ExhibirNo.

woto*ia"EF
Inc.

,t?f:::
n/J f/a.rfi
P Sr^( aV*+

*. t,.LJ [:1. ."t ?.lr',so AldF

7a rv-

/3r. r3o.*

m 4<il s.,47
70

a-4 a? ?'4
frn, /u.*i

7r J1'r1^.'V.obk

/orAu7 "*4y' 4oo,4 "

CJ.*

r/

Ci-eZu

)o^i

Vt o,<'t't

/<>4*wa^9

LT

,6*t--

t!.t*ar,

3).<

Q**t

-r/.'<-'Fo.-n-

t/t,
Tztcrv

? /./ */*
lZtca

/.

o,..,-4
Itd i?tr-z*t . C /-o'-I ./-A--.

lUt', /.-t te<y'.74

*'/:
/vtp,

p*/*/t-..

s^rJ--/ ,z
o--zt/4vEc.' JarS

'

o-:-:/ , - /7r'i "?

l-7n -a /o-

/";^

/*r

4.-4

2 ..,

6 ; r t - ur' '

/-y,*J^^ c
(a /r-,,c- ;Gy' ?7t *->4-- tA) Vr*

P/.7 2,r'
a/!_j

C*-za-- e*-f^
Acu Cane*g /)^,t/
. t " ' /

fi>*>Lro-z f.{ .- -/-oJ*" ^' ? a/t x z' E-tt {s-A-.//4 A;-* ao,1,r^ akz t

/oot<

&1->la-era.-r za, ,/"-/".1 r/:)

)z-/ -f<-/ att

/U
flnu Dy*

i.?",0
7a

,_/

7b,r. /%./";i1fr"7;.
//,--f c.ltui./ t1tcc,
/

/. {.'..

ot
-Ly'r

y'oL*4

u.p

DP.

s.t-- -{ {,/J'
y'onrl .t/ 5'u)
'/

cr-c-

Itl i3lJ

Dr ir fu/* t* f.<-t:-

rflh/
fs!

5r0(' , d\* t(,.-

1n/uro,\t""l" r; ?fu?'-6'^J i. ty'osffil

dd'

,tcf-rsrlrtlts' t+i,

t-,r*y."e'; )4rrif'*rn
r-,

s, tT ittJ

lo'

ar /' .' 6/4 a,- | i )- p..-./-t .{, * E-.-// ci-r st/) ,JI-,-t t -,J'LJ f o ysi 'Jh,'- N rho t'+o')f).r. tl..l) f/

I tuLs

BP-HZN-M8100021406

TREX-04953 EXHIBIT

a\

Qee

.,q"t .,. - zy";___" '.' ,--.+-'"'plr/ .t" 'i{oc{'t' ;.,," ' ,)' f" ,

'

.a

1tit';'';l ''7( ' '

I ,rc- 1'

6t.J
24@

6o LUr
7o *26

F41/"

I
t

t
/'/*,:,9,
o,A-c

5,)

{,J

ty', r./*--O-

**Jl /-J //r'*rC.* .F l-, *

f/toJet+ Jo nt<< *r.* - /<-to 4 e* .J t\

l;1
Sb)

fu/* /Co,

f,zocc**t{

*-'

83 0o
uo f /
Jo /*.-s

fLl/._e

A A. J"

o1., .." ,

Cp'.-.! : D,s7/o,.J

f/'d
f n*u-eD J,-/o...*4'
S'nt-.t<.t ) c a4</ro-* vr C &t^a_c.t' g-6.,/-^ C .'-.t

fza74a, 3' _ .s?ecen

'r/ o; ,.

{t4cE^t /E,d//s

Z6rz, , !4ro

y'oz- ;:,7o2-J.nc-_ ALtc 4s t{r,6a&t

/4 ) r-ax-

7,11"* ::,Y:z:'? ;^:::" :i")t,** y'.*,1.{*oru 6,t+c. Crart '7+t7oseT .*{.{ ;2tse-.-t/. 70 fi>ffi l, t 6fp"-X D"7t.j L ^,,c.r g^rpri eu e.r tt+++-/il,t2,

^'('2c ztt<+'* r-' Ctttt<t(' t't

r.{ Ju ^,,^,

:!'T:j-

,.

BP-HZN-MB|OOOZ1407

/./L
- Noz'
TTPtuas

e -/A/
S.ta<

6*E
drrT **

1/encq c-//J-

D trptltt zttft\{t

-e*L-t'

Q'

7v

/-/ 'rar/m.vh A C<t.*>,

/ J

a arJ)'

7hJ,affi SZpt'rts'

7 -

u7 r

F*'+a

2rt*trtteP

5,.--^rA-t'

Jr'r;..(D fr5ouz

lft peJ

t-2..r/,
h".[ a\,/ &y

.ih,^
- L"I

/)nJ.ur,*',
/"?-J o'7*y, 4^-/^ /*_

fir+ /-/ut---,
Go,<-e>otn 6r.*. -v (rxV a-414,-'

)*?
u]c''<- .lo-j-7

,'"/er#-/

l'fsn ) .

rtfAl

54w

fttr

4t+ty

6-t-t-

d'ft<=c

I d -tS'

t*--t

$"0, ^ ! , (l

/*J'* ,r:ourt,) " Aut".,r . 3::':: i''. V', tl

lutO

r'{4*) - ( y;-L Fe- San'urro -p r'-L.-J-* L.t(l }tJ s {,s, | 1>-r* t Sc*tr,*p+cn f4[.u .1 y-y fu. Qr:r\r.. 6.t l*
{ll tltz> -.<lo-z ,sutu v*l/f 6tzroc+ E 4/<ts. u/^-p,n* -\ O

c-tb-tr i s6"2 Ih'.s* F") ?-T' A' ;.. ,*J b**- : J;".t$'Y ,,'./u^1 h 3o, L=!'z
J

F'*ra n*-e-r-- i

1.^rr 5 .-.1-

l-\v 4 . nl: t-e-/ ?tor"oJJ x

a4.-err..L-e-{> i 7..'-*T ,^, \t"$f,t

r:-\
\\' \\ \\.,\,

. 7z

lfir
/qL -filace,.

cot.
fuo

/k

,rla7
ailrar.t l+JGq ,*--

n v ! - -*.**----+

- 'r"

,..

,- /3/-)ar.q

{l

UC

eDt

.lro7
6

t,o-/' ,a

i'l r It'rfu*'f \)r-.o .ll

\!

l.-rl

'tr

U --,{
I
il\

'f

ptna/

clatt) cr-x

4Z tuc--rx
[a6J-<

/.-+- .r;J
/n//n

/lzr

4-*tV
l

i{,"
i

l!.

dL6 rcfo-{.

(,$

TZ

.4

/Jy--4 7<7 fuL

r, ' l

ri

f"
'\"*'l
rrl

, i J/u./

jl--u,,^r'rt
8-Jcr+-'

\"*
3

BP- HZN - M 8100021408

I
Sl*o.t ty'I{
5rtXS&

'1ss ' tz s t 331 6aaj 281'fo'('

t^ Eortn-.- .t)cn-rar^rob

h1*-n

tr

J)t J-r--,

qlt

4t

rzt*

fot,z,ry-

|)

D rt,t+er)t e, . Tvar{ $ga-tt-r .

Ql*tt T41r-{

*a.J;al< u)e.a.-

rTc--.)& ( T

C*.|aJx s7a? l/t-" aLttL

7*& '7>r

Afwr.u*t Jt r+'f,rq

c--rF.---#f .
7a 5e+

5 .*t1--e- -

vr

ftr C.lh-(

r
F1a4'

S',-- Tl

'ilha "n

,wa)

urzl(

,'o bl ----

tn4"u

t\-t-.t:.nt-

fle-tr

C)o

r-'-,a.Je-.

fur

Nn*

u'*(f

/,leut

A-<Ofut

_- / f ) n

_--7+_--_f'

fuYZ::: /&
u,r- l/:< /Eo,/u4il,- +1,.'n,.tt,., /-2r-^.1-! Vo/u* /-/.-^//.-l .-. /!'?er, p_. >.t..Lr co{llt ' tl"{ TH luk't t't:

z/co /.r'( 7//)'<-'

ut2t''no'tt1r.ra

t:rr','-': "),r1.!l;-i ,,^",-,,!,, *,,, -:trr.!.". 56---"7,:

I/l .tlt iI,*,) i71C
qL+

Qu_yrr.)
o.

c?ne.,rtre.

J_^

,l^.k-

no(ur,

//.,_.

,L.-{

hJ[* F,,. dt

r, q r

Lt c 1* 1.. {. . o-- g(",t-in Ji.".rry-, J,,,, rn6, ,\^ ,t+.1 t-{ qtt,,J* -Vc^n.

(b

jnr-

1
BP-HZN-M8t00021409

o
)
t-

H o uJ rl(,

z.
5.

U(.\t -f6:f

r^rE,

g(n$,{t

^JG

A.
5l{.ot.f

T)VOr;r G e\/CnrJiLbt'^'t{ PC,t ltCO u

MOC

F{\+g rJrlt15
OFJ

LoG(,ip( t+r.l^Jc tpT-I.+Rg, Gffi CLA-lq,p UP R.urj

I:OC A

tOOo

Ut-l-r cf

Pd r,rg(rnD Dtlr

Tb

\-/E

uro|Lflrftr

A{}uu-r

Gl6

Ccmr.rrJc

rtsr

5lW1L

OPg\l 6,Or

r.rOu4: nH{ <,.J u/G!io r<

CO "4 9 (&). ? fUsiDR-Ad

ro B

o FJ C.,&sr w 6, FrC(r rg-5.r

(oo-^,

K.LL

Uf t*, g)

Dr5 pq <,-D

nU 45o eeu \,o' *-"A

C.u a.65.1 FaJL.rjulgD

d/ L Lllnv-G, &:6:T -r:t FtnaetT, , f n<E(

r3\, Spl'<{.1?

