    <¢Ii~

    ~
    ~
    <l>Qjl

    '51)IQ1OICZYIM<fl G1iI"f I ~ eI&1<flill~,

    Nrn ~~
    ~

    '1m ~
    _ c<r~
    Q)~

    <fi!<l1, -R\SFBII., ~Hi'~fit~ ~l!lqlJi(lH <7!~, <7!~

    ~, ~
    w<l'
    ~ ~?

    1l1uJ Df~

    No:r ~~,
    QJl ~

    0Tt~
    I~

    Nrn Dt~~,
    cQ~ ~

    1lw.:r ~~~,
    <r>~ I~
    CJi

    c~ ~
    ~~.

    *-~ ~
    ~9fr~, ~ I...~~

    \3tm ~
    ~ ~ ~

    <mJ rrli <.£j~ <.£j<fi'51~~


    cqxf-<m"f.1I!l~ 'ff~ ~ ~ '~"\PR!" <.£j~~ ~

    fi ~
    ~
    ~~,

    ~9fG1
    ~
    \5~~

    ~ What is literature I \5l1:iJ1O'i10qiSSlf.1<fl ~ <.£j~ ~


    ~

    wt:1:fl

    f3!. '1 9.';; \5l'l'f

    ~oob--<!l~

    mI
    ~ ~

    <m~ c~

    ~
    <.£j~

    Mrn wrr:G ~
    U1~ ~ r'ii~

    ~H!1M<11~ \5l"rn ~

    : "~

    ~~I~ ~

    ~ ~

    m~

    <7fI'"ifICrrI ~ ~ ~

    ~'1
    <1Stf.1 ~~

    <!1m ~
    ~

    \£l~

    I C51~ <m$li ~

    Cb1~ I~

    fIl1$ ~

    :"~/'5!"It'(~)<rRrf
    ~ GI~~"<fj

    Wlo;{
    "5f""l~ 9fi@" " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    IDT ~
    ~,
    .~

    : <!l"Ptf<f<P
    J ",,,,b-~

    ~I
    C:~SF$llro

    ~~
    .:rtV1
    \G

    '3 Hl161C<l'!1y~1!)
    .ri!f8:l9J?f
    GI ~ I~~_

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~,

    CJl~1'I8 <flti5T ~~

    \!l!1'fJim

    ~m,~ ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ <!l$f -vrn ~9fi~ "5f~J'fSf


    "~" ~ ~ '{3~ ~

    iEMT ~

    9f~\G firow ~Br 9~ fi$r(.&jfl;;:r W <IT ~~


    ~ ~

    [jm."1C~(~
    ~I~ ~ ~
    ',lrV?(, >I'~

    mF~
    ~;

    <flti5T
    ~$

    mrJ~ ~
    c<f.R

    c<fi? \5fIT."! ~~

    ~RW~
    9fC'"l' ~

    m~

    ~) ~

    ~
    \G

    ~~rrM "lSlfdic<t>lPPi"

    c<T>~ ~

    C"l~ ~~-cfl~~~

    11SiTITstI

    J'fI<J> ~

    ~?

    \5lBr
    ~

    'e:;r[

    C\5T ~

    <r.t~f.t)HI

    <n1" I 'l3t~

    ~~~~C~-;jl~1

    R>~
    ~ 8

    <!l~
    0~

    ~~
    8/C!
    '{3~

    I ~~-,~a
    ~

    w.:u eM C!
    ~ ~ ~

    );I~f.'"

    w? mfG' <rf'GT 'B J'ff<F ~


    0

    ~
    ~ ~ I ~~ i/rotG'fl _
    '!JI£

    'm<r.11 ~
    ~

    fuWI, <Rrrr

    'if.!\b<t>hFr I ~"l ~TfCQ1!\bM\S'; "<fj1r-r.;[ ~ \$~ ~ ">jC~!i:i8Fl<t>" ~Grn ~ '-fI<;f~.£lT7r "leading to .illenation of the tribal population in the neighbourhood." cflW. f.\51 $ "<P~, ~ (Xil <W1i ~ I ~I:g I!t1i Qf'l, <!l~ ~ ~,'(~

    c<T ~4,
    ~o/'!Jo

    o=r
    ~

    9Jt@ <TIl

    WFG\--<Jl~ ~
    1£0 ~

    ~t"'!11? c<TJ1<f~'f<Wft~~,

    ~-~-~~c4m
    ~ ~

    mm

    9f1~~ ~oo TCFI~)

    8/1£

    9fiQ{@~"l\5

    I <!l~

    '>iff$ (~
    ~

    9fi~
    I~

    ~.

    f1>'~ srPt
    !il~~@

    ifo1?
    <fCG1.£l~ ~

    on I ~~
    ~~

    ~ \5I"'lIM~r~
    ~

    ~~

    ~~

    0fi? .,~ ~
    ~ ~/~

    C'!J~ <Rfi <m11 ~~cJj·)jF<f~).,~


    <.pm ~

    I ~~

    ~\Gm<mm
    ~ I \5Tffi

    (p'fj'i5 <f.@ ~

    QJWli «] '\ WI ~
    ~

    1.:lB"?8r D'I

    ~'1't
    ~

    '\ <IRf ~ iBM \5T-;;ff'~ GI~

    «ole« ~
    ~ <:flC<-R" I
    I~ I ~

    I~ ~

    ~rt\Y!m ~

    \5ffif ~ -~
    ~~ ~I

    ~
    ~

    .£l:r~ ~

    c<rm~ C"11T ~

    (~-)

    ~
    Q1~

    ~
    ~

    ,-rf1r<t> xP.fur
    ~ .:11~ ~
    ).)q~1

    'tpf('.\'?-~

    c<rfif.T~,

    ~ <flWft~ rrr \5TrfiT<lr>n ~ ~'1J


    5?Pf C~ c'<f'i5 I <!l~ C¢i ~,
    ~~~~~~~~~,~~

    '5!~tffir ~

    ~\Sm ~ ~
    ~ ~
    \5ffi:'lf'G ~

    ~~mc~

    <fl<'1'Bf '~"~

    ~'1Th~
    ~~, ~

    'm<r.1 ~

    $t-~~

    m•

    xn9f~
    CYrn I ~
    ~ ~

    ~r.m
    mc"'l ~

    I
    I

    <.flf\Wf;
    ~
    I

    <S1*,:wn

    m~
    ~

    <n

    I ~m ~~
    <!lm ~ <!l~ EM~ I ~

    ~\~ ~

    ~$'Ij "l"'lat5'wl ~

    c~ ~"f

    ~'¢11~\G~~~~~~~_~
    \!l~

    w.:r '!C""~
    ~
    I

    I'~

    ~1S C'<JT.<l>

    ow 9JM<:t>$I"lHI ~
    ~I
    .£l~

    ~-vrn
    ~

    ~l:fJ ~

    DFlWT
    I~ "mr'1

    f'ITG
    ~
    ~~I

    f"iv.J i:f9jj1f C'!Jll orm- ~


    1!lRf ~
    \5{j&'ff9f ~

    <r@

    or1lV~ <n?I
    D'!Gt M-~
    c<T"l ~

    ~0

    cQ~

    "Il~ I ~

    ffi;{ 'l5TCmf C~ ~ <$?fij ~


    ~

    OWl ~

    m
    ~

    9ff~FiMM'6J}H~m~~-~,FTW?,~~
    ~~ ~ IJm C~
    ~ .£lJ1<f ~~
    cQ~ ~

    €msr
    ~ ~~

    ort:(fJ ~

    w-:u ~~

    C'$'f I

    ;;ro, ~
    ~~

    c~t\.<l> 9ft~

    ;n "-1ifij-~:..*m '{3 <n-~ '''f11I'' ~ ~ t f.to:r 1ffl ~


    ~
    \5WW('if I

    ~ ~ ~

    ~,

    lA-~ C~ ~--<!l~
    (

    '¢f"'lJ c<f$T \51

    &1\!I

    \5frn c<fifO'r
    I '5f'!1i

    W
    ~

    <fi'<l1, ~,

    ~,

    o:t1D I \51~

    ~ \GlJt I ~

    ~
    ;q-c(fJ ~

    9j~
    ~

    on?

    R> ~
    ~ ~

    ~~
    ~~

    <r( ~

    'Pf"f ~'1
    ~<f ~

    'Itm ~
    ~9f'Ip ~

    ~
    ?) ~

    \Sf?fC"inT
    ~

    8m <f.@ <!l~ ~ ~ ~l\l~ ~ Environment in West Bengal ~

    D'lt~

    ~m

    <mr lID IT'5


    Status of :r. ~ I

    ~\G~

    <1'~ I 9fl1(f1>Q8i\'l ~

    C~~

    "~~"rj$I~~OWONrn9ffiC~~ ~~~(~~)I
    ~Gff~~~"fV:if<.fl~

    ~~,""I.

    ~~

    ~r.amr

    c<fi!Uff rJtt'lfiv:rt~ ~

    ~'J'f 'Rv.:r ~
    ~
    ~<.f ~

    : c!l~:qzr; '3fiPftm mrR/ ~(;)


    '1'@

    9f\5 >elSM S~-8&


    ~ -

    ~,>e\BfOi ~

    ~ (~

    1>"0-)00

    ~
    1

    1~ ~.fJ, <l1?:?rr

    'Sjl1

    ~.Jjf >em
    ~~,

    ~9Jt~~
    \5l1"Q ~ ~

    "'M~m
    T§MJ ~

    ~~~'
    C"f'f~
    ~

    Zr.<1 ,'lIm)

    ~
    '69r~ ~

    w.r Y~,
    ~
    @

    c~
    ~

    ~
    l11W,<f'C'11

    '<l9ft~

    c<Ff;:Wr~
    1

    ~
    "~
    ~>

    c~
    c!l~

    ~ I~

    "111
    1 ~~-'~

    ~\5Ioi~r.Jt CSJiS!11i1(?f'~, c!lWl ~~~ ~~


    ~?" >e9f8!

