Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lions of Florence
Lions of Florence
by
Kenneth White
and
"The Romance of Leonardo da Vinci"
by
Dmitri Merejkowski
Kenneth White
1108 Wellesley Avenue
Modesto, CA 95350-5044
(209) 567-0600
Ken1White@aol.com
1
FADE IN:
TITLE CARD
DR. MAURIZIO SERACINI, dressed in his usual tweed jacket and tie,
chews on his fingernails.
The two scholars sit side-by-side, staring across the top of two
high-resolution computer monitors. A digital version of each
sketch is displayed on each monitor.
2
SERACINI
Imagine, Leonardo and Michelangelo.
Painting in the same room. Side-by-
side.
PEDRETTI
Two tortured, insecure geniuses.
Obsessed with their legacy.
SERACINI
This was to be their signature
achievement.
(gestures expansively)
These lions of Florence.
MELINDA HENNEBERGER
A painting competition. How incredible.
PEDRETTI
Orchestrated by Niccolo Machiavelli,
the master manipulator.
SERACINI
It just doesn’t get any better.
SERACINI
Vasari transformed the Grand Hall into
the Granduke's hearing room. He built
new walls and covered them with his own
frescoes.
PEDRETTI
It was common to build a new wall
instead of knocking down the old one.
SERACINI
We’re studying the hall’s walls using
non-destructive, multi-spectral
diagnostic imaging. By employing a
portable echo-graph, we should be able
to penetrate Vasari’s walls with low-
frequency sound waves.
3
PEDRETTI
Simply put, we’re trying to identify
the exact spot where Leonardo and
Michelangelo painted their murals.
SERACINI
For sixty years, people came to admire
the horses of Leonardo.
PEDRETTI
Though flawed, it was a beautiful
fresco by a great artist.
SERACINI
They wouldn’t dare destroy it.
ASSISTANT
(to Seracini)
Line one for you, sir. A "Mr. Gates."
SERACINI
This is the Sala del Gran Consiglio of
the Palazzo Vecchio.
PEDRETTI
It was the seat of power for the
Florentine Republic. The city’s
democratic council, the Gran Consiglio,
met here from 1495 to 1512.
SERACINI
It was home to the Medici after they
returned to power in 1512.
4
PEDRETTI
Politically speaking, this is where the
Renaissance was born.
SERACINI
The paintings would have flanked the
throne of the Gonfaloniere, the chief
executive.
PEDRETTI
A man named Piero Soderini.
SERACINI
(gestures at fresco)
When I was analyzing the Vasari fresco,
I came upon a tiny green flag. There
were words written in white paint.
Cerca Trova. "Seek, and you shall
find."
SERACINI
I assumed it was a soldier's motto. As
I continued my research, I realized
there was no other writing on any of
the frescoes in the entire hall.
PEDRETTI
Sounds inviting, yes?
SERACINI
It was a message, you see.
PEDRETTI
A challenge.
HENNEBERGER
You believe Leonardo’s fresco still
exists?
5
SERACINI
I do. And I intend to find it. It is
the least I can do for my native
Florence.
PEDRETTI
Yesterday, we found a discontinuity. A
narrow space of some kind in the wall.
There, behind the panel where Cerca
Trova is written.
HENNEBERGER
A window to the past.
SERACINI
The fresco hasn't been seen for almost
five hundred years.
The falcon drops down and skims along the surface of the
river, as it flows into Florence.
DE' MEDICI
Florence is the most powerful city-
state the world has ever known. We must
celebrate the restoration of the
Republic.
SODERINI
I have called home all the artists
scattered by Savonarola, including
Leonardo and Michelangelo.
DE' MEDICI
Two artistic titans. Native sons of
this magnificent city. They must leave
us a legacy.
MACHIAVELLI
I have a wicked notion. Quite poetic,
actually.
DE' MEDICI
Speak plainly, secretary.
MACHIAVELLI
A contest. Commission each to paint a
fresco in the Sala Grande.
DE' MEDICI
Ah, yes. To the glory of Florence.
SODERINI
Side-by-side, for all the world to see
and marvel.
DE' MEDICI
Two frescoes by the two greatest
artists of our time. It is brilliant.
SODERINI
It will distract the citizens from the
French and Spanish invaders at our
gates.
DE' MEDICI
It is rumored they despise each other.
They cannot bear to be in the same
room.
SODERINI
We must convince them this competition
is worthy. For the sake of Florence.
MACHIAVELLI
Leave that to me.
LEONARDO
(caressing his beard)
Does the music soothe you, my lady?
MONNA LISA
It does, Nardo mio. It does.
LEONARDO
Your smile tells me so.
MONNA LISA
It is a pleasant evening.
LEONARDO
The light is so forgiving, so merciful.
LEONARDO
Sfumatissimo.
The work yard runs the full width of the block behind the
Duomo Works buildings. The front half of the yard serves as
quarters for the ARTISANS who maintain the cathedral.
ARGIENTO
Your father will be proud.
MICHELANGELO
(tugging at his sparse
goatee)
He'll be paid his florins. Then he'll
be proud. For him, money shines
brighter than fame.
ARGIENTO
It is poetry. It is perfection.
MICHELANGELO
Perfection is unattainable, Argiento.
Completeness is preferable.
BIRD VENDOR
Fricassee, fry, or stew. A bird for
every meal. A meal for every bird.
LEONARDO
I partake of no animal’s flesh.
BIRD VENDOR
Don’t know what ye’re fortakin’, sir.
LEONARDO
I will take them all.
BIRD VENDOR
A banquet, then?
Leonardo opens the cages, removes the birds, and tosses them
one-by-one into the sky.
LEONARDO
No, freedom.
He throws the bread at the beast and storms off through the
Piazza.
CATERINA
You were a white fledgling in a nest of
black crows, my little Nardo.
LEONARDO
I remember when father was away on
business. I would crawl into your bed
late at night.
CATERINA
With iceberg toes.
LEONARDO
You protected me from the night demons,
dearest Mother.
CATERINA
That was a very long time ago.
LEONARDO
I am all that I am because of you.
CATERINA
I have some things for you.
CATERINA
I wove the linen myself.
LODOVICO
If the Medici think you’re dry fruit,
you will not make a single scudo.
MICHELANGELO
There's more than one family in
Florence willing to patronize the arts.
LODOVICO
What has happened to your pride?
MICHELANGELO
Pride is a sin.
LODOVICO
Are you to earn nothing forever?
MICHELANGELO
I will earn.
LODVICO
When? How?
MICHELANGELO
I don't know.
LODOVICO
Two dozen times you have said "No," or
"I don't know." When will you know?
MICHELANGELO
I don't know.
LODOVICO
I should beat you with a stick. When
will you get some sense in your head?
MICHELANGELO
I'm doing what I must. That is sense.
Lodovico slaps his own forehead with the flat of his hand.
13
LODOVICO
You are an artist. Whoever heard of a
Buonarroti an artist? I don't know any
more what a man has sons for!
MICHELANGELO
Trust me, Father. I am not looking for
wool on an ass.
GRANACCI
They burned Savonarola on this spot.
The faithful place these ashes here
each night to honor his memory.
They cross the plaza to the broad steps leading up into the
Signoria courtyard. Distracted by a noise, they stop at the
base of the statue of Judith by Donatello, and turn.
GRANACCI
Ah, Leonardo.
MICHELANGELO
Who's that with him?
14
GRANACCI
Giacomo Caprotti, his apprentice . . .
and companion. Leonardo calls him
Salai—devil—because he acts so badly
and looks so beautiful.
MICHELANGELO
(mutters, slightly
embarrassed)
He is lovely.
GRANACCI
Compared to Leonardo, Salai is dull.
GRANACCI
Don't be fooled by the elegant
exterior, Mic. Leonardo has a
magnificent brain.
MICHELANGELO
With an ego to match.
GRANACCI
He has been dissecting animals for
years, and keeping meticulous notebooks
of his anatomical drawings.
MICHELANGELO
Humans as well, I hear.
GRANACCI
He is an engineer and inventor of
amazing machines. Even now, he is
completing experiments for a machine
that will fly through the air as the
birds do.
MICHELANGELO
God did not intend man to fly. If he
had, he would've given us bird's
brains.
15
GRANACCI
It is a dazzling performance he puts
on, imitating a rich nobleman. He hopes
to persuade the world to forget that he
is the illegitimate son of a Vinci
innkeeper's daughter.
MICHELANGELO
He's very convincing. An effective
actor.
GRANACCI
Ah, yes, but he is the only man in
Florence who works as hard and long as
you do. Look for the real Leonardo
beneath that facade.
LEONARDO
Father?
LEONARDO
Look at me, please. I want to get the
eyes right.
PIERO DA VINCI
You look well, my son. Even prosperous.
LEONARDO
(without conviction)
My house is in good order.
PIERO DA VINCI
Although you are a grown man, I still
worry.
LEONARDO
I know.
PIERO DA VINCI
Is there nothing I can do for you?
16
LEONARDO
You have done enough.
PIERO DA VINCI
I have much to give and little time to
give it.
LEONARDO
You will outlive us all. Save it for
the inheritance.
PIERO DA VINCI
Ever the practical son.
LEONARDO
(mumbles to himself)
For a bastard.
PIERO DA VINCI
I’m sorry, I did not hear you. My ears
are almost as bad as my eyes.
LEONARDO
I said basta. Enough for the day. The
light is leaving us.
PIERO DA VINCI
Ah, so it is. So it is.