Sern-Mr-r;{

L3o o-j" t oxr CL-O5AD AFFIUg\.R_ i3ukD

-t,&rLL

t, r,rc.

rJtrtrJ suvi-

Dut^lN (, ,3
(, ("lo 't',.1"'

oFi:- D6rrr-e ?tp( (eog -16

4,E --$,Gi* h//v6N'i-\

-? . To

:rlur ri rJ ^''Efir+ i; 'B'u!tll

t3(gD t f-1: TO

oFJ t=LaoL , r

'rtrr.n- (z ;tgeos)
r+fitr gVrLioFJ

ro',ess, ( r - r: z
. 6U *ats G)
(c gr,,"-._ri-)

BP- HZ N - M Bt00021410

#
111-< - t1 SD cr,tt la K|LL Lr|rcr .. + FrJlrJ >rr.<rutcE 5

ru

aluo

(,-,c-rsu'i wA-(,ttED TO,

PR6ssv&e-D |,.i:l': rT u*s *,,j.r*,_

\{ rrt, tct}JG ?u

t-rrt6; rsnr)

n+JD

,f

lcrrL cor$Vr Frcgb 9@rqa I

Ll i', E

ct.&

ic

r.rr rJ

- A Vgu
. A-rrDClt/6OFJ t

Frl*LwsA

ssq 'rhs *u"nrc T\r^E

wr Fu.lr'rb Ur: h\JD \J Ir

..

#,lrrffor".,
pRGat3 E_ILL Lf^ii l)l

Cc,sT,

8l(

n+''r boi/ u A-1 .$;,L*'-RJV0D L-alJG K A L U S A c o r - r V r h . r c { i D "1F,rf t:la5T .n+\J r.virc.r+L:-D ) Do J k_rLL r-r rJ (i: 6C_Crr.e6. t$^Jv,t p cE_D IT <Jfr' PED} 1159 Drscvs s,ur.i a+ttU-O l+ft.g-Ltj: ,+r!6rzr ( *o, t4o;) For( A
51"tru O Te-gT t!,/rs $^$hJr -r.O(ar Nr 6,

ruH.RouS

tat Lt

LtNG

It+1

\^,OJT (

TO ,<

oJ -

bfLrLL ptpf
L t+EC{c tJ r i11

Br5us ? .

To

t-r+LL tBv&-tor.)

t< ,LL\_,sa )

BP-HZN-M8100021411

BP-HZN-M8100021412

r1 b-

&rtl r?-J( Pa,./ V,ncin,.,<

be^taJ cpr-J Cg,graans, h.*

.//'t lt o
"u , l-l-

Vrl

,lq

s k L<

fl r/")u',ta./

3, (^u'aryu'-t.^fi
L/, /rw <-"6 tn .r S

/, al (1 Ltno,r'g,X 2. tI47* {-vL' ?- t -lon/

r)a.t

i)*,t r-J '/(e.,n '

ky ce; i,t t" ( V /.J. e'7aa)

VU

, lr'--t

ilt

':ilffir,ffJZnv*p tr?:'
{rt {}
' ,el.n tt /{. [>c.c, ^o h. e -,, ,9 lttntJ L,\ *t (

Djrl (r dJu ,:-i)u" .,,,\.i i "4':^ e r n !r"F' lso,''o(c,o rr..,o,^'

9nJ*14-/et r^
r)t f $r...
,1 tJrr.)n

,yfu'J ,,rLr/ . .E l-,,,-r, U^ -t'_, { (l<,/i

1-"
I

o'J

c s? ,

r) at

t{..(C .
.v

rJ<:'

S f-.* '

r-t b
07

c>Qc L^<
-l I

J fc-c'

I
BP-HZN-MB100021413

it
Cl e4

a xr '

'* i1 z o

- Jh,-t 1 n/

, (l oof

ft-L*-l {)t' ( GC, ry/4(_t) ge

(' /va, c/ {-,

Q ^ Cltzut

luf

/ bgu-lZc:,- l* S

L+t6! or\,

RL"J .16

El;t< F-r
a.r

,} ;8., '/Ftin?l/,1 I

,ir-..c rrri? 1,..,(,

t t'l

!1zt--'{?3-gr;

ft,ii;il' y:-,','i':::$ 1.., "'l;3

l(no,'u f,v_s.s cr.\r_ nU.t "(C: (

?-1rr.J'

/,-t

l, )s'tt , Z t444.:

- 7; !,1(, * S

(-^ i "= ?- ,^....ii E-l 1r^ l6r.Lo^ rtr, l-(*-.,t X,.^U?,J,,r,l,ooulof \

r1l, t,,^i fl,t<

l6ng,r''

,'llt,9',",iy /,(tu t,t /Z^" L rr L

rA
.9tn/ q, _ t/, , r

/.* ^ Lt rt r /, , I i)rr^,(-.^.4-,l,'?'<"-' l,vls,vt t'u.'-( (( , ( / /rr)u 0.-a /,! 7 * ( ,),,(|2t

,)-' ili"j'-', )rr,.-u,.

z-?_,r,t

< {)rye/q-x, / b,r.,1." / (,

fttlq

- r3U,9 qfronp/u{<* ifu zel^c, ( L,:.,! K,ll - ?fe,n' 4rt7

f;

lr rr^

Lu.t.?.s

BP-HZN-MB!OOO?1414

8t'& +." ffir-s

14,-, tu"<.h

bP o, P'/

LILo" ;,t'*,,, ff'^{,ff;r

MH,q /)c,i

''06"n* t'frli, fl:!,,'Tffo

/ -l

(t,f "c
7+r 22J

a,l

n lh

'(

{u, {-, /-<-e"^ ^s/-v<,.,,. | kt t' I

+-t ,al.u-.t( ,
t L hso,t
d/t

,?zts/, Q ,^ i^

( / /r+ U < *l! s l,l= ,.t-.r{ &6L^. ;;i: lty er,1u-* Z;i Il' 779* / -rl-"** {r, f <fttro,,,)

G" et

- B.'Ac f"

q f )1?-ly,*/,a

cru,, , jo n b I t' f-J

o F(r,.^

BP- HZ N - M Bt00021415

{t

BP- HZN - M 8100021416

I Lg_t-t+, fu o.u9

,4{
S/-ftb/ r-cfu-{

f,:z :*N+ n.u+k +.lf f.1,,L o *o-.f gr,'l < Luup&l lnzN'f ,,J fo
Rrr* ll; rm *,J
|| ?2 Iu .arg(tr\ t"\&- t^o(tr+t i-ont .;rn M ,g " 7tn

F*tln

'i+D'
t.,tL (

cnl t Sn TP ,o,'Jl t/-V h,-! c\

LuqA* ( y"uttQr.-',
, cr.--{

-fl*V d* lr^*- t(,.*.9*-9: -s7?G4

Ftw
Don s.',C 4u

/t/o n4nu-l

rit-= y'a s:
.*-, {l-

- Tlu {n-' ,116'"',) ,nu*t

' ,J^u wA\ , * \ I h^ (I

rzctY. R*tJ

llru/tt,.-t

/).,r9/

hn 4cr4_

i "rrf
sl^,-*l. ,t?

nF{'-

BP-HZN-MBIOOO21417

v
Don Vidrine Interview - Tuesdav27th April Don wasworking thenighttour andhadjoined the DW HorizonteamduringJanuary this year(2010). saidthiswashis4thtrip. He The holehadalready beendrilled whenhearrivedto srarthis trip. Therehadbeenkicksandlosses, mudweighthadbeencul andthey werecloseto the balance. The loggingprogam wentok, sometool problems, holeproblems. no on the wiper trip afterloggingpumped out, because werecloseto balance, the they to top of the ll7/8" (latersaidtheropof the9 7/8',) Gasreading was 1000unitsat bottoms this is not uncommon, stayed little up, it a longerbut we hadbeenout of thehole for a week. Pumped took the correct up,to top of 9 7/8,' liner,goodtrip. out, fill Ranthe9 7/8x 7" casing, wentwell. trip Cleared pipeandcirculated the (100+bbls)to thetopof theliner. retums job cement wentok, complexjob with different fluids,looked it wentfine. like bumped plug andtested seal the the assembly. Pulledoutof holeto pick up thecement stinger. Ranin holeto thetop of theBops andtested casing, the verygoodtestbased the on charthe sarv. carried on runningin theholeto depth, riggedup andstarted displacenrent. a the Had procedure, displaced choke kill lines,pumped displacement follow,ed the and the pill by water. conversation wentto Don'sarrivalat therig floor to start tour. then his when he arrived there was1400 on theDp. He saidtheyshuttheDp backin and psi it hadcomebackup. He quesrioned andwastold by thi teamin thedrillers this doghouse this wasannular that - he compression hadheard about buthadnot seen this it before. He wentto thekill lineandtherewasno pressure. Theythenpressured on thekill lineto check wasfull - it waslinedup ro the up it hydraulic choke. Opened kill lineandit wasstatic 30 osi. thc at

BP-HZN-MBIOOO2141B

Opened choketo themini trip tank andbledoff 2i l0s (two tenths)of a barrel.It the for with no flow. slowedto a drip thenstopped.Watched 30 minutes at The 1400psi remained the drill pipe,it stayed that pressure therewasno on indication it wasgascomingup. that Initially therewas2400psi on the drill pipe - this wasthe differentialon the u tube and60 barrelswerebledoff. between mud in the riser. This wasannular the The 1400psi wasthe difference compression they(TP etc) saidit doesthat all thetime. psi If we have1400 on thedrill pipewe should it on thekill line? Let's bleedit see off andsee- the kill line wasbledthenstopped. I thenwentto call Hafle WhenI camebackthey werestill watchingthe strippingtankandthe drippinghad stopped.Everything lookedfine. We lhen closedit in andopened bag(annular).Got the pumpslined up. Told the themto let me know whenthe pill comes so thatwe coulddo a sheen up test. I thenwentto the oflice andchecked what callsI had. Theycalled saythepillwas backso I wentto therig floor. to for Everything wasfine, checked flow and it wasok. Hadtakensomespacer was 16ppg.Everything it lookedfine. With the spacer in there, therewasstill an 8 - 900psi underbalance. Theonly otherthingis thatif theyhadalready opened dumpline?'? I didn'tgo the dou'nlhere. The strokes the panellookedaboutright - everlthingwasfine whenwe were on doingthe sheen test. Thesheen waspassing. test Saidto go ahead startdumping, and told themeverybody in placeand starr get dumping.Theplanwasto circulate thenwatchit for 30 minutes Reverted backto negative test. TheTourpusher Senior and Toolpusher me it wasthisannular told compression thing. I wanted do another - I don't knowvvhy didn't see to test we pressure thekill on line?? Askedaboutprocedurefor negative testing- Thcrcis no standard procedure is left it for therig to figureit out.