    <!l~ (.~Vl <!lG'f

    BfG'f ~
    ~~

    1>Gf ~

    ~
    ~~

    '1 ~
    ~I
    1~

    ~
    \5j~~ ?P@

    fi1G~ ~

    I iSr&l[>j(Jj~ ~
    ~

    <F@ ~ ~

    ~,

    f\?r~
    ~
    lf~?
    c<flU;
    >e

    ;n ~ ~ ''I<FJ:~'' ~ C0 ~
    -!J1l"

    c~

    W f.W:r ~
    C0" ~ ~
    ~
    ~€~

    urn, "~
    0'R" c£lV'I

    '6f"'llXJ

    \W<7f

    ~
    ~ ~

    ~
    I

    ~
    t:1t~

    -Rv.:r ~ fi1nr ~
    ~ ~
    'iFf .~

    r'lfrn~ ~
    ~
    ~

    <Ii <film
    1 ~

    ~'i C7P.Z ~

    <tt Aids
    (lrn I

    ml?,,:c:>rsr

    'SfOTI

    WHO-11' 9fIV<t ILO

    A r DS <!l~ ~

    aids?" cfI<r~ <!"l'FI

    ~
    ~ ~,
    ~

    ~
    ~
    I~ 1f1~

    \5R].~

    1;r1iS!Co'li:J ~

    "'f1G1-f~-~~
    ~
    ~~

    ~m
    ~

    ~Nr.<r ~\
    f.l:;:r~
    ~ tg~ ~~~~15fBi

    1;f<'f~

    C~lQjffi ~ i81<i1O'1Ct51 10111'&

    m MQCl1(f11
    "Tt,

    <ttvm~~
    Rii~Uj>p(\S ~I
    ~~~

    w oR ~,~ ~
    1

    ~~

    m"fti1 (S1£i1I(oH 9f~


    ~~:)'[
    f?trpj ~)

    \'5'<lt"'11 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '';ij\f3ttl'' (81 ~ ~


    ~ I <!lUi ~ ~vrISl;qs;qslm

    C'tR1 ~

    <f'ID1 ~
    <jS.~~

    ~ GITIr ieMJ ~? ~

    ~rn
    . ~"O'I

    fS;r '1<f
    <.!lzy! ~~,

    c¥iI ~
    ~
    ~

    <n

    '6l(J;j{.l1W;qs

    ~
    ~

    ~ <n I
    fIWu ~
    ~

    <!.1~.mro ~
    '&BT ~
    <!.1~
    ~ 1 ~

    ~
    -

    ~"Tt

    ~~
    ~

    2Wf19f <ft?I> 1JR:fP.Z \5[fr.fC$f\5 ~

    f%iC"1WiI -

    ~
    ~ ~

    ~-~f.T~
    9ft~Nt

    Fret ~
    ~ ~~I ~~I

    O¢t ~

    '&.:u ~
    c!l~ ~

    -Rv.:r

    c:rrrf I ~

    \f3Q <q'Nlrn

    <rtiI

    oq'(

    NQ.:I ·:?jrk<tl(fBI ~

    '5lt1"
    >em c!l~ ~~ ~ >e-g I ~

    1f<f~fuJI
    iilr.<Rt@ ~ ~
    1 1

    <@r I

    'l'fC*lW1 c<r<f
    'J'ItW'm ~ \5ffi.Xfs>N'V't
    ~~
    ~

    'il1~

    ~-*~I>j~"'I ~ >eVf1' ~
    ;q>qr ~~

    ~ ~
    <r~-~
    '~~

    ~
    ~-'W& ~l

    '~~I ~ ~ ~\ ~~~
    NQ<Hi<1
    ~ ~~, ~

    m-~

    ~ "iff~

    ;n~

    iE~~ ~, ~
    "4<l~~ ~
    ~

    ffi ~ ~~~ f4~>=Jk (,o/T ~\~ ~


    '6T}M"

    ~
    GET ~
    ~
    .
    1

    '6m

    "'11, (),HPt'}1k ~

    0lM, ~
    "I\~
    ~

    f..TGr
    ~

    <.!l<Wr C9f~

    Drn -;rr, \5T~

    <Pm ffl1...

    m~
    1

    (L'M1-C<1W!

    <.mJ
    OR)

    WI 111110ThiM ~"'I1l1Sl ~
    '6srt i81c¥1~~ reification? ~ 9fi'<@ ~

    ~
    c!l~

    l!l~~fum$~~C~OO'i'f'6~ern~I~>
    : <!.1~ ~

    I 9f!~
    'Sm? c!l~ ~

    ~iijC~ ~

    C~

    111M<t>1"'11 <It ~
    "<11

    <fm? '&~
    ~ ~

    ~ <rWf ~
    ~

    '61!S1IO'tSlll\5 ~~~ >eUJ '¢I1);jICLi'?1


    1

    reified

    ~ fuN
    ~·~~I

    ~\~3\Plt c!l~~

    m?l ~.

    C\'5i? ~

    m!i "<11

    ~<!'R'I

    ~~~

    C"T~
    ~

    c<@'f

    ~,~

    ~-R
    C~

    m~
    10

    ~ lfUf

    I5IIGf%~ <Piil<;fi~1

    w~
    ~ '6)~
    I

    '6l1SOJI{YrSl ~~

    : "fit5]f~
    GBf ~
    I/jo+

    BTR ~~ ~fi1R~ ~v:r


    ~ ~
    '5f~
    ~?

    f1>'iJ

    >e~

    s>frr;;

    fI1ti<t

    f.f; "Tt ~

    ~,

    .!r
    \5!t1"
    I
    .

    ~-~"5j~~~

    c<J01 ~~~s>Wf~ $'6

    I~ ~ ~
    [<,l1<1lt

    ~
    ~~

    ~
    ~

    c~

    '\.'SItifr~@1
    c!l;q> ~

    <:fVi'f <fiT <!J~~,

    M 8J01

    <n ~

    ><:iW11

    J9rr:9f

    WCG I '6~
    1 ~ ~

    iIf'<W3 ~

    m~

    C~
    C~,

    0#t - 'G"Wi
    ~>

    \5l1t~

    -.:r~

    C~iSi~
    ~?"

    lJffi 1'¢!1~

    m~

    C1<t-~~ ( ?) ff@rv.J
    ~.

    ~ ><i'-~
    1

    ~\'VfR
    ~

    c!lwm

    )~OW,

    "'Iii1!!jfGC'>!l ~

    \!)O /~(~r)<TRrf

    r.:mo;{
    C<ii1'iJj~, ~~ ~I
    ~ ~

    Rur

    \5"ffo1i : ..£i;;rijf~ ~ ~oo~-c£1$f ~ ~

    $Pl/\!))

    ~?

    Xf'~I?f~

    ~~
    ~ cQ~

    ~-m4BP1
    I
    ~{3-~

    errn fuR ~jWrn

    cQ<ffirn'8

    c<rf'<t~,
    \5lQJD

    errn ~
    ~?r
    cQ~~

    ~
    ~

    (,'<11:'1'~?

    ,!I$f

    C1fi<rn \5I<;J ~
    ~

    ~~"i, ~ "f.rn"4
    ~

    1S1J1 r.~
    I"

    ~?

    "_
    I

    8I ~

    ~-~~
    ~<'j

    ~. .:rAJ ~
    c<p ~I

    f.Wr1t1' W~
    tribe ~
    C~

    CG1 <fCG1'[,

    ~lFll~cq~

    u~:rl)fj>1Jlf'l'fTIl1Jl-<!1~

    c:qs non-tribe

    <iii

    ~<TI
    <roT~?

    I~,

    ~~,

    cQ~ ~

    CI5I ~~~

    ~m ~
    C1~1 ~'1
    ~,

    ~i;'j~T<ri"1

    f.mr~
    ~<:r! -

    Tribeb1 ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    Cl1\Sm c!1;q.'{;j ~~<p ~l

    '@~9f11F1 .~

    ~ <ltGl, "cQ~ ~ <tWT, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~I!dt<rr"'lrn ~ ~ ~ I cQ<RBr ['<~ C"f~ ~ cQ<P" V[~tJlIR ~_ ~1f¢l<jSc<jS ~ 9f1i3Vlffi:Cft4"i ~ Gli%~ ~~ (\51\ ~«I» ) / ~ 00) ) I ~T<r C"f~ ~9fffi ~ ClFf 8I 1%R cQ~
    ~IS ~

    ·rr;:r<r c!1~
    ~~ ~ -II <fil?l ~
    I)~

    \5llfir ~~ ~-\5TJ1I5P1H
    cQ~

    ~re~ m ~
    ~, ~ Q.rrf<js" ~

    <lS~ ~

    tribe

    mm

    ~I

    ~"<ll@

    <['<IT ~
    ~, ~ ~ ~

    I 'f<1 ~tf'1Tvm~~~'ti!IM'1I>n111

    ~~, ~

    ~ ~
    ~

    DWt ~ <mr

    9fN3m

    W I C<P" ?fr~"Pi?
    C~

    cWr~'
    ~ffi \5"'R ~

    ere ~
    ~
    ~

    \5'1U@ ~
    ~ ~
    C~~"I(I!J

    9fre"i"r~1

    m~
    I~

    <lS~rt,15TJ1~

    ~ c~Gi
    <.!.l~ ~
    ~ <j~ ~

    .flm <fi~
    I '_;I?! ~~

    '8ifmr ~
    ~~

    <fit?f~"""
    ~

    ?J1"'lU4Irn(!l>, ~

    ?f1 '_;1c.(fS

    ~
    ~
    _

    ~
    ~

    ~R

    ~I~ ~
    "¢lllIm ~

    <!1~

    ~-*-1fm ~
    ~ ~~

    9ff~~-rn ~
    I ~, I~ ~

    cQ"'1'1ii NGO C"~! ~r

    Dt77!tOk"l, c£1~~

    I f.qs~ 11<)01 ~

    ''\5n~
    cQ'f<.r

    ~~

    1J.1[?"

    \5~

    ~R ~~~:f.h""'?f
    <!1<'P \5jfM<.1I~~

    <I'@ ~ C'>lWl ~"t<P <1Tfi51~ ~ ":1r~-Fm$hr~ ~"115t1S ~


    ~

    ~9Jm ~CG
    ~
    ('-<){]J

    <i'm;;r I i5Tt~

    ~
    '5J1~
    9f~

    BTMru

    \SfR ~
    ~ll!J ~

    ~~c<fi1

    1IFrr ti"W! O1'Gsrt ~


    }1l~/on-~ffl
    ~~
    I~ I

    ~ ~ ~, ~ GilSsrt Br <f1 ~~ <ff f.IDr ~


    <fiB" ~

    1Br~<ml" I
    ~ ~ ~~

    (1f'em ~

    iSIf"Bf ~
    I·~

    ~
    ~

    !/81""C'!l:. ~ 'II ~~
    !i~ ~

    I c<FR1 ~

    ~ ~

    :IlIM<r11 C\5i ~

    I@l1 ~~'1
    ~

    I \5lH cQ~

    ~
    'f~
    ~
    ~cQ~

    ~
    I \5~~

    (,~t>1[o'11 ~-~!Wfm ~

    ~;n I '5fBf ~ \5f<f-'orr;r' ~ ~,


    ~

    <ff ~

    ClFf I ~
    'Tj C~IS ~

    c<R c<R

    wrn"Bf <rrPf~,
    8I ~, G1'8 ~

    frJ!f~ ~ ' <11, cQ~~,


    ~, ~I ~

    ~~

    1Klif ~

    ~c!l<r, ~)C'f
    ~~~~
    (QiT.<f.

    c~~rR
    ~~

    ~! ~oo~-<!1"?f..!l<lS ~

    '<1R, ~

    ~\Q9f?li1:~~ s~1if;r ~~QJrI~l:fJ (I1'e"ID QJr

    <wfCG ~

    Jm

    '1t:'11f<.1'Ci3 ~

    c~ f9f<£l~, ~ <ff 4m ~ zrnlS ""'l1-~


    ;n-~
    I

    C:Il\S!<lI"'l[<1l ~mcQm

    ~'ft~~
    'o~

    (rJWj-ISm<!irn),

    rn'T ~
    ~
    ()1 ~ ~

    ~
    ~

    ~ '<f(Vf~~~~1

    ~PflV'Rf

    ~1f.T11i C"5[<'f> <.!.l"r;;! 0Pl1S IE-I ~ 1!l~C"'l"r ~ (.~ ~~"i~ I~


    -~IG'fI~~;~~~ I c£1~~"$fA

    ~NGO-~"'~ I \.5j9fS11~ : ~r ~'11

    <liil1S 1"R5"R

    ~~,
    ~~?~~

    cQ~~ro<jSnl'1'

