Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Whit Ford
Whit Ford
Mild acid-base disturbances were induced in rats for 30 days. These disturbances did not affect % ash of maxillary incisors or % P of the developing enamel from mandibular incisors. Total fluoride intake (food and water) among groups drinking fluoride-free water was constant. Nevertheless, average plasma and developing enamel fluoride concentrations were highest in the acidotic group and lowest in the alkalotic group. Among groups drinking water containing 50 ppm fluoride, total fluoride intake was highest by the alkalotic group and lowest by the acidotic group. Plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations, however, were highest in the acidotic group. It is concluded that plasma and developing enamel fluoride levels can be independent of, or inversely related to, fluoride intake. J Dent Res 58(11):2058-2065, November 1979
Introduction.
The plasma ,2 ,3 , 5 and calcified tissue6 7,8 ionic fluoride concentrations in experimental animals and human subjects have generally been found to reflect fluoride intake. These concentrations, however, are not related to intake in a simple linear fashion and, further, most reports indicate considerable individual variation in these concentrations.3,'56'9 These findings suggest that fluoride balance or retention is variable, not only among individuals or groups but also within individuals, over time. Fluoride retention can be increased by a decreased efficiency with which the kidneys excrete fluoride (renal clearance rate) or by an increase in the rate of calcified tissue uptake and vice versa. Several factors which
Received for publication December 7, 1978. Accepted for publication May 10, 1979. This work was supported by NIDR Grants DE 04332 and DE 04832. 2058
influence the latter process have been identified. Principal among these are the rate of growth101 1 and previous exposure to fluoride.12 Until recently, the renal clearance of fluoride was thought to be mainly determined by, and a direct function of, urine flow rate1 3,14 or the renal clearance rate of chloride. 15 Additional studies,16'17'18 however, have shown that fluoride renal clearance can be easily dissociated from both urine flow rate and chloride clearance. These studies identified urine pH as a major determinant of the rate of fluoride renal clearance in the rat and dog and of fluoride excretion rate by humans. In a chronic acid-base disturbance study using rats, Whitford and Pashley18 found that plasma fluoride levels, and those of eight soft tissues, were highest in the acidotic group and lowest in the alkalotic group. Urinary fluoride excretion by alkalotic rats, however, was twice that of acidotic rats while the control group was intermediate. It was calculated that fluoride was removed from the body four times more rapidly in alkalosis than in acidosis. This greater efficiency in fluoride excretion was consistent with the lower plasma and soft tissue fluoride levels of the alkalotic group, but the role of the calcified tissue compartment was not defined. Chronic metabolic acidosis has been reported to increase the rate of bone resorptionl9'20 while alkalosis may stabilize bone mineral.20 Thus, the high plasma fluoride levels in acidosis, as well as the lower values in alkalosis,18 may have been partially due to the effects of the acid-base disturbances on calcified tissue fluoride handling. The current study was designed to provide information relevant to fluoride
Vol. S8 No. 11
2059
uptake by calcified tissue during chronic acid-base disturbances using the unerupted incisor enamel of the rat as the model.21 This tissue provides the opportunity to examine fluoride concentrations in developing partially and fully mineralized, calcified tissue.
Results.
2060
was fluoride-free. The presence of 50 ppm fluoride in the drinking water of groups 4 and 5, however, had no influence on water intake, as seen by comparison with groups 1 and 2 (Table 1). There were no statistically significant differences among the groups for food intake.
same relationship to acid-base balance, i.e., group 1 > 2 > 3, although these differences did not achieve statistical significance. The percent ash content of the dried whole maxillary incisors revealed no statistically significant differences between any of
TABLE 1 SUMMARY OF 30-DAY BODY WEIGHT GAIN AND DAILY WATER AND FOOD INTAKE
Groupa
1 2 3
21.6
61
+2.4
19.6
+1
71
+2.7
20.4
+3
151 +7
+2
57
+1.8
4
5
+3
53 +3 53
18.7
+4.2
20.0
57 +1
+1.2
6
67 2
+2
48
7.4b
+3.8
83b
+4
+3
a- Three rats per group. Groups 1-3 received fluoride-free water, and groups 4-6 received water containing 50 ppm fluoride during the 30-day study. In addition, the drinking water of groups 1 and 4 contained 0.25 M NH4C1, and that of groups 3 and 6 contained 0.15 M NaHCO3.
p < .05. Significance testing (t-test) compares group 1 with 4, group 2 with 5, and group 3 with 6.