MICHELANGELO
(whispers to Granacci)
Who’s that?
GRANACCI
Contessina. The only daughter of
Lorenzo the Magnificent. Sister to
Piero. Why?
MICHELANGELO
No reason.
17
GRANACCI
You care nothing for girls. They might
as well be radishes. You know nothing
about what it means to be mattress-
able.
The odd couple stroll around the work yard, inspecting the
sculptures. They circle back toward Michelangelo. And stop
in front of him.
CONTESSINA
(to the fat man)
The stone has a smell.
MICHELANGELO
(without looking up)
Freshly picked figs.
CONTESSINA
And this?
CONTESSINA
Does it smell of freshly picked plums?
MICHELANGELO
No, it has hardly any.
MICHELANGELO
Here, smell for yourself.
CONTESSINA
Why do you work so . . . so furiously?
It would exhaust me.
18
MICHELANGELO
Cutting stone doesn't take strength
out, it puts it back.
CONTESSINA
It is a foreign land.
MICHELANGELO
Here, try it yourself. It's amazing how
alive it becomes under your hands.
CONTESSINA
Beneath your hands, perhaps. Will you
finish that for me?
MICHELANGELO
It’s nothing.
CONTESSINA
I like it.
MICHELANGELO
I will finish it.
MERCHANT
To the Company of the Cauldron!
19
CROWD
To the Company!
MERCHANT
And the restoration of the culinary
arts to the Pantheon of noble arts for
the first time since Roman times.
CROWD
To food!
MERCHANT
Savonarola should have known better.
Gluttony is not a vanity.
CROWD
To gluttony!
GRANACCI
They are here to honor you, Mic. Do not
embarrass us.
SODERINI
To the David, Il Gigante. The first
major commission agreed upon by all
since the death of Savonarola.
SODERINI
To Florence. The first city of the
world.
SODERINI
To our rebirth.
Old ROSSELLI, the man on the litter, gestures for the throng
to be quiet. He motions for the other eleven members of the
Company to move closer so they can hear him. They do.
ROSSELLI
I am too old to enjoy these orgies of
meat and drink any longer.
ROSSELLI
As much as I dislike promoting anyone
from a rival studio, I herewith resign
from the Company. And nominate
Michelangelo Buonarroti to succeed me.
THE TWELVE
Welcome to the Company!
RUSTICI
You know what this means? You cook next
month.
LEONARDO
I refused to compete for the David
commission because, well, because
sculpture is such a mechanical art.
BOTTICELLI
Perhaps it had more to do with your
reputation for not completing
commissions.
ROSSELLI
Surely you would not call Donatello a
mechanic?
LEONARDO
In some ways, yes. Sculpture is so much
less intellectual than painting.
BOTTICELLI
Still, for a commission as important as
the David?
LEONARDO
No, no, I would never carve marble. At
day's end, the marble carver is as
filthy as a baker. His clothes stink.
When I paint, I work in my finest
clothes. I end the day as immaculate as
I began it. No, sculpting does not suit
me. No, indeed.
MICHELANGELO
(mutters under his
breath)
One day I will make Leonardo eat those
words.
LEONARDO
(oblivious)
Sculpture is for laborers.
MICHELANGELO
Sculpture is the first and original
art.
LEONARDO
It was. Until the fine art of painting
was developed. Carving is extinct.
MICHELANGELO
The sculptor comes closer to the truth.
He carves from reality. The painter
creates an illusion, a magical trick.
You can walk around a statue. You can’t
walk around a painting.
LEONARDO
The painter can portray the entire
universe. The sky, rain, stars, rivers.
The sculptor makes a man, a horse, then
does it all over again. Monotonous.
Tedious. Sculpture is a bore.
MICHELANGELO
Painting is perishable. Stone is
eternal. Show me a painting that’s as
old as the Greek statues in the de'
Medici garden.
LEONARDO
Or as cold.
MICHELANGELO
Isn't it true, Leonardo, that your
equestrian statue in Milan is so
colossal that it can never be cast? No
wonder you talk against sculpture.
You're not capable of finishing your
work!
23
MERCHANT
He is a master of self-promotion.
24
SOLDIER
Narcissist. It’s all about Leonardo.
It’s always about Leonardo.
MICHELANGELO
(to himself)
Leonardo has dissected. There is no
doubt now.
Michelangelo closes the folio, withdraws a folded sheet of
wrinkled paper and a short nub of charcoal from his work
shirt. He plunges into copying the three figures in the
massive cartoon.
LEONARDO
Water is the essence of nature. It is
to the world what blood is to our
bodies.
SALAI
It nourishes and destroys.
LEONARDO
The world will end in a flood.
Leonardo lays down his sketch pad and removes some drawings
from a leather folio.
LEONARDO
Machiavelli and I have designed a way
to control the Arno. We will build a
canal that connects the Arno to the
sea. A series of locks will carry the
water uphill to Florence.
SALAI
Magnificent. Truly original.
LEONARDO
The past flows into the present and
feeds the future. It is all connected.
RUSTICI
That will be all, Vermiglia.
RUSTICI
If you don’t like Vermiglia, she has a
buffet of cousins. Would you like her
to choose one for you?
RUSTICI
I think she’s lonely here, Angelo. It
would be a pleasant life.
MICHELANGELO
Thank you, caro. I have a way of life.
As for casual affairs, what you put
into the ladies at night, you can't put
into the marble in the morning.
Rustici sips from his goblet of wine, then stares out at the
Arno.
26
RUSTICI
Cesare Borgia is marching on Urbino.
They say he’s helping incite a
rebellion in Arezzo against Florentine
rule.
MICHELANGELO
He will not be satisfied until he rules
the entire peninsula.
RUSTICI
Leonardo has joined Borgia's army as an
engineer. I detect the hand of
Machiavelli in this.
MICHELANGELO
Leonardo is a traitor. He trades
Sforza, the tyrant of Milan, for
Borgia, the tyrant of Rome.
RUSTICI
Borgia pays him well.
MICHELANGELO
To draw war maps of Florence. We give
him hospitality, commissions to paint,
and that is how he thanks us.
RUSTICI
Leonardo is at loose ends. He can't
seem to finish his painting of Monna
Lisa.
MICHELANGELO
What else is new?
RUSTICI
He's more interested in testing his new
war machines than his art. He doesn't
understand politics, you know.
MICHELANGELO
Tell that to his fellow Florentines
when his war machines batter down our
walls. He says he respects all life,
yet he designs the most terrifying
weapons of mass destruction we’ve ever
known.
27
RUSTICI
He’s amoral, Angelo. He’s not
interested in right and wrong as it
applies to people. Only in the true and
false of science and knowledge.
MICHELANGELO
I should be glad to be rid of him, I
suppose. He fled once before, you know.
RUSTICI
Yes, that messy business with the male
prostitute. He nearly burned at the
stake for that morsel.
MICHELANGELO
I hope we can count on his absence for
at least another eighteen years.
RUSTICI
You two stand like the Apennines above
the rest of us, yet you hate each
other. It doesn't make sense. Or does
it?
SODERINI
Leonardo da Vinci is a great painter.
MACHIAVELLI
I have seen the Last Supper in Milan.
It is tremendous. No one in all of
Italy can equal him.
SODERINI
I am envious of Milan's fresco. You
pledged one for Florence.
MACHIAVELLI
I am very close. With the right
incentive, he will give Florence what
he gave Milan.
28
SODERINI
We may not have the strongest army, but
we have the greatest artists.
MACHIAVELLI
Leonardo is as hard to hold as Proteus.
The contract must be very specific.
SODERINI
Will he finish? Or, will he abandon it
for another distraction?
MACHIAVELLI
I’ll bet my life on it.
SODERINI
You may have to.
MACHIAVELLI
(taken aback)
Patience, Gonfaloniere. Patience.
SODERINI
You gave me your word, secretary. Where
I come from, a broken promise can be
lethal.
MACHIAVELLI
I will not disappoint.
SODERINI
What of Michelangelo? Is he committed?
MACHIAVELLI
I have a plan.
SODERINI
So be it.
MACHIAVELLI
Michelangelo is a melancholy young man,
driven. He must be drawn out by
kindness and flattery. He cares little
for money, but his father has enough
greed for them both. We can obtain his
services for a song.
SODERINI
It is settled then. Let the game begin.
THE PRIOR
Leonardo is returned?
MICHELANGELO
Soderini has given him the keys to the
Grand Hall of the Signoria.
THE PRIOR
He has accepted the commission, then?
MICHELANGELO
A fresco. For the wall behind the
platform on which Gonfaloniere Soderini
and the Signoria sit.
THE PRIOR
They pay him ten thousand florins for
this?
MICHELANGELO
The largest commission since the death
of Savonarola. Given to a man who would
help Borgia conquer Florence. They only
gave me four hundred florins for my
David.
THE PRIOR
Do not be greedy, my son.
MICHELANGELO
I must have a greater commission.
THE PRIOR
What about the commissions you’ve
already promised.
MICHELANGELO
They can wait.
THE PRIOR
By what right? What you have begun, you
must finish! Do not be Leonardo. Honor
your commitments.
MICHELANGELO
This is my great opportunity, Prior
Bichiellini. I can create something
glorious. I can shame Leonardo.
The Prior pushes his papers aside, his eyes blazing behind
his spectacles.
30
THE PRIOR
There is only a God-given number of
years in which to work and fulfill
yourself. Do not squander them in petty
quarrels.