    QT C"f»R

    <.!.l~ \5fNW3

    \?T9fmCffl ~ fu'3 "R",

    8I ~oo~C\5 cQ (~

    9Jrn<l1\W5 ~,

    C<P"

    mc:~1' 9ffiib :Il'~W)Bf "~

    9ffit;~"lC:!Il

    b'1Jrn ~
    1?31?3Gi[

    <.!.lm

    f\W:5 ~
    ~\G
    <f'@

    ~
    \.5j"-l<[j ~

    I ~

    'T-t151111iV't1 ~l?3mr ~mrc£1~~~

    ~~'1
    ~

    \5JBf ~

    '5ftI~(<J J1<[_0!lt(.G ~ c
    \!)~ ~ ~

    ~"'lI81G4>j rJlN;, ~~ 15fff9f~ ) ~(( ~-~ \5~'1'11p'Br G41J<HG11 ~I )",,,.9. c<f"C"lS ~oo~ '>f1UJ<r1 ~<!1~~~~ 9ff'<rn

    ISf(C1 ~

    c.<WiBr

    \BMJ ~

    <roT ~

    ~~

    I \5j1!'lRb~"'l

    C!]":!R ~D1<f<l'11

    <m:r <r! <Q":!fR

    C~

    \SfG4c>'1C151 ~<Pm

    <m:r ~

    'tl ~/~("~r)<iT'm

    j;p.p;ffrrrn ~ ~~~~ <1fi1-~-'¢ff~ Wf ~ ~ ~ ~


    ~~!

    : ~~<FIi ~~-05 ~ ~

    ~tm
    Fiutstone ~,

    mt>T/'tl~
    ~

    ~~~~I~~,~<r1m~,

    ~ (."f"I~I. ~ I

    ~ Fintstone

    1~ 9f1'{C?1"~, C"I<J~

    (J1UJ ~

    -;ro, ~~~11J11~

    9f1'<@ ~

    ~~
    ~ 9f1~~

    -F3R
    ~
    ((0

    I!lRi ~ 1

    ~l}1<lI~Of'i1

    'l5Tf~

    '1'ml\ ~

    ~
    ~{l

    vffl1 •

    ~ ?ft<fBi <l0iI<l~ 'N31C'i81 I '1'~iS?fii~ >t~<:Pl~t:<l' (.!.J<rlJr ~~<lV1J 1~ ~ 'Gi<:f5l ~<g 9fI~-~?I ['ifQl" F.:r ~
    ~ '~'-~
    1~

    ~
    ~.({O

    ~,
    9ji~?I

    11'~9f1'<@1 n.r8llil Fintstone


    '1,,~~~1 ~~~.~~OO:~~I~

    Bob The Builder~"?I"~~

    'iYt<m
    -

    ~~.m9jJ

    ~
    ~

    <p~

    <fl

    "Ilr.d~ ~
    l,f!1 ;rt 1

    1[(51

    lW

    c<J ~

    .~

    C~

    CJfiiI ~

    C~

    DWf~

    ";Wi?l ~,
    ~ ~
    ~ ~

    ~~ 9fi~~
    <flVl C~
    ()1\ffi1?I! (.!.J~

    ~'f!lcj ~ onI
    I!l~

    '5fM'rn

    <t>!(Ji ~f.ll

    ~'<frr:;r -

    '6l1fi1<l1~ ~

    \QBr ~ <r\'G <r1 ~ C\S1t'>j ~ ~ ~ <,p@?


    9f(~ <flt~ <1W[, ~

    ~~
    <JQb----tf\

    : 1fj<PW
    8f '>lt~

    Jft\~
    ~ I '¢li'<t~ ~

    ~CO<Wf~

    1~

    ~
    C"fG1'G ~ <flURl" ~
    ~'

    '5ffit,

    m~ ~ ~
    -

    <Tf<flm? 9fi~"T1 ~~ ~5fSf ~


    ~

    on'~' ~

    "<lror~iQ1, CJ1 "fCWl ~


    ~~~tmJ~~<1»WI C'lR9\ c<1TI~ I ~

    <fl'i;j

    'Jlr..~, ~
    'ro"~'

    ~OT"'! ~

    C~~ ~
    ~

    ~<;ff~~ ~ ~

    ~O)O-til~ ~~~

    'vr ~
    ''if''Mfu;'! ~

    on?
    Dta1 ~
    '8owf

    j"f[c'[ ~ If''.'Tj<JlC'1 Ulf.V.l' ~ ~

    ~"'1?1
    I-~

    ~'i

    I ~yq<lt>i1<j1!
    '!)o

    'l.-.~~
    ~ ~
    1

    9\t@

    on i ~
    <lWm.tf
    ~-~'1

    <!l<ml

    ~ -m?f

    \blJ1~lf>lU:I"IC'H ~9«?11 ~~ OOITIPI ~-~'<t-~-~

    is'i""'l" >I"ill:n~ 'X3'€31 "l'PB"'lPG ~

    f.1u:l ~
    c!l~

    mm

    ...C.[;f.4(pl1 '8?Kf

    '..lf~iQI ~'t
    (."I~ ~

    '8 ~~I5II~~'1 'f1'i1 ;ft~

    ~ -m::~ ~

    ~ ~
    C~

    ~
    ~~

    ~<p

    ~m?T

    xt9f~ f.mr ";gl1 9fT'<ffi ~

    'b!IM<lI>nrY/1 ~

    film ~ ~
    VfWITG'f I ~-("11) ~

    ~r
    ~~I

    ~~~~-~/on-~~m~
    15@t~~~
    I!l<fifij~~~ -

    ~9Gt
    ~~l'f~Cdl"IC"'l?l

    'il\~G'f ll¢fm- <w.I 0't~, ~ It. ~ ~'<t1 ~C~o;p ~~ ~-l

    ~
    ~

    ~ (~) }O{IM<r-OHI ~'

    \'If~ ~ ~ '~'
    \'1~~, ~ ~

    mro, ~
    ~b-

    (?) ~

    iSfr.a1 ~
    ~~I

    m
    ~
    ~""'l

    9Wrr:"Mf
    ~
    ~

    8~m~,
    5f1'8~,
    ~\ '6 qj~

    ""fij o;f1
    i:5ff~
    ~, ~

    M ~l
    CFff<Pl~

    C~'PfOWfi ~-~

    151~$~ I 'BJ

    \5fi!)<fl~ ~~ '1''1'M~, ~

    ~@C'<f ~

    'Pf"?!"'>1'11, "-1f~ c:<Br ~ ~ '-11~

    C<P11 ~
    1

    ~\~,

    ~ 1 9fT~9fT-~

    (.<j>?I1

    S11c4C¢1?j C~

    ~ I

    m <!l<!\ ~

    9fW1'Gt ~'i
    ~---lQ"?I"

    '5l1f9f"(7l1 ~
    ~

    <!>\~ ~

    ~1SJ_10'f?l ~ f9rD-~-9fi~

    G9~

    U9fIT9f
    C~

    <ffiT ~

    iF.( ~

    ~I

    "~, fu-~
    ~I

    f.41l>RI!l

    9ji'<@-1519fT9fW1 ~18f1Of?l C<;ff~rm 'Off'Sm& ~~

    -e, ~~

    _9f?l
    ~

    mml ~~,

    I ..!lOT"'! (~-)~
    <jSQIt,

    <J1;r ~

    'M".1\S'Si<l'.1

    <fTm
    ~

    ~m'
    -rP,J

    c<rfi<t I"
    9ft ~

    11'3~
    (.,:)1 ~

    iS1"Pi~f(.iS1~ ~t:!J ~

    1~

    o:rn, til.wt
    ~

    ~
    ~ ~

    O'R I ~

    1~~ til~

    '<t-'<tt ~

    ~>I'&I"'l

    .)~

    I <fl<fi (.!.J~

    (DlfS$lU"?f

    <n ~,

    <!1,\?1ffi ~')

    ~ S.l'!lflli{ff)<!tm <£l~-<f.TSJ-~'Iv:f;

    ~sf f.Trn \5'I<R1 ,<£l"1"'1f'f'll ~

    /~ ((

    -RuJ MC~m(ft1<'1,
    ~
    ~ ~

    !?1~fW1r ~
    ~IG

    ~~

    I'IID$! ~

    9ft'G11i ~
    mrPll ~
    <!1~ ~

    tpr'tffi<Br ~~
    9f1'13~ Of.'ll ~,

    \9'MJ

    <!1~ ~ I~
    (.I5f

    ~ , 11~'1f1~~, !Jl~ (.'11~

    ~"Bf ~

    1 ~9\Sf ~ <!11J1 <fl~

    DCG1 ~~ ~9fi ~ '(:'itl9Ji! ~' I cfl~ ~


    8[ ~

    I '<pi!)~'

    Wi ~ ~
    <£l~ ~

    <£l<PGi I

    'JII~<IT.9~~

    ?WI ~

    );!Bli~@

    ~
    >5l~

    '<TI', ~Pl19fG1
    QJ ~-~

    ''li' ~

    'fG1 'G ~ <£l'Q: q-q


    'G

    R~ISSi"w't$1 ~
    ffi~ ~,¥C<'1<11ffl
    <MI1 ~ '~'

    fu~<rffit
    <!1~

    1.1Sl"'11.~

    Ui<r>19fWrr ~
    \5fRf ~
    ~ I
    9ff@

    )'l'$1<r?l1~~

    ~~~

    I '6l1fif<!I~I'j$1 ~

    C<J1~r9f ~~Ji'i '8


    r~

    '?!1~~,
    ~~f

    I CJ11iI.51~ 41$l~C:iR!
    1{3

    "'fr-~
    ~

    ~
    ~, ~9fi

    ~
    ~ ~

    1~C'(lI~(.iji~ "Rl ~

    ~f~Rt('~I~

    I DCG1 \%l'-~

    ~, ~, ~

    c<J, ~
    ~

    ~ ~

    cQJt<fl 't@ (~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    ~)
    'G~

    ~
    I '<,p'

    <:rfC<1> <rr;a'f ~ ~<f<i ~ ~-\5If\b ~

    I <£l(;3 ~

    I rrt-S:llWI<.i>?ll'G

    ',I1l"tl ~
    ~1~~1

    .!lVM \5I116't<r1C'( ~

    ~ ~

    ~ ~'GSlB[

    ~ \?5~

    i G1l'iftC\5 ~,
    9ff~~-~ 51G11~4,
    ~ I~ ~

    Q5<p <rrf.1n:r ~'


    r;:@
    cQ[C<f.1

    m~
    ~
    ~~

    ~~
    ~
    ?f~ ~

    <re'>'fu m:~

    '1@ -Rnr

    ~~i cQT1l
    ~

    IbT.<f ~
    '<I~

    '11~~'
    ~ ~
    \5Il"b~l~

    <ffirt ~
    ~ ~

    <rRi ~\"lj>tJBl
    ~wt<f~
    <fi1l'C'(1

    <!'@ <R:~~

    Df?l' .~

    ani
    ~

    tC0:?IC\!) sr;trjj 1~H1f~

    "'H~, ~ r. ~ r.~)
    ",1051 '~'

    'R~ ~ ~
    I .51~ ~

    9JI"t;*1C?i~ ~~-(N?CS'f~r:r (~

    <TitI5 \5Ilrq<lr~
    <£l~ ~

    enG ~'
    I CifIG'f1 ~ 1:f~ ~ ~

    ~1'(f6
    I

    ~f\\:i~1 ~ ~ 9fIfff ~~. c<!'1\ ~


    ~

    lffffRi
    \5I1~11c:q~

    ~~~
    ~
    <r@'f ~-~

    ~
    ~I

    <rf ~c<!q4'?lj
    ~ ~

    <trtf?fV:l ~
    <r41
    ~j;[-~

    f<r~'
    ~

    <!1~ rrt-

    c<1116't4CQ?l ~

    05t!~~~~I~<£l~RwsP1~~~

    ~
    .,rl"1"'CG1, ~

    ~
    ~

    ct>J:)I!P<iFIt?1t, ~
    4Q,ff ~
    ~!