BP- HZN - M B10002141

Asked what a successful test looks lihe - did anlone say - No. Just do a negative test for 30 minutes.I have neverseenprocedures this. for The volurne of the pill rvas450 barrels. Crews were always on the ball. The visitors did not take any focus away from the well. Steve askedfor help to annotate the charl and Don agreed. They shut in after the pill was above the stack. They were bleeding offto Haliburton. They bled down and it came back up. 1400 psi was the difference between the mud and the seawater. I talked to Hafle about the 1400 - said that if there had been a kick in the well we would have seenit. when I first went to rhe rig floor we talked abour the 1400 psi for a long time - they (TO Toolpusher etc) found it kind of humorous that I talked about it for a long time. Asked about the TP crews - They were experienced,competent hands. ll/ho was on the rigfloor - Randy Ez, JasonAnderson, Bob Kaluza, Driller, Mud Engineer,l-eo and Gordon(they (rnud Eng) were changingout. charles wasn't there. I then n'ent back to the office to look at some paperwork. I had beenthere around l0 - 15 minutes when Jasoncalled - he said we are getting mud back and we are diverting to the gas buster. I grabbed my hat and staned forthe floor it must have taken around 30 secondsro get outside. I went through the short hall and upstairs there was mud and seawater blowing everywhcre, thcrc was a mud film on the deck. I decided not to continue and came back across. Therewas then an explosionI ablast,l hunkereddown on the deck. i was on the port sidethe blast was back .. I then proceeded the rvay to the pipe rack, got a life vest and went to the bridge to all seeifthey had hit the emergency disconnect. I wanted to get the power shut off but ir went off - I don't recall if the power went off before or after the blast. I was glad ir was off. I went to the bridge - the subsea hand said we shoulddisconnect we went to the panel and only the lower annularwas closed. Chris then hit rhe button. It looked like it hit conectly - it all lit up. Saw the gallon count. Chris said he saw the stabretract. I was then talking to peopleand gening them into the capsure therewere some injured people in the capsulesI stayedlong enoughto get everyonein the capsure, someguysjumped with a raft. The last guy came in and we olosedthe door.

BP-HZN-MB|OOOZ1420

I didn't seeany flames when the explosion occurred. The weather was calm. We hadn't back loaded all the rnud - I told the mud engineerto keep some. I heard people say that the engine room was gutted. We then went to the Bankston. |las asked if it had been mud or spacer that was being sprayedfromthe might have been spacer,my feeling is there was some mud. well - it

Never indicated any inoease in flow! I spoke to the mud logger - he didn't see anything unusual. The mud engineerwas watching the returns. Don was asked - what do you think happened - | have no idea! AdditionalThe crervs were good. The diverter can go overboard or to the poor boy degasser. When Jasoncalled to say he was diverting flow to the poor boy degasserhe also said he either was closing or had closed the bag (annular) Don thought the diverter was not closed - he said it appearedthat fluid was coming from the rig floor. He estimatedit took him I or 2 minutesto get outsidewhen he got the call. Don did not know of any issues with the BOP system. Asked about being spacedo,tt for ,he BOP - Don said that they were good about spacing out but didn't check. Asked about block height - didn't know - said he would expect them to be at the spaceout position. Didn't know if the shears would cut the tooljoint. Didn't know if there was I or 2 overboardlines on the diverter. Stated - I don't know why that mud got so far up the riser. ClariJied - When the toolpushercalled he didn't say it was a blow out or kick, mud was coming back and he was diverting to the gas buster_ on the boat the senior Toolpushersaid the AD had called to say they had a well control problem. when I rvent outsideI w,as wonderingwhy they had not soundedgeneralquarters I realisedlater that the fire alarmswere soundins.

BP-HZN-MB!OOO21421

The crewsresponded - you couldtell theyhadbeendrilled. well Our relationships the rig weregood- they will call - we keepit open- we stopthe on job. The relationship with the onshore teamis good- neverhada problemcallingin day or night. We mostlydealwith BrianandHafle - mostlyBrianMorel. Askedaboutthe negative program - Saidit wasa bullet program lest thatcameby email- we (offshore onshore / team)talkedaboutit, therewasno formalapproval I - they werecopiedon neverhad instructions I didn't think thatpeopleknewabout that theemails there wereno problems with communication. There wereno issues with TO people, problem no with themcommunicating me. with ll/hen usked- Don repliedthat therewereno fatigueissues rvith the crews. END.

BP-HZN-MB|OOOZ1422

Robinson, Martin, Cowie DonVidrine, BP night tower holedrilled before arrived he struggling kicks with andlosses cut mudwt andcloseto balance logging wentok,sometoolproblems wipertrippumped because out theywerecloseto bal.closeto top (s 7t8) 1000 units gasboftoms (notuncommon) of up stayed longer because of holefora weekduring out logging (static) holetookcorrect fillup 9 718 7 inchcasing, wentwell x trip

left stack openwhile runningthroughriser at TD with casingclearedthe pipe,circulated 100+ barrelsreturns (troublegetting,eitherpluggedor losses) job cementjob went ok, complex w/difffluids,lookedlike it went fine bumpedplug,set seal assmby,tested,seemedto be good test pump1.5xdrillpipevol.to wipedrillpipewith nerfball run in holeto top of BOP's,closedshear rams,test casing,very good test basedon chart went to depth,riggedup and starteddisplacement procedure displaced choke,kill, boost lines,pumpeddisplacement pill, followedby sw

not on rig floorat time of neg test bleddrill pipeto 0, built press.,they said it was normal- Katuza told by Sr toolpusher and tourpusher calledit annular compression heardaboutthis, but had not seen it before decidedto check kill line side,no pressure, pumpeda few strokes on kill line,pressured bledoff, shut in, builtto 30 psi bled 2bblto triptank

BP-HZN-MB!OOO21423

o
went to a drip and stopped, watchedfor 30 minswith no flow drill pipe had 1400psisteady stayedat that pressure,no indication gas comingup of at beg of test,2400psiin drillpipe, differentialon U-tube, a bled 60bblto 0psi 1400psidifferential betweenmud and riser annularcompression they said it does that all the time 1400psi, shouldbe seen on kill line- lets bleedit off and see, it bled,it stopped calledHafleto discusssurfaceplug,said stillwatchingstripping tank,drippinghad stoppedand everything lookedfine Closedit in, openedthe bag, linedup pumps guys let me knowwhen pill comesup, do sheentest,went to office to check calls call to say pillwas back,went to rig floor,everything fine realizedat that point to check flow - was not flowing as far as he knows,shakerhand and mud eng monitoring mudeng said it came backon rightstrokes,strokeslookedok to Don on panel(didn'tknow exact#) sheentest passed,expected800-900psi underbalance to reservoir they were comfortablewith test, he told them to get everyone in placeto startdumping toolpusher and Sr TP told them thiswas annularcompression askedaboutstandardprocedure negative for tests, none known (comesfrom town in bulletform, procedure left to rig to figure is out) what doesa successful test look like,checkfor flow or no-flow haflecalledofficewhile displacing about9pm, thoughthe was just curious abouthowthings weregoing neg test - TO had dismissed drillpipe pressureas anything serious joked about my concernover drillpipe - they found it somewhat humorous that I continued talkingabout ln doghouse Ezell,jason anderson, bob Kaluza,deweySevette, mud eng Leo and Gordon,maybeCharlesCredeur Sheentest - after,returned ofc 10-15mins. rec'dcall from rio to floor - jason Jason(TP) calledand said geftingmud back - diverting returnsto gas buster, (hadclosed) closing annular, hungup quickly Startedfor floor,grabbedhat - down hall,upstairstowardrig mud and seawaterblowingeverywhere (about30secelapsed time)positiveit was mud decidedto not continueto rig floor,went back aroundcorner, heardexplosion which causedhim to hunkerdown - did not see flamesat that time

BP-HZN-MBNAOZ1424

Don heardonly one explosion. Powerwent out, didn'tlmow it was before or after explosion crossed pipe rack to get life vest, Proceededto bridge to see if EDS had beenactivated Say many peopleon bridge,met Subseahand in bridge(Chris)Chrisasked about EDS went to panel- only lowerannularlightswere lit at that pointChrishit EDS button Lookedlike it actuatedcorrectlybecausepanellit up, Chris said he saw galloncount and stab retract Left bridgeto help peopleto capsules,helpedinjured Some guys jumped overboardwith life raft Last guy came into the capsule,closeddoor - weathercalm,went to Bankston Hadn'tbackloaded the mud, told eng he had to keep some - my all feelingwas therewas some mud Neverindicated any increasein flow Spoketo mudlogger while on Bankston, didn'tsee anything he unusualbeforeevent occurred- was watchingretums asked him what he thoughthappened he said he had Specifically no idea startedon Horizonin January,completed14114 rotation 4 of hitches Crews were good Divertercan go overboard to poor boy degasser or Heardthat AD calledSr TP that they had a well controlproblem Appearedfluidcomingfrom rig floor,didn'tthink diverter was closed. No issuesknownabout BOP equipment Didn'tknow if I or 2 overboard lineson diverter lf spaceout was standard,Don said yes, postedin doghouse, crewswere good about doingit, 5.5 acrossstack Blockpositionbeforeexplosion too much sprayto see top drive (notvisible, wallof mud) asked- fire alarmsworking?Yes Emergency drills- weekly,everyoneresponds accordingly Brianand Mark Hafle usuallycommunicates, Brianmosfly Negative test procedure came by email,peoplecopiedto make aware with office,TO all good Communication Fatigueissuesnot a problem 937am next morning, calledBrianMartin- this may mean nothing, minorhydraulic leak on one of the pods,reported him bv to subsea 3rd party info from Bakston 6pm negative test hadn'tstartedneg test, discusstng use kill line to preferred methodwas BP kill line