LEONARDO
If I could only talk to Michelangelo
for a while, face-to-face. He would
understand that I am no enemy of his.
There is no man who could come to love
him as I.
MONNA LISA
Would he truly understand?
LEONARDO
He would. He feels jealousy and fear
because he is shy and unsure of
himself. He has no reason to fear me.
When I beheld his David, I could not
believe my eyes. No one can imagine who
he is, and what he will be. I feel
that, even now, he is not only equal to
me, but stronger.
MONNA LISA
Messer Buonarotti may be as strong as
the wind that shakes the mountains.
But, he does not possess the still
voice, the calm, wherein the Lord
dwells. He knows this, and hates you
because you are stronger than he is,
even as the calm is more potent than
the tempest.
LEONARDO
It is finished.
31
FILARETE
There is only one place for the Giant
to reside and that is where the
Donatello Judith stands. The Judith was
erected under an evil constellation. We
have gone from bad to worse since.
MONCIATTO
The Giant was meant to adorn the Duomo.
It would be a suitable ornament to
Santa Maria del Fiore.
ROSSELLI
Messer Filarete and Messer Monciatto
speak the truth. However, I believe the
best place is on the stairs of the
Duomo.
32
LEONARDO
I choose the Loggia dei Lanzi to the
west of the Palazzo Vecchio because the
marble will be protected.
Michelangelo scowls.
MICHELANGELO
(hisses under his
breath)
The back of the statue will be
condemned to permanent shadow. The
Loggia will dwarf my Giant, you old
fool.
DA SANGALLO
My brother Antonio and I agree. It must
be kept out of the rain. The marble is
soft and has suffered already from
exposure.
IL CRONACA
What about the Grand Hall? Where
Leonardo's fresco is to be painted.
Michelangelo glowers.
MICHELANGELO
(mutters)
Isn't there one man here who will say I
should have the right to select the
spot?
LIPPI
Everyone has said wise things. But, I
am sure the sculptor will propose the
best place. He has certainly considered
longer, and with more authority, the
location where the Colossus should be
placed.
MANFIDI
Before your magnificent lords decide
where the statue ought to be placed, I
suggest that you ask the advice of the
Signori, among whom are many respected
intellects.
SODERINI
In front of the principal entrance to
the Palazzo Signoria, in the Ringhiera,
where the Judith now stands. As a
symbol of the valiant Republic. That
will please the Republic. It will
please the artist. It will please me.
LEONARDO
The haranguing place. The arrogance of
it all. I will live to tell them all,
"I told you so."
SALIA
Be calm, my lord.
LEONARDO
They have dubbed him my equal in
sculpture. On what basis? One statue.
SALAI
A breathtaking statue.
LEONARDO
One nonetheless. I am replaced because
I did not have the time to finish the
Sforza statue.
SALAI
Or the money.
34
LEONARDO
Precisely. What now? Will he challenge
me at painting? The audacity.
SALAI
He cares nothing about painting. He
said as much before the Company.
LEONARDO
I will not let him win. They should be
talking about me, praising me. I am the
center of it all. La Giaconda will
prove it.
SALAI
It shall be your masterpiece. Your
legacy.
LEONARDO
If only I had accepted the commission
for the David. If only he had not come
along. If only the Giant had not been
born.
LEONARDO
If only I could snap my fingers and it
would all be gone. And things would be
as they had been. If only.
WORKERS rip out a portion of the brick wall behind the work
shed in the rear yard.
35
YOUNG BOYS smooth the road leading away from the yard toward
the spire of the Palazzo Vecchio.
As the heavy frame inches its way forward, the rear log is
released, picked up by WORKMEN who run forward, and place it
under the front of the cage.
The David, secured at the crotch and upward over the chest
with ropes, sways slightly against the slip knots.
PROCESSION
The statue moves slowly, inexorably, out the yard and down
the Street of the Clock to the corner. The workers maneuver
the sharp turn into the Via del Proconsolo, and down that
street a half block.
CITIZENS
Good night!
Until tomorrow!
Good luck!
May God go with you!
Glory be to Florence!
MICHELANGELO
Guards!
36
MICHELANGELO
Stop! Guards! Stop them!
Two GUARDS, one with a broken nose and one with a dead eye,
wait there, holding lanterns.
BROKEN NOSE
What's all the noise?
MICHELANGELO
(pointing at the
David)
He was being stoned.
DEAD EYE
(looking around for
someone)
He who?
MICHELANGELO
(frustrated, pointing)
Him.
BROKEN NOSE
(scanning the night)
There's no one here.
MICHELANGELO
The statue.
DEAD EYE
Stoned? By?
MICHELANGELO
I don't know.
BROKEN NOSE
Did they hit it . . . him?
MICHELANGELO
(picking up a stone)
I don't think so. I only heard these
hit the cage.
37
DEAD EYE
(nudging his partner
in the ribs)
You're sure you weren't having a bad
dream?
MICHELANGELO
I tell you I saw them. And heard them.
If I hadn't been here . . .
SODERINI
Do you have enemies?
MICHELANGELO
None that I know of.
FILARETE
We should rather ask, "Does Florence,
does the Republic, have enemies?"
MICHELANGELO
(nods toward Leonardo)
What of Leonardo?
SODERINI
Impossible. He’s above that sort of
thing.
MICHELANGELO
He may not have picked the stones, but
he certainly could’ve paid for them.
MICHELANGELO
To what purpose?
MICHELANGELO
Jealousy. Pure and simple.
38
FILARETE
Of what? He has no equal.
MICHELANGELO
(glowers)
Not yet.
SODERINI
(smiles a smug smile)
We shall see. We shall see.
MICHELANGELO
Just let them try again tonight.
MICHELANGELO
Why would you stone my statue?
When no one speaks up, Broken Nose prods one of the younger
men who wears no shoes.
BAREFOOT VANDAL
They made us.
Another of the older boys, who wears a gold cross around his
neck, steps forward to stand beside his compatriot.
39
MICHELANGELO
There is an old Tuscan saying. "Art has
an enemy called ignorance."
LEONARDO
I am afraid.
MACHIAVELLI
Of what, maestro?
LEONARDO
Failing, as I did in Milan.
40
MACHIAVELLI
The Last Supper was a noble experiment.
As close to perfection as man can
attain.
LEONARDO
I fear that above all.
MACHIAVELLI
What, dear sir?
LEONARDO
Perfection. Nature is perfect. I cannot
compete with nature.
MACHIAVELLI
Pursue completeness, not perfection,
Leonardo. Perfection is something man
aspires to. Woman, on the other hand,
inclines by nature to completeness.
LEONARDO
It is true. It is nearly impossible to
be free of defect.
MACHIAVELLI
This time will be different.
LEONARDO
I am not sure.
MACHIAVELLI
(lying through gritted
teeth)
Michelangelo has been commissioned.
LEONARDO
Commissioned? For what?
MACHIAVELLI
To paint.
LEONARDO
He is a sculptor.
MACHIAVELLI
He says he will school you in painting.
41
LEONARDO
School me? The great Leonardo.
Impossible. The pupil would do well to
learn from the master.
MACHIAVELLI
They say he is twice the artist you
were at his age.
LEONARDO
"They" have much to learn.
MACHIAVELLI
He says you are a woman if you will not
accept this challenge.
MACHIAVELLI
If, for whatever reason, you choose not
to accept the commission, I may have
something else of interest.
LEONARDO
Pray, what is that?
MACHIAVELLI
The French governor is seeking a
military advisor. You would have duties
similar to those you performed for
Cesare Borgia when we first met.
LEONARDO
Do the French pay well? I have a
lifestyle to support.
MACHIAVELLI
Better than the Pope. In cash.
MACHIAVELLI
They have forgotten you.
MICHELANGELO
As I knew they would.
MACHIAVELLI
They take the magnificent David for
granted.
MICHELANGELO
The city talks only of Leonardo and the
new commission.
LODOVICO
You have had your day and it has
passed.
Michelangelo rubs his broken nose.
MACHIAVELLI
Florence has proclaimed Leonardo the
first artist of Tuscany.
MICHELANGELO
Florentines are fickle. I’ll go where
I’m appreciated.
LODOVICO
Where would that be?
MICHELANGELO
To Constantinople. To build a bridge
across the Bosporus for the Ottoman.
MACHIAVELLI
The Turkish emperor is more capricious,
and dangerous, than all the princes of
Florence.
MICHELANGELO
I've had worse patrons.
LODOVICO
You give up too easily. You always have
and always will. You haven’t the
backbone.
MACHIAVELLI
This is the chance you’ve been waiting
for all your life. To excel in
Leonardo’s own field of art.
43
LODOVICO
To show all of Florence, nay the world,
that you are now the master.
MACHIAVELLI
To let them see with their own eyes.
Your vision, side-by-side with his. It
will be no contest.
LODOVICO
It will make you more valuable to your
benefactors. Perhaps they will pay you
what you’re worth.
MACHIAVELLI
Do this for our beloved city. Do this
for the glory of Florence.
MICHELANGELO
Stop badgering me. My head hurts.
MACHIAVELLI
If you’re not the measure of this
commission, I know of another
opportunity.
MACHIAVELLI
I have spoken with the emissaries of
Pope Julius II about you. He’s seeking
someone to sculpt his tomb. I told them
only one man can do the job.
MACHIAVELLI
What?
MICHELANGELO
Water. I need water.
LODOVICO
There is none.