    I~
    <!1W ~

    on I <VrRS\
    c<1 tml \!)~

    <£l~

    c9(

    (3ITIF1

    ~~ ... ' I

    1!1fiilc<flS111
    ~~~~

    P1iEt\$c'!l4v:Bfc~
    ~~I

    <fflW{ ~~

    I <!1~ J'fim
    <£l<Wl C<'R?

    ,It '5f@! ~

    'if'l, ~

    <£lJj<['iE>~~~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    I~

    .c~

    ~<Rt

    on-~
    €~ ~
    ~

    ~
    'B~ ~

    C~r.)jC<'1S1 ~

    rb"'l ~

    \5ffC9f'B ql~(Ji~}j ~

    CPfIil?! ~
    '5I)lc1;"l1,

    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~,

    ~~9f~~
    ~9f \'5l1~~ ~

    .mu-~ ~~
    ~

    fe\. 9[1(

    rrt I 'OlR9f
    ~-

    ~~

    m?t ~

    m'if" '13 ~
    c~
    ~ ~f\b~iR4\!)f~ '51<Tl\tl~?l

    ~~\~

    Rv.J JRG1l9f
    ~ <!1~ ~\~9\Sf ~"t ~

    ~~~~~~~~~~t59f$Z~Jf~~\5I'<t'7Pf$1'

    l.ll.; ~
    ~ I ''''~1f1<:f ~
    ~ ~

    \5I1~IC:Q'!1

    fu-\(j'ffi\!)I~

    <!1't

    CG'f'<$1

    ;nPic~~a:t~ I \5~
    1{3

    GTI'>t[t<!l'lf ~l:frlT?l'
    <£l~

    c~
    9ft'$

    ~
    <!1

    <r~
    '6[~

    c:<J<'1" ~

    ~@t

    ~
    ~
    <£l~

    '¢T1~"'C'"h!l'~ I \SffiJ'i1W!

    f<r<Trn ~
    c~ c<r=9"<1" ~~

    ~
    Dtfw
    ~

    9fIb ~ =<0 ':l O-<.!i <!l~ \5l"<l3<$r ~

    ~
    ~
    ~
    "1"'@

    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~
    9f1ftf
    ~

    ~
    <£l?I ~
    (~

    cs:rm
    c<r>rl ~
    ~

    Uf<ri <!1~
    ~-~
    ~

    ~ 1Jf<l>t I '6lf~c<f ~ fum c~ QYif


    ~
    ~ I ~

    '1~~~~lm,N\5Ifsl'~<ffirI~~cYf~,
    1{3 ~

    J[\G'Tf(~

    ibl(."'I<filj~ ~ cQ!t<fl ~-;{

    \£t2~G1II~I~1~~~.51~~iblqC'(<1q<ij

    \!iIl<rF1Jl'~rc<!'

    C)jC~>Gl@ ~9f~

    "1"lmtRl ~
    ~~),

    <~~~.,fu
    !;l~ \5!~

    ~
    ~

    I~
    ~

    ~
    <!1~

    q_~
    ~
    ~

    'W J[\~'

    ftrwT"t ~

    ~-~rt>ft<'t

    o:rRr~) I ~9f~ c~rc<r>~

    ~-~

    'T>ur<W1 c<ni:( ~

    I ~'if\5 ~

    (m-~~-iEI{31)

    ~~/~~(~)<Ir.m

    c<r ~~

    ~
    (~~I

    ~~

    ~'i'fu
    ~?

    '{l1>j$f,

    ';oTV3

    ~F5 R~ i!.11 ~
    l!l~ ~
    Vj'{l"W

    l'

    ~r-~ ~
    >!1"R ~

    ~Iil:~?
    <f.?rCI7f~
    ~<p

    frf, ~
    '5I~-ID

    '1Jf ~~
    I l!l~ ~
    ~

    I~

    ffi.
    <!!~ ~

    l!l~~~JI~

    c!lW ~ <.fiim ~
    ~ e11S7~Il ~'>f
    ~

    ~.;( ~.,~

    f<r;

    "5:f~

    <r1

    -1 !j1Ttr.! ~

    ~(f'{l
    \51~J~1C4'8 ~ ~'%l~~ Il!l~~

    ~
    <:fR"~
    ..fl

    <rf1J f<r; ~?

    m:1l : ~~ ~
    ~

    \5191
    C~

    ~-rOm:rrnt <r>n

    ~Ri7l
    Market

    '5jj~mr.~

    Entitlement-era

    'J1~ICC11D~1<:p@

    c~Rl ~
    <!!lf01

    m~

    <Tnr? ~
    ~ Ecological

    , 1i'iI\5/~m~~
    '51QJ<11

    I~

    f<l<&lM~ ~
    Gj@r ~t

    <Mf1 1f11:l1 ~
    ~ ~

    f01iW~ '~"'i~' '>lI?f ~~ 'Ir.!.i.~ erR ~

    ~r~T.-m-r.1r11~
    ~

    Entitlement-nil

    (fffi'1t I
    Cr1\'35lW~,

    I 'f.f;9~ I .!lt~ '5ft~ I

    <rt"l'1'ifftw1 <D!~f.{jN3' -C~ c'i'f\Fr \5frm-?l Startegic

    on I
    l:l~

    ~ ~'1f.iJ
    >ttm ~
    ~

    Grm ~
    "111 ~\ 'i.WI~

    (frn'11t<fl ~
    \5"?r

    ~
    \5f~~f<lq ~

    ~
    ~fJ1 ~
    'Q!P1

    ~W1~ "1i~ I ~-~-~

    ~m
    ~

    <ftV5

    I .co- lundamen ta 1is m I


    M<&@\!) ~
    '5(I~r ~

    '~~' ~,~I
    <!!, ~

    FP1~ llffi(){m:r ~'>fIi~


    I!f~ ~ : <!!~

    ~(.'6tp..IJ'>'I~
    (,I1'1~q

    ft~,
    '8 ~?

    ~9f<mr ~
    ~

    f.'.P1f li1.~ ~
    9f@;'
    ~I

    <:rqrn : l!l~ ~1 l!l<:r ~ ~ C~ 'i3i


    <.l>~C"j

    f<Ii?
    ~

    , oh~/~o~o
    \ ,'111

    l!l~~l!l~m9~~~~<:rm~
    9f1@1
    ~~i

    M, ~
    ~

    l!l~ <u19J<:r ~\D1 I <fiI<f ~

    "rnf<Ii' ~

    ~
    ~ ~9f

    ~1~JetH~<rBlt't
    ~ ~

    m ~~
    IG~

    ~~

    ~~
    ~€,

    $'rn l!l~

    0f¥jl, '>11"'fR ~
    \5f@r ~

    'It
    ~~)

    'Jr.rJ$t ~?
    .1)~ ~Di~'

    Fmr,'>fu ~~ <m~ ~?
    ~ ~ ~

    ~rcr ~ ~
    (~)

    "JftIQ.( I ~
    I ~~

    (s)

    <ffi%i ~
    '{l~

    ~
    -

    ~
    ~751117f ~

    c:cmrn ~
    ~ct1

    <Rf¢frn ~?
    \5ft~ ~ ~

    m€
    ~

    €~

    I \5fBf .!l~

    \5Rr"1J

    'l$T, ~;;pmQ_f ~

    15i'8~rn ~

    <u19fnWt\.<fi c<r'I '1'>f,,~ ~


    C4iS31H<H,q'!.l! ~

    ~~

    ~~<m~
    Ci5i

    ~<e.,WIBf f<I;?
    <Q~ ~

    hr$ ~ \'~~('.l) ~

    Wrm

    (et~

    <It

    "II~~c~~~~fj;t!P~~I~~9f\5fI1!B!~

    <!!~ 9fBK~M>C\!)~

    ~
    ~

    ~9W
    fR;;!

    ~~?

    m~
    ~
    Gj-~

    "r®~ ~ :~ ~~? 9fffi~mrrmr~1P1i'8


    'l!l<fl'Rg' 9f~ ~

    fF.:l ~

    <f.I? - ~
    ~

    \5f~

    f<l>?
    <fi~ ~

    (~)

    <.Q<rrn ~
    ~I

    c~ ~
    <m~
    ~ ~
    I ~-'J1~

    ~ -Rrn
    '~I'ffQ,<:fl',

    e1~~

    '~"'"

    ~ '~'
    W~ ~ ~

    ~'1 ~
    '11, ~
    ~t
    ~qJ', '~'-

    ;q>qr ~

    ~ 'U'11'
    ~1 l!l<fi ~

    ~Cfhr <fit? - '!.l1etU1\%<:fl m'i~ l!l<rBt ~ Wro1 ~ em ~ f<r9(ff f.tJ:Il:o;fu C~ ~"if.1 ~~ '$C?1~
    (e)

    <u1~~?

    C1J

    mF<f~

    '1~
    ~<l>~ ~

    ~
    ~ l!lffi

    \5f~

    ~~

    ;;rQ!11Q ~~

    ~Ji""'11
    ~1"l\!)lM<:fl ~ ~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    f.1~ ~

    r:~ I i5f@r ~ "J11~'! (A ~


    !4*lRCa'1j, ~f<j;<:fl@

    ~1<.r-lfi;"r l!l~

    m~ ~
    I '5fI~

    I m~

    ~~
    '5!i~

    h~

    ~ m~

    I "F1~J"j~J\!)1

    ~'(Domesticated)<:r>m

    r.~retllRC\!)