BP-HZN-MB|OOO21425

TransOcean already using line drill Negtestperformed using line kill testtook20 mins 720-750 minsstatic, 30 testwasgoodwhilehe watched, didn'twatchwholetest- went but backto office jasonanderson 1015 toolpusher camein saidmudbackin displacement test (aft)mudblowing Wentoutside everywhere get couldn't to rigfloor, thenheard explosion first grabbed lifevest, bridge to pushed ESDshutin button, pushed didn'twork, again everyone evacuated statement CG to

BP-HZN-MB|OOOZ1426

Anderson,Wetherbee, 7 May 2010 - Guillot,

ON HorizonsinceJan 2010 in oilfieldsince 1971- office,field since78 neg test - annularused to test - lowerI think call madeto close BOP becauseof mud on floor,what were they closing- annular,eitherhe did or I did, not sure in bridge,beforeevac,what lightwas lit on panel- lowerannular,Justaboutsure' who hit EDS - nightSubseahand wherewere you when hit - standingnextto him when hit,what did you all see - | don'tremember, everything appearedto function, lightscame we on, received responses were supposed to did not see all panel lit up good galloncount seen did he hit both buttonson panel-'as I recallyes' how longfrom time of call of closingBOPsto EDS - can'tsay, some minutesafter,got call to go to floor, came out to deck aft, mud blowingeverywhere,couldn'tget to floor, tried to go forwardto go up that way, movingto port,explosion got lifevest and went to bridge- not sure timeframe how many blasts - firsl one heard - after heard a couple more wheredid first blastoccur- starboard, didn'tsee anything be sure,just feeling- I was on but to port,wasn'tover there when did lightsgo out - makingway towardsforward- not sure if right beforeor afterblast- I think beforebut not certain out when you got to bridge- | assumethose on bridgewere emergency, deck was all out but gen on - don't know emergency when you walkedto bridge,therewas lights- yes beforeexplosion, one annularclosedwhich one - lower On the negativetest, pressuresbeingbled otf by who - TO startedbleeding from driltpipeside not surewhen Bob got on rig floor- but Bob then had them bleedfrom the kill line per APD how linedup to bleed- trip tank off chokeline bled backto halliburton 2 sets of linesriggedup, but not sure - feelingtheywere bleeding back on that line to halliburton, sure flow paththough not crew changeduringneg test - correct when on tower,any more bleeding be done - no, all complete, to shut down

BP-HZN-MBIOOO21427

o
BOPsetup leaks system small any in hydraulic on oneof thepods, leak can't recall which one, should on morning be report notsureif it cleared or trash up, wascausing thatis onlythingI wasaware of EDSactivation, whensubsea handpushed, where wasgallon count coming from- don'tknow where. assume counter on whenhe pushed EDSbuttons, weretheyblinking solid don'tremember or green thinksomemight wereanylights green justgota response havebeen whilein drllling mode, EDSfunction at 'l or 2 - no,don,t set know mudbackto surface, coming through rotary, odors smells no,don,t any or recall where sound comefrom- no,on port,notnearme- wentdown, mudon deck- don'tknow anything other thanexplosion blast or on bridge HPUunitstillintact, damage wellbayarea- no,didnotknowdamage was or to anywhere Subsea hand wentthrough actions, appeared all correct

BP-HZN-MBIOOO2142B

12May- Cowie, Anderson Guillot, Killlineclosed, pumps rig monitoring pumping rig pumps, and with monitoring drillers from console monitoring of off pumppressure screen floorthathasHalliburton on readings pressure choke side,choke on line valves wasn't moitoring it mudbeing bledback, howinformed volume goton floor, on wentoverto bleed backin bbls, readofflogs- saidhe bledback67bbls don'tknow driller but where bledit to he - don'tknowif allwentthere it \Nhere fluidgo - assuming wentto Halliburton did though, that washisunderstanding, wasn't there whenall thatwasgoing up on 'l400psi whendidtheysay67 - rightbefore test, negative on killline, wentoverwhat test we theydid Anything bledoffafterthatotherthanwhatwentto minr-tripbledchoke 0, about12 else to bblsvolume thattime- wanted make at to sureno pressure would that affect test neg just Choke opened line allthewayto BOP- don'tthinkvalvewasopen, bledline,making sure no pressure line- didn't on wantanything bleeding through valve opened upto stripping for negtest,bledback2l1Aandstopped kill tank Kaluza bledoff3-4bbls before stopped, driller 67 had endof negtest,everything holding, back, pressure DPagainst bled still on iBOP- yes,I think
SO

how equalized open up - not sure,wasn'ttalkingto TP to

who calledto say they were closingin well - TP JasonAnderson what did he say he was closing- annular closingdiverteror anythingelse - said he would divertreturnsto gas buster closing annular yes TOI crew changetowers- 0000 and 1200 no crew changeduringthis process- TP changedat 1730-1800 timeframe Tp alreadyup therewhen I got there.Also mud engineer changed

BP-HZN-M8100021429

t,/.t T,/'

,&-.,"n ':.. -,-)

.t t

t /*'t*

,'

,..? l;--,'q't)r, ',f

,t. '4 .-"'/t'n a't ,i*"'-

1-

, -,1/ ,; ''' "/lti'P n -'* '':t! :t!

.,

-t ,r'" i ,',"'/,i.- ,.'/

t' ,' ., -/^-T":I | ,: /'+ "".' r,{:.r, ..-."):l
'
' ' t t - l

"'/

,:------

.;.*-i ;i/., ,,.,/>., i+-!:*I -- ,ir...

z
\-!:-, i

.,:,

f, " -; t'n---'li/''

1r.=t

t ) r ! - , r , 1 , ' 1 . ' r . ' ' l,,-' . . - . , , ^ ' / \ - 'k

,. ' ! ' * , ; , , t ^ , , . , , t i . , - "/ , i - { D 1 1 , , , , ; / ' - j / , . , . i i i . l 1 . , , ' , , , . . ' - : ! / - , . , ) . r" r.'-,.i" *l f :7,:', ''1,,'il- 1r/,,,1 ;)..1,' h " , L'|"/li'., '"51l" ''t | ("''l-'"' a,* ..1, :'-, ),
r. ,t
.!." , .-

( ,'

i;:, .
t f

( , . / . r , . , . & ' i't- . , l - , ! i I ' ' '

) rr r, i/. ^.:r<..

. ,_.. .

t' -./,_r/.,-,r r

t
I

I I

BP-HZN-MBIOOO2143O

,i' /, o1' !j,,*,

.{i - .1 -,+' -- ,-'',rl',.

r,; +.,. .!.

,i'

r)^

'5r: ). -*, i.-:.r ,, L.:-( i ,y'li."-{. ,--,'rth . i' ii,,,.i.:,,.,,, ,-,' /'.-f ,,,,.,r;,f, )x ,2a.-i,.:rz-_,.u -L,"-N !j,,, .

,:: r'o:4;,

('1,.'_. ,.,)fr;;,( , ,/..i, - ln.ri-'

'l"ti

-j1., ,.-,,n,',t"f;;'T)n*i' * l'. 7,,, "-,t1,--,t ,-^1 l1'/ i,l.,i, t' /,r,-,, .,
n!4-

;.i ,,.'(

,^. '',i''.-.'/ 11-<,' |

-._/ \ t . 1<,' )

.1' -"'."; ,1- - /. /-, , ,i.,.,,,=.{ 1j'",/_r,,,_,-. . .. $x.&,;,2,'7t,1' f .. -,{-,' .i:r" '"r' l*,_' ,'/

":/

F..21r,v,,!*,-. r,r./.t,.,,

. /i.-,^r, ,, *.,. ,..,, f

-^'l'

'.1'i,, ,.u^
.

l-)' :
i-' '
'i ":i;.-. tr

_ ,.
v'

-.-.;lr \
lt

^*t'' -;' ' ,"'''" ::'"::'; ut. :"..t: ;, l,| , i.tz..-, .., "/. t'.,:
_t"
t;

,
"., i' 1 /

'y': ' '- 1,-

.L

:,\

/. --:r \.

1,

,": , -' ."^,r! /r,

, ,.:;-.-. i-' .r ..., .*.q/

-.

BP- HZN- M 8t00021431

t ' ' 4 1 . ,, i , i

' . t , ! , , , ;., t1 , 1' r l ,

lo

,'i- v,.,i i

!,t

-;i ;1 ,.;"""".'/(

t:'*'./

/
t''J t tJ, .'.'y'

.<t--v"l+r31\

/'T

/ .r. ..

t.-/

, /,.. ,(,-' ,.,-.,1,.(' ...

, i :

'/i--

'
tr'

2,1,(,.-

Iitl'

!'

tlt,"',

i-i

-1'

r.l ;

,t\,

',1., .
"1. . -

'/
.1,,

--l ;
/t\P

'

..._..

--i.

BP-HZN-MB|OOO21432

,_!-rl it\

lt

r./t-rvr:t

: - . , -'t ,

t' ,l ; t t . . - . r t r& ' - " / , ' . /'..,/

.a t Ftr:u..-

l'.

:,,(.,i

i.t.r/1,r

!-

/"'
-t

^-rt.-&\...,

/
.,f,,..'

.,.r,i.''rr:n: ,-,,i,i ,i'.., ,- ln ,.

; h,'\u, ,4*,-- J-...," . .i ' 3 I-.*. i'/,,, p r,,-y', ( ,rr - -f,,^ ..,,l

,n.-../i ,4 .,ol*r. . '''\

*/

i.'-r*-

i,t

7., '' ,"- 'fr''.