MACHIAVELLI
What do you do when you run dry?
44
MICHELANGELO
No good scalpellino ever ran out of
spit.
LEADER
(reads)
"'Philosophy,' my master answered me,
'To him who understands it, demonstrates
How nature takes her course, not only from
Wisdom divine, but from its art as well.
And if you read with care your book of
physics,
After the first few pages, you will find
That art, as best it can, doth follow nature,
As pupil follows master.'"
MICHELANGELO
(mutters to himself)
Immortal Dante. Canto XI of the
Inferno.
LEONARDO
Here is Michelangelo. He knows Dante
very well. Better than I. He will
explain the verses.
MICHELANGELO
Explain them yourself. You unnatural
bastard!
LEONARDO
I was not mocking you. I asked in
earnest. It is not my fault these
others laughed.
GRANACCI
What is it, old friend?
MICHELANGELO
(sobs)
My dearest Florence has made it clear.
I’ll never be Leonardo. I’ll never be
as handsome, as graceful, as famous.
MICHELANGELO
I am the best draftsman in all Italy.
No one will believe it by my simply
saying it. I must prove it.
GRANACCI
How?
MICHELANGELO
A fresco. Of the same proportions as
Leonardo's. In the same room. He asked
for the entire eastern wall of the
Grand Hall. He was given the right
half. I’ll ask Soderini for the left
half. I’ll display my skill side-by-
side with the great Leonardo. I’ll
prove that I can out-paint him, figure
for figure! All the world will see and
judge. Then Florence can say who is
truly the first artist of our time!
GRANACCI
This obsession is a sickness, a fever.
We must find some way to cure you.
MICHELANGELO
That’s not funny.
GRANACCI
I was not trying to be. What you cannot
stand is Leonardo's proximity.
MICHELANGELO
The smell of his perfume, perhaps.
GRANACCI
There are times when a bath would not
kill you.
MICHELANGELO
Get out of my sight, you . . . you
traitor!
47
GRANACCI
I did not bring up the subject of
smells, you did. Why bother yourself
over his painting, when you have years
of sculpture at hand? Forget him.
MICHELANGELO
He's a thorn in my side.
GRANACCI
Suppose you come out second best? What
then?
MICHELANGELO
Trust me, Granacci, I'll come out
first. I have to.
EXT. MONTE CECERI - DAY
At a spot where the crag juts out and the wind is calm,
Leonardo sits on a stone to rest. Salai sits beside him.
They look down upon Florence, transparently lilac in the
smoky haze of the afternoon sun.
LEONARDO
Ah, Tuscany. Eternally green.
(recites)
"Italy is the garden of Europe, Tuscany
is the garden of Italy, Florence is the
flower of Tuscany."
SALAI
Florence sparkles like an amethyst.
LEONARDO
The apprentice is becoming a poet.
SALAI
I meant no offense.
LEONARDO
None taken.
SALAI
You feel at home here on the mountain,
dearest Nardo.
48
LEONARDO
It reminds me of Monte Albano and
Vinci. I spent my childhood climbing
its back.
SALAI
It's a good place to reflect.
LEONARDO
And escape.
SALAI
From what?
LEONARDO
Expectations. Loneliness. Despair.
SALAI
Over what?
LEONARDO
My reputation, my work. Questions
whether it will ever be more than a
worthless, unfinished mess.
SALAI
Your fame will outlive us all.
LEONARDO
(recites)
"O vain glory, of all human powers,
How briefly green endures upon the peak
. . .
In painting Cimabue thought he excelled
And now it is Giotto that is celebrated
And the fame of the first is growing
dark."
SALAI
Dante?
LEONARDO
Dante.
(he stands)
Never place your hope on the morrow,
sweet pea.
Just then, a GIANT WHITE SWAN floats up over the edge of the
bluff. It hovers there, waiting.
LEONARDO
I knew you would come again.
The swan drifts away from the edge of the bluff, beckoning
Leonardo to join it in flight.
Salai and the swan glance at each other. Salai runs to the
edge.
Salai and the swan sigh a sigh of relief. The swan waits for
Leonardo.
SODERINI
(leaning away)
Phew. What did the barber put on your
hair?
MICHELANGELO
(flushes and stammers)
. . . a scented oil . . .
SODERINI
(to a groom)
Get a towel.
SODERINI
Rub that out. Stick to your own smells.
At least they're unique.
MICHELANGELO
I’ve always valued your honesty,
Gonfaloniere.
SODERINI
Now, then, what brings you here on this
warm afternoon?
MICHELANGELO
Troubles, Gonfaloniere. But, no one
comes here to share his pleasures.
SODERINI
That's why I sit behind such a spacious
desk. It can hold all the problems of
Florence.
MICHELANGELO
It’s your shoulders that are broad.
MICHELANGELO
I’ve come seeking a favor.
MICHELANGELO
I wish a commission.
SODERINI
You have much on your plate now.
MICHELANGELO
I have many stone works. I wish to
paint a fresco.
SODERINI
You have no experience painting fresco.
MICHELANGELO
That’s never stopped me before, or
others before me.
51
SODERINI
(playing out some
line)
And, where would you like to paint this
fresco?
MICHELANGELO
In the Sala Grande. Behind the podium
from which you govern.
SODERINI
(playing out a little
more line)
We already have someone painting a
fresco there.
MICHELANGELO
Leonardo, I know. Everybody knows. I
wish to paint beside him.
SODERINI
Everyone knows you dislike him.
MICHELANGELO
What does it matter who, or what, I
like or dislike?
SODERINI
You've told me yourself you never liked
the fresco work at Ghirlandaio's.
MICHELANGELO
I was wrong. I can paint fresco. Better
than Leonardo.
SODERINI
Are you sure?
MICHELANGELO
I'll put my hand in fire.
SODERINI
Even supposing you can, why would you
want to take the years away from the
marble? Your Madonna for the Bruges
merchants is divine. So is the Pitti
tondo.
52
MACHIAVELLI
Your talent is a gift from God.
MACHIAVELLI
Why would you throw it away for an art
you consider second-rate?
MICHELANGELO
You were so thrilled, Gonfaloniere, to
convince Leonardo to paint your wall.
You said the world would come to see
it.
SODERINI
And they will.
MICHELANGELO
Why wouldn’t twice as many come to view
two panels? One by Leonardo, the other
by me? It would be a great palio, a
great race. It would excite people. And
bring great glory to Florence.
SODERINI
You think you can surpass him?
MICHELANGELO
On my mother’s grave.
SODERINI
The Signoria will never approve. You
already have a contract with the Wool
Guild and Duomo to carve the Twelve
Apostles.
MICHELANGELO
I'll carve them. But, the other half of
the wall must be mine. I don't need two
years, as Leonardo does. I'll do it in
one year, ten months, eight
. . .
SODERINI
No. I can’t let you get yourself into
trouble. I won’t let you promise what
you can’t deliver.
53
MICHELANGELO
Because you don't believe I can do it?
You're right not to believe, since I
come here with only words in my hands.
Next time, I’ll bring drawings. Then
you’ll see what I can do.
SODERINI
(nettled in spite of
himself)
Come back with a marble Apostle
instead. That's why we built you that
workshop. To carve Apostles.
MICHELANGELO
Because you’re a wise and persuasive
Gonfaloniere.
MACHIAVELLI
Who is going to get the city to pay for
painting the other half of the wall.
LEONARDO
My apologies, Niccolo.
MACHIAVELLI
None required.
LEONARDO
There is so much to do and so little
time.
MACHIAVELLI
Your mind is insatiable, your energy
unlimited.
Excited, Leonardo unrolls a scroll, flattens it with a
wooden model of a flying machine and a clay model of the
Vitruvian man.
LEONARDO
I have sketched more ideas for our
project to re-route the Arno away from
Pisa. Our dream of making Florence a
sea port is within reach.
MACHIAVELLI
That’s what I’ve come to talk with you
about.
LEONARDO
Has the funding run out again?
MACHIAVELLI
No, but the gonfaloniere’s patience
has.
LEONARDO
The fresco?
MACHIAVELLI
The contract is clear. If you miss any
deadlines, you forfeit the entire
amount.
LEONARDO
I know, I know.
55
MACHIAVELLI
I pulled many strings as secretary of
the chancellery to get you this
commission. Don’t make me look the
fool.
LEONARDO
I cannot find . . .
(stops rummaging)
When is the first deadline?
MACHIAVELLI
Already past.
LEONARDO
And the second?
MACHIAVELLI
Also past.
LEONARDO
Yes, I see.
MACHIAVELLI
Do you? You must focus at the expense
of all other projects!
LEONARDO
Yes, I will focus.
MACHIAVELLI
Our necks are at stake.
LEONARDO
I said I would.
MACHIAVELLI
Would you prefer that Michelangelo
finish his cartoon first? He will, you
know. Because he works harder. How will
that make you look?
LEONARDO
This contest is vulgar.
MACHIAVELLI
Michelangelo is eager for the duel.
56
LEONARDO
I am too old to have to compete.
MACHIAVELLI
Michelangelo isn’t.
LEONARDO
The gauntlet is thrown? The challenge
made?
MACHIAVELLI
It is.
LEONARDO
Then he will rue the day.
Leonardo finally finds what he was searching for. It is a
bird’s feather.
A WOOL DYER, one arm dyed blue the other red, sits across
the table from the money changer. He’s surrounded by other
ANXIOUS MEN, clamoring for attention, their outstretched
hands filled with coins and bills.