    "'i8<1~0{(<f' ~

    CQ;~~f4<fi ~

    ~lT/~(~)<ffim '6lf\b$l$l1i'f
    q;1(j1

    C~["C<jS ~

    C<1'83IM<fl ~

    ~
    9jrn1~

    '5lBr
    ~

    <:rffl

    <@f, ~
    ~
    ~

    ~
    \5[[~

    9fmf ~

    ~
    ~)

    <!1D1 C~I

    ffi ~
    '6l"~~ ~ 1~ '6l"~ ~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    '3IT.6 <rt ~ \58r C<r~


    ~
    '(3-Jnjj

    om
    C\5t

    frm'>f
    '6l~
    ~~

    m~
    ~r
    ..!I~ ~ ..!I~
    ~
    1:(@

    ;c!l<f.ffl:f<1l ~<nm
    .!l~ ~~ ~
    c!l<t'~

    mrPI/~~
    Dm
    ~I I~

    J@<'(

    1~

    c!l-;q~ ~1\';)1~<)s'61CA~

    ..!.i~2lC'1'?1Rr ~<P1G1'G J1\~ ~ ~

    ~~ <rL~GmM>~
    ~I ~~

    ~<r-ml

    'L1-<fWI

    ~~~c!l~t;;r~~~~,~~

    ~1'6l"~ ~ Jj"1>i~~~

    c<T~~~~~~
    ~

    ~m ~
    Gf1~
    <P@, ~

    ~
    c£l<fl ~

    ~~ ~rm~ N~ ~
    ~ ~I ~~

    ~<Lf~

    c-~
    'G~ ~~

    er'i~
    ~
    ~

    ?ffflm~ ~ ~ '6li9fR ~
    ~ ~
    ~<r'(

    ~ ~ ~
    ~

    ~ on
    ~
    C~

    ~
    I <!1~

    1'<~11Ji<fl

    fu<lcflJr ~
    ~,
    0lVl

    ~I

    ~ct ~

    tc<l'PHWj'G ~
    I '5!t9fI\!l\!l c!l~ MeaI4>1'i!\!l I ~ ~ ~ 1'6l"~
    (:J'I~

    «rom
    ~

    mI

    ~?z~
    ~

    ~,

    ~~
    <l'~
    ~

    8fm ~,
    ~
    Ql ~
    ~

    ~<"I>Oifil'$l

    (Wm f."j";$1 ~)
    ~ 11ffil ~

    ~
    ~

    'if5IblC>j~>1.g<j" (incommensurable)
    ~~,G1~~~~'(~~~o:f[1",~~ c!l~

    ~<m~~c<T,~Nm~~~
    frj-~
    c!l<fSffl ~~
    ~~'¢T~

    "fI1 ~ Ibl19fR ~,

    "511i.1liff$1 ..!I<l' ~ \51 ~


    ~.Q~

    m'S1{ii\\;<)S

    c!l~ ~~'1 ~ ~ c<l ~

    ~~~

    W'f

    1~

    0St\!5 ~ (~ ~ ~j(frlll)'il),

    c<T~
    ~
    ~ ~

    <IN on ~,
    ~Ht\5 ~ ~

    HJl~~~1

    '1f!lf"b -Q'fi
    Q:!, c!l~ ~

    ~~ \bl<Iil::[ 2l11~<;fS
    .Q'<Ji[o'T ~

    "f.1~
    ~

    Nc<l' 0rcr.1 ~
    '5I1i.1!U'!$1 ~~ ~

    f<jl "fI1 Gl~

    ~
    ~l)Qft~

    '6l1O;'11{)fi"11J1 ~ I '6l",*~ ~
    '¢T~

    t<q@l"IH<"I> 2lFJ.'f\5<)S

    (~G!tP1~
    ~, ~

    R@~~,
    '51 ~ ~
    1 ~

    ~ ~<TI\Gm
    (.'SVIf

    iS$! ~ ~

    "fI ~~

    C<r~
    I~

    mGl~i.11 \5l ~ ~~
    ~

    ~1

    cm:;r~~,C<119i31H1'~<!\~~~~~~~~~

    ~
    ~I ~ ~

    Ut<rsr ~

    on ~ (~
    D?fi115f@r, ~ ~'1,

    ~
    ~ ~
    ~

    9f1t9Bf ~
    ~ ~

    ~
    >1'1.\'[G"'1 ~

    ~'6l"~ajM~IH<fl~~,~~~vm~ <.!!<l' C1tt<:r:r iSf11T'i1i


    C~

    c~

    m~ _
    ~f%r
    ~

    C'<Jc<l' ~

    on) 'I .!l<r8f


    ~

    '1f~
    mI"1" ~

    ~~~
    ~

    fm~
    \51~
    ~r.<l, ~
    1~

    '\!)"ffi ~~
    <fl\5 ~

    M
    ~
    ~

    1t<r
    ~~$14{j1$1

    ~.,fij<Ji

    <JN~G'j1\S1C\!l
    ~ ~I
    <r@

    ~
    ~

    '1f~
    '6l"~

    m~
    ~ ~

    ~
    .!l~
    ~QJ >j'[~

    C<flR C"~

    m9( ~
    ~

    G(lI5K1'?l
    I ~-;q ~
    1

    if~

    (A.~i.1H<fl,
    ~

    \5BI c:<f.i1<1 ~ ~
    ~
    ~

    "fuBr

    'G

    Gf1~
    ~

    \5(~

    J1"l1m;; c'<:R C<119l1N<fl ~qif\5[\b~


    ~
    (1{ ~

    ~
    'fi@

    \5lBf ~~ ~
    ~

    ~f(frlIt541 <l'Bf ~ I

    ~-~ ~Hl1'i~(I't?1
    ~1"fM"1l ~
    ~$p'f"

    "1I-"lf'i~CLFl ~ J'ffC~ .!l1$ C"1li<ft'Jfrn


    ~~ ~ .!l~)
    \5(~~ ~

    m~

    81 ~ rmT
    1 1 ~

    (;:tI%t~H?l ~
    ~

    e31"1>ji.11(ibl$1

    '$pf, ~

    ~'1,
    ~~ I

    ~
    ~
    \5[[~

    9jJ~
    ;nJ, •

    ~ffll
    c!l<:r>fij ~
    <!1~ ~<p

    ~
    <r~
    1 ~~

    '5ff~
    ~
    ~ ~

    -H-@ 'fi"'li <WIBf


    ~~ ~

    mM ~~
    ~~ ~

    .!l~

    .~
    ~ ~o

    ~9f;;PiF<lMro \5It?f 8PIT:9JW


    ~

    ~~1<{
    ~98r

    m
    ~

    <f'$11 ~
    1 ~

    ~,

    C"tRf

    fu ~9fiI

    ~~

    ~H>1Jl~

    Mea1"i>i'i1\!)

    ~ ~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    (J3i<;fl1

    "5Wt ~'1 ~
    ~

    <r1 ~ ~~">\WUl ~ ~ Mi@l:n$1 ~ 1~11SiC1'?1 'fiQ.!t ~c;;; ~ '!Il1"1l~\!5j1 W,?l"


    "\@f01 ~

    ~~~~~~~I~~~'6l~

    iJI<M t:1tI? ~ 1J<f$ ~

    (~
    ~i:1J I

    ~fI&i ~

    ~.~

    c<ffif

    I '5I"lJMc<:l' ~ ~

    <Wl~
    C1i@IH1'

    <mI, \51 ~

    c<f1Xt ~

    ~~

    'm<1J ~

    ~ ~~ 8M ~ ~ ~ (objectivity) ->11i.1I"1%\!l], ~

    ClfC\5 ~
    ~ 9ffi3f

    SO/~(Q)<mn

    R":9'>l m
    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    : l!1<r>nI:f1>~r'Jt ?\'~

    ~/8)

    ?<l~
    tive)

    or~~, \t<1i ~
    ~~,

    ~
    8TW ~

    \5fM: ~~:~lJ \5I1'ilR0

    UW5 ?ff@~\!lr.'Q'51

    deterrnint)

    ~-m

    (subjecG!<l"-f.1~cp;rti'ft (under-

    ~11~

    ~~

    ~~

    ';ff I ~TI\!5 '5ff~

    ~1~rff1

    cQ'F$nl ~
    ~

    0fi<t ~
    I

    "<f\~M ~

    I \5f1~

    ~R<r'

    ~~
    9f.!TIn~

    .1 'M.<tr:1 \5II~

    ~<IJ ¢j(.Ji~:)j\tl1

    ~'ii, ~

    c<TG5 9fI@ C11B31H<r> ~

    "I 1I1'}1~

    ~1~~~~'~N-<fSc<r~~t~~~

    II~I
    .:rr:(fJ ~ ~

    Rmsfu ~ <m~
    Nrne ~

    9ftrn1

    ~<J!fG!r C"1iM1H<t' ~
    ~

    f
    m1f ~R"

    ?tt~,
    ~~It.djlt).ii
    ~'<Bf, ~ ~
    "

    '~W$trnM (~i8R"l~)
    ~ \5M'if'i-~

    zrn ~
    I~

    I~

    ~~

    Ivl C'1xtC~~~~1imf-~~@1~~

    ~~

    r.\jl ~
    l'II(Ff~

    ~
    C~

    I ..!I~
    ~

    ~~~~~191~~~~~
    ~
    <ffirr'i

    'qj~

    rrm <;fC?f ~
    ~
    ~ ~~

    ~,

    c<I W~I;>j<lIUI{'51
    UJOO1f~,

    ~ "I,
    ~ ':if~

    <i115'G ~ I ~-srr1>?f
    ~~ ;Q~Q,) ~

    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~-~-~

    ~~111 ~IC"1ldjf'{<t'rntm
    00 ~
    ~ ~ C11&.lIM<t> ~~ ~Qj"1Ni<t>I~ ~

    f.kI$Wl~

    ~
    ~~

    'Gt<fsi ~rc~l~ "<t''<l'I on, ~ ~-~-~


    <r>Q,)1 ~ l5l~ I fl I
    cQ~

    cQ~

    'Ir.~~q? c!1<lS '<t'~ ~I\\:I, ~'iifC'4J

    (~,

    (.<:pf<1

    C1\@IN~ 'G ~-~


    cQ<.T~c.!l~

    ';,f(,~

    UJ ~9f

    ~;;,r;-'Offi.,~\

    ~~
    "<§l-~,"<t'rn'1

    ?IWf~ 1>1b~1
    II'
    I'

    ~~-C~ ~; M~\~?

    i51j01I1:1"l ~

    C\5t

    1 "J~ C!!J.i8l~~~ ~
    ffi""l C'I

    f.itr..<Rr1~
    ";1~ ~
    ~ ~

    C~ __

    G!1~
    ~~

    ~ ~~,
    ~ ~
    rPf%lr:t11 ~~
    !;f@~

    ~9j;T

    ~m

    ~ ~
    I

    ~
    Gi~~~

    ~-~-

    M'63Il?1"51"~~ (15tt) cQW ~


    ~\Jf~

    Ffi!l£H1\(Yt~ <.Tart <mJ : (151)

    ;Q~"J'ff(:Q,)'"Bf1*~

    1'1~lt~lftlc<t>'G ~

    f..,~ ¢jw,~\!)11fln (c.!l~); ) r.<?tT-c~ mZ-~

    ~-H~~;
    ~JI1 ~

    tfM; (~)
    ~

    ~~~~~~!;f,~~~~1

    'I 1"1, I

    oiiilrfi%C'JI'51 !;f1Q9N3 ~ ~
    ~\5f~,~

    ~
    <fi@,

    I~

    ~~ll$lrk<t>

    ~~?f@

    M'8'3WN 1lt~ NGr c.!l<l' ~!~"l¥:<H


    ~
    ~

    m
    ~

    ~i,
    ,,!l<t'" ~
    ;Q~ ~

    ~
    <:fi@

    II ~~t>l~
    I

    r~~M

    ~'8

    UJ

    f<l1§3\C~~ ~

    G1"1~I(fl~ 'SIT.!:IJ~
    ~-<.T\~;qttP~J~

    ~"I

    Ir.\!)1 <:f1~,

    ~"11, Qi~o:rt,

    ~
    I

    <mn
    ',)~o<1'