\', , "f

i'i

,',t'|.*r;, t**i^^. e- , *

<t?

--'ts-;l ".i 7:, .

F'ru.5,

-rn-^i.

BP- HZN - M 8100021433

l-,^,so [_:*,u. ?. *. N#t,.LJ

->---'-*.

br,''

5s -rr
n/J

t.,,!/ /'t

/-7-

/3r. ^{o.*.

//

^ ,4ar/-/
arcQ
70 fi--

a-4
a? , %
/u.uJ

7r ./.u/,.-'f .obk
e/ Cio&o

/orfu7
">U
CJn-

Hrral
P .fr^( .Zf^+

/ot,?. "

)o^l

Vt o<t't

/<>L.-uro,--o

LT

6*r.-

@-t

J).< 4**r

-F/r4-'?to.-r-.

Ht,
Tztat .//

'zD /"/
lZtcre.

*/rt*

/.

a,-.-.',,-'^/
Irt z.etn-z*t, C (-.ot.I /-4"=-.

pnl*/t-..

t.l) t r,
/t't2gr.-

a/-/Vtp,

o.:/
l-),-a

,, /71,2 '/ov ;., ^ 6;> t-

,
-r., r

-r.rj{
/.y4

,o
62--1"

/'"r^
^.fi>+*r@

/.-+
? 2/t t/,{ s x -t'

,4r-4
,^ -/*J-"

/-y7^{nt
(J ?Vt /t-zc<. ta-r'

p/,r lJ /.:;-1

Q'-zd-*:

ra+r- .

E*',

{-rA-r/.

Vr*

*->1>-- /*.-

d-4v6<e. /4 L-^W, JZ5

.--4,^ tu42 "kV

I 2.vr.-e.a.,r,( ./,7?
f.-l lU
/1.u l)ct*

r/>
,.t.1*-Dr.

7ar'. ,'%,n';iilTf*
7D

3'--/ a/r.,, Fr-p*ot 1.s' .

D.z y'o/-*A

s./ -o.{ {,/r'

.>7 i'c^l

Cr-c|r'altt'J

-Ly't //'---f c *aa</ /1cc<-, tJonrl

DV/
'|l:,,rtt'
.*{r/ b:"i
10"'

/)r' r/ r-o-J
e.tt fu/*
/<.+
Llut

1,"'- '.i), ,3f ,s.i '-,

y'n/"zn'rr:'"'rlu7,x";,''-,
t* fzact. ?fu?'' s'-J ,r- dt-s /@*d/ Lr,\,_e._-!-zlJ pulJ -- * rf.-o k-t .
] rz- /).et-r...U. 6/4 ofp l+L:

,)*ro))4rrlf'-r'f*

Sr OP , C-t?a,l
ct\lZrct

.{r* f/

,6..:71 'Jr- lr,'-

3o h

c,'-t .ltfs ,/1-r/ psi , t-,.,..7,' l'+o-Dp".. s'/*;fa

.' ..J-l-J

un**)"tl1'" )':'ro rr,, ,..*-() 1r1 I

T I

.-:tsg"

htn , 'i'focft' 6-:.1r?),

2.fuo lz *o

5,)

f"J

7y'' 5a-L/
,\/*l /Jo

fiec4y'-,*
rN

/'"--

+u*

'J

t
r/
/V

l;l
5t^)

fu/.fE', fa*ca*t4

,C.^. - /<*t- t l*, * 4 zte "'a

I
t/"".'L.
ua4.-.

*-'

83 Oo
-* Jo t*, *r &tt--g ,* /l j6 6(., . -" ,

C/-"--"e :
D'r7/z.r.J 3'

f o*trr.t

J*f
ffleert

/o,-,*-lc.LA<. /ro-n ,alJtt' coyt^e.<.y' s-rt./-^ .y'of'eao/' g:76)z*,7-_ c,.-J' At ./c--rx2:,.J7..

,:fr7'L..<c) fral,ta..ay'

.fPttcen S7rvst** .&u,.,

C&<6 --rt \

,,-,r--- 1e-o,///! t
P- rt etz

glro , ,utv,r ,o7r" .unr;{r.3

SZf brc* I s-

fi'" */r.
4!nc{c<

"F. :sr*-/
a/C., 6-7&4

y'*"1.{*.ru 64./e &*r: 4 ;o '7.es-;oen .*{.hlh?\r,4r cr! .btrc..-,f n) . fi>t t7

(}p<.Lk Drtr7l.;1 D.-l

^,,6-} g^) pr: c/, aa- tt++r/U,tz-

) f Tet-, (tpc'' /4 oc

,+l.mc

r7t4\+

F, cdc<t(.- tt

,.-

o
A{L
- N.z'
fill-r*tas

e-.//./ 6^-L
S.t* /
4 etD'

/,y'*nu6 b/'vl

D trpt*t-t c+tr't\{o

uu ul*r-

e! /-/

7v

.&+7

'P.4tsc4.4t SZptorts'

1"7c J 5*-<ala'

ho

zr 2tr*tctte? jr-6EeD fr5eut

ts plhJ

trrwil7*trt-. A Cn <-<>\

/i'2..r/,

i;^

/kJ.nrv'/

fi,t

{-/,rt.'-,

)*?

t-d/er#'/

rtAel

t Ae,J

f6t

4ftay

(3 4c-.<. .7r

d'ftr-C

I o -tS

tro.-

it.v', to

,llt"l svt'.,! "

/*Ju :;'::

/"ornur,

(a,. J*-

. 5a-,, c JW ? --r A ta*t't-. Ih's* kt) b6.*_ ; J;.nt1,2 ,.-y'u^t h *J Z{l 3o,
J t4n.) -(

Utf

L.z(l "l** S<*l,-t+c'.

l\u O .

-p s 1*., 1>-r* I l4{.ua yZ

c {E?<ts..-i\

$vi-G

S-ar'urro

Fq

f::c5ran*.

A4-L-

).tJ

o;.--

ftD lfif-r>

ac..-ur...L-f.-/> i

t-u-,/ /4o cce-Lf ,-

,: A

- Ao,z .sutz_ tr^Jlf oca: . 7z 1g721

U!*- p,tt.*
(\. $\ vb

7.--*-

T ., -t-d

trtr eDs. k
/+/. '1ua,rr.,. /3t-oc.,t 1/+1ila

n7
C*tcct /AGq *r.-

{l

UC

i
" \

_.__--_-*__>.- :,f l.;:

,. tt

\. \ a\

{D'
/t '; rc./

.zro7
C

p*r'

i!t 'f
\n

ra
/Jzf /-r++

i{'f-fr*- --aJ '.ll \)- +

Ttr\

u .+
I

C-lr6ttl

,t

\O/

N/\

\'

I,-

/r-t,J

dA'6 n.f"-t. 77-" trrlpl 7 /4^fL '/'

l-t- - s;J 7Jf,* cnJ'<

.$

\-

(.$

| ,'l

t*ytJ-.
/^*'"-(.{

, t4)-!
* jwL

.'1j,J,
f,
\**

,!.-

Gcr . "".,*-8 r,t

6.J.r*^-

I
Sfro.t t 4 ,*^-*

'735 - 'k a t 731 6aej ltl'f"('

/.i Jrt*l.n *-7
) ql't .//r r?Lt

ty'Iq
'P.+CS &

Eo'nrrr--r4i|aa4,q r,zrtloA*jb r7m,.t*

poterp
(f

,) 6.7--* .{72?

D arrJ<tltc. Tt*i " $r*;,t+ .

f,,1*tl Ttrrr.i

Aa-rr'ry .)e.t.

V*&
1>i

s^4- c--rr-..-#3 .
M.uq tlu-7 7v f:er_

ft-

3 t't-**-

o4.tL

t4

-ir+'r-

Ab c. t(J
y,-o
Frrrl-

S-,-

'7"

'i>l4T-

*\

6l *ntF--t-1r'*a.g

tt-tFv7 4

wzl(

cn_l,s

trlF-ta

LrJa

l-*u.-tt-.

fuf I

ff -fc.t- /thte<-e firze .t-t ; Sp.*-e *t/ l3re-+t*r ./t|b<.cu -t<tcr'{7 fi.-.Ju-,

fl-r>tc_rj
ljait

?
Pq L

57 *__J/:
alo;--I sr

rr'.7.r4.n-

,L+

y'rtc-.tA--t

a
-'-t<*.-

&
des.6q.

?.
oF .ptc.<J-r.et

tVn+

u.n//

/tftu

A<.ypt

-. /

fJ n

fu"",::&
li/t'r '' c -/(t oy-z'J'<J 7t' u,? l1:< fr),,-tcttr +<,.,.,'',/ot,. ,

,, //)t__

c/g

/',/(

Ufrt. .sa;t,/

Vo/u*

f* f uo L-; :"r.':.".lr,,','.'l i|,:

N.llc , I ilJ*.,) iH< vobr, hJL {r[. t) / Lr . i 1* L, . pu_yrr.) o( ,r.-J r ,w c^. a?u,..,vr<, J*^ / * L.. {. uj ci:

. .1, /

r-/.-,-//.-l

.-. /!'-res,

e-.

;-{r..{ul

CollL

"'h-t

" ),rT.',j;_l
, 1 , - 1 . -/ l r , , n Mg

S6--.--.

g(",r -in J; sc,slsrvJt,,1 . Von._

lar

t-(*tltt,.