Table 2 shows the average daily fluoride intake with food, water, total fluoride intake, and the terminal plasma fluoride concentrations of each group. Due to greater water intake, group 5 received 10% more fluoride than group 4, and group 6 received 23% more than group 4. In spite of its lower intake of fluoride, the plasma fluoride of group 4 (acidotic) was significantly higher than that of both groups 5 (normal acid-base balance) and 6 (alkalotic). Further, the plasma level of group 5 was 20% higher than that of group 6 (not significant), while its fluoride intake was 1 1 % lower. The terminal plasma fluoride concentrations of the groups drinking fluoride-free water showed the
six groups. However, the combined data of the groups drinking 50 ppm fluoride water had slightly lower values. Comparing the data of groups 1-3 and groups 4-6, the latter group had a significantly lower ash content (69.8 + 0.4% vs. 68.6 0.4%, respectively). This finding was consistent with the presence of striations in the erupted enamel (fluorosis) in each of the mandibular incisors, and about 50% of the maxillary incisors of the rats in group 4-6. While no attempt was made to quantitate the degree of enamel fluorosis, examination with a dissecting scope (x3) revealed that the striations were most apparent in group 4.
Vol.58 No.11I
2061
The figure presents the enamel fluoride Among the groups drinking water fluoriand phosphorus data for each of the three dated at 50 ppm, group 4 had the highest developing enamel sections. The values fluoride levels in each enamel section as for phosphorus and the generally higher well as the highest plasma level. The diffluoride concentrations in the enamel ferences in the enamel fluoride levels were of the E2 section (transitional zone) are significant in several cases (E2: 4 vs. 5, in close agreement with the findings of 4 vs. 6; E3: 4 vs. 5, 4 vs. 6). These conWeatherell et al.21 There were no statis- centration differences occurred even tically significant differences for percent though the animals of group 4 ingested phosphorus among the six groups. Com- less fluoride than those of groups 5 or 6 bining the percent phosphorus data of (Table 2). The average fluoride concentrations in the El and E3 sections of groups groups 1-3 and of groups 4-6, however, it 5 and 6 were nearly identical. The relatively was found that the average value of the latter animals was significantly lower in each high fluoride level of the E2 section, found of the three enamel sections. in every other group, was absent in group 6, The fluoride data in the figure suggest where it averaged 41% and 22% lower than that the effects of the acid-base distur- the levels of groups 4 and 5, respectively. bances on enamel fluoride concentrations Overall, the enamel fluoride concentrations paralleled those observed in plasma (Table of groups 4, 5, and 6 were inversely re2). The amounts of fluoride consumed lated to fluoride intake and directly by the groups drinking fluoride-free water related to the plasma fluoride levels (Table 2). were not significantly different (Table 2). Nevertheless, the average plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations were highest Discussion. in the acidotic group and lowest in the We have reported that urinary pH is alkalotic group. The differences in the an important determinant of fluoride renal enamel fluoride levels reached statistical clearance in the ratl6'18 and the dog,17'18 significance in several instances (E 1: 1 vs. and of urinary fluoride excretion by 3; E2: 1 vs. 2, 1 vs. 3, 2 vs. 3; E3: 1 vs. 2, humans.18 The rate of fluoride absorption 1 vs. 3, 2 vs. 3). from the urinary bladder of the rat was TABLE 2 SUMMARY OF DAILY FLUORIDE INTAKES AND TERMINAL PLASMA FLUORIDE
CONCENTRATIONS
Fluoride Intake,
mg/group/day
Group
1
Food
Water 0
+.07
3
4
5
2.05
+.09
1.90 + .09
1.89 + .08
2.85 .07
8.4
3.35a
+ .10
5.0a .1 .3
6
a
p <
1.71 .12
4.15a .20
4.0a
.05 compared to group 4 as determined by analysis of variance and Duncan's Multiple Range Test. There were no statistically significant differences among groups 1, 2 and 3.