    ~'1-

    ~
    ~

    'is intoxicated with and anesthetized by a collective I ¢jN,(.~lI~G


    I~

    1\.11..:11 <11 ~~IM'b1C~~ iPi<t>-~

    '{311lM>1~<7i ~

    sense of pseudo-eternity'
    ~ ~
    <:fi@

    ?iJ55 ~
    ~,
    <f\@

    111GT f<ll§3t(f1~ .!J~


    ~ I'

    Eco-logic

    Ifi~ \'5ft9j'fG-

    ~'19 ~ (~ ~
    ~~

    l;frnm ~.p''G~<l
    I ~~

    ~\'i'fBl

    m~
    ~
    (',)~',)\!))
    <£J.<ri .!J~

    1fi<1$
    ~

    M®iCifS( Ifi<fifij ~

    fui'NaiFtC4' ~
    '1\~~

    W '1f~
    ~I 15l1);!W't?1

    \58 ~ FP1-;f ~

    ~ ~

    I ~ ~

    .~!jI1Y~ "'I!lll~

    o/lJl~ ~

    ~
    ~ ~ (m

    ~9J.4\tG 9j§~f\b1 R~

    ~ 1f~ m~

    )PPi~~

    cQ"<t'\5Pi~:)j'{j

    erl%

    m 1f~ m~

    Jf~t<fm ~

    1fm
    ?iJXj

    ~9f"'ifCfJ (',) ~~) ~ \llO.-I' Ql ejll\b~ilH<r> G1imIM<t'\!)1"51" ~ H I"1"'~ on I <£J.~OO ~ f<I\@lC'1~~


    'I~ ~

    N"i'& ~

    \5{~

    f.k\Stry{~ ~
    f<I~IC-H1 )'j~ltG1tl5'1\ I

    C"'Nrn I

    :J1S11(fr(\15"'11"51" .~ m
    ~'-~/~ "iTI1, ~\

    (~

    ~
    <.!1~ ~

    ~ ~-~

    .!JIatI c.!l<t>W

    'irr:~ 'i~

    I ·~I&lI..;R
    I,

    )(\"4<lC<I$mt<t'

    mm ~
    ~ ~

    ~,

    ~
    iSi'U

    CCMBT I

    1111,;.\ ~

    Wo'U

    C<t>'f't<ii

    8~/~(~)~
    <:f@

    Crl'G1J1 I 'O[Q.{r~ ~

    ~m

    C9f'<f~

    ;n:r, ~~
    \fl~:

    (Hypoth-

    r'[L> ~'i

    N8:r : "Why

    should we listen to Derrida,

    Foucault,

    esis)~~-~~m~('O[-)~('O[-)~
    ~m

    "Science is at 110 moment quite right, but it is seldom quite wrong and has, as a rule, a better chance of being than the theories of unscientific. It is, therefore, rational to accept hypothetically." (My Philosophical Development, ':l;;'({~, jq 9ft\5t) I
    1f.t~Jl"l<rrD1~pl~~1?:G'!~<:f1~~~'1

    1.1"in? Becuse they have seen 'only the Enlightenment' from \ lusc up. We cannot and must not do without the fruits of the I nlightenment. The point is to lise them from below." (~ 11"1'1 ~ I j~~q I Brast Stories, xvi 9ft\5l)~\5fflg9Br~:rl

    ,II. '.l1P'51f-;rn, ~t I'II~' <rw), \5l1~1(.1RI' ~

    Anthropology-a

    m:\'J1 ;e9[f.tc<lft<r; ~' \5'<JJ'UIG1t ~ ~ f.l;~?

    (<.Q<T~

    ~
    (}f3f, \fl~~ ~?

    ~'G

    ~l

    'Jr~ 'TI,

    'below' (?) ~ ~
    ~

    NGr
    ~

    G1!S41O'i1 <P~'G, J1~I>f<1lfl \5fft~

    <i>@

    II'Ulr.~1
    ,~~ ~~ R~~\'31 f.l; <rt?r?

    :l:~iT[<fJfiWr~1

    \fl~ 'c~R0<f"~\~9f15[<f

    '5ff@<f'~,

    \5G\51 ~~~\!lIC1S <:iBIi1 ~~


    :¥j\5T ~

    ~~
    I

    C'BJ I ~

    (~)

    f.2rv.1 -s:rt~ ~
    ~~
    ~-~ ~

    m~vr

    c<rM

    u..rlY.l
    \1

    <R\!?1

    '<f'~, ~

    '5!<P'1J c£l~
    \fl ~ ~? ~

    m1fu' ~,
    \5ftIm I
    ~<T\ ~

    ~~t
    Q1~'G

    1,"'1'}'[1"i
    /')of~o'))

    M'Ql@\!l ~
    (~I~,

    \fl~tr~~~

    '61"1"11\'3.C"1@J3IR<q>CQ1 '5l@r ~
    'ittft ~ ~ \5l1\bi!!i3GI ~ ~~ ~\vwm:r? 9I'()~
    ''l?I4'~''I ><~

    ~ ~9fi:'<t
    <T! ~

    ~~,

    Ci5t fl'>'K'5
    ~

    ~
    ~

    Illlr.~,
    I
    f

    ~ 9ft~

    ~ JIDfi ~ ~'<t ~
    ~~

    '5f,"I<i,

    11"I'fI~mt~ ~~9«1S~~~~ 11"'11'>(3 ~ c£l<!iU1 \5f.l~ct<'l ~; I ,.lfl1Q; 9fr;$f ~'I9jf.t ~ 1~'I'r ~


    1 ~

    \5l1~ 01t'T ~

    \fl<r~ \!ifI~

    c<f"rJ C'<f'i1:"I1

    ~<[i

    <n

    ~-~

    ~frf, ~

    fl

    I
    (\!)rn <f'G'K~!'l,

    ~
    ~

    Oft~?

    'Wfu"ffi (\fl~
    ~

    on1<q>i7j{ji ~,
    ~ ~

    1f~ ~
    ~\fl<T; ~~ ~I~~~ ~

    G<r ~ ~11J ~
    'i5[~

    \51t'<f' ~
    ~

    c£l~

    \5Ii9frTrn
    <.Q~

    ~
    ~

    ~ f.l;~

    ~
    '5l~

    ~
    ~

    \!lIi@( ~

    ~1~JIS1R\'J '<f'nIT'i
    ~~~

    '1~

    'G~ ~

    c£l~~1<f{3>
    ~

    'lffl ~~~

    Wm
    ~'1, ~
    (strategic

    'l~)

    I) ~

    c~
    c'<tc<f'

    :~\~,?

    11iS({;jf\b<q> ~~

    ~'<tt

    ~I

    <ffii
    eco-

    \!j) i'11iSTI"lIZ1<f' 'Wf~

    ~) 2jINi~IH<F ~

    ~~~

    m~~~

    \5fPft
    (.,..\=t~l=G1-<lI=O'l

    '>fTIf ~

    WltGf@!<f'f.t>f1

    S~'>t
    ~)' ~

    ~
    ~

    : (\5f) ~~
    (sustainable

    m<;{-~
    development)
    <p~

    1(1 \!)j'tJ11
    I'Pl~~ "I"'l:n~
    R\S3j("'l~ c£l'<f'U1~ctI

    fundamentalism); ('5!i) ~~\5[~ retreat-~ (\5lt)--<!l~~


    ~ ~,

    (Economics of austarity)

    ~~ ("Ift'G '6ltfl<f'M>'t, M'QlIB1\!l

    ro C>f '5f?Ictr'??)
    ~

    ;;n.:r, sustainable
    ~

    \5ft~

    MOW~'ilI ~~ ~ ~ ~ '6ll~

    f.l;~
    ~
    ~

    M'&IB1\!l '6l1(ft11I5ilf 'i5[f9fimr ~

    J'(t~I~<q>

    ·11\'I\!ll1~mlSit"ll\b<t>m~~~f.IDr~~~l
    "11~

    ~~~~~~I\5lt~C>f~~-.:rtI~
    'i'$l(fEI~ 'i~Nl1 C>f~ ~ C~

    R>!~'
    ~ I~

    ~4'(<I~fG ~

    om I ~~
    <[i'<I$~,

    ~'>tr
    ('$'II

    ~,
    ~

    M'l'!3!"I<11C1f'!l ~ '!I1C>f(ft1~~~

    (I

    1'.1111' ClIlb~IMq'!lt'G

    15lte<1' 11\Si't"\f\1<q> ~ m
    9Jc'I~~ '~Mro<t>JIGi~'

    <Pfu ~

    '5f8l'

    °111 ~q(~

    (=<.008)

    S8/~(~)mr
    ~ ~ ~ '~:'f <lBf"fRf 'ffi:Q,f SIliStL"'lf\1<1'

    ~o;f

    m ~ :c!.l<fiif<r<r
    'm1C~q
    '139f'?l ~

    FPl~
    ~) ~

    GJl~

    I H19j\i) ~l1fRTq !of. 101


    I

    ~NGI C~ fl ~r~~"Sf1\1f~ I~ ~ ~

    OO~I

    c!j~'PT ~

    'G ~~ ~)

    ~) SIlI';,T."'lf\Sq; ~~,

    m-\S1tT~ ~,
    8) "?11<St"ANs<t> \'5T'<~
    'G
    ~~

    I!J) ~1"'1~~<t>
    ~

    ~'<fflIi\!J
    ~

    '8 81@aIH<t>

    m'ifflt~, 9mt:<r<r
    ~

    ;:rtm-~

    m~1\b I rr&t m~rrtm


    '13 ~

    ~i'r

    mrTJi/8a
    'SfC"l

    Ir,!I"1 ~~,

    :;f~rr~;;I~'Q, (1) SIliSi7.ilf\S<:j> ::>f\~

    1'!~"'1\!)1 W9fv.J , ir,.I:1 ~ ",1-1 ~ '1':11;1~ Ih<1 ~1lII ~I~I ~ ~,

    rn.~
    ~
    I~

    ~-m ~~

    c<r <[-r&C\!l f71~\.'J~


    ':9\l'fQJ \5BI
    ~~ ~~

    ~~,
    <rj~ ~,

    <l1 ~

    1WT '~~! I '5~ ~


    I

    q)

    ~-Rl ~

    mm F'r.1"fif1~~ ~
    r<l\5t
    '13~ ~ \b!<1~I<1ro ~~? I!J~ ~

    '>5l'ftft11D<li

    ~
    ~ ~

    I <rWf
    <r>@

    '¢fr.Jm ~~
    GT'!3m ~

    m~
    ~
    ~

    ~-::>f~

    ~
    ""Itfu I

    \5l7;>« ~
    C~ Q1~ 8~ ~1"l~C'{;:$l ~fI<;jlf\5f<1' 81<101]$1

    ~,
    ~l%:r
    c!jm

    l~
    ~'

    I! l'!l • Ecoferninism' ~----"<fi

    I ~9frrBr ~
    I~ ~

    0f'!3m ~ ~ 15f~
    ~~

    m~
    ~

    ~"1Bf
    ~ mrffi\!l~It1

    c!j"1>fU 'Jf\~ ~

    ~9f ~

    1·llr.l(;J~ cS1:@rc~ ?lliSi{"IR>~ c!j<p~ c!j~'13 11·1'!l~ '&@ ~

    m.,R!1% ~
    ~
    ~~ ~I
    c;;;J ~
    ~

    '5f'4'fu
    ·:>'rlr.~:iftt'2J

    ~1\Sit~(i:3<1' \!i"f~,

    ::>f11Q,1

    fi!>w<!>Jr~ ::>f\~'8
    ?lllbit~f\b<r>

    D'<f1 ~ ~
    (1P:!01

    I 111b1t.lF11' ~~

    <r~~?f

    \5ffD1"R, ~

    f.l::>r~

    <1"1 '13 ~~ ~ ~

    .9@:. f.'prr;'>fu
    <r>@

    ,~Wr'$

    ~~'

    ~~
    ~I

    ~m~' mmm m~
    ~ ~

    (Social Ecology) c!j~


    I61ltft1rRl ~ ~

    ~ on I ~ "::>r1~ ~rn <.!lW ~I61JI<r>IOSfSl4'


    iQ~~~ ~

    ~rr,~,

    (~

    I ~, ~ "11
    I

    '8m~,

    ~1g; ~
    '>fbi!