J.-.

u,..4

.l

o
) I r/1f,!.Vt I Z. 5. A' Fl o r,J |J(r

ut/
L, E,

Doxl

V rTrCgr.J;l
^, q

rJ(|\l T6f

Bg\H,{l

T)VOr;t G cJs!'^'r

EVC\)T-

Prro rtcot

5'
$-o\f

Moc

F^f\+ , uoc(,{n.rq I OOO U|, t r-S r+.UxJc r lTt+firr 1 &S

OhJ CLC}+J UP R.U},

r:o(

tr.it+-rCC

Ptl rtPg'rD DL/rLltPiag1,1c

Tb
OPe')-J g\lr

1 "/t

tto((Lt611

4"GUU7-

G+ra

ClrrFt,*16:

rrr

r.,.J r+ou1:

rtHg

CD '< e r^)c

-ro 6

L./CLri-

OK

fQSi-

o N,

(..*sr xr 6

(oo-^,

KILL

ar -

g')

DR-A{^)

VC{r

rLc-57 (Ltuu.?i *oo

FaJL{rGlg_D

DtS Cfi (D 45u egu

{__iaf}5 i 1

al.+nv-6, &r6sr d/ pa.=a2,Er15.-.6t srlrcE(

f3v Sp^(-e-l?

SCra-tl'mtt

_r's, oFJ CI-OSCT> A-r-/rlclh{L

Z4o

u_

b&ruc

p r rrg-

urrt'rJ strvi- DudN (u'4

-_? .Tb

6ut)

opi:- Dfi-rt-c ?tp (gur, wr6 oFJ f=rooL

_t!."{t6p. E arnfN,i-\

L (.ro '--,.r,1 (r'r:z

, 5rlvr r,- I *.' i'Efi,+ iF '*""';f*l

6ue-p 0 f-{: TO

'rurrrL (u otr:aos) . 60 scts @) r+/rtf CVTL,IFJ /C ,.;},.A.r, )

r,.'es,

*A 1'11-9 - rl sb &3r *tt-" t-rJ6

',

qn^J s*o.rcS

'J

KrLL

?ra*syfLeD Tbr_u T\f,f!,. l... vB (r^rgrsr}.i \r Lt F/q ctrc . A Vg_rr

l*t,-te ranr)

n*JD

( rrrnn ,rF_r.rurp tct$c pu

,T-

wnrre6g -no. coNvr 9f}.r rgg "H.r

ic

r'tr r') r-rlsq FaA

' Arrbqn-4OJ

59F n+rs +u- \' w r U\: }\JD

Fsut-tD Ir Fo(

T\l^ \J Rr s_t.
nlFr nFre.

A^l NUL!4 COra,f CgstSbxJ,. PR633 l4r LL Lr,Jo

llr

*lHoGous A (AIJG

boiJ

lJ A_:

coiJc+rRJV6\

KALUSA COr-rVr C{r! 'r t:tc-ST -n+C.P ts6crr.a5. L$*Jv.r r a* lg3( - t.t5o Drscvs ,,t p c4t+-u tr-.r+({: ,+.36yr
SglfipU T]|Ai

'

DO J

rv.+rc.r+t:-b

rT t^Jfrs, PFD> ( -o . t4t,o)

k_t LL

r-r xJ t:

'.t
a,

1^i,/r3

\rr.Jt

T0(at N6

tz_tLL

Lr.!,(;

It+t

w6lr r

To u ( 16 Bsus

oJ ;

bLrLL C t+gctc

ptpcL/r n+ r<,ucuSA )

e)

ItrFt-pgp t*VJc4{> &zrdjq5 ?0p Od

txls UcfD Co ?q^qxUt

?_o cA+ 94./LCr

i
{

Ce/p Svtti

6oo u htqc

Acour rt5r

Gqr vG

Sp*<so

0v.;-

trrJD

P/-ice-Dvp+r

: r.ror

sTA+rDa(aD

n
*

Go-rp poDS ca<fl^l

urtr_e. Lr\6 o/c\L

co-:toxrDGT>

nr
r,J
h34r..(DorJ

fit fir

n' tv"
.r)'

a'

,r1
t4

fi^,

\l bE rtl r3-.(( Pr,.r V,^rln,i

bctaJ S k L(
/,

\-;r/tlq

,/ |

cclqtrsantc h*u ? t/")^.^s ,tt/

cprv)

,t/.t I t.,
at r fJ^

3. (,-c/raryu,t'1 .*^fi on/

L/,

Llnn,r.,'X 2,, tI47< fuJ. ?-..' 1hn t/

grr..^-ll/rw <-e-<L S

,{t'r(

+ /)-t'' T"-!r5'

!r-t
.1 tJr)rt

"(r r c t

S (t.."r '

t.,,, b
.u 0 7

/ ..

^t
c{*rs-._r! c*tDu, l,-r^
1n/ ( E9^9td l-, t1L"l .,6
{?j-g.r;

A ^{ '
-

, - it,.t

eA ry:,"f DP ( Gt, '.r4.(,s) (?,oo!n ('

/bgcr't?Ltuls5 t1,n74! o4,f

ttl<t t,/ {-,

,A '/f-tj e(p-o.^

lzo
llzf-

/3i^r..-(' trti? L"',((

{ l,f

"?lr_.t

( ( lr,-*g rtl.*? f:ss uv^.tcl c/p ) :'K;(l /t..t Lun-r ..l.r-r.J t'6-ro F.^tt.
l,(rt o.-r fN_ s-sL . RGj o((.',

P - , * l ? c . u \ ' 1 2 . . J/ / , { I

Dotl^

. z|4wi

(1loor'.-'
-(.^r= i

I
QP'<'-' lc ft1 .
^ Jf*k.*

BL& +-" Ffir-s 14,*, t*,rt.h *

'

ztic^t ^ s/,";; 4d -k
l|/*t/ It c L

Dt) p^{ t

t'?urn/4 ta!r"-f/r.,

t\-ff 0 uL*u k"+.

s c^/
Sfi-rfl c<o
Sr-v

D l-

! ^PoY?' t Tf^Affi*fu^'1(
1:r, /*r*. - (

. rTn r-,</g.1

&r t

Bl t'<il

th

'3r?c-,r-t

< /T*\

/t o-.((

0p

a, !'h 't

LyLa" r,t\'^{.,tr;.r ('t,{ o ;,*'u,

|lu^7f- , !,1,-t /?- { rf,, / I Ltro,^,/ L-f7 "/ ,ui /)t,L #H-,

t,r ,,()u,,J-/-z )*,

{u:lf t
Wt

h, , d;tc t
/?*

/"*U-

uv,.r\

/' (< '^ *-

t,l- ,.1-.r { lty ertru.,*

s/*-,,-, ktl

T"a' rZflr_, it'

/k6Lr *.s.o(,,u.
{-' f alNtrac-'o

/1,+(U<*l,ls

,'& - B,.Atc \., c F,'..

':;;,"',::'-i

^ -'l*'**

{v

h;t l"r^{fu:u (La( " ( f*r t() '5PS tk*)\ p(.t,v,r-(cl' +. /z ,-f (,{: ,;i> Tl itr ,,-,. , , (..,-.-.'' (-y,!1r S ( ottt-1n <+t r7-r uI .' t. e;it ' (-l.,ot" J ''
o f t.L!

I
'{({ |

Cy'.* dl ,9
Cctl{tr
r J' lo-f gul<
ll; rm *4
It

&o'ul

De,,",hL ,se,4 il.S/-nbV *.,1":o{

Lou*rJ;
.r
lqtt

-.*l
g-t
fu

flu* ,^-"tl .ut . k /ul,

t.\-P- r^te(trtt l{c U
nl'

f*trL

hEN'f

8rr*
?>

Iu

l-_r+t

/rn

{,-

,\ P*t/n h-J .".

,c;r---\
"/

'hD"
u,t L{

.ol I S,t- fP
Ltoq,)rrt (

,o,'J)
r.- ...

t/-v
f

y'uttQ

-TI"V
-

t_ d- /r^rr<- tt',.*"I'^,-9 - s 7 2 G4

rw cefumfLlrJ - Jii ,O

fl/ontz'n-l b
4 u ilrtt/.{ur".t

(-/s.--. Hn?t:. ,--, Ll.

fZc,(Y. f2rrf), po,rgj ,

b"u -/cray-

T/u {,m- 0,f65n',s c+-c-r\ 2 rlrf

nF{'-

"rnL" w^
\

, - \ l [^

(.- sl.----l. ,,?

Don Vidrine Interview - Tuesday27th Anril Don was working the night tour and hadjoined the DW Horizon team during January this year (2010).He saidthis was his 4th trip. The hole had alreadybeendrilled when he arrivedto starthis trip. There had beenkicks and losses, mud weight had beencut andthey were closeto the balance. The loggingprogramwent ok, sometool problems, hole problems. no on the wiper trip after loggingpumpedout, because they werecloseto balance, the to top of the 11718"(latersaidthe top of the 9 7/8") Gas readingwas 1000units at bottomsup, this is not uncommon,it stayeda little longerbut we hadbeenout of the hole for a week. Pumpedout" took the correctfill up, to top of 9 7/8"'liner, good trip. Ran the 9 718x 7" casing, trip went well. Cleared pipe and circulated the retums(lOGr bbls)to the top of the liner. cementjob went ok, complexjob with differentfluids, lookedrike it went fine, bumpedthe plug andtested sealassembly. the Pulledout of hole to pick up the cementstinger. Ran in hole to the top of the BoPs and testedthe casing,very good test basedon the charthe saw. Carriedon runningin the hole to depth,riggedup and started displacement. a the Had procedure, displaced chokeand kill lines,pumped disptacement followed the the pill by water. conversation thenwent to Don's arrival at the rig floor to starthis tour. when he arrivedtherewas 1400psi on the Dp. He saidthey shutthe Dp back in and it had comebackup. He questioned andwastold by the teamin the drillers this doghouse this wasannularcompression he had heardaboutthis but had not seen that He went to the kill line and therewasno pressure. They thenpressured on the kill line to checkit was full - it was lined up to the up hydraulicchoke. Opened kill line and it was staricaI30 psi. the

Openedthe choke to the mini trip tank and bled off 2ll0s (two tenths)of a banel. It slowedto a drip then stopped. Watchedfor 30 minuteswith no flow. The 1400psi remainedon the drill pipe, it stayedat that pressure there was no indication that it was gascoming up. Initially therewas 2400psi on the drill pipe - this wasthe differentialon the u tube and 60 barrelswere bled off. The 1400psi was the differencebetweenthe mud in the riser- This was annular compression they (TP etc) said it doesthat all the time. If we have 1400psi on the drill pipe we shouldseeit on the kill line? Let's bleedit off and see- the kill line was bled then stopped. I then went to call Hafle when I cameback they were still watching the strippingtank and the dripping had stopped. Everything looked fine. we then closedit in andopened bag (annular).Got the pumpslined up. Told the them to let me know when the pill comesup so that we could do a sheentest. I thenwent to the office and checked what callsI had. They calledto saythe pill was backso I went to the rig floor. Everythingwas fine, checkedfor flow and it was ok. Had takensomespacer was l6ppg. Everythinglookedfine. with the spacer it in there,therewas still an 8 - 900 psi underbalance. The only otherthing is that if they hadalreadyopened dump line??- I didn't go the down there. The strokeson the panel looked aboutright - everythingwas fine when we were doingthe sheen test. The sheen waspassing. test said to go aheadand start dumping,told them everybodyget in place and start dumping. The plan was ro circulate thenwatch it for 30 minutes Reverted backto negative test. The Tourpusher and SeniorToolpusher told me it wasthis annularcompression thing. I wantedto do another test- I don't know why we didn't seepressure the kill on line?? Asked about procedurefor negativetesting - There is no standard procedureit is left for the rig to figure it out.

