Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 1 of 7

GlobThink
How internationally minded individuals can contribute to business and society

Home About

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia

24 06 2009

2 Votes

One of my most challenging cross-cultural experience was defining a global Information Technology (IT) plan for all subsidiaries of my company in Asia-Pacific. There was a large number of Joint Ventures, half of them in China, and all of them used to have independent IT plans. My assumptions about Chinese people were based on my interactions with very internationalized Chinese friends in Europe. I had heard about the differences between Chinese and Western communication. I knew I had to communicate indirectly with Chinese people. But until I arrived here and experienced it on the real world, I did not really know how to do it. During six months, I visited subsidiaries across Asia and interviewed local staff from different departments about their software applications. I was interested in their problems, needs and plans. I had prepared very specific questions and imagined they would be happy to talk about this, as it would have been the case in France. Unfortunately, apart from technical software specifications, I got little information at the beginning of these travels. I found problems conducting the interviews. I was using a translator Follow and the atmosphere was very cold. There were very long gaps after questions, translations and

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 2 of 7

answers. Moreover, answers were short and vague. accounting for differences between Asian cultures, this is the way they were responding to me, regardless of where I was. I had this frustrating experience in four plants before I arrived to a subsidiary where the General Manager was a Chinese who spoke French. I told her about my interviewing problems and her advice was: Start with some small talk. Then, make open-ended questions and get very slowly into the details. In that subsidiary, where the local Management supported me, my interviewees were much more engaged than in other places. This made me realize that many interviewees were passive because they were afraid of getting in trouble by saying something the Joint Venture management would have preferred to hide. This General Managers advice worked very well. I asked an HR officer in that subsidiary what he would do if a new staff arrived. This was an indirect question. I could have asked how the employee arrival procedure was implemented in the IT systems. He answered he had to create accounts in Systems A and B, which were not interconnected. By using follow-up questions, I found out that both systems did not exchange any data and he had to synchronize this systems manually after every staff-related data change. He spent around three hours a week doing this. After that subsidiary, I confirmed in other subsidiaries in China, Korea and Thailand that the incompatibilities between system A and system B were resulting in a lot of extra work for local staff. Back to the headquarters of the company, I informed the Directors of Department A (the headquarter department managing System A) and Department B (the headquarter department managing System B) about this. Director A and Director B both came from Greater China. They both spoke English but were not really westernized. They blamed each other for the issue. I tried to arrange a meeting with them but they did not want to work together. I could never get them in the same room. I made many proposals, like for example sharing a common database, but they refused them with a harsh tone highlighting the disadvantages. They did not want to be told what to do by a new employee like me. An answer I heard from both directors was that her system could exchange information but the other one could not because the other department was more concerned about its own interests. I did not know how to handle the situation. I was totally disoriented. Then, I got an interesting feedback, which reminded me of the French-speaking Chinese General Manager. One senior colleague told me: Lead them indirectly, in such a way they feel they are still in charge. I guided them separately to brainstorm about possible solutions focusing on the pros and cons. Then, I shared the solutions with them. I avoided digging in their personality conflict. I knew Director B did not consider this issue as a priority. I explained to her why that was a problem for her. I told her I met some local staff, who were reluctant to use her system because it was not compatible with System A. I explained how the information of System A was useful for her. Then, she proposed sharing data automatically. However, when I presented this idea Department A, Director A argued this would involve confidentiality risks. This answer was final and blocking. During the following month, nobody talked about the issue. I had studied how those risks could be managed but could not tell Director A directly because I knew she would react defensively. Instead of telling her, I asked her how to avoid them and she proposed controlling this sharing manually. Then, I told Director B about that and she did not object. I drafted a preliminary project definition and discussed it with them. This way, I reached a consensus to launch a project to connect both systems by a manual data interface. Thanks to this experience, I improved my indirect communication ability with Chinese people. I Follow learnt practical skills to ask questions and get feedback indirectly. I also learnt I had to understand

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 3 of 7

peoples feelings, fears and agendas so that my interlocutor does not feel embarrassed, uneasy or annoyed. My interviewees in the subsidiaries were afraid of getting in trouble. Communicating indirectly reassured them. That is why I had to be indirect too. The second thing I learnt is that effective leadership does not necessarily mean other people recognize you as a leader. This is another aspect of indirect communication. Leadership is about getting people to work together for a higher purpose. Sometimes, you need to guide people subtly so that they find their own reasons to give you what you need, as I did with Directors A and Director B. I discovered this communication and leadership style in China. Obviously it also exists in the Europe and in the USA. It just depends on peoples personalities and personality depends on much more aspects that cross-cultural or international factor. Image: I found the picture on copyblogger

Share this: Like this:

Digg Like Be the first to like this post.