The money changer takes a swig from the tankard, licks his
lips, and slams the tankard hard on the table.
MONEY CHANGER
Now I’m ready. Back to business.
The wool dyer slides some coins across the table. The money
changer carefully counts them.
MONEY CHANGER
Your wager?
57
WOOL DYER
Ten florins.
MONEY CHANGER
On?
WOOL DYER
Broken-nose.
MONEY CHANGER
To?
WOOL DYER
Shame the Milanese whore Leonardo.
GAMBLERS
(at once)
Leonardo!
Michelangelo!
The Vincan!
Buonarroti!
The lyre player!
The quarryman!
BUTCHER
A week’s wages that neither man
finishes.
MONEY CHANGER
An interesting proposition.
BUTCHER
Consider their history. They are master
procrastinators both.
MONEY CHANGER
It will be a battle of the titans.
58
BUTCHER
And Florence will be the greater for
it.
HAIRY MONK
Pietra mossa non fa muschio. A rolling
stone gathers no moss.
The banker pauses and thinks a moment. Struck with a
thought, he pulls a nub of charcoal and a small piece of
paper from his vest and scribbles something. He continues,
veering suddenly down a muddy alleyway.
The banker steps into the main room, stops, and sniffs the
air.
BANKER
Not Patchouli oil. Pop into the
Sixteenth Century, my good man.
BANKER
I must know.
LAZERIUS
It is still too dark to see.
BANKER
I intend to place a sizeable wager. The
future of my bank depends on certainty.
LAZERIUS
Uncertainty is the only certainty.
BANKER
Stop talking in riddles.
LAZERIUS
Riddles are what I know.
BANKER
Who will prevail?
LAZERIUS
It is a competition in lateness.
BANKER
Which man will finish before the other?
LAZERIUS
I still cannot divine.
BANKER
Who will be crowned the first artist of
Florence?
LAZERIUS
Come again. Another day, Messer
Zimmerman.
LEONARDO
Please open the doors. Let my adoring
public see me at work.
Salai and some STUDENTS fling open all the doors and
windows.
MICHELANGELO
Lock the door. I don’t want any
distractions. Or witnesses.
MACHIAVELLI
The Battle of Anghiari. It was a
cavalry battle fought by the Tribes of
the Dragon.
LEONARDO
Horses. I can paint horses.
61
MACHIAVELLI
di Vespucci has written a narrative
describing it.
(turns to di Vespucci)
Agostino.
DI VESPUCCI
The battle took place in the upper
valley of the Tiber. On the flat plain
between Anghiari and Sansepolcro. It
was a battle for the bridge over the
Anghiari. The Florentines defeated Duke
Filippo Maria Visconti and the
Milanese.
LEONARDO
Is this a joke, Niccolo? Some kind of
test?
Machiavelli smiles.
DI VESPUCCI
I am confused.
LEONARDO
I, a friend of Milan, am asked to paint
the defeat of Milan?
DI VESPUCCI
Florence triumphed. That is all that
matters.
MACHIAVELLI
This work is commissioned by Florence
for the glory of Florence. For the
Republic.
LEONARDO
It’s a reason. Not a good reason, but a
reason.
MICHELANGELO
(stammers)
I am seeking . . . wisdom. Um,
information.
CURATOR
(humorless)
We all are.
62
MICHELANGELO
I wish to find a moment in history. A
moment of glory and pride for Florence.
A battle celebrating the power of the
Republic.
The curator stops and pulls a folio from the shelf. He walks
to a reading desk and gently lays the manuscript down.
CURATOR
(reads)
"Cascina, near Pisa, 1364. On a hot
summer day, the Florentine forces made
camp on the banks of the Arno. Feeling
safe from attack, a number of the
soldiers had gone bathing in the
river."
MICHELANGELO
The human body. I can paint the human
body.
CURATOR
(reads)
"English mercenaries under the command
of Sir John Hawkwood attacked. The
Florentine soldiers scrambled from the
river in time to repel three Pisan
attacks and rout the enemy."
(closes manuscript)
It was a defining moment in our
history.
MICHELANGELO
It shall be mine as well.
LEONARDO
I am thinking of a continuous cycle. A
large panoramic composition.
63
MACHIAVELLI
The hall has windows.
LEONARDO
(quickly improvising)
Divided into three sections . . .
around the windows.
LEONARDO
It is only words on paper.
MACHIAVELLI
Those words determine your
compensation.
LEONARDO
I want the viewer to experience a story
unfolding in a spatial and temporal
direction. It doesn’t merely depict
space, but time as well.
MACHIAVELLI
(impressed in spite of
himself)
Profundo.
SODERINI
I was wrong to discourage you. To be an
artist, one must sculpt and paint with
equal authority. This fresco can be as
revolutionary as the David, and bring
us the same joy.
SALAI
You’ll have your wish at last. To paint
a herd of horses.
SALAI
They expect a masterpiece.
LEONARDO
As do I.
65
SALAI
What if it fails their expectations?
Can you stand to be second best? Can
you bear the insults?
LEONARDO
Patience protects us from wrongs, just
as clothes protect us against the cold.
When we get cold, we add more clothes.
When we are wronged, we increase our
patience so the injustice cannot touch
our soul.
SALAI
Get ready, doll. It’s going to be a
cold summer.
Leonardo un-hobbles and un-tethers the beast. It skitters
across the table, a shimmering monster.
GRANACCI
How good can it get? You are going to
paint a forest of Davids.
MICHELANGELO
So they say.
GRANACCI
(a touch caustically)
You have been repatriated, Mic. You are
once again our first artist, providing
the fresco comes out brilliantly. I
only hope you are not paying too high a
price.
MICHELANGELO
A man pays what he must.
GRANACCI
You do not seem too excited.
MICHELANGELO
I am. I’ve been given an extraordinary
opportunity to paint something
magnifico. To demonstrate that the nude
can be made the sole means of artistic
expression. To prove forever and for
all that no man can capture the nude
figure as I can.
66
GRANACCI
Ah, what would we do, what would we be,
without ego.
There are so many people and they are so animated and bubbly
that they frighten the livestock away, forcing the angry
HERDSMEN to chase after the skittish beasts.
MIND’S EYE
Leonardo flashes on a tornado of intertwined figures, a
confused rage. Knots of frantic men and tormented steeds
clustered in an ecstasy of wrath around the Standard, the
Milanese banner. It is a fantasia of carnage, an orgasm of
brutality.
BACK TO PRESENT
LEONARDO
War is a most beastly madness. It runs
counter to nature. It is evil.
MACHIAVELLI
A necessary evil. It is better for a
prince to be feared than loved. He must
combine force and shrewdness, the lion
and the fox. That is how he triumphs.
LEONARDO
Man is an animal.
MIND’S EYE
BACK TO PRESENT
GRANACCI
Why a battle? A triumph of any kind
would do.
MICHELANGELO
I’m a patriot. Florence must show the
wolves at our gates. We fear nothing
and can take care of our own.
SALAI
He looks like you.
LEONARDO
It is me.
SALAI
He fights for Milan.
LEONARDO
So he does.
68
LEONARDO
There must not be a spot that is not
trampled with gore. Pazzia
bestialissima.
SALAI
War will never again be portrayed as
romantic chivalry.
It’s obvious from the bags under his eyes, the unkempt hair,
and the lank, greasy clothes, that he’s been working non-
stop and sleeping in his clothes.
MICHELANGELO
I won’t be scolded for wasting time on
canal pumps, flights of birds, and
mechanized killing machines.
MICHELANGELO
Leonardo is misguided. War is not the
most bestial madness. It’s a manly
exploit. The struggle of heroes for the
glory and greatness of their
fatherland.
GRANACCI
How strange that poor motivation can
create such rich art.
GRANACCI
You must open these doors and let
everyone see what you have
accomplished.
MICHELANGELO
I don’t want adulation. I don’t need
approval.
DA SANGALLO
People grumble over your closed doors.
GRANACCI
Even members of the Company ask why you
lock everybody out.
DA SANGALLO
Now that they can see the miracle you
have created in such short time, they
will understand.
MICHELANGELO
I would prefer to wait a little longer.
Until I have the fresco completed in
the Grand Hall. But, if you both say I
must, then I must.
SODERINI
Messer Leonardo. I have an accounting
question that requires clarification.
LEONARDO
(mumbles under his
breath)
He strangles me with his red tape.
SODERINI
There appears to have been a purchase
of thirty-five pounds of Alexandrian
white pigment that wasn’t entered into
the account.
Leonardo turns.
LEONARDO
I have not bought any white.
SODERINI
Then what were the moneys used for?
LEONARDO
I do not know.
SODERINI
That could be a problem.
LEONARDO
I will return the full amount to the
treasury. On my word.
SODERINI
Don’t be so hard on us. Compared to the
Sforzas and Borgias, we’re humble folk.
I’m accountable only to the people.
It’s a sacred trust.
LEONARDO
My apologies.
SODERINI
The princes pay you in gold, we in
copper. Don’t you prefer the copper of
liberty to the gold of slavery?
SODERINI
Simply amazing. Look at those horses.
They almost look alive.
SODERINI
However, I’ll say what I’ve said
before. If you continue as you’ve
begun, the end result will be too
heavy, too depressing. Don’t be angry
with me for telling the truth.
(gestures at the
cartoon)
This was not what we expected.
LEONARDO
What was it, then, that you were
expecting?