Asked what a successfultest looks like - did anyonesay - No. Justdo a negativetest for 30 minutes. haveneverseenprocedures this. I for The volumeof the pill was 450 barrels. Crews were always on the ball. The visitors did not take any focus away from the well. Steve askedfor help to annolate the chart and Don agreed. They shut in after the pill was abovethe stack. They were bleedingoff to Haliburton. They bled down and it cameback up. 1400psi was the differencebetweenthe mud and the seawater. I talked to Hafle aboutthe 1400- saidthat if therehad beena kick in the well we would haveseenit. When I first went to the rig floor we talked aboutthe 1400psi for a long time - they (TO Toolpusheretc) found it kind of humorousthat I talked about it for a long time. Asked aboul the TP crews - They were experienced, competenthands. lYho was on the rig floor - Randy Ez, JasonAnderson,Bob Kaluza, Driller, Mud Engineer, Leo and Gordon(they (mud Eng) werechanging wasn'tthere. out. Charles I then went back to the office to look at somepaperwork. I had beentherearound l0 - 15 minuteswhen Jason called- he saidwe aregettingmud backandwe are diverting to the gasbuster. I grabbedmy hat and startedfor the floor it must havetakenaround30 seconds get to outside. I went throughthe short hall and upstairstherewas mud and seawater blowing everywhere, therewas a mud film on the deck. I decided to continue not and camebackacross.Therewasthen an explosion a blast,I hunkered / down on the deck. I wason theportside blast the wasback. ............ I then proceeded the way to the piperack,got a life vestandwent to the bridgeto all seeif they had hit the emergency disconnect. I wantedto get the powershutoff but it went off - I don't recallif the powerwent off before or after the blast. I was glad it was off. I went to the bridge- the subsea handsaidwe shoulddisconnect we went to the panelandonly the lower annularwas closed. Christhenhit the button. It lookedlike it hit correctly- it all lit up. Sawthe galloncount. Chris saidhe sawthe stabretract. I was thentalking to peopleand gettingthem into the capsule therewere some injuredpeoplein the capsules. I stayedlong enoughto get everyone the capsule, in someguysjumped with a raft. The lastguy camein and we closedthe door.

I didn't seeany flameswhenthe explosion occured. The weatherwas calm. We hadn't back loadedall the mud - I told the mud engineerto keep some. I heardpeoplesay that the engineroom was gutted. We then went to the Bankston. rl/as asked if it had been mud or spacer that wss being sprayedfrom the well - it might have beenspacer, feeling is there was somemud. my Never indicatedany increase flow! I spoketo the mud logger- he didn't see in anything unusual. The mud engineerwas watching the returns. Don was asked- what doyou think happened- lhave no idea! AdditionalThe crewswere good. The divertercango overboard to the poor boy degasser. or When Jasoncalled to say he was diverting flow to the poor boy degasser also said he he eitherwasclosingor had closedthe bag (annular) Don thoughtthe diverterwas not closed- he said it appeared fluid was coming that from the rig floor. He estimated took him I or 2 rninutes get outsidewhen he got the call. it to Don did not know of any issues with the BOp system. Asked about being spacedoutfor the BoP - Don said that they were good about spacingout but didn't check. Askedabout block height - didn't know - saidhe would expectthemto be at the space position. out Didn't know if the shears would cut the tool ioint. Didn't know if therewas I or 2 overboard lineson the diverter. Stated - I don't know why that mud got so far up the riser. clarified - when the toolpusher calledhe didn't sayit was a blow out or kick. mud was comingbackand he was divertingto the gasbuster. on the boatthe SeniorToolpusher saidthe AD had calledto saythey hada well controlproblem. when I went outsideI waswonderingwhy they had not sounded general quarters I realised laterthat the fire alarmswere soundins.

well - you couldtell they hadbeendrilled. The crewsresponded on Our relationships the rig were good- they will call - we keepit open- we stopthe job. The relationshipwith the onshoreteam is good - neverhad a problem calling in day or night. We mostly dealwith Brian and Hafle - mostlyBrian Morel. Asked about the negativetestprogrom - Said it was a bullet programthat cameby email - we (offshore/ onshoreteam) talked aboutit, there was no formal approval- I neverhad instructionsthat I didn't think that peopleknew about - they were copiedon the emails- therewereno problems with communication. with me. Therewere no issues no with TO people, problemwith them communicating lYhen asked- Don repliedthat therewere no fatigue issueswith the crews. END.

Robinson, Martin, Cowie DonVidrine, BP nighttower holedrilledbeforehe arrived struggling withkicksand losses cut mudwt and closeto balance

logging wentok, sometool problems wipertrip pumpedout becausethey were closeto bal.closeto top (e 7t8\ 1000unitsof gas boftoms (not uncommon) up stayedlongerbecause of holefor a weekduringlogging out (static) holetook correct fillup 9718x7 inch casing, tripwentwell

leftstackopenwhilerunning throughriser at TD withcasingcleared pipe,circulated the 100+barrels returns (trouble gefting, eitherplugged losses) or job job cement wentok, complex w/difffluids,lookedlikeit went fine plug,set sealassmby, bumped tested,seemed be goodtest to pump1.5xdrillpipevol.to wipedrillpipewithnerfbatl run in holeto top of BOP's, closedshearrams,test casing, very goodtest basedon chart wentto depth,riggedup and started procedure displacement displaced pumped choke, boostlines, kill, pi[, disptacement followedby sw

not on rig floorat timeof neg test bleddrillpipeto 0, builtpress., they saidit was normat Kaluza toldby Sr toolpusher tourpushercalled annular and it compressionheardaboutthis,but had not seenit before decided checkkill lineside,no pressure, to pumped few strokes a on killline,pressured bledoff, shutin, builtto 30 psi bled.2bblto triptank

wentto a dripand stopped, watched 30 minswith no flow for drillpipehad 1400psi steady stayedat that pressure, indication gas comingup no of at beg of test,2400psiin drillpipe,differential a U-tube, on bled 60bblto 0psi 1400psi differential between mudand riser annular compressionthey said it doesthat all the time 1400psi, shouldbe seenon kill line- letsbleedit off and see, it bled,it stopped plug,saidstillwatching calledHafleto discuss surface stripping tank,dripping had stopped and everything looked fine Closedit in, openedthe bag,linedup pumps guyslet me knowwhen pillcomesup, do sheentest,wentto officeto checkcalls callto say pillwasback,wentto rig floor,everything fine realized that pointto checkflow- was not flowing far as he at as knows, shakerhandand mudeng monitoring mudeng said it camebackon rightstrokes, strokeslooked to ok Donon panel(didn'tknowexact#) sheentest passed, expected 800-900psi underbalance to reservoir theywerecomfortable test,he toldthemto get everyone with in placeto startdumping toolpusher Sr TP toldthemthiswas annular and compression askedaboutstandard procedure negative for tests,noneknown (comes fromtownin bulletform,procedure leftto rig to figure is out) whatdoesa successful looklike,checkfor flowor no-flow test haflecalledofficewhiledisplacing about9pm,thoughthe wasjust curious abouthowthings weregoing negtest- TO haddismissed pipepressure anything drilt as serious jokedaboutmy concern somewhat overdrillpipe- theyfoundit humorous I continued that talking about jasonanderson, Kaluza, In doghouse Ezell, bob dewey Sevette, mudeng LeoandGordon, maybe Charles Credeur Sheentest- after,returned ofc 10-15mins,rec'dcallfrom rio to floor- jason Jason(TP)calledand saidgettingmud back- diverting returns to gasbuster, (hadclosed) closing annular, hungup quickly Started floor,grabbed - downhall,upstairs for hat towardrig mudand seawater blowing (about30secelapsed everywhere time)positive was mud it decided notcontinue rig floor,wentbackaroundcorner, to to heardexplosion whichcausedhimto hunker down- did not see flamesat thattime

