MP Halimah Mohd Sadique asked why some effeminate men in Malaysia later become transvestites known as mak nyah. The deputy minister, Noriah Kasnon, did not have data on this as the ministry has not studied this group. However, she acknowledged these individuals have low self-esteem due to social stigma. Noriah said rehabilitation programs have had some success, with many mak nyah improving skills and realizing their mistakes. However, more support is still needed from the corporate sector. Another MP criticized Noriah's response as too long-winded and not addressing the concerns of Malaysians.
Original Description:
Original Title
TheSun 2008-11-26 Page04 Noraini Accused of Being Long-winded
MP Halimah Mohd Sadique asked why some effeminate men in Malaysia later become transvestites known as mak nyah. The deputy minister, Noriah Kasnon, did not have data on this as the ministry has not studied this group. However, she acknowledged these individuals have low self-esteem due to social stigma. Noriah said rehabilitation programs have had some success, with many mak nyah improving skills and realizing their mistakes. However, more support is still needed from the corporate sector. Another MP criticized Noriah's response as too long-winded and not addressing the concerns of Malaysians.
MP Halimah Mohd Sadique asked why some effeminate men in Malaysia later become transvestites known as mak nyah. The deputy minister, Noriah Kasnon, did not have data on this as the ministry has not studied this group. However, she acknowledged these individuals have low self-esteem due to social stigma. Noriah said rehabilitation programs have had some success, with many mak nyah improving skills and realizing their mistakes. However, more support is still needed from the corporate sector. Another MP criticized Noriah's response as too long-winded and not addressing the concerns of Malaysians.
MP’s poser on lelaki lembut Husna Yusop and Giam Say Khoon at the Dewan Rakyat and mak nyah WHY do effeminate men (lelaki lembut) become transvestites (mak nyah)? This question was posed by Datuk Halimah Mohd Sadique (BN-Teng- gara) to Deputy Women, Family and Community Development Minister ministry has failed in its rehabilitation programmes resulting in people in this situation going back to their previous activities even after going through rehabilitation. To this, Noriah said the programmes for mak nyah were not a total failure. Noraini accused of being Noriah Kasnon. Noriah said she did not have the answer because the ministry did not have a study on the matter. Besides, there has been no other study on the number of effeminate men who ended up being transvestites. “This group has very low self-es- teem. They are afraid to be approached and are always worried about the social stigma that has never stopped against them,” she said. “It is difficult for them to quickly come back to the right path even with ‘long-winded’ Rapper in A BACKBENCHER Malaysians. Your answer does not touch the heart of the rakyat.” – Datuk Mohamad Aziz
Tuanku Jaafar repeatedly
“I’m sorry we do not have the the help and social service support expressed his disappointment “This country has become asking him to stop because figure as this group (effeminate men) from our centres.” the soup over Deputy Human a haven for foreign workers,” he was not given the floor to has yet to become our target group. Noriah said although there is still again he said when interrupting speak. Resources Minister Datuk And we have not made any study on a lot to be done, many of the mak this group. But InsyaAllah (God willing), nyah have realised their mistakes pg 6 Noraini Ahmad’s “long- Noraini, who was replying to a When Noraini said she will winded reply” which he said supplementary question from consider all the feedback given, we will try to look into this matter in and started to attend classes to did not give a satisfactory Aaron Ago Dagang (BN- Mohamad said: “We have future,” she said. improve their skills such as in sewing answer to the people. Kanowit). given the same feedback for “Actually, I think, it all started and handicraft, as well as working in from education at home. And also the cosmetic counters at shopping Datuk Mohamad Aziz Dagang had asked what years.” peer group interactions, the strong complexes. (BN-Sri Gading) told the government was doing Wan Junaidi advised him influence of today’s borderless tech- She also lamented that the minis- Noraini not to deceive the to help the private sector to stop interrupting the deputy nology as well as frustrations from try did not get any support from the people with her answer and employers so that they can minister. past relations with the opposite corporate sector and suggested that accused the government of offer good salaries to the Noraini then continued sex.” they take up the issue as a corporate doing more to take care of the workers and attract more local with her answer, saying the Halimah also asked whether the social responsibility. foreign workers rather than residents to work in sectors ministry has always been like construction, agriculture, accused of being biased, either accommodation, supermarkets with the employers or the and coffee shops. workers. To this, Noraini said “To us, this is good, as it the ministry has always shows that we take care of both encouraged companies or workers and employers at the employers to enhance their same time,” she said. workers’ skills through Earlier, Noraini told Dagang training and has tightened the that according to the 2007 conditions for employers to National Workforce Survey, hire foreign workers. the average basic monthly “We also have allocations income enjoyed by workers in through the Perbadanan the construction industry was Sumber Manusia Bhd (PSMB), RM952, agriculture RM628, whereby those who contribute accommodation or hotels certain percentage to PSMB RM697, supermarkets RM853 can re-use the levy to provide and coffee shops RM573. additional skills and training to She said the salary for the their workers,” she said. private sector was determined “Also, we have the half-time by three methods – market working hour policy because forces, collective agreement, now, the government is and the wages councils. encouraging every worker to “Ten wages councils ...”. Before she could finish, have been set up since 2006, Mohamad cut in and said: which give protection to 1.33 “Your answer does not touch million workers nationwide. the heart of the rakyat.” And recently, the cabinet also Mohamad continued to approved wages councils criticise Noraini despite Deputy for the textile and electronic Speaker Datuk Dr Wan Junaidi industry,” she said.
Transport Minister Datuk Seri
Ong Tee Keat said. briefs He said it had taken large families into account by giving some “relaxation”. No reward for “The relaxation does not exposing ‘Little mean we can carry as many passengers as possible. This Napoleons’ must not be our practice,” THERE will be no reward for those he said when winding up the who expose government officers debate on Budget 2009 for his acting above their station, Prime ministry. Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ah- Ong said the implementa- mad Badawi said. tion of the rear seat belt ruling He said the government had reflected the ministry’s com- taken measures to flush out mitment to increase public these ‘Little Napoleons’ from the awareness on road safety and administration by embracing good that the ruling, to be effective governance. in January, had been imple- This include the setting up of a mented abroad. – Bernama management committee entrust- ed with preventing corruption, ‘Fees for astronaut’ abuse of power and irregularities in the civil service, he said when probe on Monday responding to a question from THE Ministry of Science, Technol- Hamim Samuri (BN-Ledang). ogy and Innovations will begin its Abdullah said the government probe on payments alleged to would set up a task force in all the have been received by national ministries to reduce bureaucracy. astronaut Datuk Dr Sheikh Musza- He said the National Integrity phar Shukor Sheikh Mustapha for Perception Index Research 2007 giving lectures on Monday. showed that integrated follow-up “We are giving this week for action was still needed to enhance people who have complaints to the people’s perception on the file them with the ministry before civil service and the government. the probe gets under way,” its – Bernama minister, Datuk Dr Maximus Ongkili, said when winding up the debate Rear seat belt on Budget 2009 for his ministry. He said Sheikh Muszaphar had ruling stays denied charging up to RM8,000 THE government will not revoke an hour for giving lectures on the rear seat belt ruling for car his space adventure and hav- passengers although it will ing accumulated RM1.2 million. cause problems for big families, – Bernama