SODERINI
That you’d depict the memorable
exploits of our heroes. Something that
would elevate the soul of man.
SODERINI
Art that doesn’t benefit the people is
the amusement of idle men, the whim of
the rich, the luxury of tyrants.
LEONARDO
To end this dispute, perhaps we should
let the citizens of the Florentine
Republic decide whether my picture can,
or cannot, bring any benefit to the
people. Ten or twenty thousand fools,
convened together, cannot be mistaken.
After all, the voice of the people is
the voice of God.
SODERINI
Let me just say that I’m confident
Michelangelo’s painting will benefit
the people.
72
GRANACCI
(whispers to Rustici)
What you say will carry great weight.
Consider your words carefully.
RUSTICI
(to Michelangelo)
Leonardo painted his panel for the
horses, you for the men. Nothing as
superb as Leonardo's has ever been done
of a battle scene. Nothing as
magnificently shocking as yours has
ever been painted of human beings.
(gestures to the
cartoon)
The Signoria is going to have one hell
of a wall.
GRANACCI
Messer Salai, good day to you.
SALAI
And to you.
GRANACCI
I trust your master is well?
SALAI
He is. And yours?
GRANACCI
The usual. He frets over the wall.
SALAI
Leonardo as well.
GRANACCI
It is quite the seductive spectacle,
this duel.
SALAI
Indeed. It’s all the talk in the
streets and squares.
Both men pause to listen to the buzz around them. They nod
in assent and shrug their shoulders.
GRANACCI
Our Florentines watch this contest with
the natural curiosity of the mob
seduced by a carriage wreck.
SALAI
They regard our masters as two starving
dogs fighting over a bone in the
street.
GRANACCI
Now they have spiced it with politics.
They say Michelangelo stands for the
Republic against the Medici.
SALAI
And Leonardo supports the Medici over
the Republic.
GRANACCI
Why must it always be about politics?
74
SALAI
For the Florentines, life without
politics is like a meal without
seasoning.
GRANACCI
The city has separated into two warring
camps.
SALAI
And daily they do verbal battle.
Both men stop to listen again. They smile and shrug once
more.
GRANACCI
Michelangelo is a painter, not a
politician. He chooses not to
participate.
SALAI
Leonardo is a lover not a fighter. He
refuses to lower himself.
GRANACCI
So be it.
SALAI
So be it.
LEONARDO
Quite good for one so young.
YOUNG MAN
Twenty-one this year, maestro.
LEONARDO
Where do you come from?
YOUNG MAN
I was born in Urbino.
LEONARDO
Who is your father and what is your
name?
YOUNG MAN
My father is Giovanni Sanzi, the
painter. My name is Raffaello Sanzi. I
am a former apprentice of Perugino’s.
LEONARDO
Former?
YOUNG MAN
I seek commissions of my own.
LEONARDO
That should not be a problem.
YOUNG MAN
I must tell you something, maestro. I
consider you the greatest of all the
artists of Italy.
LEONARDO
What of Michelangelo?
YOUNG MAN
He is unworthy to tie the shoe straps
of the creator of the Last Supper.
LEONARDO
I agree. But, let us keep that our
little secret.
Leonardo takes the young man’s sketch pad and fans through
the pages. With each sketch, he is both impressed and
unsettled.
76
LEONARDO
My son, if you continue as you are, I
predict you will some day be a great
master.
ARGIENTO
A crowd of young men await outside the
doors.
MICHELANGELO
What do they want?
ARGIENTO
They ask if they might sketch.
MICHELANGELO
Sketch what? These chicken scratchings?
ARGIENTO
Yes.
MICHELANGELO
I suppose. What harm can they do? Let
them in.
MICHELANGELO
Who is that?
ARGIENTO
They call him . . . Raphael.
MICHELANGELO
You came here to sketch. Start
sketching.
77
RAPHAEL
This makes painting a wholly different
art. I shall have to start again, at
the beginning. Even what I have learned
from Leonardo is no longer sufficient.
RAPHAEL
With your permission, maestro. I would
like to work here, before the cartoon.
ANTONIO DA SANGALLO
My nephew has asked to terminate his
apprenticeship with Perugino and work
here. With your permission, I intend to
grant his wish.
Michelangelo is bewildered.
GRANACCI
Whether you want it or not, Mic, you
are now the headmaster of a school of
talented young apprentices.
LEONARDO
Incredible. The quarryman can paint.
MICHELANGELO
Tremendous. The lyre player can paint.
LEONARDO
True beauty is inspired by nature.
MICHELANGELO
True beauty is inspired by God.
These two men are as different as the sun and the moon.
LAZERIUS
Hello, again, Messer Zimmerman.
ZIMMERMAN
I have again, as instructed.
ZIMMERMAN
Not a florin without an answer.
Lazerius waves his hands over the bowl, gazing into the
liquid. He realizes he’s trying to look through his bad eye
and rotates his head to stare with his good eye. He strains
so hard to see that his bad eye pops out of its socket and
into the blue liquid, splashing dye all over the fine
clothes of the banker.
80
LAZERIUS
You have your answer.
ZIMMERMAN
What does it mean?
LAZERIUS
A hard rain is gonna fall.
LEONARDO
There must be a misunderstanding. I was
scheduled to dissect today.
MICHELANGELO
There must be a mistake. Prior
Bichiellini promised I could dissect
today.
LEONARDO
There are equal halves. Perhaps we can
share.
MICHELANGELO
I’m willing if you are.
81
LEONARDO
A most handsome young man.
MICHELANGELO
A Moor, I believe.
MICHELANGELO
You know little about me.
LEONARDO
(genuinely excited)
Do you write left-handed as well?
MICHELANGELO
I do everything with my right hand,
except things that require force. Or,
when I’m tired. Then I use both.
LEONARDO
I have developed an ingenious way of
writing. Like the Hebrews. All-ebraica.
I call it mirror writing.
LEONARDO
The hand moves with less effort.
Because it always leads the writing, it
does not smear the ink.
LEONARDO
It is harder to decipher, but easier to
keep a secret.
MICHELANGELO
You have too many secrets.
82
LEONARDO
Who calls the kettle black? You, who
works behind locked doors.
MICHELANGELO
Touché.
LEONARDO
The devil’s hand. They call it the
devil's hand.
LEONARDO
Do you believe that?
MICHELANGELO
Sometimes. When the burden of
expectations becomes too great.
LEONARDO
The life of an artist can be lonely.
MICHELANGELO
Absolutely. But, it’s the life we’ve
chosen.
LEONARDO
The only life we would live.
MICHELANGELO
My sole ambition, my whole life, has
been to be a slave to art.
LEONARDO
I gladly share your chains.
MICHELANGELO
It’s already decaying.
LEONARDO
(recites)
"He who, without Fame, burns his life to waste
leaves no more vestige of himself on earth than
wind-blown smoke, or foam upon the water."
MICHELANGELO
(mildly irritated, but
touched)
Dante again.
83
LEONARDO
I know in my heart and deep in my soul
that one painting on a cloister wall in
Milan will scarcely secure my legacy.
MICHELANGELO
You're too harsh on yourself.
LEONARDO
My mother, Caterina, died not long ago.
In this very hospital. It makes one
think of mortality.
MICHELANGELO
Sometimes I wish my father would die.
LEONARDO
Is it that bad?
MICHELANGELO
I am his quarry.
Raphael approaches.
CELLINI
It is the school of the world. Scuola
del mondo.
RAPHAEL (V.O.)
Neither man will ever surpass it.
GAMBLER
Maestro, a man of some means, an
acquaintance of mine, has asked me to
convey a proposition.
LEONARDO
(roused from his
reverie)
What? Say what?
GAMBLER
A proposition, sir.
LEONARDO
What kind of proposition.
GAMBLER
The party I represent would be willing
to pay you five hundred ducats. In
gold.
LEONARDO
That is a great deal of money.
GAMBLER
It must not be taken lightly, sir.
LEONARDO
What must I do to receive this bounty?
GAMBLER
Stop painting.
85
LEONARDO
Painting? Stop painting what?
LEONARDO
I have only just begun.
GAMBLER
Then it will be easy to stop.
LEONARDO
I have a contract.
GAMBLER
You’ve been known to break contracts.
Besides, what do contracts mean to the
great Leonardo?
LEONARDO
I have been challenged. By
Michelangelo. I must demonstrate who is
rightfully, and forever, the first
artist of Florence.
GAMBLER
Everyone in the city, nay the world,
knows you are. What need have you to
prove it?
LEONARDO
Pride.
GAMBLER
Hubris has humbled greater men than
you.
LEONARDO
(waving his arms)
You insult me in my own home. Leave at
once. Shoo, you cockroach.
GAMBLER
(as he leaves)
As you wish. But, you’ll live to regret
it.
86
GAMBLER
(teeth mildly
chattering)
Maestro.
GAMBLER
Maestro, a moment of your time.
GAMBLER
Maestro . . .
MICHELANGELO
Stop babbling! I heard you the first
time!
GAMBLER
Apologies, maestro.
MICHELANGELO
I don’t deserve to be called maestro.
GAMBLER
Few would agree.
MICHELANGELO
What do you want? Can’t you see I’m
working.
GAMBLER
I’m the bearer of a message, m . . .
Signor Buonarotti.
87
MICHELANGELO
Be quick about it.
GAMBLER
I represent a group of men. From the
finest families in Florence. Men of
great influence and power.
MICHELANGELO
(tensing)
I’ve nothing in common with their
class.