Don heardonlyone explosion. Powerwentout,didn'tknowit was beforeor afterexplosion crossedpipe rack to get life vest, Proceeded bridgeto see if to EDS had beenactivated Say manypeopleon bridge, met Subseahandin bridge(Chris) ChrisaskedaboutEDS wentto panel- only lowerannularlightswere lit at that pointChrishit EDSbutton panellit up, Chrissaid Lookedlikeit actuated correctly because he saw galloncountand stab retract Leftbridgeto help people capsules, to helpedinjured Someguysjumpedoverboard with life raft Lastguy cameintothe capsule, closeddoor- weather calm,went to Bankston Hadn'tbackloaded the mud,toldeng he hadto keepsome- my all feeling was therewas somemud Neverindicated increase flow any in Spoketo mudlogger whileon Bankston, didn'tsee anything he unusual beforeeventoccurred was watching returns Specifically askedhim whathe thought happened he saidhe had no idea started Horizon January, on in completed 14114 rotation 4 of hitches Crewsweregood Diverter go overboard to poorboydegasser can or HeardthatAD calledSr TP thatthey hada well control problem Appeared fluidcomingfromrig floor,didn'tthinkdiverter was closed. No issues known aboutBOPequipment Didn'tknowif 1 or 2 overboard lineson diverter lf spaceout was standard, Donsaidyes, postedin doghouse, crewsweregoodaboutdoingit, 5.5 acrossstack Blockposition beforeexplosion too muchsprayto seetop drive (notvisible, of mud) wall asked- fire alarms working? Yes Emergency drills- weekly, everyone responds accordingly Brianand MarkHafleusually communicates, Brianmostly Negative procedure test cameby email,peoplecopied make to aware Communication office, allgood with TO Fatigue issuesnot a problem 937amnextmorning, calledBrianMartin- this may meannothing, minorhydraulic leakon one of the pods,reported him by to suosea 3rd partyinfofrom Bakston 6pm negative test hadn'tstartedneg test,discussing use kiltline to preferred rnethod was BP kill line

TransOcean already usingdrillline Neg test performed usingkillline testtook20 mins 720-750 minsstatic, 30 testwas goodwhilehe watched, didn'twatchwholetest - went but back to offlce 1015jasonanderson toolpusher camein saidmudbackin displacement test Wentoutside(aft)mud blowing everywhere get couldn't to rig floor,thenheardfirstexplosion grabbed lifevest, bridge to pushedESDshutin button, didn'twork,pushed again- everyone evacuated statement CG to

Wetherbee, Anderson, 7 May 2010- Guillot,

ON Horizon sinceJan2010 fieldsince78 in oilfield since1971- office, neg test - annularusedto test - lowerI think eitherhe did of call madeto closeBOPbecause mudon floor,whatweretheyclosing- annular, or I did,notsure in bridge, beforeevac,what lightwas lit on panel- lowerannular, Justaboutsure' who hit EDS- nightSubsea hand wherewereyou whenhit - standing nextto him everything lightscame when hit,whatdid you all see - I don'tremember, appeared function, to we on, received responses weresupposed to did not see all panellit up goodgalloncountseen did he hit bothbuttons panel-'as I recallyes' on how longfromtimeof callof closingBOPsto EDS- ean'tsay,someminutes after,got callto go to floor, cameout to deck aft, mud blowingeverywhere, couldn'tget to floor,triedto go forwardto go up thatway, moving port,explosion got lifevest and wentto bridge- not suretimeframe to how manyblasts- firstone heard- afterhearda couplemore wheredid firstblastoccur- starboard, didn'tsee anything be sure,just feeling | was on but to port,wasn'toverthere when did lightsgo out - making way towards forward- not sureif rightbeforeor afterblast- | thinkbeforebut notcertain outwhenyou got to bridge I assume thoseon bridgewereemergency, deckwas all out but gen emergency on - don'tknow whenyou walkedto bridge, therewas lights- yes beforeexplosion, annular one closedwhichone - lower On the negative test,pressures beingbledoff by who - TO startedbleeding fromdrillpipesidenotsurewhenBobgoton rigfloor- butBobthenhadthembleed fromthe killlineperAPD how linedup to bleed- triptankoff chokeline bledbackto halliburton2 sets of linesriggedup, but not sure- feeling theywere bleeding back on that lineto halliburton, sureflow paththough not crewchangeduringnegtest- correct whenon tower,any morebleeding be done- no, all complete, to shutdown

BOPsetupany leaksin system- smallhydraulic leakon one of the pods,can'trecallwhichone, shouldbe on morning report not sureif it clearedup,or trashwas causing that is onlythingI was awareof EDSactivation, whensubseahandpushed, wherewas galloncountcomingfrom- don,tknow where,assume counter on when he pushedEDS buttons, werethey blinking solid- don'tremember or wereany lightsgreen- thinksomemighthavebeengreen- just got a response whilein drilling mode,EDSfunction at 1 or 2 - no,don,tknow set mud backto surface, comingthrough rotary, any odorsor smells- no, don,trecall wheresoundcomefrom- no, on port,not nearme - wentdown,mudon deck- don'tknow anything otherthanexplosion blast or on bridge was HPU unitstillintact, damage well bayarea- no, did not knowdamage or to anywhere Subseahandwentthrough actions, appeared all correct

Anderson 12May - Cowie,Guillot, rig Killlineclosed, pumps ftom drillers off console monitoring of with rig pumps,monitoring monitoring pumping and pumppressure readings screenon floorthat has Halliburton pressure chokelineside,chokevalves- wasn'tmoitoring it on on mud beingbledback,how informed volume- got on floor,wentoverto bleedbackin bbls, drillerreadoff logs- said he bledback67bblsbut don'tknowwherehe bledit to that it \A/here fluidgo - assuming wentto Halliburtondon'tknowif all wenttherethough, did wasn'tup therewhenall thatwas goingon was his understanding, test,when did theysay 67 - rightbeforenegative on kill line,we wentoverwhat test 1400psi theydid Anything elsebledoff afterthatotherthanwhatwentto mini-trip bledchoketo 0, about1/2 - wantedto makesureno pressure wouldaffectnegtest bblsvolumeat thattime that Chokelineopened allthe way to BOP- don'tthinkvalvewas open,just bledline,makingsure no pressure line- didn'twantanything bleeding on through valve openedkill up to stripping tank for negtest,bledback2110 andstopped Kaluzabledoff 34bbls beforestopped, drillerhad 67 end of negtest,everything holding, bledback,stillpressure DP against iBOP- yes, I think on
SO

how equalized openup - not sure,wasn'ttalking TP to to

who calledto say theywereclosingin well - TP JasonAnderson whatdid he say he wasclosing annular diverter anything closing or else- saidhe woulddivertretumsto gas buster closing annular yes TOI crewchange towers- 0000and 1200 no crewchangeduringthis process TP changed 1730-1800 at timeframe TP alreadyup therewhenI gotthere. Alsomudengineer changed

.\ i

'' 'u'/ 4

rl I .,g* i

1.. .,." 1 i't 1

..

" "..,-:'-

'\

|!-.!'t,n

\ : ,"..

| r

,r " | ."

!v,;.'/, {, ;,il*, . u , l * n '

'-i

tj '* - ",.1

ys,,,-;r: rjt,'*Jd - 31i'rl-. v.'t'. "i"t4'-'"'i,n'*'*/'{ {rv:,,,

i" "i

{, {"' ,' .-,1.. ,i

.,-.;{ .r

.t, ur.,:i ,t}, , ".*(

; t

r i* ,r,-rr,..:,.". .-"1

.,*r, .,,f,*- -",i- , ./ lL

.i! {.-irt ' ' ,.-)tt '!'t ;

}'!' ;i" *" "t'* o"

/'*'/- , v"",';r3'" ";t

I i'-* -., . ,rj, - ;; / *u ,/ , o-,' -.i,-..

i'-:u"* ,r,:r

+/

r,,,,,-.,1i..r,.r,/ ,rrr,..
f'; ,". -ri.y';t
,/" /-'-t ,t 'l '.. :

',

,'/ ' :/,. '.

;* -. . f

z-.r:

'f r -' & , t " 7/+

, '"/ir:'L**"

_"_)._"-*,

t\:-,- . ,n.i

-r. /.r,rL,.',
t': ' f..f --.; ' r' r

": 'lr'

"r

,"**

.-{' ! 't' "'-P;.;;.i "'

1l ,ti

rI '*-'

'"'

'h.", - ,.-.,,^' k ,.1..r.'1".

. ,' ^:..JJ -- | -. .l

l.:)"1- ,; ,-r t t
'_ 1l'

:ii

'' '

., ./,i

-z'1 tr ( l) ,11,,;.,' /,^o.r / , . ,. ,i

i
!-

..:
1r

'l-' '' lr/',,{ ,','i ':' l. ,- t "' 1 '*J .t rr r . .r 'i o"-i. ) . , , t , , : i t , ! , , . . ! , . . , / . , 0 . ' , : i ,,,-",r l, f , l i i , , - . ' ' '
. * *. , . r r . - i , i i !:"1:r'..* ;,, .,./i,.r,", ,,," t

' 1,i",/^ ,. J'.-,t i,,, ',, t ,i i,., "i .',

,-

,/r

i ,,,t,"|,f l rt

, ,1, -.-***-&;: ,-*'7,u.,:.rA "*

a ' j,'

'
,;J i'd t

'i

'-"a'!
,7 t::d'

r_

-'iir.i.

_.:.
i

.4"/ "

. . r/,l . . .

.!,1 /ti..

)-t.-.

(..."(,.{

/,-

, ' . t i .-. , ' . , '

;r

i-.-.-J ?

., z"r

i.';.r...-,

' ;' ..'l t

1l

l"';i'-'v, 1'
- ' a i / .

,v ::.f h:.. )c,i**

.*t i.

'-.::.

r-

4j

,-l-";!l'

, .,r.ys.p r *t zj
"

{-Y't-#':

1" ,.<,i.,.J{'n.u

;'1:

f -v-,-r'

t.'

.'a . .f

,.r'

; -.-:-r /.i;" i ,,

;dr/:{

/*!
'-t --Jr.+1. .-. .ll

'"

.frir., ..,,/i ,,,r,,'.

" '',;;/..-. {' ,.

.* .i.,.,..,..-,r,..

,,"-:./i '& ^'r'l'*r -

i" 1 ',, ii- -. ,|4'). ' .r .' x.i.-/

-:'{'{'.i] -'i"i' t'

'l

j-. ,_";t(,..i 1",.,.

}'*, '-t'tl*.g-'''

., .'

i
iS-"
:.1,.*-.:

'
*{
.^

,' *ry,. ^ . ;
,-.,5, *r't; rl,:

-'l!

./ i'/'',

,gs:

.-!/ '.

( ,:ti-*f' -'' ,J "'