2062
found to be inversely related to pH24 and, using Streptococcus mutans, fluoride uptake was found to be a function of the magnitude of the transcellular pH gradient.25 A pre-existing metabolic acidosis was found to sensitize rats to acute fluoride toxicity, while a pre-existing metabolic alkalosis afforded significant protection.26 Furthermore, there is theoretical and experimental evidence that the steady-state distribution of fluoride between the extra- and intracellular compartments of several mammalian soft tissues is determined by the magnitude of transmembrane pH gradients.18'26'27 The influence of mild systemic acid-base disturbances on fluoride metabolism in hard tissues has received little attention, however, and the present work was done to partially fill this hiatus. The current results indicate that chronic, mild acid-base disturbances do not markedly alter hard tissue fluoride metabolism and that, under these conditions, enamel fluoride concentrations simply reflect those of plasma. Insofar as fluoride uptake by enamel is representative of uptake elsewhere in the calcified tissue compartment, the urinary pH-dependence of the renal handling of fluoride16-18'26 becomes the most important determinant of both soft and hard tissue fluoride concentrations when intakes are not markedly different. Additional studies on bone fluoride metabolism are indicated to further clarify these relationships. The present results also indicate that plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations and severity of enamel fluorosis are not always directly related to fluoride intake. Intake by groups 1, 2 and 3 (fluoride-free drinking water) was similar throughout the study (Table 2). In spite of this similarity, plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations were highest in the acidotic group and lowest in the alkalotic group (Table 2 and Figure). Among the groups drinking water fluoridated at 50 ppm, fluoride intake was highest by the alkalotic group and lowest by the acidotic group. Based on these intake patterns, one would have predicted that plasma and enamel concentrations would have been highest in the alkalotic group. However, exactly the reverse was found (Table 2 and Figure). From these data it is concluded that, when fluoride intake is not greatly different
(compare groups 1, 2 and 3 or groups 4, 5 and 6), plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations can be independent of, or inversely related to, fluoride intake. It should be noted that urinary fluoride excretion rates and blood and urine pH values were not monitored in the current study. However, in the chronic study described in the Introduction,18 in which the NH4Cl and NaHCO3 drinking water concentrations were the same as used in the present study, the average blood pH values of the acidotic, control, and alkalotic groups were 7.41, 7.46 and 7.53, respectively. The blood pH of the control group was in close agreement with the findings of other investigators (7.41-7.45).28,29 The average urine pH values were 5.38, 5.80, and 6.51, respectively. These data are representative of mild acid-base disturbances. It is not unreasonable to assume that those group pH differences and fluoride excretion rate differences were closely approximated in the current study. Fecal excretion of fluoride (or of other ions of potential importance, e.g., calcium and phosphate) was not evaluated in the present study. If there were differences among the groups, which would indicate absorption differences, they could have contributed to the results obtained. However, in the previous study,18 all groups received identical fluoride doses subcutaneously two hours prior to sacrifice. This fluoride was never in contact with the lumen of the gastrointestinal tract. In agreement with the present results, the plasma fluoride concentration of the acidotic group was twice that of the alkalotic group. It is, therefore, unlikely that group differences in the absorption of fluoride contributed significantly to the current results. Finally, the lower values of maxillary incisor percent ash and mandibular incisor enamel percent phosphorus values of groups 4, 5 and 6, compared to those of groups 1, 2 and 3, were consistent with the observation of enamel fluorosis in the former groups. The fact that there were no differences among groups 4, 5 and 6 for these variables (percent ash and phosphorus) perhaps was due to the small sizes of the groups. An elevated protein content and decreased mineral content is characteristic of fluorosed enamel30'31 and, as described in the Results, the fluorotic striations
Vol. S8 No. II
2063
400r
340
140r
E 100 0.
CL
E
U.
a-
0.
[
I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
2800
60F
220
20 0
11
X 13
r
GROUPS 1-3
GROUPS 4-6
CL
113
9
E, E E I '2
aI
0'
'3
E1
E2
E3
Fig. 1 -Average values of fluoride concentrations (bars, SEM) and percent phosphorus in the three sections of the developing enamel of rat mandibular incisors. Groups 1, 2 and 3 received fluoride-free drinking water and groups 4, 5 and 6 received water containing 50 ppm. Groups 1 and 4 (0-*) were acidotic, groups 2 and 5 (o-o) were in normal acid-base balance, and groups 3 and 6 (o-o) were alkalotic.
2064
were most pronounced in the incisors of the acidotic group. This observation was associated with the higher plasma and enamel fluoride concentrations of this group. Based on these findings, studies are in progress to determine a fluoride intake level which will produce enamel fluorosis in mildly acidotic animals, but no fluorosis in normal or alkalotic animals. The results of such studies might have direct bearing on the endemic fluorosis reported among humans residing in areas where fluoride intake is apparently not excessive.32-34
6.
7.
8.
Conclusions.
The results of this study permit the
following conclusions:
1. Chronic metabolic acidosis is associated with elevated plasma and developing enamel fluoride concentrations, compared to the values associated with normal acid-base balance or chronic metabolic alkalosis. 2. These relationships obtain even when fluoride intake is greater by the normal or alkalotic animals. 3. Enamel fluoride concentrations reflect those of plasma and these, in turn, appear to be mainly determined by the efficiency with which the kidneys excrete fluoride.
9.
10.
11.
12.
Acknowledgment.
Mr. R. Harp assisted with the statistical analyses.