GAMBLER
These men think very highly of you.
This gets Michelangelo’s attention, despite his resistance.
GAMBLER
In fact, they think so highly of you
they’d like you to join them.
MICHELANGELO
In what?
GAMBLER
A secret society of sorts.
MICHELANGELO
And what do they expect in return?
GAMBLER
Something you can afford.
MICHELANGELO
Get to the point, man. You waste my
time. And take my air.
GAMBLER
(gestures at the
cartoon)
They would have you walk away from this
contest.
MICHELANGELO
You confuse me with Leonardo. I never
walk away from a job.
88
GAMBLER
What about the statues for the Wool
Guild? What about the bronze Hercules?
What about . . .
Argiento grabs his master by both arms and pulls him away
before he can do more damage, or even kill the man.
The gambler, bleeding from the nose and mouth and ears,
stands, a bit wobbly.
MICHELANGELO
Nothing, no man, not even the Pope, can
make me abandon this work!
GAMBLER
Perhaps yes, perhaps no.
MICHELANGELO
I should kill you. Cut you open before
you die. Just to study your final
moments.
The gambler scurries for the door. The stool clatters in his
wake as he dashes out the door.
MACHIAVELLI (O.S.)
The Flemish masters are fascinating.
LEONARDO
Ah, Machiavelli. I did not hear you
come in.
LEONARDO
They continue to develop amazing new
paints and techniques. If only I were
as brilliant.
MACHIAVELLI
You are.
Leonardo runs his hand over the words on the leather cover.
LEONARDO
Pliny the Elder.
LEONARDO
(reads)
"A layer of granular plaster is applied
and primed to a hard flat finish. Over
this is added a layer of resinous
pitch, applied with a sponge, onto
which the paint is applied. It requires
heat to fix the colors onto the
plaster. The effect is to heighten the
brilliance of the colors by producing a
very glossy effect."
MACHIAVELLI
It’s an experiment, a risk, but you’ve
never shied from an experiment.
LEONARDO
I am the disciple of experiment!
GRANACCI
You have never painted fresco, Mic.
MICHELANGELO
Oil painting is for flowery young men
who smell like women. Fresco is the
method of men.
GRANACCI
True fresco, buon fresco, is difficult
to master. The potential for disaster
is great.
MICHELANGELO
You question my mastery? Or, perhaps my
masculinity?
GRANACCI
Painting on wet plaster requires
preparation and precise timing. Once
you begin a section, you cannot change
your mind. You cannot procrastinate.
MICHELANGELO
I’m not a schoolboy, Granacci. I
understand the risks.
GRANACCI
Many great artists have conceded when
faced with a fresh wall of plaster.
MICHELANGELO
If Leonardo can master fresco in Milan,
I can master fresco in Florence.
LEONARDO
Quicklime, sand, linseed oil, Greek
pitch, Venetian sponges, and
Alexandrian white.
MICHELANGELO
(whispers to Argiento)
Perugino. My mentor.
MICHELANGELO
Please . . . sit down . . . I'll get
some water.
Perugino knocks the stool out from behind him with a savage
backward kick.
PERUGINO
(sputters)
. . . beastly . . .
92
PERUGINO
Give a wild animal a brush, and he
would do the same. You will destroy us
. . . all we have spent a lifetime to
create!
MICHELANGELO
(sick at heart)
Perugino, why do you attack me? I
admire your work . . .
PERUGINO
My work! How dare you speak of my work
in the presence of this . . . this
filth! If my work is painting, then
yours is . . . debauchery!
MICHELANGELO
(ice-cold)
You mean the technique is bad, the
drawing, the design . . . ?
PERUGINO
You know nothing of such matters! You
should be thrown into the Stinche and
kept from destroying the art that God-
fearing men have created!
MICHELANGELO
Why am I not a God-fearing man? Is it
that I’ve painted nudes? That this is
. . . new, revolutionary?
PERUGINO
Don't talk to me of originality. I have
done as much as any man in Italy to
revolutionize painting.
MICHELANGELO
(trying to control his
temper)
Yes, you’ve done much. But, painting
doesn’t end with you. Every true artist
re-creates the art.
PEREUGINO
You go backward. Before civilization,
before God.
93
MICHELANGELO
(eyes narrow)
You sound like Savonarola.
PERUGINO
You will never get one figure of this
immorality up on the Signoria wall. Not
if I have anything to say about it.
SALAI
It’s an ingenious design, maestro.
Leonardo takes Salai by the hand and leads him closer to the
scaffold. Leonardo gestures for the workers to raise the
platform.
LEONARDO
The screws have a double-threading, you
see. To the right and to the left. One
raises, the other lowers.
SALAI
Marvelous.
LEONARDO
It will save these weary old bones from
too much wear and tear.
94
SALAI
(affectionately kisses
Leonardo)
Look who’s talking of old.
MICHELANGELO
(mutters to himself)
What a fool I’ve been. I should never
have left sculpting.
DARK-HAIRED STUDENT
It is so real.
LEONARDO
It is called camera obscura. If someone
stands outside bathed in light, their
exact image can be projected through a
concave lens inside onto a canvas.
Upside down like this.
(he traces)
INQUISITIVE STUDENT
It is more real than nature.
LEONARDO
(frowns momentarily)
Nature is the only reality.
SHORT-HAIRED STUDENT
It is witchcraft.
LEONARDO
It is art.
BLONDE-HAIRED STUDENT
Beware the eyes of the church.
LONG-HAIRED STUDENT
Leonardo is untouchable.
MICHELANGELO
(over his shoulder)
Why have you come? You’re Perugino's
countryman. You studied in his studio.
RAPHAEL
I came to apologize for my friend and
teacher. He has had a shock, and is now
ill . . .
MICHELANGELO
Why did he attack me?
RAPHAEL
When he saw the Bathers, he felt
exactly as I had. That this was a
different world. That one had to start
over. For me, it was a challenge. But,
I am not yet twenty-two. Perugino is
fifty-five. He can never start over.
MICHELANGELO
I appreciate your coming here, Raphael.
RAPHAEL
Then be generous. Ignore him.
MICHELANGELO
I’ll hold my tongue. For now.
LEONARDO
It is none of my business.
SALAI
If art is business, then it’s your
business.
LEONARDO
What is it to me?
SALAI
Defend him and, perhaps, he’ll befriend
you.
97
LEONARDO
I have no time for their petty
squabbles.
SALAI
It’s great art. It must be seen.
LEONARDO
If it is meant to be, it will be.
SALAI
It’s censorship of the worst kind. How
would you feel if the shoe were on your
foot?
SALAI
You were lucky then. You had friends.
LEONRDO
He does not want us to be friends.
SALAI
Then stand beside him . . . in the name
of freedom.
SODERINI
You've both been summoned here to put
an end to this petty squabbling.
MICHELANGELO
He attacked me.
PERUGINO
He deserved it.
98
SODERINI
Enough. I declare a truce. Now.
SODERINI
The harm you've done each other is
cruel, but reversible. The damage
you've done Florence is not.
SODERINI
We’re known around the world as the
capital of the arts. We can’t allow our
artists to indulge in quarrels that
hurt us. The Signoria orders that you
both apologize. That you desist from
attacking each other. And, that you
both return to the work from which
Florence draws its fame.
DWARF
Tell me, Messer, you haven’t, of
course, finished the portrait of La
Gioconda as yet?
LEONARDO
I have, sir. For now. What concern is
that of yours?
99
DWARF
I was simply curious since you have
been struggling with this one picture
for many years. To us, who know no
better, it seems even now so perfect
that a greater work we could not even
imagine.
DWARF
What is the future fate of this
picture?
LEONARDO
The lady and I will decide.
DWARF
Ah, then you haven’t heard yet, Messer
Leonardo.
LEONARDO
(croaks)
Heard?
DWARF
Ah, my God, you do not know. What a
misfortune! Poor Messer Giocondo is a
widower for the third time. The Madonna
Lisa has departed this world, by the
will of God.
MICHELANGELO
There’ll be no Hercules to stand beside
my David. The giant must remain in his
tomb of stone.
SODERINI
You’re the two greatest artists of our
time, titans each, and I have to scold
you like schoolboys.
LEONARDO
Gonfaloniere, I have sketches. For the
statue of Hercules.
LEONARDO
It will rival the David, standing
shoulder-to-shoulder at the entrance to
the Palazzo Vecchio. Twin towers of
freedom.
SODERINI
I don’t want to see sketches for new
projects.
SODERINI
I want to see the current projects
completed. I simply wish you to finish
what you’ve started. Your reputation,
no, your very lives, depend upon it.
LEONARDO
Who cares about reputation. I have
bills to pay.
MACHIAVELLI
We should go where we’re appreciated.
To France.
LEONARDO
Yes, to France, and a more friendly
clime.
MICHELANGELO
I’ve let Soderini down. I’ve let
everyone down.
GRANACCI
It is of no importance.
MICHELANGELO
How can you say that? This is my home.
102
GRANACCI
(whispers)
I have been told by those who know. The
Pope has heard of the cartoon. The Holy
Father plans a massive fresco in the
Sistine Chapel.
(pauses for effect)
And, he wants you to paint it.
The two men work all day. Leonardo in his reserved, relaxed
style. Michelangelo in his furious, attacking style.
SALAI
Charles d’Amboise, the French governor
of Milan, has written again.
LEONARDO
He is nothing, if not persistent.