    .?JF1Mr~r ~

    ~?t'l, f.t$rr.$ ~
    ~~I

    \5B-f9J ~

    1I11'''lij~,~~~~,<fiI<f.lI!JWM3.Pl~~ 1101 \5ffiI '611SlI0'Bl ~~ 1'1',11 ~~>(3~ I 'JI9j@~ Ir"l'


    }-j\l3~
    '$

    (ecoferninisrn)
    ~

    t3~<;pt?l~CG"I"'1 ~r'8f-~'<~
    ~~, ~-~,

    'fJ?l'C\!l ~

    ~~
    ~ ~

    ~
    ~

    ~~
    c<T ~

    f5R ~
    1151~~~,

    m~ ~
    f.t8! ~

    m~ f'i'fG! rfIf---W,

    HGr ~,

    ~"SlFll~
    C\5tr.~
    ~...:~

    '51H{1~\!l
    -

    C5!'i'J f.V.rr:$ \b!<l'4'C{1?l 2:1<rt<1 m'f ~ ~


    ~<:p

    111 !>1f, \5ffi 2:lfhRrrn


    ~

    <rI ~

    ~,
    ~

    <m:r1tmJ
    81@3IH<1'

    mo;{-'Jfm, ~ ~ ~-m '8


    ~ C~ ~ ~ <r1'~

    Ol~

    m~ >j~li8r\!lC'ii1?l :5rrr.'<11 c!j~ 'STC<,fJ<!l<t>W ~'>1J


    ~~~

    \St<Tt ~ I f<rf.tl;f 1:frn'i1t<fl 'Jf\~ '1>1.?lfik.CG"H


    J"l1~11@r<1' ~

    ILII)lUllic farming, organic food) ~~"IT;<,fJ 111"1'1"~~, iI!'1 .~~ ~


    1\111

    I 'Gi~

    "rr~im,
    ~ ~

    m~ ~
    ~

    fik~,~
    ~~

    1611~~F11' '5f19jI\~\!l
    W\:l;fJ ~

    :>j(Jj\!lF1~hl ~

    <rt symbiosis' I~
    <Q~ ~

    11' I (;\!i!"if[.l QJf<TI I c!jlj\!lI<1~I{1I61I~I(fj'?l

    ~9ft@

    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    1i~~ ~::>f11'<1
    f

    1i '~:;qr.<:!J
    ~~m~<pl~~

    U~
    f.2p:r~
    ~ I

    '5I1Cfr115"l1 ~

    c<T~
    <Q'<f' ~~

    1i ~

    cmr
    ~

    I Ifl'\'l"

    fiffi:ro.11'8iQ:1f\b4l
    ~M~M\!l

    ~
    ~
    f

    :;qr.(jJ~

    ~WI'13

    m~
    ~
    I~

    1l5lrA%rn ~

    RJJ~
    c!j~ ~

    -Rc~
    ~

    ~~
    ~
    J:jf~I~<r>

    'mc~
    '13

    (\!lI&1 1~1?l~{1

    11"1I1lfi:j ~'8

    ml:1l<;p~C~?l ~ .?JUJIItiT4!{1

    ~) 11'81I"1M"l'

    m~ ~ ~
    ~
    ~'ijj

    <rI ~\5l
    j LIst do it
    ~

    '13 M<1Ib'C"lfl ~

    J"l1"'llliSt<1' m'>FiT~

    J"I~I0Si'!l (.<1'1~JC'1>~

    "Fm I mBr ~

    cmF1

    ~'>fu:
    ~9

    eIi% ~
    I ~I?l ~

    cxrm"f ~

    m <r>(31~
    ~o;fu

    ~
    c<T

    II. '1':<rr:f "<1'!!.:fi, \5l C"l<:j>{; ~sf.T) I


    1

    1I5I'<ff~, m9f ~
    ~ ~

    2:lJI<1'NCJ"I1

    II

    .~'l

    <:p@ ~.

    C<1'W11
    J"I~)jJl!U(j(I'i ~I

    I f.tJrro;fu

    GTf~"*Z .

    I ,11m\!) ~ 1'1:1 \:l~~~~

    r.~;

    ~ofmr.-?j ~

    1WT C'>fDi2:; J"llIJ"lJIN!.<t>

    «PPU0Tl ~

    (11 l<l 1M &1 I fl

    "iffl1>jj~j~<1'

    m~

    on

    J"l11l1@r<1'~
    "<P@

    c!j':1.R ~'l ~::>rm~~~1 8f<'I i8l1~\!lIN<1'

    11'111~'o/fc!j~rn~~,~~,C~(context)

    11.1'11 ~<ll <f'~

    ~'>fu

    'Jj1l1'fJr

    (epistemology)

    8~/~(?f)~ om r ~

    f.:p:j,,(

    f.T8r ~1<l"11 : c(I<!l'If!i<f;


    ~ ~1~

    ~m
    ~

    mrPl/S"l <I'm ~ I

    <rf\em <1'1 ~CG1 Q.fI<f>rn ~


    ~

    <!l?z l5<i'rn

    ~~

    ~
    ?

    051 ? ~ Fl> f.1~ ~ m"<!tsr <!l7;\5j'5ltnr ~'1 '5l1CG1115'1H!;mH\5c'Q~ 'S:fC~, 1511~1()1~ ~ 'S:fC~ ~ ~
    ~r~~~<f>~~<fCG'T~~~I~~

    ~sfu
    ~

    , . 1 bll<rFf ~

    ~re<'f.lj'ffiS1 ~

    Ih :-lfiSR!1'1 ~
    ,·I-j

    ~
    ~

    ~ct~,

    Wt! <A1 ~

    !Bf ~\5f1nli~

    \ r. ~l<fiTIf C\51G4i
    ~~ I
    ~ ~

    m I <iN

    (\5f.'rf <mT, ~~
    \'l~

    m'if~
    '<l'@

    c-t"R df;T; m'if (f<l'J1~,

    sPr~
    ~

    ~151Vf ~) ~

    ~ <!l~

    <!l~
    <:fS]"~

    :>j~I(.f.jlti'1ll

    RlifulC'1~

    \5f1c~l15~1 (time) <!l<fl

    Ir.w'; ~
    11

    FP=r?:9@ ~T5"'Ii
    ~'1fV,p

    <I'm ~ C>1 GM 1 JRRl"~'1fS1' ~<;f ~


    1

    ~'1~'~'BI.
    ~,
    \'l~

    i1~"1 ~

    '1'll6r-!f<rm ~

    \511~
    I \5ff~

    <p@ ,,~~

    cal emergency ~

    ~ ~~

    <QSlI?1C\S1M,

    <iW~
    ~ <Q~

    ~~'1{
    \5fR:m ~

    cm-m ~~ em"! ~ <m:rq


    fhBrct ~
    ~ ~
    r

    m~ ~ ClJiR ecologi\5I<!i ~ .!I";i.fI?1(!§tM~ ~ ~ ~ '11lr~ ~ ~ I m~ ~ c.<FT


    I
    I ~"fI?ffl",

    CI'Mt ~

    \5l ~

    I '.111 I ~

    <!I~ <:rBfrn

    ~-0'<R

    ~-~

    I
    I

    ?II 'PPUlrnl!) '~

    orr I
    \5T<!I\5 (~ I!l~

    \5lI&~xrrm
    ~
    ~

    11'8~

    'Jllf"_I<!1~~rn~~~~I~~

    em~

    H~r~
    1 ~ \::)~

    m~

    "1:!CJfJt~~ o:r1'<frn
    <fj~ ~

    \5l1~~1"'l~

    \5l<Rl ~
    ~ ct'~:>j('<fl ~ ~ .!I'~

    If"

    l.!1<l'

    <.Q~

    ~
    ~

    I ~~:>j I&t~

    m*~ ~
    ~ ~~

    ~"'t<f I mibi{o;J1\S15

    f.P:!~

    ~
    I <f1<;p

    fu.4<r

    (;j1\b<'f.lGII

    \11'.1

    I5I?f ~~

    srn I!»

    ~1ffi1 <fl~

    m i:Rf'11TI' @'$S1(A1ffi::t15srn I Q'f


    ~ (?j~

    m \5l'IV=r on
    ct'1~jJpi ~

    ~«,T, <!l?z\51<Rf

    ~m.,j-~~?~~ I-j, ~, S1'~

    ~~~~,
    l' \5jj~
    <Q~ <Wf(.I!l

    9f@ 8r

    "Tlf<is ~
    ~9f?1'
    (.J'! ~

    .!I~ \SIr."~ ~ ¥fm~ ~?