13.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
REFERENCES SMITH, F. A.; GARDNER, D. E.; and HODGE, H. C.: Investigations on the Metabolism of Fluoride: II. Fluoride Content of Blood and Urine as a Function of the Fluorine in Drinking Water, J Dent Res 29:596600, 1950. SHEARER, T. R. and SUTTIE, J. W.: Effect of Fluoride Administration on Plasma Fluoride and Food Intake in the Rat, Am J Physiol 212:1165-1168, 1967. GUY, W. S.; TAVES, D. R.; and BREY, W. S.: Organic Fluorocompounds in Human Plasma: Prevalence and Characterization. In: Biochemistry Involving Carbon- Fluorine Bonds (ed. Robert Fuller), ACS Symposium Series, No. 28, pp 117-134, 1965. OPHAUG, R. H. and SINGER, L.: Influence of Variations in Fluoride Intake on the Ionic and Bound Fractions of Plasma and Muscle Fluoride, Proc Soc Exper Biol Med 155: 23-26, 1977. EKSTRAND, J.: Relationship between Fluo-
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
2065
19. ALBRIGHT, F. and REIFENSTEIN, F. G., JR.: In: The Parathyroid Glands and Metabolic Bone Disease, Baltimore. Williams and Wilkins Co., 194 8, pp. 24 1-247. 20. BARZEL, U.S. and JOWSEY, J.: The Effects of Chronic Acid and Alkali Administration on Bone Turnover in Adult Rats, Gin Sci 36:517-524, 1969. 21. WEATHERELL, J. A.; DEUTSCH, D.; ROBINSON, C.; and HALLSWORTH, A. S.: Fluoride Concentrations in Developing Enamel, Nature, Lond. 256:230-232, 1975. 22. TAVES, D. R.: Determination of Submicromolar Concentrations of Fluoride in Biological Samples, Talanta 15:1015-1023, 1968. 23. CHEN, P. S., JR.; TORIBARA, T. Y.; and WARNER, H.: Microdetermination of Phosphorus, Analyt Chem 28:1756-1758, 1956. 24. WHITFORD, G. M.; PASHLEY, D. H.; and REYNOLDS, K. E.: Fluoride Absorption from the Rat Urinary Bladder: a pHdependent Event, Am J Physiol 232:F10F15, 1977. 25. WHITFORD, G. M.; SCHUSTER, G. S.; PASHLEY, D. H.; and VENKATESWARLU, P.: Fluoride Uptake by Streptococcus mutans 6715, Infect Immun 18:680.687, 1977. 26. REYNOLDS, K. E.; WHITFORD, G. M.; and PASHLEY, D. H.: Acute Fluoride Toxicity: The Influence of Acid-Base Status, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 45:415427, 1978. 27. WHITFORD, G. M.; PASHLEY, D. H.; and REYNOLDS, K. E.: Fluoride Tissue Dis-
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
tribution: Short Term Kinetics, Am JPhysiol 236:F141-F149, 1979. IRVINE, R. 0. H.; DOW, J.; and FONG, J.: Effect of Anesthesia on the Collection of Blood for Acid-Base Studies in the Rat, Med PharmacolExp 14:55 7-562, 1966. ROLLINS, D. E.; WITHROW, C. D.; and WOODBURY, D. M.: Tissue Acid-Base Balance in Acetazolamide-Treated Rats, JPharmacol Exptl Ther 174:535-540, 1970. SHEARER, T. R.; KOLSTAD, D. L.; and SUTTIE, J. W.: Bovine Dental Fluorosis: Histologic and Physical Characteristics, Am J Vet Res 39:597b602, 1978. SHINODA, H.: Effect of Long-Term Administration of Fluoride on Physico-Chemical Properties of Rat Incisor Enamel, Calcif Tiss Res 18:91-100, 1975. LEATHERWOOD, E. C.; BURNETT, G. W.; CHANDRAVEJJSMARN, R.;and SIRIKAYA, P.: Dental Caries and Dental Fluorosis in Thailand, Am J Pub Itith 55:1792-1799, 1965. NANDA, R. S.; ZIPKIN, I.; DOYLE, J.; and HOROWITZ, H. S.: Factors Affecting the Prevalence of Dental Fluorosis in Lucknow, India, Arch Oral Biol 19:781792, 1974. GRAHNEN, H.; LYSELL, L.; MYRBERG, N.; and OLLINEN, P.: Fluoride, Mineralization Defects of the Enamel, and Tooth Width, Acta Pediat Scand 63:188-192, 1974.
ANNOUNCEMENT
Combined First Annual Scientific Session Society For Clinical Trials AND Seventh Annual Symposium For Coordinating Clinical Trials May 6-8, 1980
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The Sessions will focus on the design, organization, management, and analyses of clinical trials. Abstracts must be received by January 21, 1980. For more information write to: Christian R. Klimt, M.D., Secretary Society for Clinical Trials, Inc. 600 Wyndhurst Avenue Baltimore, MD 21210