SALAI
He wishes to resurrect what the Sforzas
began. Since you helped start it, he’d
like you to help finish it.
LEONARDO
Have you seen this?
Salai nods.
SALAI
Soderini is an ungrateful fool.
LEONARDO
Allow me.
LEONARDO
(reads)
"The actions of Messer Leonardo are
most unworthy. Having taken a large sum
in advance, and scarcely begun work, he
has dropped everything, and has behaved
in this matter like a traitor to the
Republic."
LEONARDO
A traitor. He accuses me of treason.
After all I have done.
SALAI
He’s a small-minded bureaucrat.
LEONARDO
I offered to re-pay the commission. I
borrowed money. From friends. From you.
He refused it.
SALAI
He’s incapable of forgiveness.
LEONARDO
I promised I would return to finish the
fresco. Three months. That is all I
asked.
LEONARDO
I know, I know. I have a reputation.
SALAI
Your promises are like footprints in
the sand.
LEONARDO
I am condemned to be an eternal
wanderer.
GRANACCI
The Pope wants you to come to Rome at
once. He has sent one hundred florins
as a travel allowance.
108
MICHELANGELO
It’s a bad time to leave. I must finish
the painting for the Signoria wall
while it’s still fresh in my mind.
GRANACCI
It is the Holy Father, Michelangelo.
SALAI
It’s so real.
LEONARDO
I have heard of portraits so alive that
when pierced with a poisoned needle,
the portrayed dies.
SALAI
She will live forever.
LEONARDO
It scares me.
SALAI
She is so distant from fear.
LEONARDO
Like her, I wonder if the entire labor
of my life has been a delusion.
SALAI
Like her, your name will echo through
time.
LEONARDO
I recall something Machiavelli once
said to me.
(quotes)
"The most fearful thing in life is not
cares, nor poverty, nor grief, nor
disease, nor even death itself. It is
tedium. Boredom is truly this century’s
malaise."
MICHELANGELO
Perhaps I should go north, maybe to
France. Then I’d no longer be your
problem.
SODERINI
You can’t run from the Pope. His arms
reach across Europe.
MICHELANGELO
Why am I so precious to the Holy
Father? I’m only a grain of sand in the
eye of the Colossus.
SODERINI
What is harder to obtain becomes more
valuable.
MICHELANGELO
I just want to be left alone.
SODERINI
Too late. You lost that right the day
you finished your stone satyr in
Lorenzo’s sculpture garden.
MICHELANGELO
I’d be content to live out the rest of
my days working in Florence.
SODERINI
One cannot refuse the Pope,
Michelangelo. If Julius says "Come!",
you must go. His friendship is
important to us in Florence.
MICHELANGELO
And my house . . . the two contracts
. . . ?
SODERINI
We will hold them until you learn what
the Holy Father wants. The contracts
must be honored.
110
MICHELANGELO
I understand, Gonfaloniere. I
understand.
SALAI
(an excited child)
Let’s release her. Now!
Leonardo opens the cage and a GIANT SWAN steps out, looks
around, and makes eye contact with Leonardo. The enormous
white bird noisily and joyously waves its wings, turning
rose-colored in the last rays of sunset, and flies straight
toward the sun.
SALAI
You once said man will undertake his
first flight on the back of an enormous
swan.
LEONARDO
I just realized something. I will never
fly again.
LEONARDO
(whispers)
Goodbye.
MICHELANGELO
(gasps)
Contessina.
Contessina beckons him to her bed, patting a place for him
to sit.
She closes her eyes. When she opens them again, there are
tears.
CONTESSINA
Remember the first time we met? In the
Duomo yard.
CONTESSINA
They all said how much you frightened
them. You never frightened me. I saw
how tender you were, under the scowl.
CONTESSINA
We have never spoken of our feelings.
MICHELANGELO
I loved you, Contessina.
CONTESSINA
I loved you, Michelangelo. I have
always felt your presence.
CONTESSINA
My sons will be your friends.
MACHIAVELLI
You followed the instructions
carefully?
SALAI
The paint refuses to dry.
LEONARDO
I am hoping the heat will finally set
the colors.
They watch closely as the fire grows and sends heat up the
wall. Leonardo holds out his hand to feel the warmth as it
climbs.
SODERINI
(waves documents)
I’ve received three briefs from the
Vatican. Full of threats that we should
send you now, by fair means or foul.
MICHELANGELO
They’re empty threats. This is
Florence, not Rome.
SODERINI
In Rome, you could be of considerable
help to Florence. Defying His Holiness,
you become a source of potential danger
to us. You’re the first Florentine to
defy a Pope since Savonarola. I'm
afraid your fate may be the same.
MICHELANGELO
(shivers
involuntarily)
Which means I'll be hanged in the
piazza, then burned.
SODERINI
You’re not guilty of heresy, only of
stubbornness. In the end, the Pope will
have his way.
MICHELANGELO
Gonfaloniere, all I want is to remain
in Florence. I'll start carving the St.
Matthew tomorrow, so I can have my
house back.
SODERINI
His Holiness would consider it a
personal insult. No one can employ you,
not Doni, or Pitti or Taddei, without
incurring the Pope's wrath.
SODERINI
You’ve tried the Holy Father as the
King of France wouldn’t have done. He’s
not to be kept begging any longer. We
don’t want to go to war with him over
you. Prepare to return.
114
MICHELANGELO
I seem to be a source of constant
sorrow for the Republic.
SODERINI
Your talent outweighs the aggravation.
MICHELANGELO
And the Bathers? Can I finish the
fresco? I am not done with Leonardo.
SODERINI
You’ve not been in the Grand Hall?
MICHELANGELO
The groom brought me through your
apartment.
SODERINI
Come with me.
MICHELANGELO
(groans)
Dio mia, no!
MICHELANGELO
What could’ve gone wrong? We Tuscans
have been the masters of fresco for
over three hundred years. Gonfaloniere,
how’d this happen?
SODERINI
He was trying to show his young rival
who the true master of Florence was.
MICHELANGELO
(shudders, then sighs)
All that time and effort wasted.
115
SODERINI
Leonardo ignored an important detail.
Pliny didn’t recommend applying the
process . . . to walls.
MICHELANGELO
The mistakes of the brilliant are
always mistakes no fool would ever
make.
SODERINI
He made a very small beginning of a
very great thing. And, now, it’s over.
MICHELANGELO
Leonardo, I've just come from the Grand
Hall. I want you to know how sorry I am
about the fresco. Such a shame.
LEONARDO
(cool, defensive)
You are kind.
MICHELANGELO
I wanted to apologize for the things
I’ve said about you, about the statue
in Milan . . .
LEONARDO
You were provoked. I said unkind things
about marble carvers.
MICHELANGELO
That’s still no excuse for such
rudeness.
116
LEONARDO
Your cartoon of the Bathers is truly
magnificent, Michelangelo. I sketched
from it, even as I did from your David.
Should you finish it, it will become
the glory of Florence.
MICHELANGELO
I don't know, Leonardo. I fear I've
lost all appetite now that your Battle
of Anghiari will not be fought beside
mine.
LEONARDO
There are many rivers between us.
MICHELANGELO
Indeed.
LEONARDO
We are more alike than different. We
will always be outsiders.
MICHELANGELO
Two southpaws.
LEONARDO
We will show them, will we not?
MICHELANGELO
They’ll not see the likes of us for a
very long time.
LEONARDO
I suspect we will never be friends.
MICHELANGELO
Too late for that, I suppose.
LEONARDO
There is no one I would prefer to
supplant me than you. There is no one I
respect, or fear, more than you.
MICHELANGELO
I’m profoundly grateful.
117
LEONARDO
Amusing is it not? How we spend all
this time and energy to create a
reputation and secure our legacy. And
the only one we can never impress is
the one person who matters the most.
MICHELANGELO
Ourselves.
LEONARDO
This city, our birthplace, treated us
both so badly, in so many ways, for so
long.
MICHELANGELO
Now, they can’t deny us.
LEONARDO
I fear Florence is too small a town for
both of us.
MICHELANGELO
I'll be going to Rome. To work on the
ceiling of the Pope’s chapel.
LEONARDO
I am off to France. To be court artist
and engineer to the King.
MICHELANGELO
Florence has always been our home and
now we’re both leaving her.
LEONARDO
They say I cheated Soderini and
embarrassed the Republic. It was never
about the money.
MICHELANGELO
They say I threatened the Republic by
not bowing down to Pope Julius. I’ll
obey the man, but I’ll not be his
slave.
LEONARDO
Small minds.
MICHELANGELO
Little hearts.
118
LEONARDO
May God go with you.
MICHELANGELO
And you.
SERACINI (V.O.)
They never finished.
119
SERACINI
An incredible loss to the world.
PEDRETTI
Can you imagine having frescoes by
Leonardo and Michelangelo side-by-side
in one room today?
HENNEBERGER
I really can't.
SERACINI
The only record we have of Leonardo’s
work are the few sketches that survive.
PEDRETTI
And a handful of reproductions done by
Rubens and others.
SERACINI
They buried Leonardo's fresco because
it was a threat.
PEDRETTI
They cut Michelangelo’s cartoon into
pieces because it was too good.
SERACINI
They erased all traces.
HENNEBERGER
I guess that's the price of perfection.
PEDRETTI
Or the price of fame.
SERACINI
There! Do you see it?
120
A HORSE'S HEAD
The Arno River flows through the Tuscan valley, wending its
way to the sea.
TITLE CARD
FADE OUT.
THE END