    111~11J1f~
    '1

    m~
    ~

    ~'>I<:r.4t;;rn'5jQ.[<ff~~~ fl 'TIT,

    m~
    ~

    I Nr.11"iT.'BI ~
    ~
    II

    l5W I D1~
    9ft@

    \5foi~ ~

    ~
    ~

    9fT2iJ <P.J: ~
    ~ (~~

    rr;~ DWI m~
    r.~

    ~
    ~ ~

    ("f\!31J1 ~

    fi'r~
    (?j ~ ~

    I IH'r~ 1I1'1~

    "11'; I!l~
    ~

    m~

    J=f,~ ~~,
    orr~ ~
    \!3~

    m~

    <!J$rc~ ~

    ~
    l5<ff
    I

    \!3~

    Dtr; mim

    tift

    Drn~ I ~
    (~~~ ~\!3 ~

    ~
    ~ ~

    ~~~,
    '6j"1~1b I~ ~

    II

    -lf1S1''S:fC':IJAT~~~1 ~ ~~ <!I~ ~ lf1<jj~'t)1t1 <!lUi <Pm ~<fl \511~I(ft1 >j'{jll!ll~oqs

    f.Prcsfu ~
    ~ (ontology) ~ ~~

    ~n~m:~~~,
    on ~ "?1'1'Si&!f\115
    .!I~I~<fl1 ~
    \5f~

    ~,
    frpj~

    c:m:~,

    CSft"1S1', ~

    \5PF7!cf (~
    ~~

    ~
    ~~

    tfS1"'1 Rv.:r ~
    I
    ~~

    "'1

    :1(~('ljij'j-~~~f'1(~~m~ \5l!);lWtS1
    <H.Q.(t<;>f<'f.lQ.1[oT

    11r,!Jb~'/ 11·1I'.~·1 ~~

    C\51 ~

    ");l1CG11~~~
    'I!l'""~

    cQ~

    8) l5<!Br <fj~ <!I~ ~<r ~

    \51 ~
    ~~ I ~, ~ ~

    <11 'O!:J_ ~
    <A11' ~'1
    ~/?l1\<3j{o;JNi<t>

    m9f'fVtt ~ ~ '5l1);llCLi($1'5ltcGiII5'iHI,

    \'j31"1<:pI~IC~I~,

    ~ r:<f\.W
    ~ ~I

    lf1<fiW ~

    <M
    fuel
    onJ,

    '11 J1:'flo:'fWrl1

    C<fliHf

    W~~
    efficient
    ~

    <rrn, \51 ~
    ~
    ~~ ~ <.f1~ ~

    r- 111}1i

    ~
    ~

    Wrmt-~
    ~
    I m'if '8~,

    ~
    Gft~
    ~ ~
    <!l~

    ~
    ~ ~
    N'{I<lltflS1

    ~ 'R I \51 !W"f m'if


    <ft? ~
    ~? 'TC<iJ

    Gil'>jf(\<) ~,

    I HI~I ~ , I"I'~, ~9~'8


    11..

    Gf<l~It"1$1 "ffi9fV1"1ffG

    systemic 'TIT I <l'\Pf


    systemic

    rn

    '5'!<li ~

    <!l~'blt<'l 8r~

    WI ~
    (dualism)

    9jfi1<'1~C<N~~

    \5fIt:ll 'Tf I <!I<'f.lSlIf1i<'f.lIbIS1' <!l<fSffl

    t;;~

    I~I (."'i~

    ¥ e31"'l~r.\$ ~

    Tiw.J
    <iiM

    8b-/~(~)<r~

    f.lJ:I1 f.TI:<J:
    ~ ~
    I

    ~1<f.11 : ~

    1!i<f.1f~ ;;r~:r"lTIrr ~!
    9f~

    8",

    'l!u'
    ~
    8f ~

    \51Q1\!)J'jItl'1 ~ ~

    <r&f.t0-

    (objective)

    \£l<r~
    !

    '.1 ;'11r..1 <m~ITI <Ii ~ 1 "(3.1([ ~


    ,iI' ~~

    "1~"'1 <:ITf~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~t\7nR1 \5f1l

    "ttY!

    CYm I

    (subjective) I .!j<f5 ~
    J=[~"1?:mr

    ~I~~f~

    ~'f~

    m~
    ~

    ~'Bl

    <''1~jf.:1<:f' <1'<§r.:1~ J=[<[~,~,~.;t ~~

    VfFfl <ru:f

    c~f&<:f' I~
    'a3'~

    18 (\5R-) "5lQ.(-R~'iSr
    iES~~'8 ~

    ''If'.1\!lI-5f~~ <llIPl19f<f>"f.i 1 J=[~'5

    05Hf~EiNn$!.!j~

    H 1I~IC6t f<I~

    ~
    ~

    <:p!<l ~

    'view from nowhere'l

    '5jqt~ ~
    ~

    '1f~
    ~

    f\Sf.i

    .Q~ \51'<'J~I"'1i'04 ~

    'God-trick'
    ~

    Ir, II

    }jd~

    'm~
    I J'f~~
    ~<'j~

    <I'~~'

    CQ.tm' Xj~\!)tSl,

    tF<I>
    ~ ~

    G'l'B:qs~ I .!j~ I

    If~I~,';111, \!)Jj\!)m " b~ I

    ~
    9

    \51'1~I("'I?1 ~~

    I :.£I~I"'If<l;'61~"";J

    Positionjal Objectivity-a
    :.£I<r~ Positional ~tpTr~ ~~ 1S,iS@\!), -

    ~
    (}f~'8

    ~~
    .Q<IS ~

    m .Q~

    ~
    ~

    '11"f"Ri 'f~?fI7.'>'Rl ~~

    'fl"?lit rn

    m~'5f1m11 f.tJ'fc~ ~
    .2l~ ~ ~ ~
    .Q~

    situate

    Objective
    ~

    1I:I1"'1'1C<t>fclt<:f' '£i~ l' ll1<=1<l('<:f'fclt<t>,\5ltt<f'if


    i;!~-~

    M~lR!J
    ~ ~'8nr

    m,

    '!"1\d1rWr ; , .) b~

    ~ I '5r~

    (~I

    <41 <fl~!:f<t' ~

    0wI ~ f.t>r'>f'

    <.fl<PW 'O~"1cf'f~~~
    J'!J1't-:.£I~

    ~
    '!w<f may

    Nl:!i~, ~

    f.iC\!) \5l'~

    <rI subjective
    ~ ~

    I ·11·1"~f <rI ~K"iTII~ ~~t <f0'f ~~~ h, ~uuld be/perhaps/somehow) I

    :.!1 Q:R' 'view from everywhere'


    .Q<r ~

    I $1'8UJ

    '£i~ '6l'ij«&! ~,

    'view from somewhere' I somewhere "'1G'fC\3 ('51- )'11@f.:j~\!)11l <pQJ1 ~ ~, 'If ~~

    ~nl'lIi11 ~18

    Fffi, \5f ~

    ~ ~

    ~11fn'f ~ W~ <p~
    ~c<r
    l5i<1l

    ~
    <m'11 ~
    c<rC'3 ~,

    ~
    mc<:fi
    ~

    • 11111 C<15'it"'1'I '1'8'<l)c<P ~ ;J'JiI"11l' (<11 RBI~)


    IfI, 'i )[ III ~.." ~
    Ilf '~ ~

    c~-f.B11~

    ~ ~,

    Jf'~J~;\!) (situated) I ~nlsr

    ~ <fl@ on; ~ (\51'- )'1'@f.i~\!)1 ~ 'mutual and usually unequal structuring, about taking risks in a world where 'we' are permanently mortal, that is, not in 'final' control' I ~ ~~ 9f1'@

    "'Jfffi

    c!r~J'rtc<,t \5f ~ J'f~, ~ (\51'- )"1~f.:l0\!)1 C'1~IM<:f'


    JTC5f c<fSf.l 'dis-engagement'

    .Q<f\

    ~-.5f~

    ~<r,~~,~,
    ~~~

    <wrt ~ I ~Srrr9f?;'lji~

    c.<!'tRI ~~,

    :.£I<i~ 'ORl},&, ~~
    ?ff@<rt

    9ff@o:rt I

    ifP<1f~ ~
    ~ :.£I<l~'~ I ~~

    ~
    -

    I I '1~1 <V-'f1 ~T I Xj~~Wr


    t

    .~ ~Q.ft R~, ~~, ~,


    '5lQ«.ff
    ~~-<!l'$f

    m xrt ~ ~ ~
    ~

    :.£I<i~~,

    <:rIVi>.

    ~,

    "\<11,
    <jBr"f1

    somewhere-cast
    ~ ~

    II 101>'-11,

    ~q

    ~9(?

    :.£I~

    l1ffi-~ ~

    ~ ~

    \'.ilBJ '5l"'1JfflC<:f' "l<jlIDm<:f'\!)f~

    ~rn
    ~~
    st.;t ~

    8f '11~'1GIT!fl

    00m

    'fw<f J'f,~ 8f~

    (partial perspective) 'if~,


    J'f\!)J ~

    C<:fiR ~ c:<P'fV:1, \!IT!(iD ~

    I :.£I 8R

    "UQJffi ~

    practice of objectivity' -~ ~ deconstruction,

    I ftf.t :.£I<#ij 'doctrine and J'f'8~ ~ <rr 'contestation , webbed connection

    m~-~ ~

    l5fI~m m~ ~
    ~

    N~f(;c<P

    "\5~"(3f

    11 1~ 'ffl~
    11(:11 )'[~

    <rm ~

    I G1 ~ ~ .Q~ ~q (~ (o:m-4f'f) :.£I<fife c<rIC<TI :.£1<1$ <i{-;{ (/lJ~) ~ (!fI8lT1 <1m I ~


    '5~ ~

    1:.£I~~~~~·~~f.tr~I~

    Ir.ll ,r1_c(G-I"?I ~ 1.\ !>l~~


    I'j ·J.II

    <r~~ ~

    ~9f

    :.£1«,

    J1~

    (contingent)~l~
    '6l<1~"'1ff;C* ~

    ~~~m
    \bll~R0 ~
    ?'ffi'1cAGMCll

    'JIr.'I~

    passioriate construction,

    \.1 11,',1-1 ~
    I

    <Wf ~
    I~

    m~

    ro ~
    ~ ~

    ~I \51 W ~,

    '5T~ C'1i$31fok4'~

    (.~ ~

    f.Bm; ~
    ~ ~

    ~
    18 ~

    ~'-~
    '8~
    <j<:f~~.~

    ~~
    :.£I~~
    ~

    OWl I ~~ ~ <l~f.:1~\!)m I~

    c.!ttf~; <rt

    C1

    ~~rW\

    18 '6l'&'4i@ ~~\!)1

    '$f\vNt

    8ii~
    ~

    11' 1

    \S!R ~

    o:rn, ~

    ~~

    ~r.'ifr;;;rn ~ 1;fG'f-~-~~, \!IT'<M1f\1nU'l1 'i:~R '"tftU 11.Jr.,r~ ~ iS3fo:r - <Q~ fum AA~ ~~ ~ I <rfif~,
    ~ ~ ~,

    :.£I~"11f.lJ<:f'~~;

    II 11,1 bI1?ff'Ci1 ~

    ~f.&e <W ~

    <rtG", ~

    Q 0 1~(~)<If.m

    'bl<U'G'15

    <WJ
    ~

    I~

    G<lillilf~ ~

    ~~ "f@ ~

    ~'t 'it
    1~

    ~
    ~~

    9ff@

    'it I

    ~t
    ~"i$i

    ~,,-( ~
    9f@ I

    ~~ ~

    1!1<!f ~ ~

    <r>'<l1 ~

    <!l"<{l ~

    ffil eRB'm~W=r<;f
    ~
    ~

    ~
    cQ~ ~ ~'~

    ~~?f~
    ~~ ~"1.

    Cl5%t ~
    ~9@

    ~?

    Ii:1\!)J?J~ ~ "J1\~
    1!1~

    <rf ~ ~
    ~-<rl

    ~?

    ~
    1!1~

    ~98!
    I~

    <;5fl~I()'f~ '!iI17.'11b'1rn ~~ ~
    (~)
    1!1~ c<JiR~, -

    ~ 1'¢!i~IUHI ~~<f.fr:'f ~-<rl<fiii3'~~1 ~I~ '" I ~

    ifl~

    '1f~
    «.ilUjf

    1f~ ~
    '8

    '8

    <Tt-~

    'Wlr,

    1J~J
    ~

    '8 ~f<11

    ;n-~

    I~

    ~rm;~ifl~~~ifl<r>W~1

    You might also like