Deux blessures incicatrisables de lhistoire allemande et le sens de lhumour Becas La Caixa: Contribuir a Espaa desde el extranjero

Actions
Comments RSS Trackback

Information
Date : June 24, 2009 Tags: Asia, China, Communication, Hong Kong, Leadership, Management Categories : China, English

2 responses
15 07 2009

Chinese Working Culture GlobThink (22:57:23) : 1 0 Rate This

[...] Indirect Communication: Indirect communication is another consequence of the high population that China has always experienced. Taking into account that you have many neighbors and that they are very close, you better pay attention to your communication in order to avoid conflict. This is how they think. In Spain, where I come from, I think many managers are very likely to care more about resolving conflict than about avoiding it. In China, it is clearly the contrary. I have a quite detailed post about indirect communication here. [...] Reply
Follow

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 4 of 7

24 01 2010

E. T. Hall High / Low Context Notes on Intercultural Communication

(09:45:39)

: Rate This

[...] For an example how a low context culture interacts with a high context culture as the Chinese, please have a look at this interesting blog: http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-asia/ [...] Reply

Leave a Reply
Enter your comment here...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Email (required) Name (required) Website

(Address never made public)

c d e f g Notify me of follow-up comments via email.

Post Comment

Languages
All Languages
Follow

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 5 of 7

Search
Search

Most Read
Memoria de estudios para las becas La Caixa Consulting Interview Case Frameworks Las entrevistas de las becas La Caixa Carta de agradecimiento a La Fundacin La Caixa - Becas. Moroccan women, the veil and a deeper dilemma The Nordic model of capitalism Las becas La Caixa y la deuda con la sociedad La mujer oriental y la mujer occidental Becas de postgrado en el extranjero Unrestricted Work Authorization in the US What is Chicago Booth all about? Rotational / Leadership Development Programs for MBA

Contact Calendar
June 2009 M T W T F S S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 May Jul

Archives
July 2011 May 2010 March 2010 February 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009

Follow

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 6 of 7

Recent posts
Cocktail con Estudiantes de Chicago Booth en Madrid Chicago Booth European Conference 2010 Chicago Booth European Conference Chicago Booth European Conference 2010: Exploring Challenges and Opportunities for EU/US Business Conferencia de estudiantes espaoles de MBA en EEUU- MBA Internacional 2010 (II) Conferencia MBA Internacional 2010 10 y 11 de abril CHICAGO Globthink Prize to the Most Global US Company Chicago Booth European Business Group Follow your inner voice in B-school Vote for uroBooth to run the European Business Group of Chicago Booth Presentaciones del MBA de Chicago Booth en Madrid y en Barcelona Carta de agradecimiento a La Fundacin La Caixa Becas. Consulting Interview Case Frameworks Language Skills and Active Listening Financial Reforms and the Millenium Bridge

Blog Stats
71,687 visitors

Recent Visitors

Tag Cloud
America Asia Australia Aznar Basque Country

Becas Becas
Communication

La Caixa Business Career Goal

Conference Confucius Culture Democracy

Chicago

Chicago Booth China

Education Effort Europe European Expatriate Expectation France Fulbright Generosity Germany Hong

Kong Idealism Integration Interview Isidre Fain Jose Maria Aznar Leadership MBA Openmindedness Politics Rafael del Pino Society Spain Stereotypes USA VIE Vision Working Culture

Recent Comments
globthink on Las entrevistas de las becas L MARIA PEREZ HERNANDE on Las entrevistas de las becas L Lambert on Memoria de estudios para las b Ralph Fernandes on Chicago Booth International MB Vera on La gestin de los pasaportes e

Follow

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012

Indirect communication and indirect leadership in Asia GlobThink

Page 7 of 7

Blogroll
Chicago Booth European Business Group Chicago Booth European Conference 2010 Chicago Booth MBA ChicagoNet La Caixa Scholarships MBA Internacional The University of Chicago Alumni Club of Spain This is Africa

Blog at WordPress.com. Theme: Freshy by Jide.

Follow

http://globthink.com/2009/06/24/indirect-communication-and-indirect-leadership-in-a... 31